You are on page 1of 165

maxmin

,=,
0, unr, 0

max(min)
s.t.

min
=
0

min
s.t.

zC X
AX ( , )b
T

X ()0, unr
z CT X
AX b
X0


max
s.t.

z=x1+3x2
x1+ x26
-x1+2x28
x1 0, x20

x2

-8

6
0

x1

max z= 2x1 +3x2 +x3


s.t.
x1 +3x2 +x3 15
2x1 +3x2 -x3 18
x1
-x2 +x3 3
x1,
x2,
x3 0

min z= -2x1 -3x2


st
x1 +3x2
2x1 +3x2
x1 -x2
x1, x2,

-x3
+x3 +x4
=15
-x3
+x5
=18
+x3
+x6 =3
x3, x4, x5, x6 0

x1 +3x2 +x3
2x1 +3x2 -x3
x1
-x2 +x3

+x4
+x5
+x6

=15
=18
=3

x1x2x3x4x5x6

x1 +3x2 +x3
2x1 +3x2 -x3
x1
-x2 +x3

=15
=18
=3

x1x2x3x4x5x6=531000

z=20

x1 +3x2 +x3
2x1 +3x2 -x3
x1
-x2 +x3

+x4
+x5
+x6

=15
=18
=3

x1x2x4x3x5x6

x1 +3x2 +x4
2x1 +3x2
x1
-x2

=15
=18
=3

x1x2x3x4x5x6=27/512/502/500

z=18

x1 +3x2 +x3
2x1 +3x2 -x3
x1
-x2 +x3

+x4
+x5
+x6

=15
=18
=3

x1x2x5x3x4x6

x1 +3x2
2x1 +3x2 +x5
x1
-x2

=15
=18
=3

x1x2x3x4x5x6=6300-30

x1 +3x2 +x3
2x1 +3x2 -x3
x1
-x2 +x3

+x4
+x5
+x6

=15
=18
=3

x1x2x6x3x4x5

x1 +3x2
2x1 +3x2
x1
-x2 +x6

=15
=18
=3

x1x2x3x4x5x6=340004

z=18

x1 +3x2 +x3
2x1 +3x2 -x3
x1
-x2 +x3

+x4
+x5
+x6

=15
=18
=3

x2x3x4x1x5x6

3x2
3x2
-x2

+x3
-x3
+x3

+x4 =15
=18
=3

x1x2x3x4x5x6=021/227/2-3000

x1 +3x2 +x3
2x1 +3x2 -x3
x1
-x2 +x3

+x4
+x5
+x6

=15
=18
=3

x1x2x3x4x5x6

3x2
3x2
-x2

+x3
-x3
+x3

+x5

=15
=18
=3

x1x2x3x4x5x6=0360150

z=15

x1 +3x2 +x3
2x1 +3x2 -x3
x1
-x2 +x3

+x4
+x5
+x6

=15
=18
=3

x1x2x3x4x5x6

3x2
3x2
-x2

+x3
-x3
+x3

+x6

=15
=18
=3

x1x2x3x4x5x6=011/2-3/20010


max
s.t.

z=x1+3x2
x1+ x2+x3 =6
-x1+2x2 +x4 =8
x1, x2,x3,x40

D
B
x4=0

xj<0

O
x3 x4
x1 x2
-

A
x1 x4
x2 x3
-

C
x1=0

x3=0

O
B
x1 x2
x3 x4
-

C
x2 x3
x1 x4
-

x2=0
D
x2 x4
x1 x3
x4

A
E
x1 x3
x2 x4
x1

max
s.t.

z=

3x1 +4x2
x1 +x2
x1 +2x2
x1
x2

-x3
+x3
+x3
x3

+2x4
+x4
+2x4
x4

25
36
0

min z'= -3x1


s.t.
x1
x1
x1

-4x2
+x2
+2x2
x2

+x3
+x3
+x3
x3

-2x4
+x4 +x5
=25
+2x4
+x6 =36
x4 x5 x6 0

z'
x5
x6

z'
1
0
0

x1
3
1
1

x2
4
1
2

x3
-1
1
1

x4
2
1
2

x5
0
1
0

x6
0
0
1

RHS
0
25 25/1
36 36/2

x2
40
10
21

x3
-3
-1
1/2
1
1/2
1

x4
2-2
10
21

x5 x6 RHS
00 -2
0 -72
0
7
11 -1/2
0
25
18
00 1/2
1
36

x2 x6

z'
x5
x2

z'
11
00
00

x1
31
1/2
1
1/2
1

x1 x5

7/1/2
18/1/2

z'
x51
xx22

z'
11
00
0

x1
10
1
1/2
0
1/2

x2
0
0
1

x3
-4
-3
1
1/2
0
1/2

x4
-2
-2
00
1

x5
-2
0
12
-1
0

x6 RHS
-1 -86
-2
-72
-1 14
-1/2
7
1/21 11
18

x1x2x3x4x5x6=14110000
min z=-86max z=86

max z= 2x1 +3x2 +x3


st
x1 +3x2 +x3 15
2x1 +3x2 -x3 18
x1
-x2 +x3 3
x1,
x2,
x3 0

min z= -2x1 -3x2


st
x1 +3x2
2x1 +3x2
x1 -x2
x1, x2,

-x3
+x3 +x4
=15
-x3
+x5
=18
+x3
+x6 =3
x3, x4, x5, x6 0

min z= -2x1 -3x2


st
x1 +3x2
2x1 +3x2
x1 -x2
x1, x2,
z
x4
x5
x6

z
1
0
0
0

x1
2
1
2
1

x2
3
3
3
-1

x3
1
1
-1
1

-x3
+x3 +x4
=15
-x3
+x5
=18
+x3
+x6 =3
x3, x4, x5, x6 0
x4
0
1
0
0

x5
0
0
1
0

x6
0
0
0
1

RHS
0
15
18
3

15/3
18/3
-

z
x4
x5
x6
z
x2
x5
x6
z
x2
x1
x6

z
1
0
0
0

x1
2
1
2
1

z
1
0
0
0
z
1
0
0
0

x1
1
1/3
[1]
4/3
x1
0
0
1
0

x2
3
[3]
3
-1

x3
1
1
-1
1

x2 x3
0
0
1 1/3
0
-2
0 4/3
x2 x3
0
2
1
1
0
-2
0 [4]

x4
0
1
0
0
x4
-1
1/3
-1
1/3
x4
0
2/3
-1
5/3

x5
0
0
1
0

x6
0
0
0
1

x5 x6
0
0
0
0
1
0
0
1
x5
x6
-1
0
-1/3 0
1
0
-4/3 1

RHS
0
15
18
3

15/3
18/3
-

RHS
-15
5
5/1/3
3
3/1
8
8/4/3
RHS
-18
4
4/1
3
-4
4/4

z x1 x2 x3 x4
x5 x6 RHS
z 1 0 0
2
0
-1
0 -18
x2 0 0 1
1 2/3 -1/3 0
4
4/1
x1 0 1 0 -2 -1
1
0
3
-x6 0 0 0 [4] 5/3 -4/3 1
4
4/4
x3 x6
z x1 x2 x3
x4
x5
x6
RHS
z 1 0 0 0 -5/6 -1/3 -1/2 -20
x2 0 0 1 0
1/4
0
-1/4
3
x1 0 1 0 0 -1/6 1/3 1/2
5
x3 0 0 0 1 5/12 -1/3 1/4
1
:(x1,x2,x3,x4,x5x6)=(5,3,1,0,0,0), max z=20

RHS

-CT

XB

XN

RHS

-CBT

-CNT

XB

XN

RHS

-CBT

-CNT

XB

B-1N

B-1b

XB

XN

RHS

0T

CBTB-1N-CNT

CBTB-1b

XB

B-1N

B-1b

XB

xj

RHS

-CBT

-cj

aj

XB

xj

RHS

0T

CBTB-1aj-cj CBTB-1b

z
z 1

B-1aj

B-1b

CBTB-1aj-cj=zj-cj Reduced Cost


B-1aj=Yj

B-1b=

CBTB-1b=z0

XB

0T

CBTB-1aj-cj CBTB-1b

XB

XB 0

xj

RHS

B-1aj

B-1b

xj

RHS

0T

zj-cj

z0

Yj

DUAL

Kuhn-Tucher

min z=CTX
s.t.
AXb
X 0
min

max y=bTW
s.t. ATWC
W 0

CT

max

bT

AT

n
m


1
min z=CTX
s.t. AXb
X 0

max z=-CTX
s.t. -AX-b
X 0

max y=bTW
s.t. ATWC
W 0

min y=-bTW
s.t. -ATW-C
W 0

2
min z=CTX
s.t. AXb
X 0

max y=bTW
s.t. ATWC
W 0

min z=CTX
s.t. AX=b
X 0

max y=bTW
s.t. ATWC
W unr

min z=CTX

max y=bTW
s.t. ATWC
W 0

s.t.

AXb
X 0


1
XFWF

z=CTXF WTAXF WTb=y


2
XoWo

z=CTXo=WoTAXo=WoTb=y

3
min z=CTX
s.t. AXb
X 0

max y=bTW
s.t. ATWC
W0

min z=CTX
s.t. AX-XS=b
X, XS0

max y=bTW
s.t. ATW+WS=C
W, WS0

XXs

WWs

XTWS=0 WTXS=0


min z=CTX
s.t. AX-XS=b
X, XS 0

max y=bTW
s.t. ATW+WS=C
W, WS 0
n

XTWS=0
WTXS=0

XS

-I

WS

AT

= b

= C

x1

w1

xj

xn

wi wm wm+1

xjwm+j=0 wixn+i=0

xn+1 xn+i xn+m

wm+j

wn+m

(i=1,2,,m; j=1,2,,n)

00

3
(1)PFC
AX-XS=b
X, XS 0

Kuhn-Tucher

(2)DFC
ATW+WS=C
W, WS 0
(3)CSC

XTWS=0
WTXS=0


1
min z=CTX
s.t. AXb
X 0
1

max z=CTX
s.t. AX b
X 0
3

min z=CTX
s.t. AX b
X 0
2

max z=CTX
s.t. AX b
X 0
4

(1)

min z=CTX
s.t. AXb
X 0

min z=CTX
s.t. AX-XS=b
X, XS0

max y=bTW
s.t. ATWC
W0

max y=bTW
s.t. ATW+WS=C
W, WS0

z=CTX

min
s.t. AX-XS=b
X, XS0

y=bTW

max
s.t. ATW+WS=C
W, WS0
WT=CBTB-1
WST=CT-WTA

XS

RHS

-CT

0T

-I

XS

RHS

CBTB-1A-CT

-CBTB-1

CBTB-1b

B-1A

-B-1

B-1b

XS

RHS

-WST

-WT

CBTB-1b

B-1A

-B-1

B-1b

(2)

min z=CTX
s.t. AX b
X 0

min z=CTX
s.t. AX+XS=b
X, XS0

max y=bTW
s.t. ATWC
W0

max y=bTW
s.t. ATW+WS=C
W 0, WS0

z=CTX

min
s.t. AX+XS=b
X, XS0

max y=bTW
s.t. ATW+WS=C
W 0, WS0
WT=CBTB-1
WST=CT-WTA

XS

RHS

-CT

0T

XS

RHS

CBTB-1A-CT

CBTB-1

CBTB-1b

B-1A

B-1

B-1b

XS

RHS

-WST

WT

CBTB-1b

B-1A

B-1

B-1b

(3)

max z=CTX
s.t. AX b
X 0

max z=CTX
s.t. AX-XS=b
X, XS0

min y=bTW
s.t. ATW C
W0

max y=bTW
s.t. ATW-WS=C
W 0, WS0

z=CTX

max
s.t. AX-XS=b
X, XS0
min y=bTW
s.t. ATW-WS=C
W 0, WS0
WT=CBTB-1
WST=WTA- CT

XS

RHS

-CT

0T

-I

XS

RHS

CBTB-1A-CT

-CBTB-1

CBTB-1b

B-1A

-B-1

B-1b

XS

RHS

WST

-WT

CBTB-1b

B-1A

-B-1

B-1b

(4)

max z=CTX
s.t. AX b
X 0

max z=CTX
s.t. AX+XS=b
X, XS0

min y=bTW
s.t. ATW C
W0

max y=bTW
s.t. ATW-WS=C
W, WS0

z=CTX

max
s.t. AX+XS=b
X, XS0

min y=bTW
s.t. ATW-WS=C
W, WS0
WT=CBTB-1
WST=WTA- CT

XS

RHS

-CT

0T

XS

RHS

CBTB-1A-CT

CBTB-1

CBTB-1b

B-1A

B-1

B-1b

XS

RHS

WST

WT

CBTB-1b

B-1A

B-1

B-1b

2
min z
s.t.

3x 1 2x 2 x 3
x1 x 2 x 3 4
2x 1 3x 2 x 3 5
x 1 2x 2 x 3 2
x1

min z
s.t.

x2

x3 0

3x 1 2x 2 x 3
x1 x 2 x 3 x 4
4
2x 1 3x 2 x 3
x5
5
x 1 2x 2 x 3
x6 2
x1

x2

x3

x4

x5

x6 0

min z
s.t.

3x 1 2x 2 x 3
x1 x 2 x 3 x 4
4
2x 1 3x 2 x 3
x5
5
2x 1 2x 2 x 3
x 6 2

x1

x2 x3 x4 x5 x6 0
x2 x3 x4 x5 x6 RHS

-3

-2

-1

x4

-1

x5

-3

-5

x6

-2

-1

-2

x1

-3/-2

-1/-1

x1

x2

x3

x4

x5

x6 RHS

-1

-4

-1

x4

-1

x5

-1

-7

x3

-2

-1

x1

x2

x3

x4

x5

x6

RHS

-1

-4

-5

30

x4

-1

-5

x2

-1

-1

x3

-2

-3

16

x1

x2

x3

x4

x5

x6

RHS

-1

-5

-7

35

x1

-1

-1

-2

x2

-1

-1

x3

x1, x2, x3, x4, x5, x6=5, 7, 6, 0, 0, 0

min z=35

w1, w2, w3, w4, w5, w6=-1, 5, 7, 0, 0, 0 max y=35

3
min z
s.t.

3x 1 2x 2 2x 3
x1 x 2 x 3 4
2x 1 3x 2 x 3 5
x 1 2x 2 x 3 2
x1

min z
s.t.

x2

x3 0

3x 1 2x 2 2x 3
x1 x 2 x 3 x 4
4
2x 1 3x 2 x 3
x5
5
x 1 2x 2 x 3
x6 2
x1

x2

x3

x4

x5

x6 0

min z
s.t.

3x 1 2x 2 2x 3
x1 x 2 x 3 x 4
4
2x 1 3x 2 x 3
x5
5
2x 1 2x 2 x 3
x 6 2
x1

x2

x3

x4

x5

x6

1
z

x1

x2

x3

x4

x5

x6

RHS

-3

-2

x4

-1

x5

-3

-5

x6

-2

-1

-2

x1

x2

x3

x4

x5

x6 RHS

-7

-4

x4

-1

x5

-1

-7

x3

-2

-1

x1

x2

x3

x4

x5

x6 RHS

-7

-18

x4

-1

-5

x2

-1

-1

x3

-2

-3

16

x1

x2

x3

x4

x5

x6 RHS

-7

-5

-10

17

x1

-1

-1

-2

x2

-1

-1

x3

x1, x2, x3, x4, x5, x6=5, 7, 6, 0, 0, 0

min z=17

w1, w2, w3, w4, w5, w6=-7, 5, 10, 0, 0, 0 max y=17

2
z

x1

x2

x3

x4

x5

x6

RHS

-3

-2

x4

-1

x5

-3

-5

x6

-2

-1

-2

x1

x2

x3

x4

x5

x6

RHS

-5

-2

-8

x3

-1

x5

-2

-1

-9

x6

-1

x1

x2

x3

x4

x5

x6 RHS

-5

-2

-8

x3

1/2

3/2 -1/2

17/2

x2

-1/2

1/2 -1/2

9/2

x6

-1/2

1/2 1/2

-5/2

x1

x2

x3

x4

x5

x6

RHS

-7

-5

-10

17

x3

x2

-1

-1

x1

-1

-1

-2


x1, x2, x3, x4, x5, x6=5, 7, 6, 0, 0, 0

min z=17

w1, w2, w3, w4, w5, w6=-7, 5, 10, 0, 0, 0 max y=17

max z c1 x 1 c 2 x 2 c 2 x 2
s.t.
a 11x 1 a 12 x 2 a 1n x n x n 1
b1
a 21x 1 a 22 x 2 a 2 n x n
x n2
b2

a m1 x 1 a m 2 x 2 a mn x n
x nm b m
x1
x2
x n x n 1 x n 2 x n m 0

2
max z=min y

min y b1 w 1 b 2 w 2 b m w m
/
s.t.
a 11 w 1 a 21 w 2 a m1 w m w m 1
a 12 w 1 a 22 w 2 a m 2 w m
w m2

a 1n w 1 a 2 n w 2 a mn w m
w m n
w1
w2
w m w m 1 w m 2 w m n

c1
c2

cn
0

w1w2...
wmmShadow Price

z y b1 w1 b 2 w 2 b i w i b m w m

z z b1 w1 b 2 w 2 (b i b i )w i b m w m
z b i w i
o

o
wi

i
b i i

max z c1x1 c 2 x 2 c j x j c n x n
s.t.
a11x1 a12 x 2 a1jx j a1n x n b1 w1
a 21x1 a 22 x 2 a 2jx j a 2n x n b 2 w2


a m1 x1 a m2 x 2 a mj x j a mn x n b m wm
x1
x2
xj
xn 0

a 1 j w1 a 2 j w 2 a ij w i a mj w m

5Reduced Cost

min y b1 w 1 b 2 w 2 b m w m
s.t.
a 11 w 1 a 21 w 2 a m1 w m w m 1
a 12 w 1 a 22 w 2 a m 2 w m

a 1n w 1 a 2 n w 2 a mn w m
w1
w2
wm

c1
w m2

w m 1

w m2

w m n
w m n

c2

cn
0

w m j ( w1a 1 j w 2 a 2 j w m a mj ) c j W T a j c j
= -

5
w i 0 x n i 0
w i x n i 0
x n i 0 w i 0
x j 0 w m j 0
x j w m j 0
w m j 0 x j 0

10
20
3
4

s1=14

s2=27
s3=19

d1=22

d2=13

d3=12

d4=13

6
7
5

3
8
4
2
7
5
9
10
6


min z 6x 11 7x 12 5x 13 3x 14 8x 21 4x 22 2x 23 7x 24 5x 31 9x 32 10x 33 6x 34
s.t. x 11 x 12 x 13 x 14
14
x 21 x 22 x 23 x 24
27
x 31 x 32 x 33 x 34
19
x 11
x 21
x 31
22
x 12
x 22
x 32
13
x 13
x 23
x 33
12
x 14
x 24
x 34
13
x 11 x 12 x 13 x 14 x 21 x 22 x 23 x 24 x 31 x 32 x 33
x 34
0

14

x11
8

x12
4

x13
2

x14
7

27

x21
5

x22
9

x23
10

x24
6

x31
22

x32
13

x34

x33
12

13

19


1
1

14

14
8

8
5

13
9

6
10

6
22

13

27

12

13
13

19

1
1
6

2
7

14
8

27

12
5

10

19
22

13

12
0

13

15

2
1
6

2
7

13
8

12
9

27

15

2
5

14

10

19
22

13

12

13

3
1
6

13
8

2
9

27

13
5

14

12
10

19
22

13

12

13

4
1

13
8

2
9

27

19

13
5

14

12
10

19
22

13

12

13

5
1

1
8

13
4

2
9

27

19

13
5

14

12
10

19
22

13

12

13

6
1

1
8

13
4

2
5

27

19

13
9

14

12
10

19
22

13

12

13

xijzij-cij(1)
1

14
2

8
5

-5

14
8

13
9

27

6
10

13

6
22

13

12

z12-c12=(c11-c21+c22)-c12=6-8+4-7=-5

13

19

(2)
1

13
9

14

-5
2

8
5

-5

14
8

27

6
10

13

6
22

13

12

z13-c13=(c11-c21+c23)-c13=6-8+2-5=-5

13

19

(3)
1

-5
2

8
5

-5

14
8

27

6
10

13

6
22

13

14

13
9

-7

12

19

13

z14-c14=(c11-c21+ c21 - c23 + c33 -c14)-c13=(6-8+2-10+6)-3=-7

(4)
1

-5
2

8
5

-5

14
8

-9

6
10

13

6
13

27

3
22

14

13
9

-7

12

z24-c24=(c23-c33+ c34)-c24=(2-10+6)-7=-9

13

19

(5)
1

-5
2

8
5

-5
4

-7

-9

6
10

27

+11

13

6
13

14

13
9

22

14
8

12

z31-c31=(c21-c23+ c33)-c31=(8-2+10)-5=+11

13

19

(6)
1

22

-9

6
10

14

27

+3
13

-7
7

13
9

+11

-5
2

8
5

-5
4

14
8

13

6
12

z32-c32=(c22-c23+ c33)-c32=(4-2+10)-9=+3

13

19

xijzij-cij(1)
1

3
u1

14
8

8
5

13
9

10

6
v1

v2

u2

v4=0

v3

13
v4=0

u3

(2)
1

3
u1

14
8

8
5

13
9

10

6
v1

v2

u3=6

u2

u3+v4=c34

v3

13
v4=0

u3=6

(3)
1

3
u1

14
8

8
5

13
9

6
v1

v2

v3=4

u2

6
10

u3+v3=c33

v3=4

13
v4=0

u3=6

(4)
1

3
u1

14
8

8
5

13
9

6
v1

v2

u2=-2

u2=-2

6
10

u2+v3=c23

v3=4

13
v4=0

u3=6

(5)
1

3
u1

14
8

8
5

13
9

v2=6

v2=6

u2=-2

6
10

6
v1

u2+v2=c22

v3=4

13
v4=0

u3=6

(6)
1

6
1

3
u1

14
8

8
5

13
9

v1=10

v2=6

u2=-2

6
10

6
v1=10

u2+v1=c21

v3=4

13
v4=0

u3=6

(7)
1

6
1

3
u1=-4

14
8

8
5

13
9

u1=-4

v2=6

u2=-2

6
10

6
v1=10

u1+v1=c11

v3=4

13
v4=0

u3=6

(8)
1

6
1

8
5

4
3
u1=-4

-5

14

13
9

6
10

6
v1=10

v2=6

z12-c12=u1+v2-c12=(-4)+6-7=-5

u2=-2

v3=4

13
v4=0

u3=6

(9)
1

6
1

8
5

-5

14

3
3

-5
2

13
9

v2=6

z13-c13=u1+v3-c13=(-4)+4-5=-5

u2=-2

6
10

6
v1=10

u1=-4

v3=4

13
v4=0

u3=6

(10)
1

6
1

8
5

-5

14

3
3

-5
2

13
9

v2=6

z14-c14=u1+v4-c14=(-4)+0-3=-7

u2=-2

6
10

6
v1=10

-7

u1=-4

v3=4

13
v4=0

u3=6

(11)
1

6
1

8
5

-5

14

3
3

-5
2

13
9

v2=6

z24-c24=u2+v4-c24=(-2)+0-7=-9

-9

6
10

u2=-2

6
v1=10

-7

u1=-4

v3=4

13
v4=0

u3=6

(12)
1

6
1

8
5

-5
2

13
9

11
v1=10

-5

14

z31-c31=u3+v1-c31=6+10-5=11

-9

6
10

u2=-2

6
v2=6

-7

u1=-4

v3=4

13
v4=0

u3=6

(13)
1

6
1

8
5

v1=10

-5
2

13
9

11

-5

14

v2=6

z32-c32=u3+v2-c32=6+6-9=+3

-9

6
10

+3

-7

u1=-4

u2=-2

6
v3=4

13
v4=0

u3=6

,
1

6
1

8
5

v1=10

-5
2

13
9

11

-5

14

v2=6

-9

6
10

+3

-7

u1=-4

u2=-2

6
v3=4

x31, min{x21,x33}=min{8,6}=6, x33

13
v4=0

u3=6

,,
1

22

27

-8
13

+2

12
10

+4

14

13
9

-5
2

2
5

-5

14
8

-11
12

13
13

x14, min{x11,x34}=min{14,13}=13, x34

19

,
1

22

27

-8
13

-2

12
10

19

13

14

13
9

-5
2

2
5

-5

1
8

-11
12

-4

19

13

zij-cij<0,

Min z=61+3 13+8 2+4 13+2 12+5 19=142

2
1

ij
i

4
3

j
2

Path

P={(1,2),(2,3),(3,4)}

4
3

Chain

C={(1,2),(3,2),(3,4)}

1
3

Circuit

2
1

={(1,2),(2,4),(4,1)}

(Cycle)
2

={(1,2),(2,4),(3,4),(1,3)}

4
3

(Tree)

5
4

2
1

5
4

m
m-1

5
4
2

5
4

m
m-1

4
3

2
1

2
4

4
3

4
3

4
3

4
3

//

4
3

//

2
4


b2=-2

c24=5

b4=3
4

c12=6
b1=5

b6=-5

c34=4

c46=1

c13=3

c56=4
3
b3=5

c35=2

5
b5=-6

cij


b2=-2

b4=3

x12=2

x46=3
b6=-5

b1=5
1

x13=3

x56=2
3
b3=5

x35=8

5
b5=-6

x24x34
b2=-2
2

c24=5

b4=3
4

c12=6

c46=1

b1=5
1

b6=-5

c34=4

c13=3
3
b3=5

c35=2

6
c56=4

5
b5=-6

x24z24-c24
b2=-2

c24=5

b4=3
4

c12=6

c46=1
b6=-5

b1=5
1

c13=3

c56=4
3

c35=2

5
b5=-6

b3=5
z24 -c24 =(-c46+c56+c35+c13-c12)-c24=(-1+4+2+3-6)-5=-3

x34z34 -c34
b2=-2

b4=3

c12=6
b1=5

b6=-5

c34=4

c46=1

c13=3

c56=4
3

c35=2

5
b5=-6

b3=5
z34 -c34 =(-c46+c56+c35)-c34=(-1+4+2)-4=+1x34

x34
b2=-2

b4=3

x12=2
b1=5

b6=-5

x34=0

x46=3

x13=3

x56=2
3
b3=5

x35=8

5
b5=-6

min{x56,x35}=min{2,8}=2, x56

x24x56
b2=-2

b4=3

x12=2
b1=5

b6=-5

x34=2

x13=3
3
b3=5

x35=6

x46=5

5
b5=-6

x24x56z24 -c24 z56-c56


b2=-2

c24=5

b4=3
4

c12=6
b1=5

b6=-5

c34=4

c46=1

c13=3

c56=4
3
b3=5

c35=2

5
b5=-6

z24 -c24 =(c34+c13-c12)-c24=(4+3-6)-5= -4


z56 -c56 =(c46+c34-c35)-c56=(1+4-2)-4= -1


b2=-2

b4=3

x12=2
b1=5

b6=-5

x34=2

x46=5

x13=3
3
b3=5

x35=6

5
b5=-6

min z=62+33+42+26+15=46


u25=6

2
u12=8

u42=2 u45=4
u23=3

u13=7

u57=9

u65=7

u34=4 u46=3

u67=8

6
u36=1

uijxij

1
20xij uij


1xij=uijij
1

uij=5

12

xij=5

2xij<uijij
1

uij=5
xij=3

12
12=u12-x12=5-3=2

3xij=0ji

uij=5

21

xij=0

xij>0ji
1

uij=5
xij=5

21
12=x12=5

xij=0
u=6
2
u=8
f=0

x=0
u=2
x=0

x=0

u=3 x=0

x=0
3

u=9
x=0

u=4
x=0

u=7 x=0

x=0
u=4

u=7

x=0

x=0
u=8

u=3

x=0
u=1

f=0


u=6
x=0
u=8
x=0
f=0
1

u=3
x=0

u=2
x=0

u=4
x=0

u=7
x=0
3

u=7
x=0

4
u=4
x=0

u=3
x=0

u=1
x=0

u=9
x=0
7
u=8
x=0

f=0

17
2

u=8
x=0
=8
f=0

u=6
x=0
u=2
x=0

u=3
x=0
=3

u=9
x=0

u=4
x=0
u=7
x=0

u=7
x=0

u=4
x=0
3

u=3
x=0
6

=1 u=1
x=0

= min{8,3,1,8}=1
xij=xij+

7
u=8
x=0
=8

f=0

f=1

u=6
2

x=0
u=2
u=4

u=8
x=1

f=1

x=0

x=0

x=0

u=7
3

u=9
x=0

x=0

u=3 x=1

u=7 x=0

x=0
u=4

x=1

u=3

x=1
u=1

7
u=8

f=1

17
u=6 =6
2
u=8
x=1

f=1

u=3

x=0
u=7

=7

x=0
u=2
x=0
x=1
=1
x=0
u=4

u=9
=9
x=0

u=4
x=0

u=7 x=0

x=0

x=1

u=3
x=1

7
u=8

u=1

=min {7,1,6,9}=1, xij=xij+1, f=f+1=2

f=1


u=6
2
u=8
f=2

x=1
u=2
x=0

x=1

u=3 x=0

x=1
3

u=9

u=4

x=1

x=0

u=7 x=0

x=0

x=0
u=4

u=7

x=1

u=3

x=1
u=1

7
u=8

f=2

17
u=6 =5
2

=7

u=8
f=2

x=1
u=2
x=0

x=1

u=3 x=0

x=1
3

u=9

u=4

x=1

x=0

u=7 x=0

x=0

x=0
u=4

u=7

x=1

u=3

x=1

=8

u=8
6

u=1

=min {7,5,8}=5, xij=xij+5, f=f+5=2+5=7

f=2


u=6
2
u=8
f=7

x=6
u=2
x=0

x=6

u=3 x=0

x=1
3

u=9

u=4

x=6

x=0

u=7 x=0

x=0

x=0
u=4

u=7

x=1

u=3

x=1
u=1

7
u=8

f=7

17
u=6
2
u=8
f=7
1

u=3 x=0
x=1

u=7
=6

x=6
u=2
x=0

x=6

5
u=9
=3
x=6

u=4
x=0

=4 u=7 x=0

x=0
x=0 =4
u=4
u=3
x=1

x=1
u=8
6

u=1

=min {6,7,4,3}=3, xij=xij+3,


f=f+3=7+3=10

f=7


u=6
2
u=8
f=10

x=6
u=2
x=0

x=6

u=3 x=0

x=4

x=3

u=7
3

5
u=9

u=4

x=9

x=3

u=7 x=0

x=0
u=4

x=1

u=3

x=1
u=1

7
u=8

f=10

17
u=6
2
u=8
f=10

x=6
u=2
x=0

x=6

u=3 x=0

x=4

=3

u=9

u=4

x=9

x=3

x=3

u=7

u=4
=1 x=1

f=10

u=7 x=0

=3
x=0
u=3

x=1
u=8
6

=7

u=1

=min {3,1,3,7}=1, xij=xij+1, f=f+1=10+1=11


u=6
2
u=8
f=11

x=6
u=2
x=0

x=6

u=3 x=0

x=5

x=4

u=7
3

5
u=9

u=4

x=9

x=3

u=7 x=0

x=1
u=4

x=2

u=3

x=1
u=1

7
u=8

171
123

f=11


u=6

2
u=8
f=11

x=6
u=2
x=0

x=6

u=3 x=0

x=5

x=4

u=7
3

u=9

u=4

x=9

x=3

u=7 x=0

x=1
u=4

x=2

u=3
x=1

7
u=8

u=1

f=112,53,43,5
u25+u34+u35=6+4+1=11

f=11

1
1
3

10

2
4

18

5
7

3
7

5
4
8

X={1}, w1=0
w1=0
2

1
1
3

10
w1=0

2
4

5
7

4
5

3
7

5
4
8

min {c12,c14,c16}=min {0+2,0+1,0+3}=min {2,1,3}=1


X={1,4}, w4=1

X={1,4}
w1=0

w2=2
2

1
1
3

w4=1

10

2
4

5
7

4
5

3
7

5
4
8

min {c12,c16,c42,c47}=min {0+2,0+3,1+10,1+2}=min {2,3,11,3}=2


X={1,2,4}, w2=2

X={1,2,4}
w1=0

w2=2
2

1
1
3

w4=1

10

2
4

5
7

4
5

3
7

5
4
8

w6=3

min {c13,c23,c25,c47}=min {0+3,2+6,2+5,1+2}=min {3,8,7,3}=3


X={1,2,4,6}, w6=3

X={1,2,4,6}
w1=0

w2=2
2

1
1
3

w4=1

10

2
4

w6=3

5
7

4
5

3
7

5
4
8

w7=3

min {c23,c25,c47,c67}=min {2+6,2+5,1+2,3+4}=min {8,7,3,7}=3


X={1,2,4,6,7}, w7=3

X={1,2,4,6,7}
w1=0

w2=2
2

1
1
3

w4=1

10

5
7

4
5

2
4

w6=3

w5=6

5
3

4
8

w7=3

min {c23,c25,c75,c78}=min {2+6,2+5,3+3,3+8}=min {8,7,6,11}=6


X={1,2,4,5,6,7}, w5=6

X={1,2,4,6,7}
w1=0

w2=2
2

1
1
3

w4=1

10

5
7

2
4

w6=3

4
5

w3=8
3

w5=6

5
3

4
8

w7=3

min {c23,c53,c58,c78}=min {2+6,6+9,6+4,3+8}=min {8,15,10,11}=8


X={1,2,3,4,5,6,7}, w3=8

X={1,2,3,4,6,7}
w1=0

w2=2
2

1
1
3

w4=1

2
10

5
7

4
5

w3=8

2
4

w6=3

w5=6

w7=3

5
3

4
8

8
w8=10

min {c38,c58,c78}=min {8+6,6+4,3+7}=min {14,10,11}=10


X={1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8}, w8=10

X={1,2,3,4,6,7,8}
w1=0

w2=2
2

1
1
3

w4=1

10

w6=3

5
7

2
4

4
5

w3=8
3

w5=6

w7=3

5
3

4
8

8
w8=10

110{14758}10

12

B1
2

14

C1
9

10
6

B2

10

E
5
8

12
11

AE

C2

4
13

B3

D1

C3

10

D2

12

B1
2

14

C1
9

10
6

B2

10

11

C3

f5(E)=0

E
5

12

C2

4
13

B3

D1

10

D2

12

B1
2

14

C1
9

10
6

B2

10

D1

11

C3

f5(E)=0

E
5

12

C2

4
13

B3

f4(D1)=5

D2

10

f 4 ( D1 ) d( D1 E) f 5 ( E) 5 0 5

12

B1
2

14

C1
9

10
6

B2

10

D1

11

C3

f5(E)=0

E
5

12

C2

4
13

B3

f4(D1)=5

10

D2
f4(D2)=2

f 4 ( D 2 ) d ( D 2 E) f 5 ( E) 2 0 2

f3(C1)=8
12

B1
2

14

C1
9

10

B2

10

D1

11

C3

f5(E)=0

E
5

12

C2

4
13

B3

f4(D1)=5

10

D2

f4(D2)=2

(C1 , D 1 ) f 4 ( D 1 )
f 3 (C1 ) min

(
C
,
D
)

f
(
D
)
1 2
4
2
3 5
8
min
min 8 C1 D1
9 2
11

f3(C1)=8
12

B1
2

14

10

f3(C2)=7

B2

C1

10

f4(D1)=5

D1

11

C3

f5(E)=0

E
5

12

C2

4
13

B3

10

D2

f4(D2)=2

(C 2 , D1 ) f 4 ( D1 )
f 3 (C 2 ) min

(
C
,
D
)

f
(
D
)
2 2
4
2
6 5
11
min
min 7 C 2 D 2
5 2
7

f3(C1)=8
12

B1
2

14

10

f3(C2)=7

B2

C1

10

f4(D1)=5

D1

11

C3

f5(E)=0

E
5

12

C2

4
13

B3

10

D2

f4(D2)=2

f3(C3)=12

(C 3 , D1 ) f 4 ( D1 )
f 3 (C 3 ) min

(
C
,
D
)

f
(
D
)
4
2
3 2
85
13
min
min 12 C 3 D 2
10 2
12

f2(B1)=20
12

B1
2

f3(C1)=8
14

10

f3(C2)=7

B2

C1

10

B3

f4(D1)=5

D1

11

C3

f5(E)=0

E
5

12

C2

4
13

10

D2

f4(D2)=2

f3(C3)=12

( B1 , C1 ) f 3 (C1 )
12 8
20


f 2 ( B1 ) min ( B1 , C 2 ) f 3 (C 2 ) min 14 7 min 21 20
( B , C ) f (C )
10 12
22
3
3
1 3


B1 C1

f2(B1)=21
12

B1
2

f3(C1)=8
14

10
f2(B2)=14

f3(C2)=7

B2

C1

10

B3

f4(D1)=5

D1

11

C3

f5(E)=0

E
5

12

C2

4
13

10

D2

f4(D2)=2

f3(C3)=12

( B 2 , C1 ) f 3 ( C1 )
68
14


f 2 ( B 2 ) min ( B 2 , C 2 ) f 3 (C 2 ) min 10 7 min 17 14
( B , C ) f (C )
4 12
16
3
3
2 3


B 2 C1

f2(B1)=21
12

B1
2

f3(C1)=8
14

10
f2(B2)=14

f3(C2)=7

B2

C1

10

B3
f2(B3)=19

f4(D1)=5

D1

11

C3

f5(E)=0

E
5

12

C2

4
13

10

D2

f4(D2)=2

f3(C3)=12

( B 3 , C1 ) f 3 ( C1 )
13 8
21


f 2 ( B3 ) min ( B3 , C 2 ) f 3 (C 2 ) min 12 7 min 19 19
( B , C ) f (C )
11 12
23
3
3
3 3


B3 C 2

f2(B1)=21
12

B1
f1(A)=19

f3(C1)=8
14

10
f2(B2)=14

f3(C2)=7

B2

C1

10

B3
f2(B3)=19

f4(D1)=5

D1

11

C3

f5(E)=0

E
5

12

C2

4
13

10

D2

f4(D2)=2

f3(C3)=12

( A, B1 ) f 2 ( B1 )
2 21
23


f 1 ( A) min ( A, B 2 ) f 2 ( B 2 ) min 5 14 min 19 19
( A, B ) f ( B )
1 19
20
3
2
3


A B 2

f2(B1)=21
12

B1
f1(A)=19

f3(C1)=8
14

10
f2(B2)=14

f3(C2)=7

B2

C1

10

B3
f2(B3)=19

f4(D1)=5

D1

11

C3

f5(E)=0

E
5

12

C2

4
13

10

D2

f4(D2)=2

f3(C3)=12


A AB2 B2

f2(B1)=21
12

B1
f1(A)=19

f3(C1)=8
14

10
f2(B2)=14

f3(C2)=7

B2

C1

10

f2(B3)=19

f4(D1)=5

D1

11

C3

f5(E)=0

E
5

12

C2

4
13

B3

10

D2

f4(D2)=2

f3(C3)=12


A AB2 B2 B2C1 C1

f2(B1)=21
12

B1
f1(A)=19

f3(C1)=8
14

10
f2(B2)=14

f3(C2)=7

B2

C1

10

f2(B3)=19

f4(D1)=5

D1

11

C3

f5(E)=0

E
5

12

C2

4
13

B3

10

D2

f4(D2)=2

f3(C3)=12


A AB2 B2 B2C1 C1 C1D1 D1

f2(B1)=21
12

B1
f1(A)=19

f3(C1)=8
14

10
f2(B2)=14

f3(C2)=7

B2

C1

10

f2(B3)=19

f4(D1)=5

D1

11

C3

f5(E)=0

E
5

12

C2

4
13

B3

10

D2

f4(D2)=2

f3(C3)=12


A AB2 B2 B2C1 C1 C1D1 D1 D1E
AE19AB 2C1 D1 E

2
4ABC

15

13

11

28

29

30

40

43

45

51

55

58

x1

x2

x3

x4

You might also like