You are on page 1of 56

Chapter 6

Financial Statements Analysis

Tata McGraw-Hill Publishing Company Limited, Financial Management

6-1

FINANCIAL STATEMENTS ANALYSIS


Ratio Analysis

Common Size Statements


Importance and Limitations of Ratio Analysis Mini Case
Tata McGraw-Hill Publishing Company Limited, Financial Management

6-2

Ratio Analysis
Ratio analysis is a widely used tool of financial analysis. It is defined as the systematic use of ratio to interpret the financial statements so that the strengths and weaknesses of a firm as well as its historical performance and current financial condition can be determined.

Tata McGraw-Hill Publishing Company Limited, Financial Management

6-3

Basis of Comparison
1) Trend Analysis involves comparison of a firm over a period of time, that is, present ratios are compared with past ratios for the same firm. It indicates the direction of change in the performance improvement, deterioration or constancy over the years.
2) Interfirm Comparison involves comparing the ratios of a firm with those of others in the same lines of business or for the industry as a whole. It reflects the firms performance in relation to its competitors. 3) Comparison with standards or industry average.

Tata McGraw-Hill Publishing Company Limited, Financial Management

6-4

Types of Ratios
Liquidity Ratios Capital Structure Ratios

Profitability Ratios
Efficiency ratios Integrated Analysis Ratios Growth Ratios
Tata McGraw-Hill Publishing Company Limited, Financial Management

6-5

Net Working Capital


Net working capital is a measure of liquidity calculated by subtracting current liabilities from current assets.
Table 1: Net Working Capital Particulars Company A Company B

Total current assets Total current liabilities NWC


Table 2: Change in Net Working Capital

Rs 1,80,000 1,20,000 60,000

Rs 30,000 10,000 20,000

Particulars
Current assets Current liabilities NWC

Company A
Rs 1,00,000 25,000 75,000

Company B
Rs 2,00,000 1,00,000 1,00,000
6-6

Tata McGraw-Hill Publishing Company Limited, Financial Management

Liquidity Ratios

Liquidity ratios measure the ability of a firm to

meet its short-term obligations.

Tata McGraw-Hill Publishing Company Limited, Financial Management

6-7

Current Ratio
Current Ratio is a measure of liquidity calculated dividing the current assets by the current liabilities

Current Ratio =

Current Assets Current Liabilities


Firm B Rs 30,000 Rs 10,000 3:1
6-8

Particulars Current Assets Current Liabilities Current Ratio

Firm A Rs 1,80,000 Rs 1,20,000 = 3:2 (1.5:1)

Tata McGraw-Hill Publishing Company Limited, Financial Management

Acid-Test Ratio
The quick or acid test ratio takes into consideration the differences in the liquidity of the components of current assets.

Acid-test Ratio =

Quick Assets
Current Liabilities

Quick Assets = Current assets Stock Pre-paid expenses


Tata McGraw-Hill Publishing Company Limited, Financial Management

6-9

Example 1: Acid-Test Ratio


Cash Debtors Inventory Total current assets Total current liabilities (1) Current Ratio (2) Acid-test Ratio Rs 2,000 2,000 12,000 16,000 8,000 2:1 0.5 : 1

Tata McGraw-Hill Publishing Company Limited, Financial Management

6 - 10

Supplementary Ratios for Liquidity


Inventory Turnover Ratio Debtors Turnover Ratio Creditors Turnover Ratio

Tata McGraw-Hill Publishing Company Limited, Financial Management

6 - 11

Inventory Turnover Ratio


The ratio indicates how fast inventory is sold. A high ratio is good from the viewpoint of liquidity and vice versa. A low ratio would signify that inventory does not sell fast and stays on the shelf or in the warehouse for a long time.

Cost of goods sold


Inventory turnover ratio = Average inventory

The cost of goods sold means sales minus gross profit. The average inventory refers to the simple average of the opening and closing inventory.
Tata McGraw-Hill Publishing Company Limited, Financial Management

6 - 12

Example 2: Inventory Turnover Ratio


A firm has sold goods worth Rs 3,00,000 with a gross profit margin of 20 per cent. The stock at the beginning and the end of the year was Rs 35,000 and Rs 45,000 respectively. What is the inventory turnover ratio?

Inventory turnover ratio

(Rs 3,00,000 Rs 60,000) (Rs 35,000 + Rs 45,000) 2

6 (times per year)

12 months Inventory = = 2 months holding period Inventory turnover ratio, (6)

Tata McGraw-Hill Publishing Company Limited, Financial Management

6 - 13

Debtors Turnover Ratio


The ratio measures how rapidly receivables are collected. A high ratio is indicative of shorter time-lag between credit sales and cash collection. A low ratio shows that debts are not being collected rapidly.

Debtors turnover ratio

Net credit sales


Average debtors

Net credit sales consist of gross credit sales minus returns, if any, from customers. Average debtors is the simple average of debtors (including bills receivable) at the beginning and at the end of year.
Tata McGraw-Hill Publishing Company Limited, Financial Management

6 - 14

Example 3: Debtors Turnover Ratio


A firm has made credit sales of Rs 2,40,000 during the year. The outstanding amount of debtors at the beginning and at the end of the year respectively was Rs 27,500 and Rs 32,500. Determine the debtors turnover ratio. Debtors turnover ratio Rs 2,40,000 8 (times per year) 1.5 Months
6 - 15

(Rs 27,500 + Rs 32,500) 2


= 12 Months Debtors turnover ratio, (8)

Debtors collection period

Tata McGraw-Hill Publishing Company Limited, Financial Management

Creditors Turnover Ratio


A low turnover ratio reflects liberal credit terms granted by suppliers, while a high ratio shows that accounts are to be settled rapidly. The creditors turnover ratio is an important tool of analysis as a firm can reduce its requirement of current assets by relying on suppliers credit.

Creditors turnover ratio

Net credit purchases Average creditors

Net credit purchases = Gross credit purchases - Returns to suppliers. Average creditors = Average of creditors (including bills payable) outstanding at the beginning and at the end of the year.
Tata McGraw-Hill Publishing Company Limited, Financial Management

6 - 16

Example 4: Creditors Turnover Ratio


The firm in previous Examples has made credit purchases of Rs

1,80,000. The amount payable to the creditors at the beginning


and at the end of the year is Rs 42,500 and Rs 47,500 respectively. Find out the creditors turnover ratio.

Creditors turnover ratio Creditors payment period

(Rs 1,80,000) (Rs 42,500 Rs 47,500) 2

4 (times per year)

12 months
Creditors turnover ratio, (4)

= 3 months

Tata McGraw-Hill Publishing Company Limited, Financial Management

6 - 17

The summing up of the three turnover ratios (known as a cash cycle) has a bearing on the liquidity of a firm. The cash cycle captures the interrelationship of sales, collections from debtors and payment to creditors.

The combined effect of the three turnover ratios is summarised below:


Inventory holding period Add: Debtors collection period Less: Creditors payment period 2 months + 1.5 months 3 months 0.5 months

As a rule, the shorter is the cash cycle, the better are the liquidity ratios as measured above and vice versa.
Tata McGraw-Hill Publishing Company Limited, Financial Management

6 - 18

DEFENSIVE INTERVAL RATIO


Defensive interval ratio is the ratio between quick assets and projected daily cash requirement.

Defensiveinterval ratio

Liquid assets = Projected daily cash requirement

Projected daily cash requirement

Projected cash operating expenditure Number of days in a year (365)

Tata McGraw-Hill Publishing Company Limited, Financial Management

6 - 19

Example 5: Defensive Interval Ratio


The projected cash operating expenditure of a firm from the
next year is Rs 1,82,500. It has liquid current assets amounting to Rs 40,000. Determine the defensive-interval

ratio. Rs 1,82,500
365 Rs 40,000 Rs 500

Projected daily cash requirement = Defensive-interval ratio =

= Rs 500

= 80 days
6 - 20

Tata McGraw-Hill Publishing Company Limited, Financial Management

Cash-flow From Operations Ratio


Cash-flow from operation ratio measures liquidity of a firm by comparing actual cash flows from operations (in lieu of current and potential cash inflows from current assets such as inventory and debtors) with current liability. Cash-flow from operations ratio Cash-flow from operations Current liabilities

Tata McGraw-Hill Publishing Company Limited, Financial Management

6 - 21

Leverage Capital Structure Ratio


There are two aspects of the long-term solvency of a firm: (i) Ability to repay the principal when due, and

(ii) Regular payment of the interest . Capital structure or leverage ratios throw light on the long-term solvency of a firm. Accordingly, there are two different types of leverage ratios.
First type: These ratios are computed from the balance sheet Second type: These ratios are computed from the Income Statement

(a) Debt-equity ratio


(b) Debt-assets ratio (c) Equity-assets ratio

(a) Interest coverage ratio


(b) Dividend coverage ratio

Tata McGraw-Hill Publishing Company Limited, Financial Management

6 - 22

I. Debt-equity ratio
Debt-equity ratio measures the ratio of long-term or total debt to shareholders equity.

Debt-equity ratio measures the ratio of long-term debt + Other Current Total Debt Debt-equity ratio = to shareholders equity Liabilities = Total external term or total de3bt Shareholders equity Obligations
If the D/E ratio is high, the owners are putting up relatively less money of their own. It is danger signal for the lenders and creditors. If the project should fail financially, the creditors would lose heavily. A low D/E ratio has just the opposite implications. To the creditors, a relatively high stake of the owners implies sufficient safety margin and substantial protection against shrinkage in assets.
Tata McGraw-Hill Publishing Company Limited, Financial Management

Long-term Debt + Short

6 - 23

For the company also, the servicing of debt is less burdensome and consequently its credit standing is not adversely affected, its operational flexibility is not jeopardised and it will be able to raise additional funds. The disadvantage of low debt-equity ratio is that the shareholders of the firm are deprived of the benefits of trading on equity or leverage.

Tata McGraw-Hill Publishing Company Limited, Financial Management

6 - 24

Trading on Equity
Trading on equity (leverage) is the use of borrowed funds in expectation of higher return to equity-holders. Trading on Equity Particular (a) Total assets Financing pattern: Equity capital 15% Debt (b)Operating profit (EBIT) Less: Interest Earnings before taxes Less: Taxes (0.35) Earnings after taxes Return on equity (per cent) A 1,000 1,000 300 300 105 195 19.5 (Amount in Rs thousand) B 1,000 800 200 300 30 270 94.5 175.5 21.9 C 1,000 600 400 300 60 240 84 156 26 D 1,000 200 800 300 120 180 63 117 58.5
6 - 25

Tata McGraw-Hill Publishing Company Limited, Financial Management

II. Debt to Total Capital


The relationship between creditors funds and owners capital can also be expressed using Debt to total capital ratio. Debt to total capital ratio =

Total debt Permanent capital

Permanent

Capital

Shareholders equity Long-term debt.

Tata McGraw-Hill Publishing Company Limited, Financial Management

6 - 26

III. Debt to total assets ratio


Debt to total assets ratio =
Proprietary Ratio Proprietary ratio indicates the are financed by owners funds. extent to which assets

Total debt Total assets

Proprietary ratio =
Capital Gearing Ratio

Proprietary funds X 100 Total assets

Capital gearing ratio is used to know the relationship between equity funds (net worth) and fixed income bearing funds (Preference shares, debentures and other borrowed funds.
Tata McGraw-Hill Publishing Company Limited, Financial Management

6 - 27

Coverage Ratio
Interest Coverage Ratio Interest Coverage Ratio measures the firms ability to make contractual interest payments. Interest coverage ratio = Dividend Coverage Ratio
Dividend Coverage Ratio measures the firms ability to pay dividend on preference share which carry a stated rate of return.

EBIT (Earning before interest and taxes) Interest

Dividend coverage ratio =

EAT (Earning after taxes) Preference dividend


6 - 28

Tata McGraw-Hill Publishing Company Limited, Financial Management

Total fixed charge coverage ratio


Total fixed charge coverage ratio measures the firms ability to meet all fixed payment obligations. EBIT + Lease Payment Total fixed charge = coverage ratio Interest + Lease payments + (Preference dividend + Instalment of Principal)/(1-t)

Total Cashflow Coverage Ratio


However, coverage ratios mentioned above, suffer from one major limitation, that is, they relate the firms ability to meet its various financial obligations to its earnings. Accordingly, it would be more appropriate to relate cash resources of a firm to its various fixed financial obligations.
EBIT + Lease Payments + Depreciation + Non-cash expenses
Lease payment + + Interest (Principal repayment) (1 t) + (Preference dividend) (1 - t)
6 - 29

Total cashflow = coverage ratio

Tata McGraw-Hill Publishing Company Limited, Financial Management

Debt Service Coverage Ratio


Debt-service coverage ratio (DSCR) is considered a more comprehensive and apt measure to compute debt service capacity of a business firm.

DSCR

t=1

EATt

Interestt

t=1 n

Depreciationt

OAt

Instalmentt

DEBT SERVICE CAPACITY


Debt service capacity is the ability of a firm to make the contractual payments required on a scheduled basis over the life of the debt.
Tata McGraw-Hill Publishing Company Limited, Financial Management

6 - 30

Example 6: Debt-Service Coverage Ratio


Agro Industries Ltd has submitted the following projections. You are required to work out yearly debt service coverage ratio (DSCR) and the average DSCR.
(Figures in Rs lakh) Year 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Net profit for the year 21.67 34.77 36.01 19.20 18.61 18.40 18.33 16.41 Interest on term loan during the year 19.14 17.64 15.12 12.60 10.08 7.56 5.04 Nil Repayment of term loan in the year 10.70 18.00 18.00 18.00 18.00 18.00 18.00 18.00

The net profit has been arrived after charging depreciation of Rs 17.68 lakh every year.
Tata McGraw-Hill Publishing Company Limited, Financial Management

6 - 31

Solution
Table 3: Determination of Debt Service Coverage Ratio

(Amount in lakh of rupees)


Ye ar Net profit Depreciation Interest Cash available (col. 2+3+4) 5 58.49 70.09 68.81 49.48 46.37 43.64 41.05 34.09 Principal instalment Debt obligation (col. 4 + col. 6) 7 29.84 35.64 33.12 30.60 28.08 25.56 23.04 18.00 1.83 6 - 32 DSCR [col. 5 col. 7 (No. of times)] 8 1.96 1.97 2.08 1.62 1.65 1.71 1.78 1.89

1 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8

2 21.67 34.77 36.01 19.20 18.61 18.40 18.33 16.41

3 17.68 17.68 17.68 17.68 17.68 17.68 17.68 17.68

4 19.14 17.64 15.12 12.60 10.08 7.56 5.04 Nil

6 10.70 18.00 18.00 18.00 18.00 18.00 18.00 18.00

Average DSCR (DSCR 8)

Tata McGraw-Hill Publishing Company Limited, Financial Management

Profitability Ratio
Profitability ratios can be computed either from sales or investment. Profitability Ratios Profitability Ratios

Related to Sales
(i) Profit Margin (ii) Expenses Ratio

Related to Investments
(i) Return on Investments (ii) Return on Shareholders Equity
6 - 33

Tata McGraw-Hill Publishing Company Limited, Financial Management

Profit Margin
Gross Profit Margin
Gross profit margin measures the percentage of each sales rupee remaining after the firm has paid for its goods.

Gross profit margin =

Gross Profit X 100 Sales

Tata McGraw-Hill Publishing Company Limited, Financial Management

6 - 34

Net Profit Margin


Net profit margin measures the percentage of each sales rupee remaining after all costs and expense including interest and taxes have been deducted. Net profit margin can be computed in three ways Earning before interest and taxes Net sales Earnings before taxes Net sales

i. Operating Profit Ratio =

ii. Pre-tax Profit Ratio =

iii. Net Profit Ratio =

Earning after interest and taxes Net sales


6 - 35

Tata McGraw-Hill Publishing Company Limited, Financial Management

Example 7: From the following information of a firm, determine (i) Gross profit margin and (ii) Net profit margin. 1. Sales Rs 2,00,000 2. Cost of goods sold 1,00,000 3. Other operating expenses 50,000
(1) Gross profit margin =
Rs 1,00,000

Rs 2,00,000
Rs 50,000

= 50 per cent

(2) Net profit margin =

Rs 2,00,000

= 25 per cent

Tata McGraw-Hill Publishing Company Limited, Financial Management

6 - 36

Expenses Ratio
i. Cost of goods sold = ii. Operating expenses = Cost of goods sold X 100 Net sales Administrative exp. + Selling exp. Net sales Administrative expenses iii. Administrative expenses = Net sales iv. Selling expenses ratio = Selling expenses Net sales X 100 X 100

X 100

Cost of goods sold + Operating expenses v. Operating ratio = X 100 Net sales vi. Financial expenses = Financial expenses Net sales X 100
6 - 37

Tata McGraw-Hill Publishing Company Limited, Financial Management

Return on Investment
Return on Investments measures the overall effectiveness of management in generating profits with its available assets.
i. Return on Assets (ROA) ROA = EAT + (Interest Tax advantage on interest) Average total assets

ii. Return on Capital Employed (ROCE)


ROCE = EAT + (Interest Tax advantage on interest) Average total capital employed
6 - 38

Tata McGraw-Hill Publishing Company Limited, Financial Management

Return on Shareholders Equity


Return on shareholders equity measures the return on the owners (both preference and equity shareholders) investment in the firm. Return on total shareholders equity = Net profit after taxes X 100 Average total shareholders equity

Return on ordinary shareholders equity (Net worth) =


Net profit after taxes Preference dividend X 100 Average ordinary shareholders equity
Tata McGraw-Hill Publishing Company Limited, Financial Management

6 - 39

Efficiency Ratio
Activity ratios measure the speed with which various accounts/assets are converted into sales or cash.
Inventory turnover measures the efficiency of various types of inventories.

Cost goods sold i. Inventory Turnover measures theof activity/liquidity of Inventory Turnover Ratio = Average inventory inventory of a firm; the speed with which inventory is sold
Cost of raw materials used i. Inventory Turnover measures the activity/liquidity of Raw materials turnover = inventory of a firm; the speed with which inventory is sold Average raw material inventory
of goods manufactured i. Inventory Turnover measuresCost the activity/liquidity of Work-in-progress turnover = Average work-in-progress inventory inventory of a firm; the speed with which inventory is sold
Tata McGraw-Hill Publishing Company Limited, Financial Management

6 - 40

Debtors Turnover Ratio


Liquidity of a firms receivables can be examined in two ways.
Credit sales i. Inventory Turnover measures the activity/liquidity of inventory of i. Debtors turnover = a firm; the speed with Average whichdebtors inventory + Average is sold bills receivable (B/R)

2. Average collection period =

Months (days) in a year Debtors turnover

Months (days) in a year (x) (Average Debtors + Average (B/R) i. Inventory Turnover measures the activity/liquidity of inventory of a Alternatively = Total firm; the speed with which inventory is credit sold sales

Ageing Schedule enables slow paying debtors.

analysis

to

identify
6 - 41

Tata McGraw-Hill Publishing Company Limited, Financial Management

Assets Turnover Ratio


Assets turnover indicates the efficiency uses all its assets to generate sales. with which firm

Cost of goods sold of inventory of i. Inventory Turnover measures the activity/liquidity i. Total assets turnover = a firm; the speed with which inventory Average total is sold assets ii. Fixed assets turnover = Cost of goods sold Average fixed assets

Cost of goods sold i. Inventory Turnover measures the activity/liquidity of inventory of iii. Capital turnover = Average is capital a firm; the speed with which inventory sold employed Cost of goods sold iv. Current assets turnover = Average current assets Cost of goods sold of inventory of i. Inventory Turnover measures the activity/liquidity v. Working capital turnover = Net working capital a firm; the speed with which inventory is sold
Tata McGraw-Hill Publishing Company Limited, Financial Management

6 - 42

1)
2)

Return on shareholders equity = EAT/Average total shareholders equity.


Return on equity funds = (EAT Preference dividend)/Average ordinary shareholders equity (net worth).

3)

Earnings per share (EPS) = Net profit available to equity shareholders (EAT Dp)/Number of equity shares outstanding (N).

4)

Dividends

per

share

(DPS)

Dividend

paid

to

ordinary

shareholders/Number of ordinary shares outstanding (N).

5)
6) 7)

Earnings yield = EPS/Market price per share.


Dividend Yield = DPS/Market price per share. Dividend payment/payout (D/P) ratio = DPS/EPS.

8)
9)

Price-earnings (P/E) ratio = Market price of a share/EPS.


Book value per share = Ordinary shareholders equity/Number of equity shares outstanding.
Tata McGraw-Hill Publishing Company Limited, Financial Management

6 - 43

Integrated Analysis Ratio


Integrated ratios provide better insight about financial and economic analysis of a firm.
(1) Rate of return on assets (ROA) can be decomposed in to (i) Net profit margin (EAT/Sales) (ii) Assets turnover (Sales/Total assets) (2) Return on Equity (ROE) can be decomposed in to (i) (EAT/Sales) x (Sales/Assets) x (Assets/Equity)

(ii) (EAT/EBT) x (EBT/EBIT) x (EBIT/Sales) x (Sales/Assets) x (Assets/Equity)


Tata McGraw-Hill Publishing Company Limited, Financial Management

6 - 44

Rate of Return on Assets EAT as percentage of sales EAT Divided by Sales Sales Fixed assets Gross profit = Sales less cost of goods sold Minus Expenses: Selling Administrative Interest Assets turnover Divided by Plus Total Assets Current assets

Alternatively Shareholder equity Plus Long-term borrowed funds Plus Current liabilities

Minus
Income-tax

Tata McGraw-Hill Publishing Company Limited, Financial Management

6 - 45

Return on Assets
Earning Power
Earning power is the overall profitability of a firm; is computed by multiplying net profit margin and assets turnover.

Earning power = Net profit margin Assets turnover Where, Net profit margin = Earning after taxes/Sales Asset turnover = Sales/Total assets
Earning after taxes Sales of inventory EAT of i. Inventory Turnover measures the activity/liquidity x x Earning Power = a firm; the speed with which Salesinventory isTotal sold Assets Total assets

Tata McGraw-Hill Publishing Company Limited, Financial Management

6 - 46

EXAMPLE: 8
Assume that there are two firms, A and B, each having total assets amounting to Rs 4,00,000, and average net profits after taxes of 10 per cent, that is, Rs 40,000, each.
Firm A has sales of Rs 4,00,000, whereas the sales of firm B aggregate Rs 40,00,000. Determine the ROA of firms A and B. Table 4 shows the ROA based on two components.

Table 4: Return on Assets (ROA) of Firms A and B


Particulars 1. Net sales 2. Net profit 3. Total assets 4. Profit margin (2 1) (per cent) 5. Assets turnover (1 3) (times) 6. ROA ratio (4 5) (per cent) Firm A Rs 4,00,000 40,000 4,00,000 10 1 10 Firm B Rs 40,00,000 40,000 4,00,000 1 10 10
6 - 47

Tata McGraw-Hill Publishing Company Limited, Financial Management

Return on Equity (ROE)


ROE is the product of the following three ratios: Net profit ratio (x) Assets turnover (x) Financial leverage/Equity multiplier Three-component model of ROE can be broadened further to consider the effect of interest and tax payments.

Net Profit EBT the activity/liquidity EBIT EAT Turnover measures i. Inventory of x = x Sales Earnings taxes EBIT with which Sales inventory before of a firm; the speed inventory is sold
As a result of three sub-parts of net profit ratio, the ROE is composed of the following 5 components.

EAT EBT

EBT EBIT

EBIT x Sales

Sales Assets

Assets Equity
6 - 48

Tata McGraw-Hill Publishing Company Limited, Financial Management

A 5-way break-up of ROE enables the management of a firm to analyse the effect of interest payments and tax payments separately from operating profitability. To illustrate further assume 8 per cent interest rate, 35 per cent tax rate and other operating expense of Rs 3,22,462 (Firm A) and Rs 39,26,462 (Firm B) for the facts contained in Example 8. Table 5 shows the ROE (based on the 5 components) of Firms A and B. Table 5: ROE (Five-way Basis) of Firms A and B Particulars Net sales Less: Operating expenses Earnings before interest and taxes (EBIT) Less: Interest (8%) Earnings before taxes (EBT) Less: Taxes (35%) Earnings after taxes (EAT) Total assets Debt Equity EAT/EBT (times) EBT/EBIT (times) EBIT/Sales (per cent) Sales/Assets (times) Assets/Equity (times) ROE (per cent) Firm A Rs 4,00,000 3,22,462 77,538 16,000 61,538 21,538 40,000 4,00,000 2,00,000 2,00,000 0.65 0.79 19.4 1 2 20 Firm B Rs 40,00,000 39,26,462 73,538 12,000 61,538 21,538 40,000 4,00,000 2,50,000 1,50,000 0.65 0.84 1.84 10 1.6 16 6 - 49

Tata McGraw-Hill Publishing Company Limited, Financial Management

Common Size Statements


Preparation of common-size financial statements is an extension of ratio analysis. These statements convert absolute sums into more easily understood percentages of some base amount. It is sales in the case of income statement and totals of assets and liabilities in the case of the balance sheet.

Limitations
Ratio analysis in view of its several limitations should be considered only as a tool for analysis rather than as an end in itself. The reliability and significance attached to ratios will largely hinge upon the quality of data on which they are based. They are as good or as bad as the data itself. Nevertheless, they are an important tool of financial analysis.
Tata McGraw-Hill Publishing Company Limited, Financial Management

6 - 50

CASE STUDY

Tata McGraw-Hill Publishing Company Limited, Financial Management

6 - 51

From the following selected financials of Reliance Industries Ltd (RIL) for the period 2001-2006, appraise its financial health from the point of view of liquidity, solvency, and profitability. Selected financial data and ratios Particulars (I) Related to Liquidity Analysis Current assets Marketable investments Inventory Debtors Advances Cash and bank balance Current liabilities Short-term bank borrowings Sundry creditors Interest accrued Creditors for capital goods Other current liabilities & provisions Other data and ratios Net working capital Credit sales Cost of goods sold Cost of raw material used Credit purchases Average debtors Average creditors Current ratio Acid test ratio Debtors turnover Creditors turnover Debtors cycle (days) Creditors cycle (days) 2001 9,844.48 3387.25 2299.85 1,134.17 2,922.58 100.63 5,312.06 337.76 3,754.50 223.00 104.72 892.08 2002 13,025.31 536.80 4976.07 2,722.46 3,310.27 1,760.71 9,830.10 2,148.27 5,847.20 389.23 175.16 1270.24 2003 17,925.25 536.19 7510.14 2,975.49 6,756.22 147.21 18,160.39 7,193.77 8288.10 380.15 717.48 1580.89 2004 23,245.88 536.11 7,231.22 3,189.93 12,064.38 224.24 16,966.15 9,145.14 366.78 676.45 2,670.75 4,107.03 (Amount in Rs crore) 2005 28,988.62 536.11 7,412.88 3,927.81 13,503.03 3,608.79 21,934.45 12,684.39 366.95 525.37 3471.80 4,885.94 2006 24,591.03 16.58 10,119.82 4,163.62 8,144.85 2,146.16 21,441.88 11,438.69 310.42 728.18 3,890.98 2,073.61

4,532.42 22,886.51 21,290.91 18,155.98 21,608.85 988.31 3,170.68 1.85 0.87 23 7 16 54

3,195.21 45,073.88 45,957.85 41,023.35 45,083.06 1,928.31 4,800.85 1.33 0.51 23 9 16 39

-235.14 49,743.54 54,642.60 50,378.65 56,884.49 2,848.97 7,067.65 0.99 0.20 17 8 21 45

6,279.73 56,247.03 41,657.92 34,721.39 60,246.91 3,094.02 9,413.58 1.75 .26 17.63 6.40 21 57

7,054.17 73,164.10 53,345.03 45,931.87 70,014.80 3,558.87 11,515.6 1.66 .55 18.62 6.08 20 60

3,149.15 89,124.16 65,535.84 58,342.31 68,516.87 4,045.71 12,688.31 1.49 .38 21.40 5.40 17 67

Tata McGraw-Hill Publishing Company Limited, Financial Management

6 - 52

CONTD. Particulars (II) Related to Solvency Analysis Free reserves Paid up capital Preference capital Bonus equity capital Total equity Long-term borrowings Current liabilities Total debt EBIT Interest Total debt-equity ratio Long-term debt-equity ratio Interest coverage ratio (III) Related to Profitability Analysis Sales (manufacturing) Cost of goods sold EBDIT (including other earnings) EBIT EBT EAT Interest Average total capital employed Average total assets Average equity funds Gross profit % Operating profit ratio % Net profit ratio % Cost of goods sold ratio % Rate of return on capital employed (ROCE)1 ROR (Total assets)2 ROR (Equity funds)

2001 9,307.89 1,053.49 0.00 481.77 10,843.15 9,798.03 5,312.06 15,110.09 4,032.37 1,215.56 1.39 0.90 3.32 22886.51 21290.91 5,597.48 4,032.37 2,786.00 2,646.50 1,215.55 19235.95 29622.14 10715.17 24.46 17.62 11.56 93.03 20.07 13.03 24.70

2002 21,834.29 1,395.85 0.00 481.77 23,711.91 16,780.21 9,830.10 26,610.31 6,307.71 1,827.85 1.12 0.71 3.45 45073.88 45957.85 9,123.85 6,307.71 4,434.17 3,242.17 1,827.84 27,053.32 43,325.86 17,277.53 20.24 13.99 7.19 101.96 18.74 11.7 18.77

2003 23,656.31 1,395.92 0.00 481.77 25,534.00 12,564.54 18,160.39 30,724.93 6,551.17 1,555.40 1.20 0.49 4.21 49,743.54 54,642.60 9,388.26 6,551.17 4,982.75 4,106.85 1,555.4 34,388.04 60,415.77 24,622.96 18.87 13.17 8.26 109.85 16.47 9.37 16.68

2004 33,056.50 1,395.95 0.00 481.77 34,934.22 11,149.38 12,955.22 24,104.60 7,735.86 1,434.72 0.69 .31 5.39 56,247.03 41,657.92 10,982.88 7,735.86 6,301.14 5,160.14 1,434.72 50,030.24 52,764.91 1,396.38 18.41 13.75 9.95 80.34 13.18 12.4 16.26

2005 39,010.23 1,393.09 0.00 481.77 40,885.09 6,172.98 17,131.52 23,304.50 10,537.34 1,468.66 0.57 .15 7.17 73.164.10 53,345.03 14,260.84 10,537.34 9,068.68 7,571.68 1,468.66 54,560.80 57,292.51 1,394.94 19.40 14.40 11.48 80.92 16.56 15.77 20.09

2006 48,411.09 1,393.17 0.00 481.77 50,286.03 8,185.60 16,454.48 24,640.08 11,581.10 877.04 0.49 .16 13.20 89,124.46 65,535.84 14,982.01 11,581.10 10,704.06 9,069.34 877.04 61,738.85 65,428.89 1,393.51 17.43 12.99 11.21 81.03 16.11 15.20 20.08

1. ROCE = (EAT + Interest)/ Average capital employed

6 - 53 Tata McGraw-Hill Publishing Company Limited, Financial Management 2. ROR (Total assets) = (EAT + Interest)/ Average assets

Solution: The appraisal of financial health of RIL is presented below. Liquidity Analysis: The liquidity position of RIL does not appear to be commendable during all the years under reference. In fact, its current ratio was less than one implying negative working capital (in 2003) and acid-test ratio was at an alarming low level of 0.2. Though the current ratio range of 1.33 1.85 (during 2001-2 and 2004-6) is an indicative of satisfactory liquidity position, the acid-test ratios appear to be on the lower side, the range being 0.20 0.55 (during 2002-6). The major reason for the sharp difference in these two liquidity ratios may be ascribed to a significant proportion of inventory (in current assets). The other notable observation is that the RIL seems to be banking on bank borrowings to finance its working capital requirements evidenced by a substantial increase in such borrowings over the years. From 337.76 crore (in 2001), they steadily increased to 7,193.77 crore (by 2003) and to Rs 11,438.69 crore by 2006: (registering more than 30 times increase in 2006 compared to 2001). In fact, short-term borrowings constitute more than one-half of its total current liabilities during the 6 year period. The reliance on short-term bank borrowings, to such a marked extent, is contrary to sound tenets of finance. Likewise, it appears that its net working capital is inadequate in relation to its credit sales which stood at Rs. 89,124 crore in 2006 compared to Rs. 73,164 crore in 2005. Contrary to increase in net working capital, however, there has been a more than 50 per cent decrease in net working capital of the RIL; (the relevant figures being Rs 7,054.17 crore and Rs 3,149.15 crore in years 2005 and 2006 respectively).
Tata McGraw-Hill Publishing Company Limited, Financial Management

6 - 54

The RIL has the advantage of much higher creditors payment period compared to debtors collection period. The debtors collection period (varying from 16 days in 2001 and 2002 to 21 days in 2004) seems to be at a very satisfactory level. In marked contrast, the creditors payment period is threetimes (varying in the range of 39-67 days) during the same period. This favourable gap, provides some leverage to RIL to operate at relatively low acid-test ratio. To conclude, the liquidity position of the RIL does not appear to be satisfactory. It is suggested that RIL should substitute a fair share of shortterm bank borrowings by long-term loans (which have shown sharp decrease trend over the years). Such a step would help to improve its liquidity ratios.

Solvency Analysis:
The solvency position of the RIL is sound for two reasons: First, it has a satisfactory level of interest coverage ratio during all the 6 years, being in the range of 3.32 and 13.2. The RIL is not likely to commit default in payment of interest to its lenders as even though its operating profits (EBIT) decline by more than nine-tenth (2006), it l would stil have enough margin to meet its interest obligations. Secondly, its total debt-equity ratio over the years has shown a substantial decrease from 1.39 in 2001 to 0.49 by 2006. Likewise, the long-term debt to equity ratio during over the years has improved substantially.
Tata McGraw-Hill Publishing Company Limited, Financial Management

6 - 55

Profitability Analysis: The profit margins (gross, operating and net) of the RIL over the years have reduced, albeit recent improvements. For instance gross profit margin has decreased from 24.46 per cent (in 2001) to 17.43 per cent (in 2006). Likewise operating profit margins have declined from 17.62 per cent to 12.99 per cent and net profit margins from 11.56 per cent to 11.21 per cent during these years. The lower operating profit margins have an unfavourable effect on the ROR on capital employed. It fell from 20.07 per cent in 2001 to 16.11 per cent by 2006. However, it is gratifying to note that there has been an increase in other rates of return. For instance, the ROR on total assets has improved from 13.03 per cent in 2001 to 15.20 per cent in 2006. Likewise a notable increase in observed in ROR on equity funds. From 16.68 in 2003, it has increased to more than 20 per cent in 2005 as well as in 2006. There seems to be a potential for further improvement in its various RORs by increasing its gross profit and operating profit margins.

Tata McGraw-Hill Publishing Company Limited, Financial Management

6 - 56