Publishing in Reputed Journals

PUBLISHING IN [REPUTED] INTERNATIONAL
JOURNALS: THE RIGHT PATH
Halmar Halide
Makassar, August 2015
Halmar Halide, August 2015
Background: definition, the

publication race, excess, retractions
(ethics violation)
Publication process: preparing and
presenting an article, cover letter,
submission, tracking article and
responding to peer-review
Publication ethics: plagiarism
spectrum and examples, WCOPYFIND
BACKGROUND
HAL-HAL PENTING DALAM KEGIATAN

PENELITIAN DAN PUBLIKASI (UNSUR B)
Jurnal internasional bereputasi adalah jurnal yang
memenuhi kriteria jurnal internasional sebagaimana butir 8
dengan kriteria tambahan mempunyai faktor dampak (impact
factor) dari ISI Web of Science (Thomson Reuters) atau
Scimago Journal Rank (SJR) mempunyai urutan tertinggi dalam
penilaian karya ilmiah dan dinilai paling tinggi 40.
Jurnal yang memenuhi kriteria jurnal internasional pada butir 8
dan terindek oleh database internasional bereputasi (Web of
Science, Scopus, atau Microsoft Academic Search) namun
belum mempunyai faktor dampak (impact factor) dari ISI Web
of Science (Thomson Reuters) atau Scimago Journal Rank (SJR)
dalam penilaian karya ilmiah dan dinilai paling tinggi 30.
Jurnal yang memenuhi kriteria jurnal internasional pada butir 8
yang belum terindek pada database internasional bereputasi
(Web of Science, Scopus, atau Microsoft Academic Search)
namun telah terindek pada database internasional seperti
DOAJ, CABI, Copernicus, dan/atau laman sesuai dengan
pertimbangan Ditjen Dikti dan dapat dinilai karya ilmiah paling
KEWAJIBAN JENIS PUBLIKASI (V) UNTUK

MENDUDUKI JENJANG JABATAN AKADEMIK
No
Jabatan Akademik
Jurnal
Jurnal
Nasiona
Nasional
l
Terakreditasi
Jurnal
Internasion
al
Jurnal
Internasion
al
Bereputasi
Asisten Ahli
Lektor
Lektor Kepala/Magister
Lektor Kepala/Doktor
Profesor
201
5
http://personal.fmipa.itb.ac.id/hgunawan/2015/01/28/50perguruan-tinggi-indonesia-paling-produktif-menurutscopus-2015/
benchmarking
Productivity: Unhas vs ITB
Year
RENSTRA UNHAS: target and

expectation
baseline 2016
2017
2018
2019
2020
Productivity
(papers/staf
s)
0,3
0,4
0,46
0,54
0,62
0,72
#publication
s expected
for
1800 stafs
540
720
828
972
1116
1296
Comparisons: # Stafs: 1200 (ITB) 1800 (Unhas)

# ITB papers in SCOPUS within a year=(4094-3302)/1200 = 0,25
# Unhas papers in SCOPUS within a year=(645-498)/1800 = 0,08
ITB = 3 UNHAS
http://personal.fmipa.itb.ac.id/hgunawan/files/2015/01/50-Perguruan-TinggiIndonesia-di-Scopus-7-Agustus-2015.pdf
EXCESS:
SUICIDE
http://www.slate.com/articles/health_and_science/science/2014/08/fraud_i
n_stem_cell_research_japanese_biologist_yoshiki_sasai_commits_sui
cide.html
One of the biggest science scandals in recent history took place at one of
Japans most prestigious research institutions, the Riken Center for
Developmental Biology in Kobe. Over the past several months, a research
misconduct investigation has focused on two papers about a simple new
method for creating stem cells. The papers describing the method, called
stimulus-triggered acquisition of pluripotency, were published in the
prestigious journal Nature in January to much fanfare. But they were
retracted in July after Nature discovered that the papers included
plagiarized writing, misidentified images, and misreported data.
Haruko Obokata, the lead author, who performed the studies and wrote the
manuscripts, was found guilty of falsifying data. Biologist Yoshiki Sasai, leader
of the Riken research group, was a co-author on both papers. According to
the Japan Times, he had been responsible for overseeing Obokatas research,
and he was criticized for his poor supervision. During the investigation, both
Obokata and Sasai were hospitalized for stress. This week, Sasai
committed suicide at the Riken Center.
Article withdrawal Policies and Forms

https://www.elsevier.com/about/publishing-guidelines/policies/articlewithdrawal
the importance of the scholarly archive as a permanent, historic
record of the transactions of scholarship. Articles that have been
published shall remain extant, exact and unaltered as far as is possible.
However, very occasionally circumstances may arise where an article is
published that must later be retracted or even removed.
Article Withdrawal: Only used for Articles in Press which represent early
versions of articles and sometimes contain errors, or may have been
accidentally submitted twice. Occasionally, but less frequently, the
articles may represent infringements of professional ethical codes, such
as multiple submission, bogus claims of authorship, plagiarism, fraudulent
use of data or the like.
Article Retraction: Infringements of professional ethical codes,

such as multiple submission, bogus claims of authorship, plagiarism,
fraudulent use of data or the like. Occasionally a retraction will be used to
correct errors in submission or publication.
Article Removal: Legal limitations upon the publisher, copyright holder or
author(s).
Article Replacement: Identification
of false or inaccurate data that, if
PROBLEMS?
http://retractionwatch.com/2014/07/02/stap-stem-cell-papers-officiallyretracted-as-nature-argues-peer-review-couldnt-have-detected-fatalproblems/
DIFFERENCES
Figs Legends
Wrong descriptions
Wrong labels
more journal retractions:

Animal Husbandry and Veterinary
Science
But, why???
http://retractionwatch.com/2015/07/13/retraction-of-monkey-paperlinked-to-problems-at-shuttered-federal-research-institute/#more29133
http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.2042-3306.2011.00518.x/abstract
http://retractionwatch.com/2011/12/19/which-came-first-vet-journalretracts-previously-published-chicken-paper/
http://retractionwatch.com/2012/01/10/eye-of-the-needle-paper-aboutcamels-gets-rejected-then-published-then-retracted/
elsevier.com http://www.elsevier.com/connect/six-things-to-dobefore-writing-your-manuscript
PUBLICATION PROCESS:
On PREPARING
Dr. Borja is the Editor of several journals, including
Frontiers in Marine Ecosystem Ecology, Revista de
Investigacin Marina, Elsevier's Journal of Sea
Research and Continental Shelf Research. In addition,
he is a
member of the editorial boards of Elsevier's Marine
Pollution Bulletin, Ecological Indicators and Ocean &
Coastal
Angel Borja, PhD
Management.
His main topic of investigation is marine ecology, and
has published more than 270 contributions, from which
150 are in over 40 peer-reviewed journals, through his
long career of 32 years of research.
WHY publish???
author
reviewer
WHAT TYPE???
WHICH JOURNAL???
IMPACT FACTOR
http://www.citefactor.org/journal-impact-factor-list-2014_N.html
SJR:
NATUR
E
UN-REPUTED
Quick Search from Elsevier
Provide: Title and abstract
Output: alternatives journal

example
http://journalfinder.elsevier.com/
result
AVOID THESE
PREDATORS!!!
s
d
!
!
1.
GIF
Check: does it include

NATURE?
2.
GISI
3.
IIFS
Check: does it also
include NATURE?
4. SJIF
Check: does it also include NATURE?
BEWARE
more on PUBLISHER
problems
1-3013
1-3007
1-7192
AR
E
G
r
a
v
t
a
i
n
o
i
in
e
h
t
t
o
t
#
l
a
a
p
of
s
e
g
1-8789
1-3013
1-3007
1-9013
+
ad 1-7192
di
ti
on
al
is
su
in
20
14
Difers in # issues in each volume
backwards
overlaps
Number
pages
# pages
1-151
151
153-296
144
297-399
103
401-513
113
515-627
114
629-742
114
743-848
106
851-1016
166
1017-1222
206
10
1223-1481
259
11
1483-1786
304
12
1787-2086
300
13
2095-2423
329
14
2425-2770
346
15
2271-3172
902
16
3173-3632
460
17
2825-4238
1414
18
4239-5298
1060
19
5301-6480
1180
20
6481-8220
1740
8221-11778
3557
11779-18113
6334
21
22
http://www.elsevier.com/connect/11-steps-to-structuring-a-science-papereditors-will-take-seriously
ON PRESENTING
Angel Borja, PhD

WHAT STRUCTURE?
1. Figures and Tables
STRESSING NUMBERS:
STRESSING GRADIENTS
1. Figures and Tables (CONTINUED)

Appropriateness

Self explanatory

Not too crowd
HOW TO ORGANIZE IT
LINE VS HISTOGRAM
Histogram: no gradient
Halmar (gradient)
Halide, August 2015
Line: time-series, transect
HOW TO ORGANIZE?
EASY TO SEE

COST SAVING
2. Presenting METHODS (How did yo do it?
2. Presenting METHODS (How did yo do it?

(continued)
. Presenting RESULTS (What have you found?
. Presenting RESULTS (What have you found?

(continued)
4. Presenting DISCUSSIONS (What do THE

RESULTS mean?)
4. Presenting DISCUSSIONS (What do THE

RESULTS mean?) (continued)
5. Presenting CONCLUSIONS (How does

THE WORK advances the field?)
6. Presenting INTRODUCTION (Why THE WOR

s useful?)
6. Presenting INTRODUCTION (Why THE WOR

s useful?) (continued)
. Presenting ABSTRACT (What did you do and

what are the important findings?)
. Presenting ABSTRACT (What did you do and

what are the important findings?) (continued)
. Presenting TITLE (HOW do you attract the

EADER attention?)

EADER attention?) (continued)

EADER attention?) (continued)
9. Selecting KEYWORDS (HOW to label?)
9. Presenting KEYWORDS (HOW do you label

your work?)
10. Presenting ACKNOWLEDGEMENT (HOW

do you THANK OTHERS?)
11. Presenting REFERENCES (HOW to avoid

Plagiarism?)
http://www.elsevier.com/connect/writing-a-science-paper-some-dos-and-donts
ON PRESENTING (continued)
Angel Borja, PhD

www.elsevier.com/authors
:
e
l
p
m
Exa
M
I
G
J
ON RESPONDING to Peer Review
https://www.aje.com/en/author-resources
Examples:
Examples (continued):
Example: real world
Invitation
to review
2 reviewers comments
Comment R1
Comment R2
Tr
P
c
a
b
u
n
i
k
h
s
li
d
e
..
p
p
a
r
e
Commercial Break
But why worries

how about your former supervisor (s)?
Ready for Submission?
http://www.elsevier.com/authors/journal-authors/submit-your-paper#prepare
http://www.elsevier.com/editors/elsevier-editorial-system#authors
http://tie.ieee-ies.org/MC/Responding%20to%20Decisions.htm
Publication ethics:
Plagiarism detective
https://www.scribd.com/doc/269731116/uji-testing-detektif-plagiasi-wcopyfind
PERINGATAN (QS ASH SHAFF 51: 2-3
Hai orang-orang yang beriman, mengapa kam

mengatakan apa yang tidak kamu perbuat?
Amat besar kebencian di sisi Allah bahwa

kamu mengatakan apa-apa yang tiada
kamu kerjakan.
Halmar Halide, Fisika Unhas 2014
TS Adiningrum
LECTURER-STUDENTS
DIFFERENT STANDARD
GOI regulation on
plagiarism
Ten types of Plagiarisme

Compiled by: halmar halide@unhas
http://www.icmje.org/recommendations/browse/roles-andresponsibilities/defining-the-role-of-authors-and-contributors.html
http://www.icmje.org/recommendations/browse/roles-andresponsibilities/defining-the-role-of-authors-and-contributors.html
http://www.biochemia-medica.com/2013/23/237
Using a plagiarism detective:

WCOPYFIND
Wcopyfind was developed by a physicist Prof. L. Bloomfield @ Univ
Virginia
http://plagiarism.bloomfieldmedia.com/zwordpress/software/wcopyfind/
https://www.scribd.com/doc/269731116/uji-testing-detektif-plagiasiwcopyfind
http://plagiarism.bloomfieldmedia.com/zwordpress/sample-page/
Terms and
Conditions
File usulan
File-file pembanding
Hasil perbandingan file-file
Target: Proposal tugas akhir/penelitian, publika

http://retractionwatch.com/2014/01/07/journal-dumps-grainpaper-for-controversial-data/
Testing: Abstract
Testing: Abstract
Testing: Tables
Thank you and,

Happy [ethical]
publishing.

Publishing in Reputed Journals

Uploaded by

Document Information

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Publishing in Reputed Journals

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

PUBLISHING IN [REPUTED] INTERNATIONAL

JOURNALS: THE RIGHT PATH

Background: definition, the

Halmar Halide, August 2015

HAL-HAL PENTING DALAM KEGIATAN

KEWAJIBAN JENIS PUBLIKASI (V) UNTUK

Halmar Halide, August 2015

Halmar Halide, August 2015

RENSTRA UNHAS: target and

Comparisons: # Stafs: 1200 (ITB) 1800 (Unhas)

Halmar Halide, August 2015

Article withdrawal Policies and Forms

Article Retraction: Infringements of professional ethical codes,

more journal retractions:

Halmar Halide, August 2015

Halmar Halide, August 2015

Halmar Halide, August 2015

Halmar Halide, August 2015

Halmar Halide, August 2015

Halmar Halide, August 2015

Halmar Halide, August 2015

Halmar Halide, August 2015

Halmar Halide, August 2015

Halmar Halide, August 2015

Halmar Halide, August 2015

Quick Search from Elsevier

Provide: Title and abstract

Output: alternatives journal

Halmar Halide, August 2015

Halmar Halide, August 2015

Halmar Halide, August 2015

Halmar Halide, August 2015

Halmar Halide, August 2015

Check: does it include

Halmar Halide, August 2015

Halmar Halide, August 2015

Halmar Halide, August 2015

Halmar Halide, August 2015

Halmar Halide, August 2015

Halmar Halide, August 2015

Halmar Halide, August 2015

Halmar Halide, August 2015

Halmar Halide, August 2015

Difers in # issues in each volume

Halmar Halide, August 2015

Halmar Halide, August 2015

Angel Borja, PhD

Halmar Halide, August 2015

1. Figures and Tables

Halmar Halide, August 2015

1. Figures and Tables (CONTINUED)

Halmar Halide, August 2015

1. Figures and Tables (CONTINUED)

Halmar Halide, August 2015

1. Figures and Tables (CONTINUED)

Halmar Halide, August 2015

Halmar Halide, August 2015

1. Figures and Tables (CONTINUED)

Halmar Halide, August 2015

2. Presenting METHODS (How did yo do it?

Halmar Halide, August 2015

2. Presenting METHODS (How did yo do it?

Halmar Halide, August 2015

. Presenting RESULTS (What have you found?