Experiment 3: Le Châtelier¶s Principle

Cabajar, Jairus B., Dionisio, Nicole Anna Marie H. Group 3

INTRODUCTION
³If an external stress is applied to a system at equilibrium, the system adjusts in such a way that the stress is partially offset as it tries to reestablish equilibrium´
²Henri Le Châtelier.

At equilibrium, both products and reactants are present in the reacting system.

INTRODUCTION stressors
Changes in Concentrations
An increase in the concentration of reactants, or decrease in the concentration of products, causes a right shift. On the other hand, an increase in the concentration of products, or decrease in concentration of reactants, causes a left shift. Basically, increased concentrations are used up while decreased concentrations are filled up.

INTRODUCTION stressors
Changes in Pressure and Volume
Changes in pressure usually only affect reacting species in the gas phase. By the ideal gas law, pressure is inversely proportional to volume. Generally, an increase in pressure (decrease in volume) causes the reaction to shift to the side with fewer moles of gas; on the other hand, a decrease in pressure (increase in volume) causes it to shift to the side with more moles of gas. Whenever there is equal number of moles on both sides, a change in pressure (or volume) has no effect.

INTRODUCTION stressors
Changes in Temperature
Only a change in temperature can alter the equilibrium constant. In general, a temperature increase favors an endothermic reaction, and a temperature decrease favors an exothermic reaction.

¨ H0
+ + -

¨T
+ + -

Shift + (forward) (reverse) +

INTRODUCTION stressors
The Effect of Catalyst
A catalyst affects the activation energy of the forward and reverse reaction to the same extent. Adding a catalyst to a reaction will simply cause the mixture to reach equilibrium sooner (in the case of a + catalyst). The presence of a catalyst does not alter the equilibrium constant, nor does it shift the position of an equilibrium system.

EXPERIMENTATION
and RESULTS

0.1 M HCl

H2 O

0.1 M K4Fe(CN)6

0.1 M NaNO3

0.1 M Cu(NO3)2

0.1 M NH4OH

0.1 M NaOH

1ml of solution + 0.50ml water subjected to water bath

DISCUSSION
For the first solution in part A, this equilibrium was formed: Cu+2(aq) + 4NH3(aq)
sky blue colorless

Cu(NH3)4+2(aq)
dark blue

DISCUSSION
For the systems A and B, similar concepts may be applied. By increasing the concentration of reactants, the reaction shifts to the right forming more products, causing the solution to become darker. In the A depression, when Cu+2 dissociated from the added reagent, Cu(NO3)2, the number of effective collisions between the reactants increased. The same is true in B depression where NH3, from the reagent, was added to the solution. Both of these favor the formation of products.

DISCUSSION
In the system C, a brownish-red precipitate was formed after adding 0.1 M K4Fe(CN)6. In this system, as the reagent dissociated to K+1 and Fe(CN)6-4, the ferrocyanide ion reacted with the Cu+2. By consuming the copper ion, the reaction counteracts by shifting to the reactant¶s side. The formation of Cu2Fe(CN)6 caused the solution¶s color.

DISCUSSION
For system F, based on the experiment, the solution became darker after adding 0.1 M Na(NO)3. Theoretically, the said reagent must not affect the reactant. After dissociating to Na+1 and NO3-1, none of these ions may significantly disturb the equilibrium. A contamination may account to the obtained results.

DISCUSSION
For system D, HCl, an acid was added to the original solution. H+ from the dissociation will react with NH3, forming NH4+, decreasing the reactant. In order to conform to this, the reaction shifts to the reactant side, resulting to a lighter color. For system E, a base, NaOH, was added. When OH- dissociated from the reagent, it reacted with Cu+2, like that of system D, the reaction shifted to the left.

DISCUSSION
In the case of system G, the results suggest that it is endothermic because it became lighter. But since the reaction is known to be exothermic, decreasing the temperature must cause it to shift forward, thus turning the solution darker. Again, a contamination may account to this.

DISCUSSION
Summary of how the reaction will theoretically adjust to the different applied stressors.

System A B C D E F G

Applied stress 0.1 M Cu(NO3)2 0.1 M NH40H 0.1 M K4Fe(CN)6 0.1 M HCl 0.1 M NaOH 0.1 M Na(NO)3 Decrease in temp.

Reaction shift forward forward Reverse/backward Reverse/backward Reverse/backward No shift Forward

DISCUSSION
For the part B of the experiment, the K2CrO4 turned from yellow to orange when HCl was added to it. And when NaOH was added, the solution became lighter, almost the same as that of the original. For this part of the experiment, this equilibrium was formed:
yellow

2CrO4-2 + 2H+

Cr2O7-2 + H2O
orange

DISCUSSION
When HCl was added, the solution became acidic. As HCl dissociated to H+ and Cl-, the hydrogen ion reacted with CrO4-2 and Cr2O7-2 (an orange solution) was formed. It can be concluded that Cr2O7-2 is predominant in an acid solution due to the H+ from the dissociation of an acid. Next, a base, NaOH, was added. When OH- dissociated from the base, it reacted with H+, consuming it and at the same time forming more water which is part of product¶s side. By this, the reaction shifts to the left, in a basic medium, Cr04-2 is dominant.

DISCUSSION
For the last part of the experiment, when Pb(NO3)2 was added to K2CRO4, a yellow precipitate was formed. This equilibrium was formed:
yellow

CrO4-2 + Pb+2

yellow precipitate

PbCrO4

And when HCl was added to the solution, it became darker²from yellow to orange. The precipitate also lessened.

DISCUSSION
When the reaction was subjected to HCl, similarly to system H, H+ reacted with Cr04-2 forming Cr2O7-2 causing it to change color. This can be verified by the decrease of the precipitate, the CrO4-2 was consumed causing the reaction to shift to the reactant¶s side.

CONCLUSION
Several factors affect the shift of an equilibrium. Changes in concentration, pressure and volume can alter the equilibrium concentrations of the reacting mixture, but not the equilibrium constant as long as the temperature remains constant. Only a change in temperature changes the value of the equilibrium constant.

RECOMMENDATION
We recommend changing the system being studied in this experiment. Observing the changes in color² which is basically the core procedure of the experiment²caused confusion. The light blue color of the solution made it hard to see if the solution became lighter or not. Systems that are expected to be darker, on the other hand, were equally confusing due to the minimal darkening of the solution. Proper handling of the reagents, too, must be observed, several deviations from the theoretical results is probably due to contaminations.

RECOMMENDATION
Finally, to fully understand the principle, the effect of pressure (and volume) as a stressor must also be conducted. But since these kinds if experiments are in need of tremendous amount of effort and experience, at least allow the students to see how the concept works for the sake of better understanding.

SOURCES
Chang, Raymond. (2008). General Chemistry: The Essential Concepts, Fifth edition. New York: The McGraw-Hill Companies, 2008. Committee on General Chemistry (2007) Learning Modules in General Chemistry 2. University of the Philippines Manila. "Henri Louis Le Châtelier." Microsoft® Encarta® 2007 [DVD]. Redmond, WA: Microsoft Corporation, 2006. Silberberg, M.S. (2006). Chemistry: The molecular nature of matter and change (4th edition). New York: The McGraw-Hill Companies, 2008

Sign up to vote on this title
UsefulNot useful