A mishap occurred at about 5:30 in the morning of March 24, 1958 on Highway 54 (now E. de los Santos Avenue)
CAEDO was driving his Mercury.
Cadillac of YU KHE THAI, with his driver RAFAEL
BERNARDO at the wheel. Caedo was driving his mercury at 40 to 50 kilometers per hour
Bernardo driving Thai’s Cadillac at
approximately 48 to 56 kilometers per hour.
Ahead of the Cadillac, going in the same
direction, was a caretella owned by a certain Pedro Bautista. The carretela was provided with two lights Bernardo veered to the left in order to pass. As he did so the curved end of his car's right rear bumper caught the forward rim of the rig's left wheel, wrenching it off and carrying it along as the car skidded obliquely to the other lane, where it collided with the oncoming vehicle. Caedo, confronted with the unexpected situation, tried to avoid the collision at the last moment by going farther to the right, but was unsuccessful.
As a result of a vehicular accident in which plaintiff
Marcial Caedo and several members of his family were injured they filed this suit for recovery of damages from the defendants. 1. Whether or not Rafael Bernardo‘s must be held liable for the damages suffered by the plaintiffs.
2. Whether or not Yu Khe Thai, as owner of the
Cadillac, is solidarily liable with the driver. In motor vehicle mishaps, the owner is solidarily liable with his driver, if the former, who was in the vehicle, could have, by the use of due diligence, prevented the misfortune. It is disputably presumed that a driver was negligent, if he had been found guilty of reckless driving or violating traffic regulations at least twice within the next preceding two months. HELD
The imputation of liability to Yu Khe
Thai, solidarily with Rafael Bernardo, is an ERROR. The trial court awarded PHP 48,000 by way of MORAL DAMAGES. Plaintiff’s appealed from the award claiming that the court should have granted also actual or compensatory damages aggregating PHP 225,000 for the injuries they sustained. Defendants argued that the moral damages awarded to Caedo is excessive and should be reduced. ACTUAL DAMAGES to be compensable, must be proven. PAIN and Suffering are not capable of PECUNIARY estimation but of MORAL DAMAGES The trial court stated that the moral damages awarded to Caedo are not excessive . Defendant-apellant Yu Khe Thai was free from liabilty and Rafael Bernardo held liable for the costs.