You are on page 1of 45

|  

 | 
|  
    
 | 
| 
   
 | 


  
 | 


|    
 
 

   


|
|
! 

 

 "  
_ 
    


#  

$
!
% 
| 
!

!&' 
 &  

|   
( 
) 
*
+
, 
-
 
. 
 
,  
/  
 ,

0
1123
 "  
 "  
 "  
 "  "
V
        

 
  
    

 !


 
  $%  
 
   

 
 
 

"  
     
#
    
 

  "  


     

  

 "  4
FFS From Private Health Insurers Accounts for
50% of Physicians¶ Practice Revenue, on Average

 
 

 
@ 
@ 
  @  



Still most in a Fee For
Service environment



   
  
 
&'( 
)
 "  2
ïany Other Practice Arrangements Where
Physicians Receive a Salary
*  #(     # $  + 
  #,
 ) 
 - 
   $% , 

$ /
$  $   
  $%

 
 .

 


'
        

  
$       
  

  
 # $%-  )$%



  0  # 
0  )
1 
)
   
$    
 
 
" 

 
 "  +
ïost o perienced Physicians in Group Practices
Have Strong Performance Incentives

    +

@
 




@ @ 

@



 @

 

_ew MDs ostablished ostablished


PCPs Specialists

 
&      
  
#'(#2333)

 "  5
! 
|
!
/

66

 
, 
7)8)9:
; )8)9
0)   &8 
)  
9
 3
<   

55
< )  
7  

:
  
 
; !
 
)8)9
 
 
= 

 

=



 

! 

( 
m 
  
 

< 5>
-
!

 

! 

%?
; #  


- 
 = 
  

  

 

0-
   
  
 
  3
; =

 =

-
! 
|
8
 
; #
 &-&
  
-
 

 
   
 
 "  1
)8)9?
.=

= 
0-
!  3
; @
 
 
 -  



A

0+1113
< , 
|   
( 
0,|(3

; @
,|(

 

  
 


 
0)9 3
0"&&3
÷ 
 )9

0  
  
-- 
 
3
 # 

-
)9

mm )9

0  
 
  3
 # 
 

-
)9
  
mm )9

0  
= 3
 "  
. B

- ?
0=C
   

D   3
/  )  
9
 
0)9 3
l |  
E  )9
l !  
E  )9

( 
)9 

±@
,|(


)9 
 


F

-


)9 
- 
 
 "  
. B

- ?
( 
)9 
 , 
6 
0G
, 
6 
0G2 +52"

H123

2 +52"

H123

0 
 
3

76
 
| 
 :
0=
< 
= 

 



0=
<

! 

  
 3

 "  
, !
" %&"# 
 =

  ! !"#  $%&$

ß  
 
  
  
   
 
   
        

 
8 I
; 
 


  


!  


! 
; 
! 
 

]
m
mm
 0%|,3 -
= 

  
E 


  
E 
)9 

 "  "


- 




 EI
/ 
)9
E / 
%|,3
l 0|  
E 
)9
E |@
%|,3
l 0!  
E 
)9
E !@
%|,3

( 
)9 

E , 
6 

| 

-

 -
 
 "  4
Calculating a ïanhattan Physician¶s Payment
for a ³ïid-level´ Office Visit

' 
  (7 
*VU 7  *VU

   "
1 5)86 9 2)53 : 5)6;
   0  5)83 9 2);< : 5)3;

  0  5)5; 9 2)86 : 5)5<
2)62
9
 
  
.;6)35
  .8=)>2
 
&
 #4556)

 "  2
%   
|  
,
 E


%   
|  
,
 E

 |   
E  |  



 
|    
J 

6=? 
   
 

    7  

 
*@*V  



 24;?  

*@*V 

 "  5
ïedicare Currently Pays Physicians
Less Than Private Health Insurers
 

  ? 
 

-


 

± >;?
62?
± 84? 83?
± 84?
=3?


=<?  
±  
± ïedicaid is least, then
±
ïedicare, then Private
±
 ±          ±±± ±± ±± ±± ±± ±±

_ & 

 
2336233>) '  -"  1
 
& *
   
 #45554556) 

   

  -
 "  1
|
 
 

)8)9
7K,
6L:
;  
 =

0%)3
 
< 
- 
-

 


 
- 

< 6 
  

 
 
 =
0
- 

-
 

 = 3
 
=
 =



 

; 8 
 


 =
-





- 
  
 

- 
 

=

 
 
; , 

  
 





  
 
-  
 
-


%)
0>

-
-
    3
; |   B
  

=
-E
-

  
-
G41M


 "  
 "  
÷   !  

÷ "
# m $$
% &' $
( )  'm$


 ') *


+ ', -m
. )
 '
  
/0'
-
0 ") &*
÷

 $

 "  
 "  
Physician Income Gre in the 1950s, 1960s, and Late 1980s
4555. ïean Physician Income, in 2000 ollars
†
.44<)8
.45<)6
† (   
.2<4)=
†


 

†    

†

†
4555
51

59

65

68

70

72

74

76

78

80

82

84

86

88

90

92

94

96

98
'

_ &

 
     
  #
  
#

  )

 
&(
  (  #      
)
 "  "
eep g Perspec ve: Geerl Prc  oers  ll or ïore
 e

T Oer our es
   '

  
.555
† 

† 
† ± † ± † ±

†

†



_e    rce ec

 
 .  
 
&%,#455<)  0 
)
 "  4
Lifetime oarnings of a La yer Versus
an Obstetrician
/  % 
 
/0+  A"




/0 
/÷+ 
A"

/÷ 
/+ 
/
/+  ÷ 0  . + 1 ( % # ÷ ÷÷ ÷0 ÷ ÷. ÷+ ÷1

/÷  6 


  

+  



" 
 "  2
ïedian Physician Income by Specialty, 2006 ($000)
+2   ( 3 4 
   ( 
!2  *  2(2 
)    (  
'2  ( 
!"#$%& @
2    @
 
  
  2  1    
 2    @ 
   
 
  2  Primary care
  2   

  @   


,_+&.;4<#555B'
 

&.;58#555
 " 

& '
(  ) +
Overvie of the National Resident
ïatching Program (the ³ïatch´)

w  
23<5  
 
 

C     
    
 
     )
w = 
   
""/
  

 )
w  
1 

25

 ))#D $ 1

  

 

 )
w *  

 1" 
1    )
w  

      
    
 > )*    
)
w  
  

   )
w       "  -
 
 
   
)
 "  5
ïost U
S
Students Receive a ïatch

 U  (  E 


 

 
 
 


     ±±±
'

 
&_*#4555)
 "  1
% of U
S
ïedical School Graduates Who id Not ïatch
in 2006, Among Those Ranking a Single Specialty
  %&  
) $$  
!( ÷ 
'   $ ÷ 
%& ÷ 
#$ ÷ 
"# $$ ÷ 
 ! 
  
   
   

  ÷

 "  
 
&*  &4558 #_*)
_*#(
4525

 "  
_*#(
4525
 "  
High income specialties have the highest demand
+2   ( 3 44 
   ( 
!2  *  2(2 
)    (  
'2  ( 
!"#$%& @
2(   @
  2 
 2    @
  2  Primary care
 *2   

  @   


,_+&.;4<#555B'
 

&.;58#555
 " 

& '
(  ) 
Percentage of Graduating U
S
ïedical Students Ranking
a Primary Care Specialty as Their 1st Choice in the ïatch
 <8)4?
<=)2?


=;)3?





@




  @        @ @ @@ @ @ @

 
&_ *  

)
 "  "
Number of Physicians Per Capita in U
S
Has
Almost oubled Since ÷
    
255#555  
0


2325 &  
  "F
 U)) 
÷
÷ 
÷
÷
÷

÷ ÷ ÷ ÷  ÷ ÷ 

 
&@ #455=B #4556)
 "  4
Bu U. . o s No a Ou a io ally
Nu b of Physi ia s P 1,000 Po ula io , 2000 (2004 fo U. .)
5.9

3.5
3.1
2.75 2.6
2.1
1.8 1.7

aly a y ai U. . a Ca a a UK Ja a

 
&%,
 "  2
 Ne ïedical Schools Opened in the
÷s and ÷s

÷ ÷  ÷  ÷  ÷  ÷  ÷ 
÷  ÷÷
÷
_
÷ 
U)) 

 

























Year

 
&(   (
   
 "  +
* =
! 
 
 N
; 0(  m,m m
)

- $ mm
 

m 
< $
')m 0
'
 
;
 mm)
 
mm
 )m ),

,,m - 
<  mm,,-'  ÷m
m÷#%÷

 "  5
Number of Applicants to U
S
ïedical Schools and
Number of First-Year ïedical Students, 1960-2005

, $  "

,
+
( 238= ( 
,

,

,

@,

@,

,


  
,

,






















÷

÷

 6?3?22?4;?;5?;<?=5?=;?=6?<5?


 
&(   (
    )
 "  1
!
   
 
 
; 


 

'

">



 E
"
  

  
 

 
< 6 
 

'
 =

 >

 
< 1
 
  

'




1>

; / 



-

 

EO

 "  
 "   
&* 
 

  
   
 #4556) 

  

  " 

&* 
 

  
   
 #4556)

U
S
Government is Already Heavily Involved;
ïaintaining the Status Quo is Itself a Policy
 
 6  $ " 
 
   0  "
1

w 6 U    w   
 "
C 

  

 #  "
 
  
6      )
  

 )

w  /
      
  w
  
/  


  

  

w     - w 


   
" 

 
  

 "  
 
; 
51>
-
 


 
  
; | 



 


-
  

  



 

< ,  


= 
=
- 



551



= 

 
<   
 


 

 
 
   


.!K
< !  B
)8)9
-
 

 
 
C

 


 






-

 
; %  
 
 
 

  




   


  
;  



-
  


   


 
 

  
; | D  
 
   

 

 
 


  

E


-
 
 


' 

-
E 
 

 "  "