Ayes, 42 Mr Albanese Mr Bandt Ms Bird Ms Brodtmann Mr Butler Mr Champion Mr Cheeseman Mr Clare Ms Collins Mr Combet Mr Crean Mr Dreyfus Mrs Elliot

Ms Ellis Mr Garrett Mr Georganas Mr Gibbons Mr Gray Ms Grierson Mr Griffin Ms Hall* Mr Jenkins Mr S. P. Jones Dr M. J. Kelly Ms King Ms Livermore Ms Macklin Mr Marles Mr Oakeshott Ms Parke Mr Perrett Ms Plibersek Ms Rishworth Noes, 98 Mr Abbott Mr Adams Mr Alexander Mr K. J. Andrews Mrs K. L. Andrews Mr Baldwin Mr Billson Mrs B. K. Bishop Ms J. I. Bishop Mr Bowen Mr Bradbury Mr Briggs Mr Broadbent Mr Buchholz Ms A. E. Burke Mr A. S. Burke Mr Byrne Mr Chester Mr Christensen Mr Ciobo Mr Cobb Mr Coulton* Mr Crook Mr Danby Mrs DAth Mr Dutton Dr Emerson Mr Entsch Mr L. D. T. Ferguson Mr M. J. Ferguson Mr Fitzgibbon Mr Fletcher Mr Forrest Mr Frydenberg Ms Gambaro Mrs Gash Ms Gillard Mrs Griggs Mr Haase Mr Hartsuyker Mr A. G. Hawke Mr Hayes Mr Hockey Mr Hunt Mr Husic Mr Irons Dr Jensen Mr E. T. Jones Mr Katter Mr Keenan Mr C. Kelly Mr Laming Dr Leigh Ms Ley Mr Lyons Mr McClelland Mr McCormack Mr Macfarlane Ms Marino Mrs Markus Mr Matheson Mr Melham Mrs Mirabella Mr Mitchell Mr Morrison Mrs Moylan Mr Murphy Mr Neumann Mr Neville Mr OConnor Mr ODowd Ms ODwyer Ms ONeill Ms Owens Mrs Prentice Mr Pyne Mr Ramsey Mr Randall Mr Ripoll Mr Robb Mr Robert * Tellers And so it was resolved in the negative. Ms Rowland Mr Wyatt Roy Mr Rudd Mr Ruddock Mr Schultz Mr Scott Mr Secker* Mr Simpkins Mr Slipper Mr A. D. H. Smith Mr Somlyay Dr Southcott Dr Stone Mr Swan Mr Symon Mr Tehan Mr K. J. Thomson Mr Truss Mr Tudge Mr Turnbull Ms Vamvakinou Mr van Manen Mr Vasta Dr Washer Mr Windsor Mr Wyatt Mr Zappia Ms Roxon Ms Saffin* Mr Shorten Mr Sidebottom Mr S. F. Smith Ms Smyth Mr Snowdon Mr C. R. Thomson Mr Wilkie