Welcome to Scribd, the world's digital library. Read, publish, and share books and documents. See more
Download
Standard view
Full view
of .
Look up keyword
Like this
2Activity
0 of .
Results for:
No results containing your search query
P. 1
Tameka Lorraine Butler, A097 998 935 (BIA July 26, 2013)

Tameka Lorraine Butler, A097 998 935 (BIA July 26, 2013)

Ratings: (0)|Views: 1,389|Likes:
In this unpublished decision, the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA) denied a DHS appeal and upheld the termination of proceedings upon finding the respondent's conviction for grand theft in violation of Fla. Stat. 812.014 was not a crime involving moral turpitude because the statute is divisible and the record of conviction did not establish an attempt to permanently deprive the owner of property. The decision was written by Member Elise Manuel.
In this unpublished decision, the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA) denied a DHS appeal and upheld the termination of proceedings upon finding the respondent's conviction for grand theft in violation of Fla. Stat. 812.014 was not a crime involving moral turpitude because the statute is divisible and the record of conviction did not establish an attempt to permanently deprive the owner of property. The decision was written by Member Elise Manuel.

More info:

Published by: Immigrant & Refugee Appellate Center, LLC on Jul 30, 2013
Copyright:Attribution Non-commercial

Availability:

Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
See more
See less

02/12/2014

pdf

text

original

 
Soberal-Vigh, Rosa H.
US Dpartmnt  Ji
Executive Oce r Immigation Review
Board of Immigraton AppealsOce ofthe Cerk
517 Leesbrg Pike Sute 2000 Fal Chrch Vrna /
Law Ofice of Rosa H Sobea-Vi, PA2101 Vista PakwayHS / ICE Oice of Chief Counsel -MIA333 Soth Miami Ave, Suite 200Miam, FL 33130
W.
Palm Beach, FL 33411Name: BUTLER, TAMEKA LORRAINE A 097998-935Date of tis notice7 / 26/ 2013
Enclosed is a copy of the Board's decisio and orde i the above-erenced case.Eclosue
P b:M, E
Sinceey,
D
C
v
Dona CarrChief Clerk
schuckec 
Cite as: Tameka Lorraine Butler, A097 998 935 (BIA July 26, 2013)
For more unpublished BIA decisions, visit www.irac.net/unpublished
 
, \
<'
. S Deparent
of
usce
Executive Oce r Immiaion ReviewDecision of e Boad of Imaon Appeals Fas Chuch, Vkgna 
22041
Fie:A097 998 935 -Miai, FLI re TAMEKA LORRAE BUTLR
I
EOVAL PROCDIGSAPPALDateON BEHALF OF RSPONEN Rosa H SoberalVig, squireON BEALF OF HSVera ochbergAssisat Chef CouselAPPLICATION Teiatio
JUL
26 0\3
The Depret of omelad Seuriy (HS) appeals om the Immiao Judge's Juy 18, 2012, decisio eiatig proceedigs. e appeal wl be dismissedWe review migraio Judges' digs of ct, icludig e deteiao of credibility,der a cearly eoeous stdrd 8 CFR § 1003(d)(3)(i) We review uestios of lawludig wheter the parties ave et the relevat brdes of proof, ad issues of discreiou der a de ovo sadrd 8 CFR § 1003(d)(3)(ii)As a itial mater, we aee wit the miaio Judges coclusio that he DS has ot  et its brde to demosate by ear ad covicig evidece ha he respodet is removableas arged uder secto 237(a)(2)(A)(i) of he Imiao ad Natioaliy Ac, 8 SC§ 1227(a)(2)(A)(i) r havg bee covicted of a crime ivolvig moral iude commiedwhi 5 years of admissio r wih a setece of 1 year or oger may be imposed (IJ at 34)
See
sectio 24(c)(3) of the Act, 8 USC § 229a(c)(3); 8 CFR § 12408(a) We agree withtheImmiatio udge tat the record does o esabish hat he respodets 2008 covictior d e  violatio of Forida Stautes sectio 812014 is r a cre ivolvg moraiude (J at 34)lorida Satutes sectio 82014(1) staes, i reeva p "A perso commis the if e or she koigly obtas or uses, or edeavors to obta or to use, he property of aother wihitet o eiter temporariy or peely (a) Deprve the other perso of a rgt tohe property or a beet o te proper b) ppropate e propery to is or er ow use or toe se of y perso ot etled o te use of he propey e ste aso provides "t isd te i the trd degree d a feloy of the third deee  if te property sole is [v]alued at $30 or more, but less t $5,000 
" See
Fa Stats § 812014(2)()We ave og eld that i order r a takig to be a he oese that ivolves moraitde,a peret takig mst e iteded
See e.g, Mater of Gazley,
14 &N Dec 33,333BA 1973) We agree w the iratio Judge tat Florida Stautes § 812014 is
@
;61 
v
 
VQius
 
6W :

1


Cite as: Tameka Lorraine Butler, A097 998 935 (BIA July 26, 2013)
 
·
07 8  ·5 dvsbl su
See Ramos
v
U A' Gen,
709 Fd 066 070
(I
h r 20)Flod Stus § 204 s dvisbl s  rquirs hr  i o dpriv or   oppropri d spcclly compls  mpory akig)
Jaggeauh
v
US A' Gen
42 Fd 46 54 h r 2005) "cus o dsc  strds xs §204)  cno sy h boh subprs ould cssrly volv   o dprvohr prso of  rgh o th propry) W thrr mus pply h modd cgorcalpproch o d hhr th os cosus  cr volvg morl urpd
SeeDescamps
v
nied Saes,
 S 2276 228 20) pplco of h moddcgorcl pproch s ppropr h h su of covco "ss ou o or mor of thlms  h lv);
Shepad 
v.
nied Saes,
544 US  2005)Udr h modd cgorcl pproch  cosdr h rcor of covco h s thchgg docum pl vrdc d sc
See Fajado
v
S A' Gen,
659 Fd 0th r 20
l
) h o socd h h rspods covco dcs h thrspod cd h h  o hr mporrly
o 
 ply dpriv Mcy's of hgh o h propry or o  b om h prop
o 
o ppropr h propy o hr ousor  us of y prso o ld o h us of th propry mphss ddd)hrspod pldd o cos o h chrg; sh s scd o  y of proboth s mr h rcord of covco dos o sablsh h h rspod scovcd r  o prmly dpriv s opposd o  o mporly dprv or omrly pproprihrr our qury ds hr
See Faado
v
S At' Gen supa
holdg th hs ord co cosdr vdc byod h rcord of covco
dg hhr  l h b covcd of  c volvg morl ud)ccordgly   h h mmio Judg h h HS dd o m ts burd of proof o sblsh h h rspods covco s r  crm volvg morl ud d hrspod hrr s o rmovbl udr sco 27)2))) of h cFurhor  do o d or  h mgro Judgs dcso dg h hddiol chrg of rmovbly udr 27))D)) of h c s o susid  hsrgd o th  h m of h l hig h rspod hd  Fo 75 Po oRmov h odtios of Rsdc pdg h d Ss zship d moScsUSS) ddolly hr codol rsdc s xdd by h ssuc of 55 smp o hr psspor such th sh 
ll sus W lso tk misvoch ccordg o h SS bs  pprs h h rspods Fo 75 spprovd d  rsd  crd mld o hr ccordgly h lloig ordr shllb rdOERh DHS ppal s dsmssdFOR HE ORD2
Cite as: Tameka Lorraine Butler, A097 998 935 (BIA July 26, 2013)

Activity (2)

You've already reviewed this. Edit your review.
1 thousand reads
1 hundred reads

You're Reading a Free Preview

Download
scribd
/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->