Professional Documents
Culture Documents
trsK;d orD;pmapmif
oH'dki f;az
trsKd;orD;wef;wla&;tajccHyifr0g'
Edik if aH &;tawG;tac:eJ@rwlnw D hJ pOf;pm;csuf Greer wd@k [m trsK;d orD;wef;wla&; tajc cHyifr0g'udk
vpfb&,fe@J qd±k , S v f pf tawG;tac:awGrmS wjznf;jznf;wdk;wufatmif vkyfcJh=uwJholrsm;jzpf
vl@tzG@J tpnf; twGi;f rSm±Sw d hJ trsK;d orD;awG&hJ tae
txm;udk t"duqef;ppfcsuaf wG ±Scd ahJ yrJv h @kd Gender
*si'f gv@kd ac:wJh vlrb _ 0 vdiv f uQ%m owfrw S cf su[ f m
vlrb _ 0xJrmS ±Sw
d hJ cGjJ cm;r_awGtm;vH;k &Jh tajccHjzpfw,f
qdw k hJ t,ltqudak wmh todrw S ðf yr_ r±Scd yhJ gb;l ?
1960 eJ@ 1970 umvawGrmS trsK;d orD; wef;
wla&; v_y±f mS ;r_[m Edik if aH &;/ trsm;qdik b f 0eJ@ pD;yGm;a&;
u¾awGrmS omrubJ ae@w"l0jzpfysuaf ewJh vlra_ &;/
yk*v ~ u d b0eJ@ vdiyf ikd ;f qdik &f m taetxm;owfrw S f
csufawGay:rSmyg zdk0g'}uD;pdk;r_&Jh v$rf;rdk;r_udk c0gcszdk@
t"duóud;pm; aqmif&u G cf yhJ gawmhw,f?
trsKd ;orD;wef;wla&;tajccHyifr0g'rD sm;
'Da&pD;a=umif;udk pwif óud;pm;aqmif&u G o f l
awGxrJ mS pDreG f 'Db;l 0g; Simone de Beauvoir (1906-
86)[m txif±mS ;qH;k vd@k q&kd ygr,f? tJ'aD emuf rSmawmh
Eva Figes
at;0zD;*spef @J *smrde;f *&D,m Eva Figes and Germaine
27
zsuzf @kd pGr;f aqmif=u&r,fqw kd hJ tod %mqdw k ahJ e&mrSm vdiyf ikd ;f vuQ%m odr;f +yD; vGwaf jrmufatmif vkyEf ikd f
w&m;udk trsK;d orD;awG wqxuf qdkwJhoabmudk tpm;xdk;+yD; avh &r,fqw kd hJ rwfp&f o hJ abmw&m; vdk
wqjrifhwufatmif aqG;aEG;wm vmwJh oabmjzpfygw,f? vlrb _ 0 ygbJwJh? trsKd;orD;awG udk,f0ef
a&m/ ynmay;wmawGyg vkyv f m=u vuQ%m yHak zmfcsuaf =umifh omr aqmifjcif;eJ@ uav;arG;zGm;jcif;qdw k hJ
ygw,f? or±d;k us rdom;pkz‹JG pnf;r_ [kwyf gb;l ? ZD0aA'oabma=umifh 0efxw k 0f efy;kd udk vGwaf jrmufatmif
awGukd wdu k zf sujf cif;eJ@ vlrt _ zG@J t vnf; vdiyf ikd ;f qdik &f m rwlnD r_awG acwfreDS nf;ynmawGu zGiahf y;r,f
pnf;wGif;rSm&SdwJh e,fy,fwdkif;rSm jzpfay:vmjcif;jzpfygw,f? trsK;d o qdrk o S m trSew f u,f vdiyf ikd ;f qdik f
v$rf;rdk;aewJh trsKd;orD;awGtay: rD;awG cav;arG;w,fqw kd hJ tajccH &m wef;wlnrD #ra_ wGjzpfvmEdik v f rd hf
pdw"f mwfa&;&mydik ;f eJ@ cE<mud, k f vdif tcsu[ f m obm0w&m;&Jh tvkyf r,fv@kd wGuq f cJyh gw,f? oaE<wm;
ydik ;f qdik &f m zdEydS rf a_ wGukd z,f±mS ;ypf cGjJ cm;vkyu f ikd rf j_ zpfygw,f? 'g[m ZD0 jrpfenf;awGe@J ud, k 0f efaqmifwmudk
&r,fv@kd qykd gw,f? 'Dvekd @J trsK;d orD; aA'oabmaqmifwrhJ o d m;pk/ vlr_ a±SmifEikd rf ,f 'grrS [kwf zsucf sEikd f
b0vGwfajrmufa&; v_yf±Sm;r_[m b0jzpfygw,f? vlrt _ zG@J tpnf;[m ovdk zef¹yGefoaE<om;eJ@ uav;
awmfveS af &;qefwhJ ajymif;vJrw _ ck ukeyf pPn;f xkwv f yk wf hJ jzpfpOfw ck apmifha±Smufr_awGudk vlr_tzGJ@t
jzpfvmygw,f? 'guawmh rD;vwf&hJ wnf;udo k mrubJ rsKd ;qufjyef@ymG ; pnf;u wm0efcaH qmif&u G jf cif;awG
vdifydkif;qdkif&m EdkifiHa&; Millet’s jcif;qdkwJhjzpfpOfudkvnf; em;vnf udk zefw;D ay;Edik yf gowJ?h od@k ro S mt
Sexual Politics rSm azmfjycJw h mjzpf xm;zd@k vdt k yfygw,f? uav;arG;zGm; rsKd ;orD;awG[m ZD0A'qdik &f m rdom;
ygw,f? ay;&jcif;qdw k m trsKd ;orD;awG&hJ ZD0 pkb0xJuae vGwaf jrmufEikd rf mS jzpf
ZD0aA'qdkif&m obm0w&m;udk aA'qdik &f mtaeeJ@ oem;pzG,jf zpf ovdk vl@tzGJ@tpnf;xJrSm trsdK;
ausmfv$m;rvm;? rwlnDjcm;em; aeovdk ±kyfydkif;qdkif&m ±Sifoefa&; om;awGe@J twl trSew f u,f wef;
csuaf wGukd wefz;kd xm;atmif vkyf twGuf trsK;d om;awGukd rScD akd e&yg wl&nfwl yg0ifEikd rf mS jzpfygw,f?
rvm;? w,f? 'gayrJv h nf; zd0k g'}uD;pd;k r_ukd vdifydkif;qdkif&m wef;wl
zdik ;f &m;pwke;f &Jh vdiyf ikd ;f obm0 'grrS [kwf rv$rJ aoG jzpfay: &nfwjl zpfru _ kd zd0k g'pd;k rd;k r_u zk;H uG,f
qdkif&m tnrn oabmw&m; vm&wmygqw kd hJ usKd ;a=umif; qif xm;wmjzpfovdk trsK;d orD;awG&hJ
Firestones’s The Dialectic of Sex jcifru _ kd vufrcHEikd yf gb;l ? uHqdk;vSwJh=urRmvdk@qdk&rJh arG;u
(1972) rSmawmh vdiyf ikd ;f qdik &f m cGjJ cm; trsK;d orD;awGb0 trSef wnf;u uav;arG;zd@k om;tdryf gvm
r_awGe@J ywfouf+y;D vlra_ &;eJ@ ordik ;f wu,fvw G af jrmufz@kd q&kd if ZD0aA' jcif;uvnf; vdiyf ikd ;f qdik &f m cGjJ cm;
qdik &f m ausmaxmufaemufcH awGe@J qdik &f m obm0w&m;eJ@ bk&m;ocif r_awG&t hJ a=umif;vd@k q&kd ygr,f? vl
±Si;f jycJyh gw,f? rwfp&f hJ oabmw &Jh vGrJ mS ;wJ}h urd pf mudk ausmv f eG v
f wG f awGtm;vH;k [m arG;zGm;prSm Andro
&m;udk erlem,l&if; trsK;d o rD;awG&hJ ajrmufEikd rf o S m jzpfygvrd rhf ,f? o genous vl r _ b 0 vd i f v uQ % m
tcef;u¾udk cGJjcrf;pdwfjzm=unfh rdik ;f qdwk m t+rJw;kd wufaew,f? 'g owfrw S cf suq f w kd mrsK;d ygc=hJ uwm
ygw,f? vlrb _ 0 vlwef;pm;vuQ a=umifv h w l ef;pm;yÉdyuQawGukd zsuf r[kwyf gb;l ?
29
trsK;d orD;wef;wla&; t trsK;d om;awGu jynfjh ynf0h 0 b,f pdwyf ikd ;f qdik &f mrSm trsK;d orD; tm;
ajccHyifr0g'aD wG[m trsK;d om;eJ@ t wke;f urS wefz;kd rxm;cJ=h uygb;l qd+k y;D vH;k udk zdEydS zf @kd yHak zmfxm;vd@k jzpfyg
rsK;d orD;=um;rSm&Sw d hJ tajccHe@J b,f trsKd;orD; wef;wla&;v_yf±Sm;ol w,f? wenf;tm;jzifh trsKd;om;
vdrk S ajymif;vJðyjyifv@kd r&Edik w f hJ rwl awGu rSwcf suaf y;avh±ydS gw,f? awGtm;vH;k [m &efoal wGjzpfygo
nDwhJ tcsut f vufawG tay:rSm trsK;d orD;A[dðk y,Ofaus;r_ wJ?h 'Dvekd @J trsK;d orD; wef;wla&; oD;
vnf; qef;ppfcsufawG xkwfcJh=u 'Dvekd @J b,fvrkd ðS yjyifajymif; jcm;cGx J u G af qmif&u G af &; t,ltq
ygw,f? jyifopfe@J tar&durSmawmh vJvdk@r&EdkifwJh trsKd;orD;eJ@ trsKd; awG Feminist Separatism jzpfvm
trsK;d orD;yxr Pro-women Posi- om;=um;rSm&SdwJh rwlnDr_awGudk ygawmhw,f?
tion qdw k t
hJ aetxm;jzpfz@kd awmif; vufcv H m=u&if; yHpk EH pS rf sK;d uGx J u G f zdESdyfoleJ@ zdESdyfcHqdkwJh vdiftwef;
qdv k m=u&ygw,f? zdik ;f &m;pwke;f &Jh vmygw,f? wcsK‹d trsK;d orD; wef;wl tpm;ESp&f yf
trsK;d orD;awG[m uav;arG;zGm;& a&;v_yf±Sm;olawG[m ,Ofaus;r_ trsKd;om;awG[m wGef;
jcif;eJ@ apmifah ±Smufxrd ;f odr;f &jcif;qdk e,fy,fbufukd OD;vSnphf Of;pm;vm wGe;f wdu k w f u kd vf yk jf cif;/ v$r;f rd;k cs,f
wJ}h urd pf mudk vGwaf jrmufatmifvyk f =uygw,f? Edik if aH &; oabmw&m; vS,jf cif;eJ@ zsuq f ;D jcif;qdw k hJ zdEydS w f hJ
Edik rf jS zpfr,fqw kd hJ qifjcifpOf;pm;csuf raqmifwt hJ rsKd ;orD;A[dðk y,Ofaus; vd i f twef ; tpm; Oppresive
[m wu,fwef;tm;jzifh rsKd ;quf r_e@J vlrb _ 0taetxm;awGqD jyef Class jzpfvmovdk trsK;d orD;awG
jyef@ymG ;jcif;eJ@ rdcifb0udk tav;ay; a&mufoGm;ygw,f? 'Dvdkvkyfvdkuf uawmh tpOfxm0& zdEydS cf t H wef;
tr$e;f wifaewmjzpfygowJ?h trsK;d wJt h wGuf trsK;d om;awG&u hJ rBmvd@k tpm; Universal Victims jzpfvm
orD ; qd k w m trsKd ; om;awG e J @ wl qdw k hJ Edik if aH &;e,fajrxJuae aemuf ygawmhw,f? cE<mud, k ±f yk yf ikd ;f eJ@ vdif
atmif óu;d pm;zd@k vyk af qmifp&m rvdk qkwv f u kd w f mrsK;d jzpfomG ;ygw,f? ydik ;f qdik &f m t"rRusio hf ;kH r_awGe@J t
ygb;l ? rvkyaf qmifoifyh gb;l ? trsK;d aemufwrsK;d uawmh qef@usib f uf rsK;d om;awG[m trsK;d orD;awGukd zd
orD;awG&hJ oabmobm0eJ@ wefz;kd jzpfwhJ Edik if aH &;t& wGe;f wGe;f wdu k f ESyd x f m;ygw,f? trsK;d om;awG[m
xm;r_awG[m trsK;d om;awGe@J rwl wdu k v f yk zf @kd jzpfvmcJ=h uovdk awmf vdifydkif;qdkif&m t"rRðyusifhEdkifwJh
nDygbl;? wcsKd@e,fy,fawGrSm t vSeaf &;oabmaqmifvm=uygw,f? pdwyf ikd ;f qdik &f m zefw;D wnfaqmuf
xufwef;usjcif;/ wDxiG zf efw;D Edik f vdifydkif;qdkif&m rwlnDjcm;em;csuf xm;Edkif+yD;om;jzpfouJhodk@ 'g[m
pGr;f / cHpm;em;vnfEikd rf e_ @J xdr;f odr;f awG[m obm0a=umifv h @kd qckd &hJ if trsKd;orD;awGtm;vHk;twGuf t
apmifha±Smufr_qdkwJh t&nftcsif; awmif zd0k g'}u;D pd;k r_&hJ Zpfjrpf[m t a=umufw&m;eJ@ trsK;d om;tm;vH;k
awGrSm trsKd;orD;awG[m trsKd; rsK;d om;vdiaf =umifjh zpfygw,f? trsK;d &Jh xdr;f csKyfru _ kd tpOft+rJcaH e&r,f
om;awGxuf ydo k m=uygw,f? 'gukd om;tm;vH;k [m cE<mud, k ±f yk yf ikd ;f eJ@ qdkwJh todw&m;jzpfvmygawmh
30
w,f? trsK;d om;awG[m vdiyf ikd ;f oGm;ovdjk zpfaeygw,f? 'Dvw kd uG f }u;D pd;k wJh vl@tzG@J pnf;awG=um;rSm t
qdik &f m t"rRðyusiw hf wfw,f? bm csu&f if; wcsK@d [m trsK;d orD;csi;f eJ@ rsK;d orD;awG&hJ trke;f w&m;aemufu
jzpfv@kd vq J akd wmh olw@kd [m vdiyf ikd ;f om aygif;azmfr,fqdkwhJ Political yHpk u H JG a&mifjyef[yfcsuaf wGv@kd cH,l
t"rRðyEdkifwJh taetxm;±SdwJht Lesbianism ,lqr_awG jzpfvmyg xm;=uygw,f?
wGuf jzpfw,f? bmjzpfv@kd vq J akd wmh w,f? trsK;d orD;awGtwGuf Edik if H 'Dvekd @J vdiyf ikd ;f qdik &f m cGjJ cm;
olw@kd rmS vdiyf ikd ;f t"rRðyusiEhf ikd zf @kd a&;qdik &f m tqH;k tjzwfawGðyvky&f qufqrH u _ if;wJh vl@tzG@J tpnf;wck
ZD0aA'tpGr;f tp±Sad evd@k jzpfw,f? rJah e&mrSm vdiyf ikd ;f qdik &f m a±G;cs,rf _ udk trsK;d orD;eJ@ trsK;d om;=um; [ef
aemuf+yD; vdiyf ikd ;f t"rRrðyusib hf ;l [m ta&;}u;D wJh udpw P ck jzpfvmyg csun f n D D wnfaqmufv@kd jzpfEikd &f
qdw k hJ trsK;d om;awGawmifrS trsK;d w,f? trsK;d orD;tcsi;f csi;f vuf r,fqw kd hJ vdiyf ikd ;f qdik &f m wef;wlnrD #
orD;awG&hJ vdiyf ikd ;f qdik &f m t"rRðy qufaygif;oif;wJh trsKd;orD;awG a&;yef;wdik ef @J ,H=k unfcsut f ay:rSm
usichf &H Edik wf ,fqw kd hJ ta=umufw om trsK;d orD;b0jyXmef;csuf tppf cdik rf mpGmudik pf &JG if; trsK;d orD; wef;
&m;eJ@ pd;k &drpf w d t f ay:rSm tusK;d t trSef Women Identified Women wla&; v_y±f mS ;ol trsm;pk}uD;[m
jrwfawG&aeygw,f? 'guawmh pl udk &&SEd ikd of rl sm;om jzpfygw,f? 'g aqmif±Gufae=uygawmhw,f? 'g
qefba&mif;rDvm&Jh usrwd@k qENukd rSom aemufq;kH rSm trsK;d om;awG&hJ a=umifh vdifydkif;qdkif&m a&G;cs,fjy
qef @ usif v suf Susan Brown- zdEydS rf u
_ ae vGwaf jrmufEikd af tmif Xmef;r_ (Sexual Preference) qdk wm
miller’d Against Our Will qdw k hJ pGr;f aqmifEikd rf mS jzpfwt hJ wGujf zpf yk*v ~ u d ydik ;f qdik &f m a±G;cs,&f rJh udpP
pmwrf ; xJ u aumuf c suf j zpf yg ygw,f? ‘trsK;d orD; wef;wla&;v_yf wckjzpf+yD; Edik if aH &;ydik ;f qdik &f m ydik ;f
w,f? ±Sm;r_0g'[m oabmw&m;jzpfw,f? jzwfcsufeJ@ ar;cGef;xkwf&rJhudpP r
jyXmef;cHqw kd mbmvJ? trsK;d orD;csi;f aygi;f azmfa&;uawmh [kwyf gb;l vd@k qd=k uyga=umif; wif
vdifydkif;qdkif&m wef;wl vufawG@ygb?J ’ wD*a&@pf twfuD jyvdu k yf gw,f? Ô
&nfwljzpfa&;eJ@ [efcsufnDa&;qdk pef Ti Grace At-kinson &Jh wifjy
wm tvG,w f ul rjzpfEikd yf gb;l ? t csujf zpfygw,f? 'Dvekd @J oD;jcm;cGx J uG f oH'ikd ;f az
rsK;d om;eJ@ trsK;d orD;=um; qufqH aqmif±u G af &; Seperatism eJ@ trsKd ; 14;28 em&D
a&;tm;vH;k [m zdEydS rf a_ wG±adS ewm orD;csi;f aygi;f azmfa&; Lesbianism 2007 ckEpS f ZGev
f 30 &uf
ygb?J 'ga=umifh trsK;d om;eJ@ vuf t,ltqawG[m trsK;d orD;wef;
xyfw,fqw kd hJ trsK;d orD;awGukd t wla&; v_yf±Sm;r_awG=um;rSm euf
rsK;d om;awG&hJ tjyXmef;cH Man Ide- euf±_dif;±_dif; uGJvGJay:xGufvmcJh
ntified Women awGtjzpf,lq ygw,f?
vmygawmhw,f? rdrw d @kd &hJ obm0 'gayrJvh @kd trsK;d orD; wef;
w&m;udk rSerf eS u f efueftodtrSwf wla&; v_y±f mS ;oltrsm;pk}u;D uawmh
rðyEdik af wmhovdk trsK;d orD;jyXmef; 'gawG[m b,fvrkd S aphpyfv@kd r&Edik f
csufqdkwmrsKd;vnf; aysmufuG,f wJh taetxm;jzpf+yD; trsKd;om;
31