You are on page 1of 16

Exploring naturalistic spiritualty since 1999 Issue 20 Autumn 2007

The Dawning of Dark Skies


W e rarely have an opportunity
to realize how the spread of
development and of light pollution has
pollution light pollution is not intended
– it’s an unwanted by-product, something
that our needed activities spill out onto the
robbed us. Contrasting images (left)
rest of the world. It’s light that serves one
taken during and after the great 2003
person or company’s needs, but interferes
blackout in North East USA and Canada
with many others’ needs. It’s light that
bring home the loss graphically.
strays beyond the area where it’s needed,
Dark Skies are a central issue for
light that sprays into the sky or strays into
pantheism. They enable us to experience
a neighbor’s bedroom. It’s wasted light
our surrounding Universe directly. Their
- light that nobody wants, light that wastes
nemesis, light pollution, makes the
money and energy and produces the waste
experience increasingly difficult to come
of greenhouse gases.
by. On top of that it wastes energy, results
in excess greenhouse gas emissions,
damages human health and disrupts
wildlife. That’s why, last month, the
WPM decided to become a supporting
S tealing the stars
The most obvious effect of light
pollution is to obscure the night sky. It’s
organization of the International Dark- somewhat like stretching wrapping plastic
Sky Association. over your windows. I lived for over thirty
Pantheism reveres the Universe. years in London, close to Parliament Hill –
The impulse for that reverence comes with a full horizon all around this would be
not from scripture or theory, but from in theory a superb viewing spot for anything
what we see and learn about the vast in the skies. But I remember going up there
cosmos that envelops us. Today we have at the peak of meteor showers and seeing
astonishing images from the Hubble maybe one meteor in several hours. The rest
telescope that show us details of distant of the time there was the same reddish grey-
supernovae, majestically spiralling or black, with only the very brightest stars
awesomely colliding galaxies. More visible.
telescopes are coming on line or planned In 2001 Pierantonio Cinzano of the
that will expand that vision. While the and his colleagues produced the World Atlas
ancients speculated on the meaning of of Artificial Night Sky Brightness, based on
those dots of light – Heraclitus thought satellite data and accurate modelling of how
they were holes in an upturned black light propagates in the atmosphere.
bowl – we know what they are. This was the first attempt to survey
But to place those images in their the extent of the problem world-wide.
living context, to show how they all About two-thirds of the world population
fit together and how we and the Earth live in areas where the night sky is above
fit into that vast picture, we rely on the threshold set for polluted status. The
the direct experience of looking up more developed the region, the higher
into a dark moonless night. Looking the proportion of people living with
at astronomical imagery, and lying on light-polluted night skies: in the United
Top: the glorious star-flooded skies your back gazing into the heavens, are States (excluding Alaska and Hawaii) and
above an Ontario home in August 2003, complementary – one is not complete the European Union, 99 per cent of the
during the biggest power blackout in without the other. population are affected. In concrete terms,
North American history. Below: the Light pollution is gradually this means that for eight out of ten people
impoverished and washed out sky after diminishing our direct experience. How in the USA and two out of three in the EU
power was restored. do we define it? Like other forms of the night sky is brighter than a full moon

Editing and Design: Paul Harrison Associate Editor: Rene Lawrence

1
Pan Magazine Autumn 2007

The World Atlas of Artificial Night Sky Brightness shows


the extent of light pollution across the world. We have
probably all seen NASA pictures of the earth at night,
showing the lights of human activity. Light pollution is
brighter than the lights themselves, because it spreads
far beyond its sources, diffused by atmospheric dust.
The lightness of the image coincides with areas of light
pollution and also locates the sites of human energy use
and greenhouse gas emissions.
In Euope, North America, Asia, South Africa and the
coasts of Latin America, the light pollution derives mainly
from cities and industries.
In the interior of Africa and Latin America and in South
East Asia, brightness on this map may indicate forest and
grassland fires, lit to clear land for farming or pasture. In
parts of the Arab countries or coastal Africa it reveals gas
flarings in oil fields. And in the ocean (eg off the Falkand
Islands or in the Sea of Japan) it may represent the
presence of very large fishing fleets or (in the North Sea
east of Britain) offshore oil fields.
There is almost nowhere in the whole of Japan, Europe
or the Eastern USA where pristine dark skies are
viewable.
This image is based on data from 1996-97 - the situation
today is almost certainly considerably worse.

Source: Cinzano et al.,


World Atlas of Artificial Night Sky Brightness

sky woud be in a dark-sky area – what Cinzano calls “moonlight


without the moon.” In these areas people never actually
experience true night. In the UK almost everyone living in the
L eaking energy and pollutants
Virtually all of the light that causes light pollution is
unwanted and wasted. Apart from air raid wardens, the Luxor
South East and the Midlands can see less than 400 stars, while in hotel in Las Vegas and a few special events, nobody wants
the larger conurbations the total is less than 200. This compares light to leak skyward. The Environmental Protection Agency
with up to 1300 stars visible with the naked eye in areas with no has made rough estimates of the cost of the wasted light in the
light pollution. United States, where lighting accounts for up to a quarter of the
Probably the single element of the night sky that evangelizes electricity used annually. Lighting for industry, stores, offices,
people to pantheism is the Milky Way, revolving above us like and warehouses represents from 80 to 90 percent of the total
some gigantic illuminated Ferris wheel, brilliantly dense and lighting electricity use. If energy efficient lighting were used
radiant in the constellation of Sagittarius, where the heart of the everywhere that it was profitable, the electricity required for
galaxy resides hidden behind thick veils of dust. Cinzano’s team lighting would be cut by at least 50 percent. This reduction would
found that about one-fifth of the world population have already free up $18.6 billion for investment. It would cut carbon dioxide
lost naked eye visibility of the MilkyWay - including over two- emissions by 232 million tons a year - equivalent to taking 42
thirds of the US population and more than half the population of million cars off the road – and also reduce emissions of sulfur
the European Union. dioxide and nitrogen oxide, which cause acid rain.
Another effect of light pollution is to reduce people’s night The production of this wasted light means an annual waste
vision capabilities. Full night vision takes about 30 minutes to of at least six million tons of coal or 23 million barrels of oil,
set in, in very dark areas. In areas that are not fully dark because with all the acid rain, air pollution and greenhouse gases that
of light pollution, night vision is weaker and so even less is seen these imply. In reality all these figures are probably serious
of an already depleted sky. The Atlas found that about one tenth underestimates.
of the world’s population no longer views the heavens with
their eyes adapted to night vision, because of the sky brightness.
This is the case with more than 40 per cent of the United States
population and one sixth of the European Union population.
D amaging human and ecosystem health
Light pollution also has effects on human health – excess
lighting in workplaces can increase stress. Poorly shaded security
and street lights can scatter light into homes and bedrooms,
These results, based on data from 1996-97, are troubling interfering with sleep which is essential for good physical and
enough, but ten years later – given rapid urbanization in China mental health.
and an extra 900 million people in the world – they are probably So far we have been seeing light pollution from a human
a good deal worse. The team are now working on the growth of point of view, where only stray light is considered as polluting.
light pollution – results from Italy show an alarming deterioration From the point of view of other living creatures and ecosystems,
between 1971 and 1998. any artificial light is light pollution and can have complex effects
2
Pan Magazine Autumn 2007

that are only just beginning to be investigated. Among moths from the light.
artificial light interferes with mating, dispersal, and migration. It Artificial light can change whole ecosystems. In the ocean
diverts moths into traffic, and burns or desiccates moths that fly many creatures descend to lower depths in daylight hours, to
into lamp housings. One of the best-known effects is on hatching avoid predation, and rise again at night. Many zooplankton forage
sea turtles. They normally head towards the sea, which under near the surface during dark conditions. Artificial light can reduce
normal conditions will be lighter, while things in land are darker. their rising, which may result in population increases in the algae
With artificial lights land is lighter they normally eat, leading to algal blooms.
and sea darker, so the turtles head What you can and cannot see
inland - towards predatory gulls
and roadways with traffic. Excellent Zodiacal light and zodiacal band visible; M33 directly visible to naked-eye; many
dark sky Messier globular clusters are distinct naked-eye objects; Sagittarius region of
Some animals use changed site the Milky Way is complex and casts obvious shadows on the ground; clouds
light levels to their advantage. visible only as dark holes
Harbor seals congregate under Rural sky Near horizon, light pollution is evident and clouds are illuminated; the Milky Way
lights to eat juvenile salmon as still appears complex; M33 is visible with averted vision; nearer surroundings
they migrate downstream. Crows are vaguely visible.
prefer to roost near lights, where Rural/ Light pollution domes are visible in various directions over the horizon; Milky Way
they can spot owls. Artificial light suburban above the horizon is still impressive, but lacks most of the finer details; clouds
has important effects on predator- transition are illuminated in the directions of the light sources, but still dark overhead.
prey relationships. Moths and Suburban The Milky Way is very weak or invisible near the horizon and looks washed out
other insects such as lacewings, sky overhead; artificial light sources are visible in most, if not all, directions; clouds
are noticeably brighter than the sky.
beetles, bugs, caddisflies, crane
flies, midges, hoverflies, wasps, Bright The Milky Way is visible only near the zenith; the sky within 35° of the
and bush crickets are attracted suburban horizon glows grayish white; clouds anywhere in the sky appear fairly bright;
sky surroundings are easily visible.
to lights and may be killed by
the heat, or exposed to higher Suburban/ The entire sky has a grayish-white hue; strong light sources are evident in all
urban directions; Milky Way is invisible; M31 and M44 may be seen with the naked eye,
predation by bats and insect- transition but very indistinct; clouds are brightly lit; even in moderate-sized telescopes
eating birds. Light may affect the brightest Messier objects are only ghosts of their true selves.
reproductive behavior - frogs in
City sky The sky glows white or orange - you can easily read; even with a telescope, only
one study stopped mating during a few bright Messier objects can be detected; stars forming familiar constellation
nearby night football games. Male patterns may be weak or completely invisible.
choruses tuned up again only Source: Simplified from Bortle Dark-Sky Scale, Wikipedia
when the frogs were shielded
3
Pan Magazine Autumn 2007

What’s being done


First Dark Sky Park
Earlier this year, in April, the IDA
recognized Natural Bridges National
Monument as its first International
Dark Sky Park. The park, already
one of the darkest in the USA,
shielded more the 80 percent of their
light fixtures so all the light points
downward. Most of the fixtures now
use 13-watt compact fluorescent
light bulbs that reduce light from
the park buildings straying into the
campground and backcountry. In
summer, the park provides astronomy
ranger programs under spectacular
starry skies.
The whole US National Park Service
is now committed to protect natural
darkness and other components of
the natural lightscapes of parks.
UPS Management Policies of
2006 describes natural lightscapes
© 1997 Terry Acomb/John Chumack/PhotoResearchers: vwww.galacticimages.com as “natural resources and values
that exist in the absence of human-caused light.” The Service will minimize light that emanates from park facilities, and seek the
cooperation of visitors, neighbors, and local government agencies to minimize the intrusion of artificial light. The Service will avoid
artificial lighting in areas such as sea turtle nesting locations where the presence of the artificial lighting will disrupt a park’s dark-
dependent natural resource components; restrict artificial lighting to areas where security, basic human safety, and cultural resource
demands it, and use minimal-impact lighting techniques.

First International Dark Sky City: Flagstaff Arizona


The title was awarded in 2001 to Flagstaff, Arizona, which has advanced municipal lighting policies such as replacing of high-pressure
sodium and mercury vapor roadway lighting with fully shielded low-pressure sodium. The city distributes Dark Sky brochures with all
building permits, and funds an innovative program to help businesses replace obsolete lighting. It was aiming to bring all city-owned
facility lighting completely into compliance with the lighting code by the end of 2002. All Arizona counties now have outdoor lighting
control ordinance.

First Dark Sky Country: Czech Republic


In 2002 the Czech Republic became the first country to bring into force national legislation aimed at eliminating light pollution,
and mandating the use of the use of fully shielded light fixtures that emit no light above the horizontal direction. Italy has also
made considerable progress: 15 of the countries’ 21 regions have Dark Sky laws and seven of these have the best-practice laws
recommended by anti-light pollution organizations. At least eight US states have regulations to restrict light pollution - Arizona,
California, Connecticut, Colorado, Maine, New Mexico, Texas and Vermont.

National Dark-Sky Week


In 2002 a 15 year old student, Jennifer Barlow, began campaigning for a US National Dark-Sky Week (NDSW), and the first such week
was held in April the following year. It’s now endorsed by the American Astronomical Society, Astronomical League, International
Dark-Sky Association, and Sky & Telescope magazine. It is held in the week of the new moon in April, and people in the US are
encouraged to turn out their unnecessary outdoor lights. In 2008 NDSW will be April 6-12. Visit http://www.ndsw.org/

4
Pan Magazine Autumn 2007

What you can do


● Think in terms of conserving the natural ● Turn all lights off using a timer or sensor or
lightscape, conserving energy, reducing manually when you don’t need them.
greenhouse gas emissions and restoring ● Ask yourself if you really need to illuminate
natural diurnal rhythms for yourself and for that tree or that fountain after dark!
nature.
● Join the International Dark-Sky Association
● Consider your human and non-human at http://www.darksky.org/
neighbors, and the effect your lights may have
● Invite your friends and neighbors to star
on them.
parties for events such as meteor showers, in
● Design your outdoor lighting system based dark sky locations so they see the difference.
on what light is actually needed. ● Celebrate and promote Dark Sky Week and
● Use light sources no stronger than is the peak of the Perseid shower (August 12).
required for your purpose. ● Write to your local papers about local
● Improve your fixtures and shades, so they light pollution issues such as gas stations and
direct more light where you need it, and less excessive street lighting.
light strays where it may harm or annoy ● Lobby your local representatives and
others or pollute the night sky. officials to introduce and enforce Dark Sky
● Adjust the type of bulbs and tubes used, to policies.
ones that emit light waves less likely to cause ● Enjoy the peace of darkness.
problems and that use less energy.

Star-friendly lighting
Many modern outdoor light fitments
direct the light where it’s wanted,
and keep it away from where it’s not
wanted. Usually this involves fairly
simple techniques like shades that
point the light downwards, or in a
limited pool, rather than through all
azimuths and all degrees. When light
goes only where it’s wanted, much less
light is required to do the job, resulting
in savings in cost, energy use, and
greenhouse gas emissions.
These four light fitments are produced
©Hubbell Incorporated

by Architectural Area Lighting (http://


www.aal.net), and are approved by the
International Dark-Sky Association.
In addition, many of the fitments are
produced in environmentally friendly
ways and use low-energy bulbs and
tubes.
5
Pan Magazine Autumn 2007

Fogged In on the Shores


of the Cosmic Ocean
F or as long as I can remember, I
have been graced with fabulous
“aurora karma.m” For example, one
that organic molecules, and by fearless
extrapolation perhaps life itself, could
be produced by energetic processes
beautiful summer night at Lenox in such as lightning, acting upon ordinary
western Massachusetts, a group of atmospheric constituents. All this led
us were listening to Rachmaninoff me to a fresh view of the skies, which
on the lawn of the Tanglewood were crystalline as seen from my home
Music Center, far from the lights in northern Vermont, far from the city
of Boston. As the music swelled, a lights of the seaboard.
spectacular auroral display erupted Leaving teaching to pursue
overhead. Perfectly choreographed research training that would be
to the music, it danced above us for applicable to these interests, I landed in
perhaps 20 minutes, creating for us a program with a focus on the contents
all a truly unforgettable experience. of our own solar system. With no
The friends with whom I witnessed illusions that life on Mars was likely,
this are at this very moment sailing these interests seemed like a call to
down the eastern seacoast and will study how our solar system came to be
arrive in my neighborhood this as it is; ready for life on Earth, at least.
weekend. As sailors, they have a WPM Vice President Tom Moore Still, the Viking landings on Mars in
great appreciation for the skills lives with his family near 1976 had me glued to my telescope,
Annapolis, MD, where he enjoys
of dead reckoning and celestial the seafood and walks along the
imagining those dauntless robots trying
navigation. woodsy shore, but misses the to sniff out life in a red desert.
My point in relating these clear skies of his New England Faced with an opportunity to
youth. He has worked as a
anecdotes is that the dark night skies landscaper, engineer, teacher,
build a scientific instrument and fly
play a dual role in our lives with homebuilder, executor, landlord, it on a sounding rocket above an
both practical and spiritual or artistic writer, and for the past 25 years aurora, I guessed that the auroral
as a heliophysicist studying the
aspects. Dark skies form a perfect effects of solar and interstellar assault of the solar wind on the upper
yin/yang duality with the blazing sun winds on our cosmic shoreline. atmosphere might well be relevant to
He recently joined the ranks of
of daytime. The sun brings energy NASA’s middle management.
the composition and stability of our
to life and creates a merry campfire atmosphere over geologic time. So
around which we gather, while the soon I was treated to the very clearest
dark night skies behind us reveal the cold vastness of the of skies anywhere on our planet, in the long cold arctic
universe as well as the infinity of other distant campfires. night of winter, where aurora is a nightly occurrence.
My own interests in astronomy and space began as an When my own children developed interests and school
interest in physics and the Earth, including “meteorology”, assignments relating to the skies, we lived in Huntsville,
the root of which refers to all that lies above and beyond Alabama. Though the south is not renowned for clear skies,
the ground. When Carl Sagan asked whether life on Earth and Huntsville suffers from widespread use of sodium
could be detected through a telescope trained on us by vapor lamps, dark skies do occur during dry air periods.
an alien culture, I was astounded by the audacity of his Indeed, auroras are not unknown in Huntsville, though
perspective. But my interest was cemented by experiences they tend to be huge red blobs rather than the rayed green
as a young teacher of math and physics, from which I drew and pink draperies of the polar aurora. Later, in Maryland,
energy when teaching those topics. Watching Star Trek and likewise prone to murky skies, we sought at one point to
reading Carl Sagan led to daily discussions with students watch a meteor shower in the early morning hours. We first
that ranged far and wide over topics including the origins tried a nearby highway intersection that is surrounded by
of life on Earth and perhaps elsewhere in the cosmos. At farm lands. However, there were so many others already
that time, the first experiments were reported suggesting there by the time we arrived, that it was impossible to
6
Pan Magazine Autumn 2007

find a parking place or darkness! We then resorted to an oppressed by a night sky that is actually or effectively
incomplete subdivision lacking street or home lights and closed in by a cloud deck, as if we were fogged in and
had a beautiful head-on view of the incoming meteors. thereby prevented from leaving harbor. A view of the
Of course that subdivision has since been completed and infinite is something we all treasure and from which we
would be brightly lit at this point. draw endless pleasure and inspiration. We are willing to go
Increasing light pollution and sub/urbanization are far out of our way to find places where we get that view, in
rapidly consuming the dark skies that have been a source place of the glow of nearby civilization. It is equivalent in
of inspiration, information, and meditation for humankind some sense to the climbing of a mountain at the seashore,
since our appearance on Earth. Instead of studying the skies from which we can obtain a commanding view of all
as we guard our flocks at night, we now deploy more and reality. Dark skies are valued because bearing witness to
more lights in hopes of deterring vandals as we sleep under the infinite is a spiritual experience. Perhaps this speaks of
roofs, behind blinds and draperies. We have to place our a universal pantheism of the human heart, widely felt if not
telescopes in space, or in the few clear spots on the ground acknowledged. In Carl Sagan’s words, from the shores of
where (so far) light pollution is not a factor. Cameras on the cosmic ocean:
these telescopes bathe us in views of the universe that are “Our feeblest contemplations of the Cosmos stir us.
far more revealing than the human eye could ever be in There is a tingling in the spine, a catch in the voice, a
both sensitivity and detail. And rather than the stars, we use faint sensation, as if of a distant memory, of falling from
GPS systems to navigate in these days of cheap complex a height. We know that we are approaching the greatest
devices. Why then should we care about our loss of dark of mysteries...We are made of star stuff... Some part of
night skies? our being knows that is from where we came. We long to
It seems universal that humans feel somewhat return... We are a way for the Cosmos to know itself.”
7
Pan Magazine Autumn 2007

Members write about the spiritual meaning of dark skies

W here I live, the city lights pollute


the natural dark sky and its
magical perspective of the universe
possible, into the infinity beyond me.
My eyes lustfully drink it all in.
As I look up I’m always startled by
lights, in the “boonies,” so a simple
step outside the door enables me to
connect. I first became aware of the
and our relationship to it. I am often the torrent of lights of other galaxies, vastness of our Universe when at
robbed of the balance it would other worlds. I quickly become totally sea as a young mariner. Long night
provide me. absorbed by this overpowering force watches during the wee small hours
And so if I want that feeling, I which goes on and on. I’m filled with amidst the deep oceans permit much
have to drive into the Santa Monica awe and wonder. I feel intensely time for calmer and quieter thought,
Mountains, which I try to do as humble as I realize my oneness with and a growing connection to the
frequently as possible. I immediately this powerful immensity. My own limitless scope of our existence. It is
relax into the lush darkness. I’m problems and anxieties shrink into both amazing and comforting, to be
drawn into the natural beauty, like nothingness as my perspective of faced with that infinity.
huge black arms surrounding me, my own tiny existence becomes very George Mycroft
excited about the surprise that I know clear. I tell myself to hold on to this
awaits me. I find a clear spot, lie down
on my back and feel pulled into the
biggest, most mysterious journey
awareness and use it to guide me in
the future and ease my sensitivity
about my own life’s path.
I don’t have kids at home, and
where I live close to the Smoky
Mountains National Park I don’t have
As I drive home back big problems with light pollution.
into the blindness of light But I will say that looking at the night
pollution I feel angry sky filled with stars from my hilltop
that so many of us are (especially in the winter) makes me
deprived of this mighty feel more at home in the vast universe
reminder of our true than just about anything I have
place in the universe, and experienced. I still haven’t gotten a
of a much larger, wiser telescope yet, but that’s ok. There’s
perspective and guidance something about going out on the
of our own lives and porch and just looking up with my
actions. own eyes that seems right. It makes
Sheila Rosenthal me feel really small and kind of huge
at the same time. It makes me feel

I f there is one thing


that sparks my
“inclusivity” with the
like I belong. It makes me just feel. I
don’t use the word awesome much,
but one dark night my daughter and
Universe, it is standing I were riding down the road and with
and looking up into the the curves and hills, all of a sudden
vastness of space, the the full moon was straight ahead of
dark night sky, especially us and absolutely huge, and I could
when I am skyclad. It swear that we were going to ride right
is both humbling and into it. That was truly awesome. That
awe-inspiring. I find was three or four years ago and she
it a great leveller and a and I still talk about that even now,
deeply calming influence it was so amazing. I guess I’m lucky
in today’s madness that I can see the sky and the stars
to see and absorb the so clearly from where I live - in fact,
immenseness that in the past relatives from a big city
surrounds us and of visited here and actually complained
which we are an integral about how dark it is! I can’t imagine a
part. If I have a “church,” life without that, so I think our joining
then being free in Nature the International Dark-Sky Association
and connected to that is definitely a worthy pantheist cause
awesome majesty is “it” if it means more people can have that
for me. Luckily, we experience.
live far away from city Sharon Wells
8
Pan Magazine Autumn 2007

T hough the night skies did not


figure much in my childhood, I
have been lucky enough to travel into
kids hanging backwards out of their
windows, a bunch of bikers, a young
couple, a man flat out on his back on
sides of me have big bright security
lights. If I look at them they affect my
night vision so I must find a spot to
remote rural areas in Africa, Asia and his car roof, another guy on an air sit where I will not see them. Those
Latin America, and there I have had mattress with pillow. spots are not the best ones to view the
the joy of seeing the Milky Way in all Finally I got to a place high above heavens. Their light pollution, like all
its glory. I wantd to make sure my the Pacific about 15 miles from my pollution, does not recognize property
two sons had the same experience. In home. It was quite dark and the Milky boundaries. I sometimes get the urge
London you could only see a pathetic Way was strong and clear, rising out to bring along my rifle but don’t
scattering of the brightest of stars, of the ocean and soaring vertically because temptation may get the best
but we used to holiday on the island overhead with its dust clouds and of me. A full moon is light enough.
of Tresco, 30 miles from the English millions of stars. A big hill blocked off Jerald Robertson
mainland. On the night of the Perseid the view of the shower’s radiant, but
peak, around August 12 we used to
turn off all the lights, and lie back on
deckchairs, staring in the direction
I could see some of the larger meteors
that got further, some of them heading
to plunge into the Pacific. With one
I live in a development of condos
which has several hundred lamp
posts spaced about 20 feet apart, and
of Perseus. I am sure my boys will sweep I could see the earth’s ocean lamps outside each garage. These
remember those nights and I hope and land, and the earth’s place in a lights are left on all night. The whole
they will pass the tradition on. solar system still full of debris from place seems flooded with light like
These days I live in a canyon its formation and later collisions, and a high security jail, but most of it is
backing onto 60 square miles of in the wider circling galaxy. Life is unnecessary for visibility or safety. We
wild lands. I see more stars than wonderful and has many wonderful could manage with half the number of
London, but because of a haze of moments, but for me few of them lampposts, while the garage lights are
light pollution from Los Angeles embody and reward the pantheist redundant since everyone drives up
and the Valley it’s not possible to view better than this. with their car headlights on. The lights
see the Milky Way here either. One Paul Harrison waste energy, and glaze over the night
of the worst sources is an auto-mall sky. I just love the nights when some
in Thousand Oaks about ten miles
from here, where dealers leave half
a mile of floodlights switched on all
I have a place in the country where
I can get away from the lights of
the city and really see the night sky.
malfunction blacks out the outdoor
lights – the place looks so much more
cozy, with warm little lights emerging
night long. Light pollution like this Unfortunately my neighbors on both from scattered windows, like a village
is a crime against human
wonder.
While the solstices and
equinoxes are theoretically
important, Nature does not
provide any fireworks to
mark them. So for me the
Perseid shower is one the
high points of the pantheist
year. This year I headed
for the nearest wild area,
Malibu Creek State Park,
surrounded by steep hills.
Even here, shielded from
all nearby artificial light,
light pollution from Los
Angeles was bad, so I
headed further West, where
there are fewer houses. As
I got deeper into the darker
areas there were people by
the roadside out to watch
the show - a family with

Van Gogh’s Starry


Night expresses the
most intense emotional
response to the
enveloping night sky.
9
Pan Magazine Autumn 2007

in a forest. separated by so much space that when we look up in the


I am a light sleeper and easily awakened by dawn or night sky, we will see very little other than our own galaxy,
other lights, so these lights constitute “light trespass” and and less and less of that. We are very lucky to live in the
for a long time I found them intrusive and distressing. present time when so much is still visible in the night sky.
One day I took matters into my own hands and Our great, great, great . . . . nth great grandchildren may
unscrewed the bulbs outside my own townhome. There not be so lucky.
was plenty of light from the adjacent lamps. I had a quiet Dave Kiebert
agreement with the maintenance guy that he would not
screw them back in again. Then one of the homeowners’ I’m a New York City native, so I grew up only knowing
board noticed, and I got a letter from the association to about the few stars we could see. I was lucky enough to
screw them back in again, with threats of fines if I did not. go pretty often to the Hayden Planetarium. Not quite the
My latest trick has been to insert aluminum foil same, though.
shaped to the lamp glass, cutting out the light that points at A few years ago I was on the beach at night on Koh
my unit while increasing illumination on the path. It works Samui, Thailand. The stars covered ever inch of sky, and
a treat and I can sleep peacefully again. Don’t tell anyone! they seemed as big and heavy as ripe fruit waiting to be
Mary Wild plucked. The experience felt almost hypnotic.
A few days ago, I was watching a movie about
I have enjoyed looking up at the night skies, away from Beethoven. One of the climactic moments is the
the city lights, since I was a child. My family used to performance of his 9th Symphony. The old man, now deaf,
go camping in the San Bernardino Mountains, and I climbs onstage and recalls his life as a boy as he hears the
remember singing songs around the campfire, dazzled by music in his head. His memory takes him to a time when
the number and brightness of the stars in the sky. When he climbed out his window to escape a beating from his
I was a senior in high school, my father and I took a long abusive father. Then he ran through the woods to a pond
trip around California, visiting various college campuses and, with the night sky reflected all around him in the
I might attend, and one night we camped out in Yosemite black water, he floats on his back. The famous, powerful
park, in sleeping bags under the open sky. I remember Ode to Joy plays in his mind, and camera pans out, showing
how absolutely silent it was that night, how cold, and how how tiny he is among the vast expanses of the galaxy, until
bright the stars were. I later learned that the expansion of the boy becomes only a few little stars among all
the universe appears to be accelerating, and eventually the others.
(millions of years from now, at least) the galaxies will all be Zen

At France’s Mont
St Michel, light
illuminates buildings
tastefully but does
not stray beyond
their margins.
10
Pan Magazine Autumn 2007

Our lists need your thought


E very now and then we send out a message to encourage people to post to our lists. We know from the join form statements
that our members are intelligent, sensitive and profound people. All of you have experiences and insights or inspiring and
enlightening stories that we could all benefit from hearing. So please don’t be shy, let’s hear them. They will broaden, inspire or
inform us or simply help us all feel that we are not alone in our positive, life-affirming, nature-valuing, reality honoring viewpoint.
I know that for new members the lists can seem daunting, especially the Ideas list. It can sometimes feel like you have just
entered a room where a private conversation is going on among a group of people you do not know. Try to overcome that feeling
and just jump in. Remember that every frequent poster was once a first-time poster just like you. If you don’t like the threads
that are running, you can always start a new thread. It may seem that you need a high level of writing skill, or scientific or
philosophical expertise in order to post. On most of our lists, what counts above all is not not rhetoric or expertise but sincerity
and experience: everyone is the world expert on their own experience and feelings. On the Ideas list it is preferable if people
are cautious about posting on topics with which they are not at all familiar – but with the Internet it’s easy to get at least a
general idea of most things rather quickly. It may also appear sometimes that if you stick your head above the parapet, you may
get it cut off. That should not be the case and if that happens to you and we notice it, we will be on your side. If you think we
haven’t noticed it, write to one of the moderators (see the table opposite). We have firm rules to encourage mutual respect and
we enforce them. Please remember that our major lists are not censored in advance, we don’t control what goes in, we can only
deal with things after the event. Posts (other than WPM announcements) represent ONLY the opinions and character of the person
who posted them. Paul Harrison

Choosing your lists Ideas list: This list is mainly for discussing pantheist and
related beliefs, and also discusses science, ethics, philosophy
and comparative religion related to a reverent naturalistic
In the first few years of our existence, we used to have life-view. These are topics where opinions may differ, and
just one list for everything from philosophical and scientific where people may challenge each other’s ideas. It’s a
ideas to feelings and experiences, poems and ceremonies. list primarily for people in sympathy with the WPM belief
This “Big List” started out with 35 members and eventually statement: people who feel a deep religious reverence for the
grew to almost 1000. But there was one big problem that universe and nature, who generally do not believe that mind
kept recurring every few weeks. Debates on political and and matter are two separate substances, or that supernatural
philosophical issues would get heated, two or three individuals phenomena exist. If you want to challenge these viewpoints,
would start baiting each other, a fight would break out, then the place to do that is the Pantheist_Spirituality list
everyone else would go silent, and good feelings and sharing where you will find more supporters for alternative versions
would vanish. This interfered seriously with our efforts to of pantheism. Here too we encourage people to be friendly,
build up a community spirit. So we divided the Big List into cooperative and constructive. Since ideas can only be
two – one for the kind of topic that led more frequently into developed if debated, be prepared, if you raise a pet idea, for
adversarial debate (the Ideas list), the other for sharing someone else to offer a (hopefully constructive) critique.
feelings and discussing pantheist living (the Community list.) Pantheist_Spirituality: This list was the first generic pantheist
These days we have four major lists and one safety valve forum on the Internet. Although the WPM set it up, it is for
list. Each has its own special niche. Here’s a brief guide to all types of pantheist to communicate and share experiences
give you some idea of which list to choose for your post, or and ideas. This is the place to post if you don’t agree with
which you might be interested in reading. You can belong to the WPM’s form of pantheism. There are natural/scientific
all four. pantheists there along with dualists and so on. For that reason
However many you belong to, cross-posting between there may be disagreements at times. As always we encourage
the lists is not a good idea. We do this only for WPM-wide people to remain respectful, and this list usually is.
news, to make sure everyone sees it. There is a considerable Intro list: Our only fully moderated list, this is for people
amount of overlap in membership, so a large proportion of interested in getting to know the ideas and practices of the
people will see the same post twice. People may cross-post WPM before becoming supporting members. All posts are
their replies. And finally, cross-posting blurs the distinctions moderated, and there are a number of experienced WPM
between the lists and confuses everyone. It’s best to get to members who can discuss pantheism and answer questions.
know the differences between the lists and to choose the most Hot Topics list: This list is a kind of safety valve where high
appropriate list. If it’s a borderline subject, ask yourself: is pressure steam can be let off. It fused three of our prior lists:
this likely to create adversarial debate? If so, then post to the Politics, WPMVocabulary and the adversarial aspects of our
Ideas or Spirituality lists. vegetarian lists. Hot Topics covers two kinds of topics:
Community List: This list is for sharing experiences and Those that often generate an unusual amount of heat, such
feelings about nature, discussing everday problems of as vegetarianism v meat eating or discussion of national or
pantheist living, suggesting ways of celebrating life’s stages international political issues and political systems. [Note:
and the seasons, inspirational quotes, and developing the as a charity the WPM may take positions on issues core to
World Pantheist Movement and its local groups. As it’s title us, but we do not endorse any particular political group or
implies, this is the place where we stress community and candidate.]
cooperation and sharing rather than adversarial debate. We ● Those that have come up dozens of times on the Ideas list
emphasize mutual respect, sharing and patient listening to and that frequently hinge on the definition of terms, such as
each other, warmth rather than heat. We want everyone to “Is pantheism a philosophy or a religion?” or pantheist usage
feel totally safe to post without anxiety, regardless of age, of the word “God.”
gender or level of education.
11
Pan Magazine Autumn 2007

How list moderation works moderators must agree. If not, then they bring the case to
the moderators’ committee which consists of all the main
Our lists have different levels of moderation. The Ideas list list moderators, and a majority decision there decides the
is not moderated at all, except for a limit of two posts per appropriate action.
day of 130 lines or less. This limit is enforced robotically by
the software – if you exceed these your post will not get in. How we deal with rule breaches
So please post in text only, not in HTML, and please don’ t Moderation is usually very light. Off-topic stuff gets in, as
quote the whole of the digest you are replying to. long as there is some kind of link with pantheism. When
All our other lists are at Yahoo groups and they are set someone violates the more important rules – usually the
to moderate new members for a few months – Yahoo’s soft- one against insults - we follow a set procedure. We send
ware decides how long. That’s because there are tons of a private informal and friendly warning to the person con-
spammers out there, many of them automated, who keep cerned. Most people respect these. However, a few people
pouring in with new IDs and when allowed post a message do not. If they repeat the behavior, then they get a formal
every day. Lists with no moderation quickly get flooded warning, also in private. Any breach following the formal
with spam. For everyone who is past this introductory warning may lead to the person being set to moderated, or
period, the Community list and the Pantheist Spiritual- in extreme cases (which are very rare) they may be sus-
ity list, like the Ideas list, are not moderated before the pended from all our lists. We don’t discuss specific cases
event. That provides freedom of expression, but it also in the lists to avoid embrarrassment. However we may is-
brings risks. A few times a year someone comes along who sue a very generalized reminder to the list about the rel-
just can’t stop themselves insulting or mocking or putting evant rules. If the person concerned discusses the modera-
down other people. That kind of behavior is not compat- tion in the list, then we will respond to that in the list.
ible with a friendly environment where people feel safe.
Mailing List Active moderators
Who moderates
Each of our major lists has at least Ideas (pantheism-l@listser.aol.com) Eljay Love-Jensen, Tom Moore
two moderators (see box) to make WPMCommunity@yahoogroups.com Tom Moore, Sharon Wells
sure that pending messages are dealt Pantheist_Spirituality@yahoogroups.com Paxdora, Sharon Wells
with promptly. For any stage beyond Pantheism_Intro@yahoogroups.com Eljay Love-Jensen, Paul Harrison
informal warning, or if either has
WPMHotTopics@yahoogroups.com Elay Love-Jensen, Paxdora
doubt about an informal letter, both

Rules of the games attitudes do not help to advance any


subject. They take attention away
members with chain letters, advertising,
commercial approaches, flaming, threats,
The basic rules apply to all our lists, and from the content, turn discussions into harassment or calls to leave the list.
are designed with two goals in mind. The brawls. Reason is replaced by posturing. Anyone found to be breaching these rules
first is to maintain a civilized, positive Outbursts of flaming, hostility or hand- will be expelled from all our lists. Names
and friendly atmosphere in which to-hand combat monopolize attention, and contact details on the geo-database
open-minded exploration and mutual focus interest on personal clashes, close must not be divulged to people who are
development can thrive. The second goal off intelligent exchange and drive good not members of the WPM.
is to keep mail volume within digestible
limits. Many people are busy, and some
sign off a list if confronted with excess
people into silence or even departure. If
you want to lose respect and credibility,
and divert attention from the content of
V olume and focus: A maximum of
two posts per person per day are
allowed on our busiest lists. That allows
volume. The rules about privacy are also your message to your personality, this is for corrections and responses to later
important. the way to go! posts. It is designed to prevent what
A few rules apply to all of our lists. So no personalized attacks are often happens in no-limits lists, that just
The most important is mutual respect allowed against individuals or sections one or two individuals with a lot of time
and avoidance of insults directed at of the group, whether targets are named on their hands post massive numbers of
persons or groups of persons on our lists. or can be easily inferred. Ideas may be emails and drive most people away.
Mockery and put-downs are also strongly criticized or disagreed with, but persons Try to be concise and avoid rambling.
discouraged. Adversarial style – eg point- should always be treated with respect. Reliable research shows that shorter
by-point refutation – may sometimes Please also try to avoid racist, sexist, letters are far more likely to be read
be necessary on the Ideas or Pantheist_ obscene or foul language. Remember we than longer ones. Also turn off your email
Spirituality lists, but hopefully rarely. have members aged between 13 and 93 program’s options for automatic quoting

E thos: Generally write your messages


in the tone you would talk to friends.
so consider your content and language
accordingly.
or posting HTML along with text – these
massively pump up volume without
Assume that all your readers, even if
they disagree with you, are intelligent,
sensitive people who have joined the WPM
P rivacy issues: We know that our
members’ value their privacy, and
we will defend it vigorously. So please
adding to content, and make lists harder
for people to read.
To complain about a rule breach or
because they want to interact positively don’t cite people’s private posts to the private mail harassment, please email
with like-minded folk. list without the author’s permission. listadmin@pantheism.net.
Experience has shown that adversarial Don’t send private mails to other list
12
Pan Magazine Autumn 2007

WPM joins the top ten groups


saving wildlife habitat
The World Pantheist Movement recently moved into the top ten of all
groups saving land at EcologyFund, taking over tenth position from
the Green Party. We have also saved more than WWF and Sierra Club
supporters or any other environmental organization!
We have been the biggest land saver among just the religious groups
for quite some time - we save more than Buddhists, Catholics, Unitarians,
and than the largest pagan group. Our group now has 306 members and
has saved almost 53 acres. We have saved an additional 75 acres through
sponsorship of click schemes. Most of this land is rainforest brought
under the protection of conservation organizations in Central America.

Why does this matter?


If the state of the planet bothers you, then this a contribution that makes
a really worthwhile difference. It costs half a minute of your time per
day. It’s not an alternative to greening up your life but it’s a valuable
addition. Each person who clicks the buttons every day, at the current
total of 63 sq ft per day, can save at least half an acre of wildlife habitat
per year from development or exploitation. That’s almost 22,000 sq ft
- half a small soccer pitch. Rainforest is the most biodiverse habitat on
earth. Just one acre contains around 300-400 individual trees of 20 to 80
different species, and each tree is home to thousands more species. The
photograph on this page show some of the hundreds of plants growing
up a single huge tree in Costa Rica, each one with their own attendant
court of fungi and animals. One tree in Peru was found to house 43
different species of ant. There are benefits for the climate as well as for
biodiversity. If this area were cleared for farming, which it might well be
if not protected, it could emit up to half a year’s average carbon dioxide
emissions of an American – or a year’s worth for a European. So your
daily clicking is helping to prevent that from happening.

How can it be that easy to save land?


After you click on a button, you are shown the next page which includes
ads for eco-friendly companies and non-profits. The payments from
these advertisers go to fund nature conservation organizations. These
organizations in turn spend the funds on buying up private land in
sensitive areas to dedicate in perpetuity to wildlife habitat. Basically
then your clicking is stimulating organizations and companies to spend
money on conserving wildlife habitat.
The World Pantheist Movement has direct experience that this
works, because we advertise with EcologyFund from time to time.
When we advertise, our check is made out to and posted directly to the
conservation organization we wish to sponsor – in our case it has been
the World Land Trust USA. EcologyFund does not take a percentage cut.
World Land Trust undertakes to preserve one acre of habitat for every
$100 donated.

Why is the WPM so keen on this?


For the WPM, preserving the diversity of life has always been a top
priority. As our belief statement says:
We are an integral part of Nature, which we should cherish,
revere and preserve in all its magnificent beauty and diversity.
Conserving wildland is also a survival issue for millions of humans
threatened by sea level rise or climate change. Being in a team that can
show visible collective results is a motivator to stick at it and not forget.
It gives the excitement and satisfaction not only of your own totals but
also those of the group.
13
Pan Magazine Autumn 2007

Some projects funded via EcologyFund’s click site


Rare green sea turtle,
protected by an
EcologyFund sponsored
project in Tanzania

• Jocotoco Reserve in Ec-


uador (home to nearly
1,600 species of birds)
• Reserva Comunal Tam-
shiyacu-Tahuayo in the
Peruvian Amazon, home
to pink river dolphin,
manatee, jaguar, ocelot,
margay, giant otter, and over 700 • Mkwaja-Saadani National Park in Among the large mammals found are
bird species. Tanzania, East Africa, a project to pur- the rare Roosevelt sable antelope, wil-
• Sabalillo Forest Reserve in Peru chase a 280 sq km ranch and donate it debeest, zebra, and eland, and beaches,
– with diverse habitats such as to the Tanzanian Government. The park elephants, buffaloes, large antelopes,
flooded forest, upland forest and contains a mosaic of distinctive and and the very rare Giant Brown Bat.
sandy ridges which shelter many rare habitats including five woodland In each case EcologyFund chan-
extremely rare species. types, two forest types, coastal thicket, nels the donations through respected
• Atlantic Rainforest of Paraguay, scrub, grassland, wetlands, saltmarsh- conservation charities including the
home to more than 310 species of es and mangroves, along with one of World Land Trust, the Rainforest Con-
bird and 40 species of large mam- the last significant breeding beaches servation Fund, and Rainforest2Reef
mal. in East Africa for the green sea turtle. (formerly friends of Calakmul).

Support WPM’s cause


at Facebook
When Facebook opened itself up
to developers earlier this year, one
of the best new applications was
Causes, which allows people to
sign up for their favorite causes,
spread these to their friends, and if
they are so moved, donate.
Very soon after this became
possible the WPM set up a cause
to sponsor our advertising at
EcologyFund. Each $100 we
collect helps the World Land Trust
to preserve 1-2 acres of wildlife
habitat, depending on the region.
Causes includes a built-in
mechanism for secure payments.
You can check out and donate to
this cause at http://apps.facebook.
com/causes/view_cause/4632

14
Pan Magazine Autumn 2007

Make sure your landsaving clicks add up


We know for sure than a very tomorrow.
significant proportion of people If these measures don’t work, How to join our
who are clicking are not getting maybe your cookie has been Save Rainforest group
the credit of that for themselves deleted or messed up.
or for World Pantheism. Then you have a few extra steps 1. Register with Ecology Fund
The reason lies with cookies. to take. Bear with us here, this 2. Join the WPM group.
EcologyFund uses cookies stored is all worth while. Ask a friend [Scroll down to us, click JOIN]
on your computer to confirm who to do this for you if you have 3. Start clicking and clocking land. Make the Save
you are, and to link up your daily computer-phobia. Land page your first Web visit of each day.
clicks with your EcologyFund 1. Delete the EcologyFund 4. Remember to keep clicking.
identity. They need this so they cookie. Make Ecologyfund your home page so it’s there first
can add your clicks to your own Internet Explorer: Go to Tools/ thing every time you go on the Internet, or make a
total and that of the group you Internet Options/General/ bookmark.
belong to. Without the cookie, Under “Browsing history” 5. If you think you might forget, write to
your clicks will still save land – Choose Settings/View Files info@EcologyFund.com to ask for a daily email
so you are not wasting your time Sort by site, find ecologyfund. reminder.
- but they will not count towards com or www.ecologyfund. Visit our page for the links:
your own achievements or the com and delete all ecologyfund http://www.pantheism.net/EcologyClick.htm
WPM’s. In this era of firewalls cookies. OK out of all the
and browser security settings dialogue boxes.
and ad and popup blockers, it’s Firefox: Go to Tools/
very easy indeed for cookies to Options/Privacy, click on the
get disabled or deleted. So it’s “Show Cookies” button, find
really worthwhile for everyone ecologyfund and delete all
to check regularly that things ecologyfund cookies. Close out
are as they should be. Here’s of all the dialogue boxes.
information on what you should 2. Re-register with
see if everything is working
properly – and how to put it right
EcologyFund
Just your name and email.
WPM membership: Join or Renew
if it’s not. Make sure you use the same The World Pantheist Movement depends on the generous sup-
Check regularly that your email you used when you first port of its members to sustain, improve and expand its activities
clicks are counting registered. Click the “Register” and services. If you would like to join or renew by check in US $,
button down at the bottom. please fill in the form below and mail check and form to us. Oth-
Look in the left-hand pane on the
3. When it tells you you are erwise please renew at http://members.pantheism.net/imdms/
Save Land page.
registered, MAKE SURE you or join at http://www.pantheism.net/join.htm
Everything is good if you can see
Please tick as applicable if this is an address change and if you
● Your name and totals under click on the link “Click here to
wish us to correct the database entry for you.
under “My EcologyFund”, return to Ecologyfund’s home
● The WPM name and totals page to begin free donations.”
Name
under “My Group Info,” and This is VERY important.
Address 1
● They both increase each time 4. If the above steps don’t
you click on the save buttons. work, make sure your Address 2
If not, then try these browser allows cookies from City
remedies EcologyFund.
State etc
● Allow EcologyFund to set a Internet Explorer: Go to
Tools/Internet Options/Privacy/ Zip code
persistent cookie.
● Don’t set your browser to Sites, paste or type in http:// Country
www.ecologyfund.com/ and
delete all cookies when you exit. New? Yes No
● Are you registered at click Allow and OK.
Firefox: Go to Tools/ Change it? Yes I’ll do it
EcologyFund and signed up for
Options/Privacy, click on
the WPM group? (See “How to Membership level:
join?” above) the Exceptions Button,
paste or type in http://www. Basic ($30) Family ($60) Low Income ($12)
● Are you logged in? Check the
left hand pane. ecologyfund.com/ and click Other amount
● Did you already click in the Allow and Close.
last day? Bear in mind that If all else fails Please mail this form with your check (US $ only) to:
EcologyFund’s “day” may not Write to World Pantheist Movement
coincide with yours and try again webmaster@EcologyFund. P.O. Box 103, Webster, NY 14580, USA
15
Pan Magazine Autumn 2007

Calendar & Almanac


Special Equinoxes
events & Solstices

November January Winter solstice


1 All Souls/Day of the Dead 11 International Laughter Day December 22 06:08
16 International Day for 16 Martin Luther King Jr. Day
Tolerance Religious Freedom Day Spring Equinox
21 World Television Day 22 Surrender of Native lands by March 20 05:48
[Switch it Off] Chief Seattle
24 Spinoza born [1632]
30 John Toland born [1670]
Full Moons
November 24 14:30
December December 24 01:16
1 World AIDS Day January 22 13:35
2 International Day for the February 21 03:30
Abolition of Slavery
3 International Day of All times Universal time =
Greenwich Mean Time
Disabled Persons
10 Human Rights Day
25 Birth of Isaac Newton [1642]
29 International Day for
Biological Diversity

In Memoriam Sondra Lebost


On behalf of the whole WPM we would like to offer our sincere condolences to Barry Lebost on the loss
of his wife Sondra, and our gratitude for the generous donation of $500 for a posthumous membership in
her memory.
With Barry’s agreement we will be using this donation to sponsor an ad with EcologyFund.
This amount will sponsor the saving of at least 5 acres of wildlife habitat –
some of the sponsored projects are described on page 14.

Neither the WPM nor Ecologyfund take any percentage from the donation,
which therefore serves a triple purpose:
1. Making people aware of pantheism and the WPM
2. Helping to keep the EcologyFund site going and encouraging
people who click to think about conservation every day
3. Protecting private wildland from development
and preserving it forever as wildlife habitat.

Barry has also become one of our seven life members, joining
René Lawrence, Walt Mandell, James Poole, Loren Salmonson, Peter Schogol and Phillip Steinbachsl

16

You might also like