Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1
Pan Magazine Autumn 2007
that are only just beginning to be investigated. Among moths from the light.
artificial light interferes with mating, dispersal, and migration. It Artificial light can change whole ecosystems. In the ocean
diverts moths into traffic, and burns or desiccates moths that fly many creatures descend to lower depths in daylight hours, to
into lamp housings. One of the best-known effects is on hatching avoid predation, and rise again at night. Many zooplankton forage
sea turtles. They normally head towards the sea, which under near the surface during dark conditions. Artificial light can reduce
normal conditions will be lighter, while things in land are darker. their rising, which may result in population increases in the algae
With artificial lights land is lighter they normally eat, leading to algal blooms.
and sea darker, so the turtles head What you can and cannot see
inland - towards predatory gulls
and roadways with traffic. Excellent Zodiacal light and zodiacal band visible; M33 directly visible to naked-eye; many
dark sky Messier globular clusters are distinct naked-eye objects; Sagittarius region of
Some animals use changed site the Milky Way is complex and casts obvious shadows on the ground; clouds
light levels to their advantage. visible only as dark holes
Harbor seals congregate under Rural sky Near horizon, light pollution is evident and clouds are illuminated; the Milky Way
lights to eat juvenile salmon as still appears complex; M33 is visible with averted vision; nearer surroundings
they migrate downstream. Crows are vaguely visible.
prefer to roost near lights, where Rural/ Light pollution domes are visible in various directions over the horizon; Milky Way
they can spot owls. Artificial light suburban above the horizon is still impressive, but lacks most of the finer details; clouds
has important effects on predator- transition are illuminated in the directions of the light sources, but still dark overhead.
prey relationships. Moths and Suburban The Milky Way is very weak or invisible near the horizon and looks washed out
other insects such as lacewings, sky overhead; artificial light sources are visible in most, if not all, directions; clouds
are noticeably brighter than the sky.
beetles, bugs, caddisflies, crane
flies, midges, hoverflies, wasps, Bright The Milky Way is visible only near the zenith; the sky within 35° of the
and bush crickets are attracted suburban horizon glows grayish white; clouds anywhere in the sky appear fairly bright;
sky surroundings are easily visible.
to lights and may be killed by
the heat, or exposed to higher Suburban/ The entire sky has a grayish-white hue; strong light sources are evident in all
urban directions; Milky Way is invisible; M31 and M44 may be seen with the naked eye,
predation by bats and insect- transition but very indistinct; clouds are brightly lit; even in moderate-sized telescopes
eating birds. Light may affect the brightest Messier objects are only ghosts of their true selves.
reproductive behavior - frogs in
City sky The sky glows white or orange - you can easily read; even with a telescope, only
one study stopped mating during a few bright Messier objects can be detected; stars forming familiar constellation
nearby night football games. Male patterns may be weak or completely invisible.
choruses tuned up again only Source: Simplified from Bortle Dark-Sky Scale, Wikipedia
when the frogs were shielded
3
Pan Magazine Autumn 2007
4
Pan Magazine Autumn 2007
Star-friendly lighting
Many modern outdoor light fitments
direct the light where it’s wanted,
and keep it away from where it’s not
wanted. Usually this involves fairly
simple techniques like shades that
point the light downwards, or in a
limited pool, rather than through all
azimuths and all degrees. When light
goes only where it’s wanted, much less
light is required to do the job, resulting
in savings in cost, energy use, and
greenhouse gas emissions.
These four light fitments are produced
©Hubbell Incorporated
find a parking place or darkness! We then resorted to an oppressed by a night sky that is actually or effectively
incomplete subdivision lacking street or home lights and closed in by a cloud deck, as if we were fogged in and
had a beautiful head-on view of the incoming meteors. thereby prevented from leaving harbor. A view of the
Of course that subdivision has since been completed and infinite is something we all treasure and from which we
would be brightly lit at this point. draw endless pleasure and inspiration. We are willing to go
Increasing light pollution and sub/urbanization are far out of our way to find places where we get that view, in
rapidly consuming the dark skies that have been a source place of the glow of nearby civilization. It is equivalent in
of inspiration, information, and meditation for humankind some sense to the climbing of a mountain at the seashore,
since our appearance on Earth. Instead of studying the skies from which we can obtain a commanding view of all
as we guard our flocks at night, we now deploy more and reality. Dark skies are valued because bearing witness to
more lights in hopes of deterring vandals as we sleep under the infinite is a spiritual experience. Perhaps this speaks of
roofs, behind blinds and draperies. We have to place our a universal pantheism of the human heart, widely felt if not
telescopes in space, or in the few clear spots on the ground acknowledged. In Carl Sagan’s words, from the shores of
where (so far) light pollution is not a factor. Cameras on the cosmic ocean:
these telescopes bathe us in views of the universe that are “Our feeblest contemplations of the Cosmos stir us.
far more revealing than the human eye could ever be in There is a tingling in the spine, a catch in the voice, a
both sensitivity and detail. And rather than the stars, we use faint sensation, as if of a distant memory, of falling from
GPS systems to navigate in these days of cheap complex a height. We know that we are approaching the greatest
devices. Why then should we care about our loss of dark of mysteries...We are made of star stuff... Some part of
night skies? our being knows that is from where we came. We long to
It seems universal that humans feel somewhat return... We are a way for the Cosmos to know itself.”
7
Pan Magazine Autumn 2007
At France’s Mont
St Michel, light
illuminates buildings
tastefully but does
not stray beyond
their margins.
10
Pan Magazine Autumn 2007
Choosing your lists Ideas list: This list is mainly for discussing pantheist and
related beliefs, and also discusses science, ethics, philosophy
and comparative religion related to a reverent naturalistic
In the first few years of our existence, we used to have life-view. These are topics where opinions may differ, and
just one list for everything from philosophical and scientific where people may challenge each other’s ideas. It’s a
ideas to feelings and experiences, poems and ceremonies. list primarily for people in sympathy with the WPM belief
This “Big List” started out with 35 members and eventually statement: people who feel a deep religious reverence for the
grew to almost 1000. But there was one big problem that universe and nature, who generally do not believe that mind
kept recurring every few weeks. Debates on political and and matter are two separate substances, or that supernatural
philosophical issues would get heated, two or three individuals phenomena exist. If you want to challenge these viewpoints,
would start baiting each other, a fight would break out, then the place to do that is the Pantheist_Spirituality list
everyone else would go silent, and good feelings and sharing where you will find more supporters for alternative versions
would vanish. This interfered seriously with our efforts to of pantheism. Here too we encourage people to be friendly,
build up a community spirit. So we divided the Big List into cooperative and constructive. Since ideas can only be
two – one for the kind of topic that led more frequently into developed if debated, be prepared, if you raise a pet idea, for
adversarial debate (the Ideas list), the other for sharing someone else to offer a (hopefully constructive) critique.
feelings and discussing pantheist living (the Community list.) Pantheist_Spirituality: This list was the first generic pantheist
These days we have four major lists and one safety valve forum on the Internet. Although the WPM set it up, it is for
list. Each has its own special niche. Here’s a brief guide to all types of pantheist to communicate and share experiences
give you some idea of which list to choose for your post, or and ideas. This is the place to post if you don’t agree with
which you might be interested in reading. You can belong to the WPM’s form of pantheism. There are natural/scientific
all four. pantheists there along with dualists and so on. For that reason
However many you belong to, cross-posting between there may be disagreements at times. As always we encourage
the lists is not a good idea. We do this only for WPM-wide people to remain respectful, and this list usually is.
news, to make sure everyone sees it. There is a considerable Intro list: Our only fully moderated list, this is for people
amount of overlap in membership, so a large proportion of interested in getting to know the ideas and practices of the
people will see the same post twice. People may cross-post WPM before becoming supporting members. All posts are
their replies. And finally, cross-posting blurs the distinctions moderated, and there are a number of experienced WPM
between the lists and confuses everyone. It’s best to get to members who can discuss pantheism and answer questions.
know the differences between the lists and to choose the most Hot Topics list: This list is a kind of safety valve where high
appropriate list. If it’s a borderline subject, ask yourself: is pressure steam can be let off. It fused three of our prior lists:
this likely to create adversarial debate? If so, then post to the Politics, WPMVocabulary and the adversarial aspects of our
Ideas or Spirituality lists. vegetarian lists. Hot Topics covers two kinds of topics:
Community List: This list is for sharing experiences and Those that often generate an unusual amount of heat, such
feelings about nature, discussing everday problems of as vegetarianism v meat eating or discussion of national or
pantheist living, suggesting ways of celebrating life’s stages international political issues and political systems. [Note:
and the seasons, inspirational quotes, and developing the as a charity the WPM may take positions on issues core to
World Pantheist Movement and its local groups. As it’s title us, but we do not endorse any particular political group or
implies, this is the place where we stress community and candidate.]
cooperation and sharing rather than adversarial debate. We ● Those that have come up dozens of times on the Ideas list
emphasize mutual respect, sharing and patient listening to and that frequently hinge on the definition of terms, such as
each other, warmth rather than heat. We want everyone to “Is pantheism a philosophy or a religion?” or pantheist usage
feel totally safe to post without anxiety, regardless of age, of the word “God.”
gender or level of education.
11
Pan Magazine Autumn 2007
How list moderation works moderators must agree. If not, then they bring the case to
the moderators’ committee which consists of all the main
Our lists have different levels of moderation. The Ideas list list moderators, and a majority decision there decides the
is not moderated at all, except for a limit of two posts per appropriate action.
day of 130 lines or less. This limit is enforced robotically by
the software – if you exceed these your post will not get in. How we deal with rule breaches
So please post in text only, not in HTML, and please don’ t Moderation is usually very light. Off-topic stuff gets in, as
quote the whole of the digest you are replying to. long as there is some kind of link with pantheism. When
All our other lists are at Yahoo groups and they are set someone violates the more important rules – usually the
to moderate new members for a few months – Yahoo’s soft- one against insults - we follow a set procedure. We send
ware decides how long. That’s because there are tons of a private informal and friendly warning to the person con-
spammers out there, many of them automated, who keep cerned. Most people respect these. However, a few people
pouring in with new IDs and when allowed post a message do not. If they repeat the behavior, then they get a formal
every day. Lists with no moderation quickly get flooded warning, also in private. Any breach following the formal
with spam. For everyone who is past this introductory warning may lead to the person being set to moderated, or
period, the Community list and the Pantheist Spiritual- in extreme cases (which are very rare) they may be sus-
ity list, like the Ideas list, are not moderated before the pended from all our lists. We don’t discuss specific cases
event. That provides freedom of expression, but it also in the lists to avoid embrarrassment. However we may is-
brings risks. A few times a year someone comes along who sue a very generalized reminder to the list about the rel-
just can’t stop themselves insulting or mocking or putting evant rules. If the person concerned discusses the modera-
down other people. That kind of behavior is not compat- tion in the list, then we will respond to that in the list.
ible with a friendly environment where people feel safe.
Mailing List Active moderators
Who moderates
Each of our major lists has at least Ideas (pantheism-l@listser.aol.com) Eljay Love-Jensen, Tom Moore
two moderators (see box) to make WPMCommunity@yahoogroups.com Tom Moore, Sharon Wells
sure that pending messages are dealt Pantheist_Spirituality@yahoogroups.com Paxdora, Sharon Wells
with promptly. For any stage beyond Pantheism_Intro@yahoogroups.com Eljay Love-Jensen, Paul Harrison
informal warning, or if either has
WPMHotTopics@yahoogroups.com Elay Love-Jensen, Paxdora
doubt about an informal letter, both
14
Pan Magazine Autumn 2007
Neither the WPM nor Ecologyfund take any percentage from the donation,
which therefore serves a triple purpose:
1. Making people aware of pantheism and the WPM
2. Helping to keep the EcologyFund site going and encouraging
people who click to think about conservation every day
3. Protecting private wildland from development
and preserving it forever as wildlife habitat.
Barry has also become one of our seven life members, joining
René Lawrence, Walt Mandell, James Poole, Loren Salmonson, Peter Schogol and Phillip Steinbachsl
16