You are on page 1of 16

Issue 21 Spring/Summer 2008

Faiths and Nations


I n May the World Pantheist Movement’s board of directors
voted 12:0 (with one abstention) that the WPM should be-
come associated with Americans United for the Separation
central to our naturalistic view of the Universe and Nature,
not only because it fits the scientific facts best, but also be-
cause it describes how living things have come to harmonize
of Church and State (AU - www.au.org). with the environment of living and non-living things that sur-
We have already been involved with AU before, over the rounds them. When people who believe the literal creation
Supreme Court case in which Michael Newdow objected to accounts in the Bible use political power to try to suppress
schoolchildren being asked to recite the US pledge including teaching of evolution or to introduce teaching of intelligent
the words “one nation under God.” In that case we submitted design “theory,” they are using the state to spread the beliefs
a friend of court brief. of their church and putting obstacles in the way of science
Our association with AU does not imply any degree teaching. That goes counter not only to the rights of Panthe-
of subordination. It’s basically an expression of solidarity ists and other non-Bible-based groups – it also infringes all
and shared goals - it means that we are aligned and allied as children’s rights to modern education (see Pan issue 14).
far as our commitment to church-state separation goes. We These issues are also closely linked to our commitment
can draw upon their resources and speakers, and in return to wider human rights. The right to religious freedom and
we will circulate (via the WPM Action to non-discrimination on the basis of religion is
list) their materials, and encourage enshrined in key United Nations legal docu-
awareness of this issue as it exists in ments. The Universal Declaration of Human
the US and also in other countries. Rights (1948) states that:
The level of church-state separa- §18. Everyone has the right to freedom
tion that’s feasible is sometimes ex- of thought, conscience and religion; this
aggerated. For example, it’s probably right includes freedom to change his reli-
unrealistic to expect people to keep gion or belief, and freedom, either alone
their religious beliefs completely out or in community with others and in public
of politics. Religion relates to and or private, to manifest his religion or belief
inspires people’s deepest values, and in teaching, practice, worship and observ-
these values are going to influence ance.
what policies they favor, and what Church-state links create problems for these
politicians they will vote for. Panthe- religious rights. They are most commonly sup-
ists would be very likely to favor policies to protect nature, pressed in countries with an official state religion. This is the
just as strongly as some Christians favor policies to ban gay case in some Islamic countries with very restricted freedom
marriage or to severely restrict abortions. However, a criti- for religious minorities – and was the case in many commu-
cal threshold is crossed when people use the state to impose nist countries where the official ideology was atheist, and all
their beliefs on others, or to restrict the rights of people who religions faced some degree of restriction or harassment.
disagree with them. In theory, religious freedoms can be protected for minor-
Freedom of religion and separation of church and state ity beliefs even where there is no clear separation of church
have been important for the World Pantheist Movement from and state – in countries with an established state church, like
the beginning – as our belief statement says: Norway or England, people from other religions are free to
We uphold the separation of religion and state, and teach, practice, worship and observe.
the universal human right of freedom of religion. However, established official religions usually enjoy
The promotion of this value is important to our love of powers and privileges that are not shared by minority be-
nature and our respect for science. The theory of evolution is liefs. Such discrimination in favour of one particular religion
Pan Magazine Sping/Summer 2008

is in direct conflict with the spirit of some other provisions non-theistic or atheistic beliefs such as Buddhism, Panthe-
of the UN human rights instruments, which promote the ism or Humanism. The effect is to make non-theists feel as if
principle of non-discrimination. Most of these provisions are in some way we do not “belong” or are excluded.
modelled on this clause of the Universal Declaration of Hu- Some public services are available preferentially to people
man Rights: of faith. Some of the most blatant examples of this are the
§2. Everyone is entitled to all the rights and freedoms military chaplain services. US Air Force chaplains work un-
set forth in this Declaration, without distinction of der the slogan “Glorifying God, Honoring Airmen, Serving
any kind, such as race, colour, sex, language, reli- All.” US Army chaplains have the official mission “to bring
gion, political or other opinion, national or social God to Soldiers and Soldiers to God” and they “serve both
origin, property, birth or other status. God and country by bringing their unique gifts with which
Other rights relate, for example, to the right to stand for po- they are endowed by God, to the Soldiers of our nation.”
litical office regardless of religious beliefs. The International These precepts lead to an ethos where it seems permissible
Covenant On Civil And Political Rights (1966) states: for Christian pastors to try to convert soldiers, or to criticize
§25. Every citizen shall have the right and the op- Pantheist, Humanist, or Pagan beliefs. In some institutions
portunity, without any . . . distinctions . . . and with- there have been instances of officers putting overt pressure
out unreasonable restrictions: (a) To take part in the on soldiers to convert or to join in public Christian worship.
conduct of public affairs, directly or through freely All these abuses demonstrate the continued determina-
chosen representatives; (b) To vote and to be elected tion of powerful religious groups to use the state to advance
at genuine periodic elections which shall be by uni- the cause of their own religion, to impose their religion on
versal and equal suffrage and shall be held by secret others, or to deny the full range of equal rights to minority
ballot, guaranteeing the free expression of the will religions. That is why we need organizations like the AU
of the electors; (c) To have access, on general terms in America, or the National Secular Society in the UK, that
of equality, to public service in his country. maintain vigilance to look out for abuses and to combat them
The UN Declaration On The Elimination Of All Forms where they exist. That is why the WPM strongly backs these
Of Intolerance And Of Discrimination Based On Religion organizations in their essential work.
Or Belief (1981) proclaims that:
§2.1 No one shall be subject to discrimination by
any State, institution, group of persons, or person on
grounds of religion or other beliefs. §2.2. . . . The
expression “intolerance and discrimination based
on religion or belief” means any distinction, exclu-
sion, restriction or preference based on religion or
belief and having as its purpose or as its effect nul-
lification or impairment of the recognition, enjoy-
ment or exercise of human rights and fundamental Faithful to God, we’re serving
freedoms on an equal basis. on the battlefield today.
Religious restrictions on public office in the UK and Embracing the cause of righteousness,
in Norway are clearly in conflict with the UN instruments: we’re marching on our way!
some offices, such as the monarchy, are not available on an Soldiers of God! We serve Him faithfully!
“equal basis.” And march, in His Name, through thunder and flame,
Even where there are legal guarantees to prevent church wherever the call may be.
interference in the state, religions can infiltrate public insti- Trusting in God, His Strength we lean upon!
tutions in many different ways. As into the fight, the Legions of Light,
the Soldiers of God march on!
In the USA, for example, the First Amendment to the
We are there as the chaplains of the Nation
constitution decrees that “Congress shall make no law re- Everywhere with our fighting congregation!
specting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free Serving the LORD, and serving
exercise thereof.” And yet the currency carries the slogan the cause of humanity!
“In God we trust,” and the Pledge of Allegiance contains the Onward we go, ‘til victory is won!
words “One Nation under God.” For justice and right, the Legions of Light,
These measures have escaped being banned by the Su- the Soldiers of God...Soldiers of God...
preme Court because they it has been ruled that they don’t Soldiers of God...March on!
establish any one particular religion or sect – however, they
do establish monotheism as the belief system of the USA, [Official emblem and song of the US Army Chaplaincy]
thereby favoring Abrahamic religions over polytheistic,

2
Pan Magazine Spring/Summer 2008

The AU outlines its major issues


Church Politicking to be married in a house of worship, marriage itself is ultimately
As tax-exempt entities, houses of worship may address political a civil institution; access to it should not be defined or limited
and social issues, but federal tax law bars most non-profit groups because of religious strictures.
from endorsing or opposing candidates for public office. Pulpit- Religion In Public School
based electioneering not only violates federal law, many believe it Because public schools serve children from different religious
corrupts the true mission of our faith communities. and philosophical backgrounds, the classroom is an inappropriate
It is not the job of religious leaders to tell people which candidates place for school-sponsored worship. School officials should not
to vote for or not vote for. prescribe prayers or teach religious doctrines, such as creationism,
Defending the courts in the classroom.
Majority vote determines the course of most of our public affairs, Parents are the proper agents to determine what religion, if any,
but some fundamental freedoms, like religious liberty and the their children are exposed to. Public schools have no right to
rights to speak freely and to vote, are never subject to majority usurp parental authority by imposing religion on schoolchildren.
vote because political majorities can deny minorities’ equal rights. Mandatory prayer, Bible reading or other religious activities
Courts are especially important in protecting religious minorities sponsored by public schools are fundamental violations of the
from politically powerful religious majorities. In order to protect right of conscience. Public school students have the right to pray
this sacred liberty, however, judges and justices must respect on their own in a non-disruptive fashion, and schools may teach
church-state separation. AU works to make sure judicial nominees about religion as a part of objective instruction, but public schools
will uphold this principle before they are appointed to the bench. must not sponsor religious worship. That job belongs to America’s
Lawmakers who disagree with some church-state decisions have houses of worship.
tried to pass laws barring cases on the Pledge of Allegiance and Aggressive religious pressure groups are pushing school boards
government-sponsored religion from going to federal court. AU nationwide to change the curriculum to conform to their doctrines.
works to protect a citizen’s right to stop government transgressions Backed by national Religious Right organizations, proponents
in court if necessary. of “intelligent design” seek to drive evolution from the science
Faith based initiatives. classroom and replace it with their interpretation of the Bible. If
The so-called “faith-based” initiative is a euphemism for taxpayer- they succeed, church-state separation and sound science education
supported religion. The initiative funnels taxpayer dollars to may be irreparably harmed.
religious social service providers without adequate safeguards to Religious School Vouchers
prevent proselytism. Americans have the right to support only the religious groups of
Americans in need of social services, such as welfare support, job their choosing. Vouchers and other forms of government aid to
training, emergency shelter and food/clothing supplies, should be religious schools usurp this privilege by forcing all taxpayers to
able to get the help they need without being pressured to take part subsidize indoctrination. Often, religious schools promote sectarian
in religious activities. dogma and take controversial stands on issues such as gay rights,
In addition, these groups try to discriminate in hiring based on the role of women in society and reproductive freedom.
religion even though their programs are publicly funded. In those Taxpayers should not be required to subsidize the spread of
cases where religious groups want to take tax aid to provide relief, religious/moral opinions they may strongly disagree with. Religious
they should first agree to run secular programs and drop all forms organizations are free to sponsor schools, but they should pay for
of religiously based discrimination from their hiring policies. their upkeep. Americans must be free to contribute only to the
In 2006, Americans United challenged the Iowa Corrections religious groups of their choosing.
Department’s support for Charles Colson’s Inner Change, a prison
program that trains inmates in evangelical Christianity. From the AU website: www.au.orgs
Marriage And Sexuality
Opponents of church-state separation, led by the
Religious Right, extol the “traditional” family US views on church-state relations
of a married couple with children. While many Should political leaders rely on religion when making
American families fit this mold, others do not. All decisions?
loving families, regardless of their composition, Yes No
deserve support from government and society. Republicans 62 35
The government should respect American diversity Democrats 27 65
by not imposing one tradition’s narrow view of
marriage and sexuality on the entire country. Should religious leaders try to influence politicians?
The government must not deny adoption, child Yes No
custody and other fundamental rights to families Republicans 48 50
labeled “non-traditional” because of religious bias Democrats 28 71
or narrow interpretations of holy books held by
certain religious believers. The government must 2004-05 data. Source: American Theocracy, Kevin Phillips
also recognize that while many couples choose
3
Pan Magazine Sping/Summer 2008

Models of church-state relations


range from state religions and state churches, to concordats and secular states. It has proved
difficult to find a balance between human rights, non-discrimination and full religious freedoms.

Under Islam, religion and state are closely


linked. Since the time of Mohammed the Islamic community and
the state were considered one and the same – the political ruler was
also the prime spiritual leader.
Islam was relatively tolerant - at least when compared to Chris-
tendom in the Middle Ages. Jews and Christians - “People of the
Book” - were permitted to observe their religions as long as they
paid a special tax, although they were not allowed to proselytize.
Followers of other beliefs – pagans and polytheists – were required
to convert to Islam. Muslims were not allowed to convert away
from Islam, and the punishment for conversion was death.
Today, 27 countries have Islam as their official state religion.
Five of these call themselves Islamic states, in which all laws must
conform with Islamic beliefs. A few countries such as Saudi Ara-
bia – and the Taliban-controlled areas of Afghanistan - still have
religious police or vigilantes who enforce Islamic dress and behav-
ior codes. In a number of Islamic countries today, observance of
non-Islamic religions is permitted in private, but not in public, so
churches, synagogues and other temples are not tolerated.
In Saudi Arabia, Islam is the official religion, and all citizens
must be Muslims. Religious freedom is not recognized or protect-
ed, and basic religious freedoms are denied to all but the state-
sanctioned version of Sunni Islam. Citizens are denied the freedom
to choose or change their religion, and many non-citizens, includ-
ing Muslims, practice their beliefs under severe restrictions. The E church at Easter or Christmas.
Government limits the practice of all but the officially sanctioned Since 1532-34, when Henry VIII broke off relations with the
version of Islam and prohibits the public practice of other religions. Vatican and established the Church of England, the British mon-
In Iran, members of religious minorities, excluding Sunni arch has been titular head of the church and must be a member
Muslims, are prevented from serving in the judiciary and se- of the church. No-one can succeed to the throne if they have ever
curity services, from being elected to representative bodies been a Roman Catholic, or have ever been married to one.
(except for 5 of the 290 seats in Parliament) or from hold- Church-state connections remain extensive in the UK. Coins
ing hold senior government or military positions. Adherents still carry the motto “Fid. Def.” - defender of the faith. Prince
of religious groups not recognized by the Constitution, such Charles stirred some controversy when he declared his goal, as
as the Bahá’ís, do not have freedom to practice their beliefs. future monarch, to be “defender of faiths” not just of one faith.
The Prime Minister still has the power to appoint Church of
Britain is a post-religious society where most
England bishops. Some 26 of the principal bishops have seats in
the legislature as “Lords Spiritual” – making up about 3 per cent
people have their own idiosyncratic spiritual beliefs, outside the
of the 750 lords but probably a higher share of the average attend-
sphere of organized religion. Only 4 percent of people attend
ance and votes.
church on a weekly basis, compared to over 40 percent in the USA.
Faith schools are allowed, and are generously subsidized by
The right to religious freedoms is guaranteed in the European Con-
the State. In fact religious schools make up about one third of all
vention of Human Rights,
schools and account for one quarter of all school places.
which has the force of law O Lord our God arise, Perhaps the most invasive example of church-state interference
in the UK. Scatter her enemies in England and Wales is the obligation (introduced in 1988) for a
It is a surprising anom- And make them fall; “daily act of collective worship” in schools. This must be “wholly
aly that England has an of-
Confound their politics, or mainly of a broadly Christian character.” Heads who feel this
ficially established church,
Frustrate their knavish tricks, is inappropriate for their mix of pupils – for example if they have
the Church of England
(Anglican – the US branch On Thee our hopes we fix, a high proportion of Muslims - have to apply for an exemption. In
God save us all! practice many heads ignore the “broadly Christian” requirement
is known as Episcopa-
and hold multifaith or generically spiritual or ethics-related as-
lian). The C of E is quite a
semblies.
small minority sect – only [From the British
Apart from the National Secular Society and the British Human-
around one million people National Anthem] ist Association, there is very little public protest about the church-
take communion in a C of
state situation. It’s puzzling why this situation has persisted in
4
Pan Magazine Spring/Summer 2008

blatant political interference by Pius XII, who appealed to Italians


not to vote Communist, and excommunicated all Italian Catholics
who were Communist candidates.
From 1948 to 1992, as Italy became increasingly secular, the
Catholic Church was unable to prevent the introduction of divorce
in 1970 and of abortion in 1978, both of which were confirmed by
popular referenda.
The Concordat was revised in 1984. The Catholic Church was
disestablished as the only religion of the state. In 1989, the Consti-
tutional Court pronounced that the state is secular (laico).
Taxpayers pay 0.8 percent of their income tax deductions to
the Catholic Church or other religious or charitable bodies. There
are seven choices including the Lutheran Church and the Jewish
Community, but the Catholic church gets 87 percent of the ap-
proximately Euro 1 billion assessed each year. Half of this pays the
salaries of 39,000 priests, while the rest supports building mainte-
nance, charitable work, etc.
The new Concordat provides for optional religious instruction
in public primary and secondary schools. The salaries of 22,000
teachers of religion are paid by the Italian state and amount to
about Euro 650 million annually. An additional Euro 750 million
per annum are spent on support to Church-run schools and hospi-
tals. It is estimated that the Catholic Church costs Italian taxpayers
some Euro 4 billion annually.
the UK. Certainly, official traditions have a peculiar hold on the The Catholic Church is also very prominent in broadcasting, with
British psyche, long after they have lost their original meaning. religious affairs being reported in the news on the state-owned tel-
Also, the bodies that want to keep the status quo are better organ- evision channels on a scale second only to politics. TV broadcasts
ized and better funded to put political pressure on government. of Papal masses enjoy immense audiences, and television plays
It may also be that politicians consider Anglicans as a clear in- based on the lives of religious personalities are frequently shown.
terest group of voters, who would be much more deeply offended There is little criticism of the Catholic Church on the part
if church privileges were removed, than the irreligious majority of Italian politicians, who bend over backwards to accommodate
would be pleased. Paul Harrison the Church’s views on social issues, including same-sex marriage,
euthanasia and stem-cell research. Catholic symbols such as cru-
cifixes and images of the Virgin Mary are omnipresent in schools,
In Italy, the Bishop of Rome , the Pope, is the hospitals, law courts and other public places. The majority of na-
head of the Catholic Church, and also the head of state of the Vati- tional public holidays are religious holidays, not to mention local
can City, located in the heart of Rome. celebrations of the patron saints of every town and village.
For many centuries, the Pope was the temporal ruler of Rome Few Italians believe that the State is truly secular when the
and the Papal States, which were absorbed into Italy in 1870. In Catholic Church exercises such influence over politics, education,
1929, under Mussolini, the Lateran treaties regularized relations the media and the everyday lives of citizens. Tor Myrvang
between Italy and the

France and Turkey are both secular


Holy See. They remain in
force today. They estab- Brothers of Italy, repub-
lics and have constitutions which state this explicitly.
lished the Vatican State, Italy has awoken . .
financial compensation Both countries have enforced bans on the wearing of religious
Where is Victory? symbols or apparel in public institutions (including schools and
for the loss of the Papal Let her bow down, universities.) In France a law of 2004 bans the wearing of Islamic
States, and a Concordat
For God has made her hijabs, Sikh turbans, conspicuous Christian crosses and Jewish
which confirmed Catholi-
Rome’s slave. Stars of David in public schools. In Turkey headscarves may not
cism as the state-support-
ed religion of Italy. be worn in schools and universities.
A struggle began in These policies are controversial since they go beyond the state
1948 between the Catho- [From the Italian refraining from endorsing any particular religion – some people
lic Church and the Com- National Anthem] regard them as infringing the individual right to public expression
munist Party of Italy, with of religious beliefs. P.H.
5
Pan Magazine Sping/Summer 2008

Exclusion and inclusion


Members discuss their experiences and views of church-state interaction

M y daughter played basketball for public high school, and


one of the parents (who was a Baptist minister) would say
the Lord’s Prayer with the team in the huddle before each game
This viewpoint is not limited to just the Baptists – it is imbedded
in most of Christendom and some other religions too.
What is the real purpose here? When the final layers are
in the high school gym. stripped from most of the religions the final intent is control. The
Although I wasn’t a pantheist back then, and wasn’t really desire for control is what drives them to enforce their beliefs and
anything in terms of a religious label, that whole thing bothered dogmas on the collective bodies they are a part of. We are not
me and made me uncomfortable. I knew it wasn’t right, that he dealing with a group of people who want to just live beside others
didn’t speak for everyone in that gym, that it was a sporting event peacefully. They seriously want to change others around them by
not a religious one, but I let it slide, never said anything. I would any means necessary, either by pressuring them to believe their
have been in the definite minority in my small southern town in doctrines or by forcing mandates by which others have no choice.
thinking that way. To be honest, I was a coward. I didn’t want to This reminds me of a small exchange between myself and
face the masses and take an unpopular stand. another devoted man of faith sometime back regarding the
I am a different person now, with a different focus and presence of other places of worship near their church. They did
perspective. Defining myself as a pantheist and finding other not like the thought of another church moving in down the street.
pantheists to share with has fired more passion in me about all of I stated that, in the USA, a satanic church had the right to move
the inhabitants of this planet, made me more aware. Being part in down the street. He stated that if such a church were to attempt
of the WPM has given me personally more strength and courage to open down the street they would find it hard to keep their
to stand up for issues - even when I’m the lone ranger within my doors open for their evil services. I was truly taken back by the
community or family. harshness of the comment, but I was not surprised.
I’m so glad the WPM has affiliated with the Americans United I live in the Bible belt. I have dealt with many situations where
for the Separation of Church and State and am proud to be part the Christian faith dictates things in my place of work. I work for
of a group that will take a stand and lend its name to causes that the local city government. We have a small city of 24,000 people,
not only support the environment but also give people choices. I but there are over 65 active churches (that is one church for every
have to decide which issues to put my time and energy into but I 370 people). The majority of people around me are devoted, hard
feel now that my decision comes from a place of knowledge and core Christians. I have been out to lunch with colleagues from
strength and not fear. Even seemingly small issues in a gym in work to discuss work matters and have had to sit through bowing
Sylva, NC, can be important. of heads and giving thanks for the meal. Not a simple dropping of
After seeing what has been done in the name of religion, both the head for a moment of silence to themselves, no we are talking
globally and in my own backyard, the idea of a state-mandated the holding of hands, standing about the table, openly and loudly
religion, any state-mandated religion (even my own), really giving thanks so everyone can hear it.
scares me. Sharon Wells I am constantly questioned on my church of choice or my
faith of convictions, by people who are my higher ups. The
government positions are filled with people who feel that it is

I have been where Sharon was at the ball games many times.
It is a very difficult place to find oneself in. In the USA most
of the time a Pantheist will find they are the minority, and the
their calling to be there and make this city a godly place where
people want to live and work. I recently heard this a recently
hired director state this: “I am here because god has a purpose
majority usually dictates the religious overtones during many for me here. I feel his calling on my heart to make this a great
non-religious events. I have on occasion voiced my opinion, place where people want to work for god.” This individual makes
but this usually resulted in a fight which there was no way of decisions that affect the growth and direction of the city.
winning. The resulting argument from their stand is that they How do you solve this? The only way I can see to approach
have the freedom of speech, the right to express their faith, and this level of infestation is to educate the masses that there are
the freedom from suppression. I have argued that I have the same other forms of non-aggressive religion which are not controlling.
rights, but you do not see me forcing others to be subjected to my Show them that they do not have to subscribe to the faith of their
beliefs. But that is where the real, underlying core of the issue parents just because they feel trapped in traditions. As sad as it is,
comes out. I do not see it possible to bring positive change otherwise.
Mandating the separation of church and state really will T. Staggs
not solve anything. In a semi-heated debate with a devoted
Baptist minister a few years back it was explained to me that
not only was it his god-given call to force his faith on others, it
was the calling of the ‘whole body of Christ’ to take control of
government by either their vote or by their physical presence.
T his was not “state”, but a related situation for me. One
Thanksgiving. I volunteered to say a Grace, and the one I
chose was DELIBERATELY non-denominational, and introduced

6
Pan Magazine Spring/Summer 2008

as such. When I finished, a gentleman next to me added a loud


“In Jesus’ name, Amen!!” I need to see this as being “inclusive”
rather than “having his religion forced upon me and everyone in
W hen I was in high school in SC in the mid 1940s, we began
every morning in Home Room with a brief student-led
“devotional.” When my turn came, I usually read from /The
the room.” It’s a struggle. Linda Kerby Prophet/ by Kahlil Gibran. This wasn’t a problem. Pete Tolleson

I ‘m very glad to live in a nation where the founders, at least,


had a clear idea of how to provide religious freedom. So I
wonder why this aspect of the US constitution has not been more
I lived in Canada when my oldest daughter was in primary
grades, in the 1970s. Her first grade teacher - in a non-sectarian
public school - began the day with a group prayer, which was
widely emulated? France and Turkey seem to be the closest to quite legal. I objected to that, so the teacher said that there was
our constitution at present. Tom Moore only one way that she would allow Liz to be exempt from the

S eparation of Church and State is an appealing political


solution for a country whose population is not homogeneous
in terms of religion, specifically one where compromise between
prayer - she had to go out into the hall during the prayer. The
teacher said that she simply couldn’t have children disobeying
her when she told them to pray.
different religious groups is required for a Federalist solution to We tried that for a bit, but Liz said that the teacher would not
work. call her back in when the prayer was finished and left her out
In countries which do not have a sufficiently religiously there for maybe an hour. I reported that to the principle and it
heterogeneous population, the temptation of the dominant group stopped. The teacher retired after that year. I was really relieved
is to enforce its beliefs and practices on less powerful religious to find that things here had changed by the time I moved back a
(or non-religious) minorities. Why do they do it? Because they few years later.
can get away with it. No political group or powerful religious I remember when they added “under god” to the US Pledge
group is likely to voluntarily relinquish the power to force others of Allegiance. I was attending Sunday School and church
to act (or worship) as it feels the others should do. enthusiastically at that point, but I thought it wasn’t right to put
The problem of religious coercion is particularly severe in the god into the Pledge. I never said it again; I’d stand, but wouldn’t
case of proselytizing monotheistic religions (particularly many say a word or even pretend to. Other people said that it was OK
sects of Christianity and of Islam) which believe that others who because we might all have different religions but we nearly all
believe differently are eternally damned. Such a belief is easily believed in god. But that wasn’t the point, even if it were true.
used in the service of the will to power with the rationale that “we Frankly, I’m dismayed by the prevalence of religiosity in politics
have a sacred duty to persecute the heretics lest their pernicious these days. Religion ought to be private, as long as it doesn’t
beliefs will spread and damn many souls to hell.” Walt Mandell include anything illegal. J. M.

7
Pan Magazine Sping/Summer 2008

Cultivating
Reverence
In her new book Standing in the Light:
My Life as a Pantheist (Basic Books,
$25) WPM member Sharman Apt
Russell offers a spiritual autobiography,
an enlightening exploration of her
thoughts and feelings about Pantheism,
and a personal introduction to many of
the major Pantheist thinkers. In these
exclusive extracts she explores the
tension within her pantheism between
emotion and reason, and talks about her
special relationship with Walt Whitman.

This Saturday morning I am waiting


by the Gila River to meet with biologist friends Mike and Carol and their three-year old son Dominic. Every spring and summer, Mike
and Carol run a bird-banding station at the Gila River, part of a national program with over 500 stations trying to assess what bird species
are breeding where. I am part of this banding crew, which makes me feel absurdly important.
For ten Sundays from May to August, we will set up ten nets and catch birds. We band the birds and write down their species, age, and
sex. We blow on their chests to reveal their sexual parts and brood patch. We weigh them and measure their wings. Mike and Carol do
most of this work, with Carol the go-to person for molt wear, which feathers are missing and which feathers are coming in. This May, we
will also take two tail feathers that researchers elsewhere can check for isotopes, as well as genital swabs so researchers elsewhere can
look for avian flu. I’ve been tagging along for two seasons now and am still only a net-runner, anxiously untangling a Bewick’s Wren,
waiting for Mike to get the Blue Grosbeak with its vicious bite. When all the data is collected from thousands of birds in the Southwest
and thousands more across North America, patterns will begin to emerge: who is surviving, who is not.
Every year we put the long banding table in the same place, under
a large cottonwood tree by a glistening bend of the Gila River. We
meet here today, trying to decide where to put the nets this spring.
According to protocol, all ten nets should be in the same positions
each year. But after last winter’s flood, half the original net sites
are the river. We need new sites, and we talk about that. We feel
anticipatory. These March days will get warmer, the trees will leaf
© Steve Shoup, Big Stock Photo

out, the birds will sing, and we will be at the banding table again.
I am especially anticipatory. Bird-banding mornings are my own
little nature study, trying to identify the call of a flycatcher, tramping
from net to net on the changing river bottom, noting which trees
have finally fallen down, the print of a mountain lion, and the new
patch of four o’clock with its magenta flowers opening clocklike
in the late afternoon. Is the beaver back? Is that a sphinx moth - a
hallucinatory blur in the air, then a focused image pink and white
and black, banded and checkered like an Escher print? The moth
poises before an evening primrose, its heavy body miraculously

8
Pan Magazine Spring/Summer 2008

aloft, its tongue uncurling - impossibly long, like a magician’s scarf.


I marvel at the sphinx moth. I marvel at the Four O’clock (Mirabilis multiflora) whose parts can be made into a tea to treat colic and
eye infection. I marvel, too, that all the plants around me are connected to the human body. Yarrow clots blood. Cottonwood and willow
reduce pain. The tone of my bladder is related to mullein root. My body reflects the chemistry of willow.
I marvel at the complexity. But is all this holy? Does it form a web of life we can call sacred? Or are these things just very interesting?
The tongue of a sphinx moth is half the length of its body. Its abdomen circulates hot blood like a radiator cooling an engine. Great
factoids! Very neat.
I ask Mike and Carol what they think. This is a little delicate. We have been friends for a few years, and now we are neighbors in the
Gila Valley. We laugh and talk easily. We exchange books and tools. But there are gaps in what we know about each other. Our spiritual
beliefs lie within one of those gaps.
Carol surprises me. Before she became a biologist, she studied music and as a young adult once spoke in tongues in a Pentecostal
church, loving God and the warmth of that community. Now she has the same emotions - love and awe and warmth - as strongly and
as wonderfully in nature, in the divinity of the universe. Her image of God has shifted. Her experiences have not. On a recent walk, she
says, she found herself confronted with a great-horned owl who stared at her eye-level, predatory, and somehow numinous. The feeling
was so strong she had to look away. In humility, she had to look away.
Mike claims he is less
emotional than his wife. It is
just his nature, he says. He is
impressed by the scientific ideas
of deep time and evolution and
by the fact that life came out of
matter. He gestures at his son
Dominic, who is leaning against
Carol’s leg and begging to go
home. “Isn’t it amazing,” Mike
asks, “that love itself came out
of matter?”
Mike is a big fan of the nature
writer Thoreau and can quote
passages verbatim. Once as we
walked together along the bird-
banding trail to Net Nine, Mike
quoted this one:
What is it to be
admitted to a museum, to
see a myriad of particular
things, compared with
being shown some star’s
surface, some hard
matter in its home! Talk
of mysteries! Think of our
life in nature - daily to be
shown matter, to come
into contact with it - rocks,
trees, wind on our cheeks!
the solid earth! the actual
world! the common sense!
Contact! Contact!
I look at Mike now, so clearly
© Joe Burgess, Wikimedia Commons

in love with the physical world.


The actual world! The solid
earth!
I look around me. Trees
askew, sandy arroyo, rocks
in the sand, plants growing.
A stretch of river bottom in
southwestern New Mexico.
I can call this sacred, or I can
not. Most religions have it
right: God cannot seem to exist
9
Pan Magazine Sping/Summer 2008

without us. We are made in His image, or


© Iris Abbott, Big Stock Photo

rather He is made in ours - our belief in


the divine defines the divine.
I am involved in a word choice. Sacred
means “holy” or “revered.” In some
dictionaries, the antonym is “unholy”
or “blasphemous.” For my purpose, the
antonym to sacred would be “ordinary”
or even “meaningless.” The middle
ground between sacred and secular is
“fascinating.” How do I want to describe
the world? How do I want to feel about
the world?
Just west of our bird-banding table is
a small archaeological site, a few rooms
once populated by the Salado people
around 1300 A.D. Up and down the Gila
Valley are more ancient sites dating from
the dawn of the first millennium to the
first Apache settlements in the sixteenth
century, a flow of people migrating,
hunting, farming, conquering, and being
conquered. Mostly they stayed by the
course of the river. Mostly their adobe and
rock homes are now bulldozed lumps and
troughs where pot-hunters have looked
too hard for buried treasure - something
old to sell for a good price. Potsherds still
litter these sites, especially after a storm when rivulets uncover new pieces of painted clay.
For much of my life, I have visited places like this, scouted for a sherd, and picked it up - a piece of cooking ware or the zigzag
design of black on white. I have felt something flow down through my body from head to heart to arm to earth. The woman who made
this pot links with me, some 200,000 years ago, when we were hominids together in Africa. The woman who stands here today traveled
through Europe and sailed to the New World as soon as she could build a boat, fished in New England, farmed in the Midwest, ranched
in Colorado, mined in Arizona. The woman who made this pot came by a different route. It is not really that we meet again but that we
have never truly been separate.
Once, visiting the Salado site, I had an experience that some people might call mystical. I felt that connection flow down through
a sherd of clay to soil where billions of bacteria live in one fertile ounce, where Grama Grass and Four O’clock convert sunlight into
energy, where the grasshopper mouse waits in his burrow anxious to come out and hunt pinacate beetles, scorpions, and lizards, throwing
back his head and howling his shrill wolf-like whistle-song.
I felt something flow down into the earth and then flow back up through my body with ten times as many cells as there are stars in the
Milky Way. Ninety percent of these cells are microbial, not human. I call this superorganism myself, six hundred bacterial species in my
mouth alone swimming the mountains and canyons of teeth.
I flowed out through the skull, accelerating faster. Sweat from my forehead evaporated, rose, joined with other molecules, and became
a cumulus cloud. Now I travelled east and south, following desire to tangle in the fur of a coatimundi I once met, a long-tailed, long-
snouted, white-masked relative of the raccoon. This particular bachelor male had been driven away from the matriarchal band where he
had mated with the females. Once they were pregnant, he had to leave, his tail straight up. He chittered and grumped. I left him, too, still
flowing eastward, to Texas, New York, around the globe, everywhere, everything.
How do we define a religious experience like this? People who have shared similar experiences speak of being outside themselves. They
touch something bigger, something more than being Sharman thinking about Sharman’s problems, dealing with Sharman’s insecurities
and Sharman’s vanities. They break through the limits of their life, those particular talents and faults, this father, that mother, this race,
that country, this gender, that body; the time they betrayed a friend; the ragged edge of a cuticle. Who would really want immortality as
yourself? It seems so little and so depressing.
People speak of relationship to the sacred. Perhaps they talk to Him, or Her, and they get an answer. Perhaps they spread out, connected
to everything, part of everyone. They speak to the bacteria and the grasshopper mouse. The important thing is that they are not alone.
People speak of feelings. Awe. Joy. Peace. They are uplifted. Perhaps they are afraid. Hormones cascade, neurons fire. The chest
hollows. The body gets involved.
Was my experience at the Salado site a religious one? Sometimes I think so. Not always. I believe, without doubt, in an interconnected
universe. But any faith I have in a sacred interconnected universe is hard-won. I have to search and struggle. I have to doubt. I have to
cultivate belief. I have to get up early and bird-band. I have to visit ancient sites, wait for floods, be with other believers, form the neural
pathways. I have to be on the alert for the numinous experience. I have to welcome reverence.
10
Pan Magazine Spring/Summer 2008

© Michael Fogden, Bruce Coleman


Walt Whitman is the one I blame the most
for who I am. He brought together mysticism and scientific theory and fused them in a fiery circle. He would allow for no separation,
certainly not the separation of humanity from the natural world. He infected me when I was young and impressionable with his dreams
of democracy and his cries of celebration. His “barbaric yawp” proclaimed that this was our job - to celebrate and be joyous.
I read his long poem Song of Myself like the Book of Psalms. We were all meant to be Walt Whitman, children of the cosmos,
male and female, young and old, plantation owner and slave. Like him, our bodies are made of earth and sidewalk. We spread
sideways into nature. We burrow into people. Animals adorn us. Plants grow in our ears. We have lived a trillion summers and will
live a trillion more. Unlock the doors, unscrew the door jambs, take down the walls! We experience everything. We are everyone.
We go naked and undisguised to the river bank, mad to be in contact with the air which is for our mouth forever. Logic will never
convince. Sermons do not convince. The damp of the night drives deeper.
Walt Whitman urged me to connect with the world, and in 1975, a college student at Berkeley, I thought I could do it standing on a
street corner. I could see the papery trunks of the eucalyptus trees on campus, their sharp medicinal smell, the life of the mind, the life
of the senses, people jostling by. I could make contact, naked and undisguised.
I could do it easily through the cadence of Whitman’s poetry. I am the old artillerist. I am the mashed fireman. I am the captain on
deck. I am the mother of captains. The language was a little archaic, but still, it seemed that I was all those things. And that the bigger
questions about life were answered here or would be answered.

I hear and behold God in every object, yet understand God not in the least,
Nor do I understand who there can be more wonderful than myself.
Why should I wish to see God better than this day?
I see something of God each hour of the twenty-four, and each moment then;
In the faces of men and women I see God, and in my own face in the glass.

Today, re-reading Song of Myself, I am still struck by how well Whitman held the enormity of it in his mind and body, in his hand
and words. He saw God everyday. He understood God not at all. Does he contradict himself? Very well, he contradicts himself. We are
large and contain multitudes. Joy and pain are braided. With broken breast-bone, the mashed fireman lies on the cold earth. Elsewhere,
the judge proclaims the death sentence in a hushed voice. Elsewhere, stevedores shout heavy-e-yo and strong men laugh and homely
11
Pan Magazine Sping/Summer 2008

girls croon to babies. Agonies. Good


Matthew Brady, Library of Congress

times. The procreant urge.


Elsewhere - everywhere - birds,
wheat, whales, cows, and blackberries. A
leaf of grass, the egg of a wren. We are
staggered and triumphant. We are braided
into nature. We are reflected there.
Celebrate every part, mollusk and hat.

Dazzling and tremendous, how quick


the sunrise would kill me,
If I could not now and always send
sun-rise out of me.

In southwestern New Mexico,


we wait for the monsoon season, the
rains that fall in the months of July,
August, and September. Commonly, the
thunderclouds build up in the afternoon,
growing darker and heavier until they
drop their burden like a woman throwing
water from a saucepan, hard and focused
on a few choice spots, with flashes of
lightning to make the humans run to shut
down their computers. We hope to have
rain now in the Gila Valley every day for
some sixty days.
The skies are tremendous, the
clouds huge and masted flat-bottomed
ships. Fleet after fleet set out for
conquest. Majesty embodied. This is
true democracy, beauty for everyone.
You don’t have to be rich or successful
or good. You don’t have to live by the
ocean or in the middle of wilderness.
This is drop-dead gorgeous scenery, the
ephemeral version of prime real estate.
This could be your ticket to a mystical
experience, and the show runs through
the rest of summer, almost every day.
This is a grandeur that most of us, most
of the time, barely notice, looking up and
then away, intent on some errand.
I walk Sacaton Mesa surrounded by
cloud streets, cloud turrets, a small cloud
art museum, cloud doorways arched
and dissolving. It is architecture on the
move. A storm builds in the east. The cloud cliffs grow taller. The prow of a ship crashes into another. Already there is rain over the
Mogollon Mountains, the line clear between where water is falling and where it is not. Already I should turn back and hurry home if I
do not want to get soaking wet.
I feel a correspondence. This beauty is not a doorway into something better. This beauty is my other half. This sky, this majesty, is
my other self. I feel the yearning to reunite, join with the sky. In some way, we reflect each other. I am transparent, and the clouds pass
through me.
In his preface to Leaves of Grass, Whitman prescribed what might have been an idealized biography of his own life:

This is what you shall do. Love the earth and sun and the animals, despise riches,
give alms to everyone who asks, stand up for the stupid and crazy, devote your
income and labor to others, hate tyrants, argue not concerning God, have
patience and indulgence toward the people, take off your hat to nothing known or
unknown, or to any man or number of men - go freely with powerful uneducated
12
Pan Magazine Spring/Summer 2008

persons, and with the young, and with the mothers of families - re-examine all
you have been told in school or church or in any book, and dismiss whatever
insults your own soul; and your very flesh shall be a great poem, and have the
richest fluency, not only in its words, but in the silent lines of its lips and face, and
between the lashes of your eyes, and in every motion and joint of your body.

It is essential Whitman that we move in a long sentence from the earth and sun to the skin between eyelashes. The poet greatly
admired the human body, and although the release of Leaves of Grass in 1855 was first met with praise, critics were soon pointing
in disgust to those passages which celebrated sexuality. The poems were “a mass of stupid filth,” “bombast, egotism, vulgarity, and
nonsense” and the writer “some escaped lunatic, raving in pitiable delirium.”
But Whitman never wavered. In the coming decades, he continued to revise, expand, and republish his poorly-selling manuscript.
He sometimes lived in poverty. He was sometimes depressed, lost in his soul and in his relationships. But he never denied what the
Light whispered to him about the beauty of physical love, the beauty of flesh, the sensuous details of being human.
For a pantheist, it comes down to this: as part of the larger whole, we are called upon to celebrate our existence in the universe, no
matter what and who we are, blessed or not, whole or broken, deserving or undeserving. What is the alternative? We are braided into
pain and joy, darkness and light. We are braided into nature, reflecting the sky. We transcend the material, the everyday, for we know
these things themselves to be transcendent. We are called on to rejoice. Who calls us? We preach to ourselves. A child of the cosmos.
Here we stand.

© Paul Moore, Big Stock Photo

13
Pan Magazine Sping/Summer 2008

New chart of our galactic home

Spizter Space Telescope, NASA


We can admire the Andromeda galaxy of an expansive swath of the Milky Way, Though galaxy arms appear to
three million light years away, and see the stretching 130 degrees across the sky, be stable features, stars are actually
structure of its disc in detail. But it’s much including over 110 million stars. “Now, constantly moving in and out of them as
harder to get a clear view of our own we can fit the arms together with the bar,” they orbit the center of the Milky Way, like
galaxy across the plane of its disc, through said team leader Robert Benjamin, “and waves of vehicles in traffic. Since our sun
deep veils of dust and gas. we can map the structure, position and was formed 4.6 billion years ago, it has
Until the 1990s the Milky Way was width of these arms for the first time.” travelled around the galaxy 16 times.
thought to be a regular spiral with four The new analysis suggests that our “For years, people created maps
star-forming arms, called Norma, Scutum- galaxy has only two major star-forming of the galaxy based on studying one
Centaurus, Sagittarius and Perseus. arms - a common structure for galaxies section of it, or using only one method,”
During the 1990s large infrared sky with bars. The Scutum-Centaurus and says Benjamin. “Unfortunately, when
surveys revealed that it was a barred Perseus arms have the greatest densities the models from various groups were
spiral, with an elongated elliptical bar of of both young, bright stars, and older, red- compared, they didn’t always agree.
stars across the center. giant stars. Spitzer has provided us with a starting
In 2005, a team at the University of Two minor arms, Sagittarius and point for rethinking the structure of
Wisconsin found that the bar extends Norma, are filled with gas and pockets of the Milky Way. We will keep revising
farther out from the center of the galaxy young stars. Our sun lies near a small, our picture in the same way that early
than previously thought. The team now has partial arm called the Orion Spur, located explorers sailing around the globe had to
new imagery from the Spitzer telescope between the Scutum and Perseus arms. keep revising their maps.”
14
Pan Magazine Spring/Summer 2008

Why I am I believe that nature is god.


Nature is who we are and
what is all around us. Nature
am doing the right thing. I am a
Pantheist because I have faith in
humankind to be active stewards
gives us what we need and there of this planet and universe and

a Pantheist is a purpose and reason that


only nature provides. Nature
feel that by joining this religion I
will further that cause.
is beautiful. I do not belive in Bryan McCallister
supernatural entities.
New members write Tabatha Grainger
I believe that all of nature
is collectively holy and if

I can no longer believe in


Christianity but still look for
anything deserves to be called
(metaphorically) God then
I have finally found a “home”
for what I believe in, after all
these years of not having a name
spirituality and have a great love
of nature and a reverence for all
it is nature. I do not believe
in a personal theistic God
life. I need a fresh definition of exist outside of nature. But,
for my feelings and beliefs. I the word God and believe I have I do believe in the religious
can now pass on to my children found one in Pantheism. experience, and that experience
the spirituality of our beliefs Jack Restall is part of what it means to be
with a name and hopefully some human. I seek the religious
customs which we shall develop.
I can teach them with confidence
to revere the beauty and power
I am most at peace when I
am out in my yard or going
through the fields and woods
experience through connecting
with life and nature.
Margaret Lee
of the universe. with my dogs. I have long felt an
Lisa Smith inner peace from simply being
with nature that I never felt in a W e are the only living things
that have the capabilities
I have always felt more at peace
in the forest than in a church.
I have a problem with a god
house of worship. I also strongly
believe in respecting the Earth
to protect and preserve all
other living things and our
and all its inhabitants: animals, environment. This must then be
that punishes a person for being plants, and all other manner of our own defined “purpose” and
human, for doing that which natural objects. I found this site “meaning” for existence. This
seems normal, for following his and realized that there are a lot comes from natural evolution, not
basic instincts, to love whom he of other people out there like me from a supernatural entity. We
chooses. I also find it hard to and appreciate having the chance must acquire the knowledge and
believe a person can influence to communicate with them. the will to fulfill this purpose.
what has been proven to be a D. D. Ted Radamaker
Natural process by praying to
an unseen force. Above all I
believe in freedom and honesty,
something not easily found in the
A few years ago I began
working at a telescope shop
and had my first chance ever to
I love being a part of Gaia.
I have no need for the
supernatural when the natural is
“Church.” look at the sky. Upon peering so exquisite.
George Ball at the stars and the glory of the Carrie-Ann Giles
heavens my life exploded with
I feel that everything is tied, and
I am sometimes brought to my
knees in awe of the beauty of this
new possibilities and a newfound
appreciation for our universe. N one of the popular
theistic hypotheses fit the
My goals in life had changed in observations of science. Most are
world. It angers me when others what seemed like an instant. absurd and some are dangerous
take this world for granted, After attending two years’ college to humankind and our planet.
raping and destroying it. We need majoring in music, I found Whatever the place-card word
to love that which gives us life, that I had achieved a thirst for God means, it seems to me to
the Universe. science and wanted desperately be the ground of existence and
L. C. to open the eyes of mankind to not separate from it. Spiritual
reason and understanding of reality is not something apart
I am a pantheist because in
my experience, simply put,
it’s the only attitude towards
the cosmos. Having withdrawn
from Christianity at an earlier
from natural reality but consistent
with it. And the plain fact is, the
age I have felt like somewhat natural universe is beautiful far
the Universe that makes sense: of an outcast denying Jesus and beyond any theistic daydreams to
reverence, wonder, and deep the Christian concept of God. account for it. The Medieval Age
abiding gratitude for all that is. My family will certainly feel that is over - it is time to move on.
James Anderson I am destined for Hell for my Joseph Maddox
actions today but I know that I
15
Pan Magazine Spring/Summer 2008

S exing up atheism is one of


the best ideas I’ve seen in a
long time. The credo is logically
I feel a very deep and powerful
connection with the natural
world, with the universe if you
A fter some considerable
thought (most of my life)
what else could anyone be but a
intact and allows me degrees of like. The beauty of it all is so Pantheist. It’s the only religious
freedom as an individual. The overwhelming and humbling, yet expression that makes any sense.
quotes by Einstein, Hawkings, more fulfilling to me than any Henry Barrett
Shelley encapsulate the shared doctrine or dogma. “God” is all
wisdom and beliefs of a large,
unspoken group of intelligent
people.
around us and inside us.
L. H. T here seems to be no evidence
for a personal god which
intervenes in human affairs.
P. W.
I have come to the harsh
realization that believing
However, the fact that we are
here and part of an amazingly

I am a spiritual atheist, revering


nature, including spiders,
snakes and rats. I have not
in supernatural religions has
caused and continues to
cause immeasurable pain and
complex and magnificent universe
demands an appreciation and
reverence for nature as a
previously had any group suffering. But, the potential of mysterious and powerful force. I
affiliation that honored these humanity is infinite. Pantheism see myself as pantheist because
values. is a way to give individuals a I equate the divine with nature
Robert Edwards sense of community, while more itself.
importantly, providing a catalyst Matthew Stewart
It offers a religious home where to help individuals come together
my spirit can be nourished in
ways that do not insult my
intelligence.
to work indiscriminately for the
benefit of all humans as well as
care for the world in which we
R eligion has always sent me
a “collect” call, yet nature
continues to hold and teach me
Ernesto Torres live. what truth really is.
R. K. Del Beach

Special Equinoxes
events Calendar & Almanac & Solstices

June August
Summer solstice
5: World Environment Day: 6:   Hiroshima Day - focus on peace
June 20 23:59
        Conserving the environment. 12: Perseid meteor shower:
21: Midsummer Solstice Starwatching
Autumn Equinox
26: Krakatoa day: global tectonics.
September 22 15:44
Harvest (according to location)

July September
4: US Independence Day: democracy 16: UN International Peace Day Full Moons
Bayon Temple © Elena Pokrovskaya

5: Anniversary of supernova that 23: Autumn equinox


created Crab Nebula. June 18 17:30
12: Birthday of Thoreau July 18 07:59
14: Storming of Bastille - liberty, August 16 21:16
equality, fraternity September 15 09:13
20: Moon landing day (1969)
All times Universal time =
Greenwich Mean Time

16

You might also like