Arthur Ambartsumian. On Zarer's Name and "The Fortress of Zarer" // Second Biennial Convention on Iranian Studies. Society, History and Culture in the Persianate World. Association for the Study of Persianate Societies, 2-5 April, 2004, Yerevan, Armenia. Abstracts. Yerevan (Department of Iranian Studies, Yerevan State University. Published by Caucasian Centre for Iranian Studies), 2004, pp. 49-54.
Arthur Ambartsumian. On Zarer's Name and "The Fortress of Zarer" // Second Biennial Convention on Iranian Studies. Society, History and Culture in the Persianate World. Association for the Study of Persianate Societies, 2-5 April, 2004, Yerevan, Armenia. Abstracts. Yerevan (Department of Iranian Studies, Yerevan State University. Published by Caucasian Centre for Iranian Studies), 2004, pp. 49-54.
Arthur Ambartsumian. On Zarer's Name and "The Fortress of Zarer" // Second Biennial Convention on Iranian Studies. Society, History and Culture in the Persianate World. Association for the Study of Persianate Societies, 2-5 April, 2004, Yerevan, Armenia. Abstracts. Yerevan (Department of Iranian Studies, Yerevan State University. Published by Caucasian Centre for Iranian Studies), 2004, pp. 49-54.
ON ZARER’S NAME AND “THE FORTRESS OF ZARER”
ARTHUR HAMBARTSUMIAN
This paper deals with the problem of Zarer’s name and the
place names of his abode. The name Zarer was widely observed by
Mary Boyce in her well-known article published in 1955. The
‘Avestan Zairivairi was replaced by the Middle Iranian period Zarér
[Pahl. zlyl], cf. New Persian Zarir. Mary Boyce has shown that the
form Zarér is not a regular development of the Avestan Zairivairi,
which would be in Middle Persian rather Zarwar or Zarit, like his
son’s name Bastavairi became Bastwar in Middle Persian and
Bastdr (Nastiir) in New Persian (Shah-nameh) [Boyce M., 1955, p.
466]. According to Emile Benveniste’s opinion, Zarér could be a
derivative of Zarivari, likewise dipér of *dipibara- [Benveniste E.,
1932, p. 246].
As Mary Boyce states it is strange enough that Zarer is the exact
Middle Persian equivalent of Zariadres, mentioned in Greek
sources (Athenaeus, Strabo) and the same name in Armenian
spelling Zareh (Zariadr, Zarehr). Two names fell together in the
Middle Iranian period and became indistinguishable.
The name Zariadres is known from the charming love story of
Zariadres and Odatis. The story belonged to the historian Chares of
Mytilene who served in the court of Alexander the Great as his
official reporter and participated in his Central Asian campaign
(the tenth book of his unpreserved work “The History of
Alexander”). Now we know the content of his story due to the
other Greek writer Athenaeus of Naukratis (2-3 AD), who in his
work “The Deipnosophists”, in book XIII “Concerning women”,
retells this story to his friends (Athenaeus, Deipnosophistae, Vol.
IIL, Lib. XII, 575.35). In brief the story was as follows: Hystaspes
and his younger brother Zariadres were said by the people of their
land to be born of Aphrodite and Adonis. Hystaspes ruled Media
and the lands below it, Zariadres the region above the Caspian
Gates up to the Tanais. Beyond the Tanais, lived the Marathis,
49ruled by Omartes, whose daughter Odatis was the most beautiful
woman in Asia. Odatis dreamt of Zariadres, and loved him; and he
too loved Odatis through dreams. He sought her vainly in
marriage, for her father did not wish to give her to a stranger. Soon
after, Omartes held a marrage feast attended by his own kinsmen
and nobles, and bade Odatis give a cup of wine to him whom she
wished to marry. Zariadres, forewarned by Odatis, came in full
haste across the Tanais, accompanied only by his charioteer, and
entered the hall in Scythian dress as, weeping, Odatis slowly filled
the cup. She recognized him with joy, and he carried her off.
Chares stated that this tale was greatly esteemed by the barbarians
of Asia, who painted scenes from it on the walls of temples,
palaces, and even private houses, the nobles often giving the name
of Odatis to their own daughters.
Rapp and Spiegel pointed out the striking similarity between
this story and the story told by Firdousi where Zariadres and Odatis
had been replaced by the love story of Zarer’s brother Gushtasp
(Vishtasp) and Katayun [Rapp A., 1866, Ss. 65-66; Spiegel F.,
1891, S. 197]. Many discussions has been made about the origin
and identification of the mythological “parents” of Zariadres and
Histaspes from the story told by Chares of Mytilene. Spiegel
suggested that Vishtaspa actually was a child of the Sun-god as he
was identified by Chares with Adonis. The Sun is said to have
swift horses (aurvasaspa) as the brothers had father Aurvat-aspa by
name. J. Darmsteter suggested that Adonis could have been
identified with Apam Napat, who as the Sun had the same epithet,
and Aphrodite with Anahita. It is strangely enough but in Zamyad
Yasht (Yt 19) the divinity Apam Napat Aurvat-aspa is placed as
capturer of the Kavian Khvarenah before the main its holder Kavi
Vishtaspa (Yt 19. 51-52, 84-85).
Mary Boyce and Ilya Gershevitch considered the story as
Median [Gershevitch I., 1968, pp. 2, 10], but one couldn’t agree
with these opinions because Chares, being involved in Alexander’s
campaign, might have heard this story during his stay in Central
Asia, so this legend should be considered of the Eastern Iranian
50origiri, as Chares stated that “the tale was highly esteemed by the
barbarians of Asia”. i
Another Zariadres is known from the Armenian sources. Strabo
mentions him as Zariadris (Strabo, Geography, Lib. XI, Vol.
XIV.5,15), general (strategos) of Antiochus III, who ruled in the
south-western regions of Armenia (Sophene and Acilisene). In the
Old Armenian historical writings this name is attested as Zareh.
Manichaean form Zarél is mentioned in the fragment of the
“Book of the Giants” with the names of the peaceful king Vishtasp
ruling in Aryan-Vezhan, his wife Hudos and someone named
Vahman. In opinion of Prods Skjervg, the Manichean form Zarél
could be dissimilated form of Zarér, but it is also possible that form
Zaré| is derived from *Zariardés by simple metathesis from
Zariadres [Skjzrvo P. O., 1996, p. 621].
Another form of this name Zarvar (Zarwar) is attested in the
very distorted and mythical Manichaean legend about Zrushch and
Zarvar in Babylon that preserved in Manichaean Sogdian text and
was published by Werner Sundermann [Sundermann, 1986;
Skjzrvo P. O., 1996, p. 617-618]. Zarvar, performing a demonic
role, consulted with the “evil councillor” and the prophet’s
slanderer Zamasp, killed his own two sons, tried to kill his brother
Vishtasp and the righteous Zrushch (Zarathushtra). Prods Skjzrvo
states that he can find no textual reason for Zairivairi’s
transformation into a minion of the Powers of Evil, and assumes
that there might be an pseudo-etymological one, because Mani
may have interpreted his name as “Zahr-war” - “poison-bearer”,
and connected him with his opponent in AZ, Namkhvast, who
throws a poisoned spear at Bastvar [Skjzrvo P. O., 1996, p. 618].
Concerning the name of the Armenian prince of Great Sophena
Zareh (Zarehr) and its Greek pronunciation Zariadris, J. Marquart
makes a note that it corresponds to New Persian Zarér (as dalér
from Old Persian *darda-dara), when Iranian -dr- changes to
Armenian -h-, as we have examples in Armenian Meh, Merh from
Old Persian MiOra (Pers. Mihr). He states that Avestan Zairivairi
is “falsche umsetzung von pehl. Zarér ins Awestische” and “die
51