.

 Marxs Critique of Socialist Labor-Money Schemes and the Myth of

Council Communisms Proudhonism www.marxisthumanistinitiative.
org/alternatives-to-capital/marxs-critique-of-socialist-labor-money-schemes-and-the-mythof-council-communisms-proudhonism.html www.pagkaki.
org/files/labour-money.pdf.


(David Adam) 2013 marxisthumanistinitiative.org. , ,

1000
Rotta (www.rotta.espivblogs.net). :
.
, ,
. , , , , , ,
.
, ,
.


,
.
.
,
-- .

, ..
,
.

,
. ,
,
-

, .
, 10-100-1000 ,

.
-
() .

2013

- .
. ,
(
)
-- .
,

.
,

[] .
, .

. 1952,
,
.
, i.
,

. /
[labor certificates/vouchers], .
1969
-1

ii.
/ iii.
, ,
iv.
[]
[Grundrisse]v.
(...): . http://
www.kokkinonima.gr/KN_Dauve_Eclipse.pdf.
1

,
Grundrisse.
,
. , 1875,
.
; [law of value]
;

, ,
[labour-money].
.

,
.

.
-
. ,
. ,
. ,
.
vi. , . ,
:

. ,

vii. ,

. ,
,

viii.
,
, . ,
(

 )
, ix.

,
: ,
.
,

. ,
,

[socially necessary
labor time]2 ,
.
,
[
] x. ,
, /
. ,
,
, [ ],
, ,
xi.
[value-form]
xii.
:
,
3.
...:

(, . )
2

...: , , ,
. , .
, ,
.
. ,
.

(, . ).
3

 :
,
-
.

xiii.
,
. ,
.

10

,
-

.
, ,

- .
; ;
,

. : H

.
: , , .
xiv. .
;
, .
. 1930,

.

xv. ,
(GIC), 1930,
xvi. GIC

. GIC,

 .
, .
:


.

(
, )


.
,
xvii.
xviii. , GIC

.
GIC,
, xix.
GIC
, ,
[] .
,
(
) ,
: ,


, . ,
,
xx.
, GIC :

,
,

xxi. , GIC
, ,
:
o
[prices]

11

.

.

, .

xxii;

12

GIC
,
[use values]
xxiii. ,
;
, [ GIC]
, .
iv. (

) .
M 1857, Grundrissexxiv.
,
, GIC
, ,
xxv.
, ,
.
,
xxvi. ,
. , ,
.

,

.
[scare-word4]

)
,
)
. , ,
4

...: .

 xxvii.
,
.
, . :
.

.
, . ,

. , ,
[]
[ ]
;
.
,
.
,
.
,

[] ,

. .
, ,
.
xxviii.
,

.

, . , .
,
xxix.

13

14

xxx.
Grundrisse ;
GIC

.
Grundrisse,
. , ,

;


, ,
.
; ,

.

. xxxi.
.
1844, 5 6

.
, . ,

, ,
: ,
,
xxxii.
,
, xxxiii.
Grundrisse,
...: Comments on James Mill, lments Dconomie Politique, http://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/
works/1844/james-mill.
5

...: Elements of Political Economy, http://www.marxists.org/reference/subject/

economics/mill-james.
6


xxxiv, .
.
, ,
, [token]
.


.
,

.
, .

xxxv.
, Grundrisse,
.
(
).
, ,

. :
.
, ,
xxxvi.
: [] , , ,
,
xxxvii.


, () , .

,

15

16

,
xxxviii. ,
.


. , :
, .

xxxix.
,

-
, . ,

,

.
,
. , ,
,
.

.
,
, 1,
, ( )
( ).
xl.
.
, ,
,
.
, 7.
,
.
...: : The social relations of value production thus necessarily
manifest themselves in the relation between two things, as the attribute of a thing, as an intrinsic property.
Money is described as a general equivalent, a commodity through which all other commodities express
their value.
7

 ,
,
:
,
, - ,
.
,
xli.
.
,
.
, ,
.
, . ,
.

.
.

,
. ,
,
.
,
.
.

.
, .
,
.
,
.
. ,

17

18

, .
Grundrisse ,
.
,
,
, .

,
, . ,
,
. ,
.
.
:
,
,
xlii.
, .

, , . ---
,
,
, .

Grundrisse. , , ,

.

,

xliii.
, ,
. Grundrisse,
, : :

;xliv.

 . ,
:
, xlv.

, ,
xlvi. ,
, ,
xlvii.

:
, ,
,
, ,
.
, ,
, .
,
,
, ,
,
. [ ],
,
[]

,

xlviii.
,
.

.
, 1, ,
,
xlix.

,

19

 l.
:

li.

.


. ,
.

20

, , ,
.
.

.
, .
( )
:
, ..
.
,
.


.


lii.

.

.

,
.
, : .

 ,
. , , ,
, , , ,

. ,
( ),
, ,
liii.
,
.
, 3,
liv.

.
, , 1,
,
. ,
, :
,
. .
.

. .
.
.
.

.
.
.



.

21

.

lv.

.

lvi

, Grundrisse
:

22

,
[] . ,
... ,
.
, ,
. .

, .
/ . ,

,
. .
, (
) lvii.


.
GIC .


, ,
.

( ).

- . ,

.
, .
, ,
.

23

24

i. Serge Bricianer, Pannekoek and the Workers Councils (St. Louis: Telos Press, 1978) . 289.
ii. Bring Out Your Dead, 1 [ http://endnotes.org.uk/articles/8].
iii. Jean Barrot Francois Martin, Eclipse and Re-Emergence of the Communist Movement (:
Black & Red, 1974), . 105.
iv. .., . 123.
v. .., . 123-124
vi. Paresh Chattopadhyay, The Economic Content of Socialism: Marx vs. Lenin, Review of Radical
Political Economics, . 24, . 3&4, . 91. [http://libcom.org/library/economic-content-socialismlenin-it-same-marx]
vii. Karl Marx, Critique of the Gotha Programme, Later Political Writings (Cambridge: Cambridge
UP, 2010) . 222.
viii. .., . 215.
ix. .., . 213.
x. Ted McGlone and Andrew Kliman, The Duality of Labour, The New Value Controversy and the
Foundations of Economics (Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing, 2004) . 145.
xi. Marx, Critique of the Gotha Programme, . 213. Grundrisse,
[]

. Karl Marx, Grundrisse (London: Penguin, 1993) . 171. ,
:
, ,
,
. , , ,
: .
, ,
. ,
, , , ,
, , , , [] Frederick Engels, Herr
Eugen Dhrings Revolution in Science (New York: International Publishers, 1939), . 345-6.
xii. Karl Marx, Capital: Volume I (: Penguin, 1990), . 175.
xiii. .., . 173.
xiv. Barrot and Martin, Eclipse and Re-Emergence of the Communist Movement, . 104.
xv.  What is Communism, International Council Correspondence 1, . 1 (1934), Communist
Production and Distribution, Living Marxism 4 (1938).
xvi. http://www.marxists.org/subject/left-wing/gik/1930/index.htm.
1930,
Jan Appel 1923-1925.
, Appel .

: ) ; )
;
Appel , Canne Meijer
, . John Gerber, Anton Pannekoek and
the Socialism of Workers Self-Emancipation, 1873-1960 (Norwell, MA: Kluwer Academic Publishers,
1989), . 166.
xvii. http://www.marxists.org/subject/left-wing/gik/1930/09.htm. GIC
:

 ,

( ) . ,
, . http://www.marxists.org/subject/left-wing/
gik/1930/01.htm#h4
xviii.  GIC Philippe Bourrinet,
,
Phillipe Bourrinet, The Dutch and German
Communist Left (: Porcupine Press, 2001), . 252.
xix.  GIC , http://www.marxists.org/subject/left-wing/gik/1930/13.
htm
xx. http://www.marxists.org/subject/left-wing/gik/1930/epilogue.htm#h3
xxi. Anarchism and the Spanish Revolution, International Council Correspondence 3, . 5&6 (1937), 22.
xxii. http://www.marxists.org/subject/left-wing/gik/1930/04.htm#h3
xxiii. http://www.marxists.org/subject/left-wing/gik/1930/01.htm#h4
xxiv. Barrot Martin, Eclipse and Re-Emergence of the Communist Movement, . 123-124.
xxv. Denis Authier Jean Barrot, The Communist Left in Germany 1918-1921 (Paris: Payot, 1976), .
227. [ http://www.marxists.org/subject/germany-1918-23/dauve-authier/
appendix1.htm#h7]
xxvi. 
. , ,
, , , .
xxvii. Barrot Martin, Eclipse and Re-Emergence of the Communist Movement, . 116.
xxviii. Anton Pannekoek, Workers Councils (: AK Press, 2003), . 23-27. [ : http://
www.marxists.org/archive/pannekoe/1947/workers-councils.htm#h7]
xxix. Marx, Theories of Surplus Value, Book III, . 129.
xxx. Barrot Martin, Eclipse and Re-Emergence of the Communist Movement, . 104.
xxxi. Karl Marx, A Contribution to the Critique of Political Economy ( : International Publishers,
1970), . 86.
xxxii. Karl Marx, Early Writings ( : Vintage, 1975), . 261.
xxxiii. Karl Marx, The Poverty of Philosophy (New York: International Publishers, 1992), . 59.
xxxiv. Marx, Grundrisse, . 160.
xxxv. Karl Marx, Reflections, in Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels, Collected Works, . 10 ( :
International Publishers, 1978), . 588.
xxxvi.  ;
, , Pierre-Joseph Proudhon, What is Property? (: Cambridge
UP, 2007), . 106.
xxxvii. Karl Marx, Notes on Adolph Wagner, Later Political Writings, . 255.
xxxviii. Marx, Grundrisse, . 138.
xxxix. .., . 126.
xl. Marx, Capital: Volume I, . 140.
xli. .., . 161.
xlii. Marx, Grundrisse, . 155-6.
xliii. Marx, A Contribution to the Critique of Political Economy, . 85.
xliv. Marx, Grundrisse, . 122.
xlv.  Alfredo Saad-Filho, Labor, Money, and Labour-Money: A Review of Marxs
Critique of John Grays Monetary Analysis, History of Political Economy, 25, . 1, . 67.
xlvi. Marx, Grundrisse, . 134.
xlvii. Marx, A Contribution to the Critique of Political Economy, . 70.

25

26

xlviii. .., . 85-86.

xlix. Marx, Capital: Volume I, . 139.
l. Karl Marx, The Value-Form, in Capital & Class, . 4, . 141.
li. .., . 140.
lii. Marx, Capital: Volume I, . 188-9.
liii. .., . 170.
liv. Marx, Capital: Volume III (London: Penguin, 1991), . 1020.
lv. Marx, Capital: Volume I, . 171-2.
lvi.  , , ,
.
. , , ,
. ,
. Karl Marx, Capital: Volume II (London: Penguin, 1992), . 434.
lvii. Marx, Grundrisse, . 172-3.

 ,
,
.
(
).

-
. ,


.


, . ,
,
.