JPL L lLAN

A k L l Ok J
Deadly Plan
On 27th February around 12 noon, the dead bodies were removed from the S-6 coach
and laid down in the yard itself and a huge crowd was allowed to gather all around. The
inquest was carried out by P! Nirza which was started at 13:1S was completed and
signed at 18:+S.
Under the criminal law, it is the inquesting authority who has to decide
whether to send the dead bodies for post-mortem or not. But in the present
case PM of almost all bodies were over by 1S.45 hours, the time when
inquest report was signed.
The question is, under whose orders, the Post- mortem was being conducted in the
Railway Yard !tself without any facility and equipments and also by doctors who were
not trained to do Post Nortem?
The mobile phone records would indicate that Shri Ashok Bhatt in consultation with the
Chief Ninister took the decision to 'finish' the Post Nortem at Godhra itself, however
illegal and unwarranted that may be! The mobile phone call record shows who was
organising doctors to start the Post Nortem.
9825000836
OMPRAKASH SINGH
C/O P A TO C.M.
27-feb-
2002
15:38:10 43
9825039877
(AshoK
Bhatt) Out
9825000836
OMPRAKASH SINGH
C/O P A TO C.M.
27-feb-
2002
15:05:09 173
9825039877
(AshoK
Bhatt) In
9825000836
OMPRAKASH SINGH
C/O P A TO C.M.
27-feb-
2002
14:50:44 15
9825039877
(AshoK
Bhatt) Out
9825000836
OMPRAKASH SINGH
C/O P A TO C.M.
27-feb-
2002
13:53:44 35
9825039877
(AshoK
Bhatt) Out
DiaIed / Received No. - Name Date-Time
Dura- CeII-No.
(Name)
CaII
Type
9825000836
OMPRAKASH SINGH
C/O P A TO C.M.
27-feb-
2002
15:38:10 43
9825039877
(AshoK
Bhatt) Out
9825000836
OMPRAKASH SINGH
C/O P A TO C.M.
27-feb-
2002
15:05:09 173
9825039877
(AshoK
Bhatt) In
9825000836
OMPRAKASH SINGH
C/O P A TO C.M.
27-feb-
2002
14:50:44 15
9825039877
(AshoK
Bhatt) Out
9825000836
OMPRAKASH SINGH
C/O P A TO C.M.
27-feb-
2002
13:53:44 35
9825039877
(Ashok
Bhatt) Out
DiaIed / Received No. - Name Date-Time
Duration
CeII-No.
(Name)
CaII
Type
Secs
Who Took the Post-Mortem Decision?
1
Who Called the Doctors to Godhra?
24095557
Commissioner of HeaIth
27-feb-2002
20:41:48 251
9825039877
(AshoK
Bhatt) Out
24095557
Commissioner of HeaIth
27-feb-2002
18:40:10 121
9825039877
(AshoK
Bhatt)
Out
24095557
Commissioner of HeaIth
27-feb-2002
18:37:49
118
9825039877
(AshoK
Bhatt) Out
24095557
Commissioner of HeaIth
27-feb-2002
17:19:09 146
9825039877
(AshoK
Bhatt)
In
24095557
Commissioner of HeaIth
27-feb-2002
13:39:24
38
9825039877
(AshoK
Bhatt) In
DiaIed / Received No. - Name Date-Time
Dura-
tion
CeII-No.
(Name)
CaII
Type
24095557
Commissioner of HeaIth
27-feb-2002
20:41:48 251
9825039877
(AshoK
Bhatt) Out
24095557
Commissioner of HeaIth
27-feb-2002
18:40:10 121
9825039877
(AshoK
Bhatt)
Out
24095557
Commissioner of HeaIth
27-feb-2002
18:37:49
118
9825039877
(AshoK
Bhatt) Out
24095557
Commissioner of HeaIth
27-feb-2002
17:19:09 146
9825039877
(AshoK
Bhatt)
In
24095557
Commissioner of HeaIth
27-feb-2002
13:39:24
38
9825039877
(AshoK
Bhatt) In
DiaIed / Received No. - Name Date-Time
Dura-
tion
CeII-No.
(Name)
CaII
Type
Doctors Who Carried Out the Post-Mortems:
16:30 to 18:00 Godhra RIy Yard niI 27-2-02
Dr.Rohini Katti
(3)
16:35 to 18:30 Godhra RIy Yard 1-Mar-02 27-2-02
Dr.Manisha shah
(2)
16:35 to 18:00 Godhra RIy Yard niI 27-2-02
Dr.KinjaI Doshi
(3)
15:05 to 18:00 Godhra RIy Yard 14-3-2002 14-3-02
Dr.S. B. Shah
(5)
16:30 to 19:30 Godhra RIy Yard niI 27-3-02
Rikesh Champaner
(6)
16:40 to 20:25 Godhra RIy Yard niI 27-2-02
Dr.Rajesh Kumar
(4)
16:30 to 20:00 Godhra RIy Yard 11-Mar-02 11-Mar-02
Dr.Amit s. PanchaI
(7)
Hours
PIace of Post
Mortem
Sent to
CiviI
surgeon
Signing
date
Doctor
(No Of PM )
16:30 to 18:00 Godhra RIy Yard niI 27-2-02
Dr. Rohini Katti
(3)
16:35 to 18:30 Godhra RIy Yard 1-Mar-02 27-2-02
Dr. Manisha shah
(2)
16:35 to 18:00 Godhra RIy Yard niI 27-2-02
Dr. KinjaI Doshi
(3)
15:05 to 18:00 Godhra RIy Yard 14-3-2002 14-3-02
Dr.S.B. Shah
(5)
16:30 to 19:30 Godhra RIy Yard niI 27-3-02
Rikesh Champaner
(6)
16:40 to 20:25 Godhra RIy Yard niI 27-2-02
Dr. Rajesh Kumar
(4)
16:30 to 20:00 Godhra RIy Yard 11-Mar-02 11-Mar-02
Dr. Amit S. PanchaI
(7)
Hours
PIace of Post
Mortem
Sent to
CiviI
surgeon
Signing
date
Doctor
(No Of PM )
2
Deadly Plan
Doctors Who Carried Out the Post-Mortems:
16:40 to
20:00
Godhra RIy Yard
niI niI
Dr.Yogesh Jain
(5)
16:00 to
17:30
Godhra RIy Yard
27-2-02 27-2-02
Dr.Subhash Sinha
(3)
16:45 to 20
:30
Godhra RIy Yard
27-2-02 27-2-02
Dr.P.G.Rathod
(3)
16:30 to
18:30
Godhra RIy Yard
niI 27-2-02
Dr.MauIesh S. PateI
(4)
17:30 to
19:00
Godhra RIy Yard
niI 27-2-02
Dr.K.V.Sainik
(3)
13:35 to
20:00
Godhra RIy Yard
1-Mar-02 27-2-02
Dr.S.M.Suratia
(5)
17:05 to
20:45
Godhra RIy Yard
1-Mar-02 27-2-02
Dr.S.B.Nagori
(5)
TotaI hours
PIace of Post
Mortem
Sent to
CiviI
surgeon
Signing
date
Doctor
( No of PM)
16:40 to
20:00
Godhra RIy Yard
niI niI
Dr.Yogesh Jain
(5)
16:00 to
17:30
Godhra RIy Yard
27-2-02 27-2-02
Dr.Subhash Sinha
(3)
16:45 to 20
:30
Godhra RIy Yard
27-2-02 27-2-02
Dr.P.G.Rathod
(3)
16:30 to
18:30
Godhra RIy Yard
niI 27-2-02
Dr. MauIesh S. PateI
(4)
17:30 to
19:00
Godhra RIy Yard
niI 27-2-02
Dr. K.V. Sainik
(3)
13:35 to
20:00
Godhra RIy Yard
1-Mar-02 27-2-02
Dr. S.M. Suratia
(5)
17:05 to
20:45
Godhra RIy Yard
1-Mar-02 27-2-02
Dr. S.B. Nagori
(5)
TotaI hours
PIace of Post
Mortem
Sent to
CiviI
surgeon
Signing
date
Doctor
( No of PM)
Why was
the Post Mortem
done in this Hasty
and Fraudulent
Manner?
3
Deadly Plan
!n fact one Passenger, Shri Haribhai N Joshi, !ncome Tax Officer has deposed before
Nanavati Commission that - As far as ! remember, no post mortem was done when the
dead body of my wife was given to me"
Yet Dr. Yogesh Jain has signed the PN report of Hariprasad's wife though no date was
put on the report.
The make belief Post Nortem was carried out at great haste at Godhra itself for three
objectives:
{1) The real cause of death was obliterated;
{2) The dead bodies could be transported toreach Ahmedabad next
morning tohold a funeral rally;
{3) The inflamed anger of the funeralists could be lasered intoa violent
communal reprisall
The first objective was easily achieved. All doctors simply wrote the cause of all S8
deaths to be due to 'extensive shock due to burn'. No investigation was made as to
whether the burns were anti-mortem or post-mortem!
To achieve the second and third objective, the dead the bodies were handed over to
Jaydeep Patel, the vice President of vHP at 11pm at Godhra and transporting them by
truck to reach the Civil Hospital at Sola, Ahmedabad in the early morning at 2:++ on
28th February 2002.
9825049145
Zadaphia
9825049198
DCP (ZONE 5)
27
th
Feb. 2002
21:11:20 87 ln
9825049145
Zadaphia
9825023887
Jaydeep Patel
27
th
Feb. 2002
20:39:36 48 ln
9825049145
Zadaphia
9825023887
Jaydeep Patel
27
th
Feb. 2002
20:03:25 158 Out
9825049145
Zadaphia
796631365
VHP Office
27
th
Feb. 2002
20:02:01 55 Out
Cell-name Dialed/received name Date -Time Sec. Type
9825049145
Zadaphia
9825049198
DCP (ZONE 5)
27
th
Feb. 2002
21:11:20 87 ln
9825049145
Zadaphia
9825023887
Jaydeep Patel
27
th
Feb. 2002
20:39:36 48 ln
9825049145
Zadaphia
9825023887
Jaydeep Patel
27
th
Feb. 2002
20:03:25 158 Out
9825049145
Zadaphia
796631365
VHP Office
27
th
Feb. 2002
20:02:01 55 Out
Cell-name Dialed/received name Date -Time Sec. Type
+
Deadly Plan
The District Collector of Godhra Ns Jayanti Ravi and the Addl. Chief Secretary, Home
Shri Ashok Narayan have gone on record to state that it was the Chief Ninister who took
the decision to send the dead bodies to Ahmedabad.
10 dead bodies were taken to Ramol, an area near Naroda and a massive funeral rally of
over S0 thousand mourners took the bodies to Hatkeshwar crematorium at 10am in the
morning.
Around 10.30 am or so, a part of the funeral crowd went berserk and attacked a Nuslim
Hotel at Thakkarbapa Nagar, close to Naroda.
Then in rapid succession, the violence spreads to Naroda Gam and then to Naroda
Patiya and to Gulberg Society, all within three kilometers!
The Government of Gujarat has of course being telling a different story. The story of
'Action and Reaction'. The story of an unprecedented explosion of mass anger over-
whelming the police administration.
Few hundred Affidavits have been filed before the Hon'ble Commission by the Police
officials from the rank of DGP to PSO of local police stations from all over Gujarat. Except
for a few, most of the Police officials have voiced the same reason for their failure to
prevent the killings and destruction. 'Outnumbered and Overpowered l'
What is however required to be asked and answered on
the basis of the facts and evidences led before this Hon'ble
Commission is whether, prima facie the defense put up by
the Police has any substance at all or the defense is purely
a cover up for their direct collusion with the rioters??
9825049145
Zadaphia
9825000836
Omprakash Singh
(PA to CM)
27
th
Feb. 2002
22:08:24 97 ln
9825049145
Zadaphia
9825023887
Jaydeep Patel
27
th
Feb. 2002
21:20:19 186 ln
9825023887
Jaydeep
9825049198
DCP (ZONE 5)
27
th
Feb. 2002
21:16:54 138 ln
9825049145
Zadaphia
9825023887
Jaydeep Patel
27
th
Feb. 2002
21:13:11 204 ln
Cell-name Dialed/ Received Date and Time Sec. Type
9825049145
Zadaphia
9825000836
Omprakash Singh
(PA to CM)
27
th
Feb. 2002
22:08:24 97 ln
9825049145
Zadaphia
9825023887
Jaydeep Patel
27
th
Feb. 2002
21:20:19 186 ln
9825023887
Jaydeep
9825049198
DCP (ZONE 5)
27
th
Feb. 2002
21:16:54 138 ln
9825049145
Zadaphia
9825023887
Jaydeep Patel
27
th
Feb. 2002
21:13:11 204 ln
Cell-name Dialed/ Received Date and Time Sec. Type
S
Deadly Plan
Jansangharsh Manch submits that the Nobile Call Data collected and submitted by
Shri Rahul Sharma before the Commission is of great importance as corroborative
evidence and therefore, has analyzed this data in respect of around +0 persons whose
names have already been submitted to the Commission.
Whenever any person uses his mobile, the phone company records his phone no, tower
location, time , and the phone no of other party etc.
To ascertain the geographical location of any person carrying a particular mobile,
unique location codes were assigned to each tower. The list of some important location
codes are given here:
7
Bapunagar VishaI Diamond Factory,
Bapuanar
7
8
GuIberg
Society
Shayona PIaza,
Meghaninagar
8
2
Shahibaug KedarTowers, Shahibaug
2
3
Kubernagar Kubernagar, Nr Sardarnagar
3
6
Naroda Patiya RajkamaI Apt., Thakkarnagar
6
5
Narodagam Jagdish Foundries, Naroda
5
4
Narodagam KaiIash CompIex, Naroda
4
1
Sabarmati Kothari Towers, Sabarmati
1
Code Area Tower
7
Bapunagar VishaI Diamond Factory,
Bapuanar
7
8
GuIberg
Society
Shayona PIaza,
Meghaninagar
8
2
Shahibaug KedarTowers, Shahibaug
2
3
Kubernagar Kubernagar, Nr Sardarnagar
3
6
Naroda Patiya RajkamaI Apt., Thakkarnagar
6
5
Narodagam Jagdish Foundries, Naroda
5
4
Narodagam KaiIash CompIex, Naroda
4
1
Sabarmati Kothari Towers, Sabarmati
1
Code Area Tower
IT HAS BEEN ALLEGED BY MANY VICTIMS OF NARODAGAM THAT THE
MLA OF NARODA, MAYABEN KODNANI WAS INSTIGATING THE MOB
TO ATTACK THEM. SHE HAS OF COURSE DENIED EVEN HER PRESENCE
IN THE NARODA VILLAGE. THE LOCATIONAL CHART OF MAYABEN
HOWEVER TELLS THETRUTHl
6
Deadly Plan
Maya Kodnani, 9825006729, 28 Feb ,2002
-14
-12
-10
-8
-6
-4
-2
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
18
20
22
24
26
28
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24
Time (Hour)
L
o
c
a
t
i
o
n
-
C
o
d
e
Koba
Naroda
SoIa CiviI
Shahibaug
Mirzapur
Odhav
Kankaria
Shahibaug
Similarly from graphs of accused Jaydeep Patel, Babu Bajrangi, Bipin Panchal and
Ashok Patel it is very clear that they were present at the scene of crime.
To find as to whether there was any nexus between the police officials and the political
personalities with the rioters, charts were prepared for nine persons namely the CP,
Jt. CP, DCP (Zone-!v), DCP (Zone-v), Home Ninister Nr. Zadaphia, Dr. Jaydeep Patel,
Babu Bajrangi, Bipin Panchal and Ashok Patel.
7
Deadly Plan
From the last panel it can be seen that the Home Ninister Shri Gordhan Zadaphia had
made just six calls to the CP in three days and just two calls to the Joint CP in the same
period, whereas he has made 23 calls to the DCP Shri R.J. Sawani, 11 calls to Dr.
Jaydeep Patel and five calls to Bipin Panchal, (the accused in CR No.100f2002).
From the last panel it can be seen that the Home Ninister Shri Gordhan Zadaphia had
made just six calls to the CP in three days and just two calls to the Joint CP in the same
period, whereas he has made 23 calls to the DCP Shri R.J. Sawani, 11 calls to Dr.
Jaydeep Patel and five calls to Bipin Panchal, (the accused in CR No.100f2002).
8
Deadly Plan
!t is submitted that the above figure indicate a strong nexus between the DCP Sawani
and the Home Ninister beyond their official relation in as much as despite the enormity
of the events that had taken place between 27th Feb. and 1st Narch 2002 the Home
Ninister does not contact senior most officers but repeatedly contacts a subordinate
officer who was not even connected with Zone-!v where the major crimes had taken
place.
M.K.Tandon (9825048316) 28thFeb.2002
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
18
20
22
24
0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 22
Time (Hour)
L
o
c
a
t
i
o
n
-
c
o
d
e
PoIice Hq
GuIberg Soc
Naroda Gam
ReIief Road
CTMCharrasta
Revdibazar
RakhiyaI
Protectors or Colluders?
From the Location graph of Nr. Tandon it is very clear that he was at Gulberg Society
between 11am and 12.10 hrs. That time crowd had started gathering in Gulberg but he
runs away after receiving a long 123 sec call from Sawani.
There after Nr. Tandon remains in his office in Revdibazar with his full striking force
where there were no riots.
9
Deadly Plan
P.B.Gondia(9825049197) 28 Feb. 2002
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
18
20
10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24
Time (Hours)
L
o
c
a
t
i
o
n
-
C
o
d
e
Gondia
RakhiyaI
PoIice Hq
Revdibaz
Naroda Gam
Thakkarnagar
ReIief Road
GuIberg Soc
DCP Gondia's graph indicates that he too ran away to Rewdibazar and handed over
Gulberg society to rioters.
Result: 60 people were killed including Ehasan Jafari and eight girls are missing to day
also
After every thing was burnt they did come to Gulberg at +pm , perhaps to count the
number of dead bodies.
When they were counting dead bodies in Gulberg there was no police at Naroda Patia.
As a result more than 100 people were killed between Spm to 7pm by a mob of 20000 or
so in Naroda Patia. According to affidavit file before Nanavati Commission neither DGP
nor any other police officer had any knowledge about the incident.
P.C.Pande-9825048303 (28th Feb ,2002)
- 16
- 12
- 8
- 4
0
4
8
12
16
0 2 4 6 8 1 0 1 2 1 4 1 6 1 8 2 0 2 2 2 4
Time (Hour)
PoIice HQ
GuIberg Soc.
ReIief Road
CiviI Ho spit aI,Go t a
10
Deadly Plan
The graph would indicate that the king Pande between 10.30 hrs and 19.30 hrs, had not
left the Shahibaug area and was perhaps in his office. He had also visited the Gulberg
Society around 19.+0 hrs perhaps to help Tandon and Gondia in counting dead bodies.
THE VIOLENCE THEREAFTER SPREAD TO THE REST OF THE STATE AND NO
ATTEMPT WAS MADE TO STOP THE VIOLENCE. IT IS THEREFORE CLEAR
THAT THEROLEOF THEPOLICEIS THAT OF A COLLUDER. THEY WERENEVER
OUT-NUMBERED.
THE MOBILE TELEPHONE CALLS ARE TODAY TELLING US LOUDLY THAT THE
CHIEF MINISTER, HOME MINISTER, HEALTH MINISTER AND ALL HIGHER
POLICEOFFICIALS AREALL PARTY TOTHEGENOCIDE.
!N ONE C!TY OF GUJARAT HOWEvER ONE S!NCERE POL!CE OFF!CER D!D TRY TO
STOP THE v!OLENCE AND !N THE N!GHT OF 28TH FEB. 2002, HE DESPERATELY
REQUESTED THE DGP TO SEND H!N EXTRA POL!CE FORCE.
HE WAS HOWEvER TOLD BY DGP THAT THE ENT!RE BUREAUCRACY HAD BEEN
NEUTARL!SED! AND HE HAD TO DEPEND ON H!S OWN STRENGTH.
RAHUL SHARNA, THE DSP OF BHAvNAGAR D!D PUT DOWN THE v!OLENCE AND HE
SAvED THE L!vES OF +00 CH!LDREN !N A NADRASA. !N DO!NG SO HE HAD TO
RESORT TO F!R!NG WH!CHD!D K!LL SONE R!OTERS.
FOR TH!S ACT OF BRAvERY, THE HONE N!N!STER SHR! ZADAF!A 'CONGRATULATED'
SHARNA OvER THE PHONE BY SAY!NG THAT - "HE HAD DONE A GOOD JOB BUT
THE DEATHRATIOWAS NOT CORRECT" .MORE HINDUS HADBEEN KILLED
IN THEFIRINGl
AS A REPLY !T APPEARS SHARNA TOLD H!N - "THE POLICE BULLETS DO NOT
RECOGNISETHERELIGION OF THERIOTERS l"
11
Deadly Plan