Welcome to Scribd. Sign in or start your free trial to enjoy unlimited e-books, audiobooks & documents.Find out more
Download
Standard view
Full view
of .
Look up keyword
Like this
3Activity
0 of .
Results for:
No results containing your search query
P. 1
Juan Carlos Clase, A043 986 617 (BIA Apr. 25, 2014)

Juan Carlos Clase, A043 986 617 (BIA Apr. 25, 2014)

Ratings: (0)|Views: 720|Likes:
In this unpublished decision, the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA) terminated proceedings upon finding attempted second degree gang assault under N.Y.P.L. 110.00-120.06 not to be a crime involving moral turpitude. The Board noted that New York courts have found the offense to be a "legally impossible" crime for trial purposes because it imposes liability for attempting to cause an unintended result, and that strict liability crimes are not recognized as involving moral turpitude. The decision was written by Member Roger Pauley and joined by Member Anne Greer and Member Garry Malphrus.

Looking for IRAC’s Index of Unpublished BIA Decisions? Visit www.irac.net/unpublished/index
In this unpublished decision, the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA) terminated proceedings upon finding attempted second degree gang assault under N.Y.P.L. 110.00-120.06 not to be a crime involving moral turpitude. The Board noted that New York courts have found the offense to be a "legally impossible" crime for trial purposes because it imposes liability for attempting to cause an unintended result, and that strict liability crimes are not recognized as involving moral turpitude. The decision was written by Member Roger Pauley and joined by Member Anne Greer and Member Garry Malphrus.

Looking for IRAC’s Index of Unpublished BIA Decisions? Visit www.irac.net/unpublished/index

More info:

Published by: Immigrant & Refugee Appellate Center, LLC on Apr 28, 2014
Copyright:Traditional Copyright: All rights reserved

Availability:

Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
See more
See less

08/20/2014

pdf

text

original

 
Ben Winograd, Esq. IMMIGRANT
&
REFUGEE APPELLTE CTR 3602 Forest Drve
Ax VA 
ame: CLASE, JUN CARLOS
    Ev   Ig vw
Boa o Immao ppals O o   lk
507 Leesburg Pike, Ste 2000 Fls Crc Vn 2030
HS/ICE Ofice of Chef Counsel ORL 3535 Lawon Rd, Se
1
Orando, L 3803 A 043-986-617 Dae of this Notce 4/5/014
Enclosed is a copy of the Board's desio and ode n e above-efeened case. ncoue Pane Memes:
Greer, Anne J Maphrus, Garry D Pauey, Rge A
Snceey, Dona Ca Chief Cek
For more unpublished BIA decisions, visit www.irac.net/unpublished
Cite as: Juan Carlos Clase, A043 986 617 (BIA Apr. 25, 2014)
 
U Dparm of Juc
Executive Ofce r Immaon Reew Decso f h Bad  gao Appeal Fa�Chuc, Viga
0530
Fi A3 986 617 Orad F In rUAN CAOS CASE IN MOVA PROCEEDINGS APPEA a: N BEHAF  PNDENT n Wingrad squir
O
EAF O DS HARGE Jifr ag-z Asss Cif Cus
APR
2 5
2014
ic Sc 212a)(2)(A)i)I) I&N Act [8 SC§ 82(a)2)A)()(I)] Cim invving mra tiud APICAIO: rminain; aivr  namissibiy Tis cs as rviusy br us n ctbr 31 23 A tat im  dtrn ta   Immigrain Judgs  3 23 dcisin in ic t Immiain Judg sstaind   cg  namssbity id  rsndn's apcain r a vr  inadssby and rdrd s rva t  Dinica Rpublc cand insucn ca ndings d ga aysis r ur apa rv W rr rmndd  rcrd   prcing r rnd cnsidran  sssus d t ntry  a n dcsn. W scc nscd h Iigran udg t rvd a mr cm aalyss  t rsndn's Januy  2 cnvictin r ampt gag assa  t scnd d n vai f  Yrk Pna a§§ 1/26 Th rsndn rud a hcnvcn s  r a itudnus crm ad vn  uitdins  cnvcti cms dr  yu ndr xcpn  h grund f inadmissibiy  crims invving mra tiud W as ndicatd ta  Igratin Jg sud ( ncssary) rassss r tis cnvicin disquas th rsndn r a aivr  inadmissibity dr sct 2 2()   Iain nd Nainay Ac 8 USC § 82(h) as a c  vinc aggavatd ny
S
scin a)(3)() f th Act 8 USC § 11a)(3)) nay  drctd th mmigratin g  admisativy  th rcr  rcig  s ar rng a  dcsin r rn aa bring d rsn  t rspndnt's aa  Immigrain Jdg rndrd a n dcisin and admnsratvy rd  cas  s n cm 2 23 Th Immigrain Jdg dtrmid hat th  f Hmad Scury (DHS") s stabisd by cr and cnvincing vidnc a  cnvictin r am gg assat i t scn dgr cagcay cnstiuts a crim invving ma  uiud undr sctn 22(a)(2)(A)()(I) f t Act Th Immigatin Judg r dind  a  DHS  sabisd a h y ndr xcin ds n apy (J at 2-9
Cite as: Juan Carlos Clase, A043 986 617 (BIA Apr. 25, 2014)
 
A043 986 617 (Dec. 2, 2013 The igatio udge alo deteied a the repode did o mee hi burde of etabliing by a pepodece of he evidece ha the u 4, 2000, covictio  atemed gg asau i te e·cod deee i o a diualiing crme of voece aggavaed felony (I. at 911 (Dec 12, 2013 I h Febuy 19 2014, bef, e epde enew hs aguet r teminating te reoval proceedg or, i e aleative, emdig the ce o permit im to appy  a waiver of iadmiibliy de ect 22( of te Ac Te esodes ea
ll
e sued, d te poceedig will e eiated. The esponden ubaive atute of covco vide  perso i guiy of gg asau i e ecod degee when w ie o cause  phyical juy o nother peo ad whe aided by wo o moe othe pero actualy preet, he caue eou phyical juy to uch eo o o a id  peo.  NYPL § 20.06 (2000 Uder Ne York law, a person i guilty of an aemp o commit a crie he, wi ie to comit a crie, he egages i coduc wch tend o eect e comon of such ce" N.YP.L § 1000. A e repond a poited out i i appeal bief, e ew York ae appelae cous oly allow a dedt cged wit a volaio of New Yok Penal La12006 to
 plead
guly  o
attempted
gg assault i the econd degree n violatio of New Yok Pel Law §   00012006
See In re Cisey
G
918 .YS2d 23, 25-26 (NY. A Div. 211 (cing
Poe

Foster,
278 N.YS.2d 603 (Y 1967)
 see aso Knapik

Ashcro
38 F3d 84, 91 
Cir.
204 It i mpemiible ude Ne Yok law o idic or
chge
a
defent
wi he crime of attemed gg aaul i he ecod degee d to ubit uc a cge to a jury ubjec o e beyod a reonable doubt" tadd of poof Ne York cours have eld tha atepted gag au i the ecod degree i a legaly imosible cime"
e J re Seha
R,
196 Mic2d 659,661, 766 NY.S.2d 313, 315 (NY Fam C 2003) e posio of crmal abilty  te unieded reul of ieioa cnc
s the
very eece of a sct abliy cime (N.YP.L § 150 d hee cot be  aemt to caue  uineded eult." (ooe d citaio oited Ap o certan tauory ae oee,
 see Maer of Dgea
11 I&N Dec. 723 (BIA 1966, we have eve ecogied a ic liabity cim"  a crie volvig moal tupiude Accordigly e epode a o hat, rt, New York Peal Law § 120.06 i
aua
applied i cojctio wth New York Peal Law § 1100 to coduc hat doe ot ivolve mora ttude d, nd, ta s wn cnvcon  atd gg alt n
e
con dege doe no invlve moa tupude
1
e lowng order wil be eneed
Auig withou decidg tat a coviction  gg asau  the ecod dege woud ivolve moral ude (.J. a 6, i ce i ditguiable om
Mater of Vo
25 &N Dec. 426 (BIA 2011, i wic we ed ha a covicti  a attept oene i a convictio  cre ivolvig moral ptude f te udeying ubttive oee i a cme ivolvig moral tuud Our dco n
ater o o supra,
wa peied o te pevag picile (Contiued .2
Cite as: Juan Carlos Clase, A043 986 617 (BIA Apr. 25, 2014)

Activity (3)

You've already reviewed this. Edit your review.
1 thousand reads
1 hundred reads
rabrutyn liked this

You're Reading a Free Preview

Download
scribd
/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->