Welcome to Scribd, the world's digital library. Read, publish, and share books and documents. See more
Standard view
Full view
of .
Look up keyword
Like this
0 of .
Results for:
No results containing your search query
P. 1
Some notes on climate change and social movements from 2011

Some notes on climate change and social movements from 2011

Ratings: (0)|Views: 17|Likes:
Published by Mark Bergfeld
I found this in my archives. Maybe this will be useful to some of you.

Please don't quote without prior permission.
I found this in my archives. Maybe this will be useful to some of you.

Please don't quote without prior permission.

More info:

Categories:Types, Presentations
Published by: Mark Bergfeld on May 14, 2014
Copyright:Traditional Copyright: All rights reserved


Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
See more
See less





From the archives: Some notes on climate change from 2011
Mark Bergfeld @mdbergfeld DON
Climate change is fact 
 This winter Hurricane Sandy caused massive destruction along the East Coast of the United States. Over the summer we have seen the biggest drought in states such as Oklahoma which famously was
labelled the ‘dust bowl’
of America in the Great Depression of the 1930s. Also in Britain we have seen the biggest drought followed by massive floods in some parts of the country. As austerity and the cold bite in crisis-ridden Greece, people have turned to heating their homes with firewood. This has caused a Smog-Alarm in the centre of Athens the first time since the 1980s. In Egypt and Tunisia, structural adjustment programmes, dependence on the export of gas and oil, and Foreign Direct Investment have had a massive impact on food prices. Twinned with longer drought periods, the changes in climate in the Middle East and North Africa have been one of the determining features as to why the initial demonstrations in December 2011 were so explosive.
In Syria, Assad’ neoliberal reform
s after 2000 exacerbated the environmental degradation and left ten thousands of peasants from the country side to to the brink of starvation. These peasants then flooded into the cities of Homs, Aleppo and Daraa, the bastions of the resistance against the Assad regime. On the news we hear about immigrants from Sub-Saharan Africa drowning in the Mediterranean. Bill McKibben and other climate scientists are arguing that Arctic ice is melting at much faster rates than expected. It is commonly assumed 2 Degree Celsius Threshold We find ourselves at a critical stage with climate polarisation intensifying. Runaway climate change
Climate Change summits are deadlocked 
 The Rio Earth Summit in 1992 at which more than 100 states participated was hamstrung by George
Bush Sr. The agreement on biodiversity a few years later wasn’t signed by the United States.
Rio established a charter to protect the environment but in the last twenty years carbon emissions have steadily risen. The infamous Kyoto Protocoll which G
eorge W Bush jr and the US again didn’t sign up was hailed as
a big advancement in the fight against climate change. What it however did was to enshrine market mechanisms as the only way to fight the climate crisis. These protocols committed industrialised nations to reducing their emissions by an average of 5.2 percent below 1990 levels by 2012. The first problem is the woefully low target. Britain needs to reduce its emissions by around 80 percent if we are to have any hope of dealing with climate change. Yet the treaty did at least mark a binding commitment to reducing emissions. Many people hoped that the Copenhagen Climate Change Summit would bring about necessary
results and a change in political direction however it didn’t culminate in anything. Sir N
icolas Stern
called it the “most important gathering since the Second World War”. However, Obama just turned
up for a couple of hours on the last day of the summit, gave a twenty-minute speech and flew back to the US again. The agreement that was reached is a pure joke. It committed itself to reducing carbon emissions by
10% by 2020. However, the hook is that the treaty isn’t legally binding and While Dubya didn’t sign the Kyoto Protocol he had introduced market mechanisms when he had
been Governor of Texas. He enabled companies to buy polluting permissions which turned Texas from one of the cleanest states with the lowest carbon emissions into one of the most polluted states with ever higher carbon emissions.
Market mechanisms to solve the climate crisis
The only way that states can possible imagine to solve the climate crisis is to continue to do what they always do: impose market mechanisms in order to reduce carbon emissions. Their assumption is if you give carbon emissions a price, then it will stimulate multinational companies to invest in newer technologies which produce less carbon emissions. However, the opposite has been proven to be true. As carbon emissions are bought and sold on the market and also speculated with multinational corporations ca
n buy the ‘right to pollute’ at very cheap cost rather than investing into new
technologies which undermine their profits. Following climate summits in Cancun, Bonn and Rio continued on a similar destructive path hailing a new era of global emissions trading, REDD programmes and others which exacerbate the problem of climate change rather than tackling the problems at the root.
Capitalism: The root of climate change
 Twinned with the inability of politicians and world leaders to solve the climate crisis today we see the environmentally disastrous practices of a system based upon profit accumulation.
For all the talk about ‘green growth’, ‘green enterprise’ or ‘green capitalism’ the logic of the system
based on profits means that one either stops being green, or one stops being a capitalist.
Already more than 150 years ago, Karl Marx summed up the attitude of capitalism as follows: ‘Apres moi, le deluge. (After me, the flood) That is Moses and the prophets’. More precisely, Marx and his
collaborator went o
n to analyse the effect that using guana (birds’ manure) as fertilizers was having
on European fields. Much to our surprise today they discovered that the very young capitalist system was at odds with the ecological system. Never would they have imagined the kind of environmental damages that the horrible extraction of oil from tar sands found in the Canadian forests of Alberta, to the nuclear power plants of Fukushima, to the BP oil spill of the Deepwater Horizon of the Gulf Coast. He identified the
metabolic rift
which meant that humans were at odds with their natural world.
The movements against climate change
 Over recent decades powerful movements against climate change have emerged. The Climate Justice movement has been a powerful political actor both inside the climate negotiations as well as outside in the streets, in the indigenous communities of the Global South and Black and Native American communities across North America. They have consistently argued that environmental destruction and climate change are not natural disasters but disproportionately impact depending on what class you belong to, or what colour of skin you have. For the climate justice movement it is not just about changing a few light bulbs or recycling but ultimately about changing the whole system
 whereas it remains ambigious whether they just see neoliberalism as the problem; or rather capitalism as a whole. The movements that have emerged across the Global South are inspirational. In the case of Bolivia, President Evo Morales even organised a 20 000-
strong People’s Assembly for
Mother Earth in 2010. It brought together indigenous peoples, trade unionists like the cocaleros, radical NGOs from the Global North and the Bolivian government.
While Morales’ rhetoric rem
ains radical, the recent construction of a highway (TIPNIS project) through indigenous lands has exposed the limitations of a left-wing government committed to saving the planet. In the summer of 2009, we saw a different kind of movement against climate change emerge in Britain. The Danish multinational windturbine company Vestas announced that it would close its only UK factory. 600 jobs were to go. Soon after socialists, environmental activists and most importantly the workers of the plant decided to occupy the windturbine factory on the Isle of Wight.

You're Reading a Free Preview

/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->