Professional Documents
Culture Documents
02 Carbon Literacy
Briefing
Cover image Jubilee Library,
Brighton. The library is designed
by Bennetts Associates to take
advantage of the natural energy
provided by the south coast setting
– specifically sunshine and wind.
The sun’s energy is gathered
through the south facing front
glazed wall in winter, with built-in
solar shading and automatically
opening vents to reduce solar
gain and glare in summer. Heat
generated by people and
equipment in the building is also
harnessed and re-used. Energy
use has been minimised, and
instead of air conditioning,
natural ventilation refreshes the
atmosphere inside and cools the
building. Wind towers on the roof
use the breeze to draw excess
heat from the floors below.
1
Introduction Carbon Dioxide Emissions
in Context
In 2003, carbon dioxide emissions In the 1960s, the famous American engineer
associated with energy use in the UK Richard Buckminster Fuller used to ask his Overall, each person in the UK is responsible
were approximately 560 million tonnes. audiences of engineers the question: ‘How for around ten tonnes of greenhouse gas
Almost half of this came from energy much does your building weigh?’ His interest emissions per year.
use in buildings. was in efficient designs that used less material
To provide some context a little closer to
Energy use in housing accounts for but, of course, nobody could ever answer
home, it is interesting to consider some of the
slightly more than half of the emissions his question.
carbon dioxide emissions associated with a
associated with energy use in all In the 1980s, in the wake of the 1981 OPEC oil typical UK family of four:
buildings, amounting to 27% of the embargo, another famous American engineer,
Energy use in the home (for heating, hot
UK total. Fred Dubin, asked his audience of architects
water, cooking, lighting and the use of
This document focuses on carbon literacy and engineers: ‘How will your building
appliances) results in carbon dioxide
related to buildings, but you need to take perform if it has to run on half as much
emissions of approximately six tonnes
into consideration the carbon impacts of energy as you expect it to need?’ Again,
per year2
transport and construction and other few could provide an answer.
Fuel used in an average family car, driven
processes and products, as well as wider Given the now established link between man-
an average number of miles, will produce
environmental impacts such as water made emissions from burning fossil fuels and
approximately four tonnes of carbon dioxide
efficiency, waste minimisation and climate change (see the RIBA Climate
per year (and a second car will account
sustainable drainage systems. More Change Briefing 1 ), the twenty-first century
for between two and four more tonnes)
information appears in the Government equivalent of Buckminster Fuller’s question is:
publication UK Energy Sector Indicators ‘How much carbon dioxide does your Travel by air to a family holiday at a
2008, which can be found at building emit?’ Mediterranean resort will give rise to
www.berr.gov.uk/files/file47147.pdf approximately four tonnes of carbon
When British architects are asked this
dioxide emissions
question, they rarely know the answer, so
they seem unlikely to know the answer to the Food on the family table (including
contemporary equivalent of Dubin’s question cultivation, harvesting, processing,
either. Even when architects do know how packaging, storage and distribution)
much carbon dioxide their buildings are will account for approximately seven
expected to emit, they rarely seem to know tonnes of carbon dioxide per year.
whether the answer is good or bad – perhaps
because they are unaware of benchmarks
against which to assess their buildings. The
advent of Energy Performance Certificates
and Display Energy Certificates is intended to
change this, by exposing the energy
performance of our buildings and comparing it
with appropriate benchmarks. In support of
this process, this guide explains the
relationship between buildings and carbon
dioxide emissions, and summarises some of
the existing benchmarks for building energy
use and the associated emissions.
1 The Climate Change Briefing UK emissions and sets out 2 This is a typical figure for the range of emissions,
that forms part of RIBA the challenge that climate an unimproved 1930s semi- across different types of
Climate Change Tools change presents to our detached house with a houses, is from less than two
explains the mechanisms of society newer, moderately efficient to more than twenty tonnes
climate change, summarises central heating system – but per year
2
Energy Basics If the house is electrically heated, by a 100%
efficient heater, then the delivered energy
The UK Government’s Energy White Energy is measured in joules (J). This is a very required is:
Papers in 2003 and 2007 established an small unit: 4,200 J are needed to raise the
3 kW x 24 hr = 72 kWh per day of electricity
‘aspirational’ target for reducing carbon temperature of 1 kilogramme of water by
dioxide emissions: 1 degree Celsius. However, if the house has an 80% efficient
gas boiler, then the delivered energy
‘to put ourselves on the path to cut the Temperature is a measure of the energy
required is:
UK’s carbon dioxide emissions by some content of a body or substance. It is measured
60% by about 2050, with real progress in degrees Celsius (OC) or degrees Kelvin (K), (3 kW x 24 hr)/0.8 = 90 kWh per day of gas
by 2020.’ which are essentially the same. Heat always The lower the efficiency of the heating
This became known as the ‘carbon 60’ flows from a hotter body or substance to a system, the more delivered energy is required
(or C60) target. cooler one. to supply the useful energy requirement.
3
Existing Buildings and New Build Carbon Dioxide Emissions The next three charts focus on the non-
The data in Figures 1 to 5 relate to from UK Buildings domestic building stock.
the existing building stock, which now
Figure 1 shows UK delivered energy in 2000, Figure 3 shows energy delivered to UK non-
consists of approximately two million
broken down by broad economic sectors. domestic buildings in 2000. Note that offices
non-domestic premises and
Delivered energy is the energy delivered by (including government offices), retail premises,
approximately 25 million dwellings.
the fuel industries to their customers, and the and hotels and catering accounted for over
The average rate of replacement of half of the total of 880 PJ. These sectors are
total across all sectors was 6,695 petajoules
the non-domestic building stock is the ones in which buildings are most likely to
(PJ = 1015 joules). It is clear that many of the
approximately 1% per year, but there be mechanically ventilated or air conditioned.
sectors on the chart will have involved some
is much variation between sectors,
level of energy use in buildings. Figure 4 shows carbon dioxide emissions
and significant growth.
Figure 2 shows energy delivered to UK associated with energy use in non-domestic
The average rate of replacement buildings, broken down by fuel type, in 2000.
buildings in 2000, broken into three sectors:
of the domestic building stock is Nearly two-thirds of the emissions (61%) were
domestic, commercial and public buildings and
approximately 0.5% per year, and associated with the use of electricity, most of
industrial buildings. At 3,122 PJ the total energy
there is significant growth (the number which was used for lighting, mechanical
delivered to buildings was approximately 47%
of dwellings has risen from 18 million ventilation, air conditioning and equipment
of the overall total from Figure 1, so buildings
in 1976 and is expected to reach 27 such as computers.
used nearly half of the energy delivered
million by 2020 – a 50% increase
in the UK. Figure 5 shows UK carbon dioxide emissions
in 44 years).
Note that the UK’s 25 million domestic associated with energy use in non-domestic
Currently the carbon dioxide emissions buildings in 2000, broken down by energy end-
buildings used 63% of the energy delivered
associated with energy use in new use. Note that heating accounted for nearly
to buildings, whilst the two million industrial,
buildings largely cancel out the half (41%) of carbon dioxide emissions and
commercial and public buildings accounted
reductions obtained by improvement lighting accounted for almost one quarter
for the remaining 37%.
of existing buildings. If overall (23%). Cooling and ventilation contributed a
reductions in carbon dioxide relatively modest 5%, but this figure is growing,
emissions are to be made, either and there is a danger of sustained growth if
the rate of improvement or the rate more buildings are air conditioned as an
of replacement of existing buildings adaptation to a warming climate.
must increase, or both.
Agriculture 1% Government 6%
Industrial buildings 9% Health 5%
Education 13%
Communications
and transport 1%
Commercial
Transport 35% Domestic 29% Commercial offices 11% Hotels and
and public catering 17%
buildings 28%
Warehouses
Domestic 63% 9% Other 15%
Industrial
process 18% Sports and Retail 19%
Commercial leisure 4%
and public
Total 6695PJ buildings 13% Total 3122PJ Total 880PJ
Industrial buildings 4%
Figure 4 Figure 5
Cooling and
Hot water 7%
ventilation 5%
Figure 1 UK delivered energy Figure 5 UK carbon dioxide
in 2000 emissions associated with Computers
Figure 2 Energy delivered to energy use in non-domestic 4%
UK buildings in 2000 buildings, in 2000, broken
Figure 3 Delivered energy in down by energy end-use Gas 31%
UK non-domestic buildings in (Source: CIBSE Guide F)
2000, broken down by sectors Catering 12% Heating 41%
Figure 4 UK carbon dioxide
emissions associated with Electicity 61% Process
energy use in non-domestic Oil 7% 3%
buildings in 2000, broken
Lighting 23%
down by fuel type
Other 5%
Total 81.1 Mt CO2 /year Solid fuels 1% Total 77.8 Mt CO2 /year
4
Carbon Dioxide Emissions Factors have no emissions associated with them, the
use of wood fuel does involve a relatively small
One of the reasons electricity accounts level of emissions. This is because, whilst the
for such a high proportion of carbon dioxide carbon dioxide emitted when wood is burnt is
emissions associated with energy use in almost exactly matched by the carbon dioxide
buildings is that more emissions arise from absorbed by the tree as it grows, the factor
using one unit of energy in the form of takes account of emissions associated with
electricity than, for example, one unit in the the use of fuel in felling (e.g. chainsaws)
form of natural gas. This is because the and transport.
process of generating electricity is relatively Other biofuels, for example biodiesel derived
inefficient, and emissions are calculated from from maize, have much higher emissions
‘primary energy’ – that is the fuel burnt in associated with cultivation, harvesting,
the power station (oil, coal, gas, etc). processing and distribution.
The relative emissions of different types Other renewable energy sources do have
of energy are expressed in terms of a carbon a carbon impact in terms of the materials
dioxide emissions factor. Electricity has a high used, production processes and transport
‘carbon dioxide emissions factor’ compared and distribution. However, the protocol for
with other fuels. Even with a proportion calculating emissions factors does not include
of nuclear generation, and an increasing these. You can find out more about the
contribution from renewable sources such emissions associated with products – known
as wind-power, the emissions factor for as embodied carbon or embodied energy –
grid electricity is more than twice that in The Green Guide to Specification
for mains gas. www.bre.co.uk/greenguide or in the Green
Table 1 sets out carbon dioxide emissions Building Handbook www.ribabookshops.com.
factors for various fuels, and their ratio with When designing a low carbon building, it is
the emissions factor for mains gas. (Note always better to incorporate building services
that these emissions factors do not account that use fuels with low emissions factors –
for emissions of other greenhouse gases.) or better still, use energy from a local
Although in terms of factors, renewable renewable source.
energy sources (e.g. solar water heating,
wind-power, local photovoltaic electricity)
Table 1 Carbon dioxide 3 The published emissions generation industry, to 2010. be approximately 0.55 2010, and include a significant that North Sea gas is
emissions factors for some factors for electricity are These projections have not kgCO2/kWh, which is 2.84 increase in the factor for grid becoming exhausted.
common fuels (source: based on the Government’s been borne out, and the times that for mains gas. The electricity, due to a reversion
SAP 2005) forward projections of the current emissions factor for published emissions factors to coal-fired generation now
‘dash for gas’ in the electricity grid electricity is thought to are expected to be revised in
5
Energy Use and Emissions For each property type, a table presents
Benchmarks for Buildings the estimated emissions when the house
is designed and specified to meet the
To establish energy efficiency and carbon current Building Regulations4, and the Code
dioxide emissions standards, we need for Sustainable Homes Levels 3, 4, 5 and 6.
‘benchmarks’, or indicators of the levels of Each table incorporates a chart showing
energy use and emissions that might be the relative level of carbon dioxide emissions
considered typical, and those associated for each specification.
with good practice in low carbon design
and refurbishment. About the Tables
The first column identifies the five
Domestic Buildings specifications; the second column shows the
The sections below set out carbon dioxide Dwelling Carbon Dioxide Emissions Rate (DER)
emissions for three typical new-build in kgCO2/m2/year; and the third column shows
dwellings: the carbon dioxide emissions predicted by
A two-bedroom flat (60 m2) SAP, in tonnes/year. These figures only include
emissions associated with energy use for
A three-bedroom semi-detached
heating, hot water and lighting; the emissions
house (83 m2)
associated with cooking and the use of
A three-bedroom, three-storey town domestic appliances are not included. The
house (98 m2). fourth column of each table shows the total
carbon dioxide emissions, in tonnes/year,
including those associated with heating, hot
water, cooking, lighting and the use of
appliances5.
4 The house conforms to the the Dwelling Carbon Dioxide 5 All data in figures 6 to 8 BREDEM-12 based NHER Plan were made available for
guidance in the Approved Emissions Rate (DER) is equal have been calculated by Assessor (SAP 2005) analysis courtesy of Bellway
Document to Part L1A of the to the Target Carbon Dioxide Rickaby Thompson software, under standard Homes, BMH Construction
Building Regulations (2006); Emissions Rate (TER) Associates Ltd, using occupancy. Dwelling designs and Careys
6
Figure 6 This example relates to a two-bedroom flat, mid-floor, mid-block with a floor area of 60m2
Figure 7 This example relates to a two-storey, three-bedroom, semi-detached house with a floor area of 83m2
Figure 8 This example relates to three-storey, three-bedroom, mid-terraced townhouse with a floor area of 98m2
7
Non-Domestic Buildings The CIBSE benchmarks relate to buildings
The non-domestic building stock is far less without renewable energy systems, and are
homogenous than the domestic stock – not particularly challenging. Other benchmarks
there are far more building types. and best practice standards may be found in
some of the Carbon Trust’s publications7,
Energy use in non-domestic buildings and
and a new but limited set of benchmarks has
the associated carbon dioxide emissions
been developed for Energy Performance
are dependent on five key factors:
Certificates (EPCs) and Display Energy
Building form Certificates (DECs). The Passive House
Building fabric standard (which may be applied to non-
Building services domestic buildings) sets a more challenging
performance target of 15kWh/m2/yr for space
Activity accommodated
heating demand and 120kWh/m2/yr for
Management of the building. primary energy use. See the guide to Low
Even amongst buildings of a common type Carbon Standards and Assessment Methods
such as ‘offices’ there are many different that forms part of the RIBA Climate Change
combinations of these factors: some offices Tools for further information.
are in purpose-built blocks, but many are Figures 9 to 16 illustrate the CIBSE
in converted terraced houses or attached benchmarks for energy use and the
to industrial buildings; some offices have associated carbon dioxide emissions for
central plant HVAC systems, but many have four types of existing buildings: offices, retail
domestic-scale heating systems and rely on buildings, industrial buildings and schools.
natural ventilation. Similar observations may be In each case, ‘typical’ and ‘good practice’
made about retail buildings, industrial buildings, benchmarks are given8. For the reasons
educational buildings and healthcare buildings. explained above the spread of performance
Because of this diversity, it is very difficult of existing buildings is very much wider
to establish benchmarks for building than indicated by the benchmarks – the
performance. A widely-used UK source of this performance of many buildings is worse than
information is CIBSE Guide F Energy Efficiency ‘typical’, and in some cases performance
in Buildings6, Part C of which presents energy is better than ‘good practice’.
benchmarks for many different types of non- Where existing buildings are to be refurbished,
domestic buildings. These benchmarks have it is appropriate to adopt energy standards
been derived from a wide variety of sources equivalent to the appropriate good practice
with a focus on measured (not predicted) benchmark, or better.
energy use in existing buildings.
When new buildings are being designed it is
appropriate to adopt energy standards at least
equivalent to ‘good practice’, and moving
towards low- or zero-carbon standards.
6 CIBSE Energy Efficiency in 7 See 8 In 2007, a review for CIBSE but limited set of stringent buildings. The development intended to have consistent
Buildings Guide F, Chartered www.carbontrust.co.uk/ and CLG concluded that statutory benchmarks has of voluntary benchmarks for technical underpinnings
Institute of Building Services publications these benchmarks are therefore been developed for different building sectors is related to agreed allowances
Engineers, London, 2004 inconsistent, out of date and use on Display Energy also being encouraged. All of for buildings’ needs, rather
overdue for review. A new Certificates for public these new benchmarks are than historical statistics
8
Offices
Figure 9 Energy benchmarks for office buildings (Source: CIBSE Guide F) Typical practice
Figures 9 and 10 illustrate the CIBSE
benchmarks for office buildings. Four Offices energy use Good practice
9
Figure 11
Retail Buildings
Figures 11 and 12 illustrate the CIBSE Retail energy use
benchmarks for retail buildings, the stock (kWh/m2/yr)
of which is very diverse. The figures Banks
199
134
demonstrate the significant increase in energy 280
use and the associated emissions with depth Post offices 185
of plan (e.g. in department stores), because 352
DIY stores 276
of the increased use of artificial lighting and 542
mechanical ventilation, and with refrigeration Department stores 431
(e.g. in food stores). Supermarkets are typically 600
Small food shops 480
deep-plan buildings that combine high levels 1287
Supermarkets 0 300 600 900 1200
1115 1500
of artificial lighting with mechanical ventilation
and refrigeration.
0 300 600 900 1200 1500
Figure 11 Energy use Figure 12
benchmarks for retail
buildings (Source: CIBSE
Guide F)
Retail carbon dioxide
emissions (kg/m2/yr)
Figure 12 Carbon dioxide
emissions benchmarks for 62
retail buildings Banks 40
(Source: CIBSE Guide F) 70
Post offices 46
105
DIY stores 83
172
Department stores 138
230
Small food shops 184
484
Supermarkets 425
125
General manufacturing 91
115
Factory-office 80
76
Storage and distribution 47
110
Light manufacturing 65
Typical practice
10
Figure 15 Schools
11
Energy Performance Certificates the 2002 Building Regulations, with gas-fired
and Display Energy Certificates heating and hot water services, and in which
each space is heated and cooled to fixed set-
Energy Performance Certificates (EPCs) are points (irrespective of whether the equivalent
required when a new building is first occupied, spaces in the actual building are heated or
and whenever its occupancy changes – cooled or not). A gas-heated building that
that is, when it is sold or when there is is just compliant with the 2006 Building
a new tenancy. Regulations will have an Asset Rating of 100.
Display Energy Certificates (DECs) are A better performing building (i.e. one with
required for some publicly accessible buildings. lower carbon dioxide emissions) will have
a lower Asset Rating. EPCs present Asset
For dwellings, EPCs report the SAP energy
Ratings on a banded A–G scale, where
ratings and Environmental Impact Ratings (EIRs,
A represents excellent performance and
based on the SAP carbon dioxide emissions)
G represents very poor performance:
on a banded A–G scale:
A 0–25
A 92–100
B 25–50
B 81–91
C 51–75
C 69–80
D 76–100
D 55–68
E 101–125
E 39–54
F 126–150
F 21–38
G Over 150
G 1–20
In addition, an A+ rating is assigned to
Band A represents excellent performance
buildings with less than net zero carbon
(i.e. low fuel costs and low emissions) and
dioxide emissions, i.e. buildings that export
band G represents very poor performance
more locally generated renewable energy
(i.e. high fuel costs and high emissions). Note
than they take from the grid.
that a high SAP represents good performance.
EPCs also report the minimum standard
For non-domestic buildings, EPCs report
of performance required by the Building
A
‘ sset Ratings’ and/or ‘Operational Ratings’;
Regulations (the Target Emission Rate, TER)
they are intended to send market signals
and the performance of a ‘typical’ building
about the relative performance of comparable
Energy efficiency and
that would comply with the 1995 Building
buildings.
environmental impact ratings Regulations.
on a domestic EPC The Asset Rating of a new building is the
The Operational Rating of a building is
ratio of the predicted carbon dioxide emissions
determined some time after the building
from the building (the Building Emission Rate,
has been occupied, from measured energy
BER) to a Standard Emission Rate (SER). The
use data according to an assessment and
BER is calculated by approved software (e.g.
reporting methodology developed by CIBSE.
an implementation of the Simplified Building
It is shown on a Display Energy Certificate.
Energy Model, SBEM).
More detailed information about energy ratings
The SER is the Reference Emission Rate (RER)
and emission rates can be found in the RIBA
multiplied by 0.765, and the RER is calculated
Climate Change guide on Low Carbon
for a reference building of the same size and
Standards and Assessment Methods.
shape as the actual building, specified to meet
12
Acknowledgements
The RIBA wishes to thank CIBSE for permission to reproduce
the energy benchmarks from CIBSE Guide F Energy Efficiency
in this guide.
This document is based upon work undertaken for the RIBA by:
Peter Rickaby (Rickaby Thompson Associates Ltd)
Ben Cartmel (SouthFacing Ltd)
Liz Warren (SE2 Ltd)
John Willoughby (Energy and environmental design consultant)
Rachael Wilson (Rickaby Thompson Associates Ltd)