FINAL ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT

Volume II

Proposed Project:

Newport Marine Club

Project Location:

500 Newport Road

Town of Irondequoit
Monroe County, New York

Project Sponsor / Applicant:

RSM Irondequoit Bay Development, LLC

Lead Agency:

Town of Irondequoit Planning Board

Town of Irondequoit Town Hall
1280 Titus Avenue
Rochester, New York 14617

November 23, 2009

 FINAL ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT (FEIS)

PROPOSED NEWPORT MARINE CLUB

TOWN OF IRONDEQUOIT, MONROE COUNTY, NEW YORK

Positive Declaration Issued: June 23, 2008

Public Scoping Session Held: July 23, 2008

Final Scope Accepted: August 11, 2008

Draft Environmental Impact Statement

Accepted by Planning Board: February 10, 2009

Public Meeting held on DEIS: March 9, 2009

Contact Person: Anthony Favro

Town of Irondequoit
Planning and Zoning Office
1280 Titus Avenue
Rochester, New York 14617
Phone: (585) 467-8840

ii
 FINAL ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT
NEWPORT MARINE CLUB

TABLE OF CONTENTS
Volume I

1.0 Executive Summary ........................................................................................ 1

2.0 Draft Environmental Impact Statement .............................................................. 2

3.0 Corrections to the Draft Environmental Impact Statement .................................... 2

4.0 Substantive Comments to the Draft Environmental Impact Statement

and Responses................................................................................................. 3

Tables

Table 1 Comment List by Number .............................................................. 5

Table 2 Comment List by Topic................................................................ 11

Table 3 Alternative Comparison ............................................................. 148

Table 4 Comparable Waterfront Developments ........................................ 156

Figures

Figure 1 Development Density (units/acre) .............................................. 156

Figure 2 Elevations of Bayfront Structures ............................................... 157

Exhibits

Exhibit 1 Line of Sight from Newport Road .................................................. E1

Exhibit 2 Emergency Vehicle Turnaround at Newport Marine Club .................. E2

Exhibit 3 Photo – Simulation (Mooring Line Drive) Alternative C .................... E3

Volume II

Appendices

A1 Written comments received by the Town of Irondequoit ......................... A1-1

A2 Transcript of the Town of Irondequoit Planning Board SEQR Public Hearing,

March 9, 2009 .................................................................................. A2-1

iii
A3 Notes from a Town of Irondequoit Planning Board
meeting of March 23, 2009................................................................. A3-1

A4 Letter dated February 19, 2009 from Costich Engineering, P.C.

to the Town of Irondequoit and the Ridge Culver Fire District.................. A4-1

A5 Letter dated August 17, 2009 from the Office of Fire Marshall and Ridge
Culver Fire District............................................................................. A5-1

A6 Phase II – Environmental Site Assessment Data Report, Day Environmental,

Inc. dated May 2007.......................................................................... A6-1

A7 New York State Department of Environmental Conservation Permit No. 80-85-

0147. Install seasonal floating docks .................................................. A7-1

A8 Correspondence associated with Newport Road ..................................... A8-1

A9 Town of Irondequoit Capital Improvement Program (CIP) 2010-2015 dated

6/5/2009 ......................................................................................... A9-1

A10 Town of Irondequoit Town Board Resolution (8A.2009-3) ..................... A10-3

iv
ABBREVIATIONS

Abbreviation Description
CIP Capital Improvement Program
DEIS Draft Environmental Impact Statement
ECL Environmental Conservation Law
EIS Environmental Impact Statement
EPOD, EPODs Environmental Protection Overlay District(s)
FedEx Federal Express
FEIS Final Environmental Impact Statement
HA Harbor Area Zone
HML Irondequoit Bay Harbor Management Law
HMP Irondequoit Bay Harbor Management Plan
HOA Homeowner’s Association
HSG Hydrologic Soils Group
ILUC Irondequoit Land Use Coalition
LLC Limited Liability Company
LWRP Local Waterfront Revitalization Program
MS4 Municipal Separate Storm Sewer System
NYCRR New York Codes Rules and Regulations
NYS New York State
NYSDEC New York State Department of Environmental Conservation
NYSSMDM New York State Stormwater Management Design Manual
P.C. Professional Corporation
RP Resource Protection Zone
RSM RSM Irondequoit Bay Development, LLC
SEQR State Environmental Quality Review
SEQRA State Environmental Quality Review Act
SPDES State Pollution Discharge Elimination System
SWPPP Stormwater Pollution Prevention Plan
UPS United Parcel Service
WD Waterfront Development

REFERENCE DOCUMENTS

Article IX – Town Code - Waterfront Development (WD) District –

www.ecode360.com/?CustId=IR0059

Irondequoit Bay Harbor Management Law (HML) September 16, 2008–

www.irondequoit.org/images/PublicWorks/harborlaw.pdf

Irondequoit Bay Harbor Management Plan (HMP) November 2003 –

www.newportyc.org/IBHMP2005/index.html

Master Plan for the Town of Irondequoit New York – Adopted December 1985
www.irondequoit.org/content/view/254/833

Town of Irondequoit Local Waterfront Revitalization Program (LWRP) Adopted April 21, 1988
www.irondequoit.org/content/view/296/1096

v
  
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
APPENDIX A1 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
A1 - 1
A1 - 2
A1 - 3
A1 - 4
A1 - 5
A1 - 6
Pages have been intentionally omitted. A1 - 7 to A1 - 18
A1 - 19
A1 - 20
A1 - 21
A1 - 22
A1 - 23
A1 - 24
A1 - 25
A1 - 26
A1 - 27
A1 - 28
A1 - 29
A1 - 30
A1 - 31
A1 - 32
A1 - 33
A1 - 34
A1 - 35
A1 - 36
A1 - 37
A1 - 38
A1 - 39
A1 - 40
A1 - 41
A1 - 42
A1 - 43
A1 - 44
A1 - 45
A1 - 46
A1 - 47
A1 - 48
A1 - 49
A1 - 50
A1 - 51
A1 - 52
A1 - 53
A1 - 54
A1 - 55
A1 - 56
A1 - 57
A1 - 58
A1 - 59
A1 - 60
A1 - 61
A1 - 62
A1 - 63
A1 - 64
A1 - 65
A1 - 66
A1 - 67
A1 - 68
A1 - 69
A1 - 70
A1 - 71
A1 - 72
A1 - 73
A1 - 74
A1 - 75
A1 - 76
A1 - 77
A1 - 78
A1 - 79
A1 - 80
A1 - 81
A1 - 82
A1 - 83
A1 - 84
A1 - 85
A1 - 86
A1 - 87
A1 - 88
A1 - 89
A1 - 90
A1 - 91
A1 - 92
A1 - 93
A1 - 94
A1 - 95
A1 - 96
A1 - 97
A1 - 98
A1 - 99
A1 - 100
A1 - 101
A1 - 102
A1 - 103
A1 - 104
A1 - 105
A1 - 106
A1 - 107
A1 - 108
A1 - 109
A1 - 110
A1 - 111
A1 - 112
A1 - 113
A1 - 114
A1 - 115
A1 - 116
A1 - 117
A1 - 118
A1 - 119
A1 - 120
A1 - 121
A1 - 122
A1 - 123
A1 - 124
A1 - 125
A1 - 126
A1 - 127
A1 - 128
  
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
APPENDIX A2 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
A2 - 1
A2 - 2
A2 - 3
A2 - 4
A2 - 5
A2 - 6
A2 - 7
A2 - 8
A2 - 9
A2 - 10
A2 - 11
A2 - 12
A2 - 13
A2 - 14
A2 - 15
A2 - 16
A2 - 17
A2 - 18
A2 - 19
A2 - 20
A2 - 21
A2 - 22
A2 - 23
A2 - 24
A2 - 25
A2 - 26
A2 - 27
A2 - 28
A2 - 29
A2 - 30
A2 - 31
A2 - 32
A2 - 33
A2 - 34
A2 - 35
A2 - 36
A2 - 37
A2 - 38
A2 - 39
A2 - 40
A2 - 41
A2 - 42
A2 - 43
A2 - 44
A2 - 45
A2 - 46
A2 - 47
A2 - 48
A2 - 49
A2 - 50
A2 - 51
A2 - 52
A2 - 53
A2 - 54
A2 - 55
A2 - 56
A2 - 57
A2 - 58
A2 - 59
A2 - 60
A2 - 61
A2 - 62
A2 - 63
A2 - 64
  
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
APPENDIX A3 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
A3 - 1
A3 - 2
A3 - 3
  
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
APPENDIX A4 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
A4 - 1
A4 - 2
  
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
APPENDIX A5 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
A5 -1
  
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
APPENDIX A6 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
A6 - 1
A6 - 2
A6 - 3
A6 - 4
A6 - 5
A6 - 6
A6 - 7
A6 - 8
A6 - 9
A6 - 10
A6 - 11
A6 - 12
A6 - 13
A6 - 14
A6 - 15
A6 - 16
A6 - 17
A6 - 18
A6 - 19
A6 - 20
A6 - 21
A6 - 22
A6 - 23
A6 - 24
A6 - 25
A6 - 26
A6 - 27
A6 - 28
A6 - 29
A6 - 30
A6 - 31
A6 - 32
A6 - 33
A6 - 34
A6 - 35
A6 - 36
A6 - 37
A6 - 38
A6 - 39
A6 - 40
A6 - 41
A6 - 42
A6 - 43
A6 - 44
A6 - 45
A6 - 46
A6 - 47
A6 - 48
A6 - 49
A6 - 50
A6 - 51
A6 - 52
A6 - 53
A6 - 54
A6 - 55
A6 - 56
A6 - 57
A6 - 58
A6 - 59
A6 - 60
A6 - 61
A6 - 62
A6 - 63
A6 - 64
A6 - 65
A6 - 66
A6 - 67
A6 - 68
A6 - 69
A6 - 70
A6 - 71
A6 - 72
A6 - 73
A6 - 74
A6 - 75
A6 - 76
A6 - 77
A6 - 78
A6 - 79
A6 - 80
A6 - 81
A6 - 82
A6 - 83
A6 - 84
A6 - 85
A6 - 86
A6 - 87
A6 - 88
A6 - 89
A6 - 90
A6 - 91
A6 - 92
A6 - 93
A6 - 94
A6 - 95
A6 - 96
A6 - 97
A6 - 98
A6 - 99
A6 - 100
A6 - 101
A6 - 102
A6 - 103
A6 - 104
A6 - 105
A6 - 106
A6 - 107
A6 - 108
A6 - 109
A6 - 110
A6 - 111
A6 - 112
A6 - 113
A6 - 114
A6 - 115
A6 - 116
A6 - 117
A6 - 118
A6 - 119
A6 - 120
A6 - 121
A6 - 122
A6 - 123
A6 - 124
A6 - 125
A6 - 126
A6 - 127
A6 - 128
A6 - 129
A6 - 130
A6 - 131
A6 - 132
A6 - 133
A6 - 134
A6 - 135
A6 - 136
A6 - 137
A6 - 138
A6 - 139
A6 - 140
A6 - 141
A6 - 142
A6 - 143
  
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
APPENDIX A7 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
A7 - 1
A7 - 2
A7 - 3
A7 - 4
A7 - 5
  
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
APPENDIX A8 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
A8 - 1
A8 - 2
A8 - 3
A8 - 4
A8 - 5
A8 - 6
A8 - 7
A8 - 8
A8 - 9
A8 - 10
A8 - 11
A8 - 12
A8 - 13
A8 - 14
A8 - 15
A8 - 16
A8 - 17
A8 - 18
A8 - 19
A8 - 20
A8 - 21
A8 - 22
A8 - 23
  
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
APPENDIX A9 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
A9 - 1
A9 - 2
A9 - 3
A9 - 4
A9 - 5
A9 - 6
A9 - 7
A9 - 8
A9 - 9
A9 - 10
A9 - 11
A9 - 12
A9 - 13
A9 - 14
A9 - 15
A9 - 16
  
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
APPENDIX A10 
 
A10 - 1