Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Reference : PE/IRC/DD/0012
Version : 01.03 / EN
Date : 20/07/98
Ext. ref. : ....
Type : TYP
Product : PRD
Cat : I
Status : A
Author : S. Le Graët
Approved by : C. Moreau
This confidential document is the property of NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR and may not be copied or circulated without permission
Ce document confidentiel est la propriété de NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR et ne peut être reproduit ou communiqué sans autorisation
DOCUMENT AMENDMENTS
This confidential document is the property of NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR and may not be copied or circulated without permission
Ce document confidentiel est la propriété de NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR et ne peut être reproduit ou communiqué sans autorisation
This confidential document is the property of NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR and may not be copied or circulated without permission
Ce document confidentiel est la propriété de NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR et ne peut être reproduit ou communiqué sans autorisation
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1. INTRODUCTION................................................................................................................. 3
1.1. OBJECT................................................................................................................... 3
This confidential document is the property of NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR and may not be copied or circulated without permission
Ce document confidentiel est la propriété de NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR et ne peut être reproduit ou communiqué sans autorisation
1.2. SCOPE
This document is compliant with BSS releases until V10.
First this document explains frequency hopping principle and benefits. The two (2)
types of frequency hopping (baseband and synthesised) are described and compared.
Then, engineering rules are given for synthesised frequency hopping.
This confidential document is the property of NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR and may not be copied or circulated without permission
Ce document confidentiel est la propriété de NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR et ne peut être reproduit ou communiqué sans autorisation
This confidential document is the property of NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR and may not be copied or circulated without permission
Ce document confidentiel est la propriété de NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR et ne peut être reproduit ou communiqué sans autorisation
3.2. DEFINITIONS
MTBF It is a mathematical time expectancy between two successive parts of
equipment or unit failure
This confidential document is the property of NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR and may not be copied or circulated without permission
Ce document confidentiel est la propriété de NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR et ne peut être reproduit ou communiqué sans autorisation
Basically, Frequency Hopping aim is to spread the spectrum of the signal to minimise the impact of
potential interferers. Frequency Hopping consists in changing the frequency used by a channel at
regular intervals.
In GSM, the transmission frequency remains the same during the transmission of a whole burst. Thus,
it is possible to have different frequencies on each burst of a frame. The radio interface of GSM uses
then slow Frequency Hopping.
According to the type of coupler used in the BTS, two (2) main types of Frequency Hopping
mechanism can be used :
• Synthesised mode for Hybrid couplers with duplexers (hopping time slots can hop on a large
band of frequencies)
• Baseband mode using Cavity couplers with duplexers (hopping time slots can hop on a set of
frequencies limited by the number of TRXs) - Only available with S4000 BTS.
Remark:
It is also possible to use baseband frequency hopping for hybrid couplers with duplexers, when not
using hopping BCCH (pseudo Baseband Frequency Hopping). However the interest of having
hybrid couplers is lost (possibility to have more frequencies than TRX with hybrid couplers though
baseband needs exactly the same number of frequencies than TRX).
Using frequency hopping allows to adapt and maximise the frequency re-use pattern efficiency by
maximising the capacity in term of offered Erlang/Mhz/km². The pattern to use will depend on the
available frequency band and the traffic requirement.
With frequency hopping, instead of having determined frequencies for TCH, TCH TRXs can hop on
several frequency groups.
It is possible (and recommended) to mix different frequency re-use technique, as 4:12 for BCCH and
1:3 or 1:1 for TCH. Indeed, a traditional 4:12 reuse pattern is appropriate to a wide spectrum allocation
as for BCCH frequency (only one frequency per cell is needed). However, in order to increase the
number of TRX per cell with a given frequency band, in keeping a low interference level, the only
solution is to use more restricting reuse pattern, as 1:1 or 1:3.
This confidential document is the property of NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR and may not be copied or circulated without permission
Ce document confidentiel est la propriété de NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR et ne peut être reproduit ou communiqué sans autorisation
Example
Here below is an example of spectrum efficiency, according to the type of frequency re-use pattern.
This application is supposing 30 RF carriers in a 6 MHz allocation for trisectorial cells, using a 4:12
reuse pattern for BCCH.
30 Carriers 30 Carriers
30 /12 = 2 or 3 - 12 for BCCH - 12 for BCCH
18 for TCH 18 /3 = 6 18 for TCH
11TRX
TRXfor
forBCCH
BCCHnonnonhopping
hopping 11TRX
TRXforforBCCH
BCCHnon
nonhopping
hopping 11TRX
TRXforforBCCH
BCCHnon
nonhopping
hopping
11or
or22TRX
TRXonon11 frequency
frequency(no
(noFH)
FH) up
uptoto33TRX
TRXhopping
hoppingon
on66 up
up to 4 TRX hoppingon
to 4 TRX hopping on18
18
frequencies
frequencies frequencies
frequencies
It is obvious with this example that frequency hopping associated to fractional re-use patterns leads to
a subsequent gain in terms of offered Erlangs per cell.
This confidential document is the property of NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR and may not be copied or circulated without permission
Ce document confidentiel est la propriété de NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR et ne peut être reproduit ou communiqué sans autorisation
The two main advantages of Frequency Hopping are interferer and frequency diversity.
• The first-one (interferer diversity) is minimising the standard deviation of the C/I distribution law
• The second-one (frequency diversity) allows to lower the impact of Rayleigh Fading for slow
mobiles.
The Rayleigh fading is a high attenuation of the signal at a given point, due to multiple path. The
area with fading or fading hole has a very small size which is directly dependant on the frequency of
the signal.
Negative effects of deep Rayleigh fading holes can therefore be counter-balanced. Such a robust
behaviour is especially useful for slow-moving mobiles, which are more likely to experiment low field
levels due to fast fading.
When moving, the mobile is obviously less sensitive to these fading holes and looses few information
which does not decrease the voice quality. But when not moving or in case of slow moving (e.g.
pedestrian) a mobile may stay during a long time under the same Rayleigh fading effect and loose a
significant amount of information.
For two different frequencies the Rayleigh fading is not at the same place (the distance between two
fading holes is λ/2). So with Frequency Hopping, during the same time the mobile can be considered
like if it was under different fast fading effects : the frequency hopping simulates the movement for a
fixed mobile.
dB
10
0
1
-5
F requency 1
( or T ime 1)
-10
F requency 2
-15
( or T ime 2 )
-20
-25
T ime ( or
F requency )
-30
This confidential document is the property of NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR and may not be copied or circulated without permission
Ce document confidentiel est la propriété de NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR et ne peut être reproduit ou communiqué sans autorisation
GSM Channel coding and frame interleaving allow to spread interference across the time and
frequency axes, thanks to frequency hopping activation between consecutive time slots.
As shown on the next diagram, the RxQual parameter is computed as the average over all the burst of
a SACCH period (104 consecutive bursts in case of TCH channel without DTX) of the bit error rate
(BER) before decoding. The frame erasure rate (FER) is evaluated once the 8 bursts which constitute a
full speech frame (456 coded bits interleaved in 8 half-bursts of 57 bits each) is decoded.
In the case of networks with small spectrum allocation, high instantaneous interference levels can be
expected. However, frequency hopping allows to take advantage of jammer diversity, spreading
interference across the network, which can therefore result in improvements of high RxQual values but
also in degradation of low RxQual values (tighter RxQual distribution).
Therefore, RxQual thresholds should be increased by one (1) or two (2) units when using frequency
hopping, in order to avoid an increase of handover on quality criteria.
As frequency hopping spreads over space and time the effects of fading and interferers, FER decreases
when frequency hopping is enabled.
This confidential document is the property of NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR and may not be copied or circulated without permission
Ce document confidentiel est la propriété de NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR et ne peut être reproduit ou communiqué sans autorisation
measure in BER
After Forward Error Correction :
measure in FER
It is remained that each voice frame of 20 ms is spread over 4 frames of 5 ms each. The BER Bite
Error Rate) is computed on each 5 ms frame and the FER (Frame Erasure Rate) on each 20 ms frame
after the decoding/interleaving. Hence the FER is the best way to estimate the subjective voice quality.
For handset mobiles, frequency hopping brings a high improvement. This gain is particularly
interesting since four (4) frequencies are used for frequency hopping.
Furthermore, the following curve highlights that for a given frequency hopping configuration, the gain
is particularly high when the speed of mobiles is low (less than 20 km/h).
12,00
10,00 1 km/h
3 km/h
5 km/h
8,00 10 km/h
50 km/h
FER(%)
6,00
4,00
2,00
0,00
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
NUMBER OF FREQUENCIES FOR HOPPING
• up to 8 frequencies, the higher the number of frequencies in the hopping law, the smaller the
Fading margin taken into account in the link budget (due to Rayleigh fading).
• the smaller the mobile speed and the higher the number of frequencies, the higher the benefit of the
frequency hopping.
• the higher the number of frequencies in the hopping law, the narrower the Rxqual distribution.
However Rxqual mean remains the same (see figure below). Hence the Frequency Hopping
eliminates the number of bad Rxqual samples but it also reduces the number of good Rxqual ones.
This confidential document is the property of NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR and may not be copied or circulated without permission
Ce document confidentiel est la propriété de NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR et ne peut être reproduit ou communiqué sans autorisation
90
80
70
60
50
40 NO FH
4 freq
30 8 freq
16 freq
20
10
0
0 2 4 6 8 10
BER %
• Resistance to interference
- spread of interference over all RF spectrum
- spread of interference over time
- highly loaded sites benefit from lower load on adjacent sites
- more efficient error correction gain from digital processing
4.1.3.1. Principle
Using baseband frequency hopping, each TX is dedicated to one frequency and is connected to all the
Frame Processor (TDMA) via the FH bus. It is used with cavity coupling system. It uses exactly the
same number of frequencies as TRXs.
The filling is done by the FP according to the configuration of the TDMA (all the parameters for the
frequency hopping are static and not per call basis ; so even if there is no call the FP knows if it has to
transmit on the BCCH frequency).
This confidential document is the property of NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR and may not be copied or circulated without permission
Ce document confidentiel est la propriété de NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR et ne peut être reproduit ou communiqué sans autorisation
BCCH Freq
FP1 TX1
FP2 TX2
FP3 TX3
FP4 TX4
For a given cell with the previous configuration (4 TRX), two Mobiles Allocations would be defined :
- MA1 is used with the complete set of frequencies available to hop on (including the BCCH
frequency), then four (4) frequencies.
- MA0 does not contain the BCCH to be able to hop on three (3) frequencies (MA1-BCCH frequency)
with the TS in the TDMA0.
TS 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
TDMA 0 F1 MA1 MA1 MA1 MA1 MA1 MA1 MA1 MAIO = 0
TDMA 1 MA0 MA1 MA1 MA1 MA1 MA1 MA1 MA1 MAIO = 1
TDMA 2 MA0 MA1 MA1 MA1 MA1 MA1 MA1 MA1 MAIO = 2
TDMA 3 MA0 MA1 MA1 MA1 MA1 MA1 MA1 MA1 MAIO = 3
This confidential document is the property of NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR and may not be copied or circulated without permission
Ce document confidentiel est la propriété de NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR et ne peut être reproduit ou communiqué sans autorisation
TS 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
TDMA 0 F1 F1 F1 F1 F1 F1 F1 F1 MAIO = 0
TDMA 1 MA0 MA0 MA0 MA0 MA0 MA0 MA0 MA0 MAIO = 1
TDMA 2 MA0 MA0 MA0 MA0 MA0 MA0 MA0 MA0 MAIO = 2
TDMA 3 MA0 MA0 MA0 MA0 MA0 MA0 MA0 MA0 MAIO = 3
Caution : it is not recommended to hop on BCCH frequency when using baseband frequency hopping,
because it can lead to some troubles when downlink DTX or downlink power control are enabled.
With the baseband frequency hopping mechanism, it is possible to reconfigure the frequencies in
certain cases. The process is started by BSC in case of equipment failure/recovery within a TRX, for a
Radio Cell which supports frequency hopping and uses the Frequency Management GSM function.
This function is supported by the TRX and allows the BSC to configure or to reset a frequency on a
TX which is identified by the TEI of the corresponding TRX. The loss of one TX implies the loss of
one frequency (which is not the BCCH) and of one TDMA (the one defined with the lowest priority) if
no redundant TRX.
Two symmetric mechanisms are managed by the BSC to handle the automatic frequency
reconfiguration in the case of frequency hopping cavity coupling BTS:
- loss of a frequency: the cell is stopped and restarted with new set of frequencies. This may lead
to release the calls.
- recovery of all frequencies: an automatic reconfiguration is triggered by the BSC when all the
frequencies are recovered. This may lead to release the calls.
There will be a reconfiguration if the flag bscHopReconfUse = True (defined at BSC level) and if there
are more frequencies than the threshold btsThresholdHopReconf (defined at BTS level). Otherwise the
cell is badly configured.
When a end of fault occurs if the flag btsHopReconfRestart = True and if there are more frequencies
than the threshold (btsThresholdHopReconf), there is a complete cell reconfiguration.
This confidential document is the property of NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR and may not be copied or circulated without permission
Ce document confidentiel est la propriété de NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR et ne peut être reproduit ou communiqué sans autorisation
Using synthesised frequency hopping, each TX is associated to one FP (TDMA) and can transmit on
all the frequencies. It is used with hybrid coupling systems and can use more frequencies than TRXs.
The main issue is to ensure that the frequency BCCH is transmitted all the time (on all the TS of the
TDMA) at a constant power even if there is no call to transmit (no voice or data burst). This is done by
a specific configuration which consists in dedicating a TRX to the BCCH frequency (so the TDMA
called BCCH does not hop)
Generally, the number of frequencies is greater than the number of TRX in order to have the smallest
Fading margin in the link budget.
FH bus
FP1 TX1
FP2 TX2
FP3 TX3
The TDMA configurations in case of synthesised frequency hopping are defined as follows :
• F1 is the BCCH frequency.
• the other two TDMA of the cell have the same MA. HSN and MAIO can be different (see
Engineering Rules in chapter 4.2).
This confidential document is the property of NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR and may not be copied or circulated without permission
Ce document confidentiel est la propriété de NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR et ne peut être reproduit ou communiqué sans autorisation
Tests have shown that if DTX downlink and Power Control downlink are activated simultaneously
when using baseband frequency hopping, it could lead to quality degradation and eventually to call
drops for some mobile brands.
With synthesised frequency hopping, this behaviour has never been encountered whatever the mobile
brand is. So with simultaneous activation of these two features, interference are significantly reduced.
Synthesized Frequency Hopping is then the only frequency hopping mechanism possible when using
downlink DTX and downlink power control.
The parameter setting for the synthesised frequency hopping with a fractional re-use pattern is easily
performed due to the fact that the set of frequencies is the same for each cell (1*1 pattern) or a group
of cells (for example 1*3 pattern). Implementation of new sites does not imply a new frequency
planning for the existing sites.
On the contrary, two different MA per cell (one including BCCH frequency) are needed when using
baseband frequency hopping.
In case of baseband frequency hopping, the number of used frequencies is equal to the number of
TRX. As a result, in case of TRX loss, the capacity of the site will be reduced, and the number of
frequencies in the hopping sequence is also reduced by one. Therefore, the overall benefit of the
frequency hopping (i.e. voice quality) is reduced.
In case of synthesised frequency hopping, the capacity of the site is also reduced, but the overall load
of the fractional pattern is reduced (the number of frequency in the hopping sequence is still the same,
but the number of in-service TRX is reduced by one) ; so the overall voice quality is improved.
Cavity combiners, which are mechanical equipment, have smaller MTBF than hybrid coupler
combiners which are passive equipment. Therefore, the synthesised solution with wideband coupling
system shall be more reliable than the baseband solution with cavity coupling system.
On one hand, cavity coupling systems have an insertion loss around 4,5 dB ; on the other hand,
duplexer and hybrid 2-ways coupling systems have a respective insertion loss of 1,3 dB and 4,8 dB.
Therefore, when using duplexers, a lower loss in the uplink budget allows to have a lower downlink
This confidential document is the property of NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR and may not be copied or circulated without permission
Ce document confidentiel est la propriété de NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR et ne peut être reproduit ou communiqué sans autorisation
For limited frequency spectrum networks, the maximum configuration of BTS is limited to few TRX
in case of baseband frequency hopping. This means that every timeslot is hopping on a few frequencies
(often less than 4).
When using synthesised frequency hopping, every timeslot (except those of the BCCH TRX) is
hopping on more frequencies (not limited by the number of TRX).
Now, from Nortel experience, to get the full benefit of frequency hopping, a minimum of four (4)
different frequencies shall be used. This benefit is increased up to 8 frequencies available within the
hopping sequence concerning fading effects. Moreover, beyond 8 frequencies, the additional interferer
benefits are still increasing.
100
NOHOP
2freq
4 freq
8 freq
% 10
1
-2 -1 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
FADING MARGIN (dB)
Then the use of Synthesised Frequency Hopping is more efficient than the use of baseband frequency
hopping.
This confidential document is the property of NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR and may not be copied or circulated without permission
Ce document confidentiel est la propriété de NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR et ne peut être reproduit ou communiqué sans autorisation
In case of synthesised frequency hopping, it is not always mandatory to stop a sector when adding a
TRX in this sector (it only requires that this additional TRX was previously declared within the OMC
database).
On the contrary, in case of baseband frequency hopping, this is not possible due to the fact that every
time a TRX is added, the quantities of frequencies used in the cell has to be increased.
Then it is more convenient to use Synthesised Frequency Hopping when adding TRX in a cell.
4.1.5.8. Conclusion
Thus, the use of synthesised frequency hopping really outperforms the use of baseband frequency
hopping.
It implies less interference than the use of baseband frequency hopping and it is easier to use for
parameter setting. Moreover, Synthesised Frequency Hopping is fully compliant with the use of
downlink DTX and DTX power control.
The following chapter is then describing the recommended engineering rules to follow wor synthesised
frequency hopping.
This confidential document is the property of NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR and may not be copied or circulated without permission
Ce document confidentiel est la propriété de NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR et ne peut être reproduit ou communiqué sans autorisation
The parameters used to set the Frequency Hopping are the following one :
HSN : Hopping Sequence Number [0, 63]
MAI : Mobile Allocation Index
Nf : Number of hopping frequencies
MAIO : Mobile Allocation Index Offset between 0 and Nf - 1. Each hopping TRX has a MAIO
FN : Frame Number (GSM time)
MA : Mobile Allocation
The hopping sequence generation algorithm uses the hopping sequence number (HSN) parameter to
distinguish between the 64 possible pseudo-random sequences, and produces for each frame, a Mobile
Allocation Index (MAI). This parameter is therefore GSM time and HSN dependent. The number of
frequencies in the Mobile Allocation is also used as an input in order to produce a MAI value within
the range of the frequency allocation.
This value (MAI) is increased by the MAIO assigned to each time slot, prior to selecting in the Mobile
Allocation (MA) the appropriate frequency to be used on this particular time slot.
Example:
FN HSN Nf
MA
F1
F2 Nf = 8
HSN : 10
F3 MAI 1 2 7 8 2 4 5 1
F4 MAIO : 0
MAI F1 F2 F7 F8 F2 F4 F5 F1
F5 MAIO : 2
F6
F7
+ MAI MAI F3 F4 F1 F2 F4 F6 F7 F3
F8
MAIO
The sequence number indicates the frequency used in a TRX with MAIO equal to 0, according to the
frequency order in the Mobile Allocation.
In the upper example, the sequence number 1 corresponds to the frequency F1, because it is the first
one in the MA list. The MAIO indicates the offset of the MAI in the MA list. Thus, keeping the
sequence number 1 for MAIO 0 (F1 is selected) a MAIO equal to 2 corresponds to the frequency F3
because it is the third-one in the MA list.
This confidential document is the property of NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR and may not be copied or circulated without permission
Ce document confidentiel est la propriété de NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR et ne peut être reproduit ou communiqué sans autorisation
As a general rule, the frequency for a TRX using a MAIO equal to i is the following:
F MAIO=i = F (MAI + i)
Thus, on a same site an identical value of HSN for each cell provides the same MAI. A different
MAIO for each TRX ensure the hopping sequence laws are orthogonal.
The generation algorithm in GSM has been specified so that two sequences bearing two different HSN
will statistically collide 1/Nfth of the time, where Nf is the number of hopping frequencies.
However, perfect orthogonality is ensured by assigning the same HSN but a different MAIO value to
two synchronised TDMAs. In the example above, channels 1, 2 and 3 will never collide.
This confidential document is the property of NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR and may not be copied or circulated without permission
Ce document confidentiel est la propriété de NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR et ne peut être reproduit ou communiqué sans autorisation
HSN =1 F1 F2 F6 F7 F2 F4 F5 F1
MAIO = 0
HSN = 1 F2 F3 F7 F1 F3 F5 F6 F2
MAIO = 1
The fractional reuse pattern which can be implemented on a network depends on the fractional
frequency load.
NbHopTRXCell
FrequencyLoad =
Nhfcell
For a 1:1 pattern, as all cells within a site have the same MA list, the number of hopping frequencies in
a cell is the same than the number of hopping frequencies in the corresponding site.
For a 1:3 pattern, as each cell within a site has a specific MA list, there are three (3) times more
hopping frequencies in a site (trisectorial site) than hopping frequencies in its cells.
Assuming a network with trisectorial sites with an homogeneous distribution of TRX, whatever the
pattern is, there are always three (3) times more hopping TRX in a site than hopping TRX in its cells.
NbHopTRXSite = 3* NbHopTRXCell
for trisectorial sites with homogeneous distribution of TRX
Thus, it is obvious that the defined frequency load is not comparable in a 1:1 pattern and a 1:3
pattern. In order to study the capacity (number of TRX per cell) according to the type of
This confidential document is the property of NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR and may not be copied or circulated without permission
Ce document confidentiel est la propriété de NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR et ne peut être reproduit ou communiqué sans autorisation
NbHopTRXCell
FreqLoadSite =
Nhfsite
According to the previous equations for 1:1 and 1:3 patterns, the new function FreqLoadSite can be
related to the usual frequency load:
The table below shows the fractional re-use pattern that can be implemented according to the
maximum fractional frequency load. The results in this table come from simulations and field
experience. Then they have to be understood as maximum values for a good RF quality in the network.
They are available only in case of using power control and DTX, both uplink and downlink.
Otherwise, the maximum fractional frequency load would be smaller.
16% 20%
FreqLoadSite
The maximum frequency load is the basis of the following study for engineering rules concerning HSN
and MAIO. Indeed, as the frequency load is a limitation, the aim of HSN and MAIO plans is to be as
close as possible to this limitation, and to have as less interference as possible (no adjacent frequency).
This confidential document is the property of NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR and may not be copied or circulated without permission
Ce document confidentiel est la propriété de NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR et ne peut être reproduit ou communiqué sans autorisation
With the previous results, it is possible to determine the maximum site configuration according to the
number of frequencies and the re-use pattern (considering a 4:12 re-use pattern for the BCCH), and
taking into account the results of maximum frequency load.
Here below some examples show how to find the maximum site configuration from the number of
available frequencies, or the contrary, the minimum number of frequencies needed for a given site
configuration.
Example 1:
What is the minimum number of needed frequencies for a S333 site configuration, considering one (1)
no hopping TRX (BCCH) and two (2) hopping TRX (TCH) in a 1:3 pattern for TCH ?
As seen before, with a 1:3 pattern: FrequencyLoad = 50 %
Then: NbHopTRXCell = FrequencyLoad * Nfhcell = 4
There are 3 cells, then: NbHopTRXSite = 12 TCH
As there is a 4:12 reuse pattern for BCCH, 12 frequencies are reserved for BCCH.
Finally, at least 24 frequencies are needed for using Synthesised Frequency Hopping in respecting the
maximal frequency load authorised.
Example 2:
What is the maximum site configuration with 28 available frequencies in the site, considering a
trisectorial site, a 1:1 pattern for TCH and a 4:12 pattern for BCCH ?
As there is a 4:12 reuse pattern for BCCH, 12 frequencies are reserved for BCCH.
Then, 14 frequencies are available for TCH: Nhfsite = 14
As seen before, with a 1:1 pattern: Nhfcell = Nhfsite = 14
Frequency load for a 1:1 pattern: FrequencyLoad = FreqLoadSite = 20 %
Then: NbHopTRXCell FrequencyLoad * Nfhcell = 2.8
There are 3 cells, then: Nb of TRX / Cell = BCCH + NbHopTRXCell = 3
Thus, the maximum configuration is: S333
This confidential document is the property of NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR and may not be copied or circulated without permission
Ce document confidentiel est la propriété de NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR et ne peut être reproduit ou communiqué sans autorisation
The following tables show the maximum site configuration according to the number of frequencies
and the re-use pattern (considering a 4:12 re-use pattern for the BCCH), and taking into account the
results of maximum frequency load.
number of frequencies 96 84 72 60 54 48 47
1:3 fractional re-use pattern S888 S777
1:1 fractional re-use pattern S888
4 :12 re-use pattern S888 S777 S666 S555 S444
number of frequencies 42 37 36 32 30 27 24
1:3 fractional re-use pattern S666 S555 S444 S333
1:1 fractional re-use pattern S777 S666 S555 S444
4 :12 re-use pattern S333 S222
number of frequencies 22 18 17 12
1:3 fractional re-use pattern S222 S111
1:1 fractional re-use pattern S333 S222 S111
4 :12 re-use pattern S111
This confidential document is the property of NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR and may not be copied or circulated without permission
Ce document confidentiel est la propriété de NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR et ne peut être reproduit ou communiqué sans autorisation
60
50
frequency number
40 S888
30 S777
S666
20
S555
10 S444
0 S333
1:1 fractional re-use 1:3 fractional re-use 4:12 re-use pattern S222
pattern pattern S111
re-use pattern
This confidential document is the property of NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR and may not be copied or circulated without permission
Ce document confidentiel est la propriété de NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR et ne peut être reproduit ou communiqué sans autorisation
As defined in chapter 4.1.1., this strategy means the use of the same frequency group of TCH (Mobile
Allocation) for all cells in the network.
The values of maximum frequency load in a cell (function FreqLoadSite, 20 % for 1:1, 16 % for 1:3)
indicated in chapter 4.2.2. show that for a given frequency band, this strategy (1:1 pattern) leads to a
capacity increase (more TRX per cell).
However, this maximum frequency load must be obtained without an increase of interference. Then,
the aim of the following study is to show what are the best HSN and MAIO plans to reach the
maximum frequency load without increasing the interference.
Supposing the following abbreviations, calculations can be made to show the maximum frequency
load associated to different engineering rules, according to the MA content.
Rule :
The use of a unique HSN and different MAIO for each TRX within a site (with a step of 2 for
the MAIO because all frequencies inside the group are adjacent) ensure the orthogonality and
the non-adjacency of the frequencies.
Example: for a S444 with a MAIO step 2, there are 3 hopping TRX per cell, then 9 hopping TRX
within the site.
This confidential document is the property of NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR and may not be copied or circulated without permission
Ce document confidentiel est la propriété de NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR et ne peut être reproduit ou communiqué sans autorisation
In this example, to avoid any frequency adjacency, the minimum number of hopping frequencies in the
site must be 18, as shown in the tables below.
With 17 frequencies, the adjacency appears when the frequency of the first TRX of the first cell is not
the first frequency of the band (F1).
Cell1- TRX1 F1 F5 = F1 + 800 kHz
MAIO = 0
Cell3- TRX3 F17 = F1 + 3200 kHz F4 = F1 + 600 kHz
MAIO = 16
Remark:
In the above example, another solution for the MAIO rule would have been to give MAIO 0, 2, 4 to
TRX in the first cell, MAIO 6, 8, 10 to TRX in the second cell and MAIO 12, 14, 16 to TRX in the third
cell. However, the disadvantage of this solution appears when adding new TRX in a cell. For instance,
a new TRX in the first cell would have MAIO 18 assigned, then the logic aspect of the MAIO
assignment is lost.
For a trisectorial site with an homogeneous repartition of TRX in the cells, the frequency load due to
the previous constraints on HSN and MAIO is the following :
This confidential document is the property of NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR and may not be copied or circulated without permission
Ce document confidentiel est la propriété de NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR et ne peut être reproduit ou communiqué sans autorisation
Nhfsite
Then NbHopTRXCell ≤ thus FreqLoadSite ≤ 16%
6
Nhfsite − 1
Then NbHopTRXCell ≤ thus FreqLoadSite ≤ 16%
6
Frequency band for hopping TRX: F1, F1+400, F1+800, F1+1200,... for instance
This strategy is not representative of operator strategy, because it also means that sometimes, there will
be adjacencies between BCCH and TCH frequencies. However, it is interesting to know if the previous
result can be enhanced with this strategy.
Rule :
The use of a unique HSN and different MAIO for each TRX within a site (with a step of 1 for
the MAIO because no frequency inside the group are adjacent) ensure the orthogonality and the
non-adjacency of the frequencies.
Example: for a S444 with a MAIO step 1, there are 3 hopping TRX per cell, then 9 hopping TRX
within the site.
HSN = 1 Ex : Nb hopping frequencies in the site 9
MAIO 0,3,6
NbMAIO = 9
HSN = 1 HSN = 1
MAIO 2,5,8 MAIO 1,4,7
For a trisectorial site with an homogeneous repartition of TRX in the cells, the frequency load due to
the previous constraints on HSN and MAIO is the following :
This confidential document is the property of NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR and may not be copied or circulated without permission
Ce document confidentiel est la propriété de NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR et ne peut être reproduit ou communiqué sans autorisation
Nhfsite
Then NbHopTRXCell ≤ thus FreqLoadSite ≤ 33%
3
As the maximum frequency load for having few interference with 1:1 pattern is 20 %, the previous
result will lead to many interference. The same HSN and MAIO plans can be kept, however the
number of hopping frequencies per site must be higher.
Thus, with this configuration (no adjacent frequency), it is possible to reach the maximum
frequency load (20 %).
Nhfsite
Then: NbHopTRXCell ≤
5
Thus, in a 1:1 pattern, for a trisectorial site with an homogeneous repartition of TRX in the
cells, the engineering rules to follow are the following :
Caution : the only way to have a 20 % frequency load (maximum) with a 1:1 pattern is to use an
unique HSN with adjacent MAIO. However, this engineering rule is only applicable if there are no
adjacent frequencies in the MA (what is not generally the case). Otherwise it leads to an increase of
interference and it is not recommended to use MAIO step 1.
In the same way, the use of different HSN in each cell leads to an increase of interference whatever the
HSN and MAIO rules are.
This confidential document is the property of NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR and may not be copied or circulated without permission
Ce document confidentiel est la propriété de NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR et ne peut être reproduit ou communiqué sans autorisation
This strategy is studied here below in the case of a trisectorial site with an homogeneous repartition of
TRX in the cells.
Example: for a S444 with a MAIO step 1, there are 3 hopping TRX per cell, then 9 hopping TRX
within the site.
HSN = 1
MAIO 0,1,2 MAIO max = 8 then Nb hopping frequencies in each cell 9
In this example, to avoid any frequency adjacency, the minimum number of hopping frequencies in
each cell must be 10, as shown in the tables below.
With 9 frequencies, the adjacency appears when the frequency of the first TRX of the first cell is not
the first frequency of the band (F1).
Cell1- TRX1 F11 F15 = F11 + 2400 kHz
MAIO = 0
Cell3- TRX3 F39 = F11 + 5200 kHz F34 = F11 + 2200 kHz
MAIO = 16
This confidential document is the property of NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR and may not be copied or circulated without permission
Ce document confidentiel est la propriété de NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR et ne peut être reproduit ou communiqué sans autorisation
Then, for a trisectorial site with an homogeneous repartition of TRX in the cells, the frequency load
due to the previous constraints on HSN and MAIO is the following :
Nhfsite
The reuse pattern is 1:3, then: NbMAIOSite + 1 ≤
3
As there are 3 cells per site : NbMAIOSite = 3* NbMAIOCell
And MAIO step 1 is used, then: NbMAIOCell = NbHopTRXCell
Nhfsite − 1
Then NbHopTRXCell ≤ thus FreqLoadSite ≤ 11%
9
Where :
NbHopTRXSite : the total number of non-BCCH TRX in the site.
NbHopTRXCell : the total number of non-BCCH TRX in a cell.
Nhfsite : Number of Hopping Frequencies per site
NbMAIOSite : number of MAIO in the site
NbMAIOCell : number of MAIO in the Cell
The maximum value for FreqLoadSite was defined at 16 %, then this strategy is not optimised.
Keeping three (3) non continuous frequency bands, a better MAIO plan can be chosen, in order to
reach the maximum defined frequency load (FreqLoadSite = 16 %).
An indexed frequency Fi in the MA of the first cell is not adjacent with an indexed frequency Fi in the
MA of the third cell frequency (spacing of 400 kHz). However, an indexed frequency Fi in the MA of
the first cell frequency is adjacent with an indexed frequency Fi+1 in the MA of the third cell frequency.
Thus, using the same MAIO step 2 rule for both first and third cells will not lead to frequency
adjacencies between these cells.
Moreover, using different MAIO with a step 2 rule for the second cell will also ensure a non frequency
adjacency with this cell.
Example: for a S444 with a MAIO step 2 in all cells, same MAIO in first and third cells, there are 3
hopping TRX per cell, then 9 hopping TRX within the site.
This confidential document is the property of NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR and may not be copied or circulated without permission
Ce document confidentiel est la propriété de NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR et ne peut être reproduit ou communiqué sans autorisation
Cell1 F1 F1+600 kHz F1+1200 kHz F1+1800 kHz F1+2400 kHz F1+3000 kHz
Cell2 F1+200 kHz F1+800 kHz F1+1400 kHz F1+2000 kHz F1+2600 kHz F1+3200 kHz
Cell3 F1+400 kHz F1+1000 kHz F1+1600 kHz F1+2200 kHz F1+2800 kHz F1+3400 kHz
According to the MAI, the following frequencies will be allocated to each TRX.
For MAI = 1
TRX 1 TRX 2 TRX 3
Cell 1 (MAIO : 0, 2, 4) F1+ 600 kHz F1 + 1800 kHz F1 + 3000 kHz
Cell 2 (MAIO : 1, 3, 5) F1 + 1400 kHz F1 + 2600 kHz F1 + 200 kHz
Cell 3 (MAIO : 0, 2, 4) F1 + 1000 kHz F1 + 2200 kHz F1 + 3400 kHz
Whatever the MAI is, all frequencies are spaced of at least 400 kHz, then there is no frequency
adjacencies.
Then, for a trisectorial site with an homogeneous distribution of TRX in the cells, the frequency load
due to the previous constraints on HSN and MAIO is the following :
Nhfsite
The reuse pattern is 1:3, then: NbMAIOSite ≤
3
As there are 3 cells but 2 with same MAIO: NbMAIOSite = 2 * NbMAIOCell
And: NbMAIOCell = NbHopTRXCell
Nhfsite
Then NbHopTRXCell ≤ thus FreqLoadSite ≤ 16%
6
Where :
NbHopTRXSite : the total number of non-BCCH TRX in the site.
NbHopTRXCell : the total number of non-BCCH TRX in a cell.
Nhfsite : Number of Hopping Frequencies per site
This confidential document is the property of NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR and may not be copied or circulated without permission
Ce document confidentiel est la propriété de NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR et ne peut être reproduit ou communiqué sans autorisation
Thus this solution leads to a non adjacency with a 16 % frequency load. As it is the maximum
frequency load determined in the limitation, it is the right solution to choose when using non
continuous frequency bands.
Caution
An other way to reach the maximum frequency load is to use different HSN and different MAIO for
each cell. This configuration leads to a 16 % frequency load (ideal case) but it also leads to frequency
adjacencies, then to interference increase.
Example: for a S444 with a MAIO step 2 per cell, there are 3 hopping TRX per cell, then 9 hopping
TRX within the site.
However, in this example, in order to avoid frequency adjacencies, the number of hopping frequencies
in each cell must be greater than 6.
This confidential document is the property of NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR and may not be copied or circulated without permission
Ce document confidentiel est la propriété de NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR et ne peut être reproduit ou communiqué sans autorisation
Remark
The use of different MAIO in each cell would not lead to less interference, because in the proposed
solution, the non-adjacency is already ensured.
Then, for a trisectorial site with an homogeneous repartition of TRX in the cells, the frequency load
due to the previous constraints on HSN and MAIO is the following :
Nhfsite
Then NbHopTRXCell ≤ thus FreqLoadSite ≤ 16%
6
Where :
NbHopTRXSite : the total number of non-BCCH TRX in the site.
NbHopTRXCell : the total number of non-BCCH TRX in a cell.
Nhfsite : Number of Hopping Frequencies per site
NbMAIOSite : number of MAIO in the site
NbMAIOCell : number of MAIO in the Cell
This confidential document is the property of NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR and may not be copied or circulated without permission
Ce document confidentiel est la propriété de NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR et ne peut être reproduit ou communiqué sans autorisation
Then, in a 1:3 pattern, for a trisectorial site with an homogeneous distribution of TRX in the
cells, the engineering rules to follow are the following :
This confidential document is the property of NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR and may not be copied or circulated without permission
Ce document confidentiel est la propriété de NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR et ne peut être reproduit ou communiqué sans autorisation
FreqLoadSite
This confidential document is the property of NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR and may not be copied or circulated without permission
Ce document confidentiel est la propriété de NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR et ne peut être reproduit ou communiqué sans autorisation
Additionally, the introduction of SFH means an increase of hand over on the quality criteria, however
they happen instead of hand over on RxLev or power budget. This increase is particularly important
when frequency load is superior than the defined maximum frequency loads. Then, it is advised to
adapt the quality thresholds to the fractional reuse pattern. Thus, a value of 6 in a 1:1 pattern and a
value of 5 in a 1:3 pattern is highly recommended, in order to control hand over on quality criteria.
The recommended strategies for 1:3 reuse pattern systematically leads to a non-adjacency of
frequencies, and the maximum possible frequency load (50 %, or 16 % with the defined frequency
load in site). Furthermore, this results are obtained in using either non continuous frequency band or
continuous frequency band (what is generally the case) in the MA.
For 1:1 pattern, the strategy to follow depends on the frequency bands constraints. In the case of
adjacent frequencies in the MA (general case), the maximum frequency load is not reached without
interference (16 % instead of 20 % at a maximum).
However, if there is no adjacent frequency in the MA, it is possible to reach the limitation in frequency
load (20 %). But this case is rarely used by operators, because it leads to some frequency adjacencies
between TCH and BCCH.
Though both strategies generally lead to the same capacity (TRX number per cell) for a given
frequency band, the 1:1 pattern is recommended because the frequency plan for TCH group is
easier to do than for the 1:3 pattern. It is particularly the case when adding cells, TRX or
frequencies in a network, because for a 1:1 pattern, the MA (TCH group) will be the same in all
cells.
Then, the 1:1 reuse pattern with adjacent frequency group for the Mobile Allocation is the
strategy an operator must favour. It leads to a 16 % maximum frequency load.
This confidential document is the property of NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR and may not be copied or circulated without permission
Ce document confidentiel est la propriété de NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR et ne peut être reproduit ou communiqué sans autorisation
This confidential document is the property of NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR and may not be copied or circulated without permission
Ce document confidentiel est la propriété de NORTEL MATRA CELLULAR et ne peut être reproduit ou communiqué sans autorisation