You are on page 1of 22

306-328 Islamic Finance Surveyv5 27/3/07 13:37 Page 1

Growth and Diversification


in Islamic Finance

F I N A N C I A L S E RV I C E S
306-328 Islamic Finance Surveyv5 27/3/07 13:37 Page 1

Contents
1 Introduction 1

2 Product and Market Diversification 2

3 Barriers to Growth 9

4 Conclusion 19

306-328 Islamic Finance Surveyv5 27/3/07 13:37 Page 1

Growth and Diversification in Islamic Finance 1

1 Introduction

The contemporary Islamic finance Further, the recently proposed changes In the past five years, perceptions of
industry is now in its fourth decade to U.K. tax law should help to remove the Islamic finance industry have
and, during that period, has developed the tax disadvantage which U.K. advanced considerably. Originally, says
extremely rapidly. In the past few Sukuk issuance would have previously Richard Thomas, managing director of
years, overall market growth has been suffered. U.K. Sukuk issuance is now Global Securities House U.K. Limited
estimated at between 15-20 percent looking like a valid financing option to (GSH), a wholly-owned subsidiary of
annually1, although individual Islamic be explored by businesses which want Securities House Group of Kuwait, the
banks have reported even faster to be Shariah compliant as well as by global financial services companies
growth. In 2006, for example, Arcapita other businesses which want to saw Islamic finance as a market for
Bank in Bahrain reported year-on-year diversify their investor base or benefit liquidity management and cheap short-
balance sheet growth nearer to 40 from the ongoing infrastructure term funding.
percent. Today, the sector has investments within the Middle east.
estimated assets under management More significantly these tax changes This perspective has changed. “They
of US$500bn2. help to signify that Islamic finance can now see opportunities across the
play an important role in western board from project finance to securities
Market dynamism has been felt in both economies. The changes in the U.K. issuance,” he explains. “Five years ago,
the traditional Islamic finance centers are very likely to be replicated in other they saw a one-dimensional market;
and a number of other markets. countries thereby creating an enabling now they see it as a multi-dimensional
According to Bank Negara Malaysia (the framework for the rapid global market complete with opportunities in
Malaysian central bank), the number of development of Islamic finance. fund, asset and wealth management.
Islamic bank branches in Malaysia The result has been that more
increased from 126 in 2004 to 766 in The prospects for Islamic finance have international banks are setting up
2005. Elsewhere, new Islamic financial also encouraged some conventional Islamic finance teams and one would
institutions (IFIs) are being established banks to embark on the process of be hard-pressed now to find banks not
rapidly in the industry’s traditional converting to Islamic financial having the capabilities to intermediate
markets in the Gulf Co-operation institutions. Two years ago, for the market.”
Council (GCC) countries. example, the Kuwait Real Estate Bank
(KREB) announced that it was The purpose of this report is to explore
Islamic finance is also on the rise in converting into a full-fledged Islamic current and future development of
new markets such as Syria, Lebanon, bank. In December 2006, the Central Islamic finance and to examine ways in
the U.K., Turkey and Canada. In the Bank of Kuwait approved KREB’s which the sector is predicted to
U.K., for instance, two new Islamic Islamic Banking license, complete with diversify and grow in the years ahead.
banking licence applications are name change to Kuwait International KPMG International commissioned the
currently being considered by the Bank. “The future is very exciting,” Economist Intelligence Unit (EIU) to
Financial Services Authority (FSA), says Sulaiman Al-Baqsami, assistant undertake a series of interviews in
following the authorization in the past general manager of KREB. “If we could February 2007 with leading figures
three years of the Islamic Bank of convince our traditional client base, we from the industry. Both the EIU and
Britain and the European Islamic could solicit potential customers with KPMG International would like to thank
Investment Bank. other conventional banks.” all respondents for their participation.

1, 2: Source: speech by Howard Davies, chairman of the Financial Services Authority


http://www.fsa.gov.uk/Pages/Library/Communication/Speeches/2002/sp103.shtml

© 2007 KPMG International. KPMG International provides no client services and is a Swiss
cooperative with which the independent member firms of the KPMG network are affiliated.
306-328 Islamic Finance Surveyv5 27/3/07 13:37 Page 2

2 Growth and Diversification in Islamic Finance

2 Product and Market Diversification

As IFIs consolidate in their home and incremental change—consolidation and


regional markets and venture into product refinement—will remain
cross-border start-ups and exposures central in the market’s development
further afield, there is strengthening over the short term, innovation will
evidence for market diversification. The remain important.
reason for this, explains Mr. Jaidah
from QIB, “is to allow surplus liquidity Mr. Thomas of GSH believes that the
in the Islamic market to be employed main area for product diversification is
with different risk ratings; with different Takaful (insurance). The Islamic
asset classes; and with different insurance (Takaful) industry is potentially
market exposures.” the most lucrative of the Islamic
financial landscape, simply because
The general consensus within the insurance is a highly under-developed
industry is that some of the key areas sector, especially in the conservative
for product innovation will be in the GCC countries. Even in Malaysia,
issuance and trading of asset-backed market penetration of Takaful is proving
securities (Sukuk); project and to be an uphill struggle. the market is as much in
infrastructure financing to include new need of consolidation and
markets outside traditional ones such He is more cautious about the future for
as the West; structured finance hedge funds. “They have been the next refinement as it is of
derivatives; private equity; retail big thing in the Islamic finance space for innovation and new products
banking beyond the Islamic mortgage; years, and I have not actually seen one
and value added real estate products. operating properly yet,” he explains.
Exchange traded funds (ETFs), similarly, Despite the real estate boom in the
There is, however, some question as to have been slow to take off, despite the GCC and a warning from Standard &
how much product innovation is fact that two leading Islamic equity Poor’s in a report that IFIs may be over­
actually needed at the moment, given index providers, Dow Jones and FTSE, exposed to exposure to the real estate
that the industry is relatively young and have been trying to promote them in markets, bankers such as Peter
that many of its products are still the past two years. Currently, there is Panayiotou, Deputy Chief Executive of
nascent. Indeed, some practitioners only one Shariah-compliant ETF, the Gulf Finance House (GFH) in Bahrain
stress that the market is as much in DJIM Turkey Exchange Traded Fund, are convinced that analysts are reading
need of consolidation and refinement launched in Istanbul in January 2006 by the situation wrongly.
as it is of innovation and new products. Turkiye Finans (a merger between two
Turkish Islamic banks), and based on the “Many people think the real estate
Duncan Smith, managing director and Dow Jones Islamic Market (DJIM) boom is speculation,” he asserts. “It isn’t
global head of Islamic finance at Arab Turkey Index. actually. It is catch-up. We’ve seen in the
Banking Corporation (ABC) in Bahrain, past three years, since the end of the
points out that, in the GCC and Barclays Capital and others are also in Gulf War, a concentration of initiatives
Malaysia, many of the retail needs of the process of launching an ETF off the which were suspended during the inter-
the market are probably being met. He FTSE-SGX Asia Shariah 100 Index, Gulf War period, with the exception of
does not see any shortage of products, launched in January 2006 by FTSE and Dubai, which halfway through that
although in Western markets such as The Singapore Stock Exchange (SGX). period perked up and said ‘We are going
the U.K. it will take longer to introduce Progress has been slow, however, to ignore that and carry on’.”
a wider range of Islamic consumer because of the unfamiliarity of Islamic
finance products beyond the Islamic institutional investors with ETFs.
mortgage. Nonetheless, while

© 2007 KPMG International. KPMG International provides no client services and is a Swiss
cooperative with which the independent member firms of the KPMG network are affiliated.
306-328 Islamic Finance Surveyv5 27/3/07 13:37 Page 3

Growth and Diversification in Islamic Finance 3

HSBC Amanah Case Study

HSBC Amanah has not hidden its light Muslim families in the U.K. have taken In the early stages, the bank’s
under a bushel. The Islamic finance out 134,000 conventional mortgages marketing activity consisted of
division of the world’s third-largest worth UK£9bn and there are a further explaining Islamic finance through
bank was set up in 1998 with the 76,000 households with no mortgages highly targeted seminars,
stated aim of becoming the global at all. Mr Ali believes a large proportion presentations and meetings with
leader of the nascent sector. It has of households that already have community leaders and scholars. This
devoted significant resources to the mortgages could switch to Islamic direct approach was supplemented by
task, hiring more than 100 dedicated home finance. “About 200,000 sponsorship of local groups and
staff - in addition to group-wide households in total match our target organizations. Mr. Ali believes that now
resources - across the Middle East, profile. These are mainly second- is the right time to begin marketing in
Europe, Asia-Pacific and the Americas. generation Muslims who have some earnest. “We had to build a knowledge
knowledge of finance,” he says. base and we feel that point has been
Following an early focus on the Middle reached,” he says. This year, HSBC
East, where most populations are So far, progress has been steady, if not Amanah will run radio and TV
predominantly Muslim, HSBC Amanah spectacular. By mid-2006, HSBC campaigns, many channelled through
has now decided to expand into Amanah had signed up 3,300 home Asian and Arab TV and radio stations.
countries where Muslims are in a finance customers, providing £370m in
sizeable minority. The retail market in finance to them. In addition, more than Marketing can also take more subtle
the U.K., which has a Muslim 5,000 personal bank accounts had guises. HSBC Amanah recruits heavily
population of nearly 2m, was identified been opened. from the Muslim community to build
as having the right attributes to test the cultural knowledge at each branch. Mr.
strategy. Amjid Ali, Chief Executive of In part, growth has been held back by Ali says: “We employ people who
HSBC Amanah in the U.K., says: “There the problem of convincing potential want financial rewards but also want to
is very stringent regulation in the U.K. customers that products meet the help fellow Muslims.”
so we thought if we could crack it here, demands of their faith. “Few people
we could succeed anywhere.” question Halal meat, but they don’t Of course, creating a U.K. retail market
necessarily accept Shariah-compliant for Islamic finance is not down to
Mr. Ali, Senior Business Development products,” explains Mr. Ali. Another HSBC alone. Competitors such as
Manager, had worked for the U.K.s ’ issue is the higher cost of Islamic Lloyds TSB and the Islamic Bank of
Midland Bank, which was bought by finance. Products cannot be imported Britain share the responsibility and, for
HSBC in 1992, for 17 years before wholesale from the Middle East now, there is a feeling of fraternity
being appointed in 2003 as a business division - they must be approved by an rather than rivalry between them. But
development manager for the newly independent Shariah advisory board, as the market matures, competition is
launched Islamic finance division. He pass regulatory tests and be adapted likely to intensify and, in readiness for
had encountered demand for Islamic so that they fit on HSBC’s U.K. product this, HSBC Amanah is preparing to roll
finance as long ago as the1980s. “I ran platform. The cost of this process is out new products in areas such as
a pilot program in Bristol in 1987 and inevitably passed on to clients. “Most savings, student finance and the small
many Muslims there said they wanted accept that there is a marginal cost for business sector.
products in accordance with their peace of mind,” says Mr. Ali.
faith,” he explains. These plans depend, of course, on
whether consumers buy into the
In 2005, he was appointed chief concept. Mr. Ali is confident: “Thirty
executive with a brief to develop years ago, if you wanted Halal meat you
products in home finance, current slaughtered a live chicken. Now even
accounts, pension funds, and buildings Tesco sells Halal meat. Things change.”
and content insurance. The initial target
was the mortgage market. HSBC says

© 2007 KPMG International. KPMG International provides no client services and is a Swiss
cooperative with which the independent member firms of the KPMG network are affiliated.
306-328 Islamic Finance Surveyv5 27/3/07 13:37 Page 4

4 Growth and Diversification in Islamic Finance

GFH, which is leading landmark Islamic vanilla products that don’t breach What happens if the oil
real estate projects in India, Morocco, Shariah rules. There is a whole new price goes down?
Jordan, Qatar and Bahrain, expects industry that sits on top and that is
considerable opportunities for value- completely untapped.“ Some economists stress that the real
added Islamic real estate investments, test for the Islamic finance market
especially in the GCC countries, where Mr. Jaidah of QIB agrees that Shariah would be its ability to absorb shocks in
a young demography and robust year- scholars have an important role to play an era of low oil prices and budget
on-year population growth should in product innovation. “The bankers deficits. Many Islamic bankers,
maintain demand for housing, give the explanations and the however, are bemused at suggestions
shopping complexes and leisure clarifications regarding the basic format of a negative impact on the sector, if
facilities. for the products. But, it is the scholars the price of oil were to drop to a
who have to understand the structure historical mean.
Mr. Panayiotou believes that the key and the sophistication that is needed
product segments include asset for these products to support the IFIs “Why would we have to focus on the
management, wealth management, and to leverage their use,” he says. Islamic finance sector if such a thing
insurance, consumer finance, occurs?” asks Salah Jaidah, Chief
investment banking and private equity, Many GCC-based Islamic bankers are Executive of Qatar Islamic Bank (QIB).
but concedes that there is still much aware that eventually they will have to “Such a scenario is going to affect the
work to do in the sector. “Our be more creative in product innovation financial markets as a whole.”
investment banks need to roll into and diversification, especially in the
proper investment banks,” he explains. area of exotics such as derivatives, Bankers such as Mr. Jaidah stress that
“Most of them are focused on one line swaps, options, Repos, ETFs, hedge GCC governments have budgeted for
of business. There is a lot of room to funds and even Sukuk. But many of various oil price scenarios. Many of the
grow; a lot of new products to develop. them doubt whether these products GCC states, for instance, have catered
The derivatives industry alone is a are the right ones for a market which is for a stabilization of the oil price to
huge business if we can crack the still at the lower end of a steep US$50 per barrel. Several Saudi
more complex structures beyond the learning curve. economists predict that the average

© 2007 KPMG International. KPMG International provides no client services and is a Swiss
cooperative with which the independent member firms of the KPMG network are affiliated.
306-328 Islamic Finance Surveyv5 27/3/07 13:37 Page 5

Growth and Diversification in Islamic Finance 5

US$50 per barrel scenario is the most Mr. Thomas of GSH concurs that a Sukuk Proliferation
likely for the next few years. “If the slump in oil prices is not going to affect
price of crude oil drops below US$18 the Islamic finance market materially. Sukuk—the Islamic finance world’s
per barrel, then everyone will be in a He is more concerned about the equivalent of a traditional bond—has
chaos, let alone the banks,” adds impact on asset quality and their ability taken the Islamic finance industry by
Mr. Jaidah. to comply with the capital and risk storm over the past two years, with
management provisions of Basel II. most of the origination in Malaysia and
Low oil price scenarios are not new. the GCC countries. In 2006, some 80
In fact, several Islamic bankers “There is so much cash around even if percent of the burgeoning GCC bond
interviewed stressed that the sector the oil price goes down,” he explains. market was accounted for by Sukuk,
did go through oil price downturns in “The key is the asset quality of the up from just 26 percent in 2005,
the1980s, 1990s and early 2000s, and portfolios of the Islamic financial according to City law firm Trowers
it successfully weathered the storm. institutions (IFIs), and that they remain & Hamlins.
“At QIB, we have seen the ups and robust. It would be much harder to
downs of oil prices, and we managed deal with credit problems than with The global Sukuk market is still relatively
our portfolios. We have short, medium liquidity problems. There will always be small – the estimated volume of
and long-term maturities,” explains Mr. liquidity. The question remains on the outstanding Islamic securities (including
Jaidah. “We also have different liability side, whether the assets are Malaysian issuances) totaled just some
resources we can utilize such as inter­ rated or not.” US$70bn at the end of 2006, according
bank and Murabaha liquidity to Business Times, Malaysia. The
management lines. We could support market has thus far been dominated by
any immediate needs or run on Malaysia. Saudi Arabia currently has
deposits that occur in the market.” only four Sukuk issuances to date,
although Bryan Kraty, acting general
manager of Gulf Islamic Clearing
Company (GICC) in Bahrain, predicts
that, in the future, some 90 percent of
the Sukuk issuances will originate from
© 2007 KPMG International. KPMG International provides no client services and is a Swiss
cooperative with which the independent member firms of the KPMG network are affiliated.
306-328 Islamic Finance Surveyv5 27/3/07 13:37 Page 6

6 Growth and Diversification in Islamic Finance

the Kingdom. “The biggest market for To Badlisyah Abdul Ghani, head of in 2006, some 80 percent
opportunities has to be Saudi Arabia,” Islamic finance at Malaysia’s CIMB
he explains. Other GCC markets are Group and Chief Executive of CIMB of the burgeoning GCC
also starting to catch up. Dubai Islamic Islamic Bank, more issuance will be bond market was
Bank and Abu Dhabi Islamic Bank, for one of the keys to the growth of a
example, have respectively launched global Islamic capital market. “The accounted for by Sukuk, up
US$10bn and US$5bn Sukuk programs. development of a global Islamic market from just 26 percent in
has been slow because people are
Thus far, there have been only two unwilling to take the necessary steps,” 2005, according to City law
Sukuk originations in traditional western he says. “The more players that firm Trowers & Hamlins
markets—the Saxony-Anhalt Sukuk in arrange issuance in the market, the
Germany, and the East Cameron better. You cannot have an active
Partners Sukuk in the U.S.. Nevertheless, secondary market until you have well
there is significant potential for Sukuk in excess of 100 issuances.”
origination in these markets, and in
Europe in particular. Mr. Thomas of GSH Research done by GICC suggests that
projects that Sukuk origination and the tipping point would be when the
issuance by European corporates and market attains a US$400bn pool
governments “will be the next big step comprised of about 270 issuances. “By
forward” in the market, with the U.K. that time you will have enough
leading the initiative. instruments and people will start
taking off-the-shelf products and start
Ed Balls, the Economic Secretary to the trading. The truth is that there are not
U.K. Treasury, confirmed in February enough alternative Islamic investment
2007 that the Treasury is currently instruments to further stimulate
looking at how the U.K. tax system trading,” says Mr. Kraty.
interacts with the Sukuk market; the
barriers to establishing a secondary Mr. Panayiotou of GFH agrees that
Sukuk market in the U.K.; barriers in the more work needs to be done to
way of U.K. origination and issuance; stimulate a secondary trading. “If there
and taxing of U.K. Sukuk certificate was a secondary market we would feel
holders. Market players are keen for the more comfortable,” he explains. “If the
U.K. to issue a benchmark debut people who buy the Sukuk have no
sovereign Sukuk and to spearhead the way to sell them apart from holding
development of a “Euro-Sukuk” market them to maturity, there is not much
dominated by U.K. and EU corporate incentive to buy the certificates. To be
issuances. Many IFIs privately stress a market maker you need an institution
that sovereign issuances above with a very strong balance sheet, and
US$250m by highly rated countries may the institutions with that sort of
be needed as liquidity management balance sheet are not really in our
instruments by banks. [Islamic finance] industry.”

The U.S. and Europe are not the only He goes on to express surprise that the
global markets entering the sector. major global banks have not been
Reports in the Middle East Economic quicker to enter the Sukuk market. “The
Digest and elsewhere suggest that the Islamic finance sector has actually given
Japanese government is preparing a them a new line of business,” he
debut sovereign Sukuk issuance of explains. “I don’t understand why they
over US$500m in 2007. Indonesia, have not jumped in.”
Turkey and Saudi Arabia are also
contemplating debut sovereign
benchmark issues.

© 2007 KPMG International. KPMG International provides no client services and is a Swiss
cooperative with which the independent member firms of the KPMG network are affiliated.
306-328 Islamic Finance Surveyv5 27/3/07 13:37 Page 7

Growth and Diversification in Islamic Finance 7

Unicorn Case Study


To date, no Islamic investment bank global reach, Mr. Al-Refai decided to head for the Swiss private banks. “I’ve
has developed a brand with truly global domicile Unicorn in Bahrain rather than never met a billionaire who told me he
reach. Some have made significant in his native Kuwait. “Bahrain is was satisfied with Islamic services,”
inroads but sometimes encounter cosmopolitan and has been a banking says Mr. Al-Refai.
resistance from Muslim businesses center for 30 years,” he explains. “It
and investors who do not wish to deal has strong relationships around the But to win high-margin business
with western banks. world, including with the Bank of requires high-caliber bankers who
England. It is a strict financial might otherwise work at western
Unicorn Investment Bank was set up jurisdiction but friendly at the same investment banks. Unicorn also has to
in an attempt to fill the void. Its time.” In a short period, Unicorn has compete for talent with state-owned
founder and Chief Executive, Majid Al made strides to expand internationally. regional banks, such as Dubai Islamic
Sayed Bader Al-Refai, believes he has It now has a U.S. office, as well as a Bank, Abu Dhabi Islamic Bank and the
the background and industry presence in Dubai, Kuwait and UAE Emirates Islamic Bank. “Unlike
experience to create a dominant Malaysia. In January, it acquired a 75 others in the region,” says Mr. Al-Refai,
Islamic brand. Mr. Al-Refai comes from percent stake in a Turkish brokerage. “we have put in place international pay
a distinguished Kuwaiti family, was standards.” At the same time, he does
brought up and educated in the U.S. Whereas many Middle East state- not employ bankers for their specialist
and learned his early banking in Saudi controlled banks have limited business knowledge of Shariah finance. “We
Arabia. He set up Unicorn in 2004 with lines, usually participating in property- just want expert bankers,” he says.
US$113m of his own and friends’ related deals, Mr. Al-Refai has created “Few people have Shariah expertise
money and with advisory support from a sophisticated model, based on the and, in any case, we have a whole
UBS Warburg, a global investment activities of U.S. “bulge bracket” department to structure deals.”
bank. A further US$113m was raised banks. Unicorn’s six business lines
from high net worth investors in the are: corporate finance and advisory;
middle of 2006. capital markets and treasury; global
private equity; asset management;
Mr. Al-Refai says the rationale for strategic mergers and acquisitions; and
launching the bank needs little takaful, or insurance. In each, Unicorn’s
explanation. “Asking me why we set competitive advantage is both
up is like asking why we should challenged by the constraints imposed
breathe. It’s because there are 1.5bn by Shariah law and enhanced by its
Muslims in the world and they don’t access to Islamic businesses that are
have choice and they don’t have off-limits to many western banks.
service.” He says that about 35 In 2006, Unicorn made a net profit of
percent of Muslims have always the biggest market for US$30m but it is considering a stock
avoided all forms of all interest-bearing market flotation, possibly next year, to
opportunities has to be
investments and have had little choice grow at a faster rate. “We will likely
other than to “put their savings under Saudi Arabia seek a listing in Bahrain first and then
their mattress”. With a further on the Alternative Investment Market
estimated 30 percent of “moderate” For example, rare access to Muslim- after that,” says Mr. Al-Refai. The
Muslims also potentially open to run private companies has allowed proceeds would enable Unicorn to
Islamic finance, Unicorn has a potential Unicorn to arrange the largest ever acquire more businesses and also
universe of 975m people and all the private bond sale in Saudi Arabia, grow organically by, for example,
businesses they own and manage. which closed in February at US$600m. launching new private equity funds.
On the other hand, it is not yet able to
Cultural reasons explain why an launch fully-fledged hedge funds. After the investment banking product
independent Islamic investment bank Instead it has created balanced range is filled out, Mr. Al-Refai plans to
of scale has not yet emerged, says Mr. investment funds using a mixture of tackle the consumer market. “At some
Al-Refai. “Arabs are traders by nature. equities and bonds. It believes this stage we will have retail branches
The concept of a global institution is kind of innovation will attract high net around the world,” he says.
just not in their blood.” To achieve worth investors who may otherwise

© 2007 KPMG International. KPMG International provides no client services and is a Swiss
cooperative with which the independent member firms of the KPMG network are affiliated.
306-328 Islamic Finance Surveyv5 27/3/07 13:37 Page 8

8 Growth and Diversification in Islamic Finance


306-328 Islamic Finance Surveyv5 27/3/07 13:37 Page 9

Growth and Diversification in Islamic Finance 9

3 Barriers to Growth

the current lack of qualified The prospects for the growth of necessarily be as straightforward as the
Islamic finance look bright. Basel II proposals. It is the intention of
Islamic bankers looks set Nonetheless, there are several the IFSB to bridge this gap.
to hamper the obstacles currently preventing faster
uptake of Islamic financial products. To ABC’s Mr. Smith, the process of
development of the sector These include the issue of regulatory calculating regulatory capital and
should it not be addressed capital and relative risk weightings relative risk weightings under Basel II is
under Basel II and the Islamic Financial very important for the Islamic banking
Services Board (IFSB) guidance; a lack industry. “The Islamic finance industry
of human capital; piecemeal financial is no longer the small or insignificant
and legal architecture; weaknesses in movement of say ten years ago. It has
financial reporting and transparency; moved a long way. There are
and the overarching problem of a lack responsibilities in being a bigger part of
of Shariah convergence. the world financial movement.
Calculation of regulatory capital and
relative risk weightings under Basel II
Risk weighting are some of them,” he explains.

In 2006, the IFSB issued two standards


– the Capital Adequacy Standard (CAS) Human capital
and the Guiding Principles of Risk
Management for Institutions offering Human capital development is crucial,
Islamic Financial Services. CAS offers as the current lack of qualified young
guidance on the requirements for Islamic bankers looks set to hamper
minimum capital adequacy to cover for the development of the sector should
credit, market and operational risks of it not be addressed. In part, this low
IFIs that is equivalent to the Basel II investment in the industry stems from
Capital framework for conventional the fact that the sector lacks a global
banking institutions. industry body to oversee
standardization of continuous
According to the IFSB, the key education and training.
difference between CAS and Basel II
provisions is the computation of an The lack of human capital in the sector
institution’s risk-weighted capital ratio affects all regions, including nascent
(RWCR). In Islamic banking, given that markets such as the U.K.. Training of
the risks on assets financed by profit- Islamic bankers has not kept pace with
sharing investment account holders do the rapid growth of the sector and, as
not represent risk to the capital of the a result, there are shortages
institution, the CAS allows risk- throughout the industry.
weighted assets that are funded by the
account holders to be deducted from The two centers for training have been
the institution’s total risk-weighted KFH and Bank Islam Malaysia, which
assets in the calculation of RWCR. In between them have been responsible
addition, the assets of IFIs often have for training many Islamic bankers. But
different risk characteristics to high turnover remains a problem.
conventional products, and hence “They come, they learn and they leave
calculating their risk weights may not for better prospects,” says Mr. Al-
Ghannam of KFH.
© 2007 KPMG International. KPMG International provides no client services and is a Swiss
cooperative with which the independent member firms of the KPMG network are affiliated.
306-328 Islamic Finance Surveyv5 27/3/07 13:37 Page 10

10 Growth and Diversification in Islamic Finance

There is some progress being made— Professor Rifaat Abdel Karim, secretary rising demand for Islamic
in particular, Malaysia and Bahrain are general of the IFSB, also agrees that
taking the human capital challenge systemic weaknesses present a big
finance has led to handsome
seriously. In 2006, for example, Bank risk. “Muslim member countries need returns for key players
Negara set up an RM500m endowment to beef up their financial systems,” he
fund to support The International Centre explains. “If you are going to have
for Education in Islamic Finance Islamic banks operating in your
(INCEIF), with the main objectives of system, one of the most important
making Malaysia the leading center for issues is to have a high quality
Islamic finance education and regulatory framework and good
developing human capital for the global supervisory standards. That is the
Islamic finance industry. Similarly in safety net. It is good for market players
2006, The Central Bank of Bahrain set to know what is required from them.
up a US$4.6m Islamic Finance There is still a lot to be done given the
Education scheme in cooperation with growth and developments that are
eight IFIs based in Bahrain. taking place in the global Islamic
finance industry.”
Regulation and legal
Many Muslim countries still do not changing the law or
frameworks have enabling legislation in place
covering the authorization of Islamic
introducing enabling
While rising demand for Islamic finance banks; issuance of Sukuk and legislation takes a lot of
has helped lead to handsome returns securitization; establishment of trusts
for key players, some experts in the and special purpose vehicles (SPVs);
persuasion and time, says
industry are concerned that the rapid the introduction of Takaful (Islamic one Islamic banker
proliferation of IFIs has not been insurance) products, and other such
matched by development in the Islamic issues. Additionally, and of equal
finance regulatory and supervisory concern, many countries have not yet
architecture and infrastructure, considered putting it on the agenda.
especially in the GCC states. Changing the law or introducing
enabling legislation takes a lot of
“One thing that worries me,” explains persuasion and time, says one Islamic
Ali Al-Ghannam, Head of International banker interviewed. In fact, the U.K.
Real Estate at Kuwait Finance House has to date introduced more enabling
(KFH), “is that the IFIs should be legislation to facilitate access for U.K.
controlled better to avoid any bubble in Muslims and others interested in
the industry. There are a huge number Islamic ethical finance to products
of new IFIs being established in the consistent with Islamic principles than
market. Many banks and traditional most of the Islamic Development Bank
companies are converting to Islamic (IDB) member countries.
finance. Islamic banking windows at
global majors are proliferating. Many of
these institutions are not going after
the concept itself, but are following the
flow of money.”

© 2007 KPMG International. KPMG International provides no client services and is a Swiss
cooperative with which the independent member firms of the KPMG network are affiliated.
306-328 Islamic Finance Surveyv5 27/3/07 13:37 Page 11

Growth and Diversification in Islamic Finance 11


306-328 Islamic Finance Surveyv5 27/3/07 13:38 Page 12

12 Growth and Diversification in Islamic Finance

Some notable issues include the lack Financial reporting


of a dedicated Islamic banking law in
Saudi Arabia; few laws relating to The quality and transparency of financial
corporate governance in many MENA reporting and disclosure in the Islamic
countries; the lack of Islamic deposit finance industry differs significantly
insurance schemes (only Malaysia and from one regulatory jurisdiction to
Turkey have such schemes in place); another. There is a general concern in
and a dearth of laws governing the market and among those
securitization, trusts and SPVs. interviewed that IFIs, with the notable
exceptions of those operating in the
Issam Al-Tawari, CEO of Rasameel U.K., Malaysia, Bahrain and perhaps
Structured Finance—the first company Turkey, should have more rigor in their
in Kuwait to be licensed to carry out disclosure and financial reporting,
asset securitization (Tawreeq), financial especially to the general market.
engineering and advisory—stresses
the need for stronger regulatory The international rating agency
infrastructure. “We need to develop Standard & Poor’s, in a report last year
legislation on trusts; leasing; and SPVs entitled ‘Enhancing Financial Reporting
– both to facilitate Sukuk issuances and Transparency: Keys to the Future of
and the development of a capital Islamic Finance’, warned that financial
market in Kuwait,” he explains. disclosure practices among IFIs fall
well short of international best
we need to develop In this regard, the IFSB has started to practice. “Standardisation of financial
establish prudential regulations to reporting is a key challenge for the
legislation on trusts; govern the IFIs. Beside the CAS and rapidly growing Islamic finance
leasing; and SPVs risk management guidelines for IFIs, industry,” said the report, “in order to
the IFSB has released prudential avoid fragmentation and ultimate
regulations on corporate governance ghettoisation at a time when Shariah­
and an exposure draft on disclosure compliant investment vehicles as an
and transparency. These prudential asset class are coming of age.”
regulations should now be considered
and adopted by the various countries The International Financial Reporting
offering Islamic finance. Standards (IFRS) constitute the main
reporting framework for IFIs, but
domestic regulation has also
encouraged heterogeneity over
uniformity. Frameworks in place in the
leading IFI countries include IFRS,
AAOIFI (Accounting and Auditing
Organisation for Islamic Financial
Institutions); Malaysian Accounting
Standards; and some local GAAPs
which are influenced by a combination
of IFRS, AAOIFI and local central bank
reporting guidelines.

© 2007 KPMG International. KPMG International provides no client services and is a Swiss
cooperative with which the independent member firms of the KPMG network are affiliated.
306-328 Islamic Finance Surveyv5 27/3/07 13:38 Page 13

Growth and Diversification in Islamic Finance 13

Women in Islamic Finance

Islamic finance, like conventional In the rest of the GCC, despite fewer and advisory firms. Currently, women
financial services, remains a largely formal restrictions on women in the are also working in senior positions in
male-dominated industry. A woman workplace, very few women are involved the Islamic banking sectors in Brunei,
has yet to be appointed as chief in the Islamic finance sector, this may, in South Africa and the U.K..
executive of an Islamic bank anywhere, part, be due to a strong conservative
even though several women have undercurrent in these societies. Malaysia has gone one step further in
excelled in the industry. an area that has been virtually closed
In many respects, it is Malaysian to women elsewhere. Dr. Eg Rabiah
Empowering women in the sector will women who have set the pace in Adawiah Binti Engku Ali, an academic
largely depend on the existing role of Islamic finance. But even in Malaysia, at the International Islamic University
women in a particular country or while women head the authorities that of Malaysia, is the first registered
economy – a role that ranges widely regulate Islamic finance and capital female Islamic finance Shariah advisor,
across different markets. markets, no Malaysian woman has a development that could change the
risen to head an Islamic bank. face of the Shariah advisory business
In Saudi Arabia, for instance, says over the next decade.
Samra al-Kuwaiz, managing director of Dr. Zeti Akhtar Aziz is the celebrated
the Women’s Division of Osool Governor of Bank Negara Malaysia (the The rising involvement of women in
Brokerage Company in Jeddah: “We Malaysian central bank) under whose Islamic finance has some potential to
live in a male-dominated society, which watch the Islamic banking sector has play a role in tackling the human
is only now viewing women as a flourished, and who brought forward resources bottleneck in Islamic finance.
possible economic force. Saudi Arabia the liberalization of the Malaysian However, for this to happen, many
is a special case. We are different from Islamic banking market by three years Muslim countries would have to
other GCC countries. We have by awarding licenses to three foreign introduce enabling legislation
complete segregation. We have let’s operators: Alrajhi Bank; Kuwait Finance guaranteeing gender equality and equal
say, ‘Islamic challenges’, which are House; and Asia Finance Bank. Similarly, opportunities in the workplace.
more evident in the Kingdom.” Dato Zarinah Anwar is the Chairman of
the Securities Commission, having women in Islamic finance
The difficult position women face in previously worked for the RHB Group,
has some potential to play a
Saudi Arabia is exemplified in the case where she was responsible for
of Dr. Nahed Taher, former chief introducing the Dow Jones RHB Islamic role in tackling the human
economist of The National Commercial Equity Index in 2006. resources bottleneck in
Bank (NCB), one of the largest banks
in Saudi Arabia. She spearheaded the Several non-Muslim women are also
Islamic finance
conversion of NCB’s retail banking seasoned Islamic bankers. One of the
business to an Islamic consumer most experienced is Stella Cox, There is also a straight business case
finance business—a process which is managing director and head of Islamic for an increasing role for women in
still ongoing—but left the bank to be finance at Dawnay Day CAP, the London- Islamic finance: they can unlock major
appointed chief executive officer of based Islamic finance commodity and new market segments for Islamic
First Gulf Bank in Bahrain, a position intermediation entity, whose Islamic banks. The emergence of the Sukuk,
that would not be possible for a commodity finance book business is in according to Ms. al-Kuwaiz represents
woman in her native Saudi Arabia. excess of US$3bn. As the market for a significant market opportunity.
Islamic finance becomes more “Women are risk averse,” she
There is, however, little doubt that established in non-Muslim countries, suggests. “The best kind of investment
women have huge financial impact in including the U.K., the role of women in opportunity for them would be a
the Kingdom and the other GCC the sector will undoubtedly become diversified portfolio based on bonds,
countries. Women, for instance, own stronger, and the experience gained by Sukuk, equities and real estate.”
between 10 percent - 30 percent of women in the U.K. and elsewhere will
brokerage accounts in Saudi Arabia. They be exported to other countries.
also own some 40 percent of family-run
companies, often as silent partners. Women are also coming to the fore in
They have some SR10bn in deposits in the Islamic finance departments of 3: Sources : MENA FN
(http://www.menafn.com/qn_news_story_s.asp?StoryId=1
banks and financial institutions3. international law firms, rating agencies 093146765)
Jeddah Chamber of Commerce and Industry
© 2007 KPMG International. KPMG International provides no client services and is a Swiss
cooperative with which the independent member firms of the KPMG network are affiliated.
306-328 Islamic Finance Surveyv5 27/3/07 13:38 Page 14

14 Growth and Diversification in Islamic Finance

AAOIFI, with its voluntary adoption Mr. Smith of ABC argues that the main
ethic, faces a challenge to convince the issue is that one standard is adopted in
IFI countries. Of the 56 member a particular market. “It’s horses for
countries of the Islamic Development courses,” he explains, “as long as there
Bank, for instance, fewer than ten have is some recognized standard that
adopted the AAOIFI framework. Clearly people can conform to. In Bahrain it
more effort is needed to promote happens to be AAOIFI. They do a good
convergence on this front. job. I say go for AAOIFI.”

Each convention has its pros and cons. Part of the issue with lack of
While much good work has gone into standardization of accounting
producing the AAOIFI standards, it is standards is the variation between
highly unlikely, according to several products offered by different IFIs. For
Islamic bankers interviewed for this example, a mortgage product could be
study, that Europe would adopt these structured differently from one IFI to
standards. In well-regulated markets, another, which could give rise to a
such as the U.K., people do not talk different accounting treatment. Hence,
about Islamic financial products but a broader approach to establishing
alternative investment products. As accounting standards needs to be
such, say some Islamic bankers, talk considered for Islamic finance.
about adopting AAOIFI standards could
simply create more confusion in the
U.K. market. Nevertheless, they agree
that the value of AAOIFI is for
regulators to have a reference point for
better understanding risk.

© 2007 KPMG International. KPMG International provides no client services and is a Swiss
cooperative with which the independent member firms of the KPMG network are affiliated.
306-328 Islamic Finance Surveyv5 27/3/07 13:38 Page 15

Growth and Diversification in Islamic Finance 15

Shariah Convergence such efforts have probably reached


their limits. The Islamic finance
There are significant differences in the industry would be wise, in the words
Shariah interpretation of Fiqh Al- of one banker interviewed, “to live and
Muamalat (Islamic law relating to come to terms with this scenario.”
financial transactions). This can apply
not only to products, but also to KFH’s Mr. Ali Al-Ghannam welcomes
operations and systems, because greater convergence but doubts that it
compliance can depend on certain is achievable in the short term. He
processes being undertaken. These comments that “Shariah scholars do
can cause problems, but it is important not always communicate clearly with
to remember that while harmonization each other. It is this and not the
of contracts, documentation and [theological] differences that is creating
standards is a desired objective, the variances. Our scholars also lack a
equally diversity in Shariah opinions background in finance, and most also
(Fatwas) is enshrined in Islamic legal have a language barrier. This is a huge
history, and will thus remain a feature challenge for the industry.”
of the market by definition.
For institutions in the West, issues of
The lack of Shariah convergence is not Shariah convergence are an issue,
only a phenomenon between Malaysia although not one that should be
and the GCC countries. It also applies overplayed. In general, bankers in non­
within the GCC markets. Much work traditional markets such as the U.K.
has been done to bridge the gap tend to side with the GCC model,
between Malaysia and the GCC simply because this is where the
countries and to promote greater greatest liquidity resides.
Shariah convergence in general. But

© 2007 KPMG International. KPMG International provides no client services and is a Swiss
cooperative with which the independent member firms of the KPMG network are affiliated.
306-328 Islamic Finance Surveyv5 27/3/07 13:38 Page 16

16 Growth and Diversification in Islamic Finance

Measuring Performance The Western rating agencies have so


far declined to develop a specific rating
Given all these complexities, the methodology and criteria for IFIs and
process of measuring the performance instruments based on their unique
of Islamic financial products can be Shariah-compliant structures, arguing
tough. Nonetheless, Basel II demands that their current methodology and
that banks allocate risk by rating, criteria for rating conventional
meaning that the rating of IFIs and institutions and instruments suffice.
instruments such as Sukuk will grow
significantly in importance over the To fill this gap, in Malaysia both the
next few years. Whether setting the Rating Agency of Malaysia (RAM) and
margin in a transaction or the pricing the Malaysian Rating Corporation
for commercial paper, lending (MARC) have pioneered new
institutions and institutional investors methodologies and criteria specifically
will scrutinize balance sheets and for rating IFIs and instruments such
corporate structures. as securities.

Ratings for bonds and Sukuk, especially Nevertheless, institutions such as KFH
sovereign issuances, are important to are prepared to give the Western rating
set a benchmark for individual agencies the benefit of the doubt,
institutions’ pricing of a specific stressing that performance
instrument. However, the major western measurement is a two-way education
rating agencies, such as Standard & process, and that the Western
Poor’s, Moody’s and Fitch, have been agencies “are learning just as much
slow to adapt their processes and from us”.
frameworks relative to the rapid rise of
the Islamic finance world.

“[The Islamic finance sector needs] a


tailor-made rating agency to rate the
performance of IFIs using a
methodology and nomenclature that is
consistent with the specificities of
Islamic finance,” says Mr. Al-Ghannam
of KFH. “The measurement of
performance differs even though the
start and end result of Islamic finance
is the same as conventional financing.
However, in the middle, there is a huge
difference.” It remains to be seen
whether the nascent International
Islamic Rating Agency (IIRA), set up
inter alia by the Islamic Development
Bank, can assume this role.

© 2007 KPMG International. KPMG International provides no client services and is a Swiss
cooperative with which the independent member firms of the KPMG network are affiliated.
306-328 Islamic Finance Surveyv5 27/3/07 13:38 Page 17

Growth and Diversification in Islamic Finance 17

The Role of Advisory Organizations

There is a broad understanding within Practitioners stress that advisory


the Islamic finance sector of the need organizations have themselves
for advisory organizations in the learned much from the experience of
Islamic finance industry. Such IFIs. Over the past three decades,
organizations can provide assistance many of the primary Islamic finance
with a range of issues including tax, tools such as Murabaha, Mudaraba
regulatory compliance, risk procedures, and Ijara were explored and reworked
reporting issues and addressing through the process of collaboration
shortages in human capital. The between the banks, advisory
consensus, however, is that advisory organizations and law firms.
organizations need to be well
resourced, and have a clear separation Mr. Smith of ABC, however, warns that
of advisory and auditing services from the industry point of view, only a
should the company offer both. few of the largest advisory
organizations are “resourced for this
Advisory organizations, according to kind of activity on a global scale.”
Mr. Thomas, can help offset the human Nonetheless, he agrees that retaining
resources bottleneck in the industry, a leading advisory or consultancy
and complement research and organization is essential for IFIs that
development (R&D) especially in are contemplating entering new
structuring and policy initiatives. The markets, given the resources and
banks themselves, he says, simply do expertise that these organizations
not have the time for long, drawn-out can bring.
processes because they must make
money to justify such an allocation
of resources.

© 2007 KPMG International. KPMG International provides no client services and is a Swiss
cooperative with which the independent member firms of the KPMG network are affiliated.
306-328 Islamic Finance Surveyv5 27/3/07 13:38 Page 18

18 Growth and Diversification in Islamic Finance


306-328 Islamic Finance Surveyv5 27/3/07 13:38 Page 19

Growth and Diversification in Islamic Finance 19

4 Conclusion

The Islamic finance industry is here to Muslim countries also want Islamic Conversely, many GCC countries
stay. In the space of three decades it finance to be part of the global effectively follow a de facto dual
has transformed from a peripheral financial system, and are keen to adopt banking model, which many bankers
activity to a sizeable alternative many of the more innovative practices including those interviewed stress is
financial management system. and products as long as they comply the model to emulate.
Compared to the conventional financial with the principles of Fiqh Al-Muamalat
system, it is relatively young. Industry (Islamic law relating to financial As Islamic finance continues its
practitioners are constantly learning transactions). On these principles there expansion and diversification into new
from the experience of the can be no compromise, otherwise the markets and products, there is a real
conventional system, but the learning very ethos and raison d’etre of faith- impetus to understand more clearly
curve remains steep. based Islamic financial management how it can fit into the global banking
would be undermined. sector. As our interviewees indicate,
There is a real potential for expansion there is a strong appetite for growth
in retail banking and consumer finance, As such, regulators such as Dr. Zeti and diversification both among
especially in populous Muslim Akhtar Aziz, Governor of Bank Negara regional Islamic banks and global
countries. Non-traditional markets are Malaysia, see much greater majors. At present, however, there
also expected to become increasingly convergence of Islamic finance with remain a number of barriers to
important, as is the provision of Islamic the global financial system as a niche overcome, including human capital
financial products to non-Muslim alternative financing sector. shortages, differences in Shariah
customers. The challenge here is to interpretation, and a lack of
achieve a suitable level of support from Muslim countries themselves, consistency in financial reporting.
the governments and regulators in however, should seek to address their While the prospects for growth and
these markets towards the sector. Islamic financial architecture. They diversification look good, it appears
need to establish which model they there is still much work to be done to
The growth and diversification of would prefer to follow – the dual fulfil the core ambitions of the sector.
Islamic finance, along with the banking model as in Malaysia where
geopolitical environment in which it the Islamic system operates side-by­
operates, means that it would be side with the conventional system,
unthinkable for the global Islamic cooperating but not interacting; or the
finance industry “to go it alone”. Islamization of the banking system as
Institutions such as the U.S. Treasury, in Iran, Pakistan and Sudan.
the U.K. Treasury, the International
Monetary Fund, the World Bank, and The latter has to a large extent been
the Basel Committee of the Bank of discredited because of the
International Settlements, are all fundamental anomalies that persist,
engaging with the sector in an attempt especially in dealing with the
to “demystify” it and to promote global correspondent banking relations of the
and industry best practice through the Islamic banks. Sudan, Iran and Pakistan
introduction of universal prudential and have all introduced exceptions to the
supervision standards. In addition, with rule allowing Islamic banks to engage
many global banking majors entering in interest-based banking to
the market, there is a real impetus in accommodate these relationships out
the West to promote the orderly of necessity.
development of the sector.

© 2007 KPMG International. KPMG International provides no client services and is a Swiss
cooperative with which the independent member firms of the KPMG network are affiliated.
306-328 Islamic Finance Surveyv6 27/3/07 15:58 Page 22

kpmg.com

Contact

Brendan Nelson Europe & Americas Region


Global Chairman, Financial Services Paul Furneaux
KPMG LLP (U.K.) Partner, Financial Services
Tel: +44 (0) 20 7311 5390 KPMG LLP (U.K.)
Tel: +44 (0) 20 7694 2624
Middle East Region
Jaafar Al Qubaiti Darshan Bijur
Partner, Financial Services Director, Islamic Financing Advisory
KPMG in Bahrain KPMG LLP (U.K.)
Tel: +973 (1) 722 4807 Tel: +44 (0) 20 7311 4527

Andrew Jackson Samer Hijazi


Partner, Financial Services Senior Manager, Financial Services
KPMG in Saudi Arabia KPMG LLP (U.K.)
Tel: +966 (1) 291 4350 Tel: +44 (0) 20 7694 2807

Munther Dajani Asian Sub-Continent Region


Partner, Financial Services Reyaz Mihular
KPMG in Abu Dhabi Partner, Financial Services
Tel: +971 (2) 632 3476 KPMG in India
Tel: +94 (0) 11 2426 401
South East Asia Region
John Lee Africa Region
Partner, Financial Services Ahmed Jaffer
KPMG in Malaysia Partner, Financial Services
Tel: +60 (3) 209 533 88 KPMG in South Africa
Tel: +27 (11) 647 7030
China & Hong Kong Region
Babak Nikzad
Partner, Financial Services
KPMG in Hong Kong
Tel: +852 2978 8297

The information contained herein is of a general nature and is not intended to address the © 2007 KPMG International. KPMG
circumstances of any particular individual or entity. Although we endeavor to provide accurate and International is a Swiss cooperative.
timely information, there can be no guarantee that such information is accurate as of the date it is Member firms of the KPMG network of
received or that it will continue to be accurate in the future. No one should act on such information independent firms are affiliated with KPMG
without appropriate professional advice after a thorough examination of the particular situation. International. KPMG International provides
no client services. No member firm has any
authority to obligate or bind KPMG
The views and opinions are those of the interviewees and the Economist Intelligence Unit and do
International or any other member firm vis-à­
not necessarily represent the views and opinions of KPMG International or KPMG member firms.
vis third parties, nor does KPMG
The information contained within this document does not constitute endorsement by the EIU,
International have any such authority to
KPMG International or KPMG member firms of any of the companies, products or services
obligate or bind any member firm. All rights
mentioned here.
reserved. Printed in United Kingdom.

KPMG and the KPMG logo are registered


trademarks of KPMG International, a Swiss
cooperative.

Designed and produced by KPMG LLP


(UK)'s Design Services
Publication name: Growth and
Diversification in Islamic Finance
Publication number: 306-328
Publication date: March 2007
Printed on recycled material.

You might also like