Professional Documents
Culture Documents
man studies, animal models were developed titis since it appeared to have a minimal role
to study the effects of traumatogenic occlu- in maintaining the attachment level once
sion on periodontal attachment and bone plaque was eliminated.28
loss.20 35 The prominent studies of the 1970s Human research studies reported from
and 1980s were published by Poison and 1986-1987 questioned the effect of occlusal
Zander used squirrel monkeys as their ani- forces on the progression of Periodontitis.37 39
mal model27 35 and by Lindhe, Ericsson, and In a report that evaluated patients with per-
Nyman using beagle dogs as their animal iodontal disease and occlusal parafunction,
model.20 26 In these animal models, the re- Houston et al. concluded that "...there is no
searchers could artificially induce experi- or only weak correlation between periodon-
mental Periodontitis and superimposing a tal disease and bruxism."37 Hakkarainen
traumatogenic occlusion to evaluate its ef- evaluated the effect of the resolution of in-
fects on bone and attachment loss. Studies flammation versus the resolution of occlusal
by both Lindhe and Ericsson21 and Perrier trauma on sulcular fluid flow.38 He found a
and Poison32 presented clinical and histo- significant decrease in sulcular fluid flow af-
logic data which indicated that heavy occlu- ter inflammation was reduced by oral hy-
sal forces, in the absence of Periodontitis, giene instructions and scaling procedures,
led to increased tooth mobility and bone however, no significant reduction of sulcular
loss. Bone loss was present principally in the fluid flow was detected after the elimination
form of widened periodontal ligament spaces of occlusal interferences. Pihlstrom et al.
and, in a few cases, horizontal loss of crestal evaluated the association between occlusal
bone height. trauma, severity of Periodontitis, and radio-
These research groups differed in their graphic bone loss.39 They concluded that
findings, however, when simulated trauma- teeth with occlusal contacts in working, bal-
togenic occlusion was combined with Perio- ancing, and non-working positions had no
dontitis. Studies using beagle dogs indicated greater severity of Periodontitis than teeth
that heavy occlusal forces when combined without these contacts.
with plaque induced Periodontitis led to ac- The subject of occlusal treatment was re-
celerated attachment loss.20'2226 Studies viewed by the World Workshop in Clinical
conducted using squirrel monkeys also Periodontics in 1989.40 After examining the
found bone loss and increased tooth mobil- literature up to that date, the reviewer con-
ity associated with "jiggling forces" used to cluded that the role of occlusal trauma in
simulate a traumatogenic occlusion.27 31 The the pathogenesis of Periodontitis was con-
squirrel monkey studies, however, found lit- troversial and the influence of occlusion on
tle or no effect of traumatic jiggling forces on periodontal therapy remained unresolved.
the rate of plaque associated attachment The 1989 Consensus Report, however, sup-
loss. The authors also reported that elimi- ported the use of occlusal adjustment,
nation of traumatic jiggling forces in the splinting, and orthodontic treatment for a
presence of continuing Periodontitis did not wide variety of clinical problems faced by the
lead to bone regeneration or a reduction in dentist. These included the use of occlusal
mobility.30 The resolution of inflammation in adjustment to reduce mobility and fremitus,
the presence of continuing mobility29 or jig- encourage repair of the periodontal attach-
gling trauma,34 however, led to decreased ment apparatus, treat discomfort during
mobility and increased bone density, but no function, treat parafunction, and to achieve
change in attachment level or alveolar bone functional relationships in conjunction with
level. The results of these studies led clini- restorative dentistry. Splinting was found to
cians to place greater emphasis on the elim- be indicated for the stabilization of teeth for
ination of dental plaque, the etiologic agents a variety of restorative and functional needs.
responsible for Periodontitis, and to estab- Orthodontic treatment was also found to be
lish maintenance programs to maintain per- appropriate for a variety of reasons including
iodontal health.28 Occlusal therapy was the facilitation of occlusal and restorative
deemphasized in the treatment of Periodon- treatment, to aid in the treatment of gingival
Annals of Periodontology
Review: Non-Surgical Pocket Therapy: Dental Occlusion 569
and osseous defects, to improve plaque con- The search also was expanded to include
trol, to eliminate food impaction problems, articles on risk factors to determine if occlu-
and to correct root proximity problems. sion had been implicated as a risk factor in
The multitude of articles, theories, and these research efforts. This expanded the
techniques published on dental occlusion bibliography to those reviewed in this pa-
have spawned a number of descriptive terms per.5678 The 12 most pertinent articles are
which are at times confusing and misused. summarized and presented in rank order in
This can lead to misinterpretation of re- Table 1 56-59.72.73.76-81
search findings and development of therapy Meta-analysis was considered as a method
that may not be based on sound clinical to evaluate the articles in this review. The
principles. To reduce possible ambiguity in proper use of meta-analysis to evaluate the
the evaluation of the articles being reviewed findings of articles related to a specific sub-
in this paper, a glossary of pertinent terms ject requires a large number of studies that
is included at the end of this paper. address the subject to be evaluated; small
This review follows the following outline: differences in findings to be estimated; and
randomized controlled trials; cohort or lon- an ability to rank treatments by superiority
gitudinal studies; non-controlled case stud- which will not be reversed for subgroups.
ies; indirect evidence, animal studies; indi- Meta-analysis was, therefore, not used for
rect evidence, laboratory studies; summary; this review due to the limited number of ar-
future research; and glossary. ticles on the effect of occlusal forces on Per-
A computer search was conducted to lo- iodontitis published since 1988 and the use
cate articles that could be used to evaluate of research animal models which have in the
the effects of occlusal forces on the progres- past resulted in conflicting results. The re-
sion of Periodontitis. The search included viewed articles were ranked and their find-
key words such as occlusion, dental occlu- ings discussed according to the following
sion, bite force, Periodontitis, periodontal rank order, the most important at the top of
disease, etc. The search was limited to arti- the list: 1) randomized controlled trials; 2)
cles published in English after 1988. From cohort or longitudinal studies; 3) case-con-
the thousands of articles published on per- trolled studies; 4) non-controlled case stud-
iodontal disease since 1988, only 96 related ies; 5) descriptive studies; 6) indirect evi-
occlusion or occlusal forces to periodontal dence, animal studies; and 7) indirect
diseases. A review of these articles was con- evidence, laboratory studies.
ducted to eliminate reviews, and articles on
occlusal adjustment technique, discussing RANDOMIZED CONTROLLED TRIALS
philosophy of occlusion, and those which did
not provide direct clinical or research find- Burgett et al. reported results from a ran-
ings.4155 This reduced the initial search to 9 domized clinical trial designed to test the ef-
possibly pertinent articles. It became evident fect of occlusal adjustment as a component
that since 1988 research efforts have of the treatment of Periodontitis.56 Fifty pa-
shifted away from dental occlusion to other tients with moderate to advanced Periodon-
areas of periodontal diagnosis and therapy. titis were entered in the study. All patients
Research in the fields of dental implants, received initial periodontal therapy and were
periodontal regeneration, periodontal plas- randomly divided into two groups who re-
tic surgery, the use of antibiotics to treat ceived either occlusal adjustment or no oc-
Periodontitis, and diagnostic techniques to clusal adjustment prior to definitive perio-
identify pathogenic microorganisms and ac- dontal therapy. The patients were then
tive attachment loss have drawn the inter- treated, in a split mouth design, with modi-
est of researchers away from dental fied Widman flap surgery or scaling and root
occlusion. A journal-by-journal review of planing. Those patients who received occlu-
the major peer reviewed journals was then sal adjustment had a statistically significant
conducted to identify additional pertinent mean probing attachment gain of 0.42 mm
articles not found in the computer search. when compared to the patients with no oc-
CO
g ii
—
lt)
c 5-
» 1-
to II
iL CO d) co 0 73
CD CO CO C x: o
TD CO CO CO
5
.3
IS CO 'ü i« 1 § o. co
co V
II
CD
CO
O
73
CO &
nj 5
c
=1 CO
_
Q. C
_
o I
CO
73
O
c:
0
c
0 co
Q. C
0 0
E
^ o
73 CO
.2- co fZ o
CD
XI
0 3
£ e
co o 'SCO =
CD
„
0 'S 2 2
^ z c
8 §
> xi .2 73 O
CO
>.
CO
0 §
.£ § a C
CO —
e =
-S
CO
°-
fi'c 5 £ 03
m
0 o
*"
o
a £
«1B CD
e
d
O CD
co
B e
0 E ZZ
£ >- 3
<o
*
co 73
EH *-
2
3
0 co
o 2
11
E 0 S
C *J xi a> co o t-I
o 5
CO 3 Ü 6 co O 73 c CO « CO
Ü sz £ 0
c
2
it=
CO
CO
0
„
c=
<=
g
73
~
5
S
C
0 co lu
£
0
-
CO 2 I _>>CO
§2 *
coj=e^co
CO
0
O
co > CO 73 •—
CO
0
CO
o 73
3
co CO
C
B 0 D
0
CD
2- 5
2>5 Q-
> O) O
2 c e q- Ie CO
-£
o .g
11
-
e
o
o
1 I ä
if co 'n
F
co
0
,-
0 ^0
51^ 21
0
B
-a
80 0
co
0
o
o
c
.2
E. CO
CO oo
o c
c 3
a. co
_i °-
73 73 a
0
c S o € 2 < b 3 ._
a ^c b
CO O
C
o to
eg ä
° >, co
2
3 CD
c 0 0 C
0 3= .2
_ 2 S
0 o
0 2 to
x: 1 2
2 ^1 S W s 8
3 o =
P B a 2
'
LL Q. ten I— 0 co CO o XI XI Q .2 73
££CD |£
£ c x: o>
O 0
2>i=
=
XI CD
0
ra
CO
o 0 B
o > -i .e xs
as jr &
io x
73 h 2Q.
-
**
55 c O 0 0 e CD
E £ 73
Hi 0 co .
>..2> >, £0 = V- o
"s e
co
El -
0 .
lo
CO
Ü
Q '-a
0.
.2= e
-£=
_
to
0
-g
=
11e
11 b 2
x3
"°
.
3
co
ill CO
c
°
^
0 73
co
c:
CO = xl co 0 co
b c 0 £ 5 S ±i CO
5 o p co tn
CO CD
CD O
£ <=
O co 15
c
5 O
c —
c -
O -3 x: 23 1 73
B b g
^ o
< 2 co
I zz\
5 -
g CO '5
co
8-1
o co
=
i -c
.2 A co J2
e £ 5 73
d>
A
C
0
e
2
Q. 73 2 Ü CD
> a
<3 >, 0 t
(3 Q 0
-
IO a.
8 II-135e
2 = 0 xl g 73 SB.
>- ö 0- > 73
0
73 e 0 &
10 CO co x: o
CO A > .
0 O i_- x 0
D
co x:
o 73
73
C
0
0
CO
CO
" 0
*> *? s CO 2 £ to CO S a.
I J^-
CO 73
« 2 oo ~ 0
CO
3 l_
O S2 0
. . iS c=
~
"° £ =
CO
CD
5 J £ 5 73
0
CO
2 S? < c 2
i
1 s
O 0 CO XI
c
CD
o co iz £ 8 CO
CO
0 "O o 73 CO u
o ™ 0 o
.0 CO
O 0 _i 0 CO u O O CD o
£ 2 ,co co o 3, 0 o w 2
=
52 < e LL .£ —
73 CL Q. e _
f-
».
o XI o
_
3
-° 3
«
cow
co
C
to d 0
E CO
CO
to ^ E I S
73
co £
P CO
o
0 >
5- i1 o ^= 3 3 co d
3 ?
T tö
0 CO
z -
o ^ B
to CO
—
"
t r
C CD
o co co
CD "=
c C3 CO
>-
c?5 V«2
o o
co
0
o_
CM LT.
.
LO oj co —I ^— CM -I T- LO —I t- LO ü
6!3 &
x: c
cd
< o O CO
cd
0
P> ft! < I < O <
HI
O)
(8
Q 3
CO
g
^
co
3
e
J2
g
T-
co
Z>
a>
t -52 o
Annals of Periodontology
Review: Non-Surgical Pocket Therapy: Dental Occlusion 571
c
CO CO
JO I
CD
>
0 0
CD
£ £ £
>> >>
.g .q .g 9 X3
'co
o
CO
'co
CO
o
I
o
'co
CO
o
'co
CO
O
CL CL 0_ a. OL
<Q |— "> ° CO Cl
O m
O
c =5 2 O
2 o 3
!fi CD 0 o o
£ P —
j=
c
5 -2
CO
CD CO S >> ° 0 ^ 0 2.
CD .
>-
3CD § 1£o JD Ü
O
X3 o
Ü
"5
o
£
co
o t Q
8 o-
Si
§ « CO
O 0 0
£>
2
°
o
£- o
2 'S
o 'S 3
a
E
I
a ^ CD J2 to
co
II
^ CO „
°- CD CO o —
c CD CO <o 0 J3 0
co c
11
CO o
CD
C CD II 3=
0
0
0 t3 o
2 -R
.1 E?
0 .hi
.11
Ü c
Ä o £ T3
tj O 8 1CO 8co 1so
II
CD >
q. >
c
CO
to
sl
-n
0 TS
«
g
cd
CL
CO
CO
*
>i
q. CL
X CD CO CO ^
2O 1
CD
„
CD CL
73
CO
cr
5 o
CO
0 CO
.«
0
B £
0
0
CO
=1 O E E
•a
d "o 0 %
CO t =5 .2 « CO o co
CD
CD
xi .!=
F
o
—
0
t3
II
I!
co co CD = S d
3
co o
0 o
q. q.
(I)
£ .
§1
ü
CO
c
c
§1
ü
co
1=
J3> if o £
„
T3 A
"SCO Ic
S • -i oo SI a
g2<
...
73 T3
co o
0 -d
I CD _l S .2
0 E 0 £
—
s< 0 0
eCD 5E 2 2 3
q. = xz °-
TS t3 TS
2
—
0 0 c
o 0 c
CD T> £ o 2 o p E
0 3
2 «
_
xi q. 0
Ö CO Q. to §
8 g 3CO jd>O
.2 a--a E zs 2 c
s
0
CO « -S o ^
ll
CL
2 £ 5
CD
CO CD Ü co
£ 0
§ -8
I85 5 S§
—
« 0 E Sq.
s _ 1 > E CO c 0 « -d
a o E 5 OS CO CO 73 0
Ü E
o 0
CO
CD
"o CO q_
co
73 c
CD «
g-o
c _o £ E
CO
Cl N p-i g II
CD
JO 0
-
*-
>,
d
2CO
x:
33
o
E
TR ffi co 11 £ £ E o
oil o ~
I£
s o.r
C CO o q. p
~
to o 8 g 1 8 •£ .2
o S
0
E
jo 73
1
® X, xi CO Q "gla.Q is a co JMt
1 gg la >. CD £ I E s JO
„
0 p
CO
0
I1 «Svs
s <N
•Itoo
2 0 0 2
o
I
c
2 x: 0
2 0
co
-
»
O
a
d.
= 03 o co x: co
f
lu a.co 2 E o 2 lu x3 13 lu ü 0- t 5 2 [= 4=
ll CO CO
ZS
CO CO CO
CO CO CO 0
O o o "O
CD •a 'a
0
a
ig,
CO 1 gr
Ü
a)
1S E-§
co
_
ii)
Ö) (0
co "o
r
CO
iE äs s
CD
>,|
o
Ü
0 co
a
c
E
CO CO
73
in cm
S
*8 !E 2
-
J2
CO
't
-g
o
9 S
1-
If i en z
2
73
S
|i 0
CD 7Z
< 0 CO
3 »
CO xi
CO
—
Q. CO
0 0 1=
0
1 §73
O O) "O
CD c O
CD
O
"d
c
-5
Iis
8 I
.8 Si
0 CO >>
CO
0
c
lu
Si
2d ö 5
cm
IZ
S
til P
><
<
CT)
as
T-
_iH Q Q
< O 0- 0_
clusal adjustment and a mean probing at- the effect of occlusion on the comparison of
tachment gain of 0.02 mm. There was no the surgical treatment being evaluated.36
significant effect of occlusal adjustment on The cause(s) of the ongoing tooth mobility
the reduction of probing depth. While the such as continuing occlusal trauma or con-
clinical attachment gain was considered sta- tinued plaque induced inflammation were
tistically significant, this difference may be not reported. Due to the complexities of den-
of limited clinical importance to the clini- tal furcation anatomy, it is difficult to quan-
cian. The authors also stated that "Surpris- tify and separate the effects of compromised
ingly, we did not find any significant plaque control due to the inaccessibility of
difference in reduction of tooth mobility be- the furcation from the other variables.82 89
tween the adjusted and the not adjusted
groups." COHORT OR LONGITUDINAL
In a review of data from a previous ran-
STUDIES
domized controlled human study, Wang et
al. evaluated the influence of furcation in- Ismail et al. reported on the findings from
volvement and tooth mobility on periodontal a group of 165 adults, residing in Tecumseh,
attachment loss and tooth loss for molar MI, who were originally examined in 1959
teeth.57 They reported findings gathered and reexamined in 1987.58 The purpose of
from The University of Michigan longitudinal the study was to evaluate the change in at-
periodontal clinical trial. The data used were tachment level in a sample population of
from 24 of 78 patients who had been treated adults over a period of years. Results of the
with initial periodontal treatment followed re-examination indicated that 10.9% (376
by periodontal surgery using one of three teeth) of the teeth present at the beginning
surgical techniques. The surgical techniques of the study were lost during the 28-year
used included pocket elimination surgery, evaluation period. One hundred (100) of the
modified Widman flap surgery, and gingival 3,487 teeth evaluated were mobile at the
curettage. The 24 patients evaluated had baseline examination. Forty-five percent (45%)
been professional maintained for 8 years of these teeth were lost by the end of the
without missing appointments. The author study. Three-hundred thirteen (313) (83%)
attempted to relate attachment loss and of the teeth lost had an initial attachment
tooth loss over the 8-year period to furcation loss of 2 mm or less. The cause of tooth loss
involvement and tooth mobility. Loss of a was not identified and therefore its effect on
tooth was artificially assigned an attach- the attachment loss measurements could
ment loss of 3.5 mm to account for lost teeth not be determined. Of the remaining teeth
in the attachment loss data. Teeth with fur- evaluated, only 13.3% of the adults exam-
cation involvement were found to have in- ined had a mean attachment loss of 2 mm
crease tooth loss and attachment loss versus or more from 1959 to 1987. This study iden-
teeth without furcation involvement. Mobile tified individuals with higher levels of at-
teeth were reported to have significantly tachment loss as having the following risk
more attachment loss (-1.08 ± 0.41) mm markers: were older; smoked; had tooth
during the maintenance period than non- mobility at the base line examination; had
mobile teeth (-0.48 ± 0.25 mm). A paired t higher levels of gingivitis, calculus, plaque,
test indicated that during the maintenance and tooth mobility at the second examina-
period, molars with furcation involvement tion; and had a lower education level and ir-
and mobility has significantly more attach- regular dental attendance. Increased age,
ment loss than furcation involved molars smoking, and tooth mobility were found to
with no mobility. Several problems make it be the factors most closely related to attach-
difficult to relate these findings to the effect ment loss. Considering any of these factors
of occlusal forces or mobility on Periodonti- to be risk markers does not establish a
tis. Occlusal adjustment was included as a cause and effect relationship. This study did
standard component of initial periodontal not evaluate occlusion and did not indicate
treatment in the original study to minimize if occlusion was an etiologic factor in the dis-
Annals of Periodontology
Review: Non-Surgical Pocket Therapy: Dental Occlusion 573
ease process or in the tooth mobility identi- None of these studies identified occlusion as
fied as arisk factor. a risk factor for Periodontitis; however, oc-
A retrospective study by Jin and Cao in clusal analysis and mobility measurements
1992 attempted to relate clinical signs of a were rarely included in the factors being
Annals of Periodontology
Review: Non-Surgical Pocket Therapy: Dental Occlusion 575
and used for histometric and morphometric changes in mobility may persist for several
measurements. The measurements revealed months after etiologic factors are reduced
that despite clinically healthy gingival tis- and inflammation is resolving.
sues, the teeth which had become mobile In a study in a rat model that evaluated
due to the jiggling forces had lost marginal the effect of experimental traumatic occlu-
bone. An enlarged "supracrestal connective sion on periodontal blood flow, Kvinnsland
tissue compartment" had also developed et al. reported an increase in blood flow to
which resulted in significantly greater clini- both the pulp and periodontal ligament after
cal probing depth measurements. This in- the initiation of heavy occlusal forces.79 In
creased probing depth was related to a de- the early stages of the study the experimen-
crease in collagen density and a more tal "traumatized" side had an increased
vascular connective tissue that was less re- blood flow when compared to the control
sistant to probing without loss of connective side. In the later stages of the experiment,
tissue attachment. both control and experimental sides had in-
In a related study, Giargia et al. reported creased blood flow. This study did not eval-
a reduction of probing depth and mobility af- uate the effects of occlusal forces on
ter removal of plaque retaining ligatures in a Periodontitis but did demonstrate a physio-
beagle dog model.78 This study evaluated the logic response of the periodontal tissues to
effect of experimental Periodontitis on the occlusal forces.
histologic appearance of the periodontal soft INDIRECT EVIDENCE, LABORATORY
tissues, alveolar bone height, and on tooth
mobility. After 120 days of experimentally STUDIES
induced Periodontitis, plaque retaining liga-
Photoelastic model and finite element
tures were removed and a supragingival de-
model studies have evaluated the transmis-
bridement was performed. Block sections,
sion of occlusal forces to the periodon-
taken at the time of ligature removal and 15
tium.80 81 Wylie et al. used a photoelastic
days and 3 months later, were used for his- model to simulate the effect of splinting a
tometric and morphometric evaluation. Ex-
perimental Periodontitis led to the formation periodontally involved tooth to one or more
sound teeth when placing a cantilevered
of an inflammatory lesion, extensive bone
fixed partial denture.80 They found that op-
loss, and markedly increased tooth mobility. timal stress distribution occurred when
Removal of the dental plaque led to reduced
tooth mobility and a decrease in the inflam- splinting the compromised tooth to 2 sound
teeth. Increasing the number of splinted
matory lesion, but no regeneration of lost teeth, beyond two sound teeth, did not sig-
bone. Probing depth which increased due to
the experimental Periodontitis was reduced nificantly decrease the stress transmitted to
the periodontium. Cross-arch splinting did
after removal of the microbial plaque. The not result in a significant sharing of the oc-
authors suggested that the reduced probing
clusal forces.
depth was a result of the soft tissue changes,
due to resolution of inflammation after Using a finite element model, Aydin et al.
evaluated the stresses induced by various
plaque removal and to reduced mobility of loading forces on a mandibular 3-unit fixed
the teeth. The authors' comments on the ef-
fect of reduced mobility on probing depth partial denture using a molar and a premo-
lar as abutments.81 Loads of 300 N to 600 N
changes appeared to be more related to their applied in axial and nonaxial directions were
awareness of the results of the prior Neide-
rud study than to the results of this study. analyzed. Forces applied in non-axial direc-
tions led to an increase the level of stress de-
This study does document an increase in
livered to the alveolar bone. The premolar
mobility due to periodontal inflammation exhibited greater stress distribution to the
and a decrease in that mobility as inflam-
mation is decreased. This result appeared to
bone than the molar when non-axial forces
were applied. Stress levels increased, also,
be independent of occlusal forces in this ex-
when periodontal support was diminished.
perimental model. It also documented that
Studies like these can be used to demon- periodontal attachment level have been doc-
strate the mechanics of transmission of umented when occlusal adjustment was in-
forces from teeth to the periodontium. They cluded as a component of periodontal
can not be used to interpolate results to therapy.56 The extent to which this is clini-
broader and more involved interactions such cally meaningful in the treatment of Perio-
as those involving occlusion and inflamma- dontitis is unclear. The effects of normal
tory periodontal disease. occlusion, parafunctional habits, and tooth
mobility on wound healing have also not
been adequately evaluated.
SUMMARY
Once periodontal health is established,
Despite decades of debate and multiple occlusal therapy can be an aid to help re-
publications that discuss the theory of oc- duce mobility, regain some bone lost due
clusion, occlusal design, and equilibration to traumatic occlusal forces, and to treat a
techniques, there have been few well-de- variety of clinical problems related to oc-
signed human studies that can help answer clusal instability and restorative needs.40 71
the question "does occlusal trauma modify Based on the literature, it appears that a
the progression of attachment loss due to in- clinician's decision whether or not to use
flammatory periodontal disease." The arti- occlusal adjustment as a component of
cles reviewed clearly demonstrate that periodontal therapy should be related to an
occlusal forces are transmitted to the perio- evaluation of clinical factors involving pa-
dontal attachment apparatus80'81 and those tient comfort and function and not based
forces can cause changes in the bone and on the assumption that occlusal adjust-
connective tissue.21-27'77-79 These changes can ment is necessary to stop the progression
effect tooth mobility and clinical probing of Periodontitis.
depth.23,28 74'77 While occlusal forces do not
initiate Periodontitis, results are inconclu-
sive on the interactions between occlusion
FUTURE RESEARCH
and the progression of attachment loss due
to inflammatory periodontal disease. Prospective studies on the effects of occlu-
While some studies found a relationship sal forces on the progression of Periodontitis
between increased attachment loss and are not ethically acceptable in humans.
tooth mobility,57-59 others found no relation- Double-blind controlled prospective human
ship between attachment loss and abnormal studies to determine the effects of occlusal
occlusal contacts.59 Tooth mobility can be a forces and mobility on wound healing follow-
result of a variety of factors including loss of ing periodontal therapy are possible and are
alveolar bone, attachment loss, disruption of badly needed. These studies could answer
the periodontal supporting tissues by in- questions concerning the effects of occlusion
flammation, occlusal forces which lead to and mobility on regenerative periodontal
widening of the periodontal ligament (phys- therapy such as guided tissue regeneration
iologic adaptation), periodontal ligament at- and periodontal plastic surgery.
rophy from disuse, or any process which Studies that attempt to identify risk fac-
effects the supporting periodontal struc- tors for Periodontitis should also include oc-
tures. Therefore, any relationship found be- clusal analysis in the study parameters to
tween tooth mobility and progressing Perio- evaluate this variable. These studies are,
dontitis does not necessarily indite or defend however, retrospective in nature and there-
occlusion as a cofactor in the progression of fore may find it difficult to establish cause
inflammatory periodontal disease. and effect relationships. Animal studies
Periodontitis can be treated and periodon- could help to define the effects of occlusal
tal health maintained without occlusal ad- forces on peri-implant bone loss and to de-
justment and despite the obvious presence termine if excessive occlusal forces can effect
of traumatic occlusal forces. 21,29,74,75 How- the progression of plaque induced peri-im-
ever, statistically greater gains in clinical plantitis.
Annals of Periodontology
Review: Non-Surgical Pocket Therapy: Dental Occlusion 577
14. Comar MD, Kollar JA, Garglulo AW. Local irritation 32. Perrier M, Poison A. The effect of progressive and
and occlusal trauma as co-factors in the periodon- increasing tooth hypermobility on reduced but
tal disease process. JPeriodontol 1969;40:193-200. healthy periodontal supporting tissues. J Periodon-
15. Stahl SS. The responses of the periodontium to tol 1982;53:152-157.
combined gingival inflammation and occluso-func- 33. Poison AM, Zander HA. Effect of periodontal trauma
tional stresses in four human surgical specimens. upon intrabony pockets. J Periodontol 1983;54:
Periodontics 1968;6:14-22. 586-592.
16. Ramfjord SP, Ash MM. Significance of occlusion in 34. Poison AM, Adams RA, Zander HA. Osseous repair
in the presence of active tooth hypermobility. J Clin
the etiology and treatment of early, moderate and
Periodontol 1983;10:370-379.
advanced Periodontitis. J Periodontol 1981 ;52:511-
517. 35. Poison AM. Trauma and progression of marginal
17. Nascimento A, Sallum AW. Periodontal changes in
Periodontitis in squirrel monkeys. II. Co-destructive
factors of Periodontitis and mechanically produced
distant teeth due to trauma from occlusion. J Per-
iodont Res 1975;10:44-48.
injury. J Periodont Res 1974;9:146-152.
36. Knowles J, Burgett F, Morrison E, Nissle R, Ra-
18. Waerhaug J. The infrabony pocket and its relation- mfjord S. Comparison of results following three mo-
ship to trauma from occlusion and subgingival dalities of periodontal therapy related to tooth type
plaque. JPeriodontol 1979;50:355-365. and initial pocket depth. J Clin Periodontol 1980;7:
19. Waerhaug J. The angular bone defect and its relation- 32-47.
ship to trauma from occlusion and down growth of 37. Houston F, Hanamura H, Carlsson GE, Haraldson
subgingival plaque. J Clin Periodontol 1979;6:61-82. T, Rylander H. Mandibular dysfunction and Perio-
20. Lindhe J, Svanberg G. Influence of trauma from oc- dontitis. A comparative study of patients with per-
clusion on progressive experimental Periodontitis in iodontal disease and occlusal parafunctions. Acta
the beagle dog. J Clin Periodontol 1974;1:3-14. Odontol Scand 1987;45:239-246.
38. Hakkarainen K. Relative influence of scaling and
21. Lindhe J, Ericsson I. Influence of trauma from oc-
root planing and occlusal adjustment on sulcular
clusion on reduced but healthy periodontal tissues
in dogs. J Clin Periodontol 1976;3:110-122.
fluid flow. JPeriodontol 1986;57:681-681.
39. Pihlstrom B, Anderson KA, Aeppli D, Schaffer EM.
22. Ericsson I, Lindhe J. Effect of longstanding jiggling
Association between signs of trauma from occlusion
on experimental Periodontitis in the beagle dog. J
and Periodontitis. J Periodontol 1986;57:1-6.
Clin Periodontol 1982;9:497-503.
40. Proceedings of the World Workshop in Clinical Peri-
23. Lindhe J, Ericsson I. The effect of elimination of jig-
odontics. Chicago: The American Academy of Per-
gling forces on periodontally exposed teeth in the iodontology; 1989:111/1.
dog. JPeriodontol 1982;53:562-567. 41. Chasens AI. Controversies in occlusion. Dent Clin
24. Ericsson I, Lindhe J. Effect of longstanding jiggling
North Am 1990;34:111-123.
on experimental marginal Periodontitis in the bea-
42. Rosenbaum RS. The possible effect of periodontal
gle dog. J Clin Periodontol 1982;9:497-503. diseases on occlusal function. Curr Opin Periodontol
25. Ericsson I, Lindhe J. Lack of significance of in- 1993;2:163-169.
creased tooth mobility in experimental Periodonti-
tis. JPeriodontol 1983;55:447-452.
43. Keough B. Occlusal considerations in periodontal
prosthetics. Int J Periodontics Restorative Dent
26. Nyman S, Lindhe J, Ericsson I. The effect of pro- 1992;12:359-371.
gressive tooth mobility on destructive Periodontitis 44. Devlin H. Ferguson MW. Alveolar ridge resorption
in the dog. J Clin Periodontol 1978;5:213-225. and mandibular atrophy. A review of the role of lo-
27. Poison AM, Meitner SW, Zander HA. Trauma and cal and systemic factors. BrDentJ 1991;170:101-
progression of marginal Periodontitis in squirrel 114.
monkeys. III. Adaptation of interproximal alveolar 45. Burgett F. Trauma from occlusion. Periodontal con-
bone to repetitive injury. J Periodont Res 1976; 11: cerns. Dent Clin North Am 1995;39:301-311.
279-289. 46. Rosenbaum RS. The possible effect of periodontal
28. Poison A. The relative importance of plaque and oc- diseases on occlusal function. Curr Opin Periodontol
clusion in periodontal disease. J Clin Periodontol 1993:163-169.
1986;13:923-927. 47. Seaton P. Mechanics of tensile and shear stress
29. Poison AM, Kantor ME, Zander HE. Periodontal re- generation in fixed partial denture retainers. J
pair after reduction of inflammation. J Periodont ProsthetDent 1994;71:237-244.
Res 1979;14:520-525. 48. Mericske-Stern R, Hofmann J, Wedig A, Geering
30. Poison AM, Meitner SW, Zander HA. Trauma and AH. In vivo measurements of maximal occlusal
progression of marginal Periodontitis in squirrel force and minimal pressure threshold on overden-
monkeys. IV. Reversibility of bone loss due to tures supported by implants or natural roots. A
trauma alone and trauma superimposed upon Per- comparative study. Part 1. IntJ Oral Maxillofac Im-
iodontitis. J Periodont Res 1976;11:290-297. plants 1993;8:641-649.
31. Kantor M, Poison AM, Zander HA. Alveolar bone re- 49. Randow K, Detand T. On functional strain in fixed
generation after the removal of inflammatory trau- and removable partial dentures. An experimental in
matic factors. JPeriodontol 1976;47:687-695. vivo study. Acta Odontol Scand 1993;51:333-338.
Annals of Periodontology
Review: Non-Surgical Pocket Therapy: Dental Occlusion 579
50. Ogata K, Okunishi M, Miyake T. Longitudinal study 66. Haffajee AD, Socransky SS, Lindhe J, Kent RL,
on forces transmitted from denture base to retain- Okamoto H, Yoneyama T. Clinical risk indicators
ers of lower distal-extension removable partial den- for periodontal attachment loss. J Clin Periodontol
tures with conus crown telescopic system. J Oral 1991;18:117-125.
Rehabil 1993;20:69-77. 67. Grossi SG, Zambon JJ, HO AW, et al. Assessment
51. Carlsson BR, Carlsson GE, Helkimo E, YontchevE. of risk for periodontal disease. I. Risk indicators for
Masticatory function in patients with extensive attachment loss. J Periodontol 1994;65:260-267.
fixed cantilever prostheses. J Prosthet Dent 1992; 68. Wheeler TT, McArthurWP, MagnussonI, etal. Mod-
68:918-923. eling the relationship between clinical, microbiolog-
52. Ogata K, Miyake T, Okunishi M. Longitudinal study ical, and immunologic parameters and alveolar
on forces distributed in lower distal-extension re- bone levels in an elderly population. J Periodontol
movable partial dentures with circumferencial 1994;65:68-78.
clasps. J Oral Rehabil 1992;19:585-594. 69. Grossi SG, Genco RJ, Machtei EE, et al. Assess-
53. Ogata K, Ishii A, Nagare I. Longitudinal study on ment of risk for periodontal disease. II. Risk indi-
torque transmitted from a denture base to abut- cators for alveolar bone loss. J Periodontol 1995;66:
ment tooth of a distal-extension removable partial
23-29.
dentures with circumferencial clasps. J Oral Reha-
70. Burt BA, Ismail AI, Morrison EC, Beltran ED. Risk
bil 1992;19:245-254.
factors for tooth loss over a 28-year period. J Dent
54. Yang HS, Thompson VP. A two-dimensional stress Res 1990;69:1126-1130.
analysis comparing fixed prosthodontics ap- 71. McGuire MK.
proaches to the tilted molar abutment. Int J Prognosis versus actual outcome. A
Prosthet 1991;4:416-424. long-term survey of 100 treated periodontal pa-
tients under maintenance care. J Penodontol 1991;
55. Laureil L, Lundgren D. Influence of occlusion on
62:51-58.
posterior cantilevers. J Prosthet Dent 1992;67:645-
652. 72. McGuire MK, Nunn ME. Prognosis versus actual
outcome II. The effectiveness of commonly taught
56. Bürgert FG, Ramfjord SP, Nissle RR, Morrison EC,
Charbeneau TD, Caffesse RG. A randomized trial of clinical parameters in developing an accurate prog-
occlusal adjustment in the treatment of Periodon- nosis. J Periodontol 1996;67:658-665.
titis patients. J Clin Penodontol 1992;19:381-387. 73. McGuire MK, Nunn ME. Prognosis versus actual
57. Wang H, Bürgert F, Shyr Y, Ramfjord S. The influ- outcome III. The effectiveness of commonly taught
ence of molar furcation involvement and mobility on clinical parameters in accurately predicting tooth
future clinical periodontal attachment loss. J Per- survival. J Periodontol 1996;67:666-674.
iodontol 1994;65:25-29. 74. Paul BF, Leupold RJ, Towle HJ. Occlusal trauma:
58. Ismail AI, Morrison ED, Burt BA, Caffessee RG, Ka- A case in perspective. J Am Dent Assoc 1995; 126:
vanagh MT. Natural history of periodontal disease 94-98.
in adults: Findings from the Tecumseh periodontal 75. Wolffe GN, Spanauf AJ, Brand G. Changes in occlu-
disease study. J Dent Res 1990;69:430-435. sion during the maintenance of a patient treated
59. Jin L, Cao C. Clinical diagnosis of trauma from oc- with combined periodontal/prosthetic therapy: A
clusion and its relation with severity of Periodonti- case report. Int J Periodontics Restorative Dent
tis. J Clin Periodontol 1992;19:92-97. 1991;11:49-57.
60. Horning GH, Hatch CL, Cohen ME. Risk indicators 76. Ericsson I, Giargia M, Lindhe J, Neiderud AM. Pro-
in a military treatment population. J Periodontol gression of periodontal tissue destruction at
1992;63:297-302. splinted/non-splinted teeth. An experimental study
61. Locker D, Leake JL. Risk indicators and risk mark- in the dog. J Clin Periodontol 1993;20:693-698.
ers for periodontal disease experience in older 77. Neiderud A-M, Ericsson I, Lindhe J. Probing pocket
adults living independently in Ontario, Canada. J depth at mobile/nonmobile teeth. J Clin Periodontol
Dent Res 1993;72:9-17. 1992;19:754-759.
62. Beck JD. Methods of assessing risk for Periodon- 78. Giargia M,Ericsson I, Lindhe J, Berglindh T, Nei-
titis and developing multifactorial models. J Peno- derud A-M. Tooth mobility and resolution of exper-
dontol 1994;65:468-478. imental Periodontitis. Am experimental study in the
63. Kallestal C, Matsson L: Periodontal conditions in a dog. J Clin Periodontol 1994;21:457-464.
group of Swedish adolescents (II). Analysis of data. 79. Kvinnsland S, Kristiansen AB, Kvinnsland I, Heye-
J Clin Periodontol 1990; 17:609-612. raas KJ. Effect of experimental traumatic occlusion
64. Beck JD, Koch GG, Rozier RG, Tudor GE. Preva- on periodontal and pulpal blood flow. Acta Odontol
lence and risk indicators for periodontal attach- Scand 1992;50:211-219.
ment loss in a population of older community- 80. Wylie RS, Caputo AA. Fixed cantilever splints on
dwelling blacks and whites. J Periodontol 1990;61: teeth with normal and reduced periodontal support.
521-528. J Prosthet Dent 1991;66:737-742.
65. Oliver RC, Brown LJ, Löe H. Variations in the prev- 81. Aydin AK, Tekkaya AE. Stresses induced by differ-
alence and extent of Periodontitis. J AmDentAssoc ent loadings around weak abutments. J Prosthet
1991;122:43-48. Dent 1992;68:879-884.
82. Gher ME, Vernino AR. Root anatomy: A local factor dentogingival junction. Int J Periodontics Restora-
in inflammatory periodontal disease. IntJ Periodon- tive Dent 1993;13:443-449.
tics Restorative Dent 1981;l(5):53-63. 86. Hermann D, Gher ME, Dunlap R, Pelleu G. The po-
83. Gher ME, Vernino AR. Root morphology Clinical tential attachment area of the maxillary first molar.
significance in pathogenesis and treatment of peri- JPeriodontol 1983;54:431-4.
-
odontal disease. J Am Dent Assoc 1980; 101:627- 87. Gher ME, Vernino AR. Root Morphology Clinical
633. significance in pathogenesis and treatment of peri-
-
84. Mafia JI, Bissada NF, Maybury JE, Ricchetti P. Ef- odontal disease. J Am Dent Assoc 1980; 101;627-
ficiency of scaling of the molar furcation area with 33.
and without surgical access, frit J Periodontics Re- 88. Bower RC. Furcation morphology relative to perio-
storative Dent 1986;6(6):25-35. dontal treatment. Furcation root surface anatomy.
85. Vacek JS, Gher ME. Cementum anomalies of the JPeriodontol 1979;50:366-374.
89. Bower RC. Furcation morphology relative to perio-
dontal treatment Furcation entrance architecture.
JPeriodontol 1979;50:23-27.
-
Annals of Periodontology