Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Emergent Africa Mark Kaigwa Things You Didn’t Know About Africa Tolu Ogunlesi
Ask China! Sofia Fernandes/Kinfu Adisu/Thomas Sharkey Africa’s Global Community Kasandra
Housley Africa Is Not A Country! Hans Rosling Technology For Transparency Lova Rakotomalala
Talking About A Revolution Lina Ben Mhenni SLUMCODE Albert Nashon Odhoji Spaces Of
Freedom Hisham Almiraat Stop Terrorism! Start Transformation! Arslan Chikhaoui Kenya
Matters Erik Hersman/Ethan Zuckerman A Techie In Love With The Arts Jepchumba Radio
As A Force For Peace Jocelyne Sambira You Beg, Borrow, Steal ;-) Wanuri Kahiu Our Culture
Emmanuel Charlse Richardson For Men Only? Mary Githinji I Want To Be A Computer Genius
William Dwayne-Tyga Junior Memoirs Of A Slum Boy Mark Kamau
Most people outside the continent
imagine Africa as being about the
size of a France or two.
In reality it’s the size of the USA,
China, Japan and most of Europe.
IMPRINT FOTOCREDITS
Translation Editorial:
Paul Morland, Berlin
morland@snafu.de
Contact:
Ulrike Reinhard
Faehrweg
D- Neckarhausen
phone: +
mail: we@we_magazine.net
http://africa.we_magazine.net
Africa
we_volume_/ http://africa.we_magazine.net
we_volume_/
editorial
we
we_volume_/
Welcome to the latest edition of we_magazine: Examples of what is happening are encouraging.
we_africa. Now, according the Economist Magazine, “developing
countries (editor’s remark: ‘developing countries’ is an
During Ulrike’s last trip to Africa (August & expression WE don’t like) are competing on creativity
September 2010) the idea of working on a new issue of ‘in all matter of things’ as well as cost.” That will
we_magazine dedicated to Africa took shape. change business everywhere – the rich world is losing
And now here it is: we_africa! “ its leadership in the sort of breakthrough ideas that
transform industries.
WE have tried to go beyond the stereotype “western-
like“ point of view to zoom in on the continent’s we_africa doesn’t touch too much on business and
incredible richness and diversity. industry but WE still think and can see that these
In various very personal reports from Africans all over transformations are not only happening in business.
the continent WE have sought to draw up an They’re happening everywhere! In the arts, in mobile
authentic picture of Africa – an Africa that is no communications, in society, education and politics.
longer dark but innovative, inspiring and full of hope. And this is what you’ll find here …
This is our contribution to a new worldview.
we_africa is a platform for those who personally
As usual we focus on the transformation processes new drive the change they want to see. It would be great if
technologies are bringing about in our understanding many of you continue to contribute. WE view
of WE. WE as “Westerners”, as industries, as societies, we_africa as an ongoing process which DOES NOT
as nations, as farmers, as schools … 20 years ago none end with the release date … So please do feel free to add
other than Bill Gates said: “What can we do with tech- on! You’re more than welcome!
nology when people are starving? The world’s poorest
two billion people desperately need healthcare right now, And please have a look at our special video collection
not laptops.” Maybe he was right. It is extremely (http://africa-videos.we_magazine.net/) where you’ll
difficult to fashion a technology agenda for the poorest find other stories which WE think come across better
nations in the world. Or at least it was difficult back as video than as text.
then.
COUNTRIES
DISCIPLINES
PEOPLE
All African
we_volume_/
we_volume_/
Emergent Africa
Mark Kaigwa
http://www.mark.co.ke
http://www.twitter.com/mkaigwa
http://afrinnovator.com
http://africandigitalart.com
we_volume_/
Commerce
Community Culture
If we’re to look at how the mobile’s shaping com- From South Africa, we take a trip to Ghana, where
munity, we would look no further than South Africa, like many other countries in Africa, counterfeit drugs
where the instant messaging network MXit’s revolu- are a serious problem. For example, according to
tionised youth culture and social networking across Bright Simons, an estimated % drugs in Nigeria are
the globe. What started out as an SMS-based game fake. The World Trade Organisation estimated that
has evolved into a global mobile social network of fake malaria drugs accounted for , African de-
over million users with a bulk of those users in aths a year. The estimated annual global losses to the
South Africa and over other countries including pharmaceutical industry exceed $ billion, and the
. million users in Indonesia. As far as growth goes, fake drug industry is closely linked to organised crime.
they’re adding over , new users a day from This is where mPedigree comes in.
across the world. Take this example, a patient walks into a pharmacist,
buys drugs and scratches off a panel to reveal a -
digit code. They send that number in an SMS mes-
sage – which is free – using a short dialling code.
Seconds later they get a text back confirming, or other-
wise, the authenticity of those drugs. mPedigree vali-
dates genuine medicines and brings clarity through
one of the most basic of technologies. Started in
Ghana and piloted in both Ghana & Nigeria, the
rapid success of mPedigree has seen it spread to
Kenya and soon to the rest of East Africa.
“African mobile phone users do not have contracts,”
says Mr. Bright Simons, Chief Strategist at mPedigree
“They use top-up scratch cards. So people are very
used to using scratch cards like this.” In addition to
the health benefits and financial rewards, there is also
the benefit of real-time information on drug consump-
One phenomenal example would be Yoza, a series of tion. The mPedigree data, which is routed to data
short cellphone stories that were seeded and spread centres in Ireland and Germany, provides a continuous
through MXit. The outcome in months was , picture of the pharmaceutical needs of the country al-
readers leading to over , comments. % of lowing distribution companies to prevent shortages,
whom left comments after they’d read the content. and giving health professionals early warning of epi-
Steve Vosloo Fellow for st Centurey Learning at demics or unusual drug consumption patterns.
The Shuttleworth Foundation and Project Leader on Each of these examples in their own respective ways
Yoza, describes the mobile phone as “the Kindle of apply culture, commerce and community and are
Africa”. A sentiment that rings true from what we’ve success stories in their own right. The mobile plat-
seen with Yoza and other examples on MXit. form is where Africa is writing the history books.
Through an initiative called MXit cares, the MXit plat- From businesses building on mobile payment plat-
form has gone way beyond just sharing messages to forms to connect the web and the mobile phone to
delivering education in engaging and participatory those tapping MXit’s API to create games and paid
ways to this large audience. Examples include stu- content, what we’re seeing is ecosystems and eco-
dents studying for their final exams in South Africa nomies for innovation developing from the develo-
accessing a maths tutor on MXit and HIV/AIDS infor- ping world.
mation and drug & substance abuse counselling. To The challenge with Africa is to change narratives
put this in context, Europeans spend little more than internationally about the continent, to showcase
% of their average monthly income on mobile com- success stories and to ignite that interest and the
munication, Africans spend .%. new Africa.
we_volume_/
If we have a look at the web and what redefinitions launched and succeeding because of the role such
Africa is promoting, we need not look further than spaces are playing in their localities.
the story behind Ushahidi. An extraordinary story The sum total of this brief journey takes us back to
whose genesis is traced back to a period during where we started this conversation. As we’ve just
Kenya’s / post election violence when blog- traversed the continent from East to South to West
ger Ory Okolloh along with a team of volunteers in- across Sub Saharan Africa we’ve seen just a handful
cluding Erik Herman, David Kobia and Juliana Rotich of stories. There are plenty more to focus on or show-
developed a website to map incidents of violence case, but it starts with your input. This has to be
and peace based on reports submitted via the web a conversation we carry and share between us – a
and mobile phone. This website had , users in conversation that we own.
Kenya, and was the catalyst which made us realize
there was a need for a platform based on it which
could be used by many others around the world. It
was then that Ushahidi was born.
“Ushahidi”, which means “testimony” in Swahili, has
gone on to become one of the world’s best used
crowdsourcing platforms. Ushahidi has always been
free and open-source and is developed, maintained
and driven by a group of passionate volunteers from
across the world, managed by Kenyans; a story in
and of itself. Now, Ushahidi is a global success story
in visualization, interactive mapping and crowdsour-
cing. From monitoring elections in India, Mexico,
Tanzania, Burundi, to the earthquake in Haiti and
more recently the Oil Spill in the United States, Erik
Hersman, Ushahidi cofounder puts it well. “If it’ll It’s time we shaped the African
work in Africa, it’ll work anywhere.”
narrative for the world. Politics
The nexus for all things innovative in Kenya, and
Africa at the moment has to be the innovation hubs. is a reality, so are some of the
It’s hard to point to Kenya right now and not see how development and infrastruc-
the *iHub – is at the forefront of innovation within ture challenges we face, but
the technology space. From hosting events with
leading thought leaders from across the world to
we certainly are in a position
hosting their first set of Green Members – of to dictate the kind of stories
Nairobi’s most promising developers, creatives and that dominate the African
business technologists. Described as an open space for
brand. And now that we’re in
technologists, investors, tech companies and hackers,
this space is a tech community facility with a focus
a position to lead in emerging
on young entrepreneurs, web and mobile phone markets, WE must collaborate
programmers, designers and researchers. It is part and exchange, share and build
open community workspace (co-working), part vector
on what we have. You can be
for investors and VCs and part incubator.
of service by spreading this
Such hubs, labs and co-working spaces are creating message: carrying it, remixing
the physical structure to create sustainable environ- it, orating it, spreading and
ments for conception and execution across the con-
retelling these success stories.
tinent from Limbe Labs in Cameroon to the Hive
Colab in Uganda and Banta Labs in Senegal just to WE can keep this flame
name a few. We have products being developed, glowing. Will you?
we_volume_/
Things
You Didn’t
Know About
Africa
This article was first published in the 3 Quarks Daily, July 26. 2010
http://www.3quarksdaily.com/3quarksdaily/2010/07/5-things-you-didnt-know-about-africa.html
Tolu Ogunlesi
Serengeti, Tanzania
we_volume_/
Africa their Africa that aid money go? Saving Europe’s poor? Or bailing
out Greece and Iceland? Certainly not; it would have
When I think of Tourists’ Africa I almost never think of gone instead towards providing grants for publishers
Nigeria. Tourists stay away from a country like Nigeria and novels churning out books about an ‘imaginary
– those masses of foreigners to be seen at the arrival continent of Africa’, where the only thing that worked
terminal of the Lagos International Airport (MMIA) are would be the dysfunction. If Africa didn’t exist, what
diplomats and NGO-types and oil workers and jour- we today know as Sci-fi would be set on a continent
nalists and researchers, and maybe spies. (And of known as ‘Africa’.
course the occasional ‘Nigerian letter’ victim despe- What would the slave plantations of the New World
rately hoping to recover a lost fortune). For most of have done in the absence of Africa? What would
them there will be the lure of money to be made / ear- Mungo Park have done? David Livingstone? Lord Lugard?
ned – as hardship allowance or crazy business profit. Lord Palmerston? Ryszard Kapuscinski? Bob Geldof?
Nigeria is one country where foreigners come to make What would the World Bank and IMF be without
money, not to fritter it away on guided tours and Africa?
lakeside resorts. If Africa didn’t exist, Steve Jobs would have come to
In the Congo they will be aid workers and diamond- the rescue with the i-frica.
seeking businessmen and gorilla savers; ditto the
Sudan (minus the gorilla-savers and businessmen). In
Liberia and Sierra Leone they will be IMF and World The epidemic of the angry African
Bank officials. In Guinea Bissau they will mostly be
cocaine merchants and US drug enforcement agents. Ever since the arrival of television Africa has been
greatly defined by its children. Kwarshiorkoed Biafran
kids – with bloated bellies and flies in the eyes – shocked
i-frica the world in the final years of the s, and galvani-
zed a massive humanitarian operation, the modern
If Africa didn’t exist, the world – the West, actually – beginnings of the billion-dollar charity industry. A
would have to invent it. If they failed, then China decade and half later the theatre of pity moved to
would have succeeded. Indeed the anthropologist Ethiopia. Bono and Bob Geldof (as we know them
and Africa specialist John Ryle wrote , in his review of today) were born. The hungry African child motif took
Richard Dowden’s Africa: Altered States, Ordinary its place as the unifying metaphor for a continent of
Miracles, in the London Guardian: “In an important grossly disparate parts.
sense, “Africa” is a western invention. Despite attempts And then in the s the helpless African child got
by visionaries to promote unity among the states that tough competition, in the form of the child soldier. In
inherited dominion from Europe’s retreating empires, place of the begging bowl, the African child now held
African politicians have never paid anything more a Kalashnikov. There’s an entire genre of literature
than lip-service to the pan-African ideal.” built around these children; books like Chris Abani’s
But we could even take that concept of invention to Song for Night, Ahmadou Kourouma’s Allah Is Not
the extreme; beyond the invention of African “unity” Obliged, Uzodimma Iweala’s Beasts of No Nation;
to the invention of Africa itself. Ishmael Beah’s A Long Way Gone, China Keitetsi’s
Think of a planet without Africa, without what British Child Soldier: Fighting For My Life.
journalist and author of important books about Today, decades later, another image is emerging, that
the continent, Michela Wrong described (speaking on will both reflect and define the image of the continent
behalf of all foreign journalists) as “Africa’s various in the years to come. It is the angry African. She is
trouble spots, our professional bread and butter.” everything that the child victim is not: educated, pri-
I repeat this: If Africa didn’t exist the West would have vileged, in many cases domiciled in the west. She is
had to invent it. If Africa didn’t exist, where would all angry at the portrayals of Africa by Western media.
http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:mUOrh_htwJ:travel.state.gov/travel/cis_pa_tw/tw/tw_.html+nigeria+travel+alert
&cd=&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=uk
http://www.guardian.co.uk/world//mar//drugstrade
http://www.guardian.co.uk/books//nov//africa
we_volume_/
She foams at the mouth when she sees the TIME Ma- They made handaxes which they used to butcher the
gazine essay on maternal mortality in Sierra Leone, hippos, zebras and baboons they hunted and scaven-
has a JPEG file of the Economist’s famous “The Hope- ged … The Kenyan anthropologist Louis Leakey un-
less Continent” cover on her memory stick; can quote covered a Homo erectus skull here in the s; the
Binyavanga Wainana’s essay “How to write about brain cavity was disappointingly small. There must
Africa” line by rib-cracking line; and is an avid reader have been grunts, gestures with stones, blood, the sky
and commentator on blogs and websites, her mind an blotted with vultures, ape children kept back in the
automated search engine programmed with one darkness …”
word: “Africa”. Ledgard goes on to declare: “We are all Africans. We
The angry African is as helpless about her anger as the originated in Africa. That is proved by the continent’s
hungry African child is about her hunger. But unlike rich genetic inheritance. Africans are more diverse
the hunger the angry African’s anger is justified; every than the rest of humanity put together, because they
bit of it. She has taken the AK from the child soldier, are drawn from the pool of humans who did not leave
emptied it of its lead and filled its cartridges with ink …”
instead. Africa is indeed the world’s past. In its darkest reces-
True, African anger at Western portrayal is not new. ses lies overwhelming shame – the shame of slavery,
Long before now there was Achebe (to mention only of colonialism, of neocolonialism – fuelling the guilt
one example) and his trenchant critique of Joseph of the world.
Conrad. There was the postcolonial anger of the sixties
and seventies. So what’s new? The internet, maybe, But Africa is also the future. Ask China.
which has succeeded in multiplying access to the in-
stigators of the anger as well as to means of expres- Ask Europe in a few decades, when its streets will
sing it. If there were only a handful of angry Africans teem with pensioners, beneath whose combined
before now (mostly sequestered in Ivory Towers), today weight economies will totter; when it’d be easier to
there are armies of them, let loose on the internet. find a mosquito in Germany, than a teenage German.
Backed up by blogs and Twitter and Facebook, angry percent of the world’s cobalt is in Africa, as are
Africans can wield their anger effortlessly. Beware, percent of the world’s arable land, percent of
all you misinterpreters of the continent. Being well- its gold, percent of its platinum, and a sixth of its
intentioned will probably no longer save you. There’s population. Add China and India and Western Europe
a lot to learn from what recently happened to TIME together and the resulting landmass would still be
Africa Bureau chief, Alex Perry. smaller than Africa.
There is an invasion of fibre-optic cabling across huge
swatches of the continent, that is certain to smash
Africa is the past – and the future much of the invisible ceiling that has kept Africa
on the ground floor while the world inches towards
Ever heard of the Rift Valley? It’s the place in East the penthouse.
Africa where scientists tell us humans first learned to It is a fact that it is now much harder than ever before
walk on two feet, and from where the humans who to be a dictator on the continent. Vicious wars have
today occupy other parts of the world commenced ended in Liberia and Sierra Leone and Angola.
their wandering. The Economist’s Intelligent Life ma- Africa, the scar of yesterday (In Tony Blair called
gazine summer issue had as its lead a fascina- the African situation “a scar on the conscience of the
ting piece titled: “We’re all African now.” world”) is also the potential star of tomorrow. It is
In it J.M. Ledgard writes: “According to potassium- where the guilt of the world will be assuaged.
argon dating, hominids lived here for , years.
http://www.time.com/time/photogallery/,,,.html
http://www.granta.com/Magazine//How-to-Write-about-Africa/Page-
http://www.fair.org/blog////times-alex-perry-responds-to-fair/
http://moreintelligentlife.com/content/jm-ledgard/exodus
http://www.eurodad.org/uploadedFiles/Whats_New/Reports/China_in_Africa.pdf
http://manypossibilities.net/african-undersea-cables/
we_volume_/
http://www.quarksdaily.com/quarksdaily///spilling-ink-on-africas-fires.html
http://kristof.blogs.nytimes.com////westerners-on-white-horses/
http://thenationonlineng.net/web/columnist/sunday/tatalo-alamu/index..html
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-IXu-swVk
we_volume_/
If You Want
To Know About
Africa’s Future –
Ask China!
we_volume_/
Africa is still a poor continent. 1.03 billion are living there. Of this 1 billion1 65% live on
under $2 per day2 and 59% of African households do not have electricity3, and the number
increases to 69% if you only look at Sub-Saharan Africa. Nevertheless Africa is no longer
about famine, poverty, and war. That was the Africa of the 20th century. The 21st century
Africa is about opportunity, technology, and entrepreneurship.
You may read about Sudan, Somalia, Zimbabwe, Eastern Congo, and the Ivory Coast in
the New York Times and hear about these countries on the nightly news. But these are only
five of the 54 countries in Africa. The real untold, narrative of Africa is what’s happening
in the other 49 countries. Tremendous economic growth, investment, and rapidly rising
living standards. What happened in South East Asia from 1950 - 2000 (rapid growth and
poverty reduction) is now happening in Africa from 2000 - 2050. Most of the world just
hasn’t realized it yet.
In East Africa (Kenya, Rwanda, Ethiopia, Uganda, and Tanzania) the GDP has grown
at an average annual rate of 7.6% the last four years compared to just 0.5% for the USA.
Africa will be the economic lion of the 21st century as McKinsey proclaimed in their July
Report “Lions on the Move: The Progress and Potential of African Economies.” WE think
Africa is ready now for private investment – we’ve seen in many countries around the
world, that the private sector has huge power to drive positive change in the world. The
best way WE believe investment can contribute to positive change is to help high-growth
companies that are creating jobs expand and create more jobs. At the end of the day,
the cause of poverty is a lack of jobs and productive capital. If you have been to Africa, you
can feel this everywhere. Low education, low health care, and low nutrition are the sym-
ptoms of poverty, not the causes. If you increase someone’s income they can afford better
education, health care, and food for their family. And this is what most development aid and
most countries which invest in China don’t see.
One of the biggest investors in Africa is China … and its investments are viewed critically
in many ways4.This is why WE placed this topic among the first in the line-up!
http://prb.org/Datafinder/Geography/MultiCompare.aspx?variables=®ions=
http://prb.org/Datafinder/Geography/SelectTopic.aspx?category=®ions=
http://www.iea.org/weo/electricity.asp
http://news.bbc.co.uk//hi/africa/.stm und Martine Dahle Huse & Stephen L. Muyakwa:
China in Africa: lending, policy space and governance,
Published by: Norwegian Campaign for Debt Cancellation, http://www.slettgjelda.no
Norwegian Council for Africa, http://www.afrika.no
we_volume_/
tags: investment,
development aid,
Nigeria, Niger,
Zambia, Angola,
business
If You Want To
Know About
Africa’s Future –
Ask China! tags: resources, labor,
Beijing Consensus,
Chinese approach
Kinfu Adisu
Grand Valley State University
Thomas Sharkey
College of Business Administration
The University of Toledo
_
A quote instead of a CV: Thomas is Doctor of Philosophy (PhD), Indiana
“My teaching goal is to create a rigorous learning University, 1985. He received his Masters of Business
environment that is conducive to interaction, colla- Administration (MBA) at University of Akron in
boration and development of critical thinking. It is 1977. He is also a Master of Science and holds a
very important to respect the diverse ideas and Bachelor in Arts.
background of my students and reflect fair and equal
treatment of them in and out of the class room. I also
encourage the understanding of global issues and
the importance of knowledge and cultural exper-
ience as a contributor to personal and national
competitiveness.”
This article was first published in: African Business News, November 6, 2010
http://africabusiness.com/2010/11/06/the-impact-of-chinese-investment-in-africa/
we_volume_/
_ Chinese Investments in Africa The Impact of Chinese Investment in Africa _
Sofia Fernandes Kinfu Adisu / Thomas Sharkey
The search for new markets to sell Chinese overpro- The first phase from to related to colonial
duction in the so-called light industries and also the labor demand called “coolie trade.” Coolie trade
possibility of setting up units of production with the focused mainly on plantation, mining, and railway
aim of exporting to third countries taking advantage construction. Alongside this were small but enter-
of such initiatives as the ACP agreements (Africa, Ca- prising businesses that serviced Chinese labor mar-
ribbean and the Pacific) with Europe and AGOA (Africa kets and undertook small-scale export. The second
Growth and Opportunity Act) that allow fiscal and period was from -. With the establishment
entry advantages to exports with origin in African of the People’s Republic of China and the sub-
countries, are other important drivers of Chinese in- sequent cold war, relations between China and Africa
vestment in Africa. Another important factor is the Chi- became political. China challenged the superpowers
nese search for land plots for agricultural production through foreign aid to Africa in order to cement
we_volume_/
_ to export to China. This seems to be an important ‘South-South’ relations. It also encouraged the in- _
driver for teh Chinese presence in Africa, with its ori- dependence movement in Africa. This is also when
gins going back to the ’s. At that time Chinese as- Chinese economic reforms were being instituted
sistance teams arrived in Africa to build rural allowing liberalization, special economic zones, and
extension programs, namely those regarding the hy- permitting foreign direct investment (Shenkar, ).
brid rice developed in China. Chinese activity in what The last period is from to present, most notice-
concerns food production for local consumption, can able in the last years. According to Broadman
be also perceived throughout the continent. (), there has been movement of Chinese com-
panies into African countries particularly in the areas
Furthermore in analyzing the patterns of Chinese in- of construction, mining, and oil extraction. Such
vestment in Africa one can understand that it embra- efforts have been encouraged by the Chinese go-
ces the entire continent: from oil rich countries such vernment.
as Angola and Nigeria, to land rich countries such as
Zimbabwe to countries with no natural resources like
Cape Verde, an archipelago of nine islands, but where Introduction – Conferences
Chinese shops have spread consistently since
creating fierce competition among Chinese shop One of the cornerstones of Chinese-African rela-
owners. It is important to mention that the countries tionship began after the Bandung conference in
where Chinese engagement is more noticeable are (Muekalia, ), in which, “China began to
the ones that have initially been more prone and wil- cultivate ties and offer economic, technical, and
ling to take foreign investment liberation policies, military support to African countries and liberation
pressured by the West. That is the reason why analysts movements in an effort to unite them against both
like Kragelund comment that without Western influ- superpowers”. This strategy was also reflected at the
ence it would be very difficult for China to maintain first ever China-Africa Co-operation Forum held in
its current investment pace throughout the continent. Beijing from October -, , in which Afri-
Zambia is an example of a country where Chinese in- can countries and ministers were present. Accor-
vestment has been growing steadily since , alt- ding to Muekalia (), the forum expressed a clear
hough concentrated in the mining sector. In the policy goal for dealing with African countries. It in-
stock of Chinese FDI was million dollars, conside- volved co-operations on investment, financial ope-
ring that % of that amount was in the mining sector, rations, debt relief and cancellation, agricultural,
according to data from the Zambia Development natural resources and energy, education, and multi-
Agency and the Association of Chinese Companies in lateral matters. Anshan () also reiterates this, ex-
Zambia. The other sectors involved were manufactu- plaining how the new Chinese approach enhanced
ring (% of FDI), construction (%), and services its relations with Africa in many ways including edu-
(%). It is important to notice also from the available cational, cultural, medical, public health support and
data that the FDI in mining is concentrated in only training.
companies whereas investment in manufacturing
makes only for a quarter of the amount invested in mi-
ning, but is spread through companies. This data Introduction – Motives
may indicate that mining investments come from big
state enterprises, while investment in the manufactu- In view of the above aid strategy, one may suggest
ring sector comes from smaller enterprises, probably the main motive for Chinese relationship is to gain
where private companies are in the majority. access to the abundant raw materials that Africa
offers. Although this may be a good reason, Alden
Kragelund () noted that many Zambian-run shops () states that China’s insistence on recognition
are in fact owned by the Chinese, as well as construction of its “one China” policy by Africans as another
and manufacturing companies which have only a important requirement. Alden () also lists four
“ghost” Zambian partner allowing them to win tenders factors that have shaped China’s contemporary
specifically aimed at Zambian companies. African policy: China’s need for energy security; new
we_volume_/
we_volume_/
_ In Namibia the relationship with the Chinese goes market and investment opportunity; symbolic dip- _
back to the national liberation struggles when the cur- lomacy and development; and forging strategic
rent president received broad support from the Chi- partnerships. According to Konings (), the main
nese government including diplomatic and financial drivers of the China-Africa cooperation is defined by
support. Since the Chinese have been present in recent statement by Chinese government on two
Namibia’s economy, mainly in construction and the re- issues. One is on cooperation: “China will continue
tail trade. Although at first their investment was very to strengthen solidarity and cooperation with African
well appreciated, in the last years there has been gro- countries in the international arena, conduct regu-
wing resentment against the Chinese that has gone lar exchange of views, coordinate positions on major
even further in the Parliament, with the opposition ac- international and regional issues and stand for
cusing the government of corruption in the public ten- mutual support on major issues concerning state
ders won by the Chinese. sovereignty, territorial integrity…” (pp. ) The
other one is the fact that “The one-China principle
Chinese construction companies have been winning is the political foundation for the establishment
contracts, both at the public and private level. Only in and development of China’s relations with African
/ Chinese companies won six of the sixteen pu- countries and regional organizations.” (pp. ).
blic contract tenders. On the private level too Chinese Zweig and Jianhai () concluded that China’s
companies have actually won % of the market African policy is being driven by its domestic deve-
quota in the construction business, according to data lopment strategy. First, it wants to access energy
by Dobler in “Solidarity, Xenophobia and the regulation resources. Second, it wants to establish export
of Chinese business in Namibia”, . To outweigh markets for its light manufacturing, services, agro-
the Chinese presence in the economy the government processing, apparel, and communications offerings.
has to change the bidding rules for public contracts – Already, Africa is full of low-cost motorcycles, elec-
foreign companies are not allowed to bid for contracts tronic and consumer goods made in China.
inferior to million Namibian dollars – as well as the
Affirmative Action Act of announcing that work
permits can only be issued if the workforce skills can- Chinese Investment Model
not be found among the nationals.
According to Sautman and Hairong (), there are
The retail business is very lucrative in Namibia, espe- factors that made China’s relationship with Africa
cially in its northern border area because of the in- distinctive. Other than aid and migration policies,
creasingly good living conditions in Angola. Two big the “Chinese model” of investment and infrastruc-
warehouses sell directly to Angolan traders. ture loans known as the “Beijing Consensus” is a
very important approach that needs to be discussed.
In South Africa investment relations have been gro- In Ramos’s () terms, it is a new attitude towards
wing steadily since the early ’s, especially since politics, development, and global balance of power.
when the Apartheid regime fell. South Africa was In general, it values the political and international
in fact China’s first trading partner until when relations concept of multilateralism, consensus and
Angola outpaced it as China’s main partner on the peaceful co-existence (Wenping, ). This ap-
continent. By Chinese companies had invested proach contrasts with Washington consensus, a neo-
million dollars in more than projects in the liberal paradigm that takes into consideration
areas of agriculture, textiles, electronics, mining, ban- democracy, good governance, and poverty reduction
king, transport and communications, according to (Fine and Jomo, - in Sautman and Hairong).
Garth Shelton in “South Africa and China: a strategic
partnership?”. In fact the biggest outward investment The Chinese model of investment in essence brings
of China up to the present was its buying of a % economic growth objectives and foreign policy to-
stake in the South African Standard Bank in October gether guiding trade and invest decisions in Africa
. along with “no strings attached” financial and
technical assistance (Zafar, ). Chinese bid com-
we_volume_/
_ Other investments are concentrated mainly in the mi- petitively for resource and construction projects _
ning sector, such as the million dollar investment in using investment and infrastructure loans. These
the Limpopo Province Development Corporation to loans are often advanced at zero or near zero
establish a company named ASA minerals aimed at percent interest or allow for repayment in natural
chrome mining. Shanghai Industrial and First Auto resources (Brautigam, ). For example, China of-
Works have invested in manufacturing plants. In this fered US$ billion in aid for infrastructure projects,
regard it is also important to mention South African thereby securing a former Shell Oil block in Angola
investments in China, which according to official sour- by outbidding an Indian proposal. In a similar case,
ces amounted up to in million dollars in over a Chinese firm promised US$ billion in investments
projects in China, in the areas of the brewery and rehabilitation of power stations to secure an
business with SABMillar, entertainment and television oil area sought by western corporations (Alden and
with MIH and Landpac in road building technology. A Davies, ). Many Africans view Chinese invest-
Free Trade Agreement between the countries have ment as different from the western investment.
been under discussion since , but there were ne- According to This Day (), the Chinese are not
gotiations to ensure that South African textile pro- imposing the neo-liberal package of reform usually
duction was protected against Chinese competition in required by the World Bank under its ‘‘conditionality
the first years. Angola is currently the country where provisions.” Chinese aid by contrast comes without
Chinese economic engagement is more noticeable, strings attached and is seen as supporting initiatives
mainly at the level of concessional financing that is by African states to address development issues
used to finance public construction projects. In what not solved by Western investment (Sautman and
concerns FDI we can highlight the investment of ZTE, Hairong, ).
China’s number one telecommunications company,
that has invested so far million dollars in the te-
lecommunication network as well as in the military Chinese Investment in Africa
communication system.
Africa, according to Sautman and Hairong () has
It is also very important to mention the role perfor- the highest return on FDI, ranging from % in
med by China’s Special Economic Zones (SEZ’s) in to % in . Although China’s trade with Africa
Africa. Up to the present there are eight Chinese SEZ’s is small compared to US$. trillion in world trade,
in Africa, namely in Zambia (), Mauritius, Egypt, it has grown from US$ billion in to US$
Ethiopia, Nigeria () and Algeria. These SEZ’s similar to billion in . It is predicted that Chinese invest-
Chinese SEZ’s have tax incentives and are favoured by ment will top the US$ billion mark by the end of
local governments namely in what regards land con- the decade (Taylor, ). As evidence of this trend,
cession. Sometimes SEZ’s are explored through joint there are more than Chinese companies in Africa
ventures set up between local African enterprises and in , one hundred of which are medium to large
Chinese state enterprises, like in Egypt and Zambia. It state owned firms (Xinhua, ).
is also worth mentioning that sometimes the Chinese
companies operating are actually township and village According to Kaplinsky, McCormick and Morris
enterprises, i.e. they are managed by local authorities (), China is having a profound impact on African
in China, such as Tianjin Economic-Technological De- economies. The increasing economic expansion is
velopment Areas, operating in Mauritius. particularly evident in Sub-Saharan Africa. In the last
decade, the Chinese have built a network of trade,
The Zambia-China Economic and Trade Cooperation aid and investment with close to fifty countries
zone operating in the mining region of Chambishi in (Zafar, ). Chinese companies are mining oil
the copper sector, was inaugurated in February in Angola and Sudan, building roads in Ethiopia, ge-
with a total amount invested of million dollars, nerating electricity in Kenya, building infrastructure
according to data from “China’s investment in African and encouraging tourism in Sierra Leone, and servi-
SEZ’s” by the World Bank published in January . In cing mobile phones in Kenya and Nigeria. China’s
January a new Zambia-China Cooperation Zone rapidly developing oil consumption seems to have a
we_volume_/
_ was inaugurated near Lusaka aimed at light manufac- bigger effect on Chinese-African trade (Taylor, ; _
turing and services, with an investment of million McLeary, ). This is the main reason behind the
USD. whole raft of new contracts between and .
During this period, Chinese oil companies have
The SEZ in Egypt is aimed at four clusters: textiles and signed deals to buy refineries and explore oil and
garment, petroleum equipment, automobile assembly gas in Algeria, Gabon, Angola, Nigeria, Ivory Coast,
and electrical equipment. There are plans for a second Kenya, Congo Brazzaville, Namibia, Ethiopia,
development phase for electronics and heavy industry. Madagascar and Sudan. Additionally, China also
As of July , enterprises had already moved into helped in treating infectious diseases such as mala-
the first square kilometer start-up zone. This start-up ria and HIV/AIDS and launched the first overseas
phase is planned to conclude around , when the radio station in Kenya (Brooks and Shin, ).
zone targets to have around companies. In March Recently, China and Nigeria just signed a major oil
the joint venture formed between the local mu- deal worth US$ billion (Swartz and Hall ). It
nicipal Chinese company, Investment Holdings, Egyp- calls for China to build three refineries in Nigeria.
tian interests and the China-Africa Development Fund
won a tender to build a “Chinese-style” SEZ, meaning As a result, trade between them has increased ma-
that it should include a portion destined to residential king China the continent’s third largest trading
use. partner after the European Union and the US. China
has continued to push closer ties with Africa and has
The Ethiopia Oriental Industrial Park was originally awarded US$ billion in aid for the next three years
formed by two private Chinese steel product makers and dispatched volunteers to provide medical assi-
with a total investment of million dollars. The stance and build hospitals and schools (Ewing,
completion of the zone is to be in , but the first ). As Tull () explains, Western criticisms of
cement plant has been working since September China’s human rights record and other international
. Eleven enterprises have signed letters of intent issues have induced the Chinese to seek closer ties
to move into the areas of construction materials, steel with non-western nations in an effort to build inter-
products, home appliances, garment, leather proces- national coalitions.
sing and automobile assembly.
In Mauritius the Chinese developer has been the
Tianli Group, a provincial owned enterprise, run by
Shanxi province local authorities.
_ ceramics, ironware, furniture and a high-tech agricul- always complain about Chinese shop owner’s unfair
tural demonstration park may be added in the future. competition which puts African retail businesses out
The Algeria-China Jiangling Free Trade Zone was pro- of work.
jected to be developed by a Chinese automobile com-
pany, with no local partner. However in early , In some countries such as Nigeria, Niger, Zambia and
reforms in Algeria’s investment regime required fo- more recently Angola, Chinese businesses are linked to
reign investors to have Algerian partners as majority the government. Whenever there are outbursts of so-
shareholders. The project has been on stand-by since cial discontent it has been readily directed against the
November . Chinese who are considered as the closest allies of po-
litical power. It is also important to point out the lack
Other projects however have been established with- of political freedom in many of these societies which
out the official approval and support of the Chinese means that the rage against the political power is di-
Ministry of Commerce (MOFCOM), mostly originated verted to the Chinese ally.
in provincial government enterprises and in private
companies. These projects are characterized mainly by In many countries, as in Zambia, Chinese have inve-
a lower investment amount and more flexible forms. sted in areas that did not attract the interest of other
In Sierra Leone a private joint venture between Henan investors: the Chambishi mines have been unexplored
Guoji and the national Ministry of Trade and Industry, for thirty years, but the Chinese investment has
is specialized in project contracting and international brought them back to production, giving employment
trade and investment. Because companies were sel- to thousands of people. There is however the other
ling imported duty free products in local markets ma- side of the coin: the complaints of the workers about
nufacturing activity in the zone was almost negligible. bad working conditions and low salaries. In October
there was news about Chinese managers having
In Nigeria the Lishi-CSI Industrial Park is a joint venture murdered two Zambian workers complaining on wor-
between two Chinese companies. The zone started king conditions. Riots between managers and workers
operations in July with a total investment plan- in this mine are not new.
ned of to million dollars, focusing on rubber
and plastic products, home appliances, textiles, con- One can understand that these conditions – Chinese
struction materials and machinery manufacturing. labour, Chinese labour conditions in African countries
One of the enterprises, the Nigeria Lishi Group, has and isolation – have a strong negative effect on the
been operating in Nigeria since and owns more ongoing projects as well as on future investments. In
than factories in several African countries. Another spite China does not yet have the practice of corpo-
Industrial Park, is being planned for the textile sector, rate communication, the managers of Chinese enter-
to build an entire value chain. prises should start understanding the principles and
constraints that affect the work on the field. As Lucy
In conclusion, Chinese investments have been gro- Corkin, a SOAS researcher referred they care much
wing progressively since in Africa. However the about establishing high level contacts, but forget
hiring of Chinese labor to the construction projects about the problems on the ground.
has resulted in a visible influx of immigrants to these In the present scenario one can expect increased Chi-
communities, triggering growing resentment against nese engagement in Africa since there are unmista-
the Chinese community. Local communities believe kable complementarities between both economies,
that these jobs – mostly low skilled jobs in construc- but the managing of economic and business relations
tion – could perfectly well be performed by locals. Mo- in future should be made more carefully, baring in
reover the isolation of Chinese communities does not mind culture, interests and needs of the populations
benefit their image, their enterprises nor their goals. concerned.
The Chinese are seen as unwilling to mix or learn the
habits and culture of Africans. In what concerns the
retail trade, although many Africans praise these
shops for the low price of their products, local sellers
we_volume_/
Africa’s Global
Community
Kasandra Housley
resolve the issue of have made exceptional progress building their envis-
ioned network of both online and real world actors.
Africans and the post speeches, questions about the changing role of
China, as well as news and events. Users can also
global community. include posts that link to other articles and websites.
Lastly, users can rate postings and search for specific
African Views expects issues and information.
The blog entries are part of the African Views social
that by building network, and like MySpace or Facebook, users can
create a profile which includes a picture, and other
social networks, new information. Users can track their own comments
and maintain a list of favorite posts for their own
ideas and cultural use. They can connect as friends, invite others, add
information can pass videos, or send messages all in a self contained service
on the African Views site. This allows users to meet
between these new contacts who share their interest, find them and
share very specific information with people working
respective groups on similar projects, thus elegantly merging the AV
site as one of both communication and production.
and thus reduce the Currently, the featured article on the site is titled
“What is African”. It addresses the questions with a
costs, fiscal, temporal review of the various manifestations of ‘African’ fea-
tures across the continent. Ultimately, African Views
and otherwise, of defines African as “anyone who can trace part or all
with a scrolling list tracking the percentage of any groups who have not yet been given the opportunity
state’s given population which can be called African. for external review of their work.
Thus far the website has only trace information on
most African states. However, there are tools in place It is clear that should AV succeed in its mission, the
to add additional information over time. As with other review mechanism has the potential to make a big
portions of the website, the country information difference in Africa. Many African countries still suf-
section is open to collaborative input from registe- fer the scourge of corruption and mismanagement,
red users. The tracking information is not limited, both in the public and private sectors. African Views
however, to Africa alone. Just like the information on has put the power of critique in the hands of obser-
African populations, the data pertaining to states is vers in an exciting way. The infrastructure published
accepted for nearly every country in the world under on the African Views site combined with the various
country profiles. As a result, users can include infor- activities the organization has put forward will allow
mation relevant to anyone in the Diaspora or related African Views to be a dynamic and positive force for
to African politics internationally. Africa and the diaspora well into the future.
In addition to the text or country profile, there is also
a section for country profile videos, which are posted In conjunction with and available through the online
via Google video and YouTube. These videos cover a framework, African Views expects to build a collec-
range of topics, including news and other program- tion of articles worthy of the academic eye. This effort
ming. When a user finds a video of interest on either coincides with the organization’s long term effort to
of these sites, it can be posted under a country for create its own journal in conjunction with the ACEI
use through the Africa Views site. Users will be institutes called the African Views Journal of Inter-
acting as search engines, adding videos under cultural Communication Studies. It is hoped the jour-
country profiles that a regular search engine might nal will contribute to improving quality of life in
have over looked without the requisite key words; African and Diaspora communities, like its mother
by adding videos they find to be relevant. institution, primarily through cooperative and cross
cultural learning.
The African Views Fair Marketplace tool is another
instrument available to AV users. It allows a person Beyond the Internet
to publish their work for free, including articles or
ebooks on the African Views site. Similarly, the site Wale Idris is the director of research and strategy for
makes available an Amazon widget for users to coun- African Views Organization based in Hoboken, New
try target products available on Amazon, making it Jersey. It is clear when speaking to him that he is a
easier to shop and sell related products. In this man- man of both a positive outlook and character. A for-
ner, authors who have materials available on the mer market analyst, he has dedicated his energy to
Amazon site, have a new advertising opportunity furthering the agenda of African Views Organization,
for their products and materials. This is particularly or AV, and the results of his efforts are evident. A gra-
useful for researchers or students looking for new duate of Columbia University, he has used his many
material. talents to aid the organization in growing a new and
Most interesting, however, is the performance review broad range of activities in support of its cause. But
section. This innovation is designed to provide a re- he is quick to reproach any overt focus on him alone.
view mechanism for organizations operating on the “African Views is a collaborative effort”, he insists.
ground on African and Diaspora issues, whether they
are corporations or non-profits. Given the extensive In Zimbabwe African Views is busy building a sup-
history of mismanagement and corruption some in- port system for a future African Cultural Exchange
stitutions have displayed in the past, be they public Institute or ACEI in Gweru. In keeping with the orga-
or private, this is a crucial aspect of the African Views nization’s commitment to working with a wide range
framework. By creating a forum for critique, AV has of partners, Africa Views proposes that the future fa-
also created a space for feedback which may be of cility at Gweru will act as a center for agricultural and
value to the actors themselves, particularly smaller cross cultural learning. The ACEI in Zimbabwe will
we_volume_/
we_volume_/
focus on agricultural development and practices but Views sponsored a conference on the topic of Haiti in
African Views Organization is planning on format- the aftermath of the recent earthquake.
ting a number of ACEI’s in the future to address local At the Haiti conference, there were six panelists,
needs in other countries. each bringing to bear a different side of the story.
African Views leadership anticipates that the ACEI During the discussion it was reiterated that only of
at Gweru will create an atmosphere of learning for the donor countries had fulfilled their pledges, a
both the local community and students. African sobering statistic. It was clear after the conference
Views hopes that the ACEI’s will ultimately become that US policy in Haiti was seen as needing revision,
an engaging student program that acts as a venue but that the Haitian government itself had great
for study abroad and internship opportunities. In the responsibility to bear as well for improving the con-
process, both students and locals can learn from one ditions in that country. On the topic of the Haiti
another. This will be a large part of the AV face in- conference, Wale Idris noted that, its achievement
ternationally. African Views is not an organization was in separating “emotions from practicality”, a
meant only for cyberspace. prime motive AV has in promoting the conferences.
In the United States among both adults and children, African Views selects topics for conferences based on
African Views is at work building educational infra- relevance to current events but also a need for im-
structure in the form curricula broadening the concept proved communication, a key word in the African
of African. In Brooklyn, New York, the organization Views vocabulary. This was the motive behind the
hosted a day program for rd grade students offe- recent conference on economics and governance in
ring them a taste of Africa not limited to drums and the state of Nigeria which African Views co-sponso-
nature parks. The program acted as a smaller version red at the Nigerian Consulate in New York. The
of the African Cultural Exchange program. The stu- novelty in that particular conference was in bringing
dents had the opportunity to learn about Ndebele together Nigerians with the Diaspora for a serious
dolls from South Africa and watch a presentation on exchange of questions and even more serious search
African cultural diversity. The organization anticipa- for answers. The topics covered ranged from libera-
tes that this basic format will soon be expanded for lism to corruption, all of which were in the light of
older students at the middle and high school level years of Nigerian independence.
by including more challenging material relevant to African Views boasts these accomplishments in part-
politics and history. nership with academic professionals, non-profit and
The program for the school at Brooklyn’s PS was public organizations. It sees itself as an organization
a resounding success. The children asked questions which focuses attention on topics which are often
and became engaged. The questions they asked made difficult to discuss, and at times emotionally trying,
an impression on their teachers and visiting instruc- including but not limited to racism, poverty, and the
tors. The educators involved wrote a response letter failure of leadership. The last issue is of particular
to African Views, thankfully acknowledging the salience, not only in state governance in Africa but in
“team effort” that brought “joyful expressions” from Diaspora communities as well. Still, AV focuses on
the students. But more important than the delight the facts and information and a forward looking vision.
students experienced, was the chance each student Part of that vision is encapsulated in the conferences
had to learn of African people and cultures in a posi- and outreach to students, who will ultimately play a
tive way showing the common humanity of all people. crucial role in shaping Africa’s future.
This educational effort is in addition to conferences Africa Views also prides itself on the breadth of its
covering timely topics. African Views aims to provoke activities. When Kasandra Housley, the outreach
thought and energize people to act by using confe- director in Indiana, was asked if African Views suffered
rences and events to stimulate debate. By using the from mission creep she replied, “That is almost the
institution of the conference, AV can bring together point we try to be open to whatever opportunities
academics and practitioners with the general popula- present themselves and as a result have achieved a lot”.
tion to open up the floor of debate to a wider audi- As is evident in its work African Views remains prima-
ence. For example, at the Hoboken Library, African rily focused on outreach and drawing attention to is-
we_volume_/
sues pertinent to the African and diaspora commu- In December the organization launched the
nities. This outreach has included both private and weekly radio show called the African View, airing at
public organizations but especially students, whom PM on Sundays via Skype. This radio show is the first
African Views sees as critical to carrying out its mission. of many anticipated future projects to be produced
by African Views for both radio and television. Cur-
Outlook rently on the AV website there are some broadcasts
available for listening as well as a video on the
African Views has a long list of projects for the future. Nigerian Peoples’ Parliament.
Aside from the African Views Journal of Intercultural African Views desires in the long term to reach a
Communication Studies and the ACEI’s, African Views wide audience through television, and ultimately, to
will continue to seek out new ideas for national and have its own channel on the airwaves. But for now
international conferences on contemporary issues. the organization is committed to taking one step at
Of particular importance in the future will be the rise a time. For African Views, has certainly been a
of China and the role that country is playing in productive year. Already new conference ideas are
changing the African landscape. The interest in that being circulated and new ideas floated for projects.
particular topic, as noted above, has already been de- The organization is off to a fine start for .
monstrated in the African Views discussion boards.
tags: statistics,
global health,
poverty, tintin,
gapminder, HIV,
Karolinska
we_volume_/
Africa Is Not A
Country!
Hans Rosling
we_magazine: we_magazine:
How would you describe the “WE” today? You often use the expression “continuous world” –
What does it mean to you? what do you mean by it?
Hans Rosling: . billion people. Hans Rosling: You have to realize that the difference
is no longer between the West and the rest – it’s bet-
we_magazine: ween the fourth fifths of the world population that’s
What is the driving force behind your work? moving ahead and the one fifth that is left behind. The
new gap in the world will not be between Germany
Hans Rosling: Curiosity. It’s extremely interesting to and China; it will be between China and Ethiopia,
see how the world has changed. Plus the conviction maybe between China and Mozambique. That’s the
that you can talk about the world without doing big challenge: you have to bring all the poorest coun-
advocacy. Some people make it their task to explain tries with you.
what a city looks like. When you come as a tourist
to a new city, you want to see museums, restaurants, we_magazine:
and theatres, and if you come on business you want And you have to distinguish between different countries
to know where banks and companies are – you need in a much better way than we usually do …
a map to find your way around. Gapminder provides
an updated economic, social and environmental map Hans Rosling: Exactly. Africa is NOT one country!
of the world so users can find their way around. There are huge differences between the countries in
Africa. It's misleading to treat them as one and the
we_magazine: same. For example: life expectancy in Cape Verde is
What is the core idea behind Gapminder? years longer than in Swaziland yet both are African
countries. Botswana is one of the top achievers in
Hans Rosling: To use the graphic animation techno- the world when it comes to sustained economic
logy behind computer games to show the changing growth. It has been democratic and peaceful ever
world. We apply computer games “enjoyment” to since independence. And it is also an African country.
statistics to upgrade old mindsets and thereby create The Democratic Republic of the Congo is one of the
a fact-based worldview. We must upgrade the world- most tragic economic disasters in the world, plagued
view from a “Tintin” view where the world is divided by despots and war ever since its independence.
into the West and the rest. But to understand econo- Millions have died since the Second Congo War broke
mic development, demographic change and health out in . It is the poorest country in the world. And
improvements, we now have to make data about the the DR Congo is also an African country.
world accessible in a new format. Basically, it’s a new
map: instead of north and south, we display country Or look at HIV. There are huge differences within
bubbles on a scale from healthy to sick, and instead of the African continent:
east and west, we show rich and poor.
You can clearly see that higher income does NOT we-magazine:
guarantee a smaller percentage of adults having HIV, How about if you look at a specific country?
and that the numbers vary tremendously from country
to country. Hans Rosling: Yes. Let’s take Botswana as an example.
The rise, fall and re-rise of health in Botswana. In
The Institute of Health Metrics have estimated the at independence Botswana was a poor country with
average number of years spent in schooling by men low life expectancy. years of remarkable progress
and women in different age groups for almost all increased life expectancy within years. This gain in
countries. The methods used for these estimates are life expectancy was lost during the s with the HIV
all well-documented. epidemic. By , Botswana had outpaced Turkey
and caught up with Brazil. Then HIV grew to tragic
This data shows that there is no correlation between levels, causing life expectancy to plummet by years.
education levels in countries all over the world and Over the past five years, however, treatment of infec-
the percentage of adults living with HIV. No matter if ted persons has reduced AIDS-related deaths by over
you live in the US or Africa, education does NOT corre- %. This has caused life expectancy to rise again.
late with HIV infection.
we_volume_/
we_magazine: Same thing with per capita GDP and child survival –
What about the correlation between children per woman there are huge differences between different coun-
and life expectancy? How does it look in Africa today? tries. While in Sierra Leone, for instance, there is little
money and high child mortality, Mauritius is once
Hans Rosling: Once again, there are huge differences more doing very well – with good money and a high
within the entire continent – countries like Reunion, child survival rate. Mauritius was the first country
Cape Verde and Mauritius have already caught up with to abolish trade barriers in Africa so they could sell
most of the Asian countries, and even with Europe their sugar and textiles on equal terms with the
and the US. But they are still many places like Somalia, people in Europe and North America. Ghana is right in
Uganda, Niger, Chad and Congo – to name just a few the middle between these two … Sierra Leone needs
– in which life expectancy is around years and the humanitarian aid, Uganda development aid, in Ghana
number of children per woman is greater than . it is time to invest and as we climb up to the top we
arrive at Mauritius – where you can go on vacation;-)
we_volume_/
we_magazine:
What do you mean … serious in which way?
we_magazine:
How come that you are so closely related to the poorest
in the world Hans Rosling?
Countries
we_volume_/
we_volume_/
Technology for
Transparency –
Text Messages
To Help Protect To
Children Against
Violence
Lova Rakotomalala
This article was first published on Global Voices, October, 19, 2010
http://globalvoicesonline.org/2010/10/19/benin-text-messages-to-help-protect-children-against-violence-lessons-learned/
we_volume_/
Technology for Transparency Network (TTN): TTN: What type of violence is more prominent in Benin
Tell us a little bit about the project, the genesis of the idea for and how would the project impact on the incidents?
a text message-based reporting system.
LR: The Ministry of Family generously sent the latest
Linda Raftree (LR): The project is managed by my statistics. Besides the national numbers mentioned
colleague who works in the West Africa regional office earlier, the study reports that in , about ,
and I’m supporting with the ICT integration. It started children (%) are forced to work in illegal conditions
off really as a youth project funded by our office in and that % are performing dangerous work activi-
Finland and an effort to break down the UN recom- ties. Gender-based violence is also still very important.
mendations from the Violence against Children (VAC) % of girls reported having experienced physical
study into a more mainstream language. The idea was abuse and % were verbally abused; .% were se-
to make specific areas of the study more palatable to questered at least once; .% had undergone female
the general population. The original VAC study was genital cutting (FGC) and .% of girls between the
conducted over about years in consultation with age of to had been raped.
hundreds of children, and the goal of the broader VAC Evidently, one must take into account that definitions
project is to increase awareness amongst children and of corporal punishment and verbal abuse can be cul-
adults, to get them to learn about the effects of turally different. There is also violence at school where
violence and how to prevent it and to share the corporal punishment is still a commonly utilized educa-
knowledge with their peers. tional method. % of students report having experi-
We (Plan) organized a conference in Kenya on social enced corporal punishment either inside or outside
change through new media in December , where the school.
my colleague Anastasie Koudoh in Dakar heard of So we really put the emphasis on having the support of
FrontlineSMS and Ushahidi. She started wondering the community when raising awareness and addres-
whether such a system could be set up to track vio- sing social change around this issue. We would not
lence via cell phone messages. We knew from the VAC order people around but we would explain why this is
study that many incidents of violence are not repor- not the best way, and provide alternative ways with the
ted for various reasons and decided to see if we could backing of the community. It can be difficult at times if
remedy that. We discussed internally with colleagues it is culturally ingrained.
from our Dakar and our Finnish office and we had a
lot of questions about implementation, privacy and TTN: Have you done an evaluation of the impact of the
management of the platform, etc. In January, I was project so far, and are alternatives to the SMS reporting system
lucky enough to meet for a day with Josh Nesbit and (e.g. voice reporting) being considered?
James Bon Tempo at our office in Washington DC and
we discussed and sorted out some basics about imple- LR: Colleagues are planning a check-in the first week of
mentation, data collection and privacy. We got our November with our regional specialist on child protec-
Ushahidi instance set up with help from our colleague tion. They’ll be looking at achievements and challen-
Mika at the Finnish office and the folks at Ushahidi. ges in the areas of: technology (is it working? If not,
Then I went to Benin and supported Anastasie and the why not? What do we need to adjust); human resour-
staff there to conduct workshops with the children in ces and local capacities for managing the system; part-
the community, the staff, the child protection services nership and the relationship with the local and
and the Ministry of Family, consulted with them and national government in terms of their ability and
went through the whole process of how SMS repor- interest to take on and manage the system; and re-
ting might be set up. We asked whether they thought sponse – what is the current capacity to respond? How
this new system would help, the type of information can this be improved? They’ll also do a more detailed
that they thought we might want to collect and any mapping out of all the different potential child pro-
additional risks to people reporting that we might not tection actors in the communities, including health
have thought of. Basically making sure that everyone’s workers, schools, and traditional authorities, in order
input was fully integrated into the system. to see how we can best ensure the system is integra-
ted with existing community structures and see how
we_volume_/
this sort of integration can improve local capacities to any victims or witnesses, a child protection officer at
respond to reports of violence. We’ll build a forward our district office receives the report through Frontli-
looking plan based on this assessment of the project. neSMS and Ushahidi and makes a phone call to the
So far, the staff have stated that they are satisfied with point person in that area (a CPS agent or a police of-
the set-up of the project as it is now, but they know ficer). Once we get the ‘alerts’ system functioning in
that there are a lot more reports that could be coming Ushahidi, this can be automated. At that point, the re-
in. They only have received reports via SMS since port is officially filed into the governmental system.
the start of the project, but it’s difficult to assess why
those potentials reports are not coming in: whether TTN: Could you give a broad estimate of the cost of the project?
it is the medium (text messages) or other factors in-
dependent of the new system in place. During the LR: Anastasie says that the training in Benin cost
technology assessment, we’ll look at what we can do around $,, plus the purchase of phone/modem
from that side, for example by potentially integrating for the FrontLineSMS platform. We used an existing
voice in addition to SMS and adding an improved way computer. That’s just the simple part of the project
to track verification and follow up of reported cases. though, and doesn’t include the staff time, the broa-
One could argue that the project already allowed for der project activities and work with the youth before/
more reports that would not have been reported if the after the training, and the costs of follow up that are
new system were not in place. Therefore, even if we are ongoing.
still missing many unreported cases, we are getting a
few more, and that’s progress. In my opinion, it is a TTN: Do you think the Ushahidi platform would benefit
good start if it just gets people to think differently and from being translated into the local language like Yoruba ?
look at the issue differently. Also we might see the dif-
ference not just in SMS reporting, but in reporting LR: Actually, the mapping portion of Ushahidi is not
overall. That would then allow us to evaluate what useful for the local communities. Very few of them
other channels we could consider for reporting and have access to internet so the Ushahidi platform is
which ones would be the most effective. mostly utilized by the staff and the agency, who would
At the end of the day, though, reporting is not the big- know the local languages, French and some English.
gest bottleneck – the biggest bottleneck is usually the So the SMS reports can be received in any language
response. Suppose we had reports that came in and the administrators would translate them into
by SMS, there would not be the capacity to respond French. The web interface and the map are more of
to them. So slow growth may actually be beneficial to an advocacy tool than a reporting system. For exam-
the project. Utilizing the system to advocate for more ple, we can share the map with community leaders,
capacity for child services is also one aspect of the pro- local authorities, school official and the various mini-
ject that we look into very closely. We don’t want to stries as we have more information coming in and
set up a reporting mechanism that would not be able discuss the issue with them and look for solutions. We
to deliver an adequate response mechanism. also have a privacy issue, so we are considering ma-
king it a private page or a password-protected page
TTN: How does the response mechanism work? because I am not convinced that it has any utility at
Who manages the reports and the responses? this point for someone working outside the child pro-
tection system. That would also offer some additional
LR: We are working with the Centre de Protection So- protection to the victims.
cial (CPS) and they ultimately report to the Ministry of
the Family and have the responsibility to follow up on TTN: Has the government approached you about down-
any type of child abuse. Benin has a government loading the data collected so far?
agency and clear laws against child abuse. At the
workshop, we try to gather all the local agents that LR: That’s a good question. I am not sure if the data
have some type of responsibility who can respond in has been downloaded by the government yet. What
case of child abuse (social agents but also police and we wanted to be careful about is involving the higher
community leaders). So when we receive reports from level of the government in the early phases. We wan-
we_volume_/
ted to work with the local authorities – with the ap- information, what kind of response can be triggered.
proval of the national government, of course. We It’s a difficult issue. We are looking into supporting
wanted to optimize the system to the point where it is local protection mechanisms within the communities,
easy to understand and flawless, and then advocate but this is also tricky because the perpetrators of the
for it to be adopted at higher levels. We would not violence might be parents, relatives or teachers or lea-
want to present a system that is only half-way ready ders in the community. So one of the first critical
and risk having it rejected. points is always awareness raising on the negative
impacts of violence on children or whichever issue
TTN: Since it is really focused on the community, how did that you are hoping to address.
you approach publicizing the number to which text reports What makes a difference is when the children feel em-
should be sent? powered to discuss the issue of violence. Children are
organizing radio shows centered around violence and
LR: We are working on a communication strategy and learning to look for help. There are also traditional
outreach. We need to not only determine the best way justice systems in most of the remote communities
to advertise the number, but also take care of educa- that deal with the issue of violence and we try to work
ting the community about the importance of aware- with them whenever it’s possible.
ness and how to report abuse correctly. We need them
to send complete information in the text messages,
otherwise we cannot help. There are also some new
plug-ins in FrontlineSMS that can help with better data
collection. We are also looking into possibly adding a Facts about Benin
voice feature to see if more reports would come in.
The Republic of Benin is a country in West Africa.
TTN: Are there any additional lessons learned or remarks It borders Togo to the west, Nigeria to the east and
that you would like to add? Burkina Faso and Niger to the north. The capital of
Benin is Porto-Novo but the seat of government is
LR: It is interesting to compare this project, where a located in the country’s largest city of Cotonou. Benin
structure is in place for child protection, with other covers an area of approximately , square kilo-
places. For instance, we thought about implementing meters with a population of approximately . million.
a similar project in a neighboring country, but the While Benin has seen economic growth over the past
government there is basically not interested. So the few years and is one of Africa’s largest cotton produ-
complexity there is: how does one implement a child cers, (the main driver of growth is the agricultural
protection service in a more fragile state? Would we sector, with cotton being the country’s main export) it
be able to work with a community-based protection heavily relies on trade with its eastern neighbour,
group and do without the presence of an established Nigeria.
structure? In my opinion, it’s becoming increasingly Benin ranks among the world’s poorest countries.
important not only for projects like ours, but any Currently, about a third of the population live below
Ushahidi deployment or SMS reporting in general, to the international poverty line of . $ per day and
think beyond data collection and address the response particulary women are subject to illiteracy. Only .%
mechanism when there is no judicial system. One can of the population have access to the internet.
look at Haiti and violence against women in the
aftermath of the earthquake. Sure we can talk about But Benin is also one of Africa’s most stable democra-
reporting violence, but who will respond to the cies: The political system is derived from the
reports? Maybe we should also address funding for Constitution of Benin and the subsequent transition to
building a response mechanism to go along with the democracy in . The International Press Institute
reporting mechanism. Maybe that is where we need (IPI) says Benin has one of the region’s “most vibrant
the next wave of innovation to focus on. Even in the media landscapes” while it is ranked rd out of
aid field in general, information shortage is not usu- countries in the Worldwide Press Freedom Index by
ally the issue, but rather what we can do with the Reporters Without Borders in .
we_volume_/
Talking About A
Revolution
Tunisia is the northernmost country in Africa. It is a President’s official speeches are full of references to
Maghreb country, bordered by Algeria to the west, the importance of democracy and freedom of speech.
Libya to the southeast, and the Mediterranean Sea to According to Amnesty International, “the Tunisian
the north and east. Its area is almost , km², government is misleading the world as it conveys a
with an estimated population of just over . million. positive image of the human rights situation in the
Tunisia has close relations with both the European country while abuses by its security forces continue
Union – with whom it has an association agreement – unabated and are committed with impunity”.
and the Arab world.
Tunisia practices some Internet censorship, including
Tunisia has a diverse economy, ranging from agricul- the blocking of certain websites, such as YouTube,
ture, mining and manufacturing to petroleum products Facebook, Twitter, Daily Motion and others, Reporters
and tourism. The industrial sector is mainly made up of Without Borders includes Tunisia in the country list of
clothing and footwear manufacturing, production of ‘Enemies of the Internet’ together with North Korea,
car parts, and electrical machinery. Although Tunisia Saudi Arabia and Turkmenistan. In January US
managed an average % growth over the last decade Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton sighted Tuni-
it continues to suffer from high unemployment sia and China as the two countries with the greatest
especially among youth. Tunisia was ranked the most internet censorship.
competitive economy in Africa and the th in the
world by the World Economic Forum. Tunisia has The state owned ‘Publinet’ internet network has more
managed to attract many international companies than . million users. The Tunisian netizens are the
such as Airbus and Hewlett-Packard. most connected community on Facebook in North
Since Tunisia has formally reformed its political Africa.
system several times, abolishing life presidency and
opening up the parliament to opposition parties. The
In Tunisia two weeks ago unrest started when Despite constitutional guarantees of freedom of
a young Tunisian man, Mohamed Bouazizi, set expression and association, the government uses
himself on fire to protest the country’s high un- an array of legal, penal and economic measures
employment rate. The incident, which took place to silence dissenting voices. In June of this year,
in the provincial town of Sidi Bouzid, became Tunisia’s Parliament passed a law that crimina-
the catalyst that sparked widespread protest and lizes opposition activities. Journalists and blog-
riots that have become a referendum on the gers as well as human rights activists and voices of
government of President Zine el-Abidine Ben political dissent are routinely harassed, arrested
Ali. Protesters are calling for an end to corrup- and imprisoned. The state strictly monitors and
tion, nepotism, and restrictions on basic freedoms. severely curbs the work of opposition parties.
There have been reports of Tunisian security
forces opening fire on protesters as well as large WE conducted this interview with Lina Ben
scale arrests and torture of prisoners. Although Mhenni, a young Tunisian activist and blogger,
traditional media in Tunisia is heavily restricted on December 30, 2010, two and a half weeks
and authorities have sophisticated methods for after the unrest in Tunisia started.
repressing internet freedom, reports of the protests
have spread through non-traditional forms of By now it has spread to Egypt.
media as bloggers and regular citizens have been
tracking the events.
we_volume_/
we_magazine: we_magazine:
Lina, when did you start blogging and why? How would you describe the current situation in Tunisia?
Lina Ben Mhenni (Lina): Lina: Let’s face the truth: Tunisia is a police state.
I started blogging in . First I was expressing my There is no doubt on this. People are afraid of express-
thoughts and feelings on how we live in Tunisia. I ing themselves, if they say anything wrong prison is
wrote about small social problems. Sometimes I wrote waiting. This is tough! There is no freedom of speech
poetry. in Tunisia. Media is controlled by the government.
In I went to the US, I was lucky enough to get a There are no independent TV channels or radio stati-
Fullbright scholarship. Two weeks after my arrival I no- ons or newspapers. Even the so-called “private” media
ticed the censorship of Facebook back home. With is owned by family members of the President.
some bloggers we launched a campaign against the
censorship of Facebook and I started to write about And also the economic situation is not really good,
it. Then Sami Ben Gharbia, director of Global Voices even though Tunisia is doing well in comparison to
Advocacy and Tunisian native, asked me to write for other African countries. But people are suffering: un-
Global Voices. Back then I joined them and my first employment rates are very high, living costs are very
blogpost dealt with censorship in Tunisa. high – it is hard to make a living and to find a job!
we_magazine: we_magazine:
Your personal blog is censored in Tunisia, isn’t it? Lina, could you please give us a brief timeline of what
happened so far during this revolution?
Lina: Yes. They blocked it in February , as well as
my Facebook profile and most recently, actually only Lina: The trigger for this revolution was the fact that a
hours ago, they censored my Twitter account. young unemployed man, Mohamed Bouazizi, set him-
The very first time I experienced censorship at all was self on fire to protest the country’s high unemploy-
when I was running a blog together with a dissident ment rate. This was in Sidi Bouzid. From there the riots
journalist in . spread to other areas in the country. And instead of
They just shut it down … they don’t give you any kind trying to find a solution, the government repressed
of warning. the movement and they even shot and killed some
people.
we_magazine:
Why do you call the unrest in Tunisia a revolution After the first suicide, another young man killed him-
and not riots? self. This second incident was in my eyes the main rea-
son why the movement really expanded all over
Lina: Because it is coming from the citizens. It is not Tunisia. People were very angry and started protesting
the opposition which is monitoring this. It is just the ...
people who are fed up with dictatorship, they are tired
of our current system. The people are expressing
themselves and say no to the existing situation in the
country. It is a grass roots movement – and this is why
I want to call it revolution. And from the people's side,
it is a peaceful revolution.
we_volume_/
we_magazine:
How is the situation right now in Tunis where
you are based?
we_magazine:
As far as I am informed many lawyers take part in
the protests. What role do they play?
Lina: We are using Facebook, cell phones and twitter. Lina: Until today I would say YES, there is a real chance
But since two days all of these tools are censored – we that change will happen.
cannot upload videos any more, our profiles are block- After the President’s public speech on television in
ed, even our Twitter accounts are blocked. So com- which he was threatening the people and putting
munication becomes harder. Today they even shut pressure on them NOT to join the protests, people are
down temporarily the mobile infrastructure, because still going out to demonstrate … this is new. We never
we were live streaming with our cell phones from the experienced anything like that before!
events. In people went on the streets. But it remained
local. It didn’t expand into other areas of the country.
This time it is different – it is expanding all over Tuni-
sia and people don’t allow the government to intimi-
date them.
we_magazine: we_magazine:
What kind of change do you want to see? Is there any kind of dialogue going on between the
government and the protestors?
Lina: No more dictatorship! We want to get rid of the
people who are ruling the country. We want to have Lina: No, not at all.
freedom, we want to have justice. We want to be trea- The only communication is the violence of the police!
ted as free citizens! We don’t need corruption any
more! The reigning family is controlling anything, they we_magazine:
are stealing the country’s money. We don’t want this Is there at least a chance for communication?
any more!
Lina: No, I don’t think so. The President’s speech – he
we_magazine: gave one so far during the unrest, I think it was on
Why is this happening right NOW? December , – only aimed to threaten the
demonstrators. No sign of giving in. He is not reaching
Lina: To be honest, I don’t know. out his hands to us ...
Maybe after years of dictatorship, people are sim-
ply fed up. They are tired of all of this. we_magazine:
This young man who killed himself by setting himself What is going to happen next Lina?
on fire – he really made a point. This was real. It was
tough and shocking! Such a thing never happened Lina: Probably they will block more websites, once in
before. And somehow it sets people free. Now they a while they will shut down mobile communication …
show how they feel. Many of them are going out on I don’t know what is going to happen next.
the streets – people can’t stand the situation any I hope it will remain peaceful and that the violence
more. won’t escalate.
And of course the Internet and all the social media we_magazine:
tools helped a lot. People are now able to see what is What role does Tunisia play in Africa?
really happening in Sidi Bouzid, now they are aware of
the real situation. No filters in-between. Lina: I am not sure how to answer this question.
Until recently we only received the “official version” I would say Tunisia is much more integrated and rela-
of what is going on. Officials were drawing “our” pic- ted to the Middle East than to Africa. We don’t really
ture of Tunisia, everything in their documentaries see- have big relationships with the rest of the continent.
med to be O.K. We are more an Arabic country ...
SLUMCODE –
Empowering Slum
Communities
Early dawn in Huruma, : am. The toots and hoots All this makes me realize how fortunate my team and
of matatus – a Nairobi-wide transport system – are I are that we have managed to do what we do!
gathering those preparing to go to work. Many work
far away in an industrial zone. Few job opportunities, At lunchtime women are busy cooking at the road-
low wages – but only for those who have a national side, preparing food for those who cannot cook at
identity card. Some children lucky enough to have home. Selling food is a pretty good guaranteed
some place to call a “classroom” hurry in the morning source of income – even though prices can be as low
darkness to a neighborhood school. : am: the as Kshs. But food is quite affordable and there is
terrible traffic snarl up along Juja Road builds up – even some variety in the menu.
but the price of a matatu ticket is still low – if you are
lucky, you pay about kshs (roughly US cents). In the evening those who work outside Huruma
As it approaches : am the traffic becomes unbea- don’t head back home directly, Because their houses
rable – and the cheapest tickets now cost the equi- are overcrowded, and very poorly equipped they
valent of a dollar. And if you don’t make it to town on prefer to stay at the local pubs and drink away the
time you risk loosing your job. stress of the day. They stagger home late at night
when their kids are already sleeping.
Back to us who operate in Huruma. : am: A few
“stores” are open. Women are at their shops, young At night Huruma is in full swing. Literally every high
men pull carts to dispose of the waste and garbage rise flat has a bar on the ground floor run by families
collected overnight from the numerous high rise flats. living in the building. Beer is cheap in Kenya since
Garbage and waste disposal, over flowing sewage and Kenya Breweries Limited has licensed it so that people
crowded narrow lanes that scare the hell can sell it very cheap. Alcohol is a huge problem in
out of anyone who ventures down them at night are Huruma. And prostitution is linked in with it. For many
normality here. The market place is awakening: pubs women it’s the only way they have to make some
blare out their music, motor vehicles cruise up and money. The rate of HIV infection in Huruma is stagger-
down the street. Women are already returning to their ing. Poverty and the thread of addiction and prosti-
small grocery stores from “Marikiti” and “Gikomba”, tution are closely interwoven.
the retail markets where they buy vegetables. From
food kiosks to grocery shops, local pubs, and neighbor-
hood clinics to coffin-making carpenters and gene- Security / Crime
ral ironmongers – business grinds on. Groups of
young people linger like every morning in the esta- Insecurity and crime are a constant threat as many
tes looking for something to turn their hand to – of the unemployed young people with nothing to do
they might end up as touts, bartenders, drug peddlers, idle their time away and come out on the prowl at
garbage collectors, tinsmiths or carpenters. Some try night with mobile phone being the most prized catch.
out teaching in local community schools or hone their Even though they’ve grown rarer since the death of
talents as artists. some of the most wanted hardcore gang leaders,
gun totting criminals can still be see roaming every
we_volume_/
Dennis Okoyo – is a
young man who recently
completed secondary
school and joined
SLUMCODE as a Youth
Program Coordinator.
He says:
“Through this organiza-
tion I have realized my
potential to think
critically and manage a
program at a very early
Photo © Slumcode / Dennis Okoyo
night. A government initiative dubbed, “community challenge. It was the kind of experience to write
policing” failed to work in this area after it was infil- home about – and quite a daring one too.
trated by rival gangs which made it an even worse But the worst was yet to come when everything
threat to local residents. turned dark after the fateful announcement of the
But a police post nearby has made all the difference incumbent president’s reelection. All hell broke loose
to Huruma residents and plans to have the area and everything went up in flames. The selfsame
district commissioners establish an office in the area young people I had known for so long turned against
is real good news. Youth organizations have also me just because I came from a different tribe. It be-
become more aware and emphasize being watchful came easier to count the machetes in the hands of
in the neighborhood. We can only expect things to youth than the loaves of bread brought home for fa-
get better. mily breakfast. For three days a dark cloud hung over
our country and lingered on for months and years.
As a leader, I was a key target because I’d campaigned
Volunteer Work for one of the main political parties. One of the most
dreaded vigilante groups in the country which also
Some SLUMCODE volunteers have made their way extorts money from the local households and busi-
to Baraka Primary School a community project nesses threatened to execute me just on hearsay. It
the SLUMCODE Group has supported since . had been reported that I had made certain state-
SLUMCODE has done this by mobilizing local resour- ments about them to the authorities. But that was
ces to purchase desks, pay rent arrears, and buy not true since I had spent my whole day on the
books and meals for the some children who can- streets trying to pacify mobs of rowdy youth hell-
not follow free primary school education due to the bent on mayhem, robbing and burning down the
lack of space and money to buy official expensive houses of any Kenyans perceived to be from another
school uniforms. Here they wear whatever they can tribe. I was very lucky to have escaped but I was
afford and pay whatever they can afford in install- ordered to leave Huruma, a place I had known for
ments. Huruma has only state-run schools which over years. All my programs and organizational
leaves much room for the ever increasing number of activities were focused there, but now the very
self help projects and non formal schools owned by people I had known and worked with through thick
community groups. I was surprised when I asked and thin just ejected me from my home along with
Mrs. Irene Agana the head teacher where the or all the other SLUMCODE members.
more pupils came from who filled the school within
a month of her setting it up. She said their needs are MOVING ON: Two years later we are back and once
diverse and that many of the parents are jobless more serving our community. Many people have
because they lost their temp jobs or small businesses healed and now dread seeing politicians shouting
during and after the wave of post election violence in each other down on national TV. The scars still sit
and can no longer afford to help pay for school deep. The volunteers are back at school teaching
desks and expensive uniforms as well as mandatory kids most of whom are so desperate, they probably
after-school tuition. And so such schools become an haven’t eaten since the night before.
easy option for many who can part with around Dennis is a frustrated SLUMCODE volunteer as he
Kshs a day to keep a child in school. The trend is gro- feels his days are wasted with children who cannot
wing rapidly as more and more parents find this a understand as quickly as he would like, but then again
better option for educating their children. he realizes that if he doesn’t do this job nobody’s
going to do it. So together with Otieno, Eric and Mwai
VOLATILE is the word that springs to mind when he struggles on teaching for another three months.
talking about the post election violence in . Meanwhile I try to get out there and see who can
With my work at SLUMCODE and my personal leader- support them at school by at least providing lunch.
ship qualities, many of my close friends had encourag- Not many friends come to help me but life must go
ed and assured me of their support if I decided to on. I must give them the optimism and hope that all
take part in the national elections. So I took up the will be well in the end.
we_volume_/
Photo © Slumcode / The foetus of twins discovered during a clean up event in Huruma
we_volume_/
Photo © Slumcode / Partiocipants from the Kenya Modeling Fraternity sign abstinence cards at Slumfest IV ..
we_volume_/
Spaces Of Freedom
– Web .
In Morocco
Hisham Almiraat
Blogging, and the Web . more broadly, have op- And the most remarkable thing about it – against all
posed mass and citizen media. It’s bridging the gap odds – was the fact that the Moroccan authorities re-
between the often impersonal, sometimes filtered, acted positively, and rather than shooting the mes-
mainstream media and the colorful diversity of in- senger they took steps to investigate the case. Soon
dividual narratives. By doing so Delacroix’s dream after the offenders were apprehended and concrete
becomes true: he thought the closer we get to indivi- measures were taken to abolish corruption in the po-
duals, the closer we are to the true interpretation of lice. Today, the government is running a website
their lives. The Web . is a patchwork of millions of where citizens can anonymously report cases of cor-
individuals creating a rich, constantly updated multi- ruption and abuse by officials and representatives of
media content. There are million active users on the authority. (See StopCorruption.ma)
Facebook (more than times the Moroccan popula-
tion), million on Twitter, tweeting over tweets These videos started a trend: the technique was imi-
per second, million per day. tated by many others in Morocco and elsewhere. Films
and photographs started to emerge on the web, un-
In Morocco there are half a million active netizens on covering electoral fraud, corrupt regimes, the poor
Facebook and a few hundred on Twitter. There are no infrastructure around the country, the floods in stati-
official figures for blogs but a conservative estimate ons and airports, the impact on the environment of il-
puts the number at around ,. Beyond the num- legal dumping of industrial waste.
bers, however, lies a remarkable cultural and linguistic
diversity that mirrors Moroccan society. Others have found in social networks, like Facebook,
the perfect tool to gather support for their cause or
But what social impact does the Web really have? coordinate their actions on the ground. On September
, a group of young Moroccans, calling themselves
I like to believe that those hundreds of thousands of MALI (Alternative Movement for Individual Liberties)
bloggers, microbloggers and social networkers are decided they were going to eat in public during day-
writing the corpus of Moroccan contemporary history. time in Ramadan — the holy Muslim month, during
By sharing bits of their daily lives and by expressing their which believers are supposed to observe fasting from
opinions freely, people are reclaiming a public sphere dawn until dusk. The action was coordinated almost
that has been restricted and censored for too long. And entirely via the Internet and was meant as a symbolic
by so doing, they are finding ways to change things. action in favor of the amendment of a law that calls
for the punishment by prison or fine of anyone whose
One example: July , . A Moroccan citizen, armed actions are perceived to be disrespectful of Islam. The
with a simple video camera, goes out to shoot a scene protesters were intercepted by the police but they hel-
of daily life near his remote village in the northern part ped open the debate about freedom of conscience in
of the country. In the early morning, he laid quietly on a Muslim society. A subject so far considered taboo.
the roof of an abandoned house, overlooking a cros-
sing where a police roadblock is usually set up. He There’s general skepticism about whether the Web .
made sure no one noticed his presence. Then as soon can actually change public life in a country like
as the first policemen arrived he started to film. On the Morocco. But collective power and collective action
video you can clearly see police officers stopping are taking shape thanks to initiatives on the ground
vehicles and extorting bribes from drivers. A scene of for which the Web is serving as a powerful catalyst.
everyday corruption, unfortunately all too familiar for After decades of marginalization, civil society is stan-
the villagers living nearby. The videos were soon posted ding up. If authorities or governments aren’t transpa-
on YouTube, followed by two others. They went viral rent enough, citizens will potentially step in to unfold
almost instantly, and toured the world, seen by milli- the truth. Today an ordinary citizen knows he or she
ons of Internet users. They were broadcast on news can, with good purpose, change things and start a
channels, and soon became a topic for television de-
bates. They became part in a documentary on online
activism and screened in over countries worldwide.
we_volume_/
The Kingdom of Morocco is a country located in North the outside world. France remains the primary trade
Africa. It has a population of nearly million and an partner of Morocco. France is also the primary creditor
area of , km², divided into regions. Morocco and foreign investor in Morocco. In the Arab world,
is a constitutional monarchy with an elected parliament. Morocco has the second-largest non-oil GDP, behind
A steady growth of .% between - helped Egypt, as of . The major resources of the Moroccan
the Moroccan economy to become much more robust. economy are agriculture, phosphates, and tourism.
The economic system of the country presents several % of its population have access to the internet.
facets. It is characterized by a large opening towards
we_volume_/
tags: Algeria,
Nord-Sud Ventures,
transformation,
NEPAD, reforms
we_volume_/
Stop Terrorism!
Start
Transformation!
Arslan Chikhaoui
we_magazine: we_magazine:
Arslan, what is your company Nord-Sud Ventures doing? Do you consider yourself “away from the system”?
Arslan Chikhaoui (Arslan): The trade name of the Arslan: I am “out of” the system. I will never accept
firm Nord-Sud is directly related to the vertical relation any position as a minister or a politician. What I am
between the North and the South. In , I realized trying to do in Algeria is to participate, to build some-
what this country needed was to be advised – but not thing new, to support the change – but I try to avoid
advised by foreign firms with whom Algeria had spent being a threat to the regime.
millions of dollars. So, I decided to sell my ideas to
both political and economic players in need of coun- Why?
seling. The mission of my office is to provide counse-
ling services in the economic as well as political field. If you are a threat, you will never have the chance to
We provide a wide range of counseling services in the train, to educate the regime in a better understanding
market, strategic studies by country, trade investigati- of what needs to be done in order to achieve prospe-
ons, political marketing, as well as counseling at the rity or a descent life for the majority of the people. To
political and social level. We started our activities at better understand the new dimensions of the market
the local level and then two years ago, we expanded economy.
them internationally.
We mostly focus on the politicians, very often we for-
We created a lobbying center in Algiers with branches get about the administration, we forget all the civil
in London, Paris and Brussels, to give our decision servants who don’t know much about what is going
makers a lobbying instrument in Europe. on abroad and what needs to be done to transform
our country. I see my role right in there! This can only
we_magazine: be done from inside the country, this is not something
You are here as a transformation thinker, Arslan. Do you you can achieve with anti regime blogs or any other
think you are really supporting transformation in Algeria? type of activism from the outside.
Transformation towards what? Are you working for the
“public good” in this way, helping people to achieve a better And me, being a member of the World Economic
life or are you one of these people who simply benefit from Forum (WEF)…
the situation and the regime. Which is of course absolutely
legal and there is nothing to be said against it. we_magazine:
… WEF – another of the elite clubs where a lot of “deals”
Arslan: A good question. And many people ask this. are made … not always really good for mankind. Sorry for
I have a philosophy – and I hope you can “get it” while this, but I don’t trust them very much!
we are going through this interview.
I’ve had a choice between two options. The first op- Arslan: Yes, we can argue about this as well. But it
tion was to stay abroad and live an easy life. I've stu- gives me a trump card to play within my own country.
died in the US, but I decided to come back. If I would It demonstrates some kind of reputation to our lea-
have stayed, I might have thought about ways to in- ders in Algeria. And this is why they are listening … If
fluence my country from the outside and drive change you don’t have this, you will be completely out of the
from there. But I think this is impossible. You can't in- scene.
fluence anything from the outside, you are comple-
tely disconnected from reality. So this is my way of acting.
And I try and I do my best to be as honest to both
The “real” thing is to be in the country, to be connec- sides as possible.
ted to reality, but – even when you are connected to It is some kind of balancing act.
realty – to be away from the system ...
we_volume_/
we_magazine: we_magazine:
So let’s stop this discussion here and start talking about your Would you say that Algeria has started a real transformation
country. What is the role of Algeria within Africa? process or is it just a declaration of well meaning intentions?
Arslan: Algeria is starting to come back. years ago Arslan: What I can say is that we have freedom of
Algeria was in “brackets”, it was put on hold. It wasn't speech. We have more than private media compa-
involved in any projects in Africa. But now it is moving. nies …
we_magazine: we_magazine:
Who is creating wealth in Algeria? Is there anything like Do you think a strict distinction between politics and the
a private sector? private sector is needed to transform the country?
Arslan: Do you think it is the private sector which Arslan: I think Algeria should definitely become more
creates wealth in Algeria? No! It is still the centralized open – in various ways … Today they don’t put you in
government. And this will remain so for a while – jail when you insult the President. But this doesn’t
Algeria is just starting to move … mean anything! We need free trade and more open-
ness. WE, the people need hope!
The government is still playing a game here. But even
the “western” countries are playing a game here. They
actually very much like the situation we have in
Algeria. They don’t want every Algerian to be able to
leave the country whenever he/she wants to … To be
very honest.
we_volume_/
we_volume_/
Algeria, a gateway between Africa and Europe, has employment high, particularly among Algeria’s youth.
been battered by violence over the past half-century. Endemic government corruption and poor standards
More than a million Algerians were killed in the fight in public services are also chronic sources of popular
for independence from France in , and the coun- dissatisfaction.
try has recently emerged from a brutal internal conflict Algeria’s TV and radio stations are state-controlled,
that followed scrapped elections in which was but there is a lively private press which often criticises
won by an Islamist party. The election was annulled, the authorities. There is no direct censorship, but laws
heralding a bloody civil war in which more than set out prison terms and fines for insulting or defaming
, people were slaughtered. Although political the president, MPs, judges and the army.
violence in Algeria has declined since then, the coun- There were . million internet users by September
try has been shaken by a campaign of bombings car- (InternetWorldStats). Most surfers rely on dial-up
ried out by a group calling itself Al-Qaeda in the Land connections and cybercafes. No widespread filtering
of Islamic Maghreb (AQLIM). is reported, but the blocking of a political website in
After years of political upheaval and violence, Algeria’s January was said to be the first known instance
economy has been given a lift by frequent oil and gas of online censorship.
finds. However, poverty remains widespread and un-
we_volume_/
Photo © iHub
Kenya Matters
Raised in Kenya and Sudan, Erik Hersman is a tech- ... was a co-founder of Tripod.com, a web hosting en-
nologist and blogger who lives in Nairobi, Kenya. He terprise, and later founder of Geekcorps. He cur-
is co-founder of Ushahidi, a free and open source rently serves as a fellow at the Berkman Center for
platform for crowdsourcing information and visua- Internet and Society. His work at the Berkman
lizing data. He is the founder of AfriGadget, a multi- Center has included research into global media
author site that showcases stories of African invent- attention, and the co-founding of Global Voices On-
ions and ingenuity, and an African technology blog- line in collaboration with Rebecca MacKinnon. For
ger at WhiteAfrican.com. His current project is the some years he was also a contributing writer for
iHub, Nairobi’s Innovation Hub for the technology Worldchanging.com, where he served as president of
community, bringing together entrepreneurs, hack- the board of directors. In January 2007, he joined the
ers, designers and the investment community. inaugural Wikimedia Foundation Advisory Board.
Eric is a Senior TED Fellow, a PopTech Fellow He is a graduate of Williams College, spent a year
and speaker. You can find him on Twitter at in Accra, Ghana on a Fulbright scholarship, and
@WhiteAfrican currently resides in Lanesborough, Massachusetts
with his wife Rachel Barenblat.
we_volume_/
Ulrike Reinhard
Photo © iHub
we_volume_/
we_magazine: I’ve spent most of the past two days at the iHub,
Tell us a little bit about the history of the iHub part of the vast (non-profit) corporate empire that is
and about your role in it. Ushahidi. I’m lucky enough to have known three of
Ushahidi’s founders from before their launch of their
Erik Hersman: You can look back about years ago crowdsourcing platform, and my friends invited me to
to see a post on my blog about the idea of tech hubs join their board of directors. Wednesday afternoon
needed in the major tech cities across Africa. This was a board meeting, and members flew in from three
was an idea that germinated at Barcamp Nairobi continents to review a chaotic, crazy and incredibly
when I was chatting with one of the other productive year. A team at the Fletcher School used
organizers for that event. There was obviously a void Ushahidi to coordinate information and relief efforts
in the community for a place to meet, exchange in the wake of the Haitian earthquakes. A team of blog-
ideas, and serve as a central nexus point for industry, gers and activists in Russia used Ushahidi to provide
devs, investors and others to meet. aid to people affected by Russia’s forest fires, an effort
that was so popular, it briefly broke our system. Usha-
we_magazine: hidi launched Crowdmap.com, a platform that makes it
What is the secret of its success? possible for anyone to start a crowdmapping project
with no more than a few mouseclicks, and everyone
Erik: Well, it’s still a little early in the game to know, from individuals to the BBC tried it out.
but it’s largely due to the community being in charge There’s lots for a board member to understand about
of making a lot of the decisions, therefore having a real Ushahidi – three core products, developers around the
ownership role in the space. They have done every- world, a web of partnerships and collaborations. One
thing from design the layout to setup meetings to run part of the mix I’ve never entirely understood is the
the network and servers. My role, and that of Jessica iHub, which serves as the team’s Nairobi offices, but is
and Tosh as well, is to provide a basic structure from lots more than that.
which the community has to build something. The space is located on the top floor of a five story buil-
ding on Ngong Road, one of the major arteries of the
city. Across the street from a well-known supermarket,
it’s easy to get to via cab or matatu, the minivans that
carry the majority of the city’s passengers. The space is
open, high-ceilinged, and surrounded by windows.
There’s a coffee bar in one corner, staffed by Pete,
Nairobi’s barrista champion. Above Pete’s shop is a
we_volume_/
Disciplines
we_volume_/
we_volume_/
we_volume_/
A Techie In Love
With The Arts
we_magazine: we_magazine:
Jepchumba, who are you? Why is art so important for African
What are you doing? What is your passion? communities? What kind of impact has an art community
like the African DIgital Art Network on society?
Jepchumba: My name is Jepchumba and I am an
African digital artist and digital enthusiast from Kenya.
I am also the founder of African Digital Art Network. I Jepchumba: Art has the ability to transcend barriers.
have a masters degree in Digital Media, and I enjoy It is a powerful tool for communication. There are
studying how technology affects art and culture in many untold stories in Africa and art has the ability to
Africa. give African communities a way to express and share
In many ways I consider myself a mad scientist. I love their stories and experiences. Art, especially digital
experimenting with motion, sound and various digital art, is also a form of ingenuity that often fosters in-
effects and techniques. The reason why I am so pass- novation. Through creative exercise new solutions are
ionate about digital media is mainly due to the fact brought to light which often help empower indivi-
that I have an entire laboratory at my fingertips. In duals to improve their communities. In terms of de-
many ways I am a techie with the heart of an artist. velopment art can be a powerful weapon to motivate,
inspire and direct individuals towards change.
we_magazine:
You are founder of Africandigitalart.com. What is it all we_magazine:
about? What are the goals ? Why “only” digital art? What makes art good art?
Jepchumba: African Digital Art is an online collective, Jepchumba: This is a difficult question to answer. Art
a creative space, where digital artists, enthusiasts and is truly subjective. However I find that the art that I
professionals can seek inspiration, showcase their ar- consider “good” is the one that resonates with the
tistry and connect with emerging artists. audience.
For the past two years the African Digital Art Network One of the things that I have found as an African digi-
has presented unparalleled ideas, individualistic works tal artist, is that there is an expectation of what is
and insightful designer solutions by the African crea- considered to be African art or “good” African art. We
tive community. It has become a platform for innova- are still very limited in our scope of understanding
tion and inspiration with a sophisticated blend of fresh what African art actually is. Unfortunately the majo-
talent and successful designers and artists. rity of the world considers African art as mainly tradi-
The focus on digital is quite unique and important to tional masks, sculptures and paintings. Capturing
us. We are not exclusive to digital art expressions but Africa’s visual identity is simply beyond our grasp. It is
we are mainly interested in how artists use technology a kaleidoscope – open to multiple interpretations and
as a medium for their work. We believe that African understandings. We can however engage the creative
digital art has a way of “Pushing Digital Boundaries” community to take part in a collective form of pro-
by enabling artist and creative professionals to come duction. It clearly will help to shape our understan-
up with innovative solutions for their everyday lives. ding of what it means to be African. The forms of
The African Digital Art Network is dedicated to foste- expression that break the stereotypes are the ones I
ring the growing technology-driven creative commu- find most enjoyable.
nity that still remains in its infancy in Africa.
we_magazine:
What kind of role does art play in the African school / educa-
tion system? Are there any special art schools?
many artists. There are just not enough art programs we_magazine:
in Africa. Many professional artists have received their Digital art in Africa is a fairly new concept, isn’t it?
education abroad and many struggle to find a sustain-
able income in Africa, where art is not as valued. At Jepchumba: Yes indeed, it is fairly new. Before African
the end of the day it all comes down to sustainability. Digital Art Network was created most people would
The art industry in Africa is mainly geared towards fo- have never put the words “Africa” “Digital” and “Art”
reign consumption. Art is mass produced for tourism together. The majority of the world does not see
and is undervalued within local communities. Africa from a digital perspective, they still see Africa as
Thanks to the recent World Cup in South Africa, the a place somehow stuck in the past. However as recent
creative economy throughout Africa has been flouris- developments in mobile technology in Africa show,
hing. More and more creative projects and professi- we are great early adopters. Africa is experiencing the
ons are available to African artists. As the demand for same influx of technology as the rest of the world, we
more African inspired work continues I hope to see are on Facebook, on Twitter, we text each other and
the education system, especially the higher education we share our experiences over the Internet.
system, respond to the need for trained and skilled de- As more artists are exposed to digital technology they
sign professionals. are also exposed to new tools that they can utilize for
their work. Digital art expressions are growing rapidly
we_volume_/
throughout countries such as Egypt, Nigeria, Kenya, I created the African Digital Art Network as a platform
and South Africa. Young people who have grown up in to foster and encourage new forms of creativity. We
this new connected society are experimenting with recently re-launched the social networking compo-
motion, video and sound. nent of African Digital Art, The District. The District is
We still have a long way to go, the statistics show that a new platform we designed to get artists together
Africa is underrepresented in terms of access to ICT’s and connect them with each other. On The District,
but we do have an influx of mobile technology that African creatives can network, share their work and
has inspired us to come up with new design solutions resources. They have the ability to collaborate, learn
forour everyday experiences. new skills and also promote their portfolio all within
this space online.
we_magazine:
Art has always something to do with creativity. What does we_magazine:
creativity mean for you and how can you nurture other You write on your website that you are dreaming digital ...
peoples creativity? what do you mean?
Jepchumba: Creativity is linked with innovation and Jepchumba: That is right, I often say I dream “digital”
it gives us a way of growing and inventing; experi- because I find the digital format the easiest way to
menting, taking risks and breaking rules. Creativity for express my own creativity. Digital technology has
me is the ability to generate new ideas or possibilities given me the ability to bring to life what is in my ima-
that may be useful in solving problems, communica- gination. It has given me the ability to think of new
ting with others and expressing and engaging myself possibilities and realities and offered me a unique way
with others. to imagine and shape the future.
we_volume_/
we_volume_/
we_volume_/
tags: genocide,
Burundi, Rwanda,
UN Radio
we_volume_/
Radio As A Force
For Peace
Jocelyne Sambira
In 1998, at the height of the civil war in Burundi, one of the rebel groups
operating in the suburbs overlooking the capital, Bujumbura, had just issued
threats to the local population. The rumor was that the rebel group was
going to behead 100 people in the area suspected of being government infor-
mants. The locals did not take the threat lightly. There had been several
isolated cases where the heads of people were left on small pathways to discou-
rage the locals from talking to the government army. A group of men and
women took their courage in both hands and went to one of the independent
radios with this story. The station manager called the head of the rebel move-
ment and recorded a live interview with him. The rebel chief was livid. He
rigorous-ly denied any plot to murder people. This report was broadcast
throughout the week. That night and the rest of the week, the residents of
that area slept soundly. In fact, the beheading stopped completely.
That alone says more than a thousand words.
we_volume_/
What the ordinary citizen in Burundi had come to un- People in Burundi came to trust independent radio
derstand was that information is power. In a country as a source of information but also as a vehicle to
where people at the grassroots had little or no power broadcast sensitive information. It took time to gain
of decision, their voice carried far through radio. In one that trust. In the beginning people were afraid of tal-
radio broadcast, million people could be reached, the king into the microphone. There was such an atmo-
estimated population of the country at the time. sphere of fear and profound mistrust, people ran away
In many countries ravaged by war and violent conflict, whenever they saw a journalist. It was after covering
radio is sometimes the only way of getting informa- several stories about the war, the massacres, and
tion. In most of these regions, there is little or no infra- other tragic events during that time that people began
structure and when people are on the run, it is some- to open up.
times the only link to the world they have left behind. When I went out into the field and said my name,
Repressive governments, the masterminds of the geno- people’s faces would break into a smile and I would
cide, and other war criminals in the past have under- always hear a word of encouragement. At the radio,
stood the power of radio. They use it as a tool to control we always worked as a team, regardless of our ethni-
and influence the masses, sometimes even as a wea- city, and worked hard with the fact-checking and dou-
pon of mass murder as in Rwanda. In the lead up to the ble checking our sources to report without any bias.
genocide in Rwanda, there were very divisive and po- We always made sure to go in mixed teams: both Hutu
larizing messages broadcast by the former “hate and Tutsi ethnic groups represented. It was a little
radio”, Radio Milles Collines. During the genocide it scary at times because when you went into an area
egged on its supporters, encouraging them to kill the where people were hostile towards your ethnic group,
people from the minority, the “Tutsis’ who they labe- you had to rely totally on your colleague who was of
led as cockroaches and assailants. It fuelled a lot of the the other ethnic group to keep you safe. That forged
ethnic tensions and violence, pitting one ethnic group a strong bond amongst us. Furthermore, you had to
against another. Three of the station managers were sometimes face the hostility of listeners who did not
tried and convicted with genocide, incitement to ge- like the fact that we were denouncing sometimes vio-
nocide, and crimes against humanity at the Interna- lent acts committed by people of our own ethnic
tional Tribunal for Rwanda in Arusha. group. It was not rare to be singled out in public or
Burundi has the same ethnic makeup as Rwanda, and called “traitor” by extremist groups or individuals.
almost the same ethnic issues, which is why “hate The government too was keeping tabs on us. I was
messages” were also insidiously creeping up in the filing stories on the war for Associated Press in addi-
local media. tion to my work at the radio. I often got “reprimanded”
I had just graduated from the University of Burundi or “warned” on the phone by army officials for stories
and the country was at war. It was a particularly trau- I wrote about the fighting. I was even threatened once
matic time for me. I had survived the genocide in with incarceration if I did not divulge my sources. I was
Rwanda after fleeing to a displaced persons camp gu- called into the Justice Minister’s Office for an AP story
arded by the Rwandan Patriotic Front, RPF. I was happy where I quoted one spokesman for a rebel group. The
to be alive but I was also struggling with the trauma fighting had intensified and was now taking place not
of what I had been through as well as grief over the far from the capital. The government had warned the
number of loved ones lost. I walked away from that local stations about broadcasting interviews with the
tragedy feeling that I needed to do something with rebels using the argument that the country was at war
my life, to fight for peace so that genocide would and that it was a national security issue. As journalists,
never ever happen again in our region. So it was with our position was that the same rebels were in secret
that mindset that I applied for a job with Studio talks with government, so we had an obligation to our
Ijambo, an innovative media project that was using listeners to get both views.
radio to promote peace and reconcile the two warring When I arrived at the Minister’s office, I was asked to
ethnic groups in Burundi. Together with a team of hand over the rebel chief’s cell phone number or go to
talented local journalists, we strove to uphold the jail. I chose to go to jail. Luckily for me, it was just a bluff.
highest professional standards of journalism in a very The Minister already had the number, but he wanted to
difficult moment of our history. intimidate me and maybe discourage me from any furt-
we_volume_/
her reporting. It did not stop me, but made me even Another way our radio project tried to break stereo-
more determined to do my job. I can state for a fact that types and discuss sensitive issues like ethnicity, was
non-stop coverage by Burundi journalists during the through drama. We produced a series called, “Our
civil and peace process kept the warring parties ac- neighbors, ourselves” and were able to use it as a plat-
countable and forced them to work towards peace. form to debate social issues. Things that people were
Radio in Burundi became the fourth estate. It kept the afraid to say on air, they could act out in a sketch. It
government in check and demanded accountability also allowed people to debate the issues freely since
from the local authorities. Throughout the war, radio they were discussing “fictional” characters and situa-
covered both the Hutu and Tutsi camps and kept the tions. The series was broadcast for years with huge
local populations abreast of events. Radio gave the success throughout the country.
people a platform for discussion. It often played media- When I moved to work with a UN humanitarian news
tor by organizing debates between both rival ethnic agency, IRIN, I produced another soap opera or radio
groups. Radio became the voice of the voiceless. It drama series with a group of Burundian refugees living
taught people tolerance and acceptance. By covering in the camps in Tanzania. This radio soap opera written
atrocities committed by both sides, it forced people for and enacted by Burundian refugees demonstrated
to accept and acknowledge the truth. It also gave an once again the power of radio. The project began in
unbiased account of Burundi’s recent history. May covering various aspects of refugee life, the
Radio prevented massacres and killings of innocent peace process and the return home. The Burundi refu-
civilians where it could by airing the information be- gee camps in Tanzania had existed for over thirty years.
forehand, discouraging the armed groups from carry- During that period, the previous regimes did every-
ing out their deadly plans. It helped curb violence thing they could to suppress all means of communi-
between different ethnic groups by trying to get ba- cation. Very little mention was made of the ,
lanced reports on events, giving a voice to the victims people living in camps, and when mentioned it was
and confronting the authorities and rebel groups to usually to portray them as enemies of the state, mur-
explain their actions. The politicians and armed derers and assassins. This radio soap opera gave a voice
groups could no longer pit people against one another to the Burundi refugee as well as a say on what was
by using propaganda and disinformation. The people happening in the country. For the first time, their voices
were able to judge for themselves because they were were heard across the border. And we were sending
informed. Ignorance and lack of balanced and true in- news reports about the camps and the repatriation
formation has been the root of all evil in Burundi. process that was ongoing.
Muzzling the press, harassing and arbitrarily arresting People in Burundi were curious and interested in this
journalists caused such uproar that the authorities cross-border information exchange. We were able to
had to bow down to public pressure. put a human face to the “Burundian refugee on the
One time, the government had closed down one of other side of the border”. People back home realized
the popular private radio stations because it had been that they shared the same everyday issues and aspira-
critical towards the President. People came from tions with the refugees. Many were even surprised to
every-where and demonstrated in front of the radio hear that refugees still speak the same language and
station. When the police dispersed them, they went were still attached to their country. Once the dialogue
to one of the President’s houses that was under con- opened up, people were able to set aside their diffe-
struction, and staged a sit-in. They threatened to bring rences and agree on certain issues. By experience, my
the house down, if the radio did not go back on air. A team and I knew that violence erupts out of fear, and
few hours later, the President lifted the ban on the you can only fear the unknown. By getting the two po-
radio station. That was a sign from the people to the pulations better acquainted, the project helped defuse
government that they would never again accept being past tensions. The return from exile was no longer
silenced. viewed as a threat for either population – and that is
The current UN envoy in Burundi, Charles Petrie, re- something only initiatives dealing with the grassroots
cently said in an interview that “credit needs to be given can achieve.
to the [Burundi] press” in defusing the tensions and I had the chance to experience the magic of radio
lifting the taboos in society. once again, while training Sudanese journalists at the
we_volume_/
UN Radio in Juba, South Sudan. Sudan was very diffe- showed up, I was always on the scene like the bird.
rent from Burundi in the sense that most of the local But I learned to deal with difficult and dangerous
journalists had already picked sides. It is very hard to people, like the soldier, and I also learned when to
find objectivity or people who want to be “neutral”. push and when to tread carefully when I was collec-
Sudan had many issues ranging from racial, to reli- ting information. Over time, I also developed a keen
gious and linguistic divisions. People clearly felt that sense of danger, but I learned the hard way. I remem-
they were fundamentally different and belonged to ber going out to report on a newly built camp for
two different worlds. The North of Sudan is mainly people displaced by the fighting in Burundi. On our
Arab and Muslim while the South is mainly Christian way, we saw people moving fast in the opposite
and Black. When I arrived, the language people used direction. We kept driving and got caught in the cross-
in private when talking about their fellow countrymen fire between rebels and the army. Luckily we managed
from the North or South left me in no doubt. The radio to get out safely but I always remembered from then
station also employed former soldiers to work with on to be more aware of my surroundings and look out
them. So the challenges were: how do you make jour- for possible signs.
nalists out of former combatants? How do you bring I also gained a profound passion for justice and the
people who are still politically active and under their truth. I come from a very troubled and conflict prone
political party or tribal/social/religious influence to region in Africa where information gives a person
think objectively? How do you build peace in a war great power. It can either get you killed or save your
situation? life. Those who are privy to certain types of informa-
Another daunting task was to build a solid and united tion wield it like a weapon against the weak. This
team of journalists – making the radio one. We had two secretive culture has been the reason behind our
newsrooms: one in Khartoum, the capital of North blood-filled past.
Sudan, and one in Juba, the capital of South Sudan. It I understood, when covering the war and then the
often felt like we are two separate radios without a peace process, that sharing such crucial information
common vision or goal. There was a lot of rivalry – helped the ordinary citizens make their own individual
which in normal circumstances would be healthy com- choices based on evidence and not hearsay. It also
petition – that weakened the radio. I felt that if we acted as a deterrent for people who in the past used
could bring the two newsrooms to work together, and false pretexts to push people to violence. Radio is a
build trust, it could be a test case for the rest of the very powerful tool for African citizens who want to
country. Gradually, through pep talks, a lot of on the build strong, democratic societies.
job training focusing on ethical reporting – looking at New York is just another leg of my journey. If I am here
the issues and not the actors – the quality of the work today, it is because of the power radio has had in my
improved. And as the reporting improved, the two life. And I am not alone. There are many more people
teams slowly began to appreciate each other profes- like myself whose lives have been transformed positi-
sionally and started treating each other as equals. vely. To support and strengthen radio is to support
I saw these journalists gradually change and rise people whose voices are being silenced by repressive
above the conflict and strive to be professional, non governments and bring them a step closer to achie-
partisan and independent journalists driven by their ving peace in our lifetime.
passion to obtain the truth. I left before I could see
the two newsrooms merge, listening to the radio, you
would not guess that the teams were operating from
two separate regions.
I learned a lot as a journalist working in Burundi du-
ring the war and in post conflict countries like Sudan.
I learned to be accurate and remain objective and
impartial in my reports. I sometimes made people
unhappy with my dogged pursuit of the truth. One
soldier in Burundi had even cruelly dubbed me the
“crow” because he said everywhere a dead body
we_volume_/
Photo © notphilatall
we_volume_/
You Beg,
Borrow, Steal ;-)
You Do Almost
Anything To
Get Funding.
Interview with Wanuri Kahiu
Wanuri Kahiu, a young Kenyan filmmaker, was introduced to me by Mark Kaigwa, also author in
this issue of we_magazine. Contact, first chat and the interview itself happened within one hour – thanks
to real time communication on the Web. Before we start with the interview here is a short introduction
to cinema in Africa.
African filmmakers often have difficulty accessing African audiences. The commercial cinemas in Africa
often have to book blindly and show primarily Hollywood or Bollywood films. However, there are still
limited venues where African audiences have access to African films, e.g. at the Panafrican film festival in
Ouagadougou, Burkina Faso. Most African filmmakers still rely heavily on European institutions for
financing and producing their films. A commercially viable video production has been set up in Nigeria,
colloquially known as Nollywood. When you look deeper into it, you can clearly see that many young
African film makers follow a mission: They focus on social and political themes rather than any commer-
cial interests, and they try to give an exploration of the conflicts between the traditional past and modern
times. Their role is often compared to traditional Griots. Like them their task is to express and reflect
communal experiences.
we_volume_/
we_magazine: we_magazine:
What made you a filmmaker Wanuri? Not the worst place to do this ...
Wanuri: I’m a firm believer that there will always be a Wanuri: It is the best place to be for filmmaking. LA
role for storytellers in Africa. I think I’m just a modern- was a very interesting experience for me. I don’t think
day storyteller and I use the tools that are available to that I’ve met one single “real” person in all the years
my generation. I do remember when I realized wit- I spent in LA. Everybody was playing a role: trying to
hout a shadow of a doubt that’s it what I wanted to be an actor or trying to be a singer or cab driver try-
do. I was years old. Before that I didn’t even know ing to be in drama. There was nobody just being who
that people produce TV shows or make film. they are.
we_magazine: we_magazine:
So how come? How would you describe the film industry in Africa?
Wanuri: I used to watch a lot of TV. I was a bookworm Wanuri: The film industry in Africa is twofold. Many
and a telly addict. When I walked for the first time into people probably know about Nollywood, Lagos,
a production studio and saw what they were doing, I Nigeria, because it is so prolific. But that’s only the
was like: “That’s exactly what I want to do in my life.” one type of film-making we have. And then there’s the
Do you know what I mean? African cinematography tradition that has been there
for a long time. We all know names like Ousmane
we_magazine: Sembene and Oumarou Ganda – the great godfathers
Yes! Where was it? In Nairobi or … of African cinema. They saw filmmaking as an impor-
tant political tool for rectifying the erroneous image
Wanuri: Yes, it was in Nairobi. A friend of my mother of Africans put forward by Western filmmakers and for
was trying to start a TV station. By then we were still reclaiming the image of Africa for Africans.
under the dictatorship of Moi, so he never knew ex- I would like to think myself as the latter. I would like to
actly if he would be able to get the right documents, think myself as a filmmaker that produces for theatri-
you know? cal release as well. Right now it is very exciting because
a lot of attention is turning back to the African conti-
we_magazine: nent. Africa is becoming sexy again with the World
Yes. Cup and everything. That’s great.
we_magazine:
What is your favourite movie?
we_magazine:
“In the Mood for Love”. Good. Good to hear.
we_magazine:
Wanuri, anything you would like to add at the end?
Anything missing what you would like to say?
we_magazine:
Why is this?
we_magazine:
That’s sad.
we_magazine:
Wanuri, thank you very much!! It was a great pleasure!
Photo © Frerieke
tags: mobile,
revolution,
change,
health care,
infrastructure
we_volume_/
Change Has A
Name: Mobile
Steve Song
Photo © kool_skatkat
we_volume_/
First, mobile networks and related services are grow- ally the development of telecommunication infra-
ing at an unprecedented rate. Measures of network structure across countries in Africa looks very similar.
size must be continually revised, as the landscape of
mobile access can change significantly over a few Most African countries have struggled with market li-
months. beralisation, with the separation of government in-
vestment in formerly incumbent telecommunication
Second, the medium itself is evolving. Not so long ago, operators, and with the kind of tacit influence if not
we considered mobile phones were just that, phones outright corruption that such a lucrative market in-
for voice conversations. Now more and more mobile spires. Yet, the closer we look, the more it is evident
phones are also generic Internet access devices, which that there are no simple formulas for stimulating
opens up a whole new world of access through the growth and competition, that each country has uni-
same network. que challenges and opportunities.
The third challenge to understanding mobile networks Let’s take a look at Kenya and South Africa as exam-
in Africa is obtaining relevant usage data. Network ples. On the surface the telecommunications sector of
operators regard detailed information on network these two countries have much in common.
usage and growth as confidential business informa-
tion that might give their competitors an advantage. • Both have an independent communications
Most of the available information is therefore the pro- regulator whose job is to ensure healthy growth
duct of third-party research. Unfortunately, the appe- of the telecommunications market. In both
tite of funders to support publicly-accessible, broad- countries, these regulators have adopted pro-open
based empirical research appears to be modest at best. access regulation for licensing telecommunication
As a result, comprehensive information on communi- companies. This policy approach aims to separate
cation patterns and affordability of access is not widely infrastructure from services with the intention
available and we are left to intuit the gaps in our of stimulating independent competition for the
understanding. provision of infrastructure as well as for the
services that run on that infrastructure. Thus,
So what do we know about the impact of mobiles in the company that brings copper wire or wireless
Africa? Perhaps the most significant indicator of the connectivity to your home need not be the same
impact and importance of communication networks company that sells voice, Internet or other services
is their very pervasiveness in such a short space of through those connections.
time. • Both Kenya and South Africa are recent benefi-
ciaries of new undersea fibre-optic cables which
High level macro economic studies by Leonard provide orders of magnitude for greater Internet
Waverman of the London Business School and others and voice capacity. Both countries are actively posi-
have made credible claims that the spread of mobile tioning themselves as regional hubs for that
infrastructure has had a direct positive impact on GDP. access.
At the micro level, many anthropological studies have • Kenya and South Africa have a former monopoly
profiled the use and impact of mobile phones on fixed-line incumbent telecommunications service
specific communities. Between these macro and micro provider in which their respective governments
levels, however, much is still guessed at. retain a substantial investment. Furthermore,
the largest mobile operator in these countries,
There is a seductive tendency when talking about the Safaricom in Kenya and Vodacom in South Africa
continent of Africa to refer to it as a single country. have Vodafone UK as their most significant
The mind boggles at the thought of characterising shareholder. Both countries currently have four
different states and economies and we tend to seek mobile operators.
out broad brush strokes to help cope with the dazzling • Kenya and South Africa have roughly % Internet
complexity of the continent. This is true as much in penetration.
the telecoms sector as anywhere else. And superfici-
we_volume_/
• Finally, both Kenya and South Africa have mobile degree anywhere else on the continent. South Africa
enabled money transfer and payment services. in particular has not seen a tremendous uptake of
Notably, the biggest mobile money success story mPesa since its launch. The factors underpinning this
in Africa, Safaricom’s mPesa service, was recently are complex and worth exploring further.
launched in South Africa.
More significant than any of the above points, howe-
Given this list, the development of telecommunica- ver, is the arrival of Bharti-Airtel in Kenya through its
tions infrastructure in Kenya and South Africa appears acquisition of Zain networks in Africa. Zain Kenya is
very similar. On a closer look, however, we find that the second largest mobile operator in Kenya. Indian-
the differences significantly outweigh these similari- owned Bharti-Airtel comes from a more aggressive,
ties. competitive telecommunications environment in India
and has brought operational and pricing models that
Kenyans spend a much larger percentage of their have sent shockwaves through the Kenyan mobile
disposable income on mobile services than do South market. In August , Bharti-Airtel (Zain) dropped
Africans. Ground-breaking work by ResearchICTAfrica mobile prices by over %. Safaricom held out for a
(http://www.researchictafrica.net), has shown that, couple of weeks but eventually dropped their prices
within the bottom % of earners in Kenya, people to match. Overnight Kenya became one of the most
spend an incredible .% of their disposable income competitive telecommunications markets on the con-
on mobile services. In South Africa, within the same tinent.
demographic, that figure is .%. This difference can
be attributed in large part to a higher average income Prior to buying Zain, Bharti-Airtel had been in negotia-
in South Africa but there are other factors at play as tion with MTN to buy their networks in Africa. MTN is
well. South Africa’s second largest mobile operator. It is
interesting to speculate whether, had Bharti-Airtel
South Africa has a much larger fixed-line infrastruc- bought MTN instead of Zain, South Africa might be
ture than Kenya, with % of urban areas having fixed- the most competitive telecommunications market in
line services in SA versus a little over % in Kenya. Africa.
This means that urban users in South Africa may rely
more on fixed-line for some services such as Internet Regardless, there is now a massive difference in tele-
or some voice services whereas in Kenya far fewer communications costs between Kenya and South
people have that choice. Africa. Looking at Safaricom and Vodacom, two com-
panies with the same parent in Vodafone UK, voice
While both countries have four national mobile opera- calls are times more expensive in South Africa than
tors, Kenya is dominated by Safaricom whose market in Kenya. Individual SMSes are three times more
share is over %. This is perhaps the most interest- expensive. For bulk purchases, SMS costs are up to
ing difference between South Africa and Kenya. With times more expensive. For data services, out-of-
that kind of market dominance, Safaricom has been package data rates have the same kind of distortion.
in a position to dictate its terms to the market. One Mobile data costs are three times more expensive in
would imagine that this would lead to a less competi- South Africa. More than anything else, these figures
tive environment than in South Africa where the suggest that the South African mobile market is rela-
market is somewhat more balanced. However, in the tively stagnant and uncompetitive.
last two years, Kenya has seen more price competition
than South Africa, Moreover, Kenya has managed to Interestingly, this situation contrasts dramatically with
maintain interconnection charges between telephone the Internet service provision market in South Africa
networks that are half those in South Africa. which has seen increased competition and drops in
price for pure Internet services of up to % in the last
One might also argue that Safaricom’s massive size months. Internet Services Providers (ISPs) have had
enabled the huge success of mPesa in Kenya, a success healthy competition for many years but until recently
which curiously has not been replicated to the same have been hamstrung by having all international
we_volume_/
access throttled by Telkom South Africa, thanks to tion is the cost of access and enabling real competi-
their control of the SAT undersea cable. It took about tion is the key to driving prices down.
a year after the arrival of the Seacom cable in June
for prices to move but has seen an avalan- Unfortunately enabling competition in the telecom-
che of change with ADSL Internet costs dropping as munications marketplace is not as straightforward as
much as %. Kenya is experiencing similar price simply allowing new competitors into the market, alt-
drops in the ISP market although there is much more hough that is obviously a factor. The key to participa-
demand for mobile Internet in Kenya due to the lower tion in the market is access to wireless spectrum. The
density of fixed-line infrastructure. rising price of copper as a commodity makes it in-
creasingly impractical as a last mile solution. Its in-
We can also see significant differences in the mobile crease in value also makes it more appealing as a
Internet market. Facebook, arguably the fastest grow- target for theft. The only practical option for service
ing Internet-based service in Africa, is an increasingly delivery is wireless. However, one cannot use just any
good proxy for measuring mobile Internet use on the wireless spectrum. Mobile phones are designed to
continent. Facebook is the top mobile Internet desti- work within specific wireless spectrum bands thus re-
nation in both Kenya and South Africa. And while gulators are constrained to assign specific ranges of
there are many more Facebook users in South Africa, spectrum for mobile use.
nearly . million in South Africa as compared to
about a million in Kenya, there is a different growth The result is that most of the spectrum allocated for
pattern across the two. Facebook use in Kenya has mobile use has already been assigned to existing
grown % in the last six months compared to % in mobile operators. This “administrative scarcity” of
South Africa. spectrum is something that urgently needs to be
addressed by regulators. More spectrum needs to be
Similarly, we can see mobile ad growth in Kenya ex- made available whether through the licensing of new
ploding at % in the last year versus % in South spectrum bands, sharing of existing bands, or increa-
Africa. And while mobile Internet use in general is sed use of unlicensed spectrum like WiFi.
growing in both countries, we see % growth in
Opera browser statistics in Kenya versus % in Enabling more competition through increased access
South Africa. However, as with all statistics, this evi- to wireless spectrum is an opportunity that could help
dence needs to be examined in context. The massive drive down the cost of access on the continent. To
popularity of MxIT as a messaging platform in South date we have seen great increases in efficiency
Africa may partially account for the difference in rate through access to mobile infrastructure in Africa. If we
of Facebook uptake. Also, there is evidence that use can drive down the cost of access to the point where
of the mobile Internet through dedicated “apps” such mobile users don’t need to think about how much
as a mobile Facebook or Gmail app is more popular they are spending at every access, we’ll begin to see
than using the same services through a browser such a wave of innovation in African products and services
as Opera. that will astonish the world.
People
we_volume_/
Photo © Ompeh
we_volume_/
Our Culture –
A Source Of Life
Affirming Joy
Emmanuel Charlse Richardson, , Cape Coast, Ghana
There was a time my mother and father met in life to be a couple and care
for each other. It came to the point where my father and mum gave birth to my
senior siblings.
And it then came about that I was born to the earth of Africa without anything
in my hands but came empty to the world of Africa. I started crawling on the
ground at the age of six months and I started walking at the age of one year.
At the age of five my father started teaching me drumming but different from
traditional drumming. My father was a great musician on the Ghana Cape
Coast then.
When I was nine years of age my dad and my elder brother took me to a group
called the Twerampong Traditional Drumming and Dancing Group at the
Cape Coast Castle. They knew where my source of motivation in life came from.
I never knew I could dance but I always see the music in me as my passion. I
humbly submitted to my leaders in the group and learnt drumming and dancing
very well and everything else they were willing to teach me.
When I was in junior secondary school my dad died and it was like I have lost
all my life. But I never give up on what I do. I continued but stopped my formal
group and became my own master by teaching foreign and local people to earn
some money for a living. In late 2007 when I was in senior high school I got the
opportunity to teach my mates in school for the school’s speech and prize giving
day. After this day, I took those people and I taught them drumming and dancing.
This way I started forming my own group now called UNITYDRUM which was
first known as the Peace Academy Youth Group. My aim was to pass on my
knowledge to others. However, after only four months the group was on the
verge of collapse due to financial problems because we spent too much on drums
and other equipment.
Despite these initial setbacks I still kept the vision alive, continuing to walk on
the path I felt was laid out for me. In August 2008, I met Joy Ayo Tang founder
of the Onevillage Foundation (OVF). She opened up OVF’s doors to UNITY-
DRUM. In 2010 we did a Digital Archive for OVF which uses digital tools to
record the lives of local people. OMPEH was a local fishermen’s group we got
involved in.
Drumming and dancing has always been the soul of Africa. In UNITYDRUM
and OMPEH all our dreams come together: to celebrate our spiritual heritage
and to revisit the past with SANKOFA as our spiritual guide. All this is done in
honor of our land of Africa.
we_volume_/
facebook: http://www.facebook.com/marie.githinji
twitter: mariegithinji
tags: gender, technology,
equality, iHUB, African youth
we_volume_/
Employed at: I am a Web developer, freelancer The Akirachix network is a very good example. It is
a forum for girls in IT. The community is steadily
Hobbies: I have a passion for technology, growing. Their goal is to empower women interested
I read a lot, and I also love to watch movies. in IT in Kenya.
Your wish for Kenya: My wish for Kenya is Akira is a Japanese word that means energy and
that more people will embrace technology in solving intelligence. These two words aptly describe this group
problems, especially women. These women will of ladies: “We are intelligent and we bring all our
understand that there is no such thing as careers energy together to help and empower the greater
“meant for men only”. And I guess men have to community of girls out there.”
learn this as well.
Akirachix has successfully launched a training program
for girls from poor backgrounds by offering them
free IT training courses. The same group of girls has
also been asponored by infodev to run a mobile social
network lab in Nairobi.
I Want To Be A
Computer Genius
William Dwayne-Tyga Junior, , Winneba, Ghana
twitter: @jnrwill
facebook: http://www.facebook.com/jnrwilly
tags: technology, programer,
African youth
we_volume_/
Memoirs Of A
Slum Boy
Mark Kamau, , Nairobi, Kenya
twitter: @Mark_Kamau
facebook: http://www.facebook.com/mckam
tags: slum, struggle, nairobits,
education, Kibera, African youth
we_volume_/