Professional Documents
Culture Documents
uk
‘Am I Bovvered?...’
1. The view from the media... Three girls [two aged 17, one of 16]
found guilty of an attack in which a teenage boy was sexually
assaulted were yesterday handed detention orders...The victim was
punched and kicked and forced to strip and perform a sex act. The
attack was filmed on a mobile phone...
Daily Mail, 14 December 2004 ˜Girls still beating boys at A-level but
gap narrowing˜Boys have narrowed the A-level performance gap
between them and girls for the third year running but girls are still
outshining boys at grade A in each of the main subjects, today
results show.
3. Research summary See individual sections for more detail and full
references Teenage girls and the media (page 17-18) Teenage girls
are highly influenced by the media, but they don’t particularly like
or trust it. Most of them think it misrepresents and stigmatises
them. They blame its focus on skinny celebrities for making them
more susceptible to eating disorders - a view shared by some
professionals working in this field. Media coverage concentrates on
negative stories about young people. One in three articles about
them is about crime. Young people themselves are rarely asked for
their opinions by journalists and rarely quoted in articles about them
and their behaviour. Body image (page 19-21) Young women feel
under pressure from the media to be pretty and thin. The most
influential role models are Kate Moss and Victoria Beckham. The
older girls get, the more likely they are to be unhappy with their
weight and to be on a diet. The number of women with eating
disorders is on the rise - with girls as young as 8 being diagnosed.
Death rates - including from suicide - are high. Sufferers are also
more likely to go on to abuse drugs and alcohol. The younger the
sufferer the more likely their health is to be damaged. Many
sufferers say it would help if the media showed images of more real
bodies. Professionals working with anorexics and bulimics say the
causes of eating disorders are complex but the media does play a
part. The focus on skinny bodies makes it harder for sufferers to
recover. Sex, drugs and alcohol (page 22-24) Britain has the highest
teen pregnancy rates in Western Europe. The number of
conceptions among under 16s is going up. Girls from poorer areas
are more likely to get pregnant than richer ones, and less likely to
have an abortion. The media has a role to play in creating a climate
where young girls are more likely to have sex, according to experts
in sexual health. One type of risky behaviour often leads to another
- if teenagers are abusing alcohol, they are more likely to have
unprotected sex. 40% of sexually active 13- and 14-year-olds were
drunk or stoned when they first had sex. Public health messages
about responsible behaviour are drowned out by the volume of
coverage given to celebrity behaviour involving sex, drugs and
alcohol. Girls are now bigger binge drinkers than boys. Rates of
drunkenness among girls are rising; for boys, they are falling.
Educational achievement (page 25-27) Girls not only do better than
boys in their GCSEs and A-levels but at just about every stage of
their educational careers. From key stage 1 (5- to 7-years), right
through to degree level, they get better results. At university, the
numbers of males and females getting first class degrees are equal,
but more women than men get upper seconds. One explanation
may be that girls consistently do more homework than boys. By age
15, twice as many girls as boys are doing three or more hours a
night. Role models and ambitions (page 28-29) Young girls’
ambitions are heavily influenced by the media. Many young girls in
particular want to be famous, wanting to be TV presenters, models
or popstars. Nearly half of 10- to 15-year-olds want to be on reality
television. Teenage girls think the likes of Kate Moss, Victoria
Beckham and skinny models and celebrities are bad role models,
but also believe they are very influential. Young girls career
ambitions narrow as they get older. Doing well in a career and
success at school or university is less important to older teenagers
than to younger ones. Nearly half of 16- to 25-year-olds say getting
married is very important.
4.Is this what equality looks like? All lads and ladettes together The
timing of Women in Journalism’s summit on teenage girls and the
media could hardly have been better. Just last week, lad mag FHM
was censured for publishing a topless photo of a 14-year-old girl.
Journalist Fiona Bawdon, who conducted Wij’s research into this
area, looks at questions raised by this case and the spread of lad
culture more generally Girls outperform boys academically,
apparently taking pride in their intellectual abilities, and yet each
week hundreds of them send in topless pictures of themselves to lad
mags like FHM and Nuts. Research shows that girls do more
homework than boys - and yet they also do more binge drinking.
Last week, FHM magazine was condemned for publishing a picture
of a topless 14-year-old without her consent. The PCC ruled
publication of the picture was a serious intrusion into the girl’s
private life; the solicitor acting for her parents, who brought the
complaint, said it had a significant effect on her emotionally and at
school. FHM told the Press Complaints Commission it had no reason
to believe the picture was taken without consent and, anyway, she
certainly appeared to be older. However, the commission said it
would have been a serious intrusion regardless of how old she was.
Would FHM have escaped censure for publishing the naked breasts
of this child if she’d said it was OK? FHM’s defence - that she
consented and anyway looked older - is a line of argument that will
be familiar to many a paedophile. At what point do grown men
looking at teenage breasts stop being lads and start being paedos?
Would the magazine have escaped censure for publishing the naked
breasts of this child if she’d said it was OK? Would it have been OK if
she’d been 16? It is, of course, entirely possible that this child would
still have suffered emotional damage from appearing topless even if
she’d wanted her picture to be sent in. Do lad mag publishers owe
any responsibility to young breast-baring teenagers to protect them
from behaviour their more mature selves might regret? This
particular teenager may not have wanted her picture published, but
many others do. Lad mags say they are deluged with photos sent in
by women, posing either topless or in their underwear. FHM says its
gets 1,200 such pictures a week, many of which are sent by the
women themselves. The Nuts website includes an Assess My
Breasts page (click here to upload your breasts) where women can
invite men they’ve never met to give their breast marks out of 10.
Given this, wrote Decca Aitkenhead recently in the Guardian: It is no
wonder a lot of men now genuinely believe that women want to be
treated as sex objects. But it’s not just the girl next door who is (it
seems) increasingly willing to strip for the camera. The two latest
successful and respected actresses to do just that (albeit with their
bras still on) are Nicole Kidman (in a shoot for Vanity Fair magazine)
and Maggie Gyllenhaal (in a series of underwear ads). In one photo,
Gyllenhaal is shown in black underwear, handcuffed to a chair, legs
splayed. Kidman and Gyllenhaal are not obvious candidates for this
kind of lads-mag-lite posing. Both are regarded as serious actors;
both have, in the main, avoided obvious stereotyping in their choice
of roles. Are ordinary teenage girls more ready to strip off because
they’re used to seeing the likes of Kidman and Gyllenhaal in their
underwear; or is it the other way around? It’s hard to know who is
setting the agenda here. Are ordinary teenage girls more ready to
strip off because they’re used to seeing the likes of Kidman and
Gyllenhaal in their underwear; or is it the other way around? In any
event, overtly lusting over young naked flesh is no longer solely the
preserve of lads (if, indeed, it ever was). Websites for magazines
aimed at girls as young 10 include galleries of lush lads, some
posing shirtless, to be rated out of 10. Mizz (target age range 10-14)
invites readers to rate out hotties. The website for Sugar magazine
currently includes a picture of 13-year-old Sam, from London, whose
bare shoulders are clearly visible. Daniella, from Essex, sent his pic
because I think he’s buff. Readers are invited to give him - along
with dozens of other boys in the gallery - marks out of 10. Boys are
Hot Lads or Mingers; Sexy or Sling him. Again, in language which
wouldn’t be out of place in a lad mag, readers are variously
exhorted to feast your eyes and try not to dribble too much. Are the
parents of teenage boys any more comfortable with this kind of
objectification of their children than the parents of the FHM 14-year-
old? Could young boys equally be damaged by this kind of uninvited
exposure? Is this what equality now looks like?
But it’s not just boys that these teen girl magazine websites hold up
for rating. In further blurring of the lines between teen sites and lad
mag sites, under the heading, How Sexy Am I? Bliss’s website
(target age 14-17) invites girls to send in pictures of themselves
(albeit clothed) to be marked out of 10 on looks and pull-ability.
Options in answer to the question: How do you rate your looks?
range from: Beautiful through to Ewwww. Handily for the ‘mingers’
among them, Bliss website offers readers the chance to buy
Airbrush Me software (Look gorgeous in all your pics) which can be
used to correct skin tone and remove spots or other blemishes.
Bliss’s website is also running a survey, which invites readers to cast
an almost forensically critical eye over their own bodies. For 10
parts of their anatomy, including their tummy, thighs, legs and
boobs, readers are asked to rate whether they are: happy; unhappy;
or hate ‘em. (The answer love ‘em does not feature.) In another
strong echo of lad mag-ism, the same Bliss survey also asks its
teenage girl readers to vote on who has the best boobs out of Pink,
Jessica Simpson, Colleen McLoughlin and Carly Zucker; and who has
the best bum out of JLo, Beyonce, Misha Barton and Kylie. The
reader’s reward for taking part in the survey is the chance to ‘blag a
beauty bag’, the main contents of which appear to be ‘clean feel
sanitary towels’. It’s hard to see what purpose such a survey serves,
other than for scoping the teen market for potential plastic surgery
customers Should a teen magazine really be encouraging young
girls to think in terms of hating their still developing bodies?. Sugar
magazine runs an annual modelling competition (Want fame,
freebies and fit lads?) giving girls from age 13 the chance to be
‘spotted by our model scouts’. With research suggesting over a third
of 10- to 14-year-olds want to be models, no doubt the competition
is a big hit with Sugar readers.
Despite their worries about being fat, girls are more reluctant to
take up exercise, with fewer than 3 out of 10 (28.8%) of 15-year-old
girls doing the recommended amount of physical exercise,
compared with nearly half (47.8%) of boys. Although older girls are
more concerned about their weight than younger ones, the older
they get, the lazier they get, compared with boys. It’s at the age of
11 where gap between exercise done by boys and girls is narrowest.
Girls watch about the same amount of television as boys, but do far
more homework. They are twice as likely to do three or more hours
studying a night than boys - and the disparity between time spent
on homework by boys and girls increases with age. Girls are much
more law-abiding than boys - and they grow out of criminal
behaviour two years earlier. The peak age for female offenders is
15; for males, it’s 17; four out of five offenders are male. Girls are
more likely to skip breakfast than boys; they’re more likely to eat
fruit and vegetables every day; less likely to have daily fizzy drinks;
but just as likely as boys to eat sweets every day. Over 60% of 15-
year-old girls sometimes miss breakfast on a school day, compared
with 37.6% of boys. As the researchers point out, failure to eat first
thing leads to mid-morning fatigue and interferes with cognition and
learning. However, this doesn’t appear to affect girls’ academic
performance, as they continue to outshine boys in just about every
subject at just about every age group.
The proportion of girls eating fruit and vegetables every day stays
fairly consistent from the age of 11 up to 15, despite older girls
being relatively free from parental influence over what they eat.
Marginally more 15-year-old girls have sweets and soft drinks every
day than eat daily fruit (32.5%, 36%, and 28.3%, respectively).
Girls are less likely than boys to be satisfied with their lives and feel
less healthy. The older girls get, the less likely they are to report
that their health is good or excellent. At age 11, a fifth say their
health is only fair or poor; by age 15, over a third (33.2%) say it is.
The proportion of boys rating their health as only fair or poor is
relatively static between age 11 and 15, hovering around 17-19%.
Despite being less happy with their lot in life, girls are far less likely
to kill themselves than boys. Between, 2000-2005, more than three
times as many boys aged 15-24 killed themselves as girls in the
same age group(4) (3.301 compared with 937 in the UK and
Republic of Ireland).
Females have lower pass rates for their driving tests than males
(35.8% and 47.8%, respectively) but are much safer drivers once
they are on the road. From 2002-2005, three times as many young
male drivers were killed or seriously injured than girls (3,545 and
1,089, respectively). However, while they may be relatively safe
drivers, being a young woman passenger is dangerous if the car is
driven by a novice male driver. Young male drivers carrying
passengers, are now the biggest killer of young women in this
country.
7. Body image Pressure to be pretty and thin Over half of 16- to 25-
year-olds and a quarter of 10- to 15-year-olds in a study of 3,000
young women say the media makes them feel being pretty and thin
is the most important thing(1). More than 95% said the role models
with the most influence (albeit, they believed, bad) over young girls
were Kate Moss and Victoria Beckham - both of whom are famously
skinny. In another study, nearly 30% (29.6%) of 11-year-old girls are
dissatisfied with their body weight, and one in 10 (11%) is on a
diet(2). By the age of 15, 46% of girls are dissatisfied with their
weight, and a quarter of them are dieting. Girls as young as 8 are
now being diagnosed with eating disorders Professionals working in
this field are convinced the numbers of teenage girls with eating
disorders are going up - and that sufferers are getting younger. The
majority of sufferers are aged 14-25 - but girls as young as 8 have
been diagnosed. An estimated 20% of sufferers are male. The
eating disorders charity B-eat estimates that over a million people
will be affected by an eating disorder at any one time. However,
according, to chief executive Susan Ringwood, organisations like
hers are hampered by the lack of up-to-date research into the
numbers affected. The last reliable survey on eating disorders dates
back to 1990, and hasn’t been updated since, she says.
8. Sex, drugs and alcohol If it’s OK for Kate Moss and Amy
Winehouse, why not me? Pregnancy rates among under 16s are on
the rise; and girls from deprived homes are the most likely to fall
pregnant, and more likely than girls from richer backgrounds to see
the pregnancy through. Britain has the highest teen pregnancy
rates in Western Europe - twice as high as Germany, three times a
high as France and six times as high as The Netherlands(1). The
number of girls under 16 - the legal age of consent - getting
pregnant went up by 4% from 7,615 in 2004 to 7,917 in 2005. Rates
for older teenagers, however, remain stable, 42,198 in 2004 and
42,187 in 2005. Teenagers from deprived areas are four times as
likely to fall pregnant than those living in better off areas Teenagers
from deprived areas are four times as likely to fall pregnant than
those living in better off areas - and more likely to go on to have the
baby, rather than abort. For every 1,000 teenagers in poorer areas,
80 will become pregnant, compared with 16 in richer ones. Among
under 16s, the gap between conception rates for rich and poor girls
is even higher. Most teenagers from better off areas who fall
pregnant will abort (71%); only a minority from poorer homes will
terminate their pregnancy (39%). Among under 16s, more than
three-quarters (77%) from richer areas will terminate, compared
with half of those from poorer homes. Teenage mothers are
invariably condemned by the media for being feckless and
irresponsible. However, a government advisory body on sexual
health says the media is in part to blame(2). The climate where
young girls end up having sex is fuelled by extensive and constant
coverage of celebrity behaviour. The positive media coverage of
celebrity behaviour involving sex, drugs and alcohol acts as an
encouragement to young people, it says in a report into the links
between alcohol, drugs and sex. The more likely young girls are to
drink or use drugs, the more likely they are to have unprotected sex
One type of risky behaviour often leads to another - the more likely
young girls are to drink or use drugs, the more likely they are to
have unprotected sex. You can’t tackle one without the others, it
says. According to one public health expert(3): * 40% of sexually
active 13- to 14-year olds were drunk or stoned when they lost their
virginity; * 11% of 15- to 16-year-olds had sex they subsequently
regretted after drinking alcohol; * Young people are three times as
likely to have unprotected sex when they are drunk than when
sober. Any messages about responsible behaviour are drowned out
by the sheer volume of coverage given to celebrities behaving
badly.