Professional Documents
Culture Documents
0 JEB3216
3717
Accepted 6 October; published on WWW 14 November 2000 Summary were detected in all tissues from all species, the levels of Oxygen, while being an obligate fuel for aerobic life, has SOD and GPX decreased in parallel with the exponential been shown to be toxic through its deleterious reactive reduction in the metabolic activity as estimated by citrate species, which can cause oxidative stress and lead synthase activity. In contrast, CAT was affected neither by ultimately to cell and organism death. In marine the metabolic activity nor by the depth of occurrence of the organisms, reactive oxygen species (ROS), such as the shes. High levels of metabolic and antioxidative enzymes superoxide anion and hydrogen peroxide, are generated were detected in the light organs of bioluminescent species. within respiring cells and tissues and also by photochemical The adjustment of the activity of SOD and GPX to the processes in sea water. Considering both the reduced decreased metabolic activity associated with deep-sea living metabolic rate of nektonic organisms thriving in the suggests that these antioxidative defense mechanisms deep sea and the physico-chemical conditions of this are used primarily against metabolically produced ROS, dark, poorly oxygenated environment, the meso- and whereas the maintenance of CAT activity throughout all bathypelagic waters of the oceans might be considered as depths could be indicative of another role. The possible refuges against oxidative dangers. This hypothesis reasons for the occurrence of such a reduced antioxidative prompted us to investigate the activities of the three arsenal in deep-sea species are discussed. essential enzymes (superoxide dismutase, SOD; catalase, CAT; glutathione peroxidase, GPX) constitutive of the antioxidative arsenal of cells in the tissues of 16 species of Key words: oxidative stress, deep-sea sh, reactive oxygen species, superoxide dismutase, catalase, glutathione peroxidase, oxygen, meso- and bathypelagic shes occurring between the hydrogen peroxide. surface and a depth of 1300 m. While enzymatic activities
Introduction It has long been known that oxygen is not distributed uniformly in the oceans (Sewell and Fage, 1948). Most regions of the worlds oceans are characterized by high oxygen concentrations in the euphotic zone and by a decrease to lower oxygen levels in the deep sea. In some areas, such as the Pacic Ocean, oxygen levels reach a minimum value (the oxygen minimum layer, OML) corresponding to only a few per cent of that near the surface, followed by an increase in oxygen levels at greater depths (Wyrtki, 1962). Since oxygen is essential for aerobic life, problems associated with the existence of such a gradient focused on the adaptations of organisms able to survive at the low oxygen concentrations occurring near the OML (Childress and Siebel, 1998). However, in addition to its importance as an electron acceptor in cellular energetic processes, oxygen is also a problem for living organisms because it can be toxic. Indeed, its electronic structure favors univalent reductions that lead to the formation of highly reactive intermediates, such as the superoxide anion (O2), hydrogen peroxide (H2O2) and the hydroxyl radical (OH). These intermediates, called reactive oxygen species (ROS), can oxidize most cellular constituents, such as DNA, proteins and lipids, and markedly affect the physiology of the cell, leading to the initiation of cancer or cellular death (Cadenas, 1995). Most major pathologies in humans and animals are known to involve ROS at an early stage of the disease (Chen et al., 1995), and the involvement of ROS in the aging process is well documented in many species (Pacici and Davies, 1991; Harman, 1994). Since oxygen was released into the atmosphere by photosynthetic processes, its toxicity has posed a major threat to life (Hassan and Schiavone, 1991), and all extant organisms are endowed with a complex arsenal of antioxidative defense mechanisms. Besides some small diffusible molecules, such as vitamins C and E, which are able to quench ROS in cells and tissues, specialized enzymes are aimed at neutralizing ROS. The three most important enzymes are the superoxide dismutases (SODs) that converts O2 into H2O2, which can in turn be detoxied into water and oxygen by either catalase (CAT) or peroxidases. A major peroxidase
species and their minimum depth of occurrence (MDO), 16 species were selected to cover as far as possible the range between the surface and a depth of 1300 m (Table 1). Minimum depth of occurrence is dened as the minimum depth below which 90 % of the population of the species concerned can be found (Childress and Nygaard, 1973). Sample preparation Eleven tissues and organs were selected: eyes, brain, gills, heart, liver, stomach, kidney, white muscle, red muscle, skin and skin with photophores (Aksnes and Njaa, 1981; Filho et al., 1993). After the dissection, which was carried out on ice, similar tissues of each species were pooled, weighed and homogenized for 20 s at 9500 revs min1 with an electronic homogenizer (Polytron) in 5 volumes of phosphate-buffered saline (PBS) containing 1 % Triton X-100. Supernatants were obtained by a 30 min centrifugation at 4000 revs min1 (2880 g) at 4 C (Minifuge GL, Heraeus). Part of the supernatant was stored at 80 C, while the rest was dialysed (Medicell International Ltd; 1214 kDa) overnight at 4 C against the PBS-Triton buffer. Some samples were assayed directly for CAT while others were stored at 80 C. Assay for catalase (EC 1.11.1.6) The chemiluminescent method of Maral et al. (1977) was adapted for 96-well microplates to process numerous samples and replicates simultaneously. The assay for catalase (CAT) was performed on fresh samples immediately after dialysis. The measurements were carried out at 25 C on a PCcontrolled microplate luminometer (Berthold) equipped with two 50 l injectors. A rst injection of 106 mol l1 H2O2 solution initiated its reduction by the CAT contained in the diluted sample (50 l), which was added to 100 l of
Table 2. Stastically signicant relationships between biochemical variables and the minimum depth of occurrence in tissues of meso- and bathypelagic shes collected off California
P a bS.D. Protein content (mg g1 wet mass) versus minimum depth of occurrence (m) Eyes 0.0228 196.37 0.320.12 Liver 0.0090 411.58 0.410.14 Stomach 0.0062 259.82 0.490.15 White muscle 0.0580 85.63 0.360.18 Skin 0.0277 533.79 0.680.27 Citrate synthase activity (munits g1 wet mass) versus minimum depth of occurrence (m) Eyes 0.0037 16 481 0.640.18 Stomach 0.0349 34 544 0.620.27 White muscle 0.0406 6 701 0.430.19 Superoxide dismutase activity synthase activity (munits mg1 protein) Brain 0.0004 0.57 Gills 0.0126 0.17 Liver 0.0021 2.29 Stomach 0.0100 2.20 Kidney 0.0126 0.90 Red muscle 0.0466 0.10 White muscle 0.0001 0.19 Glutathione peroxidase activity synthase activity (munits mg1 protein) Brain 0.0076 2.43 Gills 0.0140 4.01 Liver 0.0003 6.62 Stomach 0.0041 8.58 Kidney 0.0073 9.39 White muscle 0.0055 0.82 (units mg1 protein) versus citrate 0.910.18 1.140.04 0.700.18 0.510.17 0.830.25 1.110.24 1.100.20 versus citrate 0.970.30 0.780.27 0.920.18 0.570.16 0.840.22 0.970.29
104
a d b
103
c g f e
k j
n m o l p
102
h i
200 400 600 800 1000 1200 1400 Minimum depth of occurrence (m)
Fig. 1. Exponential relationship between the citrate synthase (CS) activity (munits g1 wet mass) of the eyes and the minimum depth of occurrence (MDO) (m) of meso- and bathypelagic shes: CS activity=16 841MDO0.64. Each letter represents one species (see Table 1). Values are means S.E.M. (N=4).
associated with light organs, when present, showed a signicantly higher CS activity (P<0.05). The size of the sh could be correlated neither with the minimum depth of occurrence nor with CS activity. Superoxide dismutase Although SOD activity was detected in all tissues from all species, large differences were observed among tissues and species. The highest mean SOD activity was detected in the photophores (416.40 units mg1 protein), while the lowest levels were found in the eyes (16.46 units mg1 protein). Variations of up to three orders of magnitude were found in a single organ. For example, the SOD level in the liver of the deepest-living species, Eurypharynx pelicanoides (minimum depth of occurrence 1300 m), was 1.02 units mg1 protein, but it was 175.72 units mg1 protein in Argyropelecus affinis (minimum depth of occurrence 200 m). Although there appeared to be a trend for SOD activity (units g1 wet mass) to decrease with increasing depth of occurrence, attempts to link SOD activity to either the minimum depth of occurrence or the ambient oxygen concentration did not yield signicant relationships. In contrast, the activity of SOD was tightly correlated to CS activity in most tissues and organs (Fig. 2). The relationship is best described as an exponential increase in SOD activity (units mg1 protein) with increasing CS activity (munits mg1 protein) following the equation SOD activity =a(CS activity)b, with b ranging from a minimum 0.51 in the stomach to more than 1 in the muscles and gills (Table 2). Although high CS activity was always associated with high levels of SOD in the tissues, large variations in SOD activity were observed at low CS levels (<25 munits mg1 protein), suggesting that other factors could be important in determining
Glutathione peroxidase activity (munits mg1 protein) versus superoxide dismutase activity (units mg1 protein) Eyes 0.0027 3.23 1.050.28 Brain 0.0001 3.97 1.090.18 Gills 0.0122 22.65 0.430.15 Liver 0.0003 7.69 0.950.20 Stomach 0.0001 5.42 0.970.09 Kidney 0.0278 26.31 0.700.25 White muscle 0.0001 3.56 0.870.16 Skin 0.0021 9.12 0.800.20 All relationships are described by y=axb. P, probability.
and was also demonstrated in the eyes (b=0.64; Fig. 1) and the stomach (b=0.62). Although CS activity was detected in all the tissue of all species, some activities tended to be very low when expressed as a function of protein content or wet mass. Among species, the level of CS in the liver of the deepest-living species, Eurypharynx pelicanoides (minimum depth of occurrence 1300 m), was only 2.5 % of that assayed in the myctophid Symbolophorus californiensis, a species reaching the surface. Compared with all other tissues, the skin
p 0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 Citrate synthase activity (munits mg1 protein)
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
Fig. 2. Exponential relationship between superoxide dismutase (SOD) (units mg1 protein) and citrate synthase (CS) activities (munits mg1 protein) in the liver of meso- and bathypelagic shes: SOD activity=2.29(CS activity)0.70. Each letter represents one species (see Table 1). Values are means S.E.M. (N=4).
Fig. 3. Exponential relationship between glutathione peroxidase (GPX) (munits mg1 protein) and citrate synthase (CS) activities (munits mg1 protein) in the liver of meso- and bathypelagic shes: GPX activity=6.62(CS activity)0.92. Each letter represents one species (see Table 1). Values are means S.E.M. (N=4).
SOD activity when the metabolic rate is low. As an example, it can be seen that SOD levels in the liver of Scopelengys tristis and Parvilux ingens are higher than would be expected from their CS activity. Glutathione peroxidase The activity of GPX shows a very similar pattern to that of SOD, i.e. large variations among tissues and species and a dependence on the metabolic activity as measured by CS activity. The highest activities were again associated with the photophores (P<0.05 compared with all other tissues), with levels (9308.87 munits mg1 protein) far higher than in the liver, which ranked second (541.62 munits mg1 protein). Very low levels were measured in the eyes (68.18 munits mg1 protein) and the red muscle (71.45 munits mg1 protein). Variations in activity of three orders of magnitude were observed in most tissues. In the liver, the GPX activity measured in Eurypharynx pelicanoides (minimum depth of occurrence 1300 m) reached 39.3 munits mg1 protein, while the level in Symbolophorus californiensis (minimum depth of occurrence 10 m) was 1522.76 munits mg1 protein. The relationship between GPX activity (munits mg1 protein) and CS activity (munits mg1 protein) was very similar to that described between SOD and CS, with GPX activity=a(CS activity)b and with b ranging from a minimum of 0.57 in the stomach to 0.97 in the white muscle and brain (Fig. 3; Table 2). Here again, high CS activity was associated with high levels of the antioxidative enzyme while large variations in GPX activity were found at low CS levels (<25 munits mg1 protein), suggesting that other factors also affect GPX activity when metabolic rate is low.
The similar evolution of SOD with metabolic activity (units mg1 protein) and GPX activity (munits mg1 protein) is further illustrated by the existence of a signicant relationship, GPX activity=a(SOD activity)b, linking the activities of the two antioxidative enzymes in most tissues (Table 2; Fig. 4). The value of the exponent b, which characterizes the relationships, is close to 1 in most tissues (eyes, brain, liver, stomach, kidney, white muscle and skin), indicating a linear
n 1000 Glutathione peroxidase activity (munits mg1 protein) o g m e k f i h c j a d
l 100 p 10
200
Fig. 4. Exponential relationship between glutathione peroxidase (GPX) (munits mg1 protein) and superoxide dismutase (SOD) activities (units mg1 protein) in the liver of meso- and bathypelagic shes: GPX activity=7.69(SOD activity)0.95. Each letter represents one species (see Table 1). Values are means S.E.M. (N=4).