~~

~~,~~~t~
caf~-;rttlf$l ~<F

~?fl~~,

~~~~<li1f-

.~_.®~t~.~~_.~~_£~ __ ;.
. f~~ ~
~~ I

'~'-iTllf<f

~lf<'fi1'

W~

~f~

~~~

~Jtp.~ '1!frn~ 'Uf~~

fff<!r!-Cijf~<{>~ '~' $ff;[; @'alf 'O{~<Ii

'3Ij~~

CO'I~~ c""ref ~~~ 'S!i/i ef'tlf ijff\5 ~'i1 iiI1 I ~-c'! I.<;f~ ~." il!ftll'ti '"ttl;o/{ - fuf;T f'ifCJ5j~~1 <fiCil I.<;f ~l(t\'l' '.5't~i-'lt1W1 ~'hf 11rr.i:.!i "'I1m<fif I ~.,. ~ ~"\Zif iiI''lEloT <!Ii '«t<rliifi lmnrI ~ar lf~1 ii!t~~'fl <rIfe; if't1l® CEf~ ~Z ~-~~~ ~ ~ I I.<;f( ~ <1~~ ~. '(ti'1IC~~~ ~~~ ~9f~~"'1 I C1Jt~ ~~

~?:.~ ~n
~e_~T1X ~

~~
~C,~~ ~

~ljilm I

~fu~
CtIT'It
?{C'1"
~

~tom9fTl:W"{

"5~:>t-L.!1'Q

~t~T

G'<I~~

~fh
~1fi,l~

~"U;ij~~

'fI ~
CiI'fIFr'r.l I

~t~

L.!1<1'tNi'fi co;t~i{ f'Vl cmrr.1X ~l!ift~ ~~~ mt'f L.!1'4itir C01~ I

DC~

~~'iR
m.<11f1-

'6ftC1Jtt5irt~ L.!1~.,m~ ~ 'rI orf<nrl' ~~ m~ 16l~'1 ~~ L.!1~iY\~Hh~'.Rm'1 f<r<l~ 'l\Qfttf'f~ ~~ ~~ "!t~ I ~~ ~~{ m~ Clf~ ~r'l '!{~\!j ~1~il orBllfl- f<t11'l,j~ ~~<Ii ~1t~i1hI I fm"t C<'~'T' ~W1-C1ff~iI Modern Masters ~ <rot ClI f~'Sf cmrrn-~ ~ 1.<;f!\~H:if~ ~')<{ car~ ~~ ~ I ~ ~t~-.llt~ c:w11!>ft~ Modern
Masters 'iR, Post-modern Masters!
~~ ~1
<[~

t-'1!'f<Ti~ ~.,

<S{itiftD-{i

Pl~

<rl

Masters 1 ~? <'ro1 ~
~1);5j ~~lil
<Ii$f~ on{

WW/~

~m:Q't
<w~t~

~\5J~

~lf

L.!1"m ~
1fN1 ~

Of!

~'1' ~tvT1
~jg~r

\51<I:t"1' <fil1J ~ I

lf~iSf ~"I

<n~

~C~ elf

"fi1R;t~ f"tW>rit1R! f~G'j Jffit~

'1fit~

C"ffm ~~~~'litil' ~K!J"ft~-t~'ift~i!rn f~.,<jf.l"~ '<r'JItl!1 "flfu: ~t~ ~"' ~ ~,lffi.r<i·lf~tr.~i!i!

c!11lfil '.!l'lff.l
1{1" <liQ.fj~.g
~

-N~ m~~~o;>(~
~,,~ ~
I ~

<ffi1 ~art"f

~tlfj<i ~~1 ~,

~~r~if f~ ~
Jf"ll

~~ ~

ltnr ~f~rli;l

i'!1 I

wr~'ifl ~

"f1'~Ol-'(~mC!1f~ ~m ;rt'l{ <l'l:~ :.n~. ~~ 1" ~~11qI'Ml ,.~ '111 t ~ ~~ ~roQf c<fi'{ C\lim ~? <u~ ~tt~ ~ ~t'llWl'~ 'fft~ii '5{\!IJ'Z ~~to{ i!\~ I ~ 'ttCitl5"tijj f~'1.
~~ QU <:st1lt!J

'lt~(lor(Q[~

'R'1'f~ ~

!
~~{

'1J"h1tt*ft~-

'''f~-

11

'I ~/.trA'ttlf \S

\j;i&l~

Qf~<fIlflif

;lCIilj'rM1~/'I

~::f
'e~ ~

f~

f.;r"c<pt,
<filt~ I ~

1I'J1f~-~~,
<ft~
~
~~

j;m-~1
C'l ~ <1f.<Qi[1·~
~Q(1 ~ ~.

~
~~

f~~ ~
o2It1(f~

~t'l'f{~BI

~ro;rj

Cilm<1: iii. ~
<,!ff~

'!5fW ~

~'11'i~ f<PI.":( '!iftf'l{ c~1~.~

~

~nror! I
r1lll~J ~ ~-~ ~tar

fiA'1
~
I

'iT~91l

'Ut~~

(.<ftOI ~ '!'t~ l!1-~-\!~,

\14Cl1CQi[('\

~
~

C~C<J #lllf1 ~~
-~ ~ I .Jl~ "l~

C<t'q6l~11f1
~ ~

f~'_~
~

~~

(l~

~1 'ST~ I ~

~.~
\!'j~ ~

CfU<IS
~

m~ ~t'~.~~!l:
'5fh't ~

fi1~,:~ I

'~>

'ift~
"l'i\ ~

'<lM <fim 61~. '11'3~~ 'r1 ~tf~

f~
~t<I;

~ :arrfiJw:rrtiI' <mr I

<r1 ~~"'!ir

~'<fi"o'rttt1 ~'t
"Rr~')

~if~ 1ff~
~ ~

~\!ifil: ~

~~ ~
<I>B.
(.1if{

~
~

ift'll"

TIr'"

lItiI ~q?'O\, C'l ~\

l.!I~flR ~
'!ffi~1 'ii'ii
(:Ii

m~;ft11C01

omt: flM "<IfW; ~1'0i1r;w

C6W ~~

CIf'e$ lR1fJ

fm ~
~?

C( ~~

f~

elf ~

~"ll:~ ffui C~ ~f~ ~ c;~, 111m -mf.t ~, m9 ~ C\!1 ~M' ~

mI

I.!I~ i(tlf

m~ ~~rr1 ~'tm on ~ ~ I (~~ il~l~ "Itc"r c~ta;rt~ m~\!l ~!{, ~ ~M ~rn Ojf::f1 fm .C1I ,,~ ~ q't~'l -n I <J.)~~m ~~ ~, ~m .~ 0{ ~lbl~ltil!li1 1f~~. 'i!11
'6~ 0lilfoT---.lIlj<f

"'Iit"r

~<;iW1~11
1i1i:~ I

~ ~ f.mt ,0{ ~
I.!I~-~

f.I-tt~

*~ ~ 9fIDf,
~'t
I

~C~~ (~)
"If~

mw

'!IltlliS
~$1

I.!I~~
~~$1

~-.n
~~

~t"
Ol~

~t~~. "lrPJ,

f!'&JT<'{ f.lt<pr <rul C'I'OfI ~f1';fi1 '!1 ~f~m~ l_t~ cot€U1'f~R I

otf1fi,,~ ~ f«i~
C$~ ~

P ~f~

w"t~

~, ~~t:li!

~,,~!!!
~
~

~\!j~tar1 ~~ \

'9If.~'1 \~ti!1
~
iifSl'
'e ~

~t~
I ~t\l

w:~~
~
~,

~'lfrn ~
~l(~ ~

~~1~
~

~~

~1
~
I

f~~
~'M1 ~

ClIJI::tc1ti1~'4tt9 )

~,,~

t_~ I 1l~ c~
<!l~ ~

~~1it ,,!lf1 ~f~

Oii lf~ 'ff.~ ~~--JSi ~ #\~~, c;~ if~ I f~t~ ~"!"tt~ ctl~ c'ttnlilf1f'tf.'lNl"~ ~ r.:~O'f<1tt1ji "\fm<!S'l fOi[~1t .....in the world of advertising, masking the name of a model is a normal practice" ( lS May, 1991 I f}.,;~ C;QJ11 L.!lt "normal practice" lfil'9
<II~,

ortlf ~l

m~I

f~t"ltil' I.!Ifm ~~~

".!flt~
~c:(~

~m
f~t"'1~

mlt~ti;1 ~

"If~1 C'1tor"ltf'tfir

~Th.l:ijOl;

f~Ol

~~-~'mI

5ft~.

0J'h(ffif C"roIi ~ ~ ~-W~ ~ r ~f;fsr ~i>f-~;rntto{ <'II~ fSlW <?iTt~~ fl~fSf N<t>$IC4~ ~~
~ ~if I

filn[~
<fJMJ1

f\!JR OJ'~2ft1; 'i'~tv! ~<mtfl

.,t~'friU 'ft~M~ ~9

~ ~Nlf

wtfoll ooo!
f"lt~ ~tfll

'l1t C1I ~N "$TI~w.i "itiVl"r, ~Dt~ f'<:lf~'6~, f"\"SfClf<r 1tc1{tfq{'S",

r.:"t'1~,

~
~

f~

~~

R~

~mf\f I fiIs.,.~ ~~ ~Y? <5l~ ~f~ oltll, 'll{il1 l.!I~f~"II \5d ~ f<li
'Iii ~

--rs"t.r

';{.I~

I I.il'@ton ~: slgnlfler=-signlfied, syncb.roDy~diacbreny, syntagmatic-paradigm\Jtic, substance - form, content-expression, langue-parole I !<!I~-q 0JfI'¥1 ~~C~ ~((J ~, f~'1! 'e ~i'hI <IlI"lc"ilb"il ~ '1ti4~ ~~ ~~~1-~l.!l c'Pf~ I ~ I.!Icq~h'1 ~ f[)~ rof!t't\!i~ :IllW\~ «tff.rWi '1fi15t 9fI~

~~

m-r
~

\~-'ft~~t'If~ ~
0!1li[~~ ~
.fHr~

I!(ttlf{ ~~

iffi, ~ ~ ~i1 ~

Oii I (.1\ .,I~l(-~\1llt"1 ~1 ~~'(J '~"9', 0fI-~ ( non-person ) - ~ ~ ~

(~1li["l~)~"ll:

~~

~~-~
1f1-~-~

;'Tr~l'I't 1!ffilRl1 OWl (..,'e1l1 o<!,~.11

<JI"'~ct,
r. ~
I

f~ct
t

~11f~'1
tltt'T

>!fA

~~ ~

m~-'\!i~
~~

,,~t~ ~~ Cff'Cm m 1 f~
1.!I:Ii<{ ~ ~
~'lI1, ~ "l~ ~ ~

1.!I~<r "Itr;-r c;r~tct.,~_~Qf'>l_~

~? ~n:l

~~!
~,

(arbitrary ) I '111' I 'fCiff\!i 'Pf1fi tree, {'If. C"f~, 'It ~~.,fiI,.. 'E.itimf-lIt~ ~ ;rt r.~il, H~0 1 If.0 I

j't)!lI

1; X '1

1V! ~. ~ If"!, ~t<ifti1.

''11 ~~ 1iti '1i~

~~"11 ~

vsli0ft1t-

~~ f~f'Sff~J~~" ~~ ~

~ ~ ~7.:m'l 0!111 f'1tt; 1 <!l~ Of~, ~\i5fD~ ~ <fl'!f t'llO\: ot.I"~~ 1.!11Itti{ ~f<R1 ,~O'ftli[ I ~iI' ~-m Cif~ tiN ~'l~ ~ ~'1 <11~. ~t~ \i5'tt<\l ~~

~ ?'

~J

~,<ilf'ftl~n;~ ~~~..., ~
~t<mmQi~~'l, = ~<{I1r,

'lfiI Q!'I ,~!(tt~

~ctm.

<!l~~

'ifS<il"P.l

'IfIGii
"l~m;~lf,

~tlf

,.. 1~ 1~1

~,?I«"f~~t-~

1S1"lI11 '11'11'!l :1 I "1 ~ f"'ll". "rtt'\1" ~~f~ fi{i~-ro:c;{I ~1 ~J i.!l'1't1 1-1 cl';i~Hl1~tc~, l?iTtl{!{ IJI~ ~1 ~!P11l¥I'l1 <ror ~V~ ~'l I'll c a "lft ! ,tflPltsf fomt 1ft!!ft ~tif1 ~ ~i il~ I . 't.t51~ ~ ~oo (substance~t~ rmll1) 1'fIQt I ~·If(.il \Ir~ Q ~1
I.!I~ ~~

l.!l~ ~ ~ ~ ~{ '1iltil;i(!(;"Ii1 C~1

mllftar nmr .~l"il ~

<!IW 1Jl"lS

I '"

n~
If
I

,,~

~tiI' ~

I fiI~~"t '1lir

I~~ ~ ,~t-M ~Q{

.,~11!t~~t1f -s 15'S11.fi1(i{!i'!t.1f

Of'f~

~t9ftUl1/
'l!<1iJ ~

'1~

't$ ljf;;;7;;U m~il I ~~

~fii ~" ~
,¥~'Qi ~tlf~

<215'$

"If1<n (.~

pr~~ f~f<f t~Mt~lf1<r1

~

~L1\1~

~".(fu-~'1ar-'5{f\!Oj,,~~ ~!I ~;Rar1 ~

,.td, ti6
c1j~

S)~=t
~~i(

f«1~ I f~
~ ~~

~t~~
~${

l5"~fo:rn~~~
f<l~~~

f'\fCY~C\!il C~~11otar11if1 ~111! ffl c!I~ -"f'";.ij ~ cfj"~'EI <~il1 m:ar f~ C~? c~ WI' cflt~ RilRl~ CWi?;f -<.!1~ ~~<vt~ '1tnT ~~ ~~ ~ ~ if1 I ..tI~ f.l1t~t~ <to'fI:~ I5ft~ ~1~ ( form) : t!t~~ ~t~ <2It'i~1'1ni1-~$fFar ~! ~

'i$

lfRm

'i$-~f~ ~, mt<\i,

i$ I <f'! fltli~ <ttDPItar

1ft~ lft1

~J

~@m

fir1Jl~ ~ ~f~

"lto{~~<l'1 >e lj~~ ~ ~"Q~~{ <f~: ~<K"!1.f ~tlI1 ~~ "t~ ~r,if r.5j., I ~J~"il~ ~ ~~J~~ fui')1\!i1fi~.,ljlj'f ~1Tjt"lsiif'Jf"l~ ~~~~ lft~ "'tbt1:(1ar C'I (JI"~ ,~ f.BI~r~ij @mi'if f~.,t<l; <fit\'!i' ~Q ~Wl ~t~ ~ I ~~~ LangueParole (~e<u ~;;r;IT," J[\~rt-~) T:i'l1f~ ~~ f~'€-~ '!~ ~\,ij1 ~ c1Qi I C:J'I~"'lt'-f D1!f~.fl.if<ltlft,<I' "!l{~~~ ~"Q ~'ifi ~~'1 ~ I
~~·fli ..tom t

<Ilrn I <!lt~r;ili

Ciff1lt~ fItO'f. ~1

~~

.,~1jp!i "1'W

ilim '!i{"~~

fi~>s~ ~fif Ci{~t,;-~ Of~t~ f<f C~ ~~

~ ~~ ~~ ~~~

'ltc~t~ ~?
~"{f

mt~~,
~"l{

f~~
'!KOi<ji ~.,~

<ttDi2fr~~ fol~Ol ~f~tt<m ~~ Q! "I'Iff~

~~

~~1f~
~f~
t

.<fI' ~

~~f.I ~~iRtft 'Oftc~ I '\!)t~?:aI'(3 >Jl<t>~ -'foiI1 ~"flI,f!if.T ~1iJl~~ @~ ~r~f~ ~~ ${w:.o:rn ~fDm~ ~ I5jf~1Ji ~ t-:bl~~ 't1I.liiICIf~f~ ~ISM
\Wf
~i{'ft1f" ~

~f.f ~~

cm~

'\!i1 ~te'R f;!~"~

f~Y f~'" ~
<i'~;f1

,g~Jlf'1

~tf~

'El ~ ... I

'<!f

~ ~~

~~

~'f¥tt~

~1~, ''!ifi'irtr

~tlHJ ~

~tOo:n
~~.,~

I <.!1mm~1 <nl'lf
~~<1i

lj~'"

~(Qli
C!\~ ~

~<!'~ 'artIS' ~-~it1 or! ~<Wf<T '6fl fi~;r I

<!IQ <li1:Oi[,

'{'t1!lf 'SPI~ ~-r~

~~ ~tf~tG1 !?In~~

'!!iIif-f ill I ~t~

~<Ii'" Of~~t:~.

~r:~, ~"1"'{jlf <f~~f~UOl(~ c"fl! <R~ ~ I ~~jff ilf~~rf"'l<p "'l'if~~ ~\!i~f~ C"f~ ~cor ~f\!iml'(~ C"I~-rn, <m~ ~fu~t~lj~ cift~ ~!fJR I -!rf~f~·~~ '51<lng0i11, "1fJ.f<rf<r~
('<pl5 ~~
Clf'l1"1fifY"lf~
~ I

'6lrfif f.Nt'1 'ifi~~, 'Nii C"'I!in~ ~ <!i1f5l~ C9\~io1-~

9fit"r f'ifi~ 'l!Rt~t(,l'f
~~~""'OT~
(Qj7;<j)

'5i$l1ir."rn '!iif%§l1!:1

<n~ ~ ~ OW '1;!!ttif, ~ ~~tar1 ~ fil1it'l ~

~~ I

G~t<!itf<nif1

.,;if~-

ill ~,
C'lr~'6

'<ttf'1 wtt~

R'1CJf!l' lj1@'PR'\ f~

wtm 9\W'r ~1i~ crol I ~C!fS ~f~ 'ilftrsf~ I ~t<rjll; <tl~r.n cb~Bi 1!l~'Stt<1~
~'ftt~T;
~

cfiitr;<II

~<t '5Jtrti. C\!i~R

~~~r;i\~'8

'(3!l'~

c!I~1

f.nr~Tfol~~

f;:~~~1 ~\§fi( <1inl I iffl"lT;1

c!I<li J[\~

<!I<j)
~t~O{

f~~ "rt!;~t~ ~~~ttO'f~ ~"I'\t'l I!ll'il'l ~1iT<1f;;;<l~iif C~ .JI<fio:rn ,~~ cm1~~ fij~ I f~ ~Wi!, tfff!>10l' "t>l:t;jf".,-" 1(tCi{!l' c~t;sr :J'1l(1'1''1~ro~ c~ W"f f~1'1J~~"l{ <!l<t T;1~"l/>~i!f ~'UIl ",it ~~ I
1

~fO<f

~w"f~t~ I!l~ f~"'l-~

~nm'
~~~~tlf
'!{1t'5'i~ I

~f.iT

ll'1'!T I ~

~t"5~ <ut'1i~,

'~~

foitl

~tt"I'jD-{1 ~

~TI!, ","Jtf~ ~ ... ~t~ ~

l~1
C~~

m-f~tOifrn, v.o:r~,
lil<lf
(,Q.)'C<!i

'!ft~tClii!l 1>(lliitt011~, "Language" "t?fl\;l Lingua I!Ir;O{~-Lingua 'Jitr;i\ "e;~1"-!i!~~'i "Language" ~ '~'<!l~
""I>j~

~~ <l'o;f~1 fO{~(it~ <ilt1f<fi-rn'i c~~ <{)t~'1~~"I1f.I~ <2I'll ~Cil~i{ I

~~;r'tnlrn ~

Ct>81~,
I \!l~i{

f~~1
\51<111t
~~~"l;rj
~~o{lf

~rn~
,:'<I~

~~·f~l
lj~m>tf1~~

I ~~:,
~

Language-..!lQ<!l~
~§l

'!i{t~1.; 1(tr;{~~. ~~Jf<q' 'S'j~

~~/~

'lft~\!tl{

<iI'f-,

~'3TtflR[ ~1R1

~f~~l{1

<.!1~ ~i{f~~rn~~ ~r;art{)"ltc<!l" ~~\:sr "~f;5~fil<fi"r~~<ftm{ I5ftf~<I" ~"lQi <Rti't <fi~9 ~ I 'Ilfrrr; ~Ol~ ~~i f<f~!t, ~ st~ ~oij~~lf~\5tQ "~<!F~1;il'WC'S'j~ I r.~~':;hl 'i.!iC'IJ~ '!i{t~ Cl[ lim ~~1 1l'rn 'O{fQ ~<!i ~;:r~ ~ f.l'Sjt9 <mr C£i'O'I~ I

.!if~~tf~ '''r~rmr

'\!)ls WW~~W~~~1ii ~ f~ ~ I ~f.l~RI "I<ff<tlf'@~~i{;~m ~~~ 'SfRt~ ~ '<aim m'S'ltr;l(1~ ;g,D1 f;H:~~ I ~t-.."r~ ~ ~fmt <Ii~ f~ <pt~ ~ '5I1UiIWon ~'?jf'ifilJj ~dI~~ \!l 1 ~~~ lfCOif COiJi1i~ '\5ftm

W9f~f<li <i'i1~ 'fUl

~0!1 '5T'i~ m,€5j\!i fitq>$ C'4'f"f

~iit~

C\!iTIt ~
'@~

mI

~l~1t~

~~?f

~U

~n"1ii1l~,

~<1'"11?

~fgr",-fo1'1i-f"ri'n-~"fo1"tf ~Wilnr ~
mll-~9f~-

~it;i'e

~t\5
~C\5·~.
'lji~'!~

..~, ~,
~~i[i{,

'5Jtr.R

l:~

~w ~

~,

mI
T1I

~w <Ii@O'l f'S
~rtlWI;r<~,
iillt~, ~,
I'"

f.T~~ ~t~
~~
'5Pfj

'5f!t~<rrn ~

~Oif

~"t<ftIft

~"t<ffff
~iIf

~mm
I

~~"'M

f<f<rn9~ '5~t~tf'lJ" !ilmon I ~'l1f~~ ~ ~O{<{ir.If~ C1.f ~~~'i ~, ~ Ci1"r~ ~t'ti~ ~c~1 <li~'!i ~Oif I 15ft"5!1""f~ c<1''f''1" f"tf~f~."

mf'~r;Oj-m'8~~ <mtt~ "'li~~

~~-!!tf~~P.r
~r~t~ '1~<li

f;{f1r~ ~~

C~
I \!l

'f1 ~ot

"'t.~ ~ f<'fi: ~~

<nt<t11l"11 '1!i·ll ,,~t<lr'1~ 11fttb~ If·I'

C"t~

1·11 f.~~ tr.~ 'f<1t"

'1 r

fu~1{r.=t .!If\!i~tfil<f f.lur~., "n~ ~~ ~ (.~ "t~f~ "~<i'iAA~ ~ f~'lH:9

~an

I ~'t?r
I

li;t"'41111111~t

1\

<'ftC'91 -'11'1ItOlI j<lttlt{W.t Jjc"f ~ 11i"1'~tf~ f~"'f1 "t":lif', ~f'l,;q lv'. II I '~JI<q wtwt~ \?Jw~ (.1i9 f"1l t Utl ~ I II/ M~

CIr~ - ·'ftW ~]f~trll1j,

f~"
~

~l(;pJ;t'f ~~

~~"a1'" Ii<1 fu.t 'Jft~rn Sifto;q '5fA"~ tR \i~ or~ {~ .. 2f f<f ~ 1 f~ lftt'I r It,~ ~twt-iJ1~r~ f1tf_tll ~t!l;~ 'etWi I e1'lf\!} <li~1f~ 6,ij'Ci I ~~ ~1~~ Cit~ ~~ti!Cifi ~ ~ flffi{t1 ~~ ~<{ I
}fl'
if11

~
~

~if

~tl: ~~ ~I'~"fir

'{c\!i1 l.ltl' ~~ ~!

ltiftt~ ~~ itt9rH \iriifittq ~'\!) !(t~4t~ 1ft· ~ f; ~,~ ~~ i f~itTu1~1~ fifirt~~ \!it~' ~tSl ~N (ijf I ~'if\it1 t~WI ~ ~tif ~m, ~1~Qr~ ~~ <nritnI ~m <t1fWt~ I ~t~Ql'6 _ i-.
~'i1~ ~t.i1~ ~

r••

c~1
~

G~t'!

QT

fijo'll tCJI ~9

Pff~~,~ ~il1111 ~m

D'ti-C9Ql'ftm

'f:~¥
C~

<ti",~f~ur~~ m.~
~
LQif ~ ~.,~

~~ ~~

( Design )~~ De-sign

1 l!I,~~dI~~~ ~

~!1ii{

f&'.1

~~
I

~~~'51

--r~~~~ f~iI1f~~f<rn; ~~1 ~, ~~~, ~tiilt. ~~~.~fit;~~ ~ ~ fVf~ 'Sf\i'flter ? 'f\!'i"ICif~ synchronic ~~'1i{ ~t~ ~l~tiff fi- C1ft~ r ~~vni ~ ~ ~m~ ~~li~~, ~~~ ~"\!i~k~ ~ I~t1Wii ~~f1~\lJ ~'tJ ~j~'l WiD - f-r ~~ tttf~ ..r11t~j~it~~.~~ ifl~ '~-~ii'5 .. ~! ~ ~~~ If'!\?{Pl ~~ ~i J!'l~~ if~i"\ I ~t~nr~' ~"(iRtif ~f\i~~ ~tlf 11fti ~tf~ ~1J..~ ~ f"if~(l~ i{ittlt'!) cmrflft.~1 I \!l~ ~f~#l{j lI'l\"!)t§ ~ tt.<fl fi\'it~ ~flt'1;r l2f~~<J ~~i1qti{ ~~f\!> I ~afi ~ lic;rSl Pff~~f~ fitf~(~\!'(f\!iIjli'-r.!RI:

~1l;\!,
~

l.!I~tm~ ~
C'f

~~~

'Am~4;nnctffitS ,~rn ~~f~-J

-'.~ ~~ f~
~, C\!j,W;;
)-~~ I

Q1~G{

Ciff~f'\§ ~ I f'ij,!~,
\$~'

C~

7l.~fwfil~

~~f.1i~ '3~~
'~\fJt\j

~~m·,~

~(f,'f
~11
\S

\!l~ ~ii

~~'ffI!1f~

i\If!; ~ifi1 ~~
understanding (t'fro1
if~ ~ Ir
tQ~

C(t~fif~ffl~
~-~ifttif

ee~~ ~ ~~nt
~~?f

flf~ ~f'Emli~
~ii~~>i.
~~ ~

(perception

~te
".f~~

it'!; Glfmvr1!
~~,
~~

If-.fu-r~iiff ~~~
'iJ~1 ~
cift~

~~JJI'~
I

~f-1m ~'@~tt'f

~~~~

~~~

(Essence) ( Existence ) ~
f~~j't~
~]VE

~a

m-~\\lf1~~ ~~ ',r.~i '6(.~

~~ C~~ ~~~

.t~~

~"fl1ififtt1f

~fm~ Rf~itr.":rlt~ ~~1f9fti ~

~i{""~
~~

f.f

·tt~J :rt~~'1

~nr

'1l"TIltlKT ~~~~

~toi ~~

~f~t~
t~rtif
I

.:ni~qttf, ~mtil'1t~~iI ~t~,

~1~~n~~~ mWif~ ~
~~ 1t~-~~
'l1 \¥~~Nif~,
(

~,.t'

Nit;

~,"~~~'11f
'tJ~~~~~

-M1{tct~
~t ,

~fu- ~"'1

fitf\ijft"j1, ~~J~~ ;rr;n ~1

ijf®~~1,

~r~t~ fifC"
If.

,[ ~'!RJH~

~~~

tim

tcft

4~!t!t1:milf ~ ffi~if<rtlf

GIR'fIJftlf 'WifJt"ltu1~/~· ~

firwm~ ~1ftr!1:~~'lji'l'~i
~Ci1l'lq
~ ~~. 0R

'!f'tl;:i, ~~~

~r.~

I ) tlI1f~ ;rt;r1 ~,€'if'o$'{mlf C~

"tt'R!i~
'V'i1' 0'1'<1
I

~CifJ
~~"If~

I.!l.~ <!I~

;rcJti91

<ut1fm ~~-~~"Ifafl!!
~'lfl'i

n'li I fW't

«MOl ~i'i'J ~

<!I<j,

~9i\!i;'

\!{j"~

COififi~wn~t\l

L~HI'9f'JJ ~tflT

f<fii{1 <fim~ ~?

fl\iiif-.ITii"'ttiil$. 'l~9 filllll.,

~1'tf~<f'i5tA" w-Ji~.? ~~ tlI~ "Jf1;Qj''9~lf11i ~f~~ lfDil1'~ f~t~ ;rn I f<fi <fl:~ ~~. CTft~, aft<f1 <rI ~n-( ~ ~~tif c"~J~~flfi{ (.'<tC~ ~'ij~~~nrt r <.!I<ll~ <uf'fl"!!(J ~r<fi eWes f~ "HI" l'm~ "'t~fu- '!il"~ Clff~ flrt.11~ ~ 'e ~ I '!fR"IfQ.{t6Cii1'il If<t~~ ~"1 f~ ~Rt'!r -s ~1~;rfrnl: ~T~9~ ffim ~ i{f~ COfI;r!"W
tlI ~!;Ol1f

~<ftcar

~m~

~,

f~~\'1~ ~<!", <i'J~'Si lT1"\i 'l1~ "<ffiIfi: I f<1>~ f<1;-~ '!81 fit, ~t\!i 'ttBr "11 I

~l-~lf~
<!I'3Wt~ ~Cl-

~rw '5f~ 'llrtlltc'ii -$ '.'if ~~N

~u ffl'l.:"t c>lflt

~"', 00

"rJI Or C<lOl

°lt~
I

~9f11I c~

r:;<1\"Rflr;r '\'l'ttifil' ~~

tim
I

~~

~
I

<ffi;(.
~Cij[

ii'ft<l>Rr ~G'!i

C"fr.m'(; ~

mot'.'!

UIC\el

m 1t'6f Thi'll.' '<Itil111

oTtf~ 'Wi
~~
~

'~TlTtq!i

m~ ~~
~

\!1~

~'ftlT't

M~
~
I ~~<t

~
~\!i

mi ~
~Qf

~<1i

15ari:~". " .. _ [ <.!I~ C«i~

"Iinr

~:JR

ofNifi
..

@fiI"f

"f~

if"f.mll'hi

@-;smfu1't~ ~~
~ I

~t1l-iftm~
I1fitf ~
I

I
\!{j"~

m~oftf'!l {f'&"I'ti{-~1f~
I eli

m~"ttf1S

C'l1 ~J1"1 <!It'J'itt;Z\!1<fi'

OHr I

I mtJil';;m~
I)l~ ~~

@It ~

CO'f~ ~ "I\~'"

C~~

'lfnt I mf\fC<l'i :2f5'~

~ ~~

'Oftm

~~.,~

If~

~Jtcj

~ f<1'i't

L.!I~

~~fBltffi,
~i{

~'AII

that is solid melts -into the air -..... "

tlI!i'~ ~

~
~l1"'"ll~

~f~OifO\

l1tr<i ""Ill
(<flO{

O\6iMlrn ~"lt1 ~ ~tro1 01~~ ~ ~ <!Iif" m"ffllr him <fI1I"'!Ift-11 I I ~\f.J~ ~~;r L!I'Ut"'ttCSf ~t1:&1l ~" !

~1<If~ ni

~;fl~

<fm;jf ~

~Y'-!l

.JI~ C"Iit""l 'G1iil;"J( \fI':r 0\1 I

~J

Clft-r

C<II1'i{

Of~

t1Ill'"l{ ~

Caf"<l1-'Wj-c"ftifl'1:'i ~ i11!

~t~

faj~~ ~ ~~ ii'ft~C;f{ ~Qf\Sf¢f

-n :

lft-ffil1' ~~
'1f«rn ~~

fQfC~c~;r-~~
.~, ':tj\5J

1'~ fm c<ifi"r;r 11I;;f 'l1\SJ or"!' ~~1t1! tlI'f' C1f"f'~t1I<I" ~.§Jw.'Jf tlIf.1f (,11"1 ~~fI!)t~ ~~t~t~lti1 I .,~ 'I"b<!l' = ~"-li1![!iJ1)109I!{' f'tiMr-"'f<!jlf~ -'6!iC<ljN,hri1
~:Jj i!f

r..,~
..!I~

w~"rt"l"=~~tif= ~tSJ: M"Ifl-r.~

~Mmt;r~l1fi=~~"1'
<rQ'!

~Jt'fTr

~rrf'f

~ .,~
I

~c~f&" ~mR=
__c;:

'!i\"'!2<\i'2!~'iP,['>!>fl'{ =

~<r.I" 'E. '~C1fr~ f~co\"1 I "'tM. f~if '~'\!i1' '!-t'1f~ c9 "${'>!>ftlnI ~~<11;"I~ ~~~L.!l<l o;r,;d;'1,.'~ ift'6 ~ ~ <1r'lil~ I - 11"\!i'lltfif '1tC'\'l'l ~\ <liffl- "!{t<fM mM <.ft7;'1~It"l I " ~~c!l~ ~fitrn ~CP:iiil '6~ f;{~ 'if~ '!ilj' ~ ~<rn1~1~~. f.rn~.rtf~ L.!J~1 fii'ff~ ~"'t ~~ !!I<r-. ~falf~ fO\~ ffii:iI, 't·f~iI CSttGl" 'J!~~l'ft\'l"~~~~~~G1:tQ{ .. , ••. I (<!Sif <!I\5fC<j" ff'~

~t!f~ RmtC'l'\'\' ~Il!'l{

f1't: ~

fo1~"'I1i!

'ftii9

~tf"f c~1Jtci1"

f~~
~

~$[

~~ll"<1It<'R't@

-~
~'5 ~~

c<fi.,
<!I<1it"M

~cm~
if!
I

'ift~ifl ~"IT.i'I

if"l1i1:lJ-'~ut'll~~'~~
(AOifj ~<S~~

t1I~

~ ~<ftif "'tnHA<n <!1'lfttol 1§"t<:tTr."f-J "'ttcr.m-~C\!i <!I'1"tr.~itj ~ti@l5""'11<1st~ WC$[~~'~Ol ~~; 1!i'f,~1'!:l" tlIt<p<f~

(mi om! )1!.ji.~' 01"11~

~~
~(1;\!i ~

·V

'~.'
~
~\!j

"'tf<rC'<i~~
~ <!SGl ~~ c~'!'

1fit~ «fi~

cl5f~
<.!l<1iG'1

(,<r-~oTt 'VI?f~if1 Ol~~ c\Sf~i:if "'tt~ c\'!!j'JJ 5ifo<f~~ lfi~~ I ~ li'SJ m"t <!I"f"{$ ?{« <l"0if;.r ~1 f tlI~;rt~ 'ftCi1 <!I'6f~~ 'trr"ti'l 1'tf~ ~~ ~m<!> 5f'ffil f~~l!I?f \S~st <f~ I ~r'S"j" ~tf'1Uff!>i~~ '('}~ 'itfu ~ Sli!nr ~t..,~'!Iftfif '19i{i:~ '1'tf6.?i ~~t!:Trn
Of'lrtiPfll ~

'*"

"p.~ L.!I~
L.!lCR

\!t~ f <;rf~OfI~"'IiJ~f'ilh~~~i ~rtfir C~" 'Pftrn ~ 7 f.t;~-~ '1t<fiW "I"!l'J!1 (_";j~ ~\!jl "'t"!l~ ~ I ~.\5f1{"If'fJ c~fiI ~~
O{~m"ll~
~~

1f11l".

~m ~iI
~

i"f~"ifVJf~!Jf

f'Bitt

~m~
'~

~~9f_~

m~

( ~l'{~lOl'1JJ ~"If~)
~ ~ ffi'Sf~iI

<!Ill ~

l1f'ff~

~f'W'!i~ ~
~

I" L.!l~mti ~itill

'!l(t~iI ~

I'

C~ fQf'i(i<\i c~i1t?f '<lfW "'11~ "'t~~ D~ I tlI~ c~ 1itc~~em, '5t~ ca<r<ft!i, lfhf 'fi<r1<r'Qi ~f~ 't'!Ifii~,---(!l' fWOl1W~ol I!iftCst c<fii<IItcwt~ ~ <!I'f ;rtlOf~ ~l'lft~r~~ <tit~ C<f~ I ~<f '!frn f~ om, Oi~ ~tlij"f~ '1?r~tfq'~1 'Wtr.W1: c~r>,f~t1' 'It!f1~ <ftt'lJRf ~i ~~ m-<!Ill ~
'j_0if'i' Pl\;i5f<it'l1 «<':\'1 'l1N~ <RrC"ii C5G1f~

~
~
~

~fi mff
-aci .

C'5t\ <fifif~
~

~t~tl'-rn

lffl'!l:

~ ~c1j-f~~ ~

~'f$' 1j~ lftfitau ~!Jfl'*1~Wf <!':I?;Jlt~ I 'li~ ·":11'1<11" l51'<iif.<rn 414t"frf"f

~iI

"11 I

~1f ~~

~~ I L.!I<li&'1

ifCit'Sim~, o:mI"~~"n

~~"

m '<~ ,,!'{Ii'
·I~
I

-rt!~:1~N
'"I1r."1

"*"l'I

'l'illC!, f:Jjcqj<{Pj WI

0,

.. , ...

"Ip'/,~
~ ~$i{ii

'8

Wi~Hf.ft~11f

C~,

~Wol' ~

'!Ilt~1"\1 ~

i)f<f1 ~

~tt::f[ \

1'f~t~T ~II"I

c<li'B ~~

'tlfir

~m
f~,
~~

;nm, ~~
I

1'f~ <fifI <fi'i!i<f.c~ ~r;!!!!t Q "l1f~ ~~~~ ~1 till~t~ <.!l~ lfif<l't~: i'rt17, Mmtftii. 1tm:"ti{~ ","Y(. tit
Ii.

~~~~~T" fu~
~~~

't~ljtm~ ~-'B

m~~nr~~"It(:j1hT/'I~
~'i!!i~
~,,,!>~¢if ~~

~'I!l'

m if!

,«Iii1'

litfu e, m~... I
~'iI

11~

f\s , ~iflilj1~'Sif
~.~

~.

'6mf~ ,1l.f"f~,~m1{ it-mr. f1'f.

~~'i!i
fij'[~ ~ ~

flY.

'!Iltf~ f;ff~
through ~

~~:

f~
c<fii{ ~

I 0l ~

'i5Kirt O'ftt~ ~

~t-1t'lN, ~"l~ fIf"f1 "~~t<ll c~ ~" d:~ I (,~"i~ tlIi{m"l!f ~t-1"W, ~ f~l1;j'Sl\!i1 ~'lf v.rt~t!t CD'tj ifl I Qlii{ ~ t'l{l\"l' fi11l't-1tow ~iI'f '1l1l'? ~ <!I~ ~t'l$l' ~~ni1 ~ ~ I "i{~'ll ~tPf ~ ~t'1 ~~r;~ ~~ <tlf$1;, f~~ ~. ,~ c~· ~<t>1 <.!l"1l1! '!ft~ ~~ fO'f~, '5ft~ 0"I~"f'I!l'1 C"ttil~ ~~

~m

~lfI->l\tfIil-"f!Ir lI!~reg[et ~9:

t:l{

letter ~-rejection ~ C~ -.n 1;1 "'~

I

"!f\!ic!l~.

"{'i5J1iI-

~~

<5tC~ ij'[t~1~

~\;t
~
<.!l'R

-.n

<.!l~

<rN1
~

~r;~ ~1f'"(\!i ~-expectation

-p.tf~
"5j"tPf
~
~ij'[

I ~~ f
'1'J'i5J' ~~ ~SI ~-~

~~~f~ ~ ~:

~lft~

~~

C5~ flf~.,<>to{ ~tlftfWi, ~m M ~ C~iJj ~ii11"ltf~1 COl~-~'i CIl'i( ~ f~ ... i'i!iAA 'i{1 ~ c~ ~fi! 'EI~n f<Ri. 'l5{t'lfRl ~

c~~-c<litiI

c<fiti\"

Loss of self

Job apathy ...

0fC'i f<'lli11 .. '

f<f ~

I~
f\!i~~~~~ ... ~f<rnt'!!! ~~ <.!l'lfOl' <!I'f 'Sl.'i CIfi{, ~1 <.!l~ ~ f"i!i~ '8 '!ft~'!j<Oif!lllfC~\§ c~ ~ ~ f..'\5l ~'!itf~ 'lftt:or instant ~ on! I
~~ '8~

c!I~ ~"iWIHt

Ol ~~i{

~1(

~fi ~f~ ~ ffl

oJ!~ ~

~~1~tC"lt'iltQ ~

~~

~<fl\ltifl~

f.rnt'1'8i

ortf~,Post-modern r ffl, 1!{1f1(. 'l5{tlft~ ~fl?§i'f'i!i ~om ~w f~

~" ~, ~ <ref, ~
~!:If~

f.w.I- <.!l'f ~~"l 'e fif~C\!i ~1f~ ~ ''''' c'ff1t 1

<fit~ '1tiff~ if!--.iI~i{"

'5Itf1l"

,,~t\!i
f

~Jf&~

r<f <!:m;q'i{<.!l~"

;n, ~~~~~~ f<:li CO'f~tt~ ~1 1ffi1 f

1H(~ "{tlft~ modern-condition
L'fi{

l{t<:5\
I

CO'f~~r1;i '8~.;rn

~1

118itfil
~~

I!ftf'lf C'lI ~
~~

fi>I~"i!i ~~
~~"'ft\!i'M <ttIf

'Ili"lffi ~fir ",f<i, \!i1~ ~i1 lj1'eVhf f'l"di, "IWot~ Q1 fm ... f.\1;~ <m!~-~ ~, Ql ~ 'i{1, ~f~t~ f~t.I'e Q1 ~~9 <m1 O{l I ~ '8

f~-<.!l~ "I~

C'{

'Ut"t'V ~

~ flffu ~~, ~~~

~Mif ~~
<.!Ill"{ ~CO'f ~lftll

~Jt<t; Of! -.:roI" ~~1 ~, fu~ ~~ I!frnl' C'{ ~~ ~t~ ~~, ;).. C'i9f~O'f ~ m. ~.... !if~!l C O'ft@l! ~<ftm lltl{l;O{ ",,'!iJ 'R~.-~t\"fl f<jS I."lftlft~ ~1 '~' I~ "'I~ 1 ~

~~~

<iS~

<.!l ~1'fr;<f

.~~

~.

~m <.!I~
R"I'lf
~

C<fol

1
~ :

~11rI '~:f['i5J'

'if~~' ~~~
f"lf1l~
12f~'!f
~t

~n('-\5hf\ f<wIti{" ~
f<iS 15ft~ ~~

'ill I f~mtil ~t~

(l5f~~
~~

~" ~
<{li~

c~~t"'l'W\ m '! "l'tf'T' Cij'[~~ f~ ~t-1 <ttlf T ~ ~ 'f1't~ f'I'fClJ, "!'fff'i!i"~ If'1l CIiU<\J~ "ttJ f;.n;~ m I ~1~lr;lf~ ~t;,f~ rPf~~ ~<t~'!f ,~f.{C~lifC~ I 'I.'~!) I ,\!,Qltf'1lf~ C~ '~'~ f~~ ~ ~ ~~9 Jft~ ~tj!{ '!>{1"'rt1l ~C)j qa'·'II.~'Oj·1f\ ~tI (~"f'lft~ ''l!ft\t' ~ I ) I ~ Cil~ r ~ 1ft'Sl1 f'1l 'lj.,t" ~t~l' ~ (.IWrl'l' al~1. iftf.. C~ '~' r \!;rn fDll ~tc'iI'(l C'5l C61~1 ~l\; I ~~1 f'1l !J(1)ltc~~ ~t~~f'i!~G<if~~
~~'!{e

Wb

f~ tSl'lfi{"<.!I'f

I ~mtco{::l <.!l~ ~i$~"f~

'S"'rn

~"(1

<~~<fai!'~'

COif~

~<\iIJlif\

~1c.1o
~,(.)f

lit E1 llCi{, 11t '~'€"

J

iI'Y,

'15{~

oJ! if11;r;"

"I~~ ?

~!Jf'&~R~j1(
f~t"l-yf~
~~~

'1,*itf~iS ,~~
~t~
\!i~

~!fl l)tfiif~ ~M~<f[hI

C'i!ii
~$1

<fC\1 '!it!lte

'<1i~ I~
'!{fIfPJ

'<5tf~~1f i\"tC5" 'fTIl t~1lJf~ f~f.ff, fO{~~m~" "tf'taf!

'5It{0{<ti~ ~ ~

OM-c~f<I; '!it~Olf

c.«...

'1t~~
~.

COl~I

~f.roI~ <.!l~~ ~~1 '{'l1.

(~

I~)

il!fhi~1f~ ~ f~~i{
<R1f I

rnO{~mlQlw

Q{ (.If?:''I1r ~

1 lIlf~1; <tr~ ~~

~~? ~t\, 1\TIf<i"iT~ r 'S!'i~

f~

"~iSrt' ~"

c.-q

<.!I" 'l~f~-<.!l~

'l0if~

c·t~11TN-f"ff~1i 'l5ftf1f C5a;t-e ~M: "c<tll

fi{"~
~cif'~
Cij{~'~~t!l.

~
'llti\"

~m om '<i1'tf'!i'
a1'rt' '1;,"1:

m~

~!i
~

~
I

~CJj

Oft "'if ~'tt~.

~ "'~

~~IR'~ f.ti ~ c~t~'-'f oJ!~ fO{f"f~1t ....

fi " ~~~

~m

'<'RI <mT1 'iii'

Wi ~

'If.. fit'Qi (Jf~'

'9J:r

0l~!;"l'~

1ft(jO{

'~t<rll', '\5ltt'f ~.

b-·L~l
f~ ~~
'!ff'*1~fOif II'

'&

~~<l;t'ff

m~lf

~n9ft'llt'.i/l7~

?-'.,-~ 'fW"fEl;C~

~~~f~.,. c~ ~(~ ...~fSf ett~m<rt~· f~ '~

~,

'lif~m ~

'511 c~t;{, ~~ar \!tar

I

l_~

C\!lt'lt?f ~i,<l

~MG.
llt~,
~~

IPt'llii~'! ~!1fru '!i{t~= ~s:

<J1t~~~~

~ ~fir ~ti1~ ~ .. ~ <{ifl(1 ~; ~r.w, ~ cm"f Art ~<i!1 ~fSf I 'i!!{l;1J1.i1 c~tcOf f;WSlCW ~"Mt"R ~ ~r!)i{1 ~ "~1i '51"'11 m, ~"'i1(e"lC~!~ C~lf '!I.!lI'1l' utteraqce-@, ~~~~ statement ~

<C,~
"l.\t'@.ft~

\Sf;lji~3'~$ I ~ 9f~'Iij"'!, ~
~tt{l, ~tl;"tS>ft?f
~l{~

~~

<rt91!

'!{f~,

~t~~ lTtf1ft c~-.j1 :\!ffCli, ,(";~ '!i{f'f'!ft~ <Il"~1 ~1 "11 I '11~~ ~~

'<U9r' ~1

'll't~!

m~,

'i5t!T '~ifj ~~,~

,~,
I

Gtrem;; ~
(ja'f~~

-ad

~H:<fr ~

f~~~i c~

"fi'tot, ~fu,\!i~ ~€m~ ~~ I (;1f <>tf$t;\!i'l1 '~ .. tw '1111' il'1 I ~~ U;~ f'Fli$1~ fir; ~~ ~f<N!~ ~~ iItf'f ("<fi].{ ~~~~. c<fiItmt(iti1 I!I~ ~
'iSir.<jl", 'l!til" '$'
~'8

tfil'tR I!fW

~if~

~ ~~ ~~ (~1fq ~~?) <f~-~~-"-1-"I1m

fIfi~ ~N~ ~m~, f'il.t~~

1ffir ~~~
i

'"61t1! ~~

~t

~t1l ~ f~fu, ~~ ,~e,t1ff'JW~1 l1:l1r 1it"t11tv;l I ~mt"Of ~~ ~t~·~ ~ I ~~ ~l{ ~~ 1fl~ ~~ ~~ 1 f.nm"Of, ~ lla(C~ "<li~1~ R~'ili ~ ~~ ~ ~. ~I<l,~ "'Sflf"ll 'Q'," I .!l~ ~~ ~~ ~<fOIi ~d; f~ I f~ fit~ \!{t1lt~ need, demand-a '1ft~~, dem~n!J ~<if~ ~~ De~jJ;e-~! ~
I

""ijrll1!!ft~~1 I -~t~ f~1'''""

~tljJ~.fllfl,l~

fm

<!l~

f\!';i

~t_~

Gstt~

~~5f1 ~

C1iI

I!I

fi~ lftil9 'mI-'S"~ ~ ~ ~~,f~~~

oJI~ GI ~

~tfJ

ffiif fifO.{
~ ~~

fl'ft"Q 11tJi1'~<1( {l1~*i'{ r;'I.('~:srt '!i{t~C~, \;~tf?j\!l~t~ -u'1 ~ !

C"'illtl ~ ~I ~ ~,~

~~~

f.i-rit4i'

1 fjj~'<IJ

~tm '-'1" m1\~T

~'<tt'l<l!~tOf!
\lg:g

"tt,~

~~ ~";{~ 'R~... Qlts oJlt0if1 G<ft~ ~~ I 'O{1lft~ COifm ~

I

'!5{tc~ f~

~,

f~ f~

f~:I('1~
I

fSfJt1 ~_~FlAFJ.9
9~ ~

c1ffirn,

mm.!Jl_m
f~

~J!li~

~m

~\!ifi:

(O{~

~,<m"f<i'fqiJ1 ~~. tm-Cli I!ft~... I

~tfw w~111

~I

:Jj~Qft<>f I

W!Ifhr. ~f~~

l5ft~tm1R'

mJI ($'1" I

c'( ~~{"'liR

f~

fow:r"f'
~1:~

<Rtf,

l!!Tt~
~<JI

1~~ S'f9,f'J ~

~11f..f
G~I

o-nbs ~

Dt<>t1 ~

lim, ~
~~t~~~
C~ I

ot'11 ~
lfot

~ -"(~~

lft~, '!ffflr ~Qft<>f COl"

~1

~m~(~~~OO7
m~t!t"lfV"li-n
~f'!'i1r:~ '1f1(W1fiji

~~hl1

N~~ o:r1. ~ ~
~'f1
W~~.

<If.,.

lS~t\5

~mc"M

~f~~$f fTtr",· ~
<!I<f1ttff1

~~(~11l
~

~~~tJfI
~<j"

~jfi-~~

mwrt<>f(3

~art<>f~tiI1

st~

11t~

~fDil"~

:Jj~~

~J'Nj

R~ llr.~ "ft~. ~

\!iftmii

i~ 1m,

~"if <ffil onI oJIW

~fi\" Clf~
~'1 ~~

, ,~neer1. f~ G~<\,i>fhI, 'eij'~ ~t~1 (,:I']'~r:i7l'1 9ffi'f\5 ~ ~emall~-'¢ Dcmand-.!l ~~ \l!l't~t"11~ '<f1t~1 Desire ] '!ftf1! ~ ~:iI' I ~tm~ Desil'e~~~ '!ftf"lf,~l1" ~ ~~C5f\f mr;rrft 'ft1:W ,C~1>j"f"lf-"lf1 <rim <m. ,~ ~~- ~artlf I 3"ff*~ ~<fi COi~. "Ir~ ~nr "lftfi: 01~ I lf1 c'f1 1!1~ ~
I~
1
Q{

11~'J1t1 "'lr.ll b1"'~ "{Ilftr.~it mf;{ Of'Ej'.lnf ,{;Dg1~ ~ 7 ~~ ~i'I" ~j=~~ Ift~ Io"!l.· f"lt~ ;11 I ~r"1 ~ iJ1 f~~'flfl~ ~ ~~MJrI
'trr.qj f "(If:or ~ II II
II

II

I!l~

r~ ~Jt'1~t~l ' 'I' ~I

I
t

~~?

HrlM"l

i;!tf'f<li~ ~

<!l~

~C~

~ft ~

<!ftnr~,

~~_,

~I~t
I~lijlj~:

1,

~tcq1~ ~~ IJlOO-~ !fffI I ~ "WIn ~~?i t (~~ Cl{O'I \Sf.,., ~ ~ -~tf* <rt~ ~~ ~ ~~ '1CQf i:s~ "~ 'ft1:Qi\ 1lIGifi1 :I(~ . ,") -.n-C'f '~Pfhr ~f~ f-:t~ <mf! I ~~

t; ~jC<f1

I~ It.:.> '11:i{.~1 "111

IIf1ltl1

n~

r~.
?

"I~

~\!t~tarI ~~i~

~<ftmW

~~

~~
I

~",1

~~

~tI¥l ~·I
<!l~
~

'(1

fiJ=f.~
~~7

CO{

"lf1 I ~l\TIi

~ ~ ,'S\!j~, ClPml ~

'!ffml ~1{ ~~"lf1, c"(i;:t-e 'lP1-~ ~ ems!) !)~~

f~.

~m!ii-~
, "l~f'f
c~~

~srn1

f~Of~ ~

f~·,·

I "f'tij1ilGl~~.

roforn 1Wtr ...

lJ~ ~

It ~1. 1111 5t~'fbl~~{t" 1.!l"<1l" r.'I:j~" ·1.1~1:1I '~I ~11r. <Ill! "'I1,Iil1'1!! ' 1I:'Hlj"N\ '111 1'1 '1 j ~) iii I "J 1 II ·11, ~ I"I~ '1i!lm- ~ j I <:T~1 :lJ1 !~t'lli'l'i 11·1,t~,(:"Ir~ ~C1' It~ I.ljc. I I, ')I'Il (,tlIC",~ ~1 ~1"ll'~s1 ?(r.~ PI/ 'I l!I~I'\ fiftll "11 '~l ~l!r~"J~ ~I '\\1 I ~(q (1111' tR'ff'1 I '!1i't '(;"I~ ~(j 1 (,\!II)I [, ~t~G1f ~ "11~11... ~!, '~"'C:Jji:tl~f"t:lflc~:l
I

C<1I~r.1li1 li!llfi

17~/~~1f
~51t(~' ~rn
~tD"f\_J

'!.?'~~iffi'f I
I

~fiI~titt~
~"'

~tI~c1!f~l

~
Jj

ifelt"loffl ~liS<fRI:~

I!f~llJ. 'fltlftfGFJ

"lftij~~

~m!l~~<f

-uf~~.I!l~

l ~~

flrb: ~

CIRt~fj''flf
~~~o;

<U:iij':n<ir1rrn/"'"~', . ,
I

~1~~fVBi{fif
~~'~

~'11 I

~t9ft~

~~)j

'<l~ I

:#jtf~~~~l

~~ ~~

,'~~"bli:1lf~!$i!{

·"lt~'.:.:~nOf~'iJ ~'t ~~ ~'S{ j I ~t"i-:'0 ~if<!iW~l ,!,(~~'if I !!I~lJr;t ~ ~~ I "Hf*' ""'<ft<rtIij'@~1tW '<a~ '5t1ft~tffl <fI;~ fil~ I "I'i\ II QilT11 ft~ ,~~ ~ y , ~-~~<ni;n,*

or~ off~
"

fw \
;Jrt~l

'5ltf~ II '~OR Cl!'~I~ ii~!( ~f'!)~!l' 'Olt'<ftOf ~~M'<F \IofV1fi'1: f~ ""l~~N:fj!.,"~ 1'j1f~ AA, wtl:w m'l1f'!), c<l5l'<l COTt~~~ >rn1"'ft:~"fll "~;
"i[~i

'1'lnr;O, ~If-(I;., ~~,~~ -'([~

<{~'ij"j {I'A-~t~1 ~~~

~
~\11 wtct<f

~~~"t!OI;r;'IIlI'

Ptr-~···"t~ f<'1f~Q[ttl
I'

~~1',"~

'f~R
"!Pfi.t~

M:~f[~~ ~
<iIi~m'[;l

JJ1W

*~l!t '<iiit~/w:Sf§
,I

if! I ~'<Il) :.rf~ ffC<jl~if

~"

!i5r~
'CiI~

~Ifllil ~
,~tW;

~r~.,\
I I

Qli'

~, ~

f~~

~lf~
4th
~~

~)I i$ffltlJ~

cmi1~ ~~$
llWiMm ~
'5fI~ ~'\!i'

~~'!t'

~~1

t2f~~R

r~t"Q1rn

~~i

C1It~ (Jl'6~i C~5{ l(i ~ ( ~~

~'\

td

~ I 'J; -n~r\!i~
~ ') L!l'

c~~ <mr iftf~ ~ .., 'l'1l' ~ ~ f.I' mil ~ m ~~ wrn ~,

~~<?(

".ijl~ -~~

<Jl~ ~

,,<Sf

f~

iiftfii'i!i~t'lJ~ "11 isftt~ ~~, ~h'l -r\ ~

II

't~t~itfis\ ~I

%:{;'qi, ~'

J I Ofif~ wtlI @~~~1~ ~~ ~~ 'cr l:itw~:. ~1 ,c.,~~ f<l> ~,~ ~,1 ~l 'mf~;r~ '~"I <>Mir~~w1,,<!l1ftt1 "JfiTo:rtflf ~~~'~ ;(j>A'~ 1."f1f ~(;V mr.~ '!J1 r ~~~ ~ c<n1.. @~~~ f<f ~ ~fw Q,lft<!t? ~ ~,!'1 fl;;~"1, <ftfm~ m~t'W 1$~ ~~~~r .r.~ ~m ~~ 'atHt m~~ ~~~ "''II''! ~~S!f.1fi$ Qom'~ ~ t f,~.,«~,i;?:f ~ ~

~'1>11r

~ II, \!i~

1ftvf, t1r'1<JOft-lDif

f~,~,-~C'W

,c~ ~

'f{~<i{:~

'

<f11\t «<iij~, C!tf~fC!'Wo1:,.~, 1{~ (';'i:\" "dpe;nended textual r:reepla'Y~- ?itaHt 'i'f~ 'P!;l ~1 ~~ '~D1i:-1iFf f~<tI~~ ~t~ ~ ~t'l; ~1~~~;jOj ",!1ft Ciff<nn 'i!'iW1il ~ I' ~r.i{'Fl~ &t~J l!itffl ~~ '1tU' 5!{t:q:«to;'~)
OfTInf1 ,'~ ~~ Qiil:~ ..£l~

'1'tt"h

<fi?tJ ~~.

~iifu

rn

F.!~" ~1I@"f~-~lItr.mt
~

~ttthr~ I:it11 <!l~qr1,t~f~ ~

<!I~ II

I!l~ I!{r{f~'r.5tc<fi t~ ~"m-~i(f.F;i\!lt~

"rc'.!l

f~'\i'l!ld~~'~rl~'\f~c,([
~t~
~~

I5ftf~ Ii

~"'?:~~,
C~~

'~lf~1
I,

'vttO{

(}f~"'l·,O{'(3~l!{rnf~-fi!filt{~ ~ II I!l~if fllifirn ~1 ~~ ~1 ~t1Itlt-di ~tlf ~lfOf ~~

ir;f~ ~

'Pf'rns<.I 1t~ ~'liIC!f~"1Q

~

'af~C:~'{3

;1f13f'ij I

~,~ i[l~'!)j'\!t~

",~nf-v 1,

~W; ~1,

i{r~~tf

"itif f~ l!I~~Of
'<111\'1:

\jj~fm\5

Ol''t~~f;5.!(t~'f ~t~~:a; ~(;ftf~., ~~ -rI (Wm~~

~lT

« 'VJWf'

I~.~ r'ii~,~
'{3.,

·~mt~· ~ '1~f~~~t'R1'~.
Ifolf·

Ct;(;i\ '! ", ~.fl~ift'<l'·c!1."IfR"{ ~~1

'!lftm

6"il~, r

~fit ~~

"!ti[' 1I""'lr;;$'

sri{

~1 ~Ftf;<f;rl,
~tC\!l

~r ~ m~1
~tlf,CW
~ II

II

~!ll·Of ~~

''$fI'f~J~

cqlil' ~. :rJtW ~\~

~l.g ~
$I~~

~m

Of~

~,
II f1 ~~~

~'R1 II
~~t~
~I
~ II

'tn. ~~~t"'iil'
%:{~ ~

t~(~mi ' ~

'lj1f~~~~ ~'BI~G6lO{ if! 1

-sW!.w ~

'~.~'1 !
Ot~ .t1~.;;

~'"1l ~J:f~

~~of

wt~ '.tw
(!j'{tSl ~

r~ .. Vw ~
c~t~;~.tIR'

l!ltI:I '#lt~ C'$1 ~ ~~

~'f~i.~1f::r
~
<l;~

~§M"{lI1'<1i~ ~~~

~ <!l~ ~~~

<l;t~ t

i'j~~~C~

-~V{!t ~~ ;!Pf~'ll;1 iUt'"ft:\l ~115ffir ~~~' ffif~J I

f~ -rI,

, 'i\''.i*,

-m
,,~

~'i ~Pm <!I1i'I1 m~"~~'~~~~ (~1\!1~ ~ f~~'lti) f~:{·f~~ ~\!j C)f~. '<llr~m <$ttl$ <1l~f~ <!iii~iWlitt ..f;:n I" ~"tfC'1~ \!ifh( ,-tf~ <lfl'if T!ff'~,~ ~1frn ,:~ffi!l: flB"1.~~~ ~~' m~ ~~nJ m' i ~ "T.<mT (.~ ~'I?Jfu,il <l'f~ ~,;~~m ~"'If~~ <f.~ I ~ i5~\!i' <1ff"1l'Jfil:

<t1f~

m Gl "f~

15f$,

I!)~if; CIIf[Jf 'SfW&tls c{j~~

~'\IJ

~Tf~Of ~11;~!

<'1l~1'

~14~,~1Vf1 ,«1 G~101fC'<1'~ I"

~~~NCW""

"f?J:c<n

m1~1~

<.!l!l~C~[

~'1tlfj ~if

ffl~~ ~ 'm~<tt~w

i~r;lf~,!i:j ~1It!t'(~t!f1 \

'.1;jj~

,~1t~

$51. Ofl,," ~
II

~.;;,:~~ ? ~m'" ~r1,f

~
'Uf~~
15ftir~ ~

~'R<!M 'l!r~~f~l1f-~~ ~~ ~~ f" ~ ~~

c~··~l<wtmf~ ~

<:f~f~ ,I

~1
~I

~.", C'i3~ ;rn I' <Jim~~ 9ji\!:1 f~~ f'!lt~, Cl1~ :<fl<i'iJl!'lffI$Rt~ c~~~~tfOif~~,

f1f,pp.T-~tt<l' "i;[t:Of ~'1ili!\ I C:ij~t~ -1\\ I 1'~1~, ?l1~*" ~~ 1 ,\l II (\f)'fCir~ c!1~
<it'l '.I,' II ~ '1~

~fit§ CffW"'<!l\lli~
"l1f~~.
~1

Ojft~;i'{

~~~-r.r ~tj',

CJI ~~h"~SIW

~:w,,-~~' fio~<w~
f~
~

r~ lR~ mr~~
d
I
'<$1

~~<p"

'S'<)1 ~~

~ 'Ij~"~<j f~~~'\'!!
f~lg~\'t I 1

~1 "

~Ift
'

~1 '5tc'il ~'lU
CETI;~

tile> c~

IGll f ,1Ifl!.l'fI~I'~\1 '{'~1 ~1.·~

<ftal~Jj' ~:W' f~r~qr

'I!fo(-<!iiqf'

~Pl:\IR

18

i,!Io\'~fit1

",n

~<f

CiI"~

1~C1iI' ~C1

. I'!I(~" I

'!5{tP!

II

~<\l~

~~

"1l<t\j1
1

I:!:;~~~ft

'iit~~<r ~

.nh ·~tvl

~t« ~f\!i1f~~~
~~<ft,
t;;~~-'~1offiif'1 *n:r I <l:~ II f<fi

~~

m~tlf Wl1Tt'1lttJI~/v
"1 II Slit I'. 1 I', I t>fr.~CJa
uqr. I

"\1ii~~1'l, ~Jt1>~<t ~~
'!It''f

1lift~Ir.m~1 'Sffil<fi1"

1f~~-~~'3fI0f! ~mr.<fit<j'l"if-crtr.mt ~ 4t~

~

~<{m,

r.~.1
1

~1~-<aft~Jj.{

f.lf~"'~~~.

<;!'j

~lI'-'!ftlIfOf<ll'
(:'l" ~'§<l'i

mar
I

('"'ift~ <.!1r;11 C'If~tr.ti'"I', 'tft~

:fj'i1JJ~ ~,Q1~

'~~~'

<latf1 ~~, \!t!li

~<fi~1 ~1 01'~ ~~ij "A. double articulation GMP/GI-GI/AI/LMP is, for example.v, \. \!iftfll: II '4t"<ll' ~1<f, ~~ ~~ if'i'll1 ~t~ I ~ 15,r\!)r.~ \C'l ~ l~'$(tt;' "'f~ <n ~~r.<N" ~, <n (~ '!{f~ ~ '\!)t!l PI> C<i'~ ~i~J1 1ltnlt~ ~~t'5%f ~ 7 ~otr.<l, <1't~~1 ~f\!) fimI ~'i<p '0flfi0T N~~' ~ 1t1:~Oj, f~ ~\!)~ ~st9 <lim ~y l:!:;,f\!)!'1 cq~~9 ~\!) I f<fi~ f'<P <ut"\t~ <fQI~1, ~~~ 'S ~!-~~ ~ ~t~f<fi ~~ ~"r~-~'ll'

mf.1' <rt<f1;

m"il~ ~ijt5l~

,I ("I'

gri

ff~

c~r:<l> ~toI<P <.!1t'tl'J1' j C:Jj1f or~OT

(·'IIr.itJ~ 1ft~lCt[J <.!1~ <I~m~ 'Ol'll'1"?'6"<fi~

·r.1 '~C~ ~lf
~ C~

11, I!I~
I I

<.!1WI4:~ ~

~~

f~

~c~t~ COT~~-~ ~twfOf!f

il.~

-m'e~1 <rt~, <fiiQ<1' '1f~<loij'<ft:if"~tt"ilfflr"!'!'l" 'Ii~

~~-'5ft'!fiI~Wj ~t'?'4~<lt~
\!lt9 ~lfJ
(,$lt~"<fi

Q <I~t~~
~ -~ 0f'l"f1Q

f~rf~~

~C<r~

f~t;\! f~~ ft~~

'"I~

'Iffoiar ~ ~r~01'f1r
1\ 1f'Wi:"t'ftlf

f~

f1!ii~~t~ f<ri11'C% ~'"tl'{

*I~11Rt~, ~
<!l~ ~~

"Science, Hegemony and Violence

r'

'O{t\m
~

"m\!) <tt~ ?
~ II ~

\!)1 ~'Y,

~-~'nij~

~'i:Of1 ~f1r~

~1. ~<ftt!J;rn.
~t'@!'1 Clfj:(f

~~!

<.!l~1 "'t~iffiCifil ~t~ 'iil<l1l\t~-~1lfl ~ ~\§Q-~!J..f.I~ <\"~<l1C~OT? ~C~lJ~ "The Condition of The Working Class in England (1843 )"'C"!~ ('\ill <.!1Q ~~
,'~ •••

ffl ~f~~tWt ~<t~

1iIi<>t I

'!ftf~II

~Oj~TIf ~ ~,

~;;n<lfir·~"'11 '-!i{tr.~ ~ ~
lPrtCOil~t;'<f

CIf~\!) 1t'Y, \!)t~ca<f ('II; 1 f'<1'

? ~~-

m~~~-c!1~
~r.t;

Of!

<r~~ "It'!lM1 ~<r

~t<r '-!i{~<etiOj<tf'if, ~<rtlf, ~f~m,C~T::~~~1ft~ ~~rtflf I <.!1~ C<i~4~ "{iT.P·~\!)1 ~ I ~ J1i~ 'IIt~{lf<ttlf -s c~c'lM"<lt~1f9 ~
C~C~"I<ftlfr.<Ii 1fit~~

~~mi11[ ~
f<tfi~'fifrn~
'l'lft01!

~ft

II

f<pJi
;

l'[m~

em

Post-Industrial
I

lf4{ltl31

1l1<A"'ft'ift <S{flf-

~~
CIf~ft.
~~

~~
~~

t"fsrn ~~.
~~'<!S

~m'at'ej01 ;ftf~-<.!l:fM

"ll'0'I~, df~

'-!i{trjj~'hTO!

f~ <1't~ fi~

~
~ <.!1~

~
I; ~

PI"fif ~~
rr1'if ~~

;
-riC01?
<!left' Gl.( ~1<ti""1J<\1lr,

r.~ I
II

m~1Of

<.!1<fi1ftm~.mc~'I1'

~'!'!ltlj '<fNt'i '(

~tfu'lJt~, ~1~Tt..n C"nlll:"I~ f~c~ .z'{omtlf <rI ~~, C\!iI~1 -TI<t;r;;<j ~ ~l~(}fSjt?{ ;g,;f'>f\.1{

~~temf<if~ -<.!1Q<fif
~'if~

'f1i

1.!l~1

Post-<.!1Q <Ii\!"

ort'~<ltlfC<fi ~ Mt:€l1 I llCOI I!ftt~ ('>!J1 ;rt<t,.fl<l1i:if ~~ '2fl5t<1, ~'</<11' ~'Jf1m '1t~~~-q ? ~ II Clff~1fi-~r.m ~ts!J<ltlf·f1C!ll~ Lfjf'\!il:~ttlt'll: ~~1 (~ c!1W1~SI" 'f-~1 ~~f~ I ffl ~iQ <t~1, ~omr ~<$ ~1tf'iff \'I &1top_ojt~r~ :Jt~ '-!i{"'Tt~<Ii "f4{~ ~ *1"9\,,'" "it~tt'11~'Y-1§1 c?fr.<\I' 'll1 p.IC<llf~. I f;r~~ ~ ~1 ~1f01l:<i ..t<ftr;of~ f<ff~, <.!IW~ ~1f~~, ..t~ '~twJn Pi~:{ f~iS~,"!'@l:Oim f~r;~ \!i{f~~ <i-"~1 ~ "iM~! ~\9Q-<!t'(~~lw f..>f1 C:~~~~~ P dllE",~'ll'iS""~ C'«<fi c~f~'l mmOf, em"!' !'It'Y 'e fo!H~o;f!:l" Jrf~~~1 l'[tm~~wtift lffO'fi.'f ~15'11 ~QC!fO{! ~~tfI ~~ 'lJ~'S1', '~J', '~~fo.::~', '<1't'1f~'-Q~ '~ft!~r~r~il'~fOf~ I4:t~9tlSr.~11 ~ II '3ttr~rt<Ii1~r-m~~ ~~c<'rt'5"if1, ~1 f~~~'lj':ii, @iI.\!)- '\!)t~ Pltjll<ft I
<.!1~ ~'COf
f<l'l:!'I ~

m1t~1 ~art","I'l! '-!iI1f~II "lfrn:ru <t1W1 ~ ~-~~ '\!)~J-f<I;"'tf~~ ~~t'!m1' I!!{tf~-"~t"?l f;r~illf1:jl~-'€mnt f~~rilQ,ffi-c~tf'IDlt~~ Ci11l"' 15tfm-~lj~ ~<f iT~Of 'ff'tiflf~Si~~l<lO11 ~fil ~iI. 'Ill J:!l"'ltft "I1<1i~ \!!WlJ -tcw 9f1'sm 1l_1J~ I \!l1~1~1 c~ c~ ~ ~1; ~tt; ~ta!i{ c~i!ilfilm'\!l9 C~9Pl~~~ ~ ,tl!':f~1~~ fTfl:~if! I ~ 11 ~~~ I f<U:if~ 1;t<ml r.f~c"f~ C~ If<r N.G.O. fornrn~ ~t~ (W-~ "~r.:;;:;fal"Ol" (?) '111 piece meal social engineering stti'tl:liijQflf'1'~~<f

~~~ I C"ft1(;-~1~~~" c1tJ!; ~? f~ 'II~t1f1 ~'@t~1~lfWf~ ~~tm-~~15iQ !

em-

t\!lt~t~

fuS!.i
~'!i

~~-l51"t~'<f~1!

m:Jj"<ft:if~ ~

<!'"QiQ ~\irn

\!)"J-r'1~

~~

1l1'e1l1· ••

<oft~ II

~-c~.

<1't$j"f~-~r:i;ft5ff~11" 5ftt~t1R I

~~

c~ lfti:llf~r

~~.!t'1t~ ~ '1ft?!' ~~ I fo1~"lf "6tf!\l~ I ~ltlQ I ~tj (l1~Ki1" ~t<ji' '5f.iIt~ "'\il:?l Ofl I ~"ij<f '!I{-~t~~ "'~t"tl:<ll" fmt;'" C'1l~lt··J 9(tCi!! 1.~ I 1.~ <J1~~ <J1~ If<l fu<fal'll' ~\!i '<!S~ fofC'Sl'C<fi lftf~t~ ~", ~r.~'Jir.i1i f*.ij r.~~ '"S\r~fo;<i' N.G.O. fo1~rt9 <fr.~ I ~ l{-${
.,Jt~\;1
~~

'1~'Ir.'lrn ~~ 1f'l' II

\!t~

05tClfit

m9fJtt; l
iT'll"I

~Jf~lf~~.

C'Ptol

(,1tf"'!r.~.

~tjfornf~\!) o:rn;

'!i11l"

<.!1<fi~if~i91~fo:rn~'1

ir~/~~~~
f'Wll~~Q9,

'€

~~Q.!t'a:~<tt'lf

m'<J-rtl]c;m <i'Q(1'<tfo;r-~'${ ~~f~ C5~i ~r:.Q c.~t~ ~~ '6i1'1/'" "f"f ~~ ~lT;rn f.Ft~ ~~"ft'lf~ '1~ ~fir <f§t~ <11N.G.O. ~il ~~~ I C~lT <r1 C5~~lT l!!f~~ rr1f~ c'Sr.,; "ft'?, ~~-lc'SftOil"il' fu~ fifC<iS ll!3 CI5t~ 1t~ I ~1;'tc<tS~~<;Jl~ ~'i' ~Qf~ ~1!1.~ "1'O'!f~'l:f I !!l fo.n:~ tftr."f"r ~\!''i ~~ :<lia<!rt"f l'ft-lJ10'! 'tI'~0'!1\1 ~~ij<1"ifi II (.~ i11 (.<fiij, I!ft~?( ~~~ <'l'~ I!ftCl1J I i'!t'4'~: ~m <f~t"ltWt~ ~JT;tQ ~U1~\!jt?l ~\'!jtJf "li~, f.i;~ m-~~f~'!iTIl; W~I~J~ f~\!i~1 ~Wt~ ~'t r:~tm~ flfl~~';{-~flt l!1'ii",~ llftf.r I f~"j!!\!j: ~ c!I~ R<fI"f ~ ~1 ~-"~f\!lm'l~ ~"---~\!l ~ ~~ ~~tlf1 ~'!l?r.~ c~ lJift~tc<{ lftf~ I 'Sftf~ II <t>~l\;nr ~f~"'~ f~~u fffflt~,,{<f"lJ~ ~O'f'lf ~"f I (.1\ ~fI~ '1J<t'l!1~~R1 <\l'>;jJ~ffClf1{, 'ltR<1'lf"l" ffi~ <2tfuml c't\'5tr:~<(>til: -\5f1t ~OFJl!5rr1 ~l~<ftQj' ~~ ~ C5f~1?iI ~mR<!ttlfQ CW\!D1~ C"i'Omm~ ~ C<iil:!; (<i,\"~ ~ Rc~ \51<RW'1 ~~ I f'1.i\!j"jUl'f~~Q" C"'ftm ~(i<1il ~i~~tlt1 1.!1"<P!:l<t>'l:f '51'lt~ ~ I ~<fI '5{tt:~t~"T f.f~ ~f'\'j~t~!1. ~W M~l <mri{\5fM ~~l!tm ~'~~"If~ C~ ~~~r~Q" ~ <\l~:~~-(.l] ~1 f~f.1~ <f~~!!l'f ~~ "fro- ~ I 'C$ftwl' fill:~ "1'''11 <l~, 1~~f~ <5[W~ ~·f;rfl(\!i-!!l ~R~ \51$f'G'l\1 'llT\!tmlRf ~ Cl( 1f(t'3\t"ll.tJtOf ~1 <lim ?{n. '5tc'G ~ ~ QJ~, ~fu~l] CO{~ I ~f~~~ <jJ~COf ~~~ "fc<tJ "tTIt9'\5 ~~ I
li

ClR~Jjtlr <!"to\1Jt'11~JllftrI '

~tf.lJ?1

c~ C1f~f~Jj~
I

f1l lWH

f<i'~

'3\tfir

<jJ<'1't1t ~'<5ft~

'if5ilt~

~l]

~J<AN

'\5lW[
~~ ~~,

II

l.!1'11"I'J

tt-l ..,R!iJ ~~
Oft~

nfoJ~~~

1<'fm

11'~ ~R <f~ f.l'cyf~ I C'lfnt"lf1, iiI~<fit~l i{t~

I I5\'t~~1 <.!l'f~ lJp~j" ~\!l~ <tfOFJi{',

~tn

.,ftftll.";f\<1'!1.9
C1'O{,

~f~!!l<fl~~

i1"11f<!i~0{ <!l 11'~ • 'Gt ~

~\f~"

l1cortiftf'GiJJ"t.,
<j>~t~.,. I
<!l~

fO'f\f3~nr !!l~ ~f~~R !.'?{t<f ~~~

<I~ II

R~<jJlft~~

<!I~M '!i{ftf$~ I
'l:~

iftfiI1't~l

lf~"hRC-~

W~~'1~ i~l:\!l~

<fOFJC~

<f'<fl 'lQi~, ~~, "II~1 "Pojt-rnodern condition"

~~';{,

"What are we calling postmodernity

~~!!l

~ti{ <flt~

ct~, 'l.:I:wt

I'm not up to date 7"

c13m

( 'Structuralism and Post-structuralism',

'fW~lif. '5Itf-.r

Telos 55, 1983 )

I5R

'1Ttr:~~.,pP lif"l!' ~ ill ~Uf

I

mlI"*
'!I'm-

<t>~~1 lfCil <firnii'll" Cif'«

';j~

'l:ft~~11 ,-1jt:"tN:, "'a5f<1~

i{1

I"

~t11rQj"'11'~" '~:<Il' ~

~rt"l'AAfil<fi ~.,.~

f~1!t9 <;"ill

<..!I-.ut"tttl1"
~~
i{<I

l:\!l1 ~'rr<t1ti( ~~ m-~~O{<!I'~ Gasche ~!!l~ ~~-~~m 'il:0ift~ "~...n:~'ltlf", ~~!!l~ f<1ii 'l:fCi1" ~ ~Wf I ~<rt-g iR~ ~~«9 .a,"Rttlf!(~
I

c."6fS~ ~r:m 'l"'<t1~ f<l,Yfj <!l ~'q"1iIl(<1IJ >e orf~i1"1

~~Fr ~

~~
'~\!j~'

~~)'jt'1'i I

-nl{<li !!l"<i,\"~1.,..,,~ ~

C~~<f

C"1ll:m~, ~1 ':'It~

f<'1''t ~

<\IUli{,

c·rt1l~""~i ~~H '11 I ~<fi'I; f'1'~ ~~~t':iji$f ij)~ ~S'!<Ii~ c<1it~

f<1~or c~

~ II \!lm'l:ftt~ C'!1 ,.~ 'cmil>f1' c'mK~I

~
C~

<Jl~jr.{
Cll~,

rt'~iI l]~t~t~!

~tt&~ ~Jt'¥,~ ~t ~ti1~ ~t*tclltl:<\l'i3

'3{1t'l15'li~

C'<!l:<Ii 'G'1~tliit ~'I3m I .a~flf cCi.lC<fl~~lI~<rtCif 1ft'E!lftil' "fl:~ ~ ~'1{~nm$[ "f~ '0!fi ~~f~ I tr'lft~Tfirgp" \lI "fl:'<I~ <..!Iaf I f~ 'itf~ ~ r:~ a'!~t<1,;{11p,1~t$f o.!Il5tt"'~ ~t't1 ('liC~ "tt,~ ~~'(iRtc«~'l'!f~qjrtton; ~'fIT.i5ft5iltl1 9fc~ qqfit~tIf <m'l-f-«fu <!l<til3!t~l$l"
C'{if

wrn~

II

~~~

~Ci{

str.~

"mTIlf'i

'1'~

CQ(1;<i,\"lI~rn

~Y1

l3t~ ,~,

"f1 Meta <'II''ftiJtlf ".if'il:~Nc<fi ~<fiP1\!i "fm:<f

~1{

II

G\!ii ijGiff~ t

'i~~!!l~ 'C!t~ti{

fij-!;f<1il:~ mc~I

n~ c.,.~tc<f Ql ClPfil

C1'I1Q(n~ ClJ1!<lI:q' 1l11ti11! qqtolltijO{-l~~<1Iq1~~gj

ifu~~

"r;~, \!l~fi{ C
l{~-.~~

m ifitc« Rtl'~

<t~ II

\W.f

~Jf't

<ft. "lJ1<i"«1ti{
,,~

m~I

C~

m-f"t~'io{ c1{Uf1! ~~
Jt:q~t

C\!)~11l1~mt., f~I~.

11~ ~ <rol5'(\' ~ ~tm~-··

~t\!

c~I"1OfIro1 (.lf~t~ ~~~~"hI ~!

'l:frPl'ftC'lf$f f'1!~tfit'G1~l:\!i

Dt-e"IJ1 <ft~~

or~ I f<1.... 'S:{

~-fijf"''R'llllli'1'1 ( ~\!,~ '€ Jt1T1~GI ) '3\tL1fPI~ .,tlJf <fl\!)'ft~~1';j1~t~ \!inr lJ:~P1:~ t2tf~~t~ 'U'-!,1 'fCqi ~~ <R1lf~1i1: I <r~
II !!l<'l'~i 'fI'J1

~f~~ '~ffr;~t~ (~ 'SlW ~'l'!It.1 f<fil

~,t1
~

~ II '\5{Pf~1lJr'ij'if<l-t"'!ft~ C<l'<I"a<f~? ~t<'lQl{t.,? '<;!{tlJttiT C1l '¢{r~l ~Uft~\!j" ~ M'G '3\tflr"~ (Paradigm )-~tsfm f'ltllM-'l"W1 ~f~t'lJ,
~

t'<& ~~JIfif~<!l<l'~ ~ '1R'i8t"ltO'f'l ~mrn: Rr;m;ft-CJl~ dI\!i"iji~ 'l'fJt's!1tOfh1 ~ ~tQ1 nrr.\!i m? ~~~t5 I.!'Jtillo,C'i!l -etiS,l:\!i ~
fi1"mfif,
(~

;'1fUf-~1
~\!i ~

"-T~ ~

~";!i~tra'l~ ~
1

~J ~~

'{C4'If§~-!!l

'G"J ~~tltC'lfii

~-~t~"I'~~ l'fCOf ~'lf c1Q(0'!1 Clf~llf~-·~~rq1 ~l{

~fir

~f5§ I
I f<fi~

w~

'9l:'!fo{,"'W
@DDt~1r.-<1' "'~ii!(

"·~'m'I:·~"Ri'lf

~~rn

~ CI'llt§'

lftt~ I

~t~
~01fl

<jJ~tt:o:r

"~~-'l'ilt{"l<fi"

O{n-rn

:qC~1 ~

15!~~~I:2f~~i, fij' \ motn ) '1C"of (''G"P.ti~ 'm~',! 'sttf~',~ ~t~~t'6 If<!l ''1'r. (. ',1-111 i1"1 I C\$IT!f ,~, ,~ , ~lll·. '~'lf1'.1{'.

~'3'j"~~

/
Foucault, M. J 988. Madness and Civilization: A History of Insanity in the age of Reason, New, York: Vintage Book Foucault, M. 1988. The History of Sexuality: an introduction 'Vol. I. New York: Vintage Book. Foucault, M. 1988. The use of pleasure: The History of Sexuality, vol, 2. New York - Vintage Book. Foucault, M. 1988. The Care of the self: The History of Sexuality, vol. 3. Vew York: Vintage Book. Foucault, M. 1988. The Archaeology of knowledge and Discourse on Language. New York: Pantheon Books. Gadamar, H-G. 1915. -Truth and Method, New York: Continuum. Gasche, Rodolphe, 1986. The Tain of the Mirror. Harvard
Uni versi ty Press.

lr17/..!t~l1r
Qf

'S

m~Tf

''!!{fii' ~\!rn ~ 'fBI '~"-~ ~-<;~-~"!f ~ I 'O{~!) ~ wtf~Hi ~f~ ~n;:Ft, ~~ '~~~wt"lFl1Oil" ? .....

"t!l~I" "f.l@',-~~ f<mt"'R

c~fi<I'!;~ ~ ~m~COt~ <fa; ~r;<f

~ C~Qi1!

'!5ft~ 1tf'\!)\'l1
(-<ut<1l1.iOT

m~'\!)

'1l!m "l1f<l

Altridge, C. Bannington, G. Young, R. (Ed.). 1987. PostStructuralism and the question of History. New York, Cambridge! Cambridge University Press. Atkinson, P. 1985. Language, Structure and Reproduction: An Introduction to the Sociology of Basil Bernstein. London: Mithuen. Barthes, R, 1975. The Pleasure of the Text. Oxford, Cambridge: Blackwell. Barthes, R. 1973. Mythologies. St. Albans: Paladin. Browe. M. 1991. Lacan, London! Fontana Press. Callinicos, A ]989, AgainstPostmodernism : A Marxist Critique, Cambridge: Polity Press. Coward, R. Ellis, J. 1977. Language and Mater ialism : Development in Semiology and the theory of subject. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul, Culler, J. 1990, Barthes, London: Fontana Press. Derrida. J. 197611994. of Grammatology ( Tr. G. C. Spivak) Delhi, MoWal Benarasidas, Derrida, J. 1981. Dissemination (Tr. B. Johnson) Chicago: University of Chicago Press. Dews. P. 1987. Logics of Disintegration. London, New York: Verso. Foucault. M 1973. The order of things; An Archaeology of Human Sciences. NeW York: Vintage Book. Foucault, M. 1973. The Birth of the Clinic: An Archaeology of Medical Perception, London: Tavistock Publication. Foucault. M. 1979. Discipline and Punish: The Birth of the Prison. New York: Vintage Book.

Maurya, V. 1994. Post-modernism: A Discussion. Delhi: Kalinga Nandy, A. The Intimate Enemy ~ Loss and Recovery of Self under colonialism, Delhi: Oxford University Press. Nandy, A. The Illegitamacy of Nationalism. Delhi: Oxford University Press. Nirunjana, T. 1990, "Translation, Colonialism and Rise of Bnglisli' Econumic and Political weekly, vol, xxv. No. 15 ( pp. n«- n» ) Niranjana, 'I. I \JI)(). I I istory Really Beginning: Compulsion of post-Colonial ]>cdal'Pl'Y'" bClIl10mic and Political weekly. vol, xxv i No. 42-43 (pp. 'J7 ) IXI ). Norris, C. 19S1.1 CIIHlu. IIIIUIIlIl: hllll/lI1t1 Books. Rabinow, p. (Ell.) Pantheon Books. Said, E. W. 197!S. Kagan Paul l\HI'I.
IOIi(,lIlll I

I e.ulcr.
1IIIlIoli :

New l{oLllkdgc

York; and

OriDl1lrdl'il1l

Said, B,W. 1984-91 Tho Wodd, tlte Text lu~d he 'ritic, London ~ Vintage. Said, E, W. 1993. Culture and Imperialism. London: Vintage

Silverman,

D. & Torode, and

B. 1980. its

The

Material London: in

Word: Routledge

SO;IlL
and

Theories of Language Kegan Paul Srivatsan, of Sciences." R. 1990, (Re\l'iew

Limits.

"Trajectory Article)

of reason Economic and

Historiography Weekly. Language.

Political of

( pp. 205-208 )

Vqlosinov. V.N. ( 1986) Marxism

Cambridge, Mass.: Cambridge

and Philosophy Press.

'6 ~:

University

W:fhl'1 '6 ~~~1f~[I

~, ):o.il~ ~\
)8: )

~1, lftt'1"t
I

~:"'b-b-

>ltih, ~
~IO:

<s"ffolt~f"t<\S ~~~
!)'D-~~4

~il.t?(',
~'?
I

"H~~l]!'I"

~~:

~,9f. )-)~ c<li't¢i<i'1''!i1

~:;:.:o.~ I

~:sr,
'8

~, 1: 'i'tPI~~

c<fito<I'fl'!i1

'6

Cl)I!)Of1I

~~?f'

"~I~lclf41
~~
1

~f\!'l~~
I ~:o.... ) I I

~'!3!'ltl'ij,t~

'5CF1" I

'fI't1l'tIf'Pf.
<rl~~~ C·jC<'I'I"

9j:

~·1-'\8 I

'5C\lt"ttUhr,
fsm ~~r'5<\S

1't-{
I

,.~~~

~'8~~t3\""

~~ ~ ~,"1= ~-~s I
f,i{1fI'iftlf~t.,
1f\8. s~

C~'<!i1

):
I
loS

)-):"', 9J! ~-::a) C<\Sr'a'f~t'\!i1 I

~;:'178

'CCWt~41 ~~

~~ I

~:'"f~~

f<f ~SJlfti

I ~~t'1

C1fJar'i'1~1:

w:'WJl'iPiThl

G?('~(f-t~
<l;~,

oUe..~

f"flliSl1

~;,~) I
I

,'Stt~'~iif
I

~~'l'ji~'

fit'!J~'!"J

C'fM'ft"i: "tm9f4ltJf I

"lit

~~t:Jj':

'1_'¥:lf~ I

~;;,\;>~ I

!'!"TIT.
~if

I"

~,
5f~aj'~"1'11r
C~~I

~"t I ~::.a) I "'8. fl9'. f<f <1111': <11<f1T; ~~f\!i, (\": ~,'1: S~-8~ c~fi; I ~t~ I )::.:;.)I "'6~ <l9'C'5tiil1 <h~,
'e

i2f<f',fi ~~~~if

(.~t~t\!i1:

CIf"~... I
(.OI~

~i:f~~

t5!ffi

~~
8::' I

mf~
I )::,)4

lf1l1t5lt5if1"

1Stil.~?(', ~~:

), "'.!~ ~ } ,H

!it:j,J, ";(~~t!'I"
~~ ~. 91: lf~ef,

"'''-9 8 C<i'1~t'I5I:
<fflJt;j I f"fC~tt1f

))\r~

I "st"lHl" 'OfIJiJtm" ~t.lIt~ 'f6'~t~~~~

I ~~"If: Jr-)t I

~~!Il1 c!t~
~ L!I

"~frJi, ~§-~~, I;' "ftt1r~t~,)~: ~,9j':

~1 ~~~

I.fl~

lf~<1>

,.'It<t~

modernism

(i!: C'I{T:!:i. }):;:.s) "Post and the Question of the Other: Tourist as a 'Pilgrim:

a Critique".I.fl~

~t1'OfRl?i, >&'l;

m~

~'1~

f~~~ I]