Professional Documents
Culture Documents
cq<j~
<fV11Jt9ft~
~~~'!i!i~
~~ ~ c.<4'~ (~ \5ffi:'I'fiSR~ <TrG'I
c~'ifTi§
NsPlrn'1_:J'!
1%R ~
\5ffil"
C9f(;1T C~
>It;qC\S1~~l) ~\~
~
I
#iRj
I ;''iil~8T.\5
M<rn<!r~
<is't-
i%"R ~
~
~f.pWBr
IO!~
~
~
~
: ~1mrfc1
~-<!l~
~1~
(~
~
~\~$!
<lffif\~ ~
WM~~\1J'fi.%61?l
I5l'M CI!I1,
"'\~'6D61!
~ Centre fu1r ~ ~
~
Studies!
qjVfj
<rrn<:f1-.:r ~
'iS1liSll!l'{l
~--<rf11-wrOO
~\"f~ ~;
~l<lI\!l~,
~'{j,
~m- ~
~
CGt ~~ OTt ~
'Gfj'&
~m
Ti&t?l ~
W
<TI
m~ ~
~? ~
~
I~
><inThr~
f<1; ~
I <!I~
$i~ C-<A
1.!:I<ffi ~
~~ct "iFfl
lfSl<rm-f.r41r.crn ~~
\5IBT
'1.i1118f-"~~
'<i'1"4l5hllii1 ~>?
Wm~~
'11 r?ftl:j,
C"1'iiI mm
Drn9/r5" ~
C~
~m:
I ;, 'iil~<l-Iblb~ (.~ ~
$;1
~
C'<it<l>05V1 <!I"'l
)'iillb'\-Ibir
~ ~~
~-'Jj\~ 11'f1 ~ ~
~ ~ <!I~
fuw ~rn
\til
~-fuf<wrW-l
i.!1~'Z~<f>fO'l<j>11!11~ ~
~""irim<;f[:;~
a.M,
y~ r.~
~of1? ~
(~, <!1~
~~~1~)
QlFl
Ji140Si1JC1l
Nm ~~?"<1'BI
'5l~
C<i'11'CC91?l '5l~
JimT~ ~
I~
R\5t
Dew> :
C>lm
<£l<fGt ~ c<rn <PTIR ~ "Why Sociologists?' c<r ?f1j~?J1i C3Wf1~, \51$! rrtm~r ~
g
and for
each particular care a sociologist put 10 work. One studies juvenile delinquency, another racism, a third slums. Each seeks on explanation of his (sic) partial problem and claborates a Theory' while serving as ~ proposing solutions
3 La
'Walch Dog' our sociologists will at the same lime make his (sic) con\'3 \.')~~~'<l ~j~~ ~~
Loukik Vol.2 No.1 January '08 0fV'm ~ ~ I!I<fi ~~~ ~' <lJ<l"llil ~<ptMOi ~ ~~ ~ ~.~ <pliS'/:qsoll'~ ~ ~~
QJ'e1lrn
~'8 ~
~ ~ ~
I~
~1lI~<i1C1'!~ ~ ~ ~
I ~-~
f.t I ~,
I~
1!I"Qf~ m'i'l ~ C~
(ll f.ron~~tG'I1
*~~
I!)c<I
m ~. ~
I!I~
~'i'!Ti5 ~ ~,
~:>~~8-~, ~
I
ern, I6I1Bff
"l~flSi~C'q~ ~/Wm.-:qJ<q"lfflc<p
C<lfi't ~
~-~
ern ,~
~
mi '8
<roll ~
~~
oro I \$
~
'<PlISI
~~(~~?)
~ ~~ ~. ~n~ ~~
C'i'llijl<elC<il:I :~ ~ ~
1!I~'~~~~Q!l~~,I!I~~~~~~~
(ll ~
~9fm ~
cooked) 6'I'i'1 I
~~-mn ~
\!iit~.~
161m ~
M6flSiOiUl \!iit9j1l!)l!) ~
c'i'lii ~~,
~
~,
~
~,
~~!t
~ ~~
qJ'J:'IS M611Si0iUl'(3C"Pf ~
'C<qQIH4S' '8
m~
(ij'Sm
9j~~N>~
~) m1 '8 "l>ff'i'lm
I ~I!I~ ~ 9f~~, ~ ~
rrt- ~~ptJlrnl!i~
(ll ~
!f<lai ~ 'i5'I~ ~ ~
(I!)iII
'1611~'
~ ~~,
~-~
~
~'-~ct
f.ml! ~~,
~ ~
power-el I~
'1f~ c~ ~'
~
(Disciplines, subjects) ~ I~ ~ ~
COic<It II!ltt ~
<rIC<!'~~,
ISilOiCl§~~
CISIl\1?1 ~
~., '9f1<lSt' ~
~
I
fflt<P ~
~
~
~) I!I~
\!i{~ ~'-
I -..t~I=ISiC""ISi~_ ~.~
~ ~ ~~ ~ ~
~
~
m~
C<I~" 'mm<rol'
~
~ctt<P
~ I~'8~
'~'
mm ~
~-
m 0Wl'I0i~~
~ <W;
~~ct t1f"l<plCG1~ ~ ~ I~
'(3 iGJIf&~C~~
(~ ~
.~) ~~'
I II!I~ ~.,
~
~
'<fsWI' ~
~~
'9f1<lSt' ~
I '~'-'C4S
'i'I) 1!I~1!)61c<1
~ ~ ~. ~-
mm
~
~
~~ ~~ ~
(subjects/disciplines) I6Ilf.MIC<q"Il'fof ~
~~
'" ~~
I!I~
(objectification)-I!I~
~!
m~. ~ ~ ~
1!I<lm~ ~ '(3 ~
f.ml ~
~,~,
~~ ~
M. Sc./ B. Sc.
~~
(ij'Sm ~),
I~
(>1~IISiI!)'q,~.~)
~ subjection-e
~Q!l ~ ~,
~~~
f.ml ~
~IOi<llSilN> 1!)Q!l~-~ ~
C"fI~\1?ICOil-ClII5\!,?ICOiI c~ ~
I~
SCC11
m
~
~~IISi~'q~-~
~/,*~
1C<It RCI!S ~
161m I!I~
~
c~
~
~
~~,
'~'-U1
"Dividing practice".
(ij'Sm ~ I~ ~ ~ C~I
(ll ~
<fitiSf~, ~'~~,
0ltMs
~
\!i{t(~
1C<It
~
m ~;
~-~
~-M'&I~C4S
1C<It
m~ ~
1!I~0Wl'I0i
~-mm ~ ~
(Administrative Di~ ~
~ ~~:
~ ~~ tr"1I~H4S ~~
6l~.'8
I6IOiJ ~
~ <roI? ~ ~
~~.~
~~ ~
~
'~'-t4S
~ ~
~.~
~ I!iR<IS ~
~?)
$~
~ I!I~,
m 9fI\1?1 ~
~~
(I!I~~ ~
'SfC<ll!lfij ~
c'<fC<IS ~~
I «jS
~~
.~~ m~ ~ I ~
.\
\!llMt"!l~)
I!)'f' ~
16I1C'i'I ~~OO
~'i'If.:I C'<fC<lS Ql
C<I~OlUl~
I!I~
0f<I~~9ft1.1Jffi
Loukik Vol.2 No.1 January '08 ~/~ ~~ <rt ~9jR1b$l~"l ~'If ~ ~ <ll@ HC$l~(ft1<1 (Domesticated
'iT@ffiI ~
<t>(jl~(ft1"l) ~
\5Ii'CG11'<t>~ 'li ~, ~
~1<1<1~8tC{J~~ ~ ~ ~.~
M'G3IC<B1)
~~m
\8~C'f
\8~ ~C'f
I .Q~ ~-~-c<l"~Oj
~~
~~/c!l~
~~ <ITPf~ ~-
'<l>!Dt' ~
~\8m?
~ ~
~~~? GI~lc<t>'!'l ~
<1~C<t>8t<t>Anthropocentric) (
.Q<1~
1 '15IWr'01~ ~
~
Ojf
~
1.Q"<t>'i;t
~~
1~
'~'
fi:ml
~
~C'f
\8 ~C'f f.l~'t
?ffu~~
~ ~~
c!l<P~ \8 '~' \8
g ~/
ott ~,
'~'<1-;1~
'9ft<pt'
~I
c!l~<$1Dt ~ ~
I own
'~'
\8 '~'<ll@
GJI9frn
151'<1f~ ~~~
~~,
~I ~ ~
~
m, ~.~
00
'151'@1'-~
$-mm ~
I5IOU ~ ~
<ll@ ~~,.Q<ffif
CW~rC\!i~ 9frol1
Of~ ~
~ ~
~ ~~~
m~
w.T, ~
f91~
'~',
I~
<Rll C"1<T ~
<ll@ ~
~ .Q~~'l<t>~~~
~ \5Bf ~~
~'Iffiu ~ ~ ~'li
1.Q~I<I~f{J Wb{JI~<t>
~~ \51' . c<T
c<T
vrrPf-
mm-~~~!
.Q1;t<ifq C~ '<R! 1 '00', 'CG1t<P', >1I~I..ifl<t>1C~ ~ 6T1a'f<l~ ~ ~
f<j;<ll@? ~
~ ~~H<t>~
(essentialist) ~
0Jt<lI~
'li~,
"t1f<l m W "lW<fR
'~'
'<mft-~'c<Jrof 'i!il ~
~~ ~~
<TN 15IlC~
~~
0fXI ~
~
W9fm ~
~
<mll ~,
~
~
~~
~/'T-T-OO
M'G3IC<1'!'l~ ' '~'
<tf@
<.!l~~
$1-~,
QT .Q~:.Q~
oom G~
<Tf<p, ~
'li ~,
I'~ 1 ~'
c<T"l ~~ ~
~/151-~
iSMf'$1 ~
~ ~~
~1<i>Ji<lIC't~
~
~Ca'fG1ffi(Jl~ ~~
~
.Q"<t>'i;t ~,
~ '~'
.Q~
'J'!Jtf9JnfJi' ~
~c$
W9f:1 ~
~ ~~' ~
1~ ~
~?frWir
Ula'f~fGla'f 'i;t;m~
~
'i'f7.m
\':f
~ ~
~
fur<I' ~
~-wro
C~
~'
<im <1-;1'~'t
<ll@, ~
~tc~<lC't'!'l ~.
'G3H\!)CI.l~ (~\s9jHC<lC"B!
~Nffi ~
(~ ~ I5ITJit ~
Of'Sm ~
.!rf\b~IPi<t> ~
QT 9jmf c<T JiIC~<lC't~ ~ ~liSi<f1~ ~ ~ ~
'<1-;1'~
~~
c!l~ ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ ""'iMtll"l=GttfciRi""'<t> "Sl'lf%1f~~ ~liSi<f1f\b ~ ~ <titiSi' <ll@-' 1~ (~~ ~ Studies) 1~\8 ~ I.Q~ ~~C'fm~ ~ ~
p9fur--c!l~
'00', ~-~'
<1-;1'~~ ~ ~I<I<1R<t>~~ 0fC<1J <tiIiSi ~ ~~"ff\hM'tJl ~
'C~'
~
~ 1~
m~
'~', 'CG1t<P',
.Q~
~~
JiI~I"ml'\!)
~
f.lo&C'f 1 QT .Q~
\51<f1
p9fur C<PCG1'
<1~
~C'f
'G
<ll@,
<T115OO~ ~
~~,
~liST1:<1f\h<t>.Q<P (~ ~ (univerM'G3I<1M'tllbbl
~~ ~~ ~1Sf"lI~~. g~
9ffuC'fG ~
f<j;?
ffi
oom <rI ~~
~ ~
9fW't ~
C~ C~
~C'f ~
I~ ~
.Q~ Cma'f<l~ ~
C<lC~IC"'lI~.Q<P/.Q'<t>1f~ ~ ~
151<4 ~
'JitC~
~~
15IQj<rf
\5Ii'CG11'<t>~ .Q~
~
Of\8~
~
m ~~!
~
~
~I
M'G3IC<1'!'l
~
~~1f\bf~'tJ1bbl~
~ Ojf .~
~~-<TN\8
~~~
\5lC<f ~ 1.Q~ ~
0ff.l1 ~
'.Q~'
~
~
~
~
~
~~g
'~'~D&t\8
C"1<T ~
~~~
(performance)
~~1f\hM'tll
ffi
~
(~
~ ~~
~ ~
iSWlft ~
~
~/.Qfur!/~/fmiSm/~
1 'i!ilmT
g ~~
R1~{J<1Ia'f ~
(.Q~
vrrPf ~
~
~
~
~)
m ~.~
9f!'lfG11 ~~ ~ ~
OjR~IC<l1
HC\SrC't~ 0fC~ ~
""i~
~
.Q~ I) 115IG.Q<1 1
~
~C'fl
iSi<rIf.l- ~
~~~~
151fCG'f1<t>~ <rI ~
~
'[C<t> ~)
\8 "TR<f M'G3IC<1~~~~
151~ ~~.
.~C\SCa'f~ ~
("?J9fN
W~
~C'f
<rt ~
~l1J11551~15I'5tg ~~~
'Dtm 0fC~
MiMlC<1~ ~~
.\
c<I ~~~
(.G'f~Nrn
~~I~
~~~ (~m~
~~m~,
~ ~oo~~ ~
Gen-
'~~,
~ ~ ~ ~ ~
<it ~~,
~
1~
1
~9furtol
~~,
¢I ~
~
1
<m~ ~ ~
:qslil1bl~I'il1 ~I\SCIS'I~ ~~ <Plil1bl'$llil1~~~
~
~
I"
~ ~~
~~~
~~~~~ ~fiipC;'6
~~ ~ ~ ~
~15l"~.'~~~'~
~
~ ~
~~'1
cWI ~
~ ~
~ ~ ~~ ~'(3 \St:qt\!)C<l'(3~
I
:qslil1[jl~lil1 ~
~.~/~'~~."~~"
<ptil1bl~lil1 ~
1fl>:{1Sf)~ ~
~~-~.~
der Studies~~ ~~ ~ ~ ~~·I I!I~ I~ ~ ...I ~
(~-~qJ'j_<l5
.~).~
omTt-~
: I!I~
~~~.
'6 ~~~~~~Nc;<p
""Ifu ~.
~0W!l
~ '(3
~. ~ ~ ~ ~ <iJ<i$ ~I
'(3 ~~'1
~t~t4fl1'6
'OIt<tSh1'6tGi<!S qJ'j_<l5 ~
~ ~"i1"t"I
\5Il"1mI ~ ~ ~~
'!iI1VI, ~ ~~cm ~~
~
'(3~ ~~
~-OOil1<itq') ~ ~.~'....mI ~
'511ft1Ib"ll ~ l
C'iftG'I ~
~
~<iJ@f"I'I ~
c;:qstc;;U ~
~
\!)j ~
~
~
9ff@ 1
~Olt
~ ~
~~1'6
I!I~ ~ :
~
I!I~
~
~~ 1 c<I ~
"1f~ ~ ~ ~ ~
I" I!I~ I "<jS~~-~
M"fJtb~l~ ~
I ~:
I 'J'f~1NsMlfJl,,61<j:f ~
<iJ<i$ C<I"1
11S'1"'~il1\!)t ~
"<jSQft~ >jitm ...t~
~ ~
~~~~ ~
~~'1
~
~
~~~,
~
<!S~~WrniU ~
II!I~~
~
~~.~ I~
~. ~ ~
~~ ~'6~
1!I<r$ ~
Cl1fC<p ~
\!)j ~'
: "<jSQft~-~
(~~~~), ~~(~~Ir,\),
(~~1b8) I ~~~~~~~
<oit<tSBI'6tGI<P !I1"<iS~
\!ilMJl
~~
~
Clf'6m- ~
~ ~ ~
~ m-~)
om I~
~, C<il ~
m ~ on m ~
~ ~
'~>tlttliS!J:qI'f'~~~, ~
~.~I
~ ~ 15® C<ifXt ~
~ ~
~~~~Wu-"4l<i>tlm!'l1
Olt I ~~
~
i9MJ
~
('OIOi "1f .~
15l"t~ ~~, ~ ~
\!)QjJ~
~
<iJl9fBI'UI ~
'J'f"'9I;f
a: C~
<!I~
'\St:qt\!),,' ~
(~~'\~) I ~
MIfJI{JI:)C"I<!i@~-~
f,ffi-
MeatC"'~ ~~
~~.,~M'fJtb~t
C<il 9fI~
~~ ~
'9fI~'-i<il
~~-~~
I!I~ ~
~ffl
I <m"<il CG'f1"<!S/I5l"--til11<tS,omTt/~ C<il ~1\StM<P? ~1\StM<P '(3 15l"-~I'SlMC;<p~ f.li 'Stt<t WI ~ (constituted)
~ I ~'if
~~~ ~ ~
C<ilMt
'OIH"b!lI'i1<p ~ ~.
~ on"! I!I~
<TI'6m ~'6~
~~-~~~
1~
f.t<IDli
C<plC"'I\SIC~
9ff:-~~9j\!)
I]
m~/9fRf~
~ om 1 ~ ~~
~
moo'1
~
<it
~
Althusser, L. 1977. Lenin and his Philosophy; New Left Books; London. Altridge, D. Bannington, 8andyopadhyay, 8andyopadhyay, G. Young, R. (Ed.) 1987.' Post-Structuralism and the Question of History; Cambridge University Press; New York; Cambridge. D. 1995 .. Folk Lore and Folklanguage: D. 1997. "The Myth fo Regionalism" Myth or Reality?; Kalyani University; West Bengal Chakraborty, Dasgupta, Subha ed. Regionality and Comparative Literature. (pp. 77-83). DSA, Department of Songs: The Discursive Formation and Culture Journal of
~~"~M'fJlb~t~ ~~ ~
~
~~ om I '~I5l"~-~ ~
~~
Specialization-
m~ ~~ ~
'(3 ~ ~ "\Sl~t\!5 ~
¢I
~
~~
~
~Qf
m~ ~
m C'611!lT:<tS ~"<jSQft
~-~
1 ~~
<fiI§~ ~
~·"<jSQft~onl~~~'if~(~~.~)~
Comperative Literature, Jadavpur University, Kolkata. 8andyopadhyay, of Dividing Practice." D. 2000. "Folksong-Classical Pondicherry Institute ~"<jS of Language
Cil11C;<PC"f~ Rm9j'el~"''61-~
m~
'(3~
9fMl9f1f.Cl ~
G., Massumi,
University
Maclellan, D. 1979. Marxism after Marx; The Macmillan Press Ltd.; London. Marcuse, H. 1964. aile Dimensional Industrial Society. ARK paperbacks; London. Phillipson, R. 1992. Linguistic Imperialism. Oxford University Press.
Barthes, R. 1973. Mythologies; Paladin; St. Albans. Bhabha, H. 1994. The Location of Culture; Routeledge; London. Chakravorti, Princeton. Choudhuri, Coward, Derrida, A. Das, D. Chakraborti, R., Ellis, J. A. 2000. Margin of Margin: Profile of an and Materialism: Development in unrepentant postcolonial collaborator; Anustup; Kolkata. J. 1977. Language D. 2000. Provincializing Europe; Princeton University Press;
Rainbow, P. (Ed.) 1984. Foucault Reader; Pantheon Books; New York. Rosen, B. 1985. Western Economics and Eastern Societies; Oxford University Press; Oxford. Russell, B. 1950. An Inquiry into Meaning and Truth; Unwin; London: Said, E. W. 1978. Orientalism; Routledge and Kegan Paul; London Said, E. W. 1984/91. The World, The Text and The Critic; Vintage; London. Said, E. W. 1993. Culture and Imperialism;Vintage; Wise, D., Ross, T B. 1964. Invisible Government.' House; New York London. :Bantom Books, Random
Semiology and the Theory of Subject; Routledge and Kegan Paul; London. 1976/1994. Of Grammatology. (Tr. G. C. Spivak); Motilal Banarasidas; Delhi. Dews, P. 1987. Logics of Disintegration; Feyerabend, Book; New York. Foucault, M. 1977. Power/knowledge: dom House, Inc. Foucault, M. 1988. Madness and Civilization: A History of Insanity in the age of Reason; Vintage Book; New York. Foucault, M. 1988. The History of Sextuality: Book; New York. Foucault, M. 1988. The use of Pleasure: The History of Sexutuality. Vol. 2. Vintage Book; New York. Foucault, M. 1988. The Care of the Self: The History of Sextuality. Vol. 3. Vintage Book; New York. Foucault, M. 1988. The Archaeology of Knowledge and Discourse on Language. Vol. I.; Pantheon Book; New York. Gadamar, H.G. 1975. Truth and Method; Continuum; The Macmillan Press Ltd.; London. Levi-Strauss, Levi-Strauss, C. 1963. Structural Anthropology.Beste Books; USA. C. 1970. The Raw and The Cooked; Edward Arnold; London: New York. Gouldner, A. W. 1979. The future of Intellectuals and the rise of the New Class. an Introduction. Vol. I. Vintage Selected Interviews. Ed. Gordon, C. RanVerso; London. of Sciences; Vintage P. 1988. Against Method; Verso; London.
1"
0'M'~~9\f~