:.....-.

"

'!

2
:J
4
5

...I
8

UNITED STAT2S DI

RICT COURT

c-35-2168
?lsintU'f,

12

)
)

"tiS.

13

14

e:al.,

)
)
)

15
16

.
:',,'0 opinions in ."i11S
'

17
18

19

20
21

22
23

24
25

case thst set forth in greE.: detail the facts surrounding

this plaintiff!s challenge to defendants! (hereinafter lithe
Cities") ca'Jle televisioi1 (hereinafter "CTV!!) franchising
and regulatory

scne~e.

~
Palo Alto, 648 r.

S'
D
t...P ...

See Centurv Federal. Inc. v. Citv of

---

<i.;:"::;
1...,.-...,-",

r,

1"\
\l',U
.

C~l
G..J...

198(')
0

(IIC e!1v~j,.Y
;.,~ ..

Federal II"); Century Feder=.l. l:;c. v. City of Palo Alto,

579 F. Supp.

1553 (n.D. Cal.

84).

At the conclusion of

the Centurv Federal II opinion, the Court stated that the

26

Cities did not "necessarily have to open their cable

27

facilities to all comers regardless of Size, shape, quality

I , ..... ', ,',

.,.......

*,,'

. '

,,,

EXHlBIT NO~_t--

~
CtJ

----

~
_I

~
CJ

~
Cl

~
;j.o..

~
W

~
1'-'

() ::J B ttl '1 Ul ;t:;> 'O.D ,1'

o 0 -ro ro~, 0 0 C
::J c' :1 () (n ::J n ~ ftl
UJ
' " Q.l C U
: : ' -. UJ
ct :::l"';3 C f'~ f~J ~ 0 C r ,~.,
,-. CD
PJ '< '< ,-.::J
("T 'J ;J
ro c t
0 Ul
s.:: CD
(t.l '<~
~ : j cf"
rt ," '1 rt
ro t-j 0
III
f-"' :1 CD :::l' 0
Ul ~J' (' .-1' :1
o
.n ro \1) ct (\)
~r (1"
:::lUI.:
UUJ
OW
PJ C t-"' 0 f~
c:.:~,
0
I-J 'J "1
(j) ,~. :1
()',
1--"'0 CO O~
:J ,_. -> 0 0

r:: (,)

ru

;t:;>
rt
'1

::J :::l
(D
~

U
(li

c_.

:1
(lJ

:1
0,
'J -
III

-<

'J.

,t

ro

;p

c:

( t _

(" l'

:VO

()
(T

:;-

ro

W.

(1' ()

CD
Ul

ro

o:sn

0' ,", rt

I~OO
(I; ::l

Ul

;j.o..

(t

0)

("T

(J)

()

::r
(ll

",
,5
(li
i1
(')

Ul
Ul

'1
III

,"

(lJ

"Ul

:J
:.J

III

(lJ

([)

<~

I-~

1-'

, ,:1..

"
:)'

w
,"
J.

~_

,5
(Il
( t

,1

III

"

ct

;y

:y
III
(IJ

Ul

rt
(ll

,"
(

( t

(lJ
ell

~-

III

(IJ

( t

,5

(!J

CD

(ll

0,

:;:

CD
I

ro

0,
01

:)

ID !D
rt ct'

Ul

(I

C
Ul

...")
CD
(D
Ul

,",
:::l

o....
c

o
H)

I
( t

:J'
to
I
11)
,J

cr

:::l
11.
1--"

::l
Uq

:.1

:J

'0

("t
Ul

(!J

lD
'0
'U

eD

O.

:1
(~l

~1J

Uq

"

O.
C1.

([l

,t:,

(n

1--"

(fJ

ct

co

'",.

:.J

,_.

ct

::J

(!)

t-.-I o

ill

,-t

({)

i "

: J'

(fl

(tJ

,-~.

,1

( t

()

fll

<..;

1\)

<I>
(l!
X

()

,r I
:}

I'l

,:

:)'

III

IIJ

()

.1

"

\
'1

;J
"

.
:

,,

v)
(l)

, j~

~u

')

,-

\.

J.

.,

I
:I
I)

'"
I)

U)

I~

:1

'l

.,

UJ

'l

.. -t

,:

CD
.D

'1
llJ

,J
"

:)

(D

()

(I)

'1

:y

Ll

ID

)-

,~

(1)

,:)

(Il

([)

CD

til

(l!
CD
U)

:,

,,

.0

,:

'<

'J

III

'q
'(1

1--"

:J

( t

O.

::

'<

Cd

~ I.

()

(U

III

,~.

( t

, ,.

u
.;)

IPl
~IJ

, ..
()
;1

0'

r.

cn
( f

1)

: )'
(l!
(j)

()
(j

L
\.1

i.:

'U

.J
III
( I

l ~)
(

,v

,1.
r-';
:)

el.

:,'

I:

([)

rr

(l.

'1
<D

I?i

'U

II)

(f)

tIl

:)

'1

;~J

( t

,.,

to

(\)

;,.;

(I)

,!

,J

I'

ct

( t

:0

f t

:1

11)

t">

;)'

.}

:j
"

1_-'

, ')

()

, J

( ,

III

( t

,1

tIl

'1

1)

( t

(j

,:

~.

._(J

(f)

III
!

"

III
.0
C

If)

l:l

:)

{lJ

"

,J

ni

,:J,

, !

'U

0
'1

( !

()

>-OJ

(Il

::

,;

ID
.0

'1

(t

III

(I)

()

PJ

1--"
, t

::J

(jJ

I"

(Il

>ll
f--'

t"'<~
~-"""

(f

'",

(lJ
::l

'J

Ul

I1l

o
o
::J

et

:r

:J

.0

(0

>-'

::J

.:

,r

il'

:J

;l

J
CD

o
::y

(l'

(D

1--"

Ul

()

(!J

1-')

c.,;

,t

'1

III

''J

(1

(Il

(1J

'U

: )'

:~J

13

,t

,~.

(l!

III

p~

:J

(!)

III

'1

t<

:)

CD

1--"

t:

()

"

(1"

:::l

,n
t:

0,

III

(II

(0

U'l

:tj
(D

~.

Cl.,

<

PJ
'1

'J

({J

(/l

1_-'

ro

ct

(j

( t

III

P-

(U
()

1--"

,)

f-~

;r

Ul
ct

J:::'

''l

(lJ

p,

,J

III

....

CJ

(f)

I:
r-

l'

:~

()

:y

;1
, t

Ul
W

, ')

PJ

,I

c..;l

'1

0,

CD
III

ell

(!J

III

,l
Ul
(D

'J

>->,

: J

(T

(j'

:,

(l!
D.

l1q

(D

III

:J

()

:.J

c:
:1

'<

()

::1

"

tt)

I'

I~'

,J

UJ

(I;

( f

:w

Cl.

'l

(I)

()

(t

:1

II'.

IJ

'J

PJ

",

(D

1_ ,

:1

:J
O.

:J

'1

:1

I:

C
'1

CL

rt

III

;l

()
([)

1--"

~
,-.

("f

(0

(Q

~.

( 1
Cl

"

Ul
Ul

I ~

III

(j)

Ul

()

(Il
I

In

III

III

0-

:1:

00

W
'0

')

,_&.

'1

u
:)

:~1

'0

:y

; J' cr

(J)

.......

tv

'1

({J

,J

C..;~

(\)

r::

'1 CJ

()

,J,

,J

:J)

1-

,t ,..

.......

t.:>

,n

:1 r::

- - - - - - - -

~
0

,t

,t'-D:::lUl __I
\0
I-~ (!) CD Ul Ul
,t-::J
f- J O(1.J::,tl 'U 0)
ct ;:.... CD ()
, .
---J
~ (t, Ul 0
,~ ,ll (f)
ct 0 '1 -
rt 1--" J ( t J:::' C c' Ul
Q.l
PJ
Ul
\ll --l
C ("T
:::l c3 CL ,)) f " ' Uq , t
, 0
III :;
=--,
(ll
'~Q.lCLCoomc:..:O=--'
A '1 ("T :::l ~ (!J
::J (f) ,1'
U ro ro:::l'
(ll
(f) Q.l
0
Q.l
Ul 0 l:; " ' 1 '
f-' '') ( t 0
'1 Q.l Ul '1
::J (!) 0 ," 0 0 C
(t~ :::l CD 1--" (1' "] Ul'
c< '1
'1
ct
...... '< 0. N :::l' m "0
'<
Ul
CD'--:::lOUl
Co.," Ul :::l (T :.J CD 0
0
(0 :J ~
O. \') H) ,1 C to
'1
W (T
("T CJ' C:J
('f"
"1 CD (T cr ::> 0 0, ,~' ct II) U) ,t
'1::SCCDP-
0 ;y ' 1 ' ,~.
U E3 ,", ("1'
,J. (1' :::l (D '';; 0 .-')
1--"
'1 ..... Ul
uq (11 :JO:::l
O'C(IlQ.lUlOc....
ftl
Q.l 0 0 .....
,-1' N Q.l C Ul r.l.
(1' '1 ro 0-.-1'

cr (1. CD
(Il 1--" O. Ul ro :::l"' rt
I-~ uq 0
rt
...... 0 ro
~ ro :::l' CD ro :J
0
:::l "1 :::l......
ftl rt
CO.-"
:::l
O:::lPJ
CJ:JOrt
Ul 0
("T ro
C 0 Ul 0 rt ::J ::J'
:J rt
(Il.-1' Q.l (J)' ,]
(!l
:::lU.D U (1. 1'\)
........ rt (D Q.l 0 0 ~.
C:', -1.:- C
:::l"'
:::lH:l'Jro
:JCDO:::l
(1" 0) CJ (1..
,~-.
' " ~: VJ .....
:::J
() III ct ct ;r> :: ()
(t
('1' :;' '< () (") PJ ,-. Q.l (!j
'1 ro
(1' 1.1) (" t
:::l '---' PrtO;Jf--> ....t
'< '1 ro ru (0

~
.......

Ul
\ t

:r
(I;

( f

:)

(/';

CJ

-J

C;.

,;....

c.'"

t...?

......

~
c..:)

:0

e;.

CJ

-...1

.......

;....>

c...)

......

tv

....1

CI)

t,.")

CJ

c.:l

,;....

c...;

........

t"

--.-.-~------

.-----~~-

(j

cr

)l,l()(J)C

o 0
c
)

:J
tn

(])

Cil

<

UJ

()
C

(J'\ ;-"

W CD

cr- "
t~

l:

;1'

ill

"1 :J ; ,
0. Oq III

:J' () -

'j

I\)

,.....()

(Il

,r-

(n

?,-

(T

)l,l

cr- III

Cil

::J cr- <....:; ill .)

,~, 'J CD
')
t~, Vl
<...; (D
0
:J rt

O III
;-',

JC: (1'

0)

:::::r

CL

,.,. ru tn
1----' () (1''0

cr

cr- ::'y'

H}

;-,':J ;-', C
;J :J ') ill

ct 0

CD
tn
tn

f-j

:J

,." P)

:::

J--' (1.
(lJ

(D

:)

,0 IJ'l

CL
'".
(t

oq C to .,.

(1) >lP) 0.0

..oO":J
;-', . ') tn .-. ( j .) C C
(D
tn 0 (1) 1-" :J '0 :.> c t

(fJ
(fJ

I----' ill 0

(fJ

>

:J

(0

U)

H)

,ll .)

,t

O. '1

(lJ

tnOC'jOWWo.
) CD C' ; , FJ
, f ' iJ
.-'}
:::::l t---'.
(j)
{D
CD ~ ............. .
tJ n....J n :J
( ) : } '1
, t U ::T
():Y (t lJJ ( t H' tn
:J' 0 CD
C ([) Cil III ~ >. iJ ( t

.-.

I:J

(1)W

DOC

ill:J
'TQ..Cill

O. 0 C II) :} ,3 (1)
(t;lC,1

([)

;-', ;Y '1.

X
(t

:J
IT

(1)

(')

')

')''S

o:Jc

.-' ct C
:"1

W cll ([)

(f

'< " ru

('"1

;)

(-I-

;J'

:Y lO

ru

(Iv

'1

(J

:)

101

(D

(T

" J ()

:J .--.r] W ...-- t .. C
(1. !Jl (D U) , t ') ')

.-. cr-

0- CJ C

;-'. CD

Cil

cr-

(T

,t

III ( t '1
1--"
.-'
:J C i l l O III :J
f--Jr t

( ) ct

ru'-

(fJ
(D
(D

ri'

0
H

:J

n.

". (()

U) ') ;)
C W "

cr ')

'1

:1

PI CO
:1 ,0

,tocn

;,Y UJ ,: ;) 0
(0

',CD

(Il

;)

f--J

n.

:::r

CD

::T

r..J

(1J

J--'.--.r]

,-".
ru

')

ru

OJ

:J [j) tn
(n

ru

(l.

:1

tn

(1'

1:

cr-

()

I'.'"
(:L

I\)

::. }

-t:::

UJ

OJ
:")
o.

I"

D,

CD

IlJ

l:

:y
:.r

~-,

:.)
0'1

ct

::r
(\J

t')

()

:)

III

;1'

:J

'0

t--'~

Cl

'1

tJI

:.J

1----'

(t

ru

(D

,1'

cr-

Ul

.'

')

')

'j

(J

UJ

"'."

()

-=

p.

0_

,ll

t"-A.

I'
t---"'.

;)
("'

,Il

:J

()

CD
:::

:J

(Pl
()"

:l':
::'T

'J

,J,

(IJ

()

III

U)

III

D.

CD

(J.

'1

{J

III

()

(V

~ .~.

'U
'( J

.J

'J

ill

()

:l

()
([)

(Ii

(J.

III
ltl

()

,( J

:1

1-

()

~u

'j

:J

.1
Ll

:J

:~:
IlJ

:y

'Il

.-~..1

to

:J'
(D

o.

~>

III

o.

,:

:.1

,, ..

()

( t

'U

III

()

( t

1-"1

:.u
t'J
:~

(;)

0,

:J

(--~

n
(

'J

l:

III
(Il

(I)

()

(n

'J

tD

co

(l

I t

'0

( f

()

(t>

.~'
:J

f--"

\IJ

ill

:J

:1

()
(D

o
H;

tn

,.

("t

(J

"

{:

U)

<D

OJ

( t

f~

UJ

t"
()

III

~1

<-:-~

(1.

:,

CD

ri,

ill

C
:1

ill
:.1
(f)

( t

,~,

,t

CD

,J

O.

(v

'1
(lJ

:}

()

Cl

'1

I[J

, i,

~:

1-')

,n

(1)

Vl

(LJ

, ')

,)

:1::

( t
~

:J
:y

(L

!--",

()
(jJ

(lJ
D,

([)

UJ

,1

,3

.- 'J

: :;

(\)

\1.

()

(fJ

'U

()

en

t--- J
(II

en

,
,'l

l
\.lJ

()

C!

:.J

,.J

li\

I '

'~

:J

II)

~tJ

U!j

(J
,)

',]

,:

, 'J

(;)

(Il

It

(J

ct

CD

.-')

~.

(l)

,(J

c)

C
1

:.J
i--

:y

(f/

:.1

(;

'-1

"

I~'

: f
(l,

, t

(J)

,-

i-oj

ID

I ...

([;

:;

:J

en

,1

0'

I',)

(J

lJ

II
,1

,J

1\1

U)

C f

c.. ~

(ll

(!J

<1

,,,

(j)

:J'
CD

'1
( )

,.,

:)

:>::

{ !

r--'

I:

(1-

;-',

/"

(rl

'.::

:)

,)

III

( !

fll
(
I

U)

:1

ill

;1

~"

( J,

'J

()

'J

')

,1

()

'U

:J
()

;[)

<

ID

{J

( t

'-).

{JJ

,J

.,)

(1)

UJ

:)

, ..
,..
, 'J

t-
0,

,f

,l.

rq

"'.,
'-J

Cl

III

tIl

[1J

(I.

f
I

:r:

, I

;..J-

:1

(ll

:::0

'1

t'

(i'l

:. y

nc.;

o
,:

( 1

, \

(D

,t

If

I"

, ';:

('

()

'll

(l

.,

"(f

trl

(Jl

(I

(J

tn
CD

-.J

llJ

c'

~:::

{JJ

:1

(jl
(j)

(.J

\
()

:J

:1

,0

:1
c

~~

<0

"II)

O'

(II

<",,'J

UJ
'U
U

III

:)

,w.

''l

,ll

(fJ

Cil

(/)

>~

()

()

,~,

1-->
"
D,

(fl

><

ill

U)

:.1

:..J

i\)

.t)

l~
,)

llJ

'J

"l

::. J'

11.

",

, --~j

(\J
III

(\J

(f

III

')

t'

<D
( )

;-',

en

,lJ

()

(j
(j

,J

t ...

(<..~ ';

'.J
,.,

>

t))

,J

."

'j

lD
<0

rt

:y
{ t

:::

'0

U'I

til

:>"

ill

f'

()

cr

:y

til

:1_-"'

(PI

'j

( t

CL
"

( t

()
')

I.)

I"

CJ

l"J

II)

Vl

III

f--_J
(II

'0

CIt

(I.>

~y

'U

( ,

tn

(I

:5'

.D

(t

(J

:'J

,d

()

to

({)

:)

(\J

(1.

:)
()

'1)

(j)

ill

'J
Il)

ilt
::'J

I'

"
tU

::. J'

(J)

0.

((J

()

(.1

;1

t--"

'J

'0
IlJ

:1

tn

: . J'

"J

I'

( t
(J

"J
-l

ru

(JJ
()

(!

P'

( )

"

III

f>

::J
o
:)'

()

()
"

"

'.,

'1
III
;)

.......

tot)

ru
CD

(n

()\I

ij

(0

~:

I"

()

tn

I'':;

:1
Cil

VI

:1

Ii)

to

(n

Ul

1-'

'(J

'U
(D

Ul

:y

0)

(t

.J

(D

:}

( ,)

:)

(t

...;

,.

r-"

Cl
()

-to:-

t)

1- ,

t"+;

w c

()

, 'J

I'l'

(l)

;:5 (1. O.

,ll

::'1

Oq

'1

:,

~-.J

~-,

Il)

()

u)

( t

:1 'l

cr

II)

()

r:

ru

tn
tn

(D

'0

tn '0

()

:y

''l

I:""l .-'

!lJ

t;:;TJ

tn

()

0..
C

<c",.J)

('"1

<

ru

,.._h

(\)

t>

ill
()

:)

0- 0
J

'1
ill

:)

1--" ill H''O

(j)

:1'
'--<

tr
,t

( t ()

1-"

ru

f--J
1--'
,1)

:J UJ

III

1-" :J ,'') f~
~J 0': O. IT (1)
:'.r t-.J.
f--J
W Ul (]) '\l
:.J
A' (J en :1 ( t 'U
() -t:.-;:5 C cr CD ') \ll ct

:J H
ill -

.c:

(1'

(D P

:J

()

')

:1fJ<ru

<.:?>

IT

I'

tn CD U<I
(t

I~

'--<

,J

([;

: ).

U1
U)

'J

(1)
(

2 11.

I:

i
:3'

s.
n '\
I

- . '"

G
0

Commission of

op::Jlon)

Caliro~~ia,

106

s.

903

936

(plurali:y
4-:8

u.s.

241

Ilsus:ai:'.::::! a ,
i

2 ':; :2 ::; S

s.

ff

o :~

Cl

"'
1 v'
I

1:1:0

Hi

I
I

15:

1G

!!

I.

17

I II

lS

at

1472

(~'..:o::':-:g

19

2::

......

"',

......

1:.+59 (0. C

20

i~pact

211

22\

23!

the

""" ............
......

v' ........ :::. ...... 1

as a 8:3tt.er of

ha'le fai

differences

t he
..... ... r""" " ' , ' ...... '~ i
;:.
'- "'" .., ..... ""'" ""'" .... a..J":" "'"

:~e

:'-21evisl.on

en
::"3.1.'

any
ca:1

'),1 I

I
1

25

that api=llied

t::e

2G

648 F'. S:lPP

1475.

11

27
4

I,

,'

1'

",-- :

'):
-,

3:

Y"\r"'\ l ' Y"'"""

5' .....

/""

.....

i-""";""'<:";::::'''';
.... !'#r '"' "-' _ ......

-,

other

cases

-,

.-.

'-'"

-4.,,-,,<

4-;""" -. ;..
- ' .1::::"
""

-'"" ..:::..........-., ."" ,

progra~~ing

~~ey

ca~

eC2st.

The Cities read these

::

10

11

12,
: 1

13 '

"- ,.

10,

IG: i
?i~st

lR

~ ,.... -;
' - ' ' ' - , ..... ".<..J.;.j ....

fc:-'c:'ng a

.,......, r'\ ...- ,...,.., ,

~''''''~')I'~"",,,:''''O~-' ,. ..

s;;eec~

,-"~~"",,'-,....J.U"';'-"_ ..... ,,,

19

p ri ::ar:/

20

in

:raQ:~:cnal

t~is

press,
is

f)~~Y';:l""""\y'\~

Vrl'-'~-'-''-'''-',

21

22

Se e

03 i
.... ,

2-1

are

p::c~

:. d .
,

~....,

.,...., Cl -'"'"I 4-

...... ...." .....

1 .r

...... '-'-J

5
!

of the

cha~!'lels

t..:l

:;y:;

t"

tv

t"
c.."

Cl

~J

3:
>D

= ::r
0

t"

t..:>

(D>D(")C
0.0 t-":l
ellCO,to..

:J :t
>D o..ro 1-"
CD ......
(ltj ro <: ~3 >D III ro
CD u ro 'oct{JJ{JJ
., ro ., f--J .....
::J~
(1.J CJ 0
0.
~l
., ()
CJ..
::::l

~~ ...

:l (1.J

,~

'1 >-3
:T
(tJ
:T
(J)

"

iD 0

f--J

(T

'l

f~

-:;

U. [fJ

CJ'l: ,.,
ro '~':J

"I

()
()

(!J

'V

:J

'U

(If

r '

cr-

III

:J

III

:1:

PJ

,r 0

::r

()

'1

(D

"J fl)

')

:J

:T :1

r" III ([) (I.>

:)
:J
i
J

()

(t

" =

[JJiYI

:) .... ~

()

(D "1 ""'J ,_ D.
f ' (D

([)

0.. f--J
000
,-<. C <;
,I' 0' Il)

()
(y~

o (;)
Ll

<:;
(])

a,

')

",

()

:.J

o,..
cr

()

fl
il

(D

,.
: .1

f '

Ul4

l1i

( t

OJ

>-3

::ro
0'
<;
,~,

cr

:i;

:r

::<

( )

III

,
,,
(

l~

,,
,)

l.
,ll

,1

: )'
w

:y
}-~.

'J

:.l

LL

()

()

W
liJ

W
in

:,

~-, )

(V

(D

()

, 1
(Il

)-"

;::!

()

()

: J'

I,'

,[)

{jJ

III
0'

:)

:)
(l)
)-

..

.<:

:T
C,,~

Ul

c
(;]

rlJ
:.J

O.
()

:!.

iD

<

<D
"

0,

>-"

:J

c..;

UJ
(j)

'0

()

:3'

iC]

'eJ

:J
III

PJ

(D

()

,~

, 1

()
([)

:1'

()

IU

tl!

:1

(I)

;)
(D

(;1

,~

, t

:r
III

"
(;)

(IJ

",

,J

,.,

:r:

0,

"
III
l-'
C.l.

<,

:1

( t

:..J

: )'

"

tl!

()

(D
(fJ

(fJ

II)

:1'

II)

(J'

tlJ

')

I '

<D

~,

')

U.

"

ill

Ul

(lJ
1'1)

()

( 1

,"

()

,lJ

\
,1

,[)
,I

(I,

: }'

()

( t

\ll

I:)

~u

( r

w'

(IJ

( J,

O.

c:
Ul

:1.
'

':

j~

,1

()

(J

I)
"

,ll

,1

I)

(J

I)

CJ,

,j

i" ~

,l

III
I

,]

III
:1

]( I

(I,

",

(I;

'l

""~ .

:
~

I:

[j)
f

'U

IU

ll.

It,

\.

:)

d)

'(J

(U

'I
IV
.)

U)

::
OJ

, J

I J

'U
'J
c)

,-

t/ i

cy

..c::

:,

, __J

-)

: j'

,1

(;J

(G

()

rt

'(j

\ t

~.

(D

')

:1

Ii)

()

'<

'j

A~

' "

:J'

(n

C
'U

(lJ

III

D.

(D

,U

()

()

()

'U

0'1

'.
(lJ

.<:

:r
"

\:.,

, 1

, '.

('J

;~r

III

~,

(.

( 1

f--~

'j
(lJ

)J

<D

()"

.')

f'

()
f'

",.1,

(n

()

(D

(lJ

(Il

>--<1

:j'

UJ

~l-=-

()

c
cr

>-',

~.l

')
r

CD

( t

'U

.'-

(\1

,,

::l

"J

'-y

(;1

(li

UJ
Ul

( t

:J
U'l

,1

;J

:1

;1
'u

'j

')

()

II)

:l'

1 -"

:y

(~I

f,

Il)

{<

III

'U

ct

t;

~,

"

:1

ct'

')

"

()

<D

(J)

....:

()

I"

(jJ

;.l

()

(jJ

'J

(f)

\11

\~

(f

,0

(0

"

( fJ

UJ

( t

>-',

(Il

([J

:..J

.... "

:J

')

t-

oq

, I

t'-"

([)

~,

"

,J.

')

:"T

()

()

,)

t-_ J

~)'

t~,

(lJ
,

Ul

11)

III

III

[n

:r

o
II)

:)

( )

:)

(;)

.,

"

ill

",

"'J

!D

"
:r

~.

;)

')

0'1

'0
:.J'

<~
({)

:,J

(,,::

III

III

~,

cr

O.

Il'
, f

<

(f)

O.

Pl

,IJ
CD

;I

, t

L __l

:J

'j

,t'

:T

~,

(ll

U'

(JCj

(JJ

:J

:,)

r---,

ro

cr

()

III

::

::T

, r

( r

"

o
co

.......

tv

IJ:.

.....

C
f-"
Il'

()

:)

( I

!ll

\.D

(;1
---.~~--

oq

o
III

Cl

(I)

:y

:J

11)

(D

0'

(f)

, r

(t)

(I)

.)

"o

o
:-,

:l

1D

(l)

,J

,~ :

()

{/J
([)

"

"

1"';

II;

( I

rt

{ t

;1)

()
, 'J
)

:r')o

()

'J
( f

Ul
--..]

")
(jJ

tlJ

-1

I\)

(D

,D

Il)

:J

:1'

"

;>..:

( t

(lJ
()

Olj

>D

(;)

Ll_

f--';

( t

00

(j)

!ll

: l'

ill

U
C

co(",;

,"

C
III

'-<

D,

(j)

()

r-'

(j

("1

III

Il)

,
,l
l
,:
:1
')

f--'

:l l:; ::::l ;:::. III >-,' (j)

{JJ 'U ;::! ( t
'0 W, '<

0..

:1

\ll

{ltJ

(1'

>D 0

(n

;J"

(;)

f "
L
W
,J

()

()

:.J

a
a

1
)

0..

;J

:J
, 'J

')

()

::
O>D'O'
CO'"1uJ'O
:J 0 0
C 0
OC<OO'O
1-" cr 1-" 1\,) f--'
r~
{JJ
.....
::r >-" H'<> () C

:J

d)

I '

cr

(f)

(f)

(D

cr:J~

, ..

(Ii

(")

{JJ

(/J
(

,"

:) ;)
~j >D

'<

:)
,t'

<I)

1:

([)

CJ'

!ll

:1

:)

..;;

I
(D /.-, .. r III

(n

,ll

Oq
U

ct ( t

([)
()

,v

(ll

III

~,

:J 0

t""'t ~

~~~,

:y

()

:J"

:, :1._

'=l

<:.:
,,10

()

<::)

--- ---

I'

.~.

()

()

It'

......

.......

U'

<I;

Ii) -

......

,'1

ii'

( I

I"

C.l,

:)

......

:1

')

W
()

......

11)

: j'

(V

.....

(-'."

(j)

......

:y

()

"

l~

.....
(;1

---------_.-

<t

:)

'l

Cl

(lJ
()

>-"

'j

......

-1

o en

.......

:.0

:l 0.. :.J
0 ,., ,t

~ro

"

.......

f~-'~)

:j ()

(Jl

:T

CD

o
ro "
(Jl
::rO{JJ O O O " J
( j ..~. '~~
:J :!: 0
(D :"J ( f
;:t> {JJ
()
(1" :'Yr-, <
(1'" :~J'
.~
(j)
:}'
(U
::
W
o
;-,
(
)
")
()

~ 0

'Cl

......

11' l!/

~~~.

0\

tv
o

CD

r..l
n,
<:

(j)

:T

t..:>
.......

"j

n' >D

t"

,~.,

(l'J

t..:>

( )

, j

( )

- ......,
~

::0.

"-'

. . es.s
:::0.

ess
: 5

1472 & n.12,

wou~::!

t~f~ic:'1

result.s regardless

s~ea~er

fc:--'ce a

0:

~...;he~her

the a2cess

forego

~o

. s.
I

10:
i!
11 .1

belie'les is

\!

12; I

"""''-'',;J ""'::::: -

-..; r-' ,-,. '- '"

,..., n

13 ~
I

11'
15

S'7

1G

...............

..-""!/'"" ..... -.::l~-

...... v

,.....

..

"""'

...,

'""'

..... ....., .... ::::. .....

..... ...., .

,......,

,-...

r"'I

.....

. ...; -' -

""

,......,-,..

'-''-'''oj"".

'-~

.,...

.....

--1

-"

-' ............ :::!

"" -- ......

c.J ........... _:;;

17

18

proc

19

gua~ar.~

exe~2:'sed

es of a :ree 8ress

20
21

cha:'ac:erize:: as

22

CQU:: :-:2,S
sue:: an infl~ence or chilli~~
The re ''';2 S
speaker's content.

be

S~;:;;e=e

23
i

r
ui~ed
:-:-ec: en
is

21

s~s:ai~;ed

2,c:l.1al
prl::3ry

s~otl-t'i~;~

of

t'-'

cc

t'-'

~J

~
Cl

~
c..:'

~
~

~
(..)

(J

t-')

ru

1--'

o
:t:

:::l
<:T
~

''-.

-'tj

fD

0 ..
W

'J
III
f ~,.
j
.. j

er

'"~,

.o

('to

III

::>

er

~~

(lJ

(1J

cY
I--'

'1

iD

F")

[f)

:::l
()

'j

III

~l.

;1
UJ

( t

W
"

( ~

0'<

"

:1

(lJ

( t

=.)

ex>
OJ

'11
Ul

{1'

o
:<:
~-Y

"CJ

'l

;1

t--~.

: ) ..
w

,1"

Ci

'U

ru

:1"

,c

'U

"""

r .. ,

(f.;

:l:'

-I

( t

C]"

:.1

) __J

( L

ctJ

(D

(l)

,.,.

CD
if,

v,

::

C
:::l

(t

:1
( t

c_).

( t

C
\1.

U'I

:J
((l

:::l

,f

(ll
H)

(Ii

o
''l

OJ

,r
(t"

(J'

CD

r\)

II

(li

J,

Cl

'l

ttl

<0

Ct.

Ct.

([)

".

:Y

IrJ
,l

(Jl

(J'
1-"

( t

III

( r

~y

II)

(ll

(j)

<t

<l
ill
( )

( t

:r

:.1

,,

'U

I'
P,

It.
J

;1

,ll

, t

.,.

()

:r

'U

:1

~}

I:1

(')

( t

(;)

, oJ

en
'u

,"

:J

:-)

(l

t,,:

(I)

( f

(v

:,'

:1
)

.,

(J

\ f

1"--'-

,;

;)

,I

Ul

1\)

r"

... '.

I--'

(D

(J\

,..

1--'

(fl

,j'

:}
cr

Cf

0)
W

:I
J
CD

'!

,>.

I'

( t

( t

,1

,""

(V

(X)

Il!

:::l

(t

'1

iiJ

( r

(I)

1\.1

'f

't.
(J

:::l

:1

(I!

:l
u.
;J
([j

()

:1

: l'

, f

, 1

, r

'1
(,l

(0

\II
L~ )
()

:\

P}

(I)

( 1.

, oJ

1'1

(11

\JI
,f
t.)

'1

Il)

:1

, f

.11

()

,'
(';

, t

, f

'

:1
(;.1/

{j)

tJ)

\:

( f

'J

:1

()

III

If)

,~.

(n

;I

;>:
"

;J'

( t

I,

I,

(f
)

:, ..

1/)

(ilj

r'1

Il!

I:

'()

'J
Ii)

,1

'1

(v

()

if)

'u

( !

(/)
()

(l.

..

1'1.

U
L
'J

C/l

:1
( )

It)

'0
1

\.;

:!.:
o

, t

, r
: l'

~ LJ

P.
III

'Ij

<:
,~.

)Jo

,'

.l

("

:-:

;1

( )

:.Y

;1'

In
I)

\..u

,1

;5
'J

:J

c..:

"-1

")

III

( r

(f)

CJ\

'()

, \11

C~

\)1

\:

III

\tj

:::l

, t

'.

(l)

'q

, ..

Ld

" J

.1

1','

CD

(;)

:1
( f

CJ

( )

:I
I

0\

t",,:

(fl

(n

.1
( )

(J

O.

I '

I')

,'

(:1

~D

d)
( f

(i)

'1
C

'U

"J

,J

'j

,1

( 1

(Il

Ul

'1)

'

, '.

()

, 'J

( 1

ct

I \

(j,

:)

'U
I'
III

m
<.

,,'
, t

r"

'

d,
,I

UI

'0
C
'J
'U

\.)

\]1

(.,

,to

I L

(fl

..
IV

"

\11

"

()

lil

(j)

"

.J

:1

:r

()

(.)

"

'),

:::;

"

<r

( f

(1.

q)
(J,

,I)

( f
, 'J

=
(D

>.

()

:1

~-

III

')

"

(l.

'U

;1

"

:)

:!

(\)

.rl

, l.

,"

:J

'0
'1

, 'J

, t

:1

n.

,""

c:
ef)

}---",

:J

1-.1

r->'

<.;

,~

'J)

:1
,1
.1
til

(fl

:1
:)

:1

t.J

d,

.1

Ul

()

([)

(1..1

:::l'

III

'\

;1

IlJ

, r

CF

IlJ

:::l

',,1

f. '

VI

()
(t

cr

10

:!

(r

( t

Il)

t.JJ

, ,

It

([)

I))

C)

( r

;1

ci)

pJ

l.

'j

( t

D.

)1

()

'D
"1

(!)

,n
,;

II)

...

:y

(1)

en

;1

( t

,11

:!:

:J

()

In

([)

, ..

{t

~ .. ~

(D

,1

:.1

c....:

t .. 1

.
w

el)

;1

,11

()

()

.....

H)

'

l .. l

([I

to

"

()

("I"

:1

C
;1

()

0 .

([)

()

;3

o
c

~,

'j

\d
Ii)

:::l

(ll

(!)
.'t)

(J

to

([,
,)

: 1

;1

~.1

.~.

:1
t--

o.

t-~

t-l"J

(.1

~
I,"

cr

()

C
'J

III
'J
/,

Li)

~.

tJ,

.,~.

co
.... 1 C';
--._---,

(fl

:J

( t

(t>
'1

(!l

(()

It

CD
l~

:lc:

'j

;1

.:::

'U

t-.-

\J

()

:r

:)

,1

(Jl

;f-

to

,1\1,

f .,

(V

,0

U'I

(Jl

<:

(j

, ..

;J'
III

')
()

(1)

'J.

<t

t.::)

?,.

:)

:Y

(ll

..,.,.1

ct

<D

-l

Pl

>-'

(Il

('

11>

je

()

'1

:1

(I)

()

III

(I)

.......

t.J

o
'-1)

"j

CD

:r

(I>

.......

CJ

, j

,1

'0
'U

("I"

:)"

........

(L

,"

<D

:,1

:..)

<D

..

C/l

()

:,

'1

n,

( t

()

(;J

(j)

(f

(IJ

( t

{].

( t

,,'
.J

(t

( t

,;J

(IJ

,;......

Pl
()
([)

r"
:::l

......

(..11

Ul

:::l
0 ..

([J
()

( t

~:

(j)

,><

( t

III

.~

:j
o

,1

; 1

( t

(/l

: ..J"
I" ,

"
:.3"

:1

:s

III

(l)

'0

:J

\1)

<D

(i)

"
0\

:::l
CL

'1

rr

(r

pJ

((l

O.

O.

"1

ill

(1)

:1

::r

"1

CL

~s

t-'J

,<

(l)
(.,.

tJ,

......

Cl

OJ

J--.,J
(lJ

III
,r

(lJ

.... 1

:::r
I--'

er
r:

()

:::0

()

:::l
' ')

-- - -

~
0

~.

~
......

OJ
e1'

"1

"1

~
t..:J

(0

, !

10

II)
(,)

:J
).

()

,"

IV

Ii;

.'

... "

- ....

-~

. . . - r,

~
...... ~"_: ~

"

'.....,.

..... ::

oJ

ss

s
~

mO'1i e house

c d. eli '/ e r

0:1
s

-""'r"\'-"1;1')"'

....... '>-41 ........

5::S

.'

..

:'"' -= :--. ::: - ..

13

:::.-

1G

1S

17

f'""I,..... ......
__

1R

puJl:'

19

0:

20

Ct. a:

21
22'

........

'-'

__ "'"' ..... .:;

-...-

"""

._"" ...

....
".J'

""" ....
~

J I..t

s.

106

sr.e~s

2230

2 ")10,
L

, .........

1935,)

23

24

ir.:per:7lissi8le

25

right to

access

ope:-'3:::'Or"S

deter~ine

chan~el

wne:-'e and

req~ire~ent

~ne:1

fir's:

speaks.

Ccurt finds

As '..Ji ttl the

t~is

to be a

. ,I

.s

.~

1i

42~

U.. s.
::;:-,.....,-::-\,.'

III.
The

t'"',

s ::: e

Y'>.-I .,

\""I ..

,..... ....

"s~ate-o:-the-a~~"

syste;:-:.

3.

.
,

........ .:l Yi

.
,0 .-.

..-.J. ,-,._

J.

11
!\

12: '
, 1

13 ~ i,
, I

1~

'r

.' v
,

17
se !'""./ ice s

1S

::.

tra~s:e~,

19

cables

20

..,

::

2..r2

,"",

...
--

" ..

tr'

21
s '-' 2 :. e - J

22

;.'"' - ': :: e - 2. ::-' :

23
21 i I

govern~e

~al

speech

v. O'Brie:J,

regu

ncncc~~unicative

aspects of

the standard enunciated in Uni+.:.ed

u.s. 3hvi

1 968 ).

"7

10

Century Feder31 II, 645 F

,i:,

cc::s~,

2
- ~.-. -,.:::.
:::..-....J

~,.

, \ r'"

Y"~

...... '"

-'

- --:::::

....

""

:"""

-"'

""" ......

---"">-" .....

.............
"," _')
'.,.- ...........
._

-oJ

-:::::

__

~-~--

..

:C"..-.,.::!.::::,
J. ;

391

U.S.

a':-

-~

""'1-" ......
~

'-""

377

10' :
11

',,'
s::. : :. s :"" _::: '-"

, I

s:
\ 1

13, i

1-1
15

I
1

i
Hi'

17

jus:i:; ::-. e

lS

t e : e "J i

19

477

20

U:lleSS

3 : :: ~

.:::. " ...., .-. , "'\

""''-' """ .......

lS

See ic

is that

21

all t!Je

22

features

23

CTV operatJrS

24

~l

;:;UJ

25

2G

::.:. e '/2

~~rt

Jud

nt at 1

... C

C10;,:a.:n

See De:-'endan.:s

of Motion for Partial

The Cities provide absolutely no

27
28
11

Su~mary

probat~ve

~
c.r.,

~
..... 1

C':>

0..

o
o

.,
o

rv

......

:)

-,C
'-3

:r

r"

r"

:::l

0..

rv

:.:r

(lJ

o
......

en

:,'
fl)

(Y

,~.

n.

"

"

."

en
CO

t"
(!>

,I

(t

4.. ... )

:j'

0\

UJ

...

([I

<~

cD

0'

(t

:1
O.

ell

CD

UJ
,.~

(t

:1'
<D

.. "

()

0,

:J

"

0
'1

()

Il.

'0

;.1

:::l

"

(jJ

"

~]

({)

III
:1

::l

C"

0
I

()

:::J

(:;

>L

(r

'J

<tJ

CD

I"

;j

(t

';

CD

'j

0'1

([)
.D

.D

<'

Vl
CD

.,.....

CD

c:

~')

<'
::J'

I~

<'

ru

CD
!Jl

;j

;:3'

:r
(])

(')
t-~~

....

(1

.,....,

.,

CD

[j)

()

::J

::J'

(])

:r
!Jl
(0

(D

."')

::J

......

[j)

C
, ..

(D

;:l'

to

(1)

'j

!Jl

'}
(1)

(l>

r.::

"

''''l

[j)

~.)

(1*

aq

;:J
(!J
{f~

(!J

UJ

'J

'<

()

(j)

:1)

'rJ
'0

,o1

0
~.)

V1

:r

""

(,)

(]J

(])

,I

,t
III

(V

.<1
L

,1

:)
D.
I

()

'"
C

,I

C)

;:J

u.

o
o
o
o
o

!Jl

()

:J

, I

>-"

( I

:J'

::J

CD

'.

,1

I:

[Il

(jJ

Il'
(0

(I

'0

( r

(()

"

;J

U'

ii

(I;

'j

(!)

()

;>,

'"

Il)

fD

:j
([J

,:

.... :

0,

w
:

::J

0..

~l

(t

..

n
:J
(n
o

iI
(il

( f

j'

"

'l

.;

,,)

II)

\ll

'j

.J

:1
,1
( I

(u

,..

I')

,:

l;t,

;1

to

(I

;J'
, r

u'
)~

'j

:l'

:)

II)
" J

II)

d)

( J

( )

(f,
"

", 1

'II

.,

.
)

c;

,
:J

lu

~.

(J'
I,

(Il

()

(I)

III

I.

IS!

:1

.1
t).
(I)

:1

:)

,"

( )

III
( r

It}

~lJ

CD
(t!

<D

, J
I

( I

( f

:J

, 'J

:)

()
( f

\ .
j.

( ~.

'J

,f

.1

( I

III
ill

"

Il.

dl

(Il

, 'J

il
.,)

"

;1

pJ

\~

(Il

III

,n

,I

D,

(\l

.....

:J

if!

'J

U,

(U

PI

to

([;

1- .....

::J

.,
,1,.,

:1

'j

til

.J

~l

, '.

,[)

\ .

('J

()

,!

:"

.J

ill

:1

l:J

,~.

III

:J

.l

, r

()

(L)

(jJ

'(l

III

{d

.,.u

,.
t:

:)'

'J
<!

<f

D,

;j
,1

(l.

'( )

......

CJ

(,]

El

III
::J

,I

:1

:J

())

:)

U'

(if

:J

"

U)

.
.,

....

,:

(D

, r

(I)

I"

',)

10

'U

()

([)

'r)

( f

O'
,ll

I"

'j

[j)

( r

III

1.1.

CD

;:.,

.J

.)

.....

CD

In

I:

'j

, t

, f

.i l

;)

[;)

," ..

:)'

;)'

ill
1/,

ilJ

'l

,I)

:,

( t

"

(il

,a,.

l,:

I.)

, I

:)

>--'

[j)

, r

()

~j

()

"

.. J

''1

tv

l t

:J'

([l

,t

(t

III
'--I

(1)

(t

0)

,I

(lJ

:.r

U'

"

tJ

(jl

11)

.".

III

::J

III

;)
()

.1'j
\.

( r

(il

')

"

0<)

,J

'h

:J

:1

'<)

!Jl

(u

v.::

,v

,r

('

OJ
f-

'U
\'

,I

"

'j

{/J

\1l

(v

>-",

:J
[1

;)

0)

"

I:

'()

(1

:J

'.

(j)

"

"I

, t

~.

'll

l'

:r

0,

Cl)

()

ct

(j)

.J

".

:J

0\
I

,I(l>

'j

Ul

:.l

,"

d)

'0

0-)

.~,

'q
'J
iD

(Il

{ I

(j)

o
o

(j)

, t

UI

'J

, ..

.,

10
I
Pi
'l

()

{t:;'

CD

,Ci
I.

, ..

"l

....rt

(Y:j

p)

'J

:J

.(1;'

, ..
U'I

(jJ

(j)

>-",

()

::J

<'

;.J

U'

,1

-<

"

'J

([)

( I

<'

II)

!Jl

C)

PI

~ )

II)

:)

(j)

10
I

!O

()

, 'J

UJ

:J'

'J

, L

,"

(1)

(I

( I

'J

'"

.')

(j!

II:

CD

0'
!Jl

(,'J

to

o
o

( r

~r

(f

l~

f~

ell

::J'

Il)

""

<'

III

(!)

( J,
III

, ..

C
'U

.]

( t

et
eD
()

([)

()

C)

(')

, ..

c.:l

'I)

<'

......

C':>

-1

(jJ

:J

('1'

()

(t

(1'

1-')
.,

1-'

,~.

(j)

{f}

:J

Cj)

!Jl

()

'l.
I"

, ..

i1

0
(U

:1

"

III

r"

(I
t- 4 ,

ill

:1

::J
W
::J

I"

()

: )'

t-_J
I,)

co

<:.:l

(I

'0

(L'

(t

( I

'j

;)

:.)

\11

,"-~'

:J

'J

"

')

;)

:1

;J

"J

([>

~._1.

()

,t
:.1'

Cl.

(!l

:1'

:1
0,

(1)

"

"

>--'

~1

'']

(\J

:J

(I

'1

ev

Ui

(y
O

:f

::;

~ j

UJ

C!'

,t

::.J'

().

~J
(t

III

(!J

~..

...,.,
PJ

:j

()

01'
;:1"

!Jl
(])

'~

()

0..

ct'

0,

~",

.,

,1

et

:J

., "o

:J

""J

.......
o

.......

.......
tv

r:

III

f'~

::J

.......

il

(jJ

......

(!)

I~'

(ll

....

0,

(... :

~=-t

,0

) 'J

\U

"

f"

CD
"

IV

'Cl

t.<t~

c.:,

C':>

.,

'0
III

......

.......

-1

:IJ

(])

( t

"

f'

'0

ef)

'1

(1)

!Jl

v>

W
:::J
o

cl>

(l)

1:
l

Ll

: l'

......

(])

(D

([)

[,?

rv

.,

"

:J
()
C
'1

:J
ct

i'"""

CD

()

.,

<D
Cr

::J'
'--:;

>-')

.,

"

(,1

<:.:l

III
11'

- -

.......

<'
0

:1'

(])

,~

t-.J

<'

It
(j)

'0

!Jl
<&>

,--'

, 'J

(j)

:1

( t

,,)
, r
( t

:J

,:

()

'J

"

'.

{jJ

10
U;

to

10
c..;'

CJ

-J

~
>+-

(T

::r
(!)

2to

o
,T

O.

t-',

~
1-,) ~
.......

1<

I:n
<D
D.

Ul

,t

:"3'

~u

(1)

f-'

(j)

IlJ

IT

::J

iLl

(T
~-~.

''l
' 'l

:J

0,

(j)

:1

:J'

:J'

()

~-".

.;

(;

I'"'
(r

\()
() )

Cil
\0

Ul

()

.1.

LA!

l)

W
,l

( ,.

:J

(j)

:.>

("T

cr

(1)

III
cr-

:J
D.

,.........

{/J

(j)

,T
(j)

III

,....,

'-<

(j)

::J

,"

I..

(~l

flJ

U)

.}

Ul

(f)

(J.

(lJ

,'.
i~

1-"

.!.=

l.-'J

n,

,u

'J

(fj

11)

(r

(,.

:Y
C)
t,

"

o
o
w

a,
l.-')
\()

\0

III
0,

O.

C..
LtJ

C
In

.",
Ul

ill

'l)

,)

.'

(fJ

Cl

:I
III

,lJ

r"

(J

'j

('

\.:

,1>

; J'

(I

, t

III

,:(v
(

;.'

rt

III

( !

Ul

to(::

1;

Ul

:.1

~:

(u

1"--'.

, t

()

([J

: l'

,1

'}

'l

:)

:,J

UJ

'U
'0
U
')

( r

.;

ill
oq
L

:J

,r

:5

III

o
'j
n.

:l
D,

,.."

1"-"

:J

:1
it)

()

:1

,1

()

'j

,n

c:

Cl.

:--)

PJ

"

(ll

,-f

:J

\:

...,

t-

c'

'j

:J~

\I)

fl)

),;

(),

O.

(;)

....

t-~

t.J'

U'l

cr
III

,-"

"

";y

:J

(v

()

([J

'U

:,J

",

," '
(])

",

(lJ

, t

()

(u

'1

{Il

,,'
III

,~

<D

<.,

(0

III
,,~

:.1
Ul

'1

(J)

,I
t .. :

;1
'()

U
UJ

u,
:1

U)

<_1.

....

'1
f"

(j'

W
(IJ

:)

UJ

:1

\,

11>

,>

Ol

(/)

,.J

,lI

III

,.:1

:l

\ ,

([J

([)

~
()

tll

(I!
, J.

C.L

[!

,)

I
( I

;)
W

I.
J

(,c/',

'j
).i

.,

~j

c.;

:)

~ )

(J

,
(h
([)

,
I)

')

( J

,.

1"

:)

(J

'

,)

,.'

(d
([)

(v

III

'"
liJ

\.

([)

()

,"

(j'

:J

III

'J

'j

f "

( I

(l)

,"

, 'J

(J

:-Y

,I>
f'

,,,

:J

\:

;1

If'

:1)

U)

~1

'lJ

,)

'r)

, t

:r

f~

"
(\J

, 'J

( t

{h
{JJ

,
I

f\)

()

('

C.L

III

rr

")

( I

<, '

Cl
t

(}.l
'1

f'

(l.

(J)

()

l
.~

~,

:J

')

n,

:J

, 'J

(!;

f,l
(J'l

(D

~)J

II)
tll

tll

III

(J

ill

(J'l

.;
(fJ

(.

<1;
I.)

:l

:J

,.

La.

( )

.L

( I

()
'j

'J

I"

(J]

(J

fll

( t

I'

()

( I'

:,)

~J

C)

,I

III

~ 1)

(t'

t-")

n,

<,

'I)

(f

'U

( t

''l
>-"

Ul

'j

III

cr

fl'

'C)

'.

(1.

~"

< ~

PJ

o
t

\1)

( )

(I

ill

(..1.

.r

f"

rt

(j)

ct
()

'1'1
P)

')

:J

{f}

~ "~J

(I

, t

.1'

"

:..y

/0

t--~

,'1
w
::)

(1)

Ul

><

.:
(D

ur~

:J

'}

L
0.

,r

([)

(!)

\>-"

"

'1

."

:..>

t- ~.

r::

.'

\1l

,"

,1o

'(J
I..J

;':1

(j)

(II

([J

Ul
C

,1'
','

. :::

,j

(t

)',

""
o

U
<D

()

'j

,,~

C;

"
()

"1

III

.;...

,.i..

"')
()

()

(n

'1

, ..
:1

o
rt
,",

er

( t

",

(1'

'0
'1

:-'

Cf
'J

Ul
,t-

UJ

([,

(11

),

'j

UJ

o''"

( 1

II)

ill
:1

,1

r'

~:

(lJ

:l

L
'J
( 1

f"

~.

(' )

:1

(n

:J

,I

It

,}

IJ,

(Jq

, r

:1

~~~J

:)

IU

(I)

t-

"

( t

'J

III

~;

(j)

:r

({)

'lJ
()

(I

:.1

(j)

{t

'1

, !

'u

([)

,)

:J

W
W

''l

,1.

pl

(t

rr

, )

(Y

t',

""
<

\0

f-'

:'!.

(\.J

1Ft
"
III

!I)

:)

....

,I

'()

0.)

:1

"

ill

,:

)",

()

il)

(;\

<
f"
n.

>:

(j)

U
'1

!D

n.

t.<

e>
00
---1
------'"

, 'J

'1
CD

,')

U.

(!)

UJ

, r

II)

rl.

, !

'Il

:1

(j)

:,

III

(J

(I)

,lJ

,:

'J

,I
.~,

'X]

'j

(I.

(/)

".
Il.

,1

uq
,~

"

:J

(J'I

( )

flJ

('t

~:

'-<

( I

rv

()

t]
W

;1

<~

(1

(D

(\)

\1.

(J'I

()

(I'

:s

'U

(,.

til

cr

'1

0'

III

t.

cr

CJ.)
Iv

(l

Ul

~.J

'J

()

II)

\0

I'

([J

(IJ

.,

()

til

0,
(1.

\!)

:l'

"

()

C~

{r

U,
U

(J'\

el)

n)

, 'J

III

;l

, ,.

\.

II'I

([)

(1)

1-"

I'
lil

H)

til

)'
fl)

LAJ

vJ

'l
( !

'l
W

(I)

CO
W

,.'

, !

,II

'1

:l
il)
:I

(1J

(I

( I

()

O.
:.J

')

, ..

, 'J

(1

...,

\J
I'

(fJ

:j

"
'),

<

:1

()

D,

"

ill

~u

II,

'l

()

:)

UJ

,l

(,
0
'l

CD

.......

tll

(lJ

( J
( !

'l
()

(1.

'j

CJ

\()

1 ' rJ

[j)

I,'

()

:l
(I)

III
iI

,n

I,

(lJ

r\)

("T

,-r

(.1.

(I

cr

([J

,1

(lJ

......

1..:l

C:J

jll

UJ

.......
>+-

c.;.

I ..

Il)

.-.J

:s

'1)

\[)

<~

([I

(]J

'IJ

'-1

~:l

()'l

.L.

Cl

:y

'()

'~

.......

cl"

)"

))

...... 1

,1

10

~,

CD

O.

:J'
(D

I ... J
Ul
tlJ
o .,
,.,
(J
()
I
Ie:
.l
'u
LA)
'J.

1~

III

,1'

"
III

()

1-''>.

~-::

H;)

::-0

~1

4.

t-~.

lAJ

0
Ul

----

~ I:..:)

1[.

,)

( I

, I,

/'

....

~2

33

r>""::'~"

-i

r'I"'\

r"

'>

.",

"~',",,

.,

""

;:

,:

',-.

,:

1I

J '""

21

i,
:3:

..-,

..... ---,
-..'

-:"

......

,_...........

'-'

-...-.

........ 1

,J ....:se

-,

tax" was to ir:pact only

The Cour'::.

11

d.

,,...
..., ...

"'"'

.....,.""j./

,-,

~ r-, -

-.,..-,

-:..:

-i

'-.J

'"'

If
,

"'"

,.;.-,

"....,

..

"""-->..;:) .....

'-',..... ""'"

~r'ess

h,.

11

in

"""

"'\

12

'I

e.

13

14

:,......

"

....

15
16

reve~ue,

17

by a general tax

was

C8~~

a .,
~

If>

~,

19

Star rationale to inva:ida:e

20

provisions

21

Infer

22

Aut:;ori+'

. .
,

......... +-

:~e

Cr~~~a~2e's

?"'.2d

'1'-7

(0

(2d

Ci~.

i93~),

o :~
(W.D.

Pa.

,
,
...... ,....,

-'-".l

financial

Cit.ies

t~e

23

24

-- -,.

::::.!-'r' .......
--.::. ....

1987).

Gannet: upneld a

and

659

c;
o

5S'J

rev~nue-raising

f~e

imposed by the Me'::.ropoli'::.an Transportation Authority

2G

on the placement of coin-operated newspaper vending machines

')-, I

28,1
14

tv
~

t-.:>

tv

c:
:J

o
:J
01
er
0--"

c-t

c:
c-T
0--"

o
:J
Q.J
I--'

t-.:>

tv

~l

c-T

:r
>D

,r

'0

:J

')
,~

(j)

(lJ

(0

...---...
O<l
:J
Cll

c-T

:y

(T

,~

0--"

(J,

er

J.

(D

rr

(fJ

(t

G1

,r

=-,

n
~~

n
I--'

CD
Q.J

.,
I--'
<..~

o
u
(lJ
~ll

,T

o
')

<

()

L1

:J

I~

EJ

(ll

0--"

~s
(lJ

<

fl.)
I~'

CT

<..~

0--"

0.

rJ
I--'
(lJ

'"

()

o
o

1-"

(ll

~,

~'

[J

(ll

'U

(fJ

()
(fJ

fl.)
')

( t

II)

(ll

:J

I "

(II

~:
(n
, !

, -,

().

; J'

"

(ll

( I

l-<c:

fl.)
(t

, I)

,t

II)

U1

",

(u

"

:1

III

'j

U'

'j

(1)

11)

II)

:1
rr

( !

'J

.
,'

,',
()

III

II.

(ll

,1

(IJ

,'

[I.

(1,

, :,

'j

III

I.

:J

(t

(ll

,t

(1"

:J'
([)

(lJ

I-~'

:.r

0--"

D.

(fJ

~J.J

( t

(fJ

:J

CD

('

't)

'u

()

,f

;}

l<

::

,
,
I
rq
,

~,

eD

( I

;)'
()

.o

';

III

:J

(J'

,
,

(D

(I)

I IJ

(ll

')

~1

,f

,I

,ll

:1

(f

(J

{/J

(j

:j

"

, I

, 'J

'l

()

( I

(lJ
ID

( I

(ll

IiJ
III

:1'

, 3

l.." ~

:1
(])

(lJ

'1

:)'

(,)

([)

( I

(D

(ll
UJ

CI

U)

(0

f'
()

.,

:J
(1)

'0

(fJ

";

(D

(1.

(I

(II

:)
~:

lIJ

1-"

[D

'j

(D

"

( t

"

, t

[j)

,:

:)

()

IJ)

'l
ID
f--'
t .. ~

lJ<1
,

<D

:J

(ll

(f

Iii

('

'<

:)

ill

(1

"

'j
(J

'U
'U

"

[ll

(D

en
(J

CD

D,

())

c-T

U
f'

c:

U.

(lJ

-1
1
lc

(jl

>;

()

()

, r
IJI

.'(,

':
:1

()

111

(J,
( )'

:1

((J

()

:1

'j

([j

, t

ill

(D

(ll

()

, !

( r

';

( I

, f

"

(II

( t

(/J
, I

([j

11)
( r

()
( !

:)

lel

:1'

(IJ

II)

(1J

()

(JJ

{J,

1'/
l?/
()

'j

'j

, J

( )

:r

(ll

,j

I,

:J

'( j

()
)

0)

. ,,

:1

Ii)

( !

( f

:)

()
~,

,"
(PI

II)

J,

:J

'CJ

:J'

I ~

III
(J

()

I .

,,
,"
:1

( J

:,l

il)

~) )

:1

(j)

III

(lJ

( I

'J

:)

:J"

IJ'J

'

:j

:1

:)

(,.

'j

:J

(,)

.-J

'.

'J

4~

ID

(lJ

,
,

()

,J:J

(/)

CF

(t

;J'

:y

(lJ

:1'

.:...:
U

:1

( )

L1.

:.J

d)

")

III

~-'.

[PI

I\l

,1
(f,

III

:J

f~

IPI

:)

I:

[1)

I "

:1
1)'1

(I

'l

[1,

f-~

([j

, 'J

( l,

(lJ

0--"

,t

;J'

eD

: )

,!

P)

'U

(lJ

"
l.....:::

, r

:1

'.'

()

(J

en

~-:

(L

( t

, t

ill

U1

1J.

(1)

::
- -1

()

:J'

W
,

..... ~

(iJ
:1
C
(iJ

;y

'1
W

(n

/\)

(D

III

(n

([)

(.

'U
iI)

()

'()
, 'J

to
,!

()

l .....::

(jj
I-h

(ll

II)

'J]

(lJ

(j

IJl

()

ill

, 3

(fJ

())

'U
,

=-j

U.

(YJ

()

(fJ

(J

()

,
o
,
",

ct

(r

{n
(lJ

'1
P)
f ~

(fJ

( T

,"

{fJ

""
(I)

()

CD

, ..

:j
In

{Il

()

~)

11)

([)

ru

'U

III

, ..

:1

III

(fJ

'l

'j

:1

'"
<~

'l

o.

~lJ

Q.J
,

()
11)

(.

(fJ

:J

to

:J

0--"

'U
'1

IoJ

()
(t

~,

ICD

')

(iJ

~\J

f-'

lJ
'[I

()

o
H)

~~

C
(

Ul
(0
Il,

( )

[I)

'j

:)

(I

H;

'U

(Il
([j

()

:1
~ :

(I)

'j

( )

, I

(lJ

,D

[ ~

(~

(fJ

j,-:

(J' ~

'

CD

:J

G:

,T

(r

'0

'".

cr

:}

:1

c:

~ ,

::r

il

(I

()

p.;

'",

~.--'

G.:

,1

:J

~--I.

.....

0,

~l I

(ll

"

'r)

.o

()
(

'

ID
I

"

( )

III

( )

, ')

:1

:1

'j

()
'[J

<D

'--J

fl.)

:J

I~
--1
U1

'U
(lJ

(I

...

'u

( t
~

'U
,

, I

II>

to

~
'j

'j

"

(D

()

(D

[ I

{Il

(!

(/)

:1

H;

:1

CD

(D

:)

( )

III
I'

.-)

()

;1

,",

,,,

';

'"

:1

II

()

e..;,

')
(lJ
(t

"J

')
( I

(.1

'

'

(lJ

:y
",

, ';

( t

,J

~l

l:;
:J

'U

L
(D

, t

iI
'1
;-;
W

;J

~\J

,2:..
,f

III

Cl

.......1

C/J

I~'

to

I),

:1

to

:)
()

"

(lJ

( r

'U
(~I

(ll

:1

( I

'')

()

(lJ

",

";

,!

.~

'j

'j

'U

(D

(t

"

:J

J'

r:

{~ ~

'u

:)

t8

,n

()

fl.)

D,

, ..

<..;

(lJ

(T

:_1

'

([)

(fJ

0,

,I
III
(f

~lJ
I-J

c:

()
(ll

(lJ

,]o

:J'

CD

[~I

(t

"

(lJ

~ ,

:1

(r

')

CD

:J

(lJ

0_

U'

to)

()

(j)

.,

~~

....

~J

()

........

........

0--"

",

en

........
tv

t-,

Ul

(fJ

'(lJ

:J

r:

,~

(fJ

(1)

'u

,~

t-...

:J

'}

(l

.')

"

c:

CD

(fJ

0--"

c(fJ

o
o

([)

(fJ

([)

0--"

, t

'J

c-1

(fJ

.~

~~

0'

(fJ

:)

c:

fl.)

(r

Q.J

(lJ

''J

~l

eD
,!

(fJ

,r

1--"
(\)

.,c

"

0'

,~

())

1-"

(fJ

ct

:J'
eD

1---'

, t

n
o

<.<

t-...

.--.,

~~

<

(v

;)
cr

0--"

(LJ

(fJ

Cl

:r

'1
Q.J
:J

(fJ

(fJ

<

CD

,",

,t
c-T

(ll

([)

cr

X'

<..~

r:

CD

,~

(fJ

fl.)

IV

c-T

Ul
CD

(fJ

0--"

.,

;,

(T

()

l:

Cil
Ul

'LJ

ct

........

"-T)

-<:

"

:1

(lJ

,-T
(fJ

')

'1

Q.J

:r
o

0--"

,~,

C1"

(D

,r
(ll

:J

,",

c.;,

,
<D

t"l]

)'

......
......

( t

,~

ID

')
( 1

Uq

( t

~ll
(fJ

c-T

:J

(lJ

,T

(lJ

0--"

,t

CD
"

(r

0,

:J

........

0'
U1
(0

'0

~,

:~

~.

..... 1

Q.J

,~

(jJ

1-4

JJ

()

:)

'~
L1

,,3

(1)

0--"

(j)

<..~

t8

:J'
eD

~,

(lJ

1-4

I-~

"

(lJ

'1

0.

(T

0.
(j)
(fJ

(j)

'"
(1.
,h

tv

UJ

0.

tv

t-.:>
1-,)

c:
')

Vl

t-.:>

......

c.;'

:j
'j

,I
(lo

( I'

')

ll!

([.

IiJ

, I

I( ,

1
"",

.. ,

.'t

::

.'

S;:~":

-,

,-,'

'2

-,

..... ':

ir:Jpcsed on

Ordinance

The

the
ca.s~s

10:
11

",2 S:' ,

12:
t.h

"1 Y"""" """;:.::..,..., ...... ,

r-' .....

!-' "".

-".:

c:::;:s:: -. :.:. ::':;2.

"

_ ..........
c;. v -'

.::::.r_~

. '" J...

at.

lR

603-J~.

19

20
21

Ci::es'

a:'S8

eVlCe:1:2.~

~e

declara:io:ls

follo'".;i :;;:

')0,
........

a) ~2~ dces t~e a~ou~t of t~e construction c:ld

23

by

21

arnou:;ts

2S

the public

t~e

C~:ies

the

require of similarly situated Users of

dO~3in?

2G

27
28
16

t!1e

t"-'

cr.;

t~

""'J

r..)

t")

e..;,

tv
.......

t'-'

t'-'

"...:>

t'"

t'-'

t'-'

......

........

t.:l

,:t:)

..... 1

==--==::::::-:=~-=======~-

11)

'"1

"

(\J

(l)

()
()

0'1

(\J
"
CD

,1

CL

:.J
( t

cr
'-<

f~

Lv

,,11
C

.J

~;

"

~l'

f '

W
(T

(D

Cl

<D

'U

:r

t...:.;

o
(

')

( t

~_ . .J

<D
III
"

D.
'ell
-J

t->

:.J

:.J

,t

PJ
~J
i~-'

:r
(lJ

cr
"
,~.

C~

:J
( t

(LI

p.

"l

f,

,J

>-,'

'v

U)

(Jl

()

, r

III

(j)

f
f

:~

;1

.:

,~

OJ
,

J.

'J

:J

~.J

( t

':

f~

:J

r-"

;J
W

, ..

..

{JJ

"

UJ
Ul

')

([J

<-.;

ct

III
(T
([J

Ul
t---'+

Ul
:.J

o
ct

o
o

,t

;y

(!J

~~

o
o

III

...~

00

..... 1

Cl

,.....

C;1

G:

tv

>-'

(\)

Ul

I.

[n

ill

([J

( ,

;y

Cl

,...

,"

\1)

t'

if)

(J

III

(,)

u
~ !

r'

It,

(I)

>

()

()

:1

I)

u.

("

,1
,0)

: 1

: ).

;1

([

()

(t!

( r

f~'>'

(JJ

()

(iJ

:)

o
"j

"

,..

( 1

()

')

')
1"\)

o
:J

'J

:)

',J

, ..

111

I')

,.,

I ,.

:)

\0
CJ)

:J
0.

')

(~l

l:

,;1

::

({)

I'

'"

;,,)

'0

,1'

\11
'5

( t

'U

(j)
(lJ

"

,u
u,

~-.

:J

:J
-.J

'1

1"\)
"0

>U
( j.

({)

( t

I'

(i}

III

()
\. I

(~l

11'

\:

(1/

c)
, f

Il)
')

'.

: "

, '.

Il}

( I

\:

()
(')

(fJ

, ,)

:J

:)

0,

O'l
(D

(fJ

ru

{ t

(fJ

Ul

,t

:).

::

([I

( t
t~

(t

:)

(0
()

.;

()

()

::r

,:

It)

([J

III

U.

'j

:)

,,): 1

(.

f'

(iJ

~J }

(J.

nJ

:)

; -,

If

:)

'
()

i\)

ID

('t

{ t

{-<;~

: i

"I.
II!

l :

'C)

~,

,'

uq

;I

( t

II!

:1

dJ

III

.,

L.L

Hi
(

tj

, I

\I

'J
(

(J

It!
,l

( r
,

PI

( )

II

"

.)
( r

(U

( t

:).

, )

()

: )'
( I

:)

,"

n,

j,

(f)

\ 1

'"

,1

(1"

II)

rL

()

(U
(fJ

(} I

1\>

()
I~

, r

(J

(!)

;J

(J

III

:,

'{ )

~j"

.)

liJ

,..
(:

Ill,

( 1.

pJ

'[ J

( r

(fJ

1\ )

(j

'J

CJl

:1
(

,:

I-

-..-,.
;r

(ll

, 'J

{jJ

, J

t"

,'"

(>
(11

()

, j

, t

, )

()

,,

( r
(J.

( t

TJ

( J'

()

()

(j)

(lJ

(lJ
(I)

(f)

I '
"

'I

()
()

'l

(,.

:J"
(lJ

( t

:)

:J'

;:,:

t-1)

'5
Iii

(I

;.)

I'
)

()

:-,

"
,',

;1"

'J.

(L

:)
[I)

( t

I,

<II

:",

:1
0,

,;

([)

(fJ
( t

,ll .:

'0

.LJ

()

("t

(N
'J

IT

c'

')

UJ

t-~

(f)

,5

(" r

~l

U)

( t

I"
}

(T

(1,
'.

,[,

OJ

'5

:1

e..

PJ

()

, r

~ ')

III

,,

(J

(\J

,"

I.

(J

,"

\;l

()

It;

'1:.)

(,
()

(1.

It)

(C

('

'U
'U

'J

,il
(

'j

Il)

c:

:1

1l)

(!il

tf

i"
I

(i

(I)

( I

:1

'.

(j

I"
:1

n
o

, 'J

(Ii

:1

jo-'"

:>

:1

'l

it>

(l)

Ul

([)

\,II

(f)

;y

IU

()

( l

()

to:

( f

()

1,1

,:

'0

'U
I'

( )

P'

t,

,"

,I
'( J

U'
(. ~

(j)

(lJ

u)

~J
, ,)

: I'

(l!

U,

(l

')

( t

l)
'J

(jl

fll

()

il

If)

( 1.

,I
~

([!

(t!

()

f--'

r;:;

'"1
'00

;J

Ul

('.

(J.

()

:J

;r

.c~

....,

'-l

r:

C
".1
'U

:1
n,

: I
W

(r

o
o
ill

'J

:1
{/l

,0
'J

IIJ

'(J
()

n.

PJ
f-'

!-~

:1
(li
UJ

'1
!-"

!I

'1

{JJ

C/l

t)

( I

(JJ

[II

;j.

II)

:.:r

0.
,)

Ul

I IJ

Ul

PJ
O.

n.

, ..

III

(")

OJ

( t

:)'

<I)

'\ )

I"

(r

,~.

0.

:1

(n

:)

"')

')

( t

<D

,,)

')

( t

:1

,J.

(\l

:J

,~.

jl,

'0

"
:1'

' l!

'(I

:)'

')

III

O.

'-<

1\)

::1

(.,

II)

~,

~)

ru

,t

n)

r-"

Ot}

()

c1'

()

,I)(D

;~ 1

,ll

:1

PJ

C
:J

e:J

o
!-"
'-+)

~:J
([)

(!)

CO

Ul

......

( t

(!J

(lJ

........

........

([J

cr

,1"

tv

;J
:1

''l

::r

........

(fJ

'J

t "

f J

(1J

<D

(...::

.......

:!:

'0

0'1
, ::>

........

........

t-~

:,,"

r-"

......

e..;.

C"l

C/l

ct

,;

U.

.....

~--

'

'"

:.3

-I

0:

...,
8

10
11 :, 'I

f) i

I -,
I

1J ~

1-1;

15~

IG:

17

19

20

21

22

18