Read without ads and support Scribd by becoming a Scribd Premium Reader.
See Premium Plans
 
U
NITED
S
TATES
D
ISTRICT
C
OURTFORTHE
N
ORTHERN
D
ISTRICTOF
I
LLINOIS
E
ASTERN
D
IVISION
________________
APPLE
INC.
and
NeXT
SOFTWARE)INC.(f/k/aNeXTCOMPUTER,INC.),))
Plaintiffs
 ,)No.1:11cv08540)v.))JudgeRichardA.Posner.MOTOROLA,INC.andMOTOROLA)MOBILITY,INC.,))
Defendants
.)
O
RDEROF
J
UNE
7,
2012
Onthebasisofthemotionsfiledbythepartiesregardingdamages,injunctiveanddeclaratoryrelief,andmootness,andtheparties’filingsthismorningaddressedtothesemattersandthehearingheldthisafternoon,Ihavetentativelydecidedthatthecaseshouldbedismissedwithprejudicebecauseneitherpartycanestablisharighttorelief.ThetrialscheduledtobeginthiscomingMondayisthereforecanceled.ButIwilldelayentryofjudgmentuntilIhavepreparedafullopinion,becauseinthecourseofthatpreparationImaychangemymind.Iwillmerelysketchthegroundsformytentativeviewverybrieflyinthisorder.Appleconcedesthat,inlightofmyOrderofMay22,2012,rulingonthe
Daubert
motionfiledbyMotorola,itcannotprovedamagesfortheallegedinfringementofthe‘002and‘949patents.ThatleavesApplewithjustitsclaimsforinfringementofthe‘263and‘647patents.ItentativelyconcludethatitsadmissibleevidenceofdamageswithrespecttothoseclaimsdoesnotcreateagenuineissueofmaterialfactenablingittowithstandMotorola’smotionforsummaryjudgment.Ilikewisetentativelyconcludethattheadmissi bleevidenceofdamageswithrespecttotheallegedinfringementbyAppleofMotorola’s‘898patentalsofailstocreateagenuineissueofmaterialfact.
Case: 1:11-cv-08540 Document #: 1028 Filed: 06/07/12 Page 1 of 2 PageID #:91487
Search
Search History:
Searching...
Result 00 of 00
00 results for result for
  • p.
    • Notes
    Load more