Principles of Project Management
Principles of Project Management
Module Guide
Copyright © 2021
MANCOSA
All rights reserved; no part of this book may be reproduced in any form or by any means, including photocopying machines,
without the written permission of the publisher. Please report all errors and omissions to the following email address:
modulefeedback@[Link]
This Module Guide,
Principles of Project Management (NQF level 6)
module guide will be used across the following programmes:
Preface .................................................................................................................................................... 4
i
Principles of Project Management
List of Contents
List of Tables
Table 3 - Purpose of the various documents that make up the overall project plan.......................................... 60
Table 4 - Causes for change requests to the Baseline Plan. The PMBOK Guide (2017) ................................ 62
Table 5 - Change Request Form. Adapted from The PMBOK Guide (2017) ................................................... 64
Table 7 – Example of a Risk Register for a 21st Birthday Party ...................................................................... 111
Table 8 - Qualitative Risk Analysis. Adapted from own source ...................................................................... 112
Table 9 – An example of a Risk Register from a 21st Birthday Party .............................................................. 112
Table 11 - Risk Probability & Impact Matrix for the 21st Birthday Party. ......................................................... 115
Table 12 - Risk Response Strategy for the 21st Birthday Party. ..................................................................... 117
Table 17 - Tabular illustration of High or Low Power rating and a High and Low Interest rating. ................... 135
1 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
Figure 2 - The important factors to consider within the project environment. ..................................... 23
Figure 13 – Work Breakdown Structure example for a 21st Birthday Party. ...................................... 74
Figure 15 - Most project management solutions have a table format for the Activity List. You can also
use MS Excel or other spreadsheet packages. ............................................................... 76
Figure 23 - Project Budget for 21st Birthday Party Per Deliverable .................................................. 104
MANCOSA 2
Principles of Project Management
Figure 28 - High or Low Power rating and a High and Low Interest rating. ...................................... 135
Figure 29 - High or Low Power rating and a High and Low Interest rating ....................................... 136
3 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
Preface
A. Welcome
Dear Student
It is a great pleasure to welcome you to Principles of Project Management (PPM6). To make sure that you share
our passion about this area of study, we encourage you to read this overview thoroughly. Refer to it as often as
you need to, since it will certainly make studying this module a lot easier. The intention of this module is to develop
both your confidence and proficiency in this module.
The field of Project Management is extremely dynamic and challenging. The learning content, activities and self-
study questions contained in this guide will therefore provide you with opportunities to explore the latest
developments in this field and help you to discover the field of Project Management as it is practiced today.
This is a distance-learning module. Since you do not have a tutor standing next to you while you study, you need
to apply self-discipline. You will have the opportunity to collaborate with each other via social media tools. Your
study skills will include self-direction and responsibility however; you will gain a lot from the experience! These
study skills will contribute to your life skills, which will help you to succeed in all areas of life.
MANCOSA does not own or purport to own, unless explicitly stated otherwise, any intellectual property rights in or
to multimedia used or provided in this module guide. Such multimedia is copyrighted by the respective creators
thereto and used by MANCOSA for educational purposes only. Should you wish to use copyrighted material from
this guide for purposes of your own that extend beyond fair dealing/use, you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.
MANCOSA 4
Principles of Project Management
B. Module Overview
The content covered in this module starts from defining what a project is to project closure. This broad coverage
will provide you with the necessary skills to articulate to the next levels with reasonable ease. It is written in an
accessible language accompanied with simple illustrations and examples to facilitate learning. At the end of this
module, you should be able to utilise Project Management tools and implement projects irrespective of scale –
large or small - the principles remain the same. As you read this module, take down some notes and highlight
important concepts. It is advisable to attempt all the examples. It intuitively true that practice makes perfect.
Initiate and plan a project. Project plan components are developed and integrated
into an approved and documented project management
plan.
Execute, monitor and control a project. Project work is undertaken, and products delivered in
accordance with project requirements, the project
management plan and agreed procedures.
Hand over and close a project. Project closure tasks and outputs are listed and
summarised to show understanding of the project
closure lifecycle phase.
Use and apply concepts and Project management concepts and terminology are
terminology of project management conceptualized for better understanding.
5 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
E. Acronyms
EF Early Finish
ES Early Start
LF Late Finish
LS Late Start
MANCOSA 6
Principles of Project Management
The purpose of the Module Guide is to allow you the opportunity to integrate the theoretical concepts from the
prescribed textbook and recommended readings. We suggest that you briefly skim read through the entire guide
to get an overview of its contents. At the beginning of each Unit, you will find a list of Learning Outcomes and
Associated Assessment Criteria. This outlines the main points that you should understand when you have
completed the Unit/s. Do not attempt to read and study everything at once. Each study session should be 90
minutes without a break.
This module should be studied using the prescribed and recommended textbooks/readings and the relevant
sections of this Module Guide. You must read about the topic that you intend to study in the appropriate section
before you start reading the textbook in detail. Ensure that you make your own notes as you work through both the
textbook and this module. In the event that you do not have the prescribed and recommended textbooks/readings,
you must make use of any other source that deals with the sections in this module. If you want to do further reading,
and want to obtain publications that were used as source documents when we wrote this guide, you should look at
the reference list and the bibliography at the end of the Module Guide.
G. Study Material
The study material for this module includes tutorial letters, programme handbook, this Module Guide, a list of
prescribed and recommended textbooks/readings which may be supplemented by additional readings.
7 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
Additional Reading:
Burke, R. 2014. Project Management: Planning and Control Techniques. 5th Edition. Wylie & Sons.
Gido, J. and Clements, J.P. 2018. Successful Project Management. (7th Edition). Cengage Learning.
Kloppenberg, T.J. 2017. Contemporary Project Management. (3rd Edition). Stamford USA: Cengage
Learning
I. Special Features
In the Module Guide, you will find the following icons together with a description. These are designed to help you
study. It is imperative that you work through them as they also provide guidelines for examination purposes.
LEARNING The Learning Outcomes indicate aspects of the particular Unit you
OUTCOMES have to master.
A Think Point asks you to stop and think about an issue. Sometimes
THINK POINT you are asked to apply a concept to your own experience or to think of
an example.
MANCOSA 8
Principles of Project Management
You may come across Activities that ask you to carry out specific
tasks. In most cases, there are no right or wrong answers to these
ACTIVITY
activities. The purpose of the activities is to give you an opportunity to
apply what you have learned.
At this point, you should read the references supplied. If you are
READINGS unable to acquire the suggested readings, then you are welcome to
consult any current source that deals with the subject.
PRACTICAL
Practical Application or Examples will be discussed to enhance
APPLICATION OR
understanding of this module.
EXAMPLES
9 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
Unit
1: Project Management
Concepts
MANCOSA 10
Principles of Project Management
1.2 Project Management Principles Identify key role players and their responsibilities within a project
and Concepts
1.4 Project Environment Discuss various project management key principles and
methodologies in a project
1.7 Projects in Organisations Explain the project phases that make up a typical project
1.8 Introduction to Knowledge Areas Explain project management processes that occur within each
and Project Lifecycles project phase and explain the relationships and interactions
between process groups, processes and knowledge areas
11 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
1.1 Introduction
This unit explores the key principles and strategies used to execute projects cost-effectively. Consideration will be
given to the importance of project management, organisational strategy, project selection and prioritisation, as well
as organisational capability in the context of projects such as structure and project life cycle. You will learn the
initial steps to develop a project-related product or service description and to charter a project. The unit also
includes the suggested process groups and processes that the project manager may customise to the phase or to
the entire project. Key project management processes shall be defined and addressed.
Newton (2015) clarified that the company is increasingly using project management methods within its activities
and that the technical vocabulary of project management has become increasingly popular in management and
executive meetings. Project management is a concept that most people are familiar with; it is the ability to do
projects on schedule and within the budget. From an academic and career point of view, it is a relatively recent
development that occurred in the 1960s with the development of advanced machinery and complex systems such
as jet aircraft, military machinery, and the development of space exploration. As these industries and projects
became more advanced and complex, the cost overruns and time delays began to be questioned. As a result,
Project Management was developed as an ability to minimise costs and control scheduling.
The term project management is sometimes used to describe an organisational approach to the management of
ongoing operations. This approach, more properly called management by projects, treats many aspects of ongoing
operations as projects in order to apply project management to them.
Project Management is a process, which focuses on a project. A project is an undertaking that has beginning and
an end and is carried out to meet established goals within cost, schedule and quality objectives. Project
management brings together and optimises the resources necessary to successfully complete the project. These
project resources include the skills, talents, and cooperative effort of a team of people; facilities, tools, and
equipment; information, systems and techniques; and money.
A key aspect of project management is that the responsibility for achieving objectives is given to a single individual,
the project manager, who gets things done through a team of people. Regardless of the size, the ultimate success
or otherwise of the project is the responsibility of a single individual.
MANCOSA 12
Principles of Project Management
Project managers, for example, may usually work in the operations departments of their businesses. The survival
of the company depends largely on the combined performance of its project managers. Project managers are not
only responsible for various vital aspects of the business, but project managers tend to face difficulties in the form
of tight deadlines, weak output by subordinates, demanding buyers, slow production by suppliers, etc. Appropriate
project management principles are the best way to address these challenges.
The project should also have a clearly specified set of objectives that translates into a set of deliverables and a
specific product or service. Uniqueness matters when considering a product or service, as it distinguishes between
one project and another. In fact, it sets project activity apart from the regular tasks that an organisation conducts
on a daily basis.
For starters, Hiner (2009), former Chief Editor of TechRepublic, lists and addresses five (5) pre-requisites for
successful IT projects as follows:
Meet the business goals;
Embrace change;
Be honest;
Align vendors (customers, service providers and technology);
Arrange a strong executive sponsor.
From a more general project viewpoint, Watt (2015) points out the pre-requisites of 'Managing the Environment
Plan' as follows:
Executive Support – The Executive must clearly demonstrate support for the concept of project
management through active sponsorship and control.
External Authority – The project manager must be the responsible agent in dealing with all parties and the
person in charge and the only formal communication with them.
Internal Authority – The project manager must have the requisite managerial authority within his/her
organisation to ensure that he/she meets his / her requirements.
Commitment Authority – The project manager must have the duty and the authority to monitor the
allocation of resources, including financing, within the defined limits. The consequences of these decisions
must be both transparent and clear.
13 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
Project Manager to be Involved in All Major Decisions – No major technical, cost, schedule or performance
decisions should be taken without the involvement of the project manager.
Competence – The Project Manager and the members of his team must be professional. The other
workers assigned to the project must also be qualified.
Project Team – The project manager will have a say in the assembly of his / her project team, which will
help him / her gain their personal engagement, encouragement, and standard of service.
Management Information Systems – Good knowledge and control systems for project management must
be in place.
Oosthuizen and Venter (2018:4) defines a project as “any planned, temporary endeavour undertaken to create
a unique product, service or other complete and definite outcome (deliverable) within a limited time scale and
with limited resources”
MANCOSA 14
Principles of Project Management
2. Types of Projects
To gain a better understanding of projects, Oosthuizen and Venter (2018:5) classifies the four unique needs
(criteria) of a project in terms of:
Industry – different project life cycles models exist for different industries as they often have unique
requirements.
Project size – large projects, for example, require more detailed and complex planning and control, than
smaller projects.
Project scope – establishing the project scope (what you can aim to deliver to the customer at completion) is
important, and how soon it can be established with certainty, varies between complex and less complex
projects.
Project application – refers to the complexity of a project based on its unique focus and aim. A project as a
change intervention differs substantially from a research and development project, in terms of aspects such
as focus, objectives, cross-functional work and multidisciplinary interaction.
Oosthuizen and Venter (2018:5) argue that it depends on the nature of the project, organisations may consider the
abovementioned criteria for classifying a project. For example: providing a face lift to the interior of a restaurant
and the Gautrain development are both projects, but these two projects differ in terms of industry, where they are
located, as well as their size, scope, and application.
Different types of projects require a range of resources and skills. Youker (2017) in his journal article, The
Distinction between Various Types of Projects, 2nd Edition, classifies projects according to their basic
characteristics.
15 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
READING
You are encouraged to read the full journal article at: Youker, R. 2017. The
Difference between Different Types of Projects. 2nd Edition [Online]. Available at:
[Link]
[Link] [Accessed 22 August 2019].
The following has been adapted from Yourker's (2017) journal paper, which helps us summarise the specific
characteristics of the nine (9) styles of projects:
Administrative Projects
Usually, this form of project will require other levels of analytical skill; for example, when a business transitions
from one accounting method to another. These types of projects require careful consideration, as new systems
may be unreliable or unsuitable, workers may fail to learn new technology and may incur high training costs. It is
vital that staff embrace the new program, team building exercises and other similar forms of motivation may be
required.
Construction Projects
Blue-collar employees, led by skilled managers, usually carry out construction tasks, such as buildings and
highways. Price is an essential consideration and this constraint typically takes precedence over time. There is an
intrinsic risk factor for workers; thus, the health and safety laws should be strictly complied with.
MANCOSA 16
Principles of Project Management
Time is important since this form of project often usually requires downtime. If a municipality is preparing to
establish power grids, people are told of periods when they will be without electricity. If the project were to run
overnight, the town would be overwhelmed with complaints and grievances. One example of that might be
arranging the maintenance of the company's database servers, which would mean that they could be without
network or email access during maintenance. A large manufacturing business can need to maintain its equipment,
which would interrupt routine work and involve the involvement of specialist contractors.
Research Projects
Usually, this type of project evolves over time, particularly when long-term studies are performed. Examples include
feasibility studies and trials, environmental impact evaluations and long-term medical research.
Project Sponsor
Oosthuizen and Venter (2018:78) explains that a “project sponsor may be an external stakeholder, but is normally
a senior executive in an organisation, accountable to the Board, and who has a number of responsibilities for the
project.” The project sponsor is the person with the greatest interest in the success of the project and bears the
greatest risk. Consider, for example, the head of the department (sponsor) who will delegate a project to the project
manager to prepare a business function to sell a product. If the project failed, the company manager would not
have gained from the project for his / her department.
17 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
The Project Sponsor has significant responsibility for linking the project to the outside world. Principle among these
obligations, if the project is to be successful, the sponsor of the project must:
Serve as an important contact link between the management of the project and the senior management
of the supporting organisation.
Ensure that organisational policies and processes are in place and practiced.
Create a positive working environment by acting as a project advocate.
Provide high-level guidance and supervision before successful completion of the project and beyond. This
involves involvement in the production of the business case of the project, ensuring its compliance with
the higher "task" of the company and, ultimately, gaining its approval so that the project can move forward
in the planning process.
Finally, review and gain approval of the Project Charter so that the project can progress through the
phases of development. This contains the following:
o Approval of the project scope.
o Decide what is "in" and "not in"
o Defining the Key Performance Metrics of the project as the basis for decision-making during the
work post-project evaluation.
Project Manager
The project manager is the person assigned to direct the team and is responsible for achieving the goals of the
project. In the event of a business function being planned, the sponsor would appoint and assist the project
manager by making funds and resources available to them. The project manager shall report to the sponsor.
Oosthuizen and Venter (2018:437) states that “a project manager’s duties go far beyond the day-to-day
management of the project. It includes leadership required to negotiate upwards in the organisation with top
management to collaborate sideways with other managers and to influence and direct downwards with project
team members”. We will expand on the roles and responsibilities of the Project Manager later in this module guide.
MANCOSA 18
Principles of Project Management
Stakeholders
Oosthuizen and Venter (2018:13) refers to a stakeholder as the “end users, customers, or the people who will
influence the design of the project, and ultimately, the people who will reap the benefits of the final project”. They
have a vested interest in the project, for example, sponsor, functional managers or internal customers or suppliers,
creditors, community members and/or members of the project team’s family.
Steering Committee
Projects and project managers must be accountable and given input from experienced and senior individuals within
an organisation. Oosthuizen and Venters (2018:78) refers to this group of people as a steering committee and it is
their duty to approve proposals, distribute funds for projects from the budget of the organisations and ensure that
the projects performed are in line with the organisation's strategic direction. At an early stage, the sponsor would
propose the projects and obtain the approval of the steering committee before appointing the project manager.
When it is underway, the sponsor or project manager may have to proceed through the steering committee at the
accepted level of reporting and funding approval. The members of the Steering Committee are also members of
the Board of Directors or of senior executives.
When all of these are beyond the control of the project manager and his or her staff, they too should be "escalated"
to higher resolution management. Never forget that there are no projects in isolation. While the project team brings
intelligence, motivation, and skills to the project, the sponsoring organisation must also play its part. The role of
corporate management is to provide the right atmosphere for project work. The representative of the organisation
to the project, i.e. the person to whom the project manager reports, is usually referred to as the "Project Sponsor"
or, where multiple related projects are involved, the "Program Manager."
Oosthuizen and Venter (2018:12) refers to project management as “the process of applying knowledge
associated with the planning, organising, leading and controlling of required project tasks and activities, effectively
and efficiently, to achieve the set project objectives.”
The above description refers to a typical project that is big and/or has several elements that need to be organized.
The construction of bridges is the typical example of these projects. It also takes diligent management to ensure
that the tasks are finished on time.
19 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
The five (5) management functions are planning, organising, staffing, leading, and controlling (Davis, B and Reily,
M., 2019).
Planning - Involves the development of objectives and objectives, the creation of an overarching strategy to
achieve these objectives and objectives, and the development of a systematic ranking (hierarchy) of strategies
to incorporate and organise these activities. Planning provides direction and encouragement to the project
team leaders.
Organising - Unless the project is to achieve its goals and objectives, it must coordinate its activities and
assign resources (including human resources) to accomplish these activities. The organisation process
includes deciding what activities are to be carried out, who will do them, and how they are to be handled and
organised
Staffing - Recruitment and selection of workers for positions within a organisation (within teams and
departments).
Leading – It is the power to manipulate others, either individually or in groups, to achieve the goals of the
project. This includes tasks such as giving orders, inspiring people, advising people, leading groups, and
rewarding people for good results.
Controlling – Compares the actual outcome or implementation of the project with the priorities and
expectations that were defined during the planning phase. When there is a deviation from the plans, action
must be taken to correct the errors.
Project managers must also have the skills to successfully complete the project to the satisfaction of all relevant
stakeholders (client, government, company management, etc.). While small tasks, such as the assignment of a
student group, do not require a management team, even these small projects would require at least some
cooperation and communication between the members of the group to ensure that everyone works together in a
harmonious manner in order to reach the deadline.
Later in the module, you will also be introduced to the principles of tools and techniques that need to be learned in
order to be able to use them. Many of the methods used by project managers are Gantt maps, task breakdown
systems and software programs. Techniques include, but are not limited to, work preparation, budget management
and critical path review.
MANCOSA 20
Principles of Project Management
THINK POINT
Imagine that you are the manager of a project where you are told that you
have an unlimited budget, that you have all the time you need to complete
the project, and that quality is of no interest to us, since we are not concerned
with whether the customer is pleased with the new product.
As depicted and explained in Figure 1, Kaschny and Nolden (2018) refers to the four (4) quadruple constraints as:
Scope is all the things that need to be carried out on a project. When all deliverables have been
completed, the project is finished.
Cost includes services such as team members, team leaders and supplies. The goal is generally to keep
the costs to a minimum while still conducting the work in compliance with the quality agreed upon.
Time according to the definition of a project, must have the date of completion. This is also critical that
the project manager finishes the project within the time limits. Most businesses are subject to strict and
serious penalties when service providers fail to meet deadlines. Such punishments can include heavy
fines, termination of potential work or both.
Quality refers to the level of workmanship and materials needed by the customer. It is important that an
agreement is reached between the client and the project manager on the acceptable standard – the client
may always hesitate to pay more for better-than-agreed quality work. On the other hand, the company is
not likely to pay for low quality of work at all.
21 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
Scope
Quality
Cost Time
MANCOSA 22
Principles of Project Management
Watt (2015) in Figure 2, discusses the important factors that need to be understood within your project environment.
At one level, you need to think in terms of the cultural and social environments (i.e., people, demographics, and
education). The international and political environment is where you need to understand about different countries’
cultural influences. Then we move to the physical environment; here we think about time zones. Think about
different countries and how differently your project will be executed whether it is just in your country or if it involves
an international project team that is distributed throughout the world in five (5) different countries.
Angel (2015) notes that not all initiatives or organizations are the same or similar. This also addresses the difficulty
of project management by stating that not all the methods and strategies outlined in the Project Management
Institute (PMI) provide common requirements for all projects. Considering, it suggests four (4) steps that can be
taken to help project managers achieve strategic success. Angel (2015) provides information alignment based on
PMI principles that project managers should recognise and implement from the very start of a project, such as
PMBOK ®, the Organisational Project Management Maturity Model (OPM3 ®) and the PMI Practice Framework
for Configuration Management.
23 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
He points out that this guide outlines four steps of the project management model that can be followed to help
achieve the success of the project, namely:
Step 1
Recognise the form of organisation in which the project is to be carried out.
Step 2
Identify the expertise and practice of an organisation to recognize the degree of sophistication of its
processes and standards.
Step 3
Using the proper configuration of the project.
Step 4
Apply good governance to the project.
READING
Read the explanation regarding the four (4) steps in his article available at:
[Link]
Managers-Should-Follow-to-Help-Ensure-Strategic-Success
MANCOSA 24
Principles of Project Management
The explanation that this method is most used is that it is relatively easy to understand and the reporting lines are
straightforward. Every person in the hierarchy must report to a primary supervisor. The functional structure is the
conventional structure and shape in which most organisations are designed.
A negative aspect, however, is that this form may be too time-consuming (and less flexible) for today's rapidly
changing business environment. This arrangement is also not necessarily well suited to organisations that
specialise in projects, as project managers typically have little control.
For a large organisation, the project manager can have the title of project coordinator and basically perform the
position of the clerk rather than the manager. A lot of control lies in the hands of the practical supervisors, and the
project manager will usually have to seek approval from the relevant department before action can be taken. For
example, prior to procurement of products or payment by contractors, approval would have to be obtained from
the financial department.
Oosthuizen and Venter (2018:71) explains the advantages and disadvantages of operating within the functional
organisational structure:
Advantages:
Stability – employees are located within their departments, which minimises change and decreases
movement of employees and improves organisational stability.
Flexibility – temporary assignments of work can easily be facilitated, and the use of specific skills can be
easily managed using various employees within the functions.
25 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
Focused expertise – the use of the specific, skilled employees facilitates the focus of appropriate skills
and expertise on critical project tasks. Expertise can also be shared across multiple projects.
Easy transition to production – employees implements the project and the continue to deliver within their
functional areas. This facilitates business continuity and efficiency.
Ability to change – employees are readily available and can be used at short notice to deliver tasks that
may need urgent attention and delivery.
Employee advancement facilitated – employees could learn new skills. Employees are managed and
promoted, using existing structures and processes, which facilitates performance monitoring and
development.
Less costly – internally recruited employees are less costly than external consultants.
Disadvantages:
Easily distracted – project responsibilities are often seen as secondary to functional responsibilities.
Difficulty integrating – employees struggle to adapt to a project environment when used to very functionally
focussed roles.
Time consuming – key employees are now focussed on project delivery and therefore removed from the
business, reducing its capacity and capability.
Lack of ownership – several projects may decrease levels of ownership as employees are thinly spread
and are less focused and accountable.
Reduced capacity – functional areas now need to continue with day to day activities as well as facilitate
project delivery. The reduction in capacity can negatively affect performance.
Quality decreases – offloading of less experienced employees to project delivery by functional manager
reduces project quality and may extend delivery timescales and even reduce scope.
Poor communication – project delivery is hindered as bureaucracy, silo and “ivory tower” mentalities, and
open/honest communication.
Figure 4 indicates that the Project Manager is in a position of authority and has the power to approve project
budgets and has the title of Program Manager or Project Executive. It is also expensive to delegate permanent
roles to team leaders because teams do not always have work to do. Many companies are working on this issue
by employing staff on a contractual basis for the duration of a specific project. Contractors are compensated only
while they work, but since they are not permanent workers, they can be less loyal to the organisation.
MANCOSA 26
Principles of Project Management
Project Manager
Oosthuizen and Venter (2018:74) explains the advantages and disadvantages of operating within a project
organisational structure:
Advantages:
Simple, fast and flexible – project teams are autonomous and operate without distractions
Cohesive – a common goals means that the project team can work together and are driven to achieve
this goal.
Cross-functional integration – Specialists can work together and can achieve efficiencies while supporting
other members in the process.
Communication benefits – communication is faster and more efficient with a focussed audience.
Accountability and authority – the project manager has responsibility and accountability for the project,
which allows for focussed and clear recruitment/selection decisions.
27 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
Disadvantages:
Expensive – project managers may purchase and stockpile resources.
Internal divisions and conflict – competition with other projects and/or managers means that business
continuity is compromised.
Limited functional and technological experience – employing project team members who lack seniority
and experience may limit functional expertise.
Complicated and difficult post-project handover and transition – the transfer of project specific skills and
knowledge, i.e. operating a machine, may be difficult and time consuming.
Effort and resources are duplicated – each project duplicates significant effort and resources resulting in
overstaffing and cost increases.
Identifying projects override organisation goals – the project takes on a persona of its own and starts
driving the organisation instead of supporting the overall business objectives of the organisation.
CEO
Project
Figure 5 – Matrix Project Organisation
MANCOSA 28
Principles of Project Management
Weak form - If the matrix structure is the middle way between the functional structure and the project
structure, the weak form matrix is primarily centred on the functional structure. This means that the heads
of the functional divisions have more control and authority than the project managers do. Project
managers have a role like that of the project manager in the functional framework.
Strong form - The strong form matrix is the opposite of the weak form, because in this system, project
managers have authority – equivalent to the level of control enjoyed by project managers in the project
structure.
Balanced form – As anticipated, this type is the middle ground between project managers and functional
managers, and they share power and authority.
Oosthuizen and Venter (2018:75) explains the advantages and disadvantages of operating within the matrix
organisational structure:
Advantages:
Project manager accountability – accountability for project delivery lies with the project manager, although
employees still report to their functional managers.
Resource availability – resources are more freely available given the ability to hire outside the organisation
to supplement a project resource pool.
Post-project employment – all employees are affiliated to a functional department and therefore have
employment after the project is delivered.
Efficient – allows for simple, fast and flexible project delivery, as well as improving communication and
making reporting lines clear for all team members.
Project focussed – the project manager facilitates a clear project focus as no functional distractions cause
confusion amongst team members.
Transition to production easier – employees have an excellent understanding of the functional processes
and therefore can reduce the complexity of the transition and delivery to production.
Flexible – the structure is very flexible and draws on positives from other structures.
Disadvantages:
Conflict – employees report to a functional head and work on a project, which can cause conflict when
resources are scarce.
Stressful – the goals of the functional organisation can be conflicting or different to the project goals.
Slow – employees need to fulfil roles of their functional areas, as well as deliver project goals and
objectives.
Accountability – employees struggle to manage the dual accountability between their day and jobs and
their responsibilities to the project.
29 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
Project Control – when managing various projects and business-as-usual activity, the project and
functional managers are responsible for the allocation and management of resources in order to efficiently
and effectively control the delivery of the organisational objectives.
Pure
Project
Matrix
OBS OBS
Functional
OBS
Functional Manager
POWER
MANCOSA 30
Principles of Project Management
Figure 6 depicts selecting the right organisational breakdown structure which will be suitable for your organisation.
There is “no one fits all model”. Selecting the right organisational structure is essentially a balancing act between
addressing the customers requirements, the project requirements (scope), the team requirements, the stakeholder
requirements and just as importantly, the individual’s requirements. On some projects, the customer may request
or instruct the contractor to use a certain type of project management. Selecting an organisation structure to
manage a project depends on a number of dependent and independent factors such as:
Project Scope
Project Size
Project Duration
Risks Involved
Company Culture
Resource (Manpower, Budget, Cashflow)
PRACTICAL APPLICATION
Suppose you work at an organisation that plans to run a project to automate
certain factory floor processes.
What do you think is the best organisational structure that the company
should implement?
31 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
Business Sphere
According to the King IV report on corporate governance published in 2016 by the Institute of Directors in
Southern Africa (IoDSA), organisations should submit an Integrated Report providing a reliable,
comprehensive and holistic overview of the organisation from both a financial and a non-financial perspective
(Institute of Directors in Southern Africa, 2016:48). A crucial feature of comprehensive reporting is that
organisations will be able to explain the effect of their activities on all three fields in which they work, namely
economic, social, and environmental. Such three (3) elements shall be referred to as the Triple Bottom Line.
Essentially, King III and King IV recognise that organisations cannot separate their business objectives and
derive profitability from them.
MANCOSA 32
Principles of Project Management
Benefits, such as securing potential projects or strengthening procedures, must be weighed. Upgrading
computer networks would have no clear financial benefit for the company – it would be cost-effective. By the
end of the day, though, demand should have risen, leading to higher profits. In such a scenario, the issue
would usually be whether the organisation could afford to subsidise the cost.
Technology Sphere
Technology should be the means to an end, not the end itself. This means that the technology we are
purchasing should be justified in the sense that it will eventually ensure a positive cash flow or be more
effective. For example, an executive may be fascinated by the beautiful appearance of the new Windows ®
operating system. He / she then initiates a project to install an operating system on all of them. Unfortunately,
the hardware is a little out of date and the machines would not be able to use any of the display features of
the new operating system, which is why the executive decided to update the new operating system first. In
this situation, the project will not be pursued because the new technology would bring little significant value to
the client and will not warrant the cost of the project.
Organisational Sphere
Organisations consist of individuals, a fact that is sometimes ignored. Projects can affect people; therefore,
project managers should never underestimate the possible opposition they can face if the project fails to obtain
support from workers. Often workers are resistant to change for several reasons, such as bad experience with
a previous project, concerns as to whether they have the requisite improvements. People are normally
confident with things they know, so they may be afraid of an unfamiliar method. This is discussed in the
management of transition, which needs to be handled as part of most projects.
When we look at the previous example, we may infer that the project would also have a huge effect on workers
who will have to adjust to the new operating system. The value of the upgrade would have to be weighed by
the executive against the cost of training employees. He / she will also need to examine their attitudes towards
the proposed project in order to decide if they will support his / her decision. When there is good support for
an update, it might also be agreed that all equipment must be updated to accommodate a software upgrade.
PRACTICAL EXAMPLE
The project team consists of seven (7) staff members. Two (2) members of
the team have powerful, extroverted personalities, and the project manager
expects future clashes between them. The team leader will be chosen, and
there is a good chance that when the announcement is made, the group will
be split into two groups. How does the project manager prevent a
confrontation between the members of the team?
33 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
Various issues, such as health, safety, and legal implications, are also important in projects, depending on the
industry and the project environment. According to PMI Instructor (2016): these can include:
Compliance issues relating to project management and contracts:
Considering the selection of examples of project procurement contracts, evaluating contracts, determining
how each of them deals with specific procurement problems, and suggesting how the contract can be an
instrument by which the project manager can better organize and control project resources;
Labour law in the sense of the project:
Evaluate common labour problems that can affect projects across the regulatory environment and discuss
how project managers should use different tools, methods, and strategies to overcome these constraints
positively throughout the project.
Implications for health and safety.
Compliance with the standards and regulations.
Data security and privacy:
In the context of a particular project background and strategy, examine where information and information
systems may be vulnerable to such risks, or where the privacy of stakeholders may be compromised by
the handling of information, and propose best practices for protecting data security, access and privacy
during the project.
MANCOSA 34
Principles of Project Management
This calls for careful preparation. This preparation is a progressive process, as mentioned above. It
must:
o Continue through all phases of the project.
o To increase the details.
To help put plans on paper and keep them up to date, there are many different methods that you can
use. A variety of automated scheduling systems are also available to support.
The PMBoK, which is in its 6th edition, sets out ten knowledge areas as depicted in Table 1 below:
35 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
MANCOSA 36
Principles of Project Management
These processes are categorised according to the knowledge area and grouped under the followiing five process
groups.
The initiating process group is where the projects usually begin. It could be a idea that was debated and discussed
over a cup of coffee, or it could be a formal answer to the business concerns posed by the steering committee. It
does not really matter where the project started or how, from the point of view of project management, the Initiating
Process Group focuses on formally receiving authorisation to commence the project.
Such procedures are carried out in order to identify a new project or a new phase of an existing project by gaining
authorisation to start a project or phase. Processes within the Initiating Process Group are as follows:
Developing a charter – developing a charter is all about giving a name to the project, formalising what needs
to be done and whether or not there is approval for the project.
Identify stakeholders – this process is all about identifying everyone who will be involved or be affected by the
project either negatively or positively. This could be quite a long list so it’s best to spend some time on it and
get it right. It’s a bit late when you are busy executing your project to suddenly realise that you forgot to consult
an important stakeholder.
The planning process group is all about preparation and making sure that when it is time for the strategy to be
executed, you have been talking about all that needs to be accomplished. As you can imagine, there is a broad
process group that works to ensure that the project is a success by preparing it in adequate detail.
The planning phase will take the outputs from the initiation phase (charter and stakeholder analysis) and will
establish a clear description of what is to be delivered and how it is to be delivered. When this process is finished,
the final action plan will be ready to be enforced. At the time the planning process is finished, both details and
preparation will lead to the overall project management or reference plan that will be used in the execution phase
of the project.
The Executing Process Group is all about the actual execution of this process. When approved to continue with
the project , the project management plan established during the planning process will be used to implement /
execute the project.
37 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
The Closing Process Group is the last of the project lifecycle phase groups. It is all about getting the project or
process to a close, handing over the deliverables and terminating the contracts.
Oosthuizen and Venter (2018:9) refers to the project life cycle as a “logical sequence of activities to accomplish
the project’s goals or objectives”.
These project tasks and activities need to be set up and then organized into stages so that project manager and
project team can easily plan, coordinate and execute resources for each activity. The project manager can also
objectively measure the achievement of the objectives and explain its decision to continue, correct or cancel the
project while applying control during the execution stage. Figure 7 refers to a typical example of a project life cycle.
MANCOSA 38
Principles of Project Management
Define problem
and cause Formulate
Analyse context objectives
Project transfer
Set overall goal Develop Authorise and
Release
Formulate schedules & implement
resources
specification budgets Monitor and
Lessons learned
Establish tasks Establish control
Closure
and resource needs
responsibilities Identify risks
Time
Start End
Oosthuizen and Venter (2018:10) explains that diverse project management tools and methodologies exist in the
different project life cycles stages:
Project Selection
In most instances, it is not possible to undertake all of the projects that an organisation would like to due to
resource constraints (usually skills, time and money). A choice must be made on which project to undertake.
There are various methods to select projects in organisations. These include both financial and non-financial
methods as will be discussed in the following paragraphs.
39 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
Every activity done by the organisation, is guided by strategic choice or policy. This strategic choice concerns
how the company pursues the desired goals and objectives (Oosthuizen and Venter, 2018:42). Consulting
with the company to decide whether chosen tasks align with the goals and objectives of the organizations
makes sense for the project manager.
Oosthuizen and Venter (2018:48) suggests that the next move is to consider whether the project meets any
predetermined financial criteria once the company has established that potential projects can help them
achieve their strategic goals. Financial criteria may include Payback Analysis, Net Present Value (NPV) and
Internal Rate of Return (IRR).
o Payback Analysis
The payback period is essentially a measure of how long it takes to repay the organization's investment in the
project (Oosthuizen and Venter, 2018:48). The company agrees on a reasonable period of time and it is nice
if the project earns the investment back within that timeframe. When it takes longer to pay back the investment
than the stated period, it may not be a good idea to undertake that project. The shorter the duration of payback,
the better for project and organisation.
MANCOSA 40
Principles of Project Management
The most widely used payback calculation is when cash flows into a project are the same over the project's life
each year. In this case the formula used for estimating the time of payback is as follows:
Let’s assume an initial total investment of R500,000 with an annual cash inflow of R150,000 The payback period
would simply be:
Payback = R500,000
R150,000
The payback period indicates the time in months or years, in which the costs associated with the project will be
recouped (paid back) by revenue streams from savings and benefits. Most organisations have specific payback
targets that must be met before a project is approved or authorised.
Oosthuizen and Venter (2018:49) draws our attention to the two disadvantages of the payback period model in
project selection.
(i) It does not consider the time value of money, i.e. two projects might have the same payback period,
but one project might bring in more money and quicker than the other.
(ii) The payback period does not consider the cash flow after the payback period has been completed
and is only concerned with the break-even point, without considering future cash flows beyond this
point therefore, the two projects might have the same breakeven point, but one project might
generate more money for the organisation in the long term.
The NPV is a sophisticated financial analysis technique that discounts cash flows expected over the life of the
project, to give an idea of the viability of the project (Burke, 2014). NPV calculations find the present value of
expected net cash flows of a project, discounted at the cost of capital (the interest rate at which the organisation
can borrow money) and subtract from the initial cost outlay of the project.
41 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
The NPV analysis can be laid out in the form of Table 2 as shown below:
In this example, a project will incur a R10 000 expenditure in Year 0 and will have a R3 000 cash inflow each
year for 5 years.
The discount factor can either be obtained from Discount Tables, or can be calculated from the formula:
Discount Factor = 1
(1 + r)t
Where: r = discount rate (interest rate at which money can be borrowed), t = period in years.
In the example above, the project would realise a positive cash flow of R1642.10 over the 5-year period. If the net
present value is positive, the project should be accepted; if it is negative, it should be rejected. If two projects are
mutually exclusive, that means, only one or the other project can be undertaken, not both, and then the project with
the higher net present value should be undertaken.
MANCOSA 42
Principles of Project Management
A negative NPV means that the costs of the project outweigh any future benefits, anticipated from the project in
the future, and therefore the project will not be viable.
Although the formula for NPV calculations is very complex and difficult to use manually, the calculations themselves
can be performed very simply using most financial calculators, as well as by using the formulas built into all of the
popular computer spreadsheet programs such as Microsoft Excel. The key is to interpret the results correctly.
Essentially, the technique works by setting a “hurdle rate” for the project. For example, management might
require any project to generate a 15% return on the money invested in the project. The 15% is the hurdle
rate. If the IRR analysis returns a rate greater than 15%, then the project can be considered as being viable.
A project that gives an IRR value below the hurdle rate should not be considered unless there are very good
strategic reasons for the project to go ahead. The same formula for Net Present Value is also used for
determining the Internal Rate of Return; it is just used in a different way. In determining the NPV, the
discount rate is specified, and in calculating the IRR, the NPV is set to = 0, and the discount rate is
calculated.
o Weighted Scorecard
In addition to the abovementioned methods of selecting a project, is the weighted scorecard (Oosthuizen
and Venter, 2018:58). The organisation will consider the financial and non-financial criteria which will assist
to provide the managers with a clearer idea of which project/s to select from a set of possible projects. In
practice, this approach to project selection is simple and effective especially where qualitative factors have
been given weights, according to their perceived performance.
43 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
ACTIVITY
Watch the video clip below to learn more about the lifecycle of the project:
Project Management. 2014. The Typical Phases in Project Management. [Online
Video]. Available at [Link]
ACTIVITY
Consider the project listed below. Focusing on one (1) step of the project, briefly
define at least one (1) key operation in each process community.
MANCOSA 44
Principles of Project Management
Project:
Monitoring
Initiating Planning Executing & Closing
Controlling
Phase Selected:
Initiating:
Planning:
Executing:
45 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
Closing:
1.9 Summary
The need for project management has been driven by businesses that have realised the benefits of organising
work around projects and the crucial need to communicate and coordinate work across departments and
professions. Many organisations do not employ full time Project Managers and it is common to pull together a
project team to address a specific need. Taking a role in a project team can be an excellent learning opportunity
and can improve a person’s career profile. Projects bring about change and project management is recognised as
the most efficient way of managing such change. The next section will deal with project integration management.
MANCOSA 46
Principles of Project Management
REVISION EXERCISE
1. Choose an organisation of your choice, map its structure and provide an analysis of
whether the organisation’s strucuture is functional, matrix or project based.
Copy the first letter of each word completed in the space provided below and then use the letters to create
as many project managements terms and concepts:
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22
47 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
Terms/ Concepts:
1. 2. 3.
4. 5. 6.
7. 8. 9.
19. 20. 21
22.
CASE STUDY
Read the case study on Clark Gates Manufacturing and answer the questions that follow:
BACKGROUND
By 1999, Clark Gates Company had grown into the third largest supplier of Gates for both commercial and home
use. Competition was fierce. Consumers would evaluate Gates on artistic design and quality. Each Gate had to be
available in at least five different colours. Commercial buyers seemed more interested in the cost than the average
consumer, who viewed the Gate as an object for security, irrespective of price.
Clark Gate Company did not spend a great deal of money advertising on the radio or on television. Some money
was allocated for ads in professional journals. Most of Clark’s advertising and marketing funds were allocated to
the two semi-annual home and garden trade shows and the annual builders trade show. One large builder could
purchase more than 5-10 gates for one newly constructed hotel or one apartment complex. Missing an opportunity
to display the new products at these trade shows could easily result in a six to twelve-month window of lost revenue.
MANCOSA 48
Principles of Project Management
CULTURE
Clark Gate had a non-cooperative culture. Marketing and engineering would never talk to one another. Engineering
wanted the freedom to design new products, whereas marketing wanted final approval to make sure that what was
designed could be sold. The conflict between marketing and engineering became so fierce that early attempts to
implement project management failed. Nobody wanted to be the project manager. Functional team members
refused to attend team meetings and spent most of their time working on their own “pet” projects rather than the
required work.
Their line managers also showed little interest in supporting project management. Project management became
so disliked that the procurement manager refused to assign any of his employees to project teams. Instead, he
mandated that all project work come through him. He eventually built up a large brick wall around his employees.
He claimed that this would protect them from the continuous conflicts between engineering and marketing.
Strange as it may seem, nobody could identify the initial cause of the conflicts or how the trouble actually began.
Senior management hired an external consultant to identify the problems, provide recommendations and
alternatives, and act as a mediator. The consultant’s process would have to begin with interviews.
ENGINEERING INTERVIEWS
“We are loaded down with work. If marketing would stay out of engineering, we could get our job done.”
“Marketing doesn’t understand that there’s more work for us to do other than just new product development.”
“Marketing personnel should spend their time at the country club and in bar rooms. This will allow us in
engineering to finish our work uninterrupted!”
“Marketing expects everyone in engineering to stop what they are doing in order to put out marketing fires. I
believe that most of the time the problem is that marketing doesn’t know what they want up front. This leads
to change after change. Why can’t we get a good definition at the beginning of each project?”
MARKETING INTERVIEWS
“Our livelihood rests on income generated from trade shows. Since new product development is four to six
months in duration, we have to beat up on engineering to make sure that our marketing schedules are met.
Why can’t engineering understand the importance of these trade shows?”
49 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
“Because of the time required to develop new products [4–6 months], we sometimes have to rush into projects
without having a good definition of what is required. When a customer at a trade show gives us an idea for a
new product, we rush to get the project underway for introduction at the next trade show. We then go back to
the customer and ask for more clarification and/or specifications. Sometimes we must work with the customer
for weeks to get the information we need. I know that this is a problem for engineering, but it cannot be helped.”
The consultant wrestled with the comments but was still somewhat perplexed. “Why doesn’t engineering
understand marketing’s problems?” pondered the consultant. In a follow-up interview with an engineering manager,
the following comment was made:
“We are currently working on 15 different projects in engineering, and that includes those which marketing
requested. Why can’t marketing understand our problems?”
Question
Critically discuss the critical project management issue and what can be done about it?
MANCOSA 50
Principles of Project Management
51 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
Unit
2: Project Integration Management
MANCOSA 52
Principles of Project Management
2.2 What is Project Integration Discuss the key principles of project integration
Management? management
2.3 Project Charter Develop a project charter using appropriate components for
a project
2.5 Direct and Manage Project Work Describe a method to direct, manage and control project
2.6 Monitor and Control Project Work work
2.7 Perform Integrated Project Control Describe perform integrated project control
53 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
2.1 Introduction
Within this unit, the concept of project integration is introduced, defining the essential role of the project manager
as the person who not only leads the initiative to develop a comprehensive project plan but also implements
processes that result in the effective execution of the project plan. Concepts will be introduced, including the
development of a project charter, a preliminary scope documenting high-level project strategy, milestones,
deliverables, and estimates for stakeholder, customer, and sponsor approval.
This unit also includes the processes and strategies used in the development of a project management plan, which
tracks the steps required to identify and organize tasks, reviews project deliverables and maintains monitoring and
management of costs, schedules and improvements to the project. This also involves evaluating how adjustments
to a specific aspect will affect how project managers can adapt their strategies, organize their responses and
convey the results to stakeholders.
Process integration – project managers are concerned with coordinating the different processes and
activities that make up a project. It is essential for the project manager to ensure that all processes are
coordinated in order to achieve the goals of the project.
Skills integration – projects are delivered according to plan and within the triple constraints of time, cost and
scope. It is necessary for project managers to integrate both “soft” and “hard” skills associated with leadership.
This will be further explored later in the module guide.
Strategic integration – project managers need to ensure that the project’s objectives are aligned and
integrated with the overall strategic objectives of the organisation. This is important aspect of both the project
selection process as well as portfolio management.
Context integration – project managers need to be keep abreast of new developments and trends in the field
of the project management. They must be mindful of the various issues that could impact the project success,
for example, new technologies could facilitate better communication and project planning.
MANCOSA 54
Principles of Project Management
Complexity and integration – projects and project processes are complex by nature. The project manager
should be cognisant that the interactions between the processes and project team needs to be carefully
managed when planning a project.
ACTIVITY
Consider the example of the project given below, and then give at least
three (3) examples of the project that you might find matching each
statement:
The first process that you are expected to undertake in any project is to develop a project charter for the project to
be formally approved. Ideally, the sponsor should develop a charter, but it is usually the project manager who
develops the project charter on behalf of the project sponsor. The process of "developing a project charter" is
located in the Integration Knowledge Area and is conducted during the Initiation Phase.
55 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
High level explanation of what the project must deliver (Scope of Work)
This is expanded to the Scope Statement and gives an overview of what would have to be done to reach the
scope statement.
Projects duration
Organisations require an estimation of how long it will take to schedule and execute on the project's
deliverables so that they can prepare and forecast their cash flow requirements, etc. accordingly.
Critical milestones
Milestones are usually main project milestones, such as a pre-Christmas product launch. There is no point in
releasing the product after the Christmas season, so that the deadline of 01 November can be set as a
benchmark for completion and launch.
Stakeholders
A list of possible stakeholders who could be impacted or influenced by the project.
MANCOSA 56
Principles of Project Management
READING
You are encouraged to read the full guest article by Angela Citivella (2020),
“Getting, Organizing and Running a Project”. Available at:
[Link] [Accessed 24
June 2020.
Oosthuizen and Venter (2018:184) states that “the purpose of the project plan is to provide the basis for managing
and controlling the project.” To draw up a project management plan, the project manager undertakes the task of
designing the project management plan. Figure 8 refers to the Project Planning Framework, which is basically the
overarching framework used by many other systems to create a final project plan or reference plan. A critical
phase that is being conducted in the planning process group, which is why it is located in the Integration Knowledge
Area.
57 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
Oosthuizen and Venter (2018:184) states that a typical project management plan (refer to Table 11) makes
reference to some of the common elements of a project plan which includes:
MANCOSA 58
Principles of Project Management
The authors further elobrate that the contents of the project plan will change from project to project as it depends
on the nature and environment of the project being undertaken. Some of the common elements of a formal plan
are illustrated in Figure 9 and Table 11 depicts the purpose of the various documents that make up the overall
project plan.
The resource-constrained schedule integrates most of the outputs of the planning process and contains key
information about the project’s schedule, scope, cost and performance data that will be used to manage and control
the project. The remaining elements of the plan are considered subsidiary plans that complement the resource-
contrained schedule (Oosthuizen and Venter, 2018:184).
Time or
Resource
Constrained
Project Schedule
Risk
Response Communication
Plan
Plan
The Project
Plan
Procurement
Quality Plan
Plan
Human
Resource
Plan
59 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
Table 3 - Purpose of the various documents that make up the overall project plan
Components of Description
the Project Plan
Resource- Integrates most of the outputs of the planning process and contains key information about the
constrained project’s schedule, scope, cost and performance data that will be used to manage and control the
Schedule project.
Communication Plan Documents stakeholder’s information needs, the communication approach, and the allocation of
communication responses.
Quality Plan Identify and document the quality specifications and/or expectations for the project and its
deliverables. This plan would also discuss the processes and expertise required to ensure
compliance.
Human Resource Identify and record the duties, obligations, skills needed, reporting relationships and training
(HR) Plan requirements of the various project team members. If team members are seconded to the project
from the functional departments of the project’s parent organisation, the HR plan may need to
address how they are transitioned into the project and then dealt with as their responsibilities
towards the project come to an end.
Procurement Plan Documents the procurement process, the criteria that will be used to choose between different
suppliers and the actions, roles, responsibilities, and timing required to ensure that the procurement
needs of the project are met.
Risk Response Plan Documents the process of managing risks on the project and documents the nature (including
assumptions) and responses to specifically identified risks on the project. Due to the nature of risks
and risk management, the initial risk response plan should be maintained throughout the life of the
project. For this purpose, the initial risk response plan that forms part of the project plan should be
translated into a formal risk register that can be used to manage and control risks over the project’s
lifecycle.
The project plan is a live document as it constantly evolves as the project progresses however, this document
needs to define key project parameters, at a high level in the beginning, such as scope, time and costs so that the
project can be baselined and against which it can be measured and reported. While the level of definition of the
project plan increases as the project progresses, any changes to it made through the approved change
management process. Furthermore, the project plan must be updated throughout the project to include new
developments about the project.
MANCOSA 60
Principles of Project Management
ACTIVITY
Watch the video clip below to learn more about the project planning process:
Project Management. 2014. Project Planning Process: 5 Steps to Project
Management Planning. [Online Video]. Available at
[Link] [Date Viewed: 20 August 2019]
The PMBOK Guide (2017) specifies that “Direct and manage project work is the process of leading and performing
the work defined in the project management plan and implementing approved changes to achieve the project's
objectives. The key benefit of this process is that it provides overall management of the project work" (Project
Management Institute, 2017).
The PMBOK Guide (2017) specifies that "Monitor and control project work is the process of tracking, reviewing,
and reporting the progress to meet the performance objectives defined in the project management plan. The key
benefit of this process is that it allows stakeholders to understand the current state of the project, the steps taken,
and budget, schedule, and scope forecasts” (Project Management Institute, 2017).
The PMBOK Guide (2017) specifies that "Perform integrated change control is the process of reviewing all change
requests; approving changes and managing changes to deliverables, organizational process assets, project
documents, and the project management plan; and communicating their disposition. It reviews all requests for
61 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
changes or modifications to project documents, deliverables, baselines, or the project management plan and
approves or rejects the changes.
The key benefit of this process is that it allows for documented changes within the project to be considered in an
integrated fashion while reducing project risk, which often arises from changes made without consideration to the
overall project objectives or plans” (Project Management Institute, 2017). The following framework may be used
to control changes in the project.
Indicator Action
MANCOSA 62
Principles of Project Management
In larger organisations, a Change Control Board may be appointed. The board normally comprises
experienced, high level individuals within the organisation who convene on a monthly basis to review change
requests from all the projects that they are involved in. Smaller projects or where no change control board
exists, the sponsor or client may constitute a Change Control Board (Project Management Institute, 2017).
63 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
Change request:
Proposed Change:
Justification:
Impact on Cost:
Impact on Quality:
Other Impact;
Associated risks
Follow Up
Documentation Updated: Yes No
Change Implemented: Yes No
Table 5 - Change Request Form. Adapted from The PMBOK Guide (2017)
Project Management Plan (Baseline Plan) is updated to include the approved changes
Once the amendment request has been approved, the change to the Baseline plan needs to be updated. Any
changes in scope and other Knowledge Areas, such as time, cost, quality, risk, etc., must be updated and
included (Project Management Institute, 2017).
MANCOSA 64
Principles of Project Management
For some, especially in the case of very large projects, the project could have been broken down into phases, in
which case this step would bring the phase to a close so that the next phase could be started and a new life cycle
could begin for the next phase of the project.
Oosthuizen and Venter (2018:264) explains that project closure activities ensures the recording of project
documents, archiving of organisational process assets, making final payments, releasing resources and
completing the project. Every project teaches lessons learned to the organisation whether it is a success or a
failure. So even after a project finishes, the documentation of this project is going to be helpful for completing the
future projects successfully.
The project closure activities will be discussed in more detail in Unit 6 of this guide.
2.9 Summary
This unit looked at the importance of Project Integration Management which coordinates all aspects of a project.
Projects are likely to have change requests to deliverables, management plans, project organisational assets and
so on. These changes must be recorded and documented in a proper way. Project integration, when properly
performed, ensures that all processes in a project run smoothly.
65 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
REVISION QUESTION
Read the following extract and develop a project charter for this project.
The college needs to embark on a project to collect funds for the anniversary celebration. All
students organising the event were asked to apply a project charter to the Managing Director
of the School. R20,000 was made available for the event. You need to find a project that will
raise the most money for the charity.
CASE STUDY
Boondoggle - Canada's Gun Registration System
A Boondoggle is a project that is considered a waste of both time and money, yet is often
continued due to extraneous policy or political motivations.
In June 1997, Electronic Data Systems and SHL System house started work on a Canadian
national firearm registration system. The original plan was for a small IT project that would cost
taxpayers only $2 million -- $119 million for implementation which was to be offset by $117
million in licensing fees.
But then, politics got in the way. Pressure from the gun lobbyists and other interest groups
resulted in more than 1,000 change orders in just the first two years. The changes involved
having to interface with the computer systems of more than 50 agencies and since that
integration wasn't part of the original contract, the government had to pay for all the extra work.
By 2001, the costs had ballooned to $688 million, including $300 million for support.
But that wasn't the worst part. By 2001, the annual maintenance costs alone were running $75
million a year. A 2002 audit estimated that the program would wind up costing more than $1
billion by 2004 while generating revenue of only $140 million, giving rise to its nickname: "the
billion-dollar boondoggle."
Questions
Critically evaluate what went wrong with the “Boondoggle” case study and how should the
scope management have been managed to avoid project failure?
MANCOSA 66
Principles of Project Management
67 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
Unit
3:
Project Scope and Time
Management
MANCOSA 68
Principles of Project Management
3.2 Project Scope Explain the key concepts of project scope management
3.3 Work Breakdown Structure Develop a Work Breakdown Structure for a project in a
given context or project
3.4 Project Time Management Explain the key concepts of project time management
3.5 Basic Network Diagram Describe basic network diagrams and determine a critical
path
3.8 Critical Path Explain and understand critical path and activity float
3.11 Control Project Schedule Explain the purpose of a control project schedule
69 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
3.1 Introduction
Within this unit, you will learn how to classify and categorise specifications, describe the scope of the project,
create a work breakdown structure (WBS), follow-up activities and develop a schedule. It also refers to scope
verification and validation. Ultimately, change control and configuration management is clarified in depth as it is a
critical process to ensure that these changes are done in a managed and monitored manner to keep the project
on track.
In order to translate an overall project objective into clearer terms, it can be described in specific, measurable,
agreed, realistic and time-bound (SMART) project characteristics. If a SMART scope statement is included in a
project charter document, it can contribute towards the success of the project planning, costing, scheduling and
implementation stages however, a project manager cannot take the scope statement for granted (Oosthuizen and
Venter, 2018:101).
READING
Read the guest article on “Actions that will define Project Management in 2020,
available at: [Link]
[Accessed on 24 June 2020]
MANCOSA 70
Principles of Project Management
The project manager draws up a proposal document in response to the RFP. In the proposal document to be
presented to the project sponsor, the project manager puts forward proposed solutions or approaches for each
task listed in the SOW. If the Project Sponsor is satisfied that the project manager has understood the scope
requirements and will achieve the project objectives, the contract or project is awarded. The original SOW from
the RFP document will then be converted into a scope statement.
A major project can be broken down into smaller, more manageable parts of work allocations by using levels to
depict the size of the work activities to be completed (Oosthuizen and Venter, 2018). The authors further note that
the WBS will reflect a complete breakdown of all needed to deliver the project to the lowest achievable level. The
degradation of the deliverables into their smallest sections is called decomposition. There are three ( 3) broad
aspects to the work-breakdown structure:
o Title
The title is taken from the Project Charter and is the title of the project or process that is being planned.
o Deliverables
In the WBS, the deliverables are generally displayed since nouns, as they are physical objects that need to be
shipped and are normally graphically depicted in a package. Based on the scope of the project, there can be
many "levels" of deliverables. The first level of deliverables is taken from the Scope Statement. For certain
71 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
instances, the 1st level deliverable could require several additional deliverables to complete it; this will entail
the development of 2nd level deliverables. Quite seldom WBS systems have more than three tiers of
deliverables. The 21st party deliverables at this stage may be place, cake, catering, etc. It may be floors,
walls, roofs, etc. for building constructions.
3.3.1 Numbering
Figure 12 shows that the WBS numbering reflects the hierarchical nature of the WBS and typically uses a decimal
numbering system where each new level adds a digit. This numbering will become important as the activity list is
created in the knowledge area of time management. Consider a WBS of 10 deliverables each with three (3)
second-level deliverables and ten work packages / activities. That will be equal to 300 job packages that need to
be handled. Without any kind of index, things could get complicated very quickly.
MANCOSA 72
Principles of Project Management
73 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
Oosthuizen and Venter (2018:108) states that define activities “… are specific actions that have to be completed
during the course of the project in order to attain the project objectives.” Activities have an expected duration, will
have associated costs, and utilise specific, identifiable resources in order to be realised. An activity can be seen
as a piece of work that consumes time, while people or equipment either work or wait. The duration of an activity
MANCOSA 74
Principles of Project Management
is measured in units of time. This means that it can be estimated in seconds, minutes, hours, days, weeks, months
or years, depending on the nature of the project.
An easy way to create an Activity List is to use a spreadsheet.
It is difficult to delegate expenses, length, or obligations to these tasks within the WBS. Figure 15 transforms WBS
graphically into a table shape, just like the one below. Costs and length can be quickly incorporated and retained
as project planning progresses.
75 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
Figure 15 - Most project management solutions have a table format for the Activity List. You can also use MS
Excel or other spreadsheet packages.
MANCOSA 76
Principles of Project Management
ACTIVITY
Use the WBS numbering system, show the degree of decomposition (e.g.
Title is Level 0) and the task reference numbers by labeling the WBS above.
Oosthuizen and Venter (2018:122) defines Sequence the Activities as “…the relationships between the activities
used to manage and control the rest of the project.” Optimising these relationships will have a significant effect on
the overall success of the project. The authors further explain that there are several methods that can be used to
document the relationships between activities; such as a list of activities with notes about how they relate to one
another, or a diagram that illustrates their dependencies.
77 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
Sequencing activities clearly means that the team must consider how each activity relies on the other. In most
instances, this means that an activity must wait for another activity to be completed before it can start. Think about
all the activities involved in making a birthday cake. You can't start icing the cake before you bake it, and you can't
cook the cake before you mix the batter. There is a clear connection between the activities and the recognition of
these connections between the activities is what sequencing is all about.
The most popular methodology used in modern project management is the Precedence Diagramming Method
(PDM) in which the activities are viewed as a diagram and the relationship between the activities is defined by
connecting arrows. There are three (3) specific forms of relationship of dependence.
Figure 16 indicates that the Finish-to-Start arrangement is the most common relationship used in project
management.
Finish-to-Finish (FF)
This relationship occurs when two (2) or more activities need to be completed before another can begin. Using
the Birthday Cake example in Figure 17, "Preheat Oven" and "Prepare Cake Batter" activities can occur at the
same time, but all must be completed before the "Bake Cake" activity can begin. The relationship between
preheating the oven and preparing the cake batter is a finish to finish relationship. They don't need to finish
at the same time, but both of them need to be done before you can "bake the cake."
MANCOSA 78
Principles of Project Management
Start-to-Start (SS)
There is a Start-to-Start relationship between activities where an activity needs an activity to start before it can
start. Using the birthday cake example, once the "bake cake" activity has begun, the "make icing" activity will
start. Activities do not have to start at the same time, but the icing can’t start until the "bake cake" has begun.
Start-to-Finish (SF)
There is a fourth relationship, called Start-to-Finish. When recording dependencies, it can become difficult if
the task description is used. The WBS reference number or other reference number is used to simplify matters.
In project software, the table line number is also used as a reference. Figure 18 shows that once established,
the dependences and relationships are reported in the operation list under the Dependency column.
79 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
The most popular type of network diagram is called an Activity on Node. Within this diagram type, the activity
description is captured within the node (box) and the relationship is expressed in the arrows. The realistic way to
build a network diagram is to use Sticky notes and place them on a whiteboard or desk so that they can be moved
around. When a diagram has been accepted, it can be formalised in a hard copy. (Take a visual snapshot of the
diagram before adding the sticky notes.)
Figure 19 is an example from an activity on node diagram that reflects a party's preparation. Remember that the
network diagram runs from left to right, and that the activity description are inside the node (box or circle). It is good
practice to provide a single start and finish operation to which all paths are connected.
MANCOSA 80
Principles of Project Management
81 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
For ease of comparison, the same network diagram as graphically shown in Figure 20 has been updated to
represent only the reference code and some of the relationships have been omitted. The reference in this case is
alphabetical characters. The reference number of the WBS may also be used in this way.
There are multiple network paths in Figure 20 above. The network path represents a series of linked activities.
Every break will establish a new route after an activity. Imagine this is a road map and there are many routes
(paths) that need to be followed from start to finish.
Oosthuizen and Venter (2018:128) implies that “activity durations and resource requirements are completed as
separate steps; in reality these steps are often completed at the same time.” The accuracy of estimating duration
MANCOSA 82
Principles of Project Management
will be based on the accuracy of the information available to the project team. Some of the methods used to
estimate the duration of activities are:
Macro-Estimating (top-down)
Macro-estimating implies that the project manager works from the highest level of the WBS to the bottom
(Oosthuizen and Venter, 2018:128).
Micro-Estimating (bottom-up)
Micro-estimating works from the lowest level of the WBS and rolls the estimates up to the major deliverables
of the project. This approach tends to provide a more accurate picture about the project, but it is usually not
the project managers first choice when making estimates (Oosthuizen and Venter, 2018:128).
Hybrid-Estimating
Oosthuizen and Venter (2018:129) posits that the quality of estimates has a significant impact on the
successful planning and outcome of any project, and therefore it is important for the project manager to
achieve the correct balance between macro- and micro-estimating. In practice, projects are often estimates
using a hybrid approach that combines the benefits of both macro and micro estimating techniques. This
provides the project manager with the flexibility to plan activities that fall into the short-term horizon in much
greater detail than would be required for those falling into the medium-or long-term horizons (Oosthuizen and
Venter, 2018:129).
Most likely estimate – This estimate is based on realistic expectations, what is the most likely estimate for the
duration of the activity?
Optimistic estimate – This estimate is based on a best-case scenario, what is the shortest possible time that
the activity could be completed in?
Pessimistic estimate – This estimate is based on the worst-case scenario. If everything goes wrong, how long
would the activity be expected to take?
83 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
Having calculated the three (3) potential outcomes, the PERT analysis uses the following formula to predict
the period of the experiment.
Project preparation will take place from a set starting point and all tasks are planned from that date onwards. The
goal is to complete the project in as short a period as possible from the start date.
ACTIVITY
List a few projects that have been planned from the start point.
On the other hand, the project may have a fixed completion date by which time everything has to be completed. In
this case, the schedule would have to be calculated backwards to ensure that the start date is feasible.
ACTIVITY
List a few projects that are planned from a fixed finish date
MANCOSA 84
Principles of Project Management
Various cultures and resources (people) use different calendars. For example, the traditional South African
calendar is different from the Chinese calendar. It is necessary to determine the calendar that is relevant to the
project and resources when planning a project.
THINK POINT
Think how the team would feel if their project manager had neglected to plan weekends
as non-workdays. The program will allow everyone to work for the entire duration of the
project seven (7) days a week in order to fulfil the deadline.
Oosthuizen and Venter (2018:132) defines the critical path as the “longest path of activities that determine the
completion date of the project. Alternatively, it refers to the path of activities with the least amount of common
slack”.
This description seems to be contradictory, but the reasoning is right. If you consider the alternative paths that the
project would have to follow, the project can only be finished after all the paths have been finished. Some paths
may be shorter than others, but the project can only be deemed complete if all paths have been completed.
Therefore, the length of the longest route is also the shortest time possible to complete the project. When a critical
route has been established, the project will be scheduled to reach any deadlines or restrictions that will impact the
project.
Find the following network diagram shown in Figure 21. The activity has an approximate period measured in the
Approximate Activity Duration phase. Table 12 indicates that if the length of each operation on the path is added
together, the length of the path can be determined. The longest path (Critical path) in this case is Start, F, G, I,
85 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
Finish. With this information, the project manager will be able to notify the sponsor that the project will take at least
18 days to complete.
Remember that the critical direction is always zero slack. This ensures that any delay in an activity along the critical
path would result in delays to the end date of the project. For this purpose, activities along the critical path usually
take priority and require careful attention to ensure that there are no delays.
MANCOSA 86
Principles of Project Management
At this point, the calculations for the complete critical path analysis need not go forward and backward. You need
to grasp the basics of the critical path as mentioned above.
ACTIVITY
Calculate the Critical Path and Float of the network diagram. Durations are in a few days.
87 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
Each phase of the project is represented by a line, or bar, put on the chart during the time period in which it is to
be carried out. When the Gantt chart is finished, it displays the flow of activities in sequence as well as those that
can be carried out at the same time. The length of the bar or line in the Gantt chart is proportional to the period of
the activity.
Some steps can be carried out in parallel, and at the same time as another step, with one step taking longer than
the other. This allows some flexibility about when to start the shorter step, if the plan has it finished in time to flow
into subsequent steps. This situation can be shown with a dotted line continuing to the time when the step must
be completed. This indicates slack time.
When the Gantt chart is finished you will be able to see the minimum total time for the project, the proper sequence
of steps, and which steps can be under way at the same time.
The usefulness of a Gantt chart can be improved by charting the actual progress of activities. This is usually done
by drawing a line in a different colour below the original line to show the actual beginning and ending dates of each
step. This allows you to quickly assess whether the project is on schedule. An alternative method is to use a
coloured highlighter to highlight progress on each activity.
Gantt charts are very useful in managing progress in projects as described above but are limited in their ability to
show the interdependencies of activities, especially in complex projects. In projects where the steps flow in a simple
sequence of events, they can portray adequate information for project management however, when several steps
are under way at the same time and a high level of interdependency exists among the various steps, the Gantt
chart is less useful.
MANCOSA 88
Principles of Project Management
In this case, a more sophisticated diagramming tool such as PERT/CPM is a better choice. The Gant Chart plays
a very important role in managing and controlling project processes. It is very easily constructed using popular
spreadsheet software or can be constructed manually using pencil and paper.
Its use in controlling a project lies in the ability to keep the Gantt chart up to date. A simple technique is to print out
the Gantt chart and then to update progress using coloured highlight pens. In order to record progress of a
particular activity or sets of activities, one simply has to colour the bar to depict progress as each day passes.
Once a week, the bar chart can be updated in the computer system and distributed at project meetings. A typical
example of a Gantt Chart is depicted in Figure 22 below:
89 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
ACTIVITY
Participate in The Project Management Game available at:
[Link] and follow the steps:
Register your name (free) before you play the game;
Read what this game is all about;
Familiarise yourself with the interfaces and what they include;
Read the instructions;
Play the game;
Capture the score or results;
Discuss the game.
The PMBOK Guide (2017) specifies that “Control Schedule is the process of monitoring the status of project
activities to update project progress and manage changes to the schedule baseline to achieve the plan. The key
benefit of this process is that it provides the means to recognize deviation from the plan and take corrective and
preventive actions and thus minimize risk”.
Tools and techniques to check and report on the projects progress according to the schedule include:
Performance reviews – Analysing the performance of the project against the agreed upon Project Plan;
Methods to analyse the performance include:
o Trend Analysis
The PMBOK Guide (2017) refers trend analysis as a mathematical tool you can use to assess your
project data to determine how it is doing and forecast how it will continue to do. It is common to see
a trend analysis represented in graphical form. This way you can easily see the way your project is
trending, i.e. is your project on track, improving, or falling behind?
MANCOSA 90
Principles of Project Management
Tracking Gantt ChartsThe PMBOK Guide (2017) notes that the Tracking Gantt charts offer a very
useful tool for assessing the actual progress of the project against the defined project plan timeline.
The initial Gantt chart remains in place and the actual dates of completion of the activities are
displayed below each activity on the chart.
3.12 Summary
Darter (2014) confirms that the finish date of a project has a major impact on the project team. While every project
has a finish date and the methodology used to arrive at the finish date varies from project to project, the amount
of stress involved to achieve the finish date also varies subject buy in from key stakeholders. Time management
therefore is a key aspect of the project management function. The project success depends on the successful time
management as time is one of the main project constraints that needs to be closely managed.
REVISION QUESTION
1 Why do you think project scope management is critical?
2 Do you agree with the ideas presented in the clip below? Why/why not?
[Link]
3 Find the following scenario to have special equipment imported by ship
from the USA.
91 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
CASE STUDY
A True Story of Scope Creep - The Wasa (Vasa)
Wasa (Vasa) is a Swedish warship built between 1626 and 1628. The ship sank after
sailing about 1,300 m (1,400 yd) into her maiden voyage on 10 August 1628.
The ship was built on the orders of the King of Sweden Gustavus Adolphus as part of
the military expansion he initiated in a war with Poland-Lithuania (1621–1629).
Sweden was leading power in Europe during that time. It was time for a new era of
large battleships, which demand the enemy’s respect, serving as firing platforms for
mighty cannons to fight from a distance. The king himself was principal stakeholder
and sole sponsor of the projects to construct the Vasa. So what went wrong?
Questions:
What went wrong and what were the lessons learned?
How could Scope Management assist the project manager on this project?
MANCOSA 92
Principles of Project Management
93 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
Sourced from Robc. 2016. The Project Management Game: Test your Skills as a Project Manager.
[Link] [Date Accessed: 16th September 2019]).
CASE STUDY
Answers:
(a) Stakeholder Disengagement - Poor communication between sponsor/stakeholders and the project manager.
The King gave orders from afar without visiting the construction to connect with key players and make more
informed decisions (a Show & Tell could have avoided this issue)
(b) Scope Creep - King does not know every task that goes into each change and the risks it induces. It
demonstrates even more the importance of a controlled change management process that reflects the impact
of each change transparent and realistically. This gives the sponsor or stakeholders a chance to reconsider
whether the change should then be approved or not
MANCOSA 94
Principles of Project Management
Unit
4: Project Quality, Cost,
Procurement and Risk
Management
95 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
4.2 Project Quality Management Develop the key deliverables in a project quality management
plan
4.4 Project Procurement Discuss the project procurement management plan that suit the
Management project and organisation
4.5 Project Risk Management Describe the key deliverables of project risk management
MANCOSA 96
Principles of Project Management
4.1 Introduction
This unit focuses on all aspects of project quality management which involves understanding the quality processes
of the company, creating an effective quality management plan, using quality management methods and
techniques, and identifying the main mechanisms for assessing and recording the quality of the project. You are
also exposed to the cost management concepts of the project and their importance to project management. You
can learn how to predict costs using cost management techniques. We further discuss the design of the project
budget and find the techniques and processes that enable project managers to track and regulate the project
budget. You are taken through the basic concepts of project management and how modern companies handle
various forms of contract relationships. Lastly, the principles of risk control and the risk management strategy are
discussed in depth.
Project Quality Management is about ensuring that the project delivers exactly what was requested in the Project
Charter. If the Project Charter calls for a low-quality product and the team produces a high-quality product, then
quality management would have failed. At the other hand, if the Project Charter calls for a high-quality product and
the project produces a low-quality product, it will also have failed to control its quality. Quality management is all
about matching deliverables to the specifications of the project.
Customer Satisfaction
Understand precisely what the consumer wants and deliver on those standards.
Management Responsibility
Although quality management should be a concern for everyone, management has a duty to ensure that time
and money are made available for the implementation of quality management.
97 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
Continuous Improvement
The use of the Deming method, Plan – Do – Test – Act (PDCA), popularized by Dr. W. Edwards Deming,
enables continuous improvement in project and organisational efficiency. Deming 's model calls for
preparation, then to act on that preparation by executing the plan, to review what is being accomplished and
then, if necessary, to act on any problems that need change. Blokdyk, G (2018).
While every effort should be made to ensure that there are no quality problems, the fact is that things are going
wrong and, as such, there will be costs associated with quality assurance.
Clements and Gido (2018) describes two (2) quality management concepts, namely quality assurance and quality
control. They highlight the importance of planning for quality by explaining that it prevents poor quality and avoids
quality problems. There are also costs of quality that one needs to be familiar with from a quality management
perspective for managing projects. These are:
The cost of quality is the sum of costs a project will spend to prevent poor quality and any other costs incurred as
a result of outputs of poor quality. Poor quality is the waste, errors, or failure to meet stakeholder needs and project
requirements (Burke, 2014). The cost of poor quality can therefore be broken down into the three categories of
prevention, appraisal, and failure costs:
Prevention costs
These are planned costs an organisation incurs to ensure that errors are not made at any stage during the
delivery process of that product or service to a beneficiary.
Appraisal costs
These include the costs of verifying, checking, or evaluating a product or service during the delivery process.
MANCOSA 98
Principles of Project Management
Failure costs
A project incurs these costs because the product or service did not meet the requirements and had to be fixed
or replaced, or the service had to be repeated.
READING
Read the guest article on “Put Quality in Place” by Robin Hornby. Available
at: [Link] [Accessed on 24
June 2020]
Kloppenberg (2017:305) explains that the Quality Management Plan may include a description of the quality
baseline by which the project will be judged, along with methods for quality assurance and control. The Quality
Management Plan is a portion of the overall project management plan. The author further explains that a Quality
Management Plan should describe how to identify some or all of the following:
ACTIVITY
Using a project of your choosing, develop a Quality Management Plan
99 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
THINK POINT
Consider the graphic below. How do you think the project would rate in terms
of project quality management?
The section presents the concepts of project cost management and their contribution to project management. You
can learn how to predict costs using cost management techniques. It also discusses the design of the project
budget and deals with techniques and processes that enable project managers to track and control the budget of
the project.
Top-down budgeting – this involves the development of a long-term budget by top management, which is
passed down to various departments and units in the organisation and translated into operational budgets.
MANCOSA 100
Principles of Project Management
Bottom-up budgeting – this is prepared by project managers for their individual projects, which are also used
by functional managers and upper management to prepare unit-level and overall budgets.
Iterative budgeting – this involves the use of both top-down and bottom-up approaches, with top
management setting an overall budget, which is then revised by project managers when setting budgets for
the projects.
The budgeting process involved four (4) steps. These steps are explained below.
Oosthuizen and Venter (2018:229) states that “cost estimation begins at the proposal stage. It is also at this stage
that a breakdown of costs is provided. Costs relating directly to projects and which can accordingly be attributed
to specific work packages include labour, raw materials and supplies, equipment and subcontractors, travel, etc.”
When a project is performed under contract, care should be taken to distinguish cost estimating from pricing. Cost
estimating involves developing an assessment of the likely quantitative result – how much will it cost the performing
organisation to provide the product or service involved.
The estimates obtained from the various approaches provide a basis for the project budget, these costs form the
project budget baseline and serves as a point of comparison. The authors further explain that estimates are made
using the following five (5) methods (Oosthuizen and Venter, 2018:229):
101 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
Parametric Testing
Parametric testing involves using project characteristics (parameters) in a mathematical model to predict
project costs. Testing may be simple (residential home construction will cost a certain amount per square
metre of living space), or complex (one model of software development costs uses thirteen separate
adjustment factors, each of which has five to seven points on it). Both the cost and accuracy of parametric
testing vary widely. They are most likely to be reliable when a) the historical information used to develop the
model was accurate, b) the parameters used in the model are readily quantifiable, and c) the model is scalable,
that is, it works as well for a very large project as well as a very small one. An example would be, if you know
that a resource costs R250 per day and the activity takes five (5) days, the activity will cost R1,250 (5 x R250).
Apportionment Approach
The total estimated cost is apportioned to different parts of the work that needs to be completed. This is also
an extension to the parametric testing. For example, the total budget for the development of new software is
R100,000. 60% of the budget may be apportioned to development of the code, 20% to testing of the new
software until the full 100% has been allocated to work that needs to be completed.
Bottom Approach
This technique involves estimating the cost of individual activities or work packages, then summarising or
rolling up the individual estimates to get a project total. The cost and accuracy of bottom-up estimating is
driven by the size and complexity of the individual activity or work package: smaller activities increase both
cost and accuracy of the estimating process. The project team must weigh the additional accuracy against the
additional cost.
Computerised tools, such as project management software, spreadsheets, and simulation/statistical tools are
widely used to assist with cost estimating. Such products can simplify the use of the tools described earlier
and facilitate rapid consideration of many costing alternatives.
Iterative Approach
This approach is also referred to as the hybrid approach is a rough total cost for which the project is estimated,
and the detailed cost estimates at the work package level are used to adjust the overall project cost. This
adjustment then allows the project managers to adjust their overall project budgets. The process might repeat
itself several times until the final estimate and budget is derived.
MANCOSA 102
Principles of Project Management
103 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
MANCOSA 104
Principles of Project Management
ACTIVITY
Suppose you have a small budget of R1.5 million. Use the sample project
plan available at
[Link] or you could
use an alternative to complete the following:
Identify and assign resources;
Estimate costs;
Schedule the project;
Determine the project budget.
105 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
Kloppenberg (2017:323) states that “In traditional project procurement management literature, purchasing, supply
management, and procurement are usually used interchangeably to refer to the integration of related functions to
purchase or acquire the needed materials and services for the project team. Thus, procurement management is
not only concerned with the standard steps in the purchasing process such as recognising needs, translating needs
into commercially equivalent descriptions, and searching for suppliers.”
From this viewpoint, Oosthuizen and Venter (2018:292) defines project risk as “an uncertain event or set of
circumstances, should it or they occur, would have an effect on the achievement of one or more project objectives”.
A risk has a cause and, if it occurs, has a consequence. For example, a cause may be requiring a permit or having
limited personnel assigned to the project. The risk event is that the permit may take longer than planned, or the
MANCOSA 106
Principles of Project Management
personnel may not be adequate for the task. If either of these uncertain events occurs, there will be a consequence
on the project cost, schedule or quality. Risk conditions could include aspects of the project environment that may
contribute to project risk such as poor management practices, or dependency on external participants that cannot
be controlled.
Project risk includes both threats to the project’s objectives and opportunities to improve on those objectives. It
has its origins in the uncertainty that is present in all projects. Known risks are those that have been identified,
and analysed, and it may be possible to plan for them. Unknown risks cannot be managed, although project
managers may address them by applying a general competency based on past experience with similar projects.
In addressing unknown risks, a generic risk model may be of benefit.
Many of us grasp the negative side of risk, not the positive side of risk. From a project point of view, it's all about
confusion. For example, currency risk, if the local currency (Rand) deteriorates against the US Dollar, any imported
materials will be costlier and adversely affect the cost of the project. Conversely, if the currency rises against the
dollar, the cost would decrease. This is referred to as a positive risk.
Organisations perceive risk as it relates to threats to project success. Risks that are threats to the project may be
accepted if they are in balance with the reward that may be gained by taking the risk. For example, adopting a fast-
track schedule that may be overrun is a risk taken to achieve an earlier completion date. Risks that are opportunities
may be pursued to benefit the project’s objectives.
107 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
Step 1 – Initiation
Oosthuizen and Venter (2018:294) explains that “Initiation is project risk management planning step.” In this
process, the project manager will prepare the ground for the managing risks on the project. This step will result in
a project risk management plan, which is part of the overall project plan. For example, the level of risk management
to build the world’s longest bridge would be far greater than that required for a stage production. The risk
management approach for each project will be specific to match the overall risk of the project. The initiation step
is the only step in the process that is not repeated. Most projects should include the elements below:
MANCOSA 108
Principles of Project Management
109 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
Once the risks have been identified, a risk register shall be created listing the risks associated with the project
(Table 13).
MANCOSA 110
Principles of Project Management
Risk Register
Set up venue Tables and chairs are dirty These columns will
Bad weather
Some activities will
Water interruptions
have several
Make cake Cake flops
associated risks
Deliver cake Cake is damaged en-route
Gets drunk
Gets drunk
Some activities may not have
Loses data/pictures
any risks. They are not
Settle accounts Funds not available recorded on the register.
111 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
Probability
Probability is linked to the probability or possibility that the event may arise under normal circumstances. An
example of that would be the possibility that there will be a chance of traffic congestion in a large city. The
chance is most likely to be four or five. Conversely, the risk of an accident on the way to work is likely to be 1
or 2; very low or low.
Impact
In evaluating the effects of the risk, presume that the risk has arisen and weigh the effects it will have on the
project. Use traffic congestion as another example, there could be a mild effect on the project and the score
will be 3. In the case of a road accident, the impact may be fatal and, as such, a score of 5 would be reported
for this risk.
In order to promote the risk-scoring process, there will always be some debate and discussion of the result.
At some point, the facilitator will have to resolve the debate by selecting the most likely score and going on.
Table 9 is an extract from the 21st Birthday Party Project Risk Register with the probability and impact
completed.
Risk Register
Bad weather 3 4
Water interruptions 1 5
The probability of water
Make cake Cake flops 2 3 interruptions is very low, but
it will have a very high
Deliver cake Cake is damaged en-route 3 3
impact if it occurs
MANCOSA 112
Principles of Project Management
Once the probability and impact have been scored, the two (2) scores are multiplied together to get a score
for each risk. For example, the risk of load shedding scored 4 for probability and 5 for impact.
The total score for the load shedding risk is 20. (4 x 5 = 20)
The risk of water interruptions scores 5. Probability 1 and Impact 5. (1x5 = 5)
Table 16 indicates that after the scores been completed, the project manager has an indication of which risks need
the most preparation and planning.
113 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
6 Bad weather 3 4 12 5
7 Water interruptions 1 5 5 18
15 Gets drunk 2 4 8 12
17 Gets drunk 2 4 8 13
18 Loses data/pictures 1 5 5 16
MANCOSA 114
Principles of Project Management
Table 11 indicates where the risk is in terms of its probability and impact ranking. Using the risk register in the
previous section, the risk matrix will look as follows:
Risk no’s 4, 5 and
Table 11 - Risk Probability & Impact Matrix for the 21st Birthday Party. 10 have a
probability of 4 and
4 4, 5, 10
High
Probability
Moderate
3 9 6, 13 2
1 7, 16, 18
1 2 3 4 5
Very Low Low Moderate High Very High
Impact
115 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
The project team needs to build a risk response strategy to respond effectively to increasing threats. The types of
project risk response strategy are structured to reduce the probability and/or impact of the risk. For example, see
Table 18 of the Risk Response Strategy for the 21st Birthday Party.
Avoid
Where the risk greatly outweighs the benefits, the team may opt to mitigate the risk by extending the timeline,
changing the scope, changing the project plan or, in extreme cases, fully stopping the project. In doing so, the
risk would have been minimised and completely excluded from the risk register.
We do this all the time in our daily life. Remember that you are heading to a restaurant at night, and you know
the dark alley is a shortcut to your goal. You also know that people get mugged in that alley on a regular basis;
by deciding to take a longer, safer route; by reducing the possibility of being mugged.
Transfer
Another choice open to the team is to pass the effect and risk analysis to a third party. This is generally
achieved in the form of an insurance premium or an outsourcing option to the contractor who takes
responsibility and liability for the risks associated with the activity.
Many households have household insurance to cover liabilities that could harm the home. The insurance is
charged as a premium and if the house is damaged by cyclones, floods or fire or destroyed, the insurance
provider must respond to the damage and compensate for the repairs.
Mitigate
Where the risk probability and impact can be reduced (mitigated), the team can prepare a risk response that
puts in place measures to reduce the impact or likelihood of the risk.
THINK POINT
Include the possibility of artefacts dropping on the construction site. The risk could
be minimized by installing screens in all exposed areas where tools and materials
could break. The probability may also be reduced by having a day-to-day inspection
of the site looking for potential falling hazards and removing them before they fall.
Accept
If the team agrees that while there is a risk, the team does not believe it is important to take any action and
acknowledges the risks and consequences if they do. If a risk is acknowledged, the safest choice is to build
up a buffer of money, time or resources to deal with the risk should it occur. You do not need to know or
understand the answer to positive risks, but you need to understand what a positive risk is.
MANCOSA 116
Principles of Project Management
4 Insufficient 4 5 20 1 Mitigate Confirm with venue manager Booking venue Rajesh / / RJSH
electrical points that there is sufficient power
If possible, the risk of load
shedding could be avoided by Mitigate Purchase extension leads and Insufficient plugs Rajesh / / RJSH
changing the schedule. If not, it multiplugs
could be mitigated by using a Mitigate Hire generator Insufficient power Rajesh / / RJSH
5 Load shedding 4 5 generator.20 2 Avoid Schedule around load Booking venue Rajesh / / RJSH
shedding calendar
Mitigate Hire generator Set up venue Joan / / Joan PT
10 Post Office fails to 4 5 20 3 Avoid Send emails and call directly Post invites Tasha / / Tasha
deliver invites
2 Preferred venue is 3 5 15 4 Select venue Tasha / / Tasha
fully booked
6 Bad weather 3 4 12 5 Mitigate Move outdoor activities into Weather forecast Devon / / Devon
hall predicts rain
In this case, the team can mitigate Mitigate Have umbrellas available for Weather forecast Devon / / Devon
for rain and bad weather arriving guests predicts rain
Mitigate Valet service for parking Weather forecast Devon / / Devon
predicts rain
13 Feuding parties 3 4 12 6 Avoid Do not invite Send out invitations Tasha / / Tasha
seated together Mitigate Place opposing parties at Plan seating Tasha / / Tasha
different tables
117 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
4.6 Summary
Egeland (2013) compares project management to a box of chocolates as you never know what is inside. Every
project is unique, and every project will have a set of risks associated with the project. While the risks can be
unknown before the start of the project, and some remain unknown after, by following the proper risk management
methodology from the beginning of the project the impact of most of the project risks can be minimized and, in
some cases, eliminated.
MANCOSA 118
Principles of Project Management
REVISION QUESTION
Statement: Project Quality Management is all about ensuring that the project
delivers what is expected to happen. This does not mean that a high-quality
product has to be supplied to the project. The charter and scope of the
project could call for a low-quality product. Discuss the above statement
using an acceptable illustration.
CASE STUDY
Read the case study on The Life Esidimeni Tragedy
The Life Esidimeni Tragedy: How 143 mentally ill South Africans were sent to their deaths
Details of the scandal have emerged through legal proceedings that have been broadcast live. Tragically, these
were deaths foretold. When word first emerged of the plan to move patients to the care homes, doctors, patient
advocacy groups and family members all pleaded with the government to halt it.
Some went to court to stop it, withdrawing their action only when the government agreed that patients would not
be moved without the families’ consent or to facilities that were not as good as Life Esidimeni. Yet, just a few
months later, the government broke its promise, moving patients so quickly and shambolically that many were sent
without medicines or medical records. So chaotic was the move that the authorities lost track of many of the
patients: 59 are still missing, and nine of the dead have not been identified.
The transfer of patients was ostensibly aimed at saving money. But an investigation by the health ombudsman, a
public watchdog, concluded that it would probably drive up costs. Ideological hostility to for-profit corporations
(such as Life Esidimeni) may have played a role. But it cannot explain why patients were handed over to charities
that were so plainly unsuitable.
The tragedy is far from unique. “Although you won’t find anything else on this scale, we hear reports on a daily
basis of mini-Esidimeni scandals around the country,” says Mark Heywood, one of the founders of Section 27, an
advocacy group that went to court to try to stop patients being moved. Jack Bloom, a shadow minister of health in
Gauteng province for the opposition Democratic Alliance, points to other crises, such as one in KwaZulu Natal, the
second-most-populous province, where hundreds of cancer patients have died because radiotherapy machines
are not working and hospitals are not staffed.
119 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
Such cases highlight a wider failure in the health service because of “corruption, a breakdown of accountability
and a culture of impunity [within government]”, says Mr Heywood. There was ample evidence of all this at the
hearings into Life Esidimeni, where a string of senior officials has blamed others for the tragedy. Take, for example,
Makgabo Manamela, the province’s director of mental health. A report by the health ombudsman found that she
played a leading role in moving patients and put them at risk by illegally certifying the facilities they were moved to
when they were plainly unsuitable. Yet, under cross examination, Ms Manamela insisted that she should not be
blamed. “I was following the instructions of my superiors,” she said. “It was not the plan that people would pass on
[die].”
Her boss, Tiego Selebano, testified a few days later that he was not to blame either, since he too had been obeying
orders and had been under “pressure” from the then provincial heath minister, Qedani Mahlangu, to move the
patients. Ms Mahlangu, meanwhile, has yet to offer an excuse. Her lawyer told the legal proceedings in November
that she was too busy to testify before late January because she was studying financial markets and wealth
management at a British university.
None of the officials involved in the tragedy has been fired (though several have been suspended and face
disciplinary hearings), nor have any politicians other than Ms Mahlangu resigned. Lawyers say that there seems
to be enough evidence for prosecutors to bring criminal charges against officials or the managers of care homes.
But few expect this to happen, since the National Prosecuting Authority has become politicised under the
presidency of Mr Zuma, who faces 783 charges of fraud and corruption.
Many of those who lost loved ones say they do not want retribution, but merely the truth. “They told me lies,” says
Ms Phehla, as she struggles to understand how and why her daughter died. “Even now I want answers.”
[Link]
their-deaths Extract of an article having appeared in the Middle East and Africa section of the print edition under
the headline "Failed by the state" (11 Jan 2018)
Question:
Critically discuss how the project team could have prevented the death of 143 patients through proper risk
management?
MANCOSA 120
Principles of Project Management
121 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
Unit
5: Project Resource, Communication
and Stakeholder Management
MANCOSA 122
Principles of Project Management
5.2 Project Resource Management Discuss the project resource management and their role in
a project
123 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
5.1 Introduction
Projects require people with specific abilities to complete them successfully. In this unit, we will first explore project
resource management – a professional field that is all about preparing, organizing and creating a project team in
order to put together the best people with the right expertise to work together to ensure the successful completion
of the project. The unit considers project coordination management, which includes processes related to efficient
communication and management of project-related knowledge. The last section, addresses project stakeholder
management, emphasizing the value of project managers and their teams to take care of all those involved or
impacted by the project and to handle the project.
MANCOSA 124
Principles of Project Management
Stakeholder Approach
This approach involves stakeholders from outside the business. The communication is often one of networks
and represents multi directional exchanges of information.
5.2.3 The difference between managing people in operational environments vs project environments
Oosthuizen and Venter (2018:375) posits that operations are ongoing, cyclical and repetitive. For example, Nestle,
will continue to manufacture chocolate bars as long as the machines are in a good working condition, and supplied
with the materials to keep the production line operating.
Projects however, are temporary and unique. A typical chocolate project may involve converting the manufacturing
plant from one type of chocolate bar to a new or different chocolate bar, e.g. the machinery required to manufacture
Nestle Bar One is different to that of Nestle Aero.
THINK POINTS
What is the relevance of project resource management to project
management?
Forming
The stage in which the team first comes together, and all participants determine where they fit into the
team. The emphasis is very much on all the tasks, and every member of the team is trying to "be good."
125 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
Storming
Commitment and direction from the project manager, the team starts to set guidelines for how they work
together.
Norming
After working through the storming stage, the team starts to embrace, appreciate and trust each other.
The team is now beginning to be successful and to see itself as a team rather than a group of individuals.
Performing
While working together and learning to work together, the team becomes successful and learns to function
independently.
Adjourning
Once the team's objectives are met and the project begins to be near completion, the team enters its final
phase where it disengages from the team and moves on to other things.
Figure 25 represents the success of the team as they progress through the stages. Remember how the
performance of the team deteriorates during the storming stage. The primary goal in coordinating team building
and growth activities is to try to push the team through the Forming and Storming stages as quickly as possible so
that the advantages in working in the process of success can be realised.
MANCOSA 126
Principles of Project Management
This allows the project manager to communicate very clearly to each member of the project team:
• What are the goals and priorities of the project;
• What needs to be done;
• For whom it is;
• In which order;
• By when;
• What kind of criteria.
This can be greatly encouraged by cultivating a participation and teamwork attitude. In order to allow effective
teamwork, the project manager must give both the necessary authority and responsibility to the members of his or
her team. Growing person or team must be able to manage their own activities based on the work they will be
contributing to. Many projects face technological challenges related to the technology of the project, whether in
information systems, engineering, construction or administration however, these are in the field of technology
involved in the project and not in the field of project management, so the project manager must have adequate
knowledge of the technology to be able to understand the issues.
For example, there will always be issues that need to be addressed by the project manager. Many issues can
become "issues" that stand in the way of progress. When the project manager does not have sufficient authority
to address the problem, it should be immediately "escalated" to the sponsor of the project, or even higher resolution
management. Conflicts should be seen constructively and resolved. Through this way, team leaders increase their
contribution to the goals and priorities of the project. Inevitable, there would be "risks" that may transform into
incidents that must also be controlled.
127 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
Listening
Observing
Sensing
Filtering
Analysing
Interpreting
MANCOSA 128
Principles of Project Management
Project communication embraces a large body of knowledge and within a project management context,
communication focuses on:
How the project team members communicate with one another;
How the project team, and specifically the project manager, liaise with senior management and
internal stakeholders on project resources and progress;
How the project team liaise with external stakeholders such as the media and community leaders;
The distribution of information to all project stakeholders and role-players using appropriate
media and technology;
The planning and compilation of a project communication plan;
Project-related documentation (progress reports, etc.).
129 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
MANCOSA 130
Principles of Project Management
131 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
MANCOSA 132
Principles of Project Management
Oosthuizen and Venter (2018:321) explains that there are several techniques that can be used to identify
stakeholders, ranging from informal (such as professional judgement and brainstorming) to formal (such as
structured interviews, survey, sampling and research). The choice of chosen technique should ideally fit the
requirements of the project and the degree of participation required.
Stakeholder Analysis
The stakeholder analysis takes a somewhat similar methodology to the risk analysis methodology. A list of
stakeholders can be identified and documented in the log by brainstorming with the team and looking at
previous projects.
Expert Judgement
More insight into the needs and desires of stakeholders can be gained by interviewing specialists around the
project.
Meetings
Through engaging with key stakeholders and the team, the priorities and aspirations of established
stakeholders can be better defined and understood.
Stakeholder Register
A stakeholder registry shall be drawn up having defined the stakeholders involved in the project. Table 16 provides
a preview of the sort of information that should be included in a standard stakeholder register:
133 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
Who will be responsible for managing any interaction with them? Joan (PM)
Adapted from own source.
Oosthuizen and Venter (2018:326) argue that the matrix should be divided into four (4) broader areas
representing a high or low power rating and a high and low interest rating as shown in Figure 28 and Table
23.
MANCOSA 134
Principles of Project Management
Figure 28 - High or Low Power rating and a High and Low Interest rating.
Source - Oosthuizen and Venter (2018:328)
Table 17 - Tabular illustration of High or Low Power rating and a High and Low Interest rating.
As the two (2) diagrams are merged, the parties collapse into quadrants or combinations of quadrants. A
strategy that suits them can be defined on the basis of where they are.
135 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
Figure 29 - High or Low Power rating and a High and Low Interest rating
Adapted from own source.
Stakeholders 1 and 2 need to be handled very closely, as shown in Figure 29. Stakeholder 5 wants similar
consideration, but with an emphasis on keeping him / her happy.
Stakeholders 4, 8 and 9 need to be kept updated and stakeholders 3 need to be handled closely with more
emphasis on being updated.
This approach is not prescriptive but offers a framework for developing a plan for managing stakeholders. A
strategy that meets the needs and desires of stakeholders can be built on the basis of the above criteria (see Table
24). The project manager can also prioritise the level of attention being paid to stakeholders.
MANCOSA 136
Principles of Project Management
137 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
Oosthuizen and Venter (2018:329) further stated that the project manager’s ability to develop effective stakeholder
management skills will depend on how well the project manager is able to identify, analyse and define stakeholder
relationships and then develop appropriate response strategies. Over and above the direct relationship between
the project and the stakeholders, the project managers also need to consider the relationship between stakeholders
when developing his/her stakeholder strategy.
Through monitoring and control the interaction between the project and the stakeholders, the project manager will
change how they communicate with the stakeholders and alter the register and stakeholder management plan as
the project progresses.
An important part of effective stakeholder management is to ensure that the wider project team has a clear view
of stakeholders and the project's approach to managing those stakeholders. Oosthuizen and Venter (18:330).
Stakeholder management is practiced through constructive communication as part of the relationship management
plan and through the development of interpersonal skills that create trust and help resolve conflicts. The
management expertise of the project manager and the team can also lead to successful stakeholder management.
READING
Read the case study by Eva Riis and Pernille Eskeriod “How to gain value
from a Project Management Model”.
Available at: [Link]
[Accessed on 24 June 2020]
MANCOSA 138
Principles of Project Management
5.5 Summary
This unit focussed on Communication and Risk Management. It showed that poor communication can result in
misunderstandings between stakeholders hence the need to have a clear Project Management Communication
Plan. It also looked at risk and presented risk mitigation measures. It also presented the tools and techniques used
in risk management.
ACTIVITY
Who do you think would the stakeholders be in a project to build a bicycle
track though and around Zoo Lake in Johannesburg?
CASE STUDY:
Read the Case Study below and answer the questions that follow:
N.S. Matsiliza (2016) conducted research into the E-toll road project implementation. The main purpose of this
study was to assess the observations that were made regarding critical factors involved in the e-tolls project.
Although the project evidently generated challenges in its incipient stage, the project manager (i.e. SANRAL) and
the Gauteng Government continued with its administration that later was to place the project under dire constraints.
The implementation of the GFIP project partly achieved its objectives relating to the need to increase the capacity
of the economy through the levying of an e-toll on all road users, and the immediate effect on job creation. The
setback of these objectives is demonstrated by refusal of motorists and stakeholders using the N1 highway to
accept the project and pay the fees levied. The problem of congestion came about as a result of the rising levels
of vehicle ownership, a phenomenon, at least in part, that was spurred on by the growth of the middle class. Such
growth was coming to place ever more pressure on the existing infrastructure, resulting in the need to adopt a
strategy that was to provide a user-friendly transport model. In conclusion, some of the critical factors that were
overlooked and affected the E-Toll project’s success enabled the prevailing threats to be seen as emanating from
the decision taken by SANRAL and the Gauteng Government, lack of proper consultation, excessive project costs
due to delays and rejection of the project by the stakeholders concerned. Even though the task team that was
mandated to investigate the causes of this rejection African Journal of Hospitality, Tourism and Leisure Volume 5
(1) - (2016) ISSN: 2223-814X Copyright: © 2016 AJHTL - Open Access- Online @ http//: [Link] 8
recommended that the initial e-toll rates be halved, the solution has not yet come to alter the status quo to any
significant extent. SANRAL and the government had clearly used a top-down approach in decision making relating
to the project planning and implementation. Both bodies overlooked the warning signs in respect of the risk factors,
hence leading to the overall rejection of the e-tolls project by its key stakeholders.
139 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
Extract - Critical Factors in Respect of Managing the E-Toll Road Project in Gauteng, South Africa. Author
N.S. Matsiliza (2016)
Questions
(a) From the objectives of project management, i.e. Cost, Schedule and Scope, critically discuss whether the E-
tolls project was successfully implemented – state your assumptions, if any.
(b) Identify the main critical factor which lead to the current situation whereby the people are not paying for E-
tolls.
(c) What lessons can be drawn from this case study?
REVISION EXERCISE
1. Why do you think teams are more effective than individuals working on
their own?
2. How could this contribute to the success of a project?
3. Why does communication play a pivotal role in any project?
4. In what ways other than project meetings could the project manager
communicate with team members and stakeholders?
MANCOSA 140
Principles of Project Management
(b) There are many critical factors in a project like E-toll. The main factor causing people not to pay is the with
regards to Client Consultation and Participation.
(c) What we can learn? – a project cannot be successful is the stakeholder’s expectations are not managed
properly
141 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
Unit
6:
Project Closure
MANCOSA 142
Principles of Project Management
6.2 Triggers to Project Closure Summarise and list project closing tasks and outputs
6.3 Project Closure Activities Discuss the process of closing a project performed as part
of project integration management
6.4 Lessons Learned Explain several best practices used in project management
143 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
6.1 Introduction
Project closure is the last process of the Integrated Management knowledge area. Project closure focuses on
closing out all project management knowledge area because there are several processes and activities that are
executed in all other knowledge areas. Close projects or phase process will ensure successful completion of these
activities and processes as well.
The main purpose of the project closure process is collecting all project documents, getting final acceptance
archiving documents and finalizing the project officially. Project Closure is also referred to “Project Closeout” which
is a formal process to end a project, either because it is completed, or because it has been terminated.
Project completion
When the project is completed successfully, the close project process should be implemented.
Notifying the client of project completion and ensuring that delivery is accomplished
The customer will be requested to indicate acceptance and/or satisfaction by signing a formal document stating
that the project’s final product, as requested, has been delivered.
MANCOSA 144
Principles of Project Management
Ensuring that documentation is complete, including the preparation of the closure report
The project manager will use a checklist to make sure that all project documents have been completed with final
entries, and then prepare the project closure report. Storing project records of completed projects is important to
ensure:
The required documents are updated to reflect the completion of activities on the project
Accurate historical data exists. This can be used to assist in the planning of future similar projects
Project files reflect final actual values in terms of time, cost, functionality and quality. This can be compared
against the planned values
Specification sheets reflect how the deliverables look and perform
Contractual and procurements records reflect any modifications or contractual exceptions
Redistributing project team members, materials, equipment or any other resources to appropriate places
After the project is completed successfully, all assignments of the project resources are closed, lessons learnt
inputs from the project resources are collected and then these resources are released respectively. Project closure
is as important as the other project life cycle phases. These activities must, therefore, be taken into consideration
for better outcomes in future projects.
145 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
Ensuring that such documents are stored in proper places and that the responsibility for document
retention is turned over to the client
Collected documents are finalised. Final versions of the project management plan and all necessary documents
about the project are archived in a manner that will assist with easy future retrieval. Some project records (for
example, user manuals, training materials and product procedures) will be used by the customer and ownership
must be transferred to the customer.
Ascertaining any product support requirements, deciding how such support will be delivered and
assigning responsibility
Once the product of the project has been accepted by the customer, the project manager may still be required to
provide support. This would be described in warranty/support documentation.
READING
Read the case study by Hessel Friedlander “Did everything right but got it
wrong”
Available at: [Link]
[Accessed on 24 June 2020]
MANCOSA 146
Principles of Project Management
Project Name Enter the project name Date Enter the Date (dd/mm/yy)
Lessons learned are recorded
Knowledge Areas Lessons Learned What Worked Well Lessons Learned that What Didn’t Work Well
that Worked Recommendation Didn’t Work Recommendation
Scope Describe the lessons Provide a recommendation Describe the lessons Provide a recommendation
learned that worked for continued use for each learned that didn’t work for improvement for each
so that a novice would lesson learned that worked so that a novice would lesson learned that didn’t
understand. well. understand. Add/delete work well. Include details
Add/delete numbers numbers as needed for such as: Role, Position of
Add/delete numbers as
as needed for each each knowledge area. who needs to make the
needed for each
knowledge area. change, etc.
knowledge area.
Time
Cost
Quality
Communication
Risk Management
Project Resources
Procurement
6.5 Summary
Looking back over the various phases of the project as the entire undertaking comes to an end is an important
task. Project managers must make sure no pieces have been left undone. During this phase the project manager
will meet with team leaders to close out all work orders related to individual team participation. It is important to
be sure that all details related to the procurement process throughout the project have been properly documented.
It is common for some goods and services to change throughout a project; all necessary paperwork regarding
substitutions and any resulting change in budgetary allotment must be reflected. Closing out invoices and preparing
the final report in a timely manner gives a good impression about the project and the due diligence of the project
manager. Lesson learned should also be documented.
147 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
REVISION EXERCISE:
What are the most important project closure activities?
Case Study:
In relations of the case study below and using an example from your personal
experience, critically discuss the concept of post project review and with the
aid of a close out report, identify and explain the lessons learned.
When you’re weren’t listening to that, team members were engaged in other shouting matches;
“You can’t keep making changes or we’ll never to get to finish!”
“You never tell us about delays until the last minute!”
“I don’t care that you’ve already finishing testing, this is not what we want!”
“What’s this project really about anyway?”
Usually, post project reviews are poorly attended and rather than offering an opportunity for learning and
improvement, they often slide into finger-pointing, blame avoidance and a continuation of the conflicts that
developed during the project. Neither the project team members, the users, nor the project manager learn anything
from this process of poking through the wreckage. The wounds may be too fresh and the effort seems pointless.
Worst of all, the organisation’s process for doing projects don’t get better and the same problems wreck project
after project. But there is an alternative.
MANCOSA 148
Principles of Project Management
Question:
In relations to the above case study and using an example from your personal experience:
1. Critically discuss the concept of post project review
2. With the aid of a close out report, identify and explain the lessons learned.
149 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
Answer:
It is important in closing projects that all activities are finalised and the completed project is transferred to the
appropriate people. In situations where a project was not completed but cancelled, steps must still be taken to
bring the project to closure.
5. The closing stage of a project comprises all the final processes needed to close out a project and deliver final
products and reports to the stakeholders. This stage ensures that all documents and deliverables are
organised and handed over to the relevant stakeholder’s / business units. Also, any remaining contractual
obligations, payments, vendor evaluations, etc. is done during the project closing stage.
6. The Project Management Plan was poorly designed and implemented, i.e. Project Charter, Project Scope
Creep and Project Time Management.
MANCOSA 150
Principles of Project Management
Choose an organisation of your choice, map its structure and provide an analysis of whether the organisation’s
strucuture is functional, matrix or project based.
UNIT TWO
151 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
Project Charter
Project Title
Client / Company
Sponsor
Project Manager
Date Initialized Date Appointed
Explanation of what the project must deliver to honor the Scope Statement (Scope of Work)
Identified Risks (High Level Risk Analysis that Relates to the Project as a Whole)
Date Relevance to the Project
Stakeholders
Stakeholder Description of How They May Affect or be Affected by the Project
MANCOSA 152
Principles of Project Management
Other
153 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
UNIT 3
UNIT 4
Statement: Project Quality Management is all about ensuring that the project delivers what is expected to
happen. This does not mean that a high-quality product has to be supplied to the project. The charter and scope
of the project could call for a low-quality product. Discuss the above statement using an acceptable illustration.
Answer:
Do not underestimate the value of the project charter as any project should not be started without one. If the
project charter serves as a definition of how success will be measured, then without a project charter, the project
and project manager cannot be successful. It states the deliverable or end result of the project.
MANCOSA 154
Principles of Project Management
UNIT 5
UNIT 6
REVISION QUESTION ONE:
Answer:
Refer to Section 6.3 for a list of the project closure activities.
155 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
Bibliography
All Africa. (2013) South Africa: Nation, Vietnam Sign Pact to Save Rhino. [Online]. Available at:
[Link] [Accessed 30 May 2019].
Angel, M. (2015) Four Steps Project Managers Should Follow to Help Ensure Strategic Success.
[Online]. Available at: [Link]
Managers-Should-Follow-to-Help-Ensure-Strategic-Success [Date Viewed: 7 June 2019].
Bolman, L. and Deal, T. (2017) Reframing Organizations: Artistry, choice and leadership. (6th Edition).
San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.
Blokdyk, G. (2018) Deming PDCA Cycle: A Clear and Concise Reference. Emereo Pty Limited
Burke, R. (2014). Project Management: Planning and Control Techniques (5th Edition). John Wiley &
Sons
Fred, D (2013). Strategic Management: Concepts and Cases, (14th Edition). Pearson’s Education.
Gido, J. and Clements, J. P. 2015. Successful Project Management. (6th edition). Cengage Learning.
Hiner, J. 2009. Five Prerequisites for Successful IT Projects. [Online]. TechRepublic. Available at:
[Link]
projects/ [Date Viewed: 30 May 2019].
Lewis, JP. 2007. Fundamentals of Project Management. 3rd edition. New York, (NY): Amacom.
MANCOSA 156
Principles of Project Management
Kaschny, M. and Nolden, M. 2018. Innovation and Transformation: Basics, Implementation and
Optimization. Springer International Publishing. Switzerland
Oosthuizen, T.F.J. and Venter, R. (2018). Project Management in Perspective. 2nd Edition. Oxford
University Press.
Project Management Institute. 2017. A Guide to the Project Management Body of Knowledge.
(6th edition). Pennsylvania (PA): Project Management Institute, Inc.
Steyn, H., Carruthers, M., Du Plessis, Y., Kruger, D., Kuschke, B., Sparrius, A., Van Eck, S.,
and Visser, K. 2012. Project Management: A Multi-Disciplinary Approach. (3rd edition).
Pretoria: FPM Publishing.
Thayer School of Engineering at Dartmouth. Five-level Work Breakdown Structure. [Online Video].
Available at [Link] [Date Viewed: 30 May 2019].
Thayer School of Engineering at Dartmouth. Project Task Descriptions – Work Packages. [Online
Video]. Available at [Link] [Date Viewed: 30 May
2019].
The Institute of Directors of Southern Africa (2016). King IV Report on Corporate Governance.
[Link]
E3A007F15A5A/IoDSA_King_IV_Report_-_WebVersion.pdf [Date Viewed: 27 November 2019]
157 MANCOSA
Principles of Project Management
Watt, Adrienne. 2015. Project Management. The adaptation is a part of the BCampus Open
Textbook Project.
Youker, R. The Difference between Different Types of Projects. [Online]. Available at:
[Link] [Date Accessed: 07 December
2015].
MANCOSA 158
Principles of Project Management
159 MANCOSA
The key responsibilities of a project team include maintaining effective communication with stakeholders, compiling project-related documentation like progress reports, and planning and executing meetings to discuss project status, deliverables, and team dynamics . Project teams are also responsible for managing resources effectively as defined in the project resource plan, which involves recruiting, team building, and ensuring team members are adequately trained for their roles . Another responsibility is fostering high degrees of teamwork and cooperation, which involves ensuring that all team members understand their roles and contributions to the project . These responsibilities contribute to project success by ensuring clear communication, optimal resource allocation, and strong team dynamics, all of which are essential for meeting project scope, time, cost, and quality objectives . Effective stakeholder engagement and communication also play critical roles in aligning project goals with stakeholder expectations, thus minimizing risks and maximizing project outcomes . Together, these elements help in achieving project success by ensuring that projects are completed on time, within budget, and to the required quality standards .
Project management processes involve a range of activities that occur at different stages of a project, and they can be categorized into process groups such as initiating, planning, executing, monitoring and controlling, and closing. Each process group encompasses several processes that are aligned to distinct knowledge areas including integration, scope, time, cost, quality, human resources, communication, risk, procurement, and stakeholder management. These processes and knowledge areas interact in a coordinated fashion to ensure the successful completion of a project, each supporting different aspects of the project lifecycle .
A project manager's role extends beyond daily project management through strategic integration, which ensures projects align with organizational objectives . They need to manage integration across processes, skills, and context, coordinating different activities to achieve project goals . This includes handling complex interactions between project processes and team dynamics . They also deal with various forms of conflict resolution and stakeholder communication, requiring both authority and negotiation skills with top management and team members to maintain smooth project operations . Project managers also play a critical role in adapting to new trends, managing changes, and improving project methodologies through continuous learning and adaptation . Leadership and the ability to influence different levels of organization and stakeholders are crucial for successful project outcomes . Additionally, they ensure that the project contributes positively to the overall strategic goals of the organization ."}
Common mistakes in risk management include confusing risks with their causes or effects, which hampers effective management. For instance, referring to heavy rainfall as a risk when it is actually a cause, or missed deadlines as a risk when they are an effect, leads to mismanagement of risks . To avoid these mistakes, it's crucial to clearly identify and differentiate between risks, their causes, and their effects using structured methods like risk registers . Another mistake is failing to engage stakeholders adequately, as their roles and responsibilities in risk management need to be clearly defined and agreed upon . This can be avoided by involving all relevant stakeholders early in the project and maintaining clear communication throughout. Additionally, not regularly updating the risk management plan is a common error. Risk management should be an ongoing process where risks are reassessed as circumstances change, and new risks are included in the risk register . Regular monitoring meetings where risks are reviewed alongside other project tasks ensure that risk management remains integrated into the project management process . To guard against these pitfalls, project managers can use proactive risk responses to absorb or harness uncertain events before they occur, and reactive responses as contingency plans . By adopting a comprehensive and iterative approach, project managers can minimize the impact of risks on their projects ."} थर्यप कमन्थाबरप ह्यश दन्नभ्यकитай थरीन्रप ह्यशणतीथ धपझक{
Change management is crucial in controlling scope creep as it provides a structured process to assess, approve, or reject change requests. This ensures all changes to the project scope are documented and their impacts on time, cost, and quality are evaluated before implementation . Formalising change requests through a documented process prevents unforeseen changes and helps maintain project objectives and deliverables, as well as stakeholder expectations, in check . Additionally, established change management processes like a Change Control Board review reduce the risk of project derailment caused by unchecked modifications . Failure to control scope creep, like in the "Boondoggle" case study, results in projects running over budget and beyond schedule due to unplanned and unapproved changes . Proper change management thereby helps mitigate these risks and avoid potential cost overruns .
Organizational strategy and project management are interlinked through the alignment of project objectives with strategic objectives to achieve desired outcomes. Strategic integration is necessary to ensure that project goals support the overall organizational strategy . Projects serve as vehicles for executing business strategies by translating strategic objectives into actionable tasks managed through project management methodologies . This involves defining projects that align with the organization’s goals, and selecting and prioritizing them based on strategic importance . Effective project integration management ensures that all processes are coordinated to achieve the project objectives, thus contributing to the strategic goals of the organization . Additionally, the allocation of resources, including human and financial, should be optimized to execute strategies through projects effectively, emphasizing the necessity of aligning project tasks with organizational aims and objectives . The integration at multiple levels—process, skills, and strategic—ensures that the project outcomes align with the organizational strategy, enhancing overall effectiveness and efficiency in achieving project objectives .
The Work Breakdown Structure (WBS) is critical in project time management as it serves as a foundational tool that organizes the project deliverables and tasks into a detailed, hierarchical structure. This detailed breakdown helps in converting project scope statements into manageable tasks that can be scheduled and timed effectively, forming the basis for creating a project timeline . The WBS helps define specific activities required for project completion, and these activities are then assigned durations and resource requirements, facilitating accurate time estimation and scheduling . By explicitly defining tasks and their dependencies, the WBS plays a pivotal role in monitoring project progress and time management, ensuring that the project remains on schedule . This structured approach is essential for controlling scope creep and ensuring efficiency in managing time constraints and delays .
Effective scope management prevents project failure by clearly defining project objectives and deliverables, thereby reducing uncertainty and misunderstandings. By freezing specifications early, scope management helps avoid rampant changes that can lead to cost overruns and delays, as seen with the "billion-dollar boondoggle" where over 1,000 change orders significantly increased costs . Properly managing scope creep through change management and effective control mechanisms can ensure that the project remains within budget and on schedule, preventing the negative impact of ever-expanding deliverables . Coordination and integration of project processes and activities, as per integration management principles, also contribute to effective scope management, ensuring that all project elements are aligned and no unexpected additional work is needed . Such strategic oversight helps achieve project objectives without unnecessary complications, thereby averting potential project failures.
A project risk register is crucial for documenting all identified risks as well as their analysis and planned responses, acting as a central repository for managing project risks . It is used to improve decision-making by providing a structured format for evaluating the likelihood and impact of each risk, which helps in prioritizing which risks to address . The risk register is maintained throughout the project, being regularly updated to reflect new risks or changes in previously identified risks, ensuring proactive risk management . By effectively utilizing the risk register, project managers and teams can develop and execute targeted risk response strategies, including mitigation and contingency plans, thus enhancing the overall resilience and success of the project .
The project sponsor plays a crucial role in linking the project to the broader organizational and external environment. They are responsible for acting as a bridge between the project's management team and senior management, ensuring that organizational policies and processes are aligned and followed, and advocating for the project to create a supportive working environment. Furthermore, the sponsor provides high-level oversight and guidance throughout the project, from developing the business case to reviewing and approving the project charter, which includes defining the project's scope and key performance metrics. This ensures that the project aligns with the overall mission and strategic goals of the organization and facilitates decision-making during and after the project's execution . Additionally, the sponsor's approval and support are vital for the project to move through different phases smoothly and maintain alignment with strategic objectives ."}