Rural Settlements
Rural Settlements
16 Study of Settlements
The situation of a settlement is its location in relation to surrounding human and physical
features. We usually describe the situation when we are telling someone where a
settlement is.
The original site selected for a settlement often refers back to the physical features
surrounding the selected site. Candidates must be able to identify these site factors on a
simple sketch diagram or on a topographic map, as this concept can be tested in Paper 2
(Mapwork).
1 Refer to FIGURE 16.4 below showing site and situation factors of various settlements.
1.1 Clearly differentiate between the terms site and situation. (2 x 1) (2)
1.2 For each of the settlements A to H, provide the most likely factor that
determined its site. The same site factor may be used for more than
one settlement. (8 x 1) (8)
1.4 Give ONE negative factor associated with selecting sites E and I
respectively. (2 x 2) (4)
1.5 Why, despite the negative factors mentioned in QUESTION 1.4, did
the development of settlements at E and I most likely continue?
(2 x 2) (4)
FIGURE 16.5 also shows which settlements are classified as rural and which are classified
as urban. In rural settlements the main function is primary activities (unifunctional),
whereas in urban settlements there are many secondary and tertiary activities (multi-
functional).
Figure 16.6: Urban hierarchy characteristics Figure 16.7: Rural and urban settlements
The concepts of rural settlement patterns and the shape of rural settlements must be
clearly separated.
Advantages are:
Disadvantages are:
Disadvantages are:
The shape of rural settlements refers to the outline shape of the entire settlement.
Features such as roads, rivers, and canals play an important role in the shape of rural
settlements. Individual houses will usually be placed as close as possible along these
features; therefore it will develop a linear shape.
When roads intersect one another, individual houses will be placed alongside the road,
resulting in a cross-shaped or star-shaped outline.
Centrally placed features such as ponds, water wells or churches play an important role in
settlements that have a circular shape. Roads will radiate outwards from the centre. In
traditional circular settlements the central feature is a kraal for protection of cattle.
1.2 Classify the settlements Brisco Hill and Longtown, with reasons,
according to the following criteria:
1.3 Describe the difference in settlement pattern between Brisco Hill and
Longtownmoor. Provide map evidence for your answer. (3 x 2) (6)
(b) Suggest a reason for the elongated (long and narrow) shape of
the individual farms in settlement C. (1 x 2) (2)
(c) Explain why the farms at C are likely to experience soil erosion.
(2 x 2) (4)
2.6 A decision was taken to upgrade the existing road running past the
settlement at B. Explain how, and why, this decision would change
the classification of the village in the urban hierarchy. (2 x 2) (4)
18 Rural Settlement Issues
Figure 18.1: Push and pull factors responsible for rural-urban migration
HOPE
Susanne Melda, 26 November 2012
1.2 The extract implies 'hope' from rural-urban migration. What are
the migrants expecting in the urban areas? (2 x 2)(4)
2.4 Mention TWO reasons why stagnation (no growth taking place)
occurs in rural towns. (2 x 2) (4)
3.1 Name the push factor in the cartoon that caused rural-urban migration.
(1 x 1) (1)
3.2 Name the pull factor that attracted John to the city. (1 x 1) (1)
3.3 Refer to the cartoon (frame 4). Why was Joan surprised by John's
attraction to the city? (1 x 2) (2)
3.4 State TWO other expectations John had that were NOT met when he
moved to the city. (2 x 2) (4)
4 Study FIGURE 18.7 showing the trend in people living in rural areas in South Africa
4.1 Comment on the trend from 2004 to 2015 in the graph regarding
people living in rural areas. (1 x 1) (1)
4.2 What percentage of South Africans lived in rural areas in South Africa
in 2015? (1 x 1) (1)
4.3 Give a projected percentage for the South African rural population in
2020. (1 x 2) (2)
4.4 What impact will the trend in QUESTION 1.1 have on rural areas in
the future? (2 x 2) (4)
4.5 If the trend in QUESTION 4.1 continues, South Africa might head for
food insecurity in the near future. In a paragraph of approximately
EIGHT lines, outline sustainable measures to ensure continued food
security. (4 x 2) (8)
18.2 Social Injustices
Access to Resources
What to expect
Understand the concept social injustice
Understand why rural areas lack access to resources
Describe the implications of a lack of access to resources for the rural community
Provide reasons for high rate of HIV/Aids incidence in rural areas
Describe and explain who is most vulnerable as result of HIV/Aids in rural areas
Implications of high rate of HIV/Aids incidence in rural areas
Provide possible measures to alleviate social injustices in rural areas
Land reform and related issues
According to the SA Human Rights Commission, who visited all nine provinces,
poor infrastructure failures and no, or little, access to water and sanitation exists in
rural areas.
Figure 18.8: No piped water in homes Figure 18.9: Unhygienic pit toilets
The major problem with sanitation in rural South Africa is that there are many pit
toilets, of which most are full and inactive. Every time it rains, the ground becomes
contaminated and this leads to many illnesses and deaths.
Various reasons are listed for the poor access to water in rural areas:
Even though the SA Government implemented many rural water supply schemes
under the National Reconstruction and Development Programme (NRDP), drinking
water continues to be of poor quality and is typically considered unsafe.
The following solutions could assist to ensure the provision of water to rural areas:
5 Study FIGURE 18.11 showing water as a social justice issue in rural areas.
5.1 How was water transported in rural areas prior to the invention of the
water wheel shown in FIGURE 18.11? (1 x 1) (1)
5.2 How has the water wheel by Wello changed access to water in rural
areas? (1 x 2) (2)
5.3 Discuss the role that access to water in rural areas play in
empowering women in rural areas. (2 x 2) (4)
5.4 Describe how access to water in rural areas could reduce poverty in
rural areas. (2 x 2) (4)
5.5 Give TWO reasons for the poor water infrastructure in rural areas of
South Africa. (2 x 2) (4)
HIV/Aids
In South Africa, HIV/Aids have been acutely experienced in rural areas. A recent
Fact Sheet prepared by the FAO clearly describes the threat to rural Africa:
South Africa has the biggest and most high-profile HIV epidemic in the world,
with an estimated 7.7 million people living with HIV in 2018. South Africa
accounts for a third of all new HIV infections in southern Africa.
More than two-thirds of the population of the 25 most-affected African countries
lives in rural areas.
Information and health services are less available in rural areas than in cities.
Rural people are therefore less likely to know how to protect themselves from
HIV and, if they fall ill, less likely to get care.
Costs of HIV/Aids are largely borne by rural communities as HIV-infected urban
dwellers of rural origin, often return to their communities when they fall ill.
Women are most vulnerable, not only to HIV/Aids infection, but also to the
economic impact of HIV/Aids. This is often a result of the gendered power relations
evident in rural households, which can leave women prone to the infection of HIV.
In rural areas, women tend to be even more disadvantaged due to reduced access
to productive resources and support services. UNAIDS has also reported that some
traditional mechanisms to ensure women's access to land in case of widowhood
contributes to the spread of the HIV infection. Women, widowed due to HIV/Aids,
sometimes lose rights to land, adding to an already insecure situation. In some
contexts, if a widow does not marry her husband's brother, she loses access to her
husband's property. The issue of HIV/Aids and inheritance therefore impacts on
women in rural areas.
HIV prevention programmes are interventions that aim to halt the transmission of
HIV. They are implemented to either protect an individual and their community, or
are rolled out as public health policies.
Figure 18.13: Prevention of HIV/Aids infection
South Africa has made great strides in tackling its HIV epidemic in recent years and
now has the biggest HIV treatment programme in the world. Moreover, these efforts
are now largely funded from South Africa's own resources. HIV prevention initiatives
are having a significant impact on mother-to-child transmission rates in particular,
which are falling dramatically. New HIV infections overall have fallen by half in the
last decade, however, there are still too many. While the short term financing of
South Africa's HIV epidemic is secure, in the longer term, the government needs to
explore other strategies in order to sustain and expand its progress.
6 Study the map in FIGURE 18.15 which shows countries with the highest number of
HIV/Aids-related deaths in Sub-Saharan Africa
6.2 Give any TWO reasons for the high number of HIV/Aids-related
deaths in Sub-Saharan Africa. (2 x 1) (2)
6.4 Discuss any TWO solutions that would reduce the number of
HIV/Aids-related deaths. (2 x 2) (4)
Although this system has worked in various countries in the world, in South Africa it
has proved to be very difficult to implement. This is because many owners do not
actually see the land they are purchasing and are not involved in the important
decisions made at the beginning of the purchase and negotiation.
The efficient introduction of land reform is important for the following reasons:
Various challenges are facing land reform in South Africa. The following are
amongst the challenges as identified by the Department of Rural Development and
Land Reform (2008):
Willing seller-willing buyer principle: it takes a long time to negotiate land price
with the current land owners
Claim disputes: it is a long process to mediate and resolve claim disputes
Beneficiary selection: it is a lengthy process and time consuming process to
select the rightful beneficiaries for land redistribution
Resettlement support: it requires enough resources and time to effectively
facilitate post-resettlement support to new land owners
Different political views: there is lack of common consensus among political
parties on land reform debate
Monitoring and evaluation: there is lack of reliable monitoring system and
evaluation thereof
Policy: there are gaps in the current policies which compromise effective
implementation of land reform programme
The land reform process has not been as successful as was being hoped for. The
following list provides reasons for it not always being successful:
Possible solutions to the challenges faced by land reform include the following:
7 FIGURE 18.16 shows data on land restitution in the various provinces in South
Africa.
7.2 Give the total number of land claims made to date. (1 x 1) (1)
7.3 Which province has allocated the largest amount of land for land
restitution thus far? (1 x 1) (1)
7.4 Comment on the total land cost in relation to the total amount
awarded for the land restitution process. (2 x 2) (4)
7.5 Give TWO reasons for your answer to QUESTION 7.4. (2 x 2) (4)
South Africa's land reform programme has suffered many failures, and its
beneficiaries have in many cases seen little or no improvements to their
livelihoods. Land reform remains an unresolved historical grievance.
There is a general agreement that land reform has been a failure and needs to be
sped up. Research shows that between 70% and 90% of the projects (including
land restitution projects) have failed. The government needs to reconsider its policy
of simply acquiring land for redistribution. It needs to take measures to make sure
that redistributed land is used productively.
If land reform is to continue in its current fashion, its prospects are doomed. It is
the government's duty to see to it that they create self-sufficient farmers through
the provision of post-settlement support.
Figure 18.18: Land reform
8.2 According to the article, why has the land reform programme failed?
(1 x 1) (1)
8.3 Mention TWO factors that explain why land reform in South Africa is
necessary. (4)
8.4 Discuss TWO reasons why land reform in South Africa has not been
a successful as anticipated. (2 x 2) (4)
8.5 Outline TWO methods that the government can put in place to
provide support to the people resettled on the land once land reform
has taken place. (4)
8.6 The slow rate at which land reform is progressing has resulted in
many people resorting to land grabs. In a paragraph of approximately
EIGHT lines, explain why taking action such as land grabs is not
conducive for the land reform process. (4 x 2) (8)
9 Study FIGURE 18.19, a cartoon showing a discussion between inhabitants of a rural
area and a developer.
9.2 Name the land reform policy which allows the government to buy
unoccupied land and share it equally amongst rural people.
(1 x 1) (1)
9.4 Why are the people of the area reluctant to help the developer
increase the productivity of the land? (1 x 2) (2)
9.5 Give ONE possible reason why the developer says that land is a key
to fight poverty. (1 x 2) (2)
OR
Classification of Settlements
[Link]
Rural-Urban Migration
[Link]
[Link]
[Link]
Social Injustices
Water and Sanitation
[Link]
[Link]
[Link]
HIV/Aids
[Link]
[Link]
Land Reform
[Link]
[Link]