-
Voti ng Systems Con tinue d Wor kshe et
Paul, :ind j.1 yc. Due ro c111hacb, only one w,11
l. 11,cre arc three account:tnts working in 311 omce: Noelle. 15
. The preference schedule hclow.
be given a r.1isc. T11e board of directors ranks rhe accountants
2 3
6
1st Choice N
-- --
p
"~
N
p
2nd Choice
3rd Choice
I'
N I N
d. Which accounr,rnt won u~mg
a. Determine the number of 111 d1oicc votes each account.1111 receive
plurality voting? Did they receive the majority~
N uE' ,rt: w (.)/\ I.I /' 1
p 1' 1
V lo
f l : 5
I
b. Determine the Condorcet winner.
------
(f
-r;;-
Determine the Borda count winner.
r F \S ~<
l
- - - rv ba r cl 0-. CDu f\f
\
vJ i (\ {\-C Y
o__ 0 D
0
Io--
-- j---t
0
() -=-JS
t,J +lo .I, (p -1- \: tit
+ d- ·} 0 - Lt \ t l I I '\ \ , ',, '> I I \ I 2b I
I
f 7MfMH:f
2
• A hirin g com 11 ,·
t I,c applicant
•tlcr tl1us rd,oo s•
•e one O ,e fiour npp I'ic,uit'l: 1>:irryl, Merv, Nellie,
s tft h . ftl
• , <'rt c lllt<'rvkws arc over. 11,c prcfcr<'ncc .ind Robw. 'J1,cy r.1nk
Rchcdule i~ below.
7
1st Choicl' 3
I)
M
'J l l
2nd Choice M
R N
R
1 3rd Choice
N
N M
1
±
I)
_4th Choice R I)
M
N
a. - - D R
D
-
Dete rmin e the Borda coun t winner.
, ,vr A)
~I ~~ °I )~
\2. /M
llf -~
g
lo ¼J-
l/ 7_
I 0 ,,..
--- - -- ::> I
I ~
► rr
fY' a 0 ID '
0
CJ
5 gu~~
b. How coul d the 3 comm ittee mem bers who
R. : 33 ~o r~
CC A.J f\t- ~J ~Y-
voted M, N, R, D insincerely vote so that some
the Bord a coun t winn er? Dete rmin e the new one else is
Borda coun t winner.
7 3 3 2
1st Choice D
2nd Choice R
M
N N
R /\A M
3rd Choice N D 0 D
4th Choice M N
R R
------- - /'J
p
"ti
- °I Ct
f2
~4 ~ Al\ CY] 1: ;a..
N
t
0
3 g 3 ID
Lj
---- - - -- ~
- -
M
0
AJ
(S f Q
I<
{)
J
o~ ~o/- 'f;. ;J o Dc __ rry / s
W} = ;;) ~ i~ f\--€v-..l ~ o-, c\~
~
N :J VJ C.. 0 v (\._ -T \ ./\ '<'-e 'V
262 ',j} l
Wi Wk rM
7 J ;J l
1st Choice 0 \.1 \t
.
2nd Choice
3rd Choice
R
N
R
IJ
"R \II
I)
4th Choice J__ M N IJ R
c. Detenninc the winner using Scqucntul P.1irwisc Voring with the .1gcndA D, M, R, N.
~
., _ __, ,,
f2V-> , ~
~
7- t
I
~
1
Yvl \, ' {2._
I'
{5) /Y]-; V') A) --
L
.--
-::i: ~
iz- 3
') I 5
,...,
- -
{~ ---
d. Create a new agenda that would make Merv the winner using Sequential Pairwise Voting. Go not
7
change the preference schedule. Demonstrate that Merv wins. If not possible, explain.
M-l'fV (Y\/i( llA-6) v J ,-1\S ,·/\.
()_jf/\dO.
, 263
3. An onlinc p01l asks its participants to rank the following 1990s boy hand~: New Kid~ on che Block (A).
13adcstrcct I3oys (B), NSYNC (C}, and Hanson (D). The preference schedule i, below.
14 10 4 1
8
1st Choice
2nd Choice
.J_
-
13
-
A
-
--
C
A
D
C
A
D + ~-j
3rd Choice -l
4th Choice
C
D
D
B
-
A
B
C
B --r A
B
~
_J
a. Dcccrminc the number of l51 choice votes each band received. Which ban d won usrng• Pluralirv
·, voe,
ing: Did they receive the majority~
B~ IL/ ~ Ct C 1-..) 'ft .. e - J1~
__,,....,c,,;(\ u
,.
r )
C ~
,. II r {(.Jr(?.. I• .. ./
J
\,) .:.i-- ~
D: g /J 0-f (v", r,1 /{ . ..)
fl ([_( - L/ 'lf/31~ :.>i'I ( _,I
b. D~•::• (Steer wincs, )~
- '0
~
IY
\D
I ---,0o I-I
LJ 1C
/V ~YJJC
CG ndurc~-'-
\ <-f \ vJ, f l ~
I \
'S
I , (., .,-,
-0 ~
l <.,,-""'
~
D
11
l, l
C
tD ,. I
{
AiJ;- }
0 6 0 B C)
loo 0
o,"- ~-\-\e VJl<icL
&,o(A ( a J/\1'"
·= iC trf;t:, :c ':WkSM *I
I
14 I
10
(
1st Choice I 13
2nd Choice
3rd Choice
L JI _
C
1/ /u
( I~
.J,(
4th Choice J_ J!:' B H B
J. Octem,ine the Instant Runoff winner.
B -7
) '2rtd-
--
/3-? J LJ
C-;>lO+ - I :: ll
C-> 1'
T) --:> 6 D 7'..-,
(J-
~~ y A '? cq-
i----
___,
C 1S
I <-I l0
6
<-f
e.
_ ---r-,_...--,-
· l.h~C . .~
D etermme t e oncmgent wmner.
---✓~
1~··
-,
4. a. On a scale of 1-10, with 1 being"I have no idea what just happened" and 10 being"! understand this
so well, I could teach it;' rate your understanding of this material.
b. Which problem was the easiest for you? Which problem was the most difficult for you? Why was it
difficulc/ 7le~ L,Uf f l tf. 11 (fc \J / :J: j-!Jf
~0-6' {1,( '1 Ol vol +,.A~, j 1 ,f l~°') the d;t'kv(lf(~
f r ~ l IAv\(lilJ1\1'-ill\
___ vv'-C.,, (.}(,,.__ l'-i 265
~ftµ et?fl i"5/-4. ft} lful\.u-C f + CCJf\..f iA..c)-€ n+-
