7

UNCLASSIFIEOIIFOR PUBLIC RELEASE

MILITARY COMMISSIONS TRIAl, .nrOl CIAIlV
G(;ANTANAMO BAY, CURA
UNITED ST:'\ 11:.<:; OF AMERICA
v.
KHAIJD SUAIKJl MOHAMMAO.
WALlO MUHAMMAD Si\I.!JI MUDARA K BIN

RAMZI BIN ALSH1 II H,
AMMAR AL BALtJCHI (AI.! ABOUL. AZlZ ALI),
MUSTAFA AHMJ::O ADAM AL IV\' WSAWI
AE 152
StipuJatktn Te$timc:my
of U.CoI . ..-u.S. Army
21 June 201]
It is hereby by aDd between the Pro!lt.:-cuti(m and the Defense for RAMZI BIN AT. SHIBH, with
the uxpn.-ss ... lhat, ifUemewmt C<l lonel _ v,:ere (:.l)lc: d to t.e.$tify in this milimry
n..:g!ITding ;.!IlIUC$ rai$Od by the IJckn.o;e in AEl:52 md AEI08B(Supp), be 'WOUld sub.tantially Wi
fulloW6:
I. Por tho past nine moalhs. J have been as5igned to Joint Task. Force Guan.t.lnamo Bay (JTF GTMO) liS lhe
Iypic-lily vimt the Camp f:\Iety
day and spend QOywbcre from 15-20 minutea to 7-8 hours during oolh dayltgtu 6Jld oJ&bltime hours. My last day a6
a member of .TTF CITMO was 20 June 2013 .
2. 1 rccei\'oo II .BacheluI' of degn:e in Zoology &om Ar; lQfl3 State Uni\'tHlty. MalJtt..'T ofSc:knce in
Uenll.b. Can: Allministntrioo fh:rrn Mnmes a Master of Public Heal th. degl'C Itom JOM'" R<lpk;lns.,
wid a Doctor ofOstcopalhy tlcgrec from Moine!! Universky. 1 performed II dU!tt in prcventi,,'c
medicine and general pyychia l:ry. I completed a fcllQWKblp 1D cblld and adolescent psyclilinry. ram Doocd Certlfied
] . r <m1 familiN with 'Ramzi bin a1 SIlibh. He mypatlwl fur the PIlJI: nine moolhll while I 'WRlI.!CeTVing al ffi'
GTMQ, During lhat I had lTcquent opportunitie9 co obmve and interact with RArnzi bin al Sbibh. _
observed him dW'ing February 20 LJ 9-11
mntloo hc!ar.ings. Within tb-.:: plllrt ...... eeks, I began meetin, with RlmtZl bin al Shlbh roc p,ycili ltric
\PPELLA TE EXHIBIT /gJ::'c,!-'6'::.)
'AGE I OF"
UNCLASSIFIEDIIFOR PUBLIC RELEASE -
1
UNCLASSIFIEOIIFOR PUBLIC RELEASE
4. I ba\'c (.:umfull ), n.: .... c:""'OO Karon biD al Shibb'.!I pS)cl.tiatric
1llls diagnosis III L1Iconsistect with my cf Wld
"'ith lt3m.ri bio at Shibb,
S. In mYllrofc:.;sionnl optnion. Rllmzi bin III Shibb doc!i not sufrtt &om any psychotic disorder. As 01 R,amzi
bin at 81lihh not su1fi:r ftom dchmooaI disorder" {I" p.vanoid lIChizophrtnia (bolh of which arc psychotic
disorders). It i5 also highJyunlikely tbat Ranm binal Sbibtl wtItrs from cl05Cd-6)'6tem ps)'(:botic

6. Seversl about If.3lTll.i trin .,11 Shibh 'lj: behavior lICe dire<:lly contradiclory to 8 findint:; of a ps.ychotic disorder.
SpecifiClllly, be demonsU'a1e!l Wgb executive functioning, whicb LS mCOllsistetlf with di t!OIlicr. He ba"a
aood seD.5e of bum or: he cleilJ'"IY\looerst;lIlds abmactconcepu: he well ; he 3btC to maintain his
OOIlceotutlon during 100glhy court IIIId he dOCN not .!lpPew" to be threatened byanyooe. His thought
process linear, logic.a l and ratiooll!. fuch ofthe!1C traif.!l with a diagnolll.!l of VltycbnLic dillordcr.
7, Delullioa IS a '\./try specltic type ofpsycb(l(ic disorder. Since,. in my opinion, Ramn biD al Sbibb is not pSJ-'ChoOc.
K. A patient in R.amzi bloal Shibh' g cOOdilion ctlJlOOI ac.curtltcly be for Odu:'iiooal Oisordcr-Pcrscocutory
Type. Fetlini:s ofpersecutiOll arc cw:iiSlrnI with hdng dctaiDCd ill an enemy conbalanl and being pro:secukd for
9. 1 have prepared cntrie,o; in Ram7.1 bin al SIDbh'& psychiatric leuord c1wugmg hi!! In my
opnloo., II p:-I)'I.'hiutrisc. would need significant IldditiunllJ inIDlT!I!!.tmn before being abJe to accurately Ramzi
bin ill Shlbh for Ilny psychilltric or personality disiJJ"denl,
10. 01lL"ll, WhOl a patient.b!l8 been dI\'lgJlostd wi-th delusiOIlw disorder and placed on antipsyclmtic ml:dil;:"Iicn, this
diagoosili will carry OVf:J' I'nxn me treating psychiatrist to anotbc:r. It is easy to dimliSll cllliml\ of hearing or feeling
things.all "ddu:.i01loJ." Once thi.! h:u beeo aPPlied people Wl1l tend til di.!ltlliIS81lU}miog!he patient reports
hearing or ti1. .. illg. i am aVtve thai Kam.ri bin al Shibh has been fhl stratcd that his COdlplaintl! of noise and
\-ibr:a. tlOflshuvo hoen wrlucn off as delusiCIl". &."\l1lzi bin al Slubh rOUlltlcly deeps during da}1ight
bolln!;. lie mil)' be expO!fl..'d 10 louder Wld that occur in lhe camp. AddItionally, iI my
oplnion, Ram.zi bin 41 Sttihh maybe u\'trreacting to sound lrtl llluhlS due to p1!'1.CJlpericnccs.
'>P5LLATEEXHJBrr/SOl,Q
',_GE ;l. OF
UNCLASSIFIEDIIFOR PUBLIC RELEASE
2
UNCLASSIFIEDIIFOR PUBLIC RELEASE
Il. ] haVl: IICCI\. no c:vu1cru.:c nr 5OWld& and vibraooasoC .... tud:t Raw]
bin 0l.I Shibb a)mpltunt. The: &cllil)' Lt ClJDSlnJcttd 0( concrete and Sled. Noises and vibralioo.s t.md to I"C\"C!Jbettlt
Ihrough the faeillty. I c:::IMOI tulc: OUI the poS1!-ibillly of. '"bid gu.uu creating noises b.:caw;c I am DOl. there all
carefi.IJ. 00110 -" Klare 00I$tS ItOUnd lta.m..I.i bua af Shihll."s .. ....u. Myobilm'ltlioo is !hal the g\llnb I irl.lcract wiih

lI. ff
IAMFS r . HARllINOTON
l.ctmIL-d Coun'-'Cl wr Mr Binilishil;il
CI.A Y TIUVETT
TriaJ Countel
KEVIN DOGUCIU. LCDR, USN
1lcrcD!lc Coun.!icl fur- Mr. Binalshibh
3
,
UNCLASSIFIEDIIFOR PUBLIC RELEASE