Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The rise and fall of F.A. Heinzd had been nothing less than spectacular.
Only 18 months earlier, the.onetime owner of a Montana copper mine had
ridden into New York with $25 millio~a in cash and stocks garnered in an
out-of-court legal settlement with a rival mining company. He soon
attracted notice by aggressively purchasing interests iu several New York
banks and engaging in speculative activities.
As is so often the case when things are going well, Heinze seemed incapable
of making a bad business deal. His downfall took everyone by surprise.
The financial empire ofF. Augustus Heinze began to unravel ill October
1907 when he overreached himself in an effort to corner the stock of
United Copper Company. (An investor who tries to "corner the market"
on a com~nodity or a stock is attempting to gain control in order to fix the
price.) In less than 24 hours, he dropped $50 million, and the financial
markets went hay~;cire. According to an article in the October 18, 1907
edition of the Boston Post:
But the trouble wasn’t over yet. As part of the trust company bail-
Just as things seemed to be improv7 out, Morgan also won acceptance
ing for banks and the stock market, of a plan to rescue Moore & Schley;
New York City’s finances took a plan that advanced his own inter-
a turn for the worse. Skittish ests as well by enabling his bank to
European investors were reluctant orchestrate U.S. Steel’s acquisition
to buy the city’s bonds, so the mayor of a competing company. (U.S. Steel
called upon Morgan for help, had very close ties to Morgan’s bank.)
which he agreed to provide after
"extracting a number of protective By mid-November, the panic had
measures, including a bankers’ subsided. But there was to be one
committee to oversee the city’s last casualty. On the afternoon of
aec0unting practices~ Thursday, November 13, Charles
T. Barney, former president of the
As the crisis wound down, there failed Knickerbocker Trust Com-
"were a few issues that needed to pany, died at his home on East 38th
be addressed. Trhst companies, Streetfrom a self-inflicted gunshot.
including Trust Company of Reportedly, he was despondent
America, required further assistance, over J.P. Morgan’s refusal to meet
and several brokerage houses still with him.
faced an uncertain iCuture, most
notably the firm of Moore & Schley, But Morgan and otherswere beii~g
which was $25 .million in debt. showered with accolades for their
Once again, Morgan devised a .handling of the situation. The New
York Clearing House passed a Yet even amidst the continuing.
resolution th3nking Morgan "for praise there were indications that
the promptness with which he had the prominent bankers and great
coxne to the aid of the situation." financiers had reached the pinnacle
President Theodore P,,oosevelt of their power and influence. The
commended TreasmT Secretary’ calls for major changes in the finan-
Cortelyou "upon, the adnxirable way cial system were growing louder
in which you have handled the and stronger.
present crisls." And although he didn’t
naention Morgan by n,’u-ne, l~oosevelt Senator Nelson Aldrich of I~hode
,also congratulated "those conserva- Island sunamed up the general feel-
rive and substantial business men in ing. "Something has got to be
this crisis who have acted with such done," he declared; "We maynot
wisdom and public spirit." Lord always have Pierpont Morgan with
l~othschild, of the renowned Euro- us to meet a banking crisis."
pean banking fanxily, praised Morgan
as "worthy of his reputation as a great And- eventually something -was
financier and a man of wonderful done. In 1910,’Senator Aldrich
resources. His latest action fills one introduced legislation for a U.S.
with adn-firation and respect for him." central bank. His bill failed to gain
passage, but several of its provisions
A New Yorker by the name of were ultimately incorporated in
McLandburgh Wilson went so far as the Federal P,_eset~ce Act (1913).
to compose an ode to Morgan, which Increased government oversight
the Times ran in its Sunday edition o£ the financial system was in the
on October 27: offing.
A milliot~aire is wicked, quite;
His doom should quick be knelled; On December 23, 1913, just over
He should not b~ allowed to £row, sLx years after the Panic of 190,7,
If 2rown he shoMd be felled, President Woodrow Wilson sigmed
But u,he, a citj/s bondLfall flat, the Federallq.eserveAct. It provided
And no one cares for them, for "the establishment of federal
l/Vho is the man who saues tl;e day? reserve banks, to furnish an elastic
It’s.].P.~VL currency, to afford means of
rediscounting co~mnercial paper, to
l/Vhett ballks a~ld trust’s go,ct’aslli~1g down establish a more effective supetwi-
From credit’s sldlied ~lame, sion of banking in the. United States,
While Sp~echifi, blg Greatness adds and for other purposes."
k4ore fiM to the flame,
HyT, wn Titan Stre~Nth is ~leeded sore j.P. Morgan, who during Fhe Panic
Black ruin’s tide to stem, of 1907, had performed many of
Who is the man who does the job? the functions of a central bank, died
It’s d.P.]14. in 1Lome on.March 31, 1913.
PART II
WEDNESDAY F RI DAY
OCTOBER 16: OCTOBER 18:
United Copper closes at $15 d share Nine banks form an emergency
after bank owner/speculator F.A. pool of funds to aid Mercantile
Heinze fails in his attempt to corner National. But depositors at
the company’s shares. Knickerbocker Trust Company
begin to withdraw their money.
THURSDAY ;Fhey are concerned because
OCTOBER 17: I~ickerbocker’s president, Charles
Shortly after midnight, Heinze T. Barney, is an associate of F.A.
resigns as president of Mercantile Heinze.
National Bank. Later that morning,
prompted by the fear that Heinze’s SATURDAY
stock market losses might affect the OCTOBER 19:
bank, Mercantile National’s deposi- Charles W. Morse, a banker and
tors scramble to withdraw their ~peculator who was involved with
money. Heinze in the disastrous copper
corner, announces he will resign
During the day, Heinze’s Butte official positions at nine banks and
(montana) Savings Bank fails as trust companies.
does the brokerage firm of Otto
Hein~e &: Co., which is owned by MONDAY
the brother of F.A. Heinze. OCTOBER 21:
Charles T. Barney resigns as
That night, the New York Clear- president of Knickerbocker Trust
ing House- Conat~ittee declares Company. Depositors withdraw
that Mercantile National is "per- $8 n~llion in less than four hours
fectly solvent and able to meet all before Knickerbocker suspends
its indebtedness." The Committee’s operations.
TUESDAY The crisis takes its toll onJ.P. Mor-
OCTOBER 22: gan. Under the headline "J.P. Morr-
J.p. Morgan refuses to aid gan Has a Cold," the New York
Knickerbocker Trust, wtiich does Times reports, "J. Pierpont Morgan
not reopen for business. has a slight Cold resulting from ex-
posure to the night air. In the last
A headline in the Neap York ~imes week Mr. Morgan has .attended
announces that Morgan Ocill many night conferences dealing
organize support for Trust Com- with the banking situation.-’ In
pany of America, which is deemed doing so he was obliged on several
to be in much better condition than occasions to ride about in his cab
Ka~ickerbocker. late at night, and in sonde instances
in the early morning. The result
WEDNESDAY was that he contracted a cold which
OCTOBER23: gave him some tr6uble yesterday.
Treasury Secretary George When he left his office late yester-
Cortelyou travels to New York to day afternoon he wore a handker-
meet with Morgan and other fin- chief about his neck."
anciers.
SUNDAY
THURSDAY OCTOBER 27:
OCTOBER 24: At the behest of J.P. Morgan,
At 1 a.m., Cortelyou ann{~unces New York City’s clergy preach ser-
that the U.S. Treasury will deposit mons urging "calmness and Confi-
$25 million in several New York dence."
City banks.
WE~)NESDAY
Later in the day, oil tycoon John D. OCTOBER 30:
Rockefeller commits $10 million In response to a plea from New
of his own money to stabilizing York’s Mayor, a Morgan-lffd syn-
the financial siguation. dicate bails out the city by agreeing
to place $30 million worth of its
FRIDAY " revenue bonds with investors.
OCTOBER25:
Under heavy pressure, fi-om J.P. Tl{e night before, Morgan had
Morgan, New York bankers con- pressured trust conlpany presidents
tribute to a $25 million rescue pool into putting up funds to support
for.cash-strapped stockbrokers, who the still ailing Trust Company of
have been unable to borrow and America and Lincoln Trust-Com-
are "facing ruin. pany. Morgan and his associates
also devise a plan to save the bro-
SATURDAY kerage firm of Moore & Schley
OCTOBER 26: from failure.
PART IiI
What follows is a ".parallel history" that offers a glimpse into the evewday
triumphs, tragedies, follies, and fraffties of ordinary people as reported by
-the New Yorle Times and the Bosto, Post during the last two weeks of
October 1907.
BEATEN CLOSE TO
CHILD STOLEN FROM HIS HOME
CONVENT Four n~en left Frank G~ll of 441
From the midst of her playmates West Seventeenth Street uncon-
in the yard of St. Joseph’s Convent scious on the sidewalk 1,~st night at
at McSherwsto~w~., Penn., Evelyn about 8 o’clock after brutally beat-
O’Draiu, 8 years old, of Philadel- ing him because he refused to give
phia, was carried otTthis afternoon theln a 1hatch when they accosted
hina at the corner of Seventeenth CRUELTY TO HORSES
Street and Niuth Avenue. The~ During nay travels in this country
also robbed him of his gold watch for the past seven weeks .I have
and about $5 in ~ash. spent a great deal of my time in the
Western states, and no~v on n~y
Neu~ York Times departure to England I wish to say
Monday, October 14, 1907 that I have never seen such cruelty
to horses as I have seen in New
York City during the past x~ceek.
FINED FOR SON’S DEATH The manuer of beating the poor
Edwin M. Watson and wife, the beasts mid the heavy loads, which
moodstown Christiau Scientists they are compelled to haul is some-
recently convicted of manslaughter thing disgraceful. I have been told
for ,allowing their seven-year-old son, at my hotel that you have a humane
Granville, to die without medical ¯ society. If you have, I think it i~ a
attendance, were sentenced here disga’ace to civilization.
to-day to pay a fine of $100 each.
An English Tourist
Front Page Story To the Editor of the
New York Times New York Times
Thursday, October 24, 1907 Sunday, October 27, 1907
"Lessons From the Panic of 1907," Ellis W. Tallman, Jon Moen, Ecol~omic
Re,dew, Federal P-.esetwe Bank of Atlanta, May 1990.
PUBLICATIONS
FEDERAL RESERVE BANK OF BOSTON
P.O. BOX 2076
BOSTON ¯ MASSACHUSETTS 02106-2076
(617) 973-3489