CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS TOPICS TOPICS TOPICS TOPICS PAGE NO. PAGE NO. PAGE NO. PAGE NO. PREFACE 3 INTRODUCTION 4 TATKAL SYSTEM 4 TABLES Train No. From To Train Name 12657 MAS SBC BANGALORE MAIL 5 12658 SBC MAS CHENNAI MAIL 6 12673 MAS CBE CHERAN EXPRESS 7 12674 CBE MAS CHERAN EXPRESS (Return) 8 16669 MAS ED YERCAUD EXPRESS 9 16670 ED MAS YERCAUD EXPRESS (Return) 10 16177 MS KMU ROCKFORT EXPRESS 11 16178 KMU MS ROCKFORT EXP. (Return) 12 12637 MS MDU PANDIAN EXPRESS 13 12638 MDU MS PANDIAN EXPRESS (Return) 14 16222 MAS MYS KAVERI EXPRESS 15 16221 MYS MAS KAVERI EXPRESS (Return) 16 12671 MAS MTP NILGIRI EXPRESS 17 12672 MTP MAS NILGIRI EXPRESS (Return) 18 12631 MS TEN NELLAI EXPRESS 19 12632 TEN MS NELLAI EXPRESS (Return) 20 12633 MS CAPE KANYAKUMARI EXPRESS 21 12634 CAPE MS KANYAKUMARI EXP. (Ret) 22 16723 MS TVC ANANTHAPURI EXPRESS 23 16041 MAS ALLP ALLEPPEY EXPRESS 25 16042 ALLP MAS ALLEPPEY EXPRESS (Return) 26 16724 TVC MS ANANTHAPURI EXP. (Ret) 27 16627 MAS MAQ WEST COAST EXPRESS 28 16628 MAQ MAS WEST COAST EXP. (Return) 30 12695 MAS TVC TRIVANDRUM EXPRESS 32 12696 TVC MAS TRIVANDRUM EXP. (Return) 33 OUTCOME OF ANALYSIS 34 SINGLE FARE SECTOR 34 TWO FARE SECTOR 35 THREE FARE SECTOR 35 FOUR FARE SECTOR 36 ADDITIONAL FARE SECTOR 36 SUMMARY OF ANALYSIS 37 INFERENCE 39 SUGGESTIONS MAIN 39 ADVANCE RESERVATION PERIOD AND TATKAL QUOTA 39 ADDITIONAL GENERAL SUGGESTIONS 40 CONCLUSION 41
3
TRAIN BASED RESTRUCTURING OF PASSENGER FARES TRAIN BASED RESTRUCTURING OF PASSENGER FARES TRAIN BASED RESTRUCTURING OF PASSENGER FARES TRAIN BASED RESTRUCTURING OF PASSENGER FARES PREFACE: PREFACE: PREFACE: PREFACE: The telescopic and distance slab basis passenger fare structure is followed by the railways for a long time without adopting any major changes except for some minor adjustment in distance slabs, reservation restriction upto minimum distances for some selected trains etc. Designating trains as super-fast, etc. is another option available for making additional income out of passenger services. Invariably the basic fare manipulation attracts dissent and become sensitive for the railways to implement revision of passenger fare as such, except for the introduction of tatkal scheme. This situation warrants and necessitates identification of alternate methods of manipulation for augmenting income out of passenger trains.
Of late the passengers travel pattern is registering a paradigm shift as there is a specific preference of trains for journeys between specific pair of points. The impact of this change of preferences is reflected in the booking patterns of the trains in various sectors. The presumable reasons for this paradigm shift are, the perpetual addition of direct trains to more and more destinations, the increase in frequency of train services i.e., multiple trains operating in individual sectors, the value added services like Rajdhani, Shatabdi, Duranto, etc,. Thus passengers are presented with multiple options to select the train for the respective journeys according to their requirements. This changing dynamics of passengers preferences opens new avenues for augmenting revenue, as this change has inherently generated an option for the railways to review and change the existing fare fixing system based on distance slabs and telescopic concept into train based fare fixing concept. i.e., to fix individual train specific fares, for various pair of points covered by the respective trains. Since this methodology has not been explored by the railways so far, an effort is made in this direction. Further the concept of tatkal scheme also needs a review for effective utilization so as to improve earnings out of this scheme.
4
INTRODUCTION: INTRODUCTION: INTRODUCTION: INTRODUCTION: This exercise is about evolving alternate methodology to meet the need for rationalizing the railway passenger fare structure commensurate with the contemporary requirements and finding out options available for enhancing the railway revenues within the ambit of the existing fare limits. This study is in continuation to the earlier proposal of restructuring of passenger fare related to the Thiruvananthapuram Mail. Since the concept of paradigm shift of passengers preference is the basis for the presumption that there is sufficient scope for introduction of alternate method of passenger fare restructuring, its essential that, the changing pattern of patronage of the passengers, is understood and explained properly. Accordingly 13 pairs of night trains were selected, and the occupancy and de boarding information of entire length of the journey of the respective trains for the whole month of May 2012 were analyzed. These trains are in three distance groups i.e., trains running Upto 400 Kms., 400 to 600 Kms., and beyond 600 Kms. The train wise patronage is tabulated class wise, with the findings and recommendations thereof.
TATKAL SYSTEM: TATKAL SYSTEM: TATKAL SYSTEM: TATKAL SYSTEM: The TATKAL system at present allows the issue of reservation tickets only in the previous day of the journey, while most of the trains reservation of berths and seats are completed well in advance as the 120 days period is very long. The waiting list starts much before, and further selling of berths through the tatkal ticket are postponed till the last day before the journey. This also needed review.
5
Station-wise and Class-wise List of Passengers and Demand Flow Report For Train No.12657 - MAS - SBC MAIL From Date: 1-5-2012 To Date:31-5-2012 1A 2A 3A SL Station Code Board DE board % DE board Board DE board % DE board Board DE board % DE board Board DE board % DE board Total Board % Total Board Total DE board % Total DE board MAS MAS MAS MAS 571 0 0 3028 0 0 6281 0 0 31344 0 0 41224 99 0 0 AJJ 0 1 0 13 1 0 10 0 0 147 1 0 170 0 3 0 KPD 1 0 0 1 4 0 2 34 1 98 24 0 102 0 62 0 JTJ 1 0 0 1 6 0 0 7 0 19 14 0 21 0 27 0 BWT 0 0 0 2 3 0 0 16 0 0 196 1 2 0 215 1 BNCE 0 1 0 0 8 0 0 8 0 0 108 0 0 0 125 0 BNC 0 32 6 0 53 2 0 156 2 0 1118 4 0 0 1359 3 SBC SBC SBC SBC 0 539 94 0 2970 98 0 6072 96 0 30147 95 0 0 39728 96 Total 573 573 100 3045 3045 100 6293 6293 100 31608 31608 100 41519 100 41519 100
1. The patronage of passengers for Train No.12657 Chennai Bangalore Mail is only for Bangalore area i.e., 99%.
2. There is only 1% of patronage for Bangarpet (BWT) which is very negligible.
3. Hence, the entire journey distance fits in a single Sector distance for fare structure.
4. The fare differences for the intermediate stations will not affect the passengers and, therefore the fare structure of a single Sector will have to be applied for this train. i.e. this trains journey will cost an uniform single fare to all passengers travelling by this train, irrespective of the pair of points the journey is performed.
6
Station-wise and Class-wise List of Passengers and Demand Flow Report For Train No.12658 - SBC - MAS MAIL. From Date: 1-5-2012 To Date:31-5-2012 1A 2A 3A SL Station Code Board DE board Net Board DE board Net Board DE board Net Board DE board Net Total Board % Total Board Total DE board % Total DE board SBC SBC SBC SBC 543 0 0 2890 0 0 5879 0 0 29226 0 0 38538 94 0 0 BNC BNC BNC BNC 34 0 0 91 0 0 228 0 0 1325 0 0 1678 4 0 0 BWT 2 0 0 12 0 0 33 2 0 350 0 0 397 1 2 0 JTJ 0 0 0 5 4 0 26 0 0 15 25 0 46 0 29 0 KPD 0 2 0 6 7 0 28 25 0 60 288 1 94 0 322 1 AJJ 0 0 0 13 4 0 26 7 0 8 212 1 47 0 223 1 MAS MAS MAS MAS 0 577 100 0 3002 100 0 6186 99 0 30459 98 0 0 40224 99 TOTAL 579 579 100 3017 3017 100 6220 6220 100 30984 30984 100 40800 100 40800 100
1. The patronage of passengers for Train No.12658 Bangalore - Chennai Mail is only from Bangalore (SBC) i.e., 98% to Chennai (MAS) i.e., 99%.
2. There is only 1% of patronage for boarding from Bangarpet (BWT) and 1% each for KPD & AJJ for de-boarding which are very negligible.
3. The fare differences for the intermediate stations will not affect the passengers and, therefore the fare structure of a single Sector will have to be applied for this train. i.e. this trains journey will cost an uniform single fare to all passengers travelling by this train, irrespective of the pair of points the journey is performed.
1. The patronage of passengers for Train No.12673 Chennai Coimbatore Cheran Express is mainly for Coimbatore i.e., 85% and 10% for Tiruppur. However, the distance between TUP and CBE is only 50 Kms. and the fare difference will be only ` 15 for SL, ` 42 for 3A, ` 65 for 2A and ` 115 for 1A. Hence these two stations can be merged for the purpose of travel fare in to a single Sector.
2. There is only 4% & 1% of patronage for Erode and Salem respectively. Hardly any higher class passengers use it daily. The distance between ED and CBE is 100 Kms. As Tiruppur and Coimbatore have been merged into one Sector the difference in fare between MAS to ED and MAS to TUP will be only ` 16 for SL, `42 for 3A, ` 66 for 2A and ` 115 for 1A which is very minimum.
3. Hence, for the entire journey distance, charging of fare can be done for only one Sector i.e., MAS to CBE for all the passengers booking from and between MAS to CBE.
1. The patronage of passengers for Train No.12674 Coimbatore Chennai - Cheran Express is mainly from Coimbatore i.e., 89% and 8% for Tiruppur. However, the distance between TUP and CBE is only 50 Kms. and the fare difference will be only ` 15 for SL, ` 42 for 3A, ` 65 for 2A and ` 115 for 1A.
2. There is only 1% of boarding patronage from ED, SA and KPD and 2% patronage each for KPD and AJJ for de-boarding which are also very negligible.
3. Hence, the entire journey distance fits in one fare sector and the charging of fare can be done for one sector i.e., MAS to CBE for all the passengers booking from and between MAS to CBE.
1. The patronage of passengers for Train No.16669 Chennai Erode Yercaud Express is mainly for Salem (25%) and Erode (67%). There is only 2% of patronage for Morappur and 1% for Bommidi which are very negligible. 2. Since more than 25% patronage is recorded for the sections before and up to Salem, it will not be appropriate to merge the total distance in one sector. 3. The entire section needs be divided in to two sectors for fare fixing purpose for this train. i.e., a. Chennai (MAS) to Salem (SA) for all the passengers booking from and between MAS to SA,(the patronage up to Salem is negligible) and b. Chennai (MAS) to Erode (ED) for all passengers booking from and between MAS to SGE or ED. 4. Thus this train will have two unit charges as sector fare for various classes for the reserved night travel. 5. If the section between SA and ED attracts passengers for end portion travel, as residual travel, special discounted fare concept to be adopted.
1. The patronage of passengers for Train No.16670 Erode Chennai - Yercaud Express is mainly from Erode (65%) and Salem (26%). There is 4% of patronage from Sankaridurg (SGE), 1% from Bommidi (BQI) and 2% from Morappur (MAP) which are very negligible.
2. Hence, the entire section is to be divided into two, the same way done for the other pair train ie. T.no.16669.
3. The two sectors are ED to MAS, which will include SGE, SA to MAS, for all the passengers booking from and between SA and MAS.
1. The patronage of passengers for Train No.16177 Chennai Trichy Kumbakonam Rockfort Express is mainly for THREE pairs of points. (1) MS TO TPJ (Trichy) 60%, (2) MS TO TJ (Thanjavur) 16% and (3) MS TO KMU (Kumbakonam) 11%. 2. This train constitutes two individual trains, one portion RUNS up to Trichy(TPJ) and the SECOND portion runs separately and continuously to KUMBAKONAM( KMU). 3. There is 16% of patronage for Thanjavur and the distance between Thanjavur and Kumbakonam is only 40 Kms. and the fare difference will be only ` 13 for SL, ` 33 for 3A, ` 43 for FC, ` 53 for 2A and ` 92 for 1A. i.e., the difference of fare for these two destinations are meager and negligible. These two sectors need to be merged in to one sector for fare fixing for this train, i.e,. MS TO KMU, for the journey beyond TPJ. 4. MS to TPJ section wholly serves to TPJ ONLY, THE Visibility of SRGM is part of TPJ only, hence the entire section of MS &TPJ shall be treated as single fare sector for this train. 5. Accordingly this train will have two fare sectors i.e., a. Chennai (MS) to Trichy (TPJ) for all the passengers booking from and between MS to TPJ and b. Chennai (MS) to Kumbakonam (KMU) for all passengers booking from and between MS to KMU for bookings beyond TPJ.
1. The patronage of passengers for Train No.16178 Kumbakonam Trichy Chennai - Rockfort Express is mainly from THREE pairs of points i.e., Kumbakonam (13%), Thanjavur (18%), and Trichy (53%). Even though there is 18% of patronage from Thanjavur the distance between Kumbakonam and Thanjavur is only 40 Kms. and the fare difference will be only ` 13 for SL, ` 33 for 3A, ` 43 for FC, ` 53 for 2A and ` 92 for 1A.
2. Hence, the entire section is to be divided into two, the same way done for the other pair train ie. T.no.16177. The two sectors are a. Kumbakonam (KMU) to Chennai (MS) for all the passengers booking from and between KMU to TPJ & b. Trichy (TPJ) to Chennai (MS) for all passengers booking from and between TPJ to MS for bookings beyond TPJ.
1. The patronage of passengers for Train No. 12637 Chennai Madurai Pandian Express is mainly for Dindigul (DG) (17%), Kodaikanal Road (KQN) (7%) and Madurai (MDU) (72%). Even though there is patronage for KQN the distance between KQN and MDU is only 40 Kms. and due to this the difference in fare would be very meager and negligible. Hence, these two sectors need to be merged in to one sector for fare fixing for this train, i.e., MS TO MDU, for the journey beyond DG. 2. There is 2% patronage of passengers for Trichy (TPJ) and the distance between TPJ and DG is 95 Kms. The difference in fare from MS to TPJ and MS to DG will be only ` 30 for SL, ` 84 for 3A, ` 109 for FC, ` 131 for 2A and ` 230 for 1A which is very minimum.
3. Hence, the entire journey distance fits in two fare sectors and the charging of fare can be done for two sectors i.e., a. Chennai (MS) to Dindugal (DG) for all the passengers booking from and between MS to DG & b. Chennai (MS) to Madurai (MDU) for all passengers booking from and between MS to MDU for bookings beyond DG to MDU.
14
Station-wise and Class-wise List of Passengers and Demand Flow Report For Train No.12638 - MDU - MS - Pandian Express From Date: 1-5-2012 To Date:31-5-2012 1A 2A 3A FC SL Statio n Code Boar d De boar d % de boar d Board De board % de boar d Board De board % de boar d Boar d De boar d % de boar d Board De board % de boar d Total Board % Total Boar d Total Deboar d % Total deboar d MDU 603 0 0 170 8 0 0 608 9 0 0 680 0 0 2181 4 0 0 3089 4 72 0 0 KQN 103 0 0 180 0 0 695 0 0 24 0 0 1332 0 0 2334 5 0 0 ABI 0 0 0 6 0 0 62 0 0 14 0 0 428 0 0 510 1 0 0 DG 103 0 0 209 0 0 120 5 0 0 124 0 0 5846 0 0 7487 17 0 0 MPA 4 0 0 5 4 0 37 1 0 11 6 1 302 10 0 359 1 21 0 TPJ 41 2 0 135 15 1 352 36 0 50 4 0 834 81 0 1412 3 138 0 VRI 0 2 0 0 0 0 4 8 0 0 1 0 29 57 0 33 0 68 0 VM 0 0 0 0 8 0 3 7 0 0 0 0 3 128 0 6 0 143 0 CGL 0 0 0 0 5 0 2 29 0 0 1 0 0 311 1 2 0 346 1 TBM 0 15 2 0 30 1 0 262 3 0 38 4 0 1651 5 0 0 1996 5 MBM 0 0 0 0 6 0 0 48 1 0 2 0 0 93 0 0 0 149 0 MS 0 835 98 0 217 5 97 0 805 8 95 0 851 94 0 2825 7 92 0 0 40176 93 Total 854 854 100 224 3 224 3 100 844 9 844 9 100 903 903 100 3058 8 3058 8 100 4303 7 100 43037 100
1. The patronage of passengers for Train No. 12638 Madurai Chennai Pandian Express is mainly from Madurai (MDU) (72%), Kodaikanal Road (KQN) (5%) and Dindigul (DG) (17%). Even though there is patronage from KQN the distance between KQN and MDU is only 40 Kms. and due to this the difference in fare would be very meager and negligible. Hence, these two sectors need to be merged in to one sector for fare fixing for this train, i.e., MDU to MS.
2. There is 3% patronage of passengers from Trichy (TPJ) and the distance between DG and TPJ is 95 Kms. The difference in fare from DG to MS and TPJ to MS will be only ` 30 for SL, ` 84 for 3A, ` 109 for FC, ` 131 for 2A and ` 230 for 1A which is very minimum.
3. Hence, the entire section is to be divided into two, the same way done for the other pair train ie. T.no.12637. The two sectors are a. Madurai (MDU) to Chennai (MS) for all the passengers booking from and between MDU to DG & b. DG to MS for all the passengers booking from and between MDU and MS for bookings beyond DG.
1. The patronage of passengers for Train No. 16222 Chennai Bangalore Mysore - Kaveri Express is mainly for Bangalore (49%), and Mysore (41%). Even though there is 4% patronage of passengers from KPD the distance between MAS & KPD is 130 Kms. 2. The difference in fare from MAS SBC and KPD SBC would be ` 41 for SL, ` 115 for 3A and ` 93 for 2A and the difference in fare from MAS MYS and KPD MYS would be ` 39 for SL, ` 109 for 3A and ` 170 for 2A which are very minimal. 3. Hence, the entire journey distance fits in two fare sectors and the charging of fare can be done for two sectors i.e., a. Chennai (MAS) to Bangalore (SBC) for all the passengers booking from and between MAS to SBC & b. Chennai (MAS) to Mysore (MYS) for all passengers booking from and between MAS to MYS for bookings beyond SBC. 4. Here for the residual travel between SBC to MYS, the special fare concept is to be adopted as more than 50% of the berths are vacant from SBC.
1. The patronage of passengers for Train No. 16221 Mysore Bangalore Chennai - Kaveri Express is mainly from Mysore (38%) and Bangalore (52%) and the major de-boarding of 94% is in Chennai area (upto AJJ). Even though there is 3% patronage of passengers for KPD the distance between KPD & MAS is 130 Kms. The difference in fare from SBC KPD and SBC MAS would be ` 41 for SL, ` 115 for 3A and ` 93 for 2A and the difference in fare from MYS KPD and MYS MAS would be ` 39 for SL, ` 109 for 3A and ` 170 for 2A which are very minimal. 2. There is 3% boarding from KGI which is only 13 Kms. from SBC. Hence KGI & SBC can be merged into one Sector. The KGI passengers can pay the fare from SBC but allowed to board from KGI. 3. Hence, the entire journey distance fits in two fare sectors and the charging of fare can be done for two sectors, i.e., a. Mysore (MYS) to Chennai (MAS) for all the passengers booking from and between MYS to SBC and b. Bangalore (SBC) to Chennai (MAS) for all passengers booking from and between SBC to MAS. 17
Station-wise and Class-wise List of Passengers and Demand Flow Report For Train No.12671 - MAS - CBE - MTP - Nilagiri Express From Date: 1-5-2012 To Date:31-5-2012 1A 2A 3A SL Station Code Board De board % De board Board De board % De board Board De board % De board Board De board % De board Total Board % Total Board Total Deboard % Total Deboard MAS 909 0 0 3297 0 0 7881 0 0 22777 0 0 34864 92 0 0 AJJ 0 0 0 28 0 0 153 0 0 539 0 0 720 2 0 0 KPD 32 0 0 96 0 0 231 0 0 1412 7 0 1771 5 7 0 SA 0 13 1 12 16 0 13 49 1 97 249 1 122 0 327 1 ED 0 6 1 4 46 1 18 54 1 56 519 2 78 0 625 2 TUP 0 25 3 0 92 3 0 183 2 0 926 4 0 0 1226 3 CBF 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 9 0 0 0 9 0 CBE 8 424 45 40 2056 59 54 3593 43 186 14948 60 288 1 21021 56 MTP 0 481 51 0 1267 36 0 4471 54 0 8409 34 0 0 14628 39 TOTAL 949 949 100 3477 3477 100 8350 8350 100 25067 25067 100 37843 100 37843 100
1. The patronage of passengers for Train No. 12671 Chennai Coimbatore Mettupalayam Nilagiri Express is mainly for Coimbatore (56%) and Mettupalayam (39%).
2. This train constitutes two individual trains, one portion RUNS up to Coimbatore (CBE) and the SECOND portion runs separately and continuously to Mettupalayam (MTP).
3. There is only 1% of patronage for Salem, 2% for Erode which are very negligible. There is 3% of patronage for Tiruppur but the distance between Tiruppur and Coimbatore is only 50 Kms. and the fare difference will be only ` 15 for SL, ` 42 for 3A, ` 65 for 2A and ` 115 for 1A.
4. As Nilagiri Mountain Railway has entirely a different system of charging of fare i.e., on inflated distance basis, through reservations beyond MTP need not be considered. Ticketing between MTP and UAM may be done separately, if necessary.
5. Hence, the entire journey distance fits in two fare sectors and the charging of fare can be done for two sectors. i.e., a. Chennai (MAS) to Coimbatore (CBE) for all the passengers booking from and between MAS to CBE and b. Chennai (MAS) to Mettupalayam (MTP) for all passengers booking from and between MAS to MTP for bookings beyond CBE.
18
Station-wise and Class-wise List of Passengers and Demand Flow Report For Train Np.12672 - MTP - CBE - MAS - Nilagiri Express From Date: 1-5-2012 To Date:31-5-2012 1A 2A 3A SL Station Code Board De board % De board Board De board % De board Board De board % De board Board De board % De board Total Board % Total Board Total Deboard % Total Deboard MTP 663 0 0 1945 0 0 5750 0 0 8135 0 0 16494 42 0 0 CBE 211 1 0 1415 40 1 2225 32 0 14280 75 0 18131 46 148 0 TUP 25 0 0 114 0 0 282 2 0 2012 3 0 2433 6 5 0 ED 27 2 0 128 1 0 211 18 0 1121 71 0 1487 4 92 0 SA 13 0 0 71 1 0 80 32 0 610 93 0 774 2 126 0 KPD 0 23 2 5 23 1 12 103 1 21 358 1 38 0 507 1 AJJ 0 0 0 0 18 0 7 39 0 0 377 1 7 0 434 1 MAS 0 914 97 0 3595 98 0 8341 97 0 25202 96 0 0 38052 97 TOTAL 940 940 100 3678 3678 100 8567 8567 100 26179 26179 100 39364 100 39364 100
1. The patronage of passengers for Train No. 12672 Mettupalayam Coimbatore Chennai Nilagiri Express is mainly from Mettupalayam (41%) Coimbatore (46%) and 6% from Tiruppur. However, the distance between Coimbatore and Tiruppur is only 50 Kms. and the fare difference will be only ` 15 for SL, ` 42 for 3A, ` 65 for 2A and ` 115 for 1A.
2. There is only 4% & 2% of patronage from Erode and Salem respectively. The distance between CBE and ED is 100 Kms. As Tiruppur and Coimbatore have been merged into one Sector the difference in fare between ED to MAS and TUP to MAS will be only ` 16 for SL, `42 for 3A, ` 66 for 2A and ` 115 for 1A which is very minimum.
3. As Nilagiri Mountain Railway has entirely a different system of charging of fare i.e., on inflated distance basis, through reservations from UAM & ONR need not be considered. There is negligible 1% booking from UAM and ONR and hence it is suggested that the passengers may purchase a separate ticket from UAM & ONR upto MTP and the reservations should commence only from MTP and beyond.
4. Hence, the entire journey distance fits in two fare sectors and the charging of fare can be done for two sectors i.e., a. Mettupalayam (MTP) to Chennai (MAS) for all the passengers booking from and between MTP to CBE and b. Coimbatore (CBE) to Chennai (MAS) for all passengers booking from and between CBE to MAS.
1. The patronage of passengers for Train No. 12631 Chennai Tirunelveli Nellai Express is mainly for Madurai (12%), Virudunagar (5%), Kovilpatti (21%) and Tirunelveli (57%). The distance between Madurai & Virudunagar is 43 Kms. and between Kovilpatti & Tirunelveli is 65 Kms. Hence MDU & VPT have been merged into one Sector and CVP and TEN have been merged into another Sector. The difference in fare would be very minimal considering the distance between these two pair of points.
2. Hence, the entire journey distance fits in two fare sectors and the charging of fare can be done for two sectors i.e., a. Chennai (MS) to Virudunagar (VPT) for all the passengers booking from and between MS to VPT and b. Chennai (MS) to Tirunelveli (TEN) for all passengers booking from and between MS to TEN for bookings beyond VPT.
1. The patronage of passengers for Train No. 12632 Tirunelveli Chennai Nellai Express is mainly from Tirunelveli (68%), Kovilpatti (14%), Virudunagar (5%) and Madurai (8%). The distance between Tirunelveli and Kovilpatti is 65 Kms. and Virudunagar & Madurai is 43 Kms. Hence TEN & CVP have been merged into one Sector and VPT and MDU have been merged into another Sector. The difference in fare would be very minimal considering the distance between these two pair of points.
2. Hence, the entire journey distance fits in two fare sectors and the charging of fare can be done for two sectors i.e., a. Tirunelveli (TEN) to Chennai (MS) for all the passengers booking from and between TEN to VPT and b. Virudunagar (VPT) to Chennai (MS) for all passengers booking from VPT and beyond.
1. The patronage of passengers for Train No. 12633 Chennai Kanyakumari Kanyakumari Express is mainly for Tirunelveli (21%), Nagercoil (41%) & Kanyakumari (19%). However, the distance between Nagercoil and Kanyakumari is only 15 Kms. Hence NCJ & CAPE have been merged into one Sector. The difference in fare would be very minimal considering the distance between these two pair of points.
2. Hence, the entire journey distance fits in two fare sectors and the charging of fare can be done for two sectors i.e.,
a. Chennai (MS) to Tirunelveli (TEN) for all the passengers booking from and between MS to TEN and b. Chennai (MS) to Kanyakumari (CAPE) for all passengers booking from and between MS to CAPE for bookings beyond TEN.
1. The patronage of passengers for Train No. 12634 Kanyakumari Chennai Kanyakumari Express is mainly from Kanyakumari (19%), Nagercoil (43%) & Tirunelveli (16%). The distance between Kanyakumari and Nagercoil is only 15 Kms. and the difference in fare would be very minimal and so CAPE & NCJ have been merged into one fare sector.
2. Hence, the entire journey distance fits in two fare sectors and the charging of fare can be done for two sectors i.e., a. Kanyakumari (CAPE) to Chennai (MS) for all the passengers booking from and between CAPE to TEN and b. Tirunelveli (TEN) to Chennai (MS) for all passengers booking from and between TEN to MS for bookings beyond TEN.
1. The patronage of passengers for Train No. 16723 Chennai Egmore (MS) to Trivandrum (TVC) Ananthapuri Express is mainly for Tirunelveli (30%), Nagercoil (19%) & Trivandrum (11%). Even though there is 13% patronage for Kuzhiturai (KZT) the distance between KZT and TVC is only 38 Kms. and the fare difference will be very minimal.
2. Hence, the entire journey distance fits in three fare sectors and the charging of fare can be done for three fare sectors i.e., a. MS to TEN for all the passengers booking from and between MS to TEN b. MS to Nagercoil (NCJ) for all passengers booking from and between MS to NCJ for destinations beyond TEN. & c. MS to TVC for all passengers booking from and between MS to TVC for destinations beyond NCJ.
3. Here for the residual travel between TEN to TVC & NCJ to TVC, which is during day time, the special fare (discounted) concept is to be adopted as more than 30% & 60% of the berths are vacant from TEN & NCJ respectively.
2. Hence, the entire journey distance fits in four distance Sectors for fare structure and the charging of fare can be done for four Sectors a. MAS to PGT for all the passengers booking from and between MAS to PGT, b. MAS to Thrisur (TCR) for all passengers booking from and between MAS to TCR for destinations beyond PGT. c. MAS to ERS for all passengers booking from and between MAS to ERS for destinations beyond TCR & d. MAS to Alleppey (ALLP) for all passengers booking from and between MAS to ALLP for destinations beyond ERS.
3. Here for the residual travel between TCR to ALLP, which is during day time, the special fare (discounted) concept is to be adopted as more than 50% of the berths are vacant from TCR. 26
Station-wise and Class-wise List of Passengers and Demand Flow Report for Train No.16042 - ALLP-MAS - Alleppey Express From Date: 1-5-2012 To Date: 31-5-2012 2A 3A FC SL Station Code Board Deboard % De board Board Deboard % De board Board Deboard % De board Board Deboard % De board Total Board Total % Board Total Deboard Total % Deboard ALLP 289 0 0 708 0 0 72 0 0 3025 0 0 4094 10 0 0 SRTL 41 0 0 130 0 0 14 0 0 612 0 0 797 2 0 0 TUVR 3 0 0 26 0 0 0 0 0 109 0 0 138 0 0 0 ERS 636 0 0 1210 0 0 201 0 0 4265 0 0 6312 15 0 0 ERN 356 0 0 749 0 0 72 0 0 1733 0 0 2910 7 0 0 AWY 114 0 0 435 0 0 45 0 0 2621 0 0 3215 8 0 0 AFK 35 0 0 93 0 0 12 0 0 626 0 0 766 2 0 0 DINR 6 0 0 14 0 0 0 0 0 113 0 0 133 0 0 0 CKI 49 0 0 151 0 0 13 0 0 1651 0 0 1864 4 0 0 IJK 55 0 0 136 0 0 34 0 0 1016 0 0 1241 3 0 0 TCR 717 0 0 1654 0 0 200 0 0 9734 0 0 12305 29 0 0 PNQ 5 0 0 11 2 0 0 0 0 8 3 0 24 0 5 0 WKI 10 0 0 26 3 0 2 0 0 331 10 0 369 1 13 0 OTP 94 3 0 268 63 1 21 0 0 2013 56 0 2396 6 122 0 PGT 522 26 1 679 144 2 83 4 0 3346 285 1 4630 11 459 1 PTJ 58 11 0 67 25 0 12 3 0 213 104 0 350 1 143 0 TUP 64 2 0 84 13 0 12 0 0 299 99 0 459 1 114 0 ED 47 9 0 59 15 0 11 2 0 215 114 0 332 1 140 0 SA 6 9 0 18 31 0 16 3 0 60 211 1 100 0 254 1 JTJ 0 8 0 2 1 0 0 3 0 1 33 0 3 0 45 0 KPD 0 22 1 3 46 1 0 9 1 24 464 1 27 0 541 1 AJJ 0 21 1 5 32 0 0 6 1 1 415 1 6 0 474 1 AVD 0 10 0 6 23 0 0 2 0 1 327 1 7 0 362 1 PER 0 6 0 0 28 0 0 4 0 0 128 0 0 0 166 0 MAS 0 2980 96 0 6108 93 0 784 96 0 29768 93 0 0 39640 93 TOTAL 3107 3107 100 6534 6534 100 820 820 100 32017 32017 100 42478 100 42478 100 1. The patronage of passengers for Train No. 16042 Alleppey (ALLP) to Chennai (MAS) Alleppey Express is mainly from ALLP (10%), ERS (15%), TCR(29%) & PGT(11%). 2. Hence, the entire journey distance fits in four distance Sectors for fare structure and the charging of fare can be done for four Sectors. A. ALLP to MAS for all passengers booking from and between ALLP to ERS, B. ERS to MAS for all passengers booking from and between ERS to TCR for destinations beyond ERS, C. TCR to MAS for all passengers booking from and between TCR to PGT for destinations beyond TCR and D. PGT to MAS for all passengers booking from and between PGT to MAS for destinations beyond PGT. 3. Here for the travel between ALLP to TCR & ERS to TCR, which is during day time, the special fare (discounted) concept is to be adopted as more than 90% & 80% of the berths are vacant from ALLP & ERS respectively.
1. The patronage of passengers for Train No.16724 Trivandrum (TVC) to Chennai Egmore (MS) Ananthapuri Express is mainly from TVC(20%), NCJ(13%), TEN(20%) & MDU(14%). Even though there is 14% patronage from KZT the difference in distance between TVC to KZT is only 38 Kms and the fare difference is very minimal. 2. Hence, the entire journey distance fits in four distance Sectors for fare structure and the charging of fare can be done for four Sectors 1) TVC to MS for all the passengers booking from and between TVC to NCJ 2) NCJ to MS for all passengers booking from and between NCJ to TEN for destinations beyond NCJ 3) TEN to MS for all passengers booking from and between TEN to MDU for destinations beyond TEN and 4) MDU to MS for all passengers booking from and between MDU to MS for destinations beyond MDU. 28
1. The patronage of passengers for Train No.16627 Chennai Central (MAS) to Mangalore (MAQ) Mangalore Express is mainly from MAS (50%), SA - TUP (22%) and CBE (14%),
2. Out of the 50% boarding at MAS nearly 35% de-boarding takes place between KPD and CBE. The major destinations are Salem (15%), Coimbatore (10%).
3. The journey between MAS & CBE is during day time and even though there is 15% patronage to SA the distance between SA and CBE is 163 Kms. and the difference in fare between MAS to SA & MAS to CBE ranges from ` 48 for SL to ` 210 for 2A. The Concept of Special Fare (discounted) may be adopted between MAS to CBE to attract more passengers between these two points.
4. Along with the 15% balance at CBE there is boarding of 47% totaling to 62% occupation from CBE and the major de-boarding is at Mangalore (43%) apart from Palghat (3%), Calicut (6%) & Cannanore (4%).
5. The distance between CLT & CAN is only 90 kms, and the difference in fare between MAS to CLT and MAS to CAN is very minimal. Hence CAN & CLT have been merged into one Sector for charging.
6. Hence, the entire journey distance fits in four distance Sectors for fare structure and the charging of fare can be done for four Sectors 1) MAS to CBE for all the passengers booking from and between MAS to CBE 2) MAS to Shoranur (SRR) for all passengers booking from and between MAS to SRR for destinations beyond CBE. 3) MAS to CAN for all passengers booking from and between MAS to CAN for destinations beyond SRR and 4) MAS to MAQ for all passengers booking from and between MAS to MAQ for destinations beyond CAN.
7. Apart from the above four distance Sectors, a separate distance Sector from CBE to MAQ for night journey is proposed.
1. The patronage of passengers for Train No.16628 Mangalore (MAQ) to Chennai Central (MAS) Mangalore Express the boarding pattern is mainly as follows: a. MAQ to KPQ 57%; b. CAN to PGT 19%; c. CBE to SGE 13% and d. SA 7%.
2. The de-boarding pattern is mainly as follows: a. SRR to CBE 27%; b. TUP to SA 13%; c. JTJ to MAS 59%
3. Even though there is 7% patronage from CLT the distance between CAN and CLT is only 90 Kms. and the fare difference will be very minimal.
4. Hence, the entire journey distance fits in four distance Sectors for fare structure and the charging of fare can be done for four Sectors 1) MAQ to MAS for all the passengers booking from and between MAQ to CAN 2) CAN TO MAS for all passengers booking from and between CAN to CBE for destinations beyond CAN, 3) CBE to MAS for all passengers booking from and between CBE to SA for destinations beyond CBE, and 4) SA to MAS for all passengers booking from and between SA to MAS for destinations beyond SA.
1. The patronage of passengers for Train No.12695 Chennai Central (MAS) Trivandrum (TVC), Trivandrum Express for upto Coimbatore CBE (21%), upto Kottayam KTYM (22%), upto Chengannur CNGR (14%) & Trivandrum TVC (43%). 2. Even though there is 7% patronage for Salem (SA) the distance between SA and CBE is 163 Kms. and the difference in fare ranges between ` 48/- for SL to ` 210 for 2A. 3. Hence, it is suggested that the charging of fare can be done for four Sectors, 1) MAS to CBE for all the passengers booking from and between MAS to CBE, 2) MAS to KTYM for all passengers booking from and between MAS to KTYM for destinations beyond CBE, 3) MAS to KYJ for all passengers booking from and between MAS to KYJ for destinations beyond KTYM and 4) MAS to TVC for all passengers booking from and between MAS to TVC for destinations beyond KYJ. 4. Apart from the above four distance Sectors, a separate distance Sector from CBE to TVC for night journey is proposed.
33
Station-wise and Class-wise List of Passengers and Demand Flow Report For Train No.12696 - TVC-MAS - Trivandrum Express From Date: 1-5-2012 To Date:31-5-2012 2A 3A FC SL Station Code Board De board % De board Board De board % De board Board De board % De board Board De board % De board Total Board Total % Board Total Deboard Total % Deboard TVC 1034 0 0 2496 0 0 236 0 0 8552 0 0 12318 28 0 0 VAK 39 0 0 63 0 0 12 0 0 400 0 0 514 1 0 0 QLN 217 2 0 452 5 0 61 0 0 2501 13 0 3231 7 20 0 KYJ 67 0 0 173 1 0 14 0 0 1093 10 0 1347 3 11 0 MVLK 44 0 0 80 3 0 17 0 0 410 6 0 551 1 9 0 CNGR 142 4 0 381 13 0 52 0 0 3507 10 0 4082 9 27 0 TRVL 86 1 0 202 17 0 22 4 0 1067 24 0 1377 3 46 0 CGY 42 1 0 115 13 0 17 0 0 530 19 0 704 2 33 0 KTYM 257 15 0 638 75 1 81 1 0 3089 124 0 4065 9 215 0 ERN 945 192 6 1590 541 8 199 11 1 5588 632 2 8322 19 1376 3 TCR 258 21 1 598 64 1 64 2 0 3814 277 1 4734 11 364 1 PGT 28 23 1 36 90 1 14 11 1 419 461 1 497 1 585 1 CBE 42 85 3 100 193 3 22 17 2 709 1084 3 873 2 1379 3 TUP 0 6 0 12 35 0 0 9 1 101 799 2 113 0 849 2 ED 15 43 1 15 102 1 0 6 1 272 1233 4 302 1 1384 3 SA 50 70 2 146 203 3 18 47 6 887 2193 7 1101 2 2513 6 JTJ 7 16 0 6 44 1 3 11 1 35 443 1 51 0 514 1 VN 1 1 0 1 1 0 1 0 0 50 207 1 53 0 209 0 KPD 19 271 8 50 520 7 1 53 6 82 2606 8 152 0 3450 8 AJJ 2 57 2 0 65 1 0 6 1 0 824 2 2 0 952 2 MAS 0 2487 75 0 5169 72 0 656 79 0 22141 67 0 0 30453 69 TOTAL 3295 3295 100 7154 7154 100 834 834 100 33106 33106 100 44389 100 44389 100 1. The patronage of passengers for Train No. 12696 Trivandrum Chennai Central Trivandrum Express is mainly from Trivandrum (28%), Chenganur (9%). Kottayam (9%), Ernakumalam Town (19%) and Trichur (11%). There is 7% patronage from QLN but the distance between QLN to TVC is 65 Kms. and the difference in fare between TVC to MAS & QLN to MAS ranges from ` 14 for SL to `.117 for 2A. Also, there is 19% patronage from ERN but the distance between KTYM and ERN is only 62 Kms. and the difference in fare between KTYM to MAS and ERN to MAS ranges from ` 14 for SL to `.117 for 2A. 2. Hence, the entire journey distance fits in four fare sectors and the charging of fare can be done for four sectors i.e., a. Trivandrum (TVC) to Chennai (MAS) for all the passengers booking from and between TVC to KYJ; b. Kayangulam (KYJ) to MAS for all passengers booking from and between KYJ to KTYM for destinations beyond KYJ. c. KTYM to MAS for all passengers booking from and between KTYM to TCR for destinations beyond KTYM. d. Trichur (TCR) to MAS for all passengers booking from and between TCR to MAS for destinations beyond TCR. 34
OUTCOME OF THE ANALYSIS OUTCOME OF THE ANALYSIS OUTCOME OF THE ANALYSIS OUTCOME OF THE ANALYSIS: :: : The study of passenger patronage profile revealed that for trains starting from MAS/MS to various destinations the percentage of boarding is more than 90% at Originating Station and major de- boarding is at two to four Sectors of stations, each within a radius of 75 Kms. Whereas in the return direction the boarding pattern is at two to four Sectors of stations with a radius of 75 Kms. each and the de-boarding at MAS/MS is more than 80%. Based on the passenger patronage, the train distance structure has been segregated to Single fare sector, two fare sectors, three fare sectors and four fare sectors for respective distance groups. Examples for each sector are given below:
SINGLE SINGLE SINGLE SINGLE FARE SECTOR FARE SECTOR FARE SECTOR FARE SECTOR: : : : Invariably trains running upto 350 kms and for certain trains running upto 500 kms the passenger patronage is point to point.
Train No.12657 99% of boarding is at Starting Station i.e, Chennai and 99% of the de-boarding at Terminating Station i.e, Bangalore. Train No.12658 98% of boarding is at Starting Station i.e, Bangalore and 99% of the de-boarding at Terminating Station i.e, Chennai.
Train No.12673 98% of boarding is at Starting Station i.e, Chennai and 95% of the de-boarding near Terminating Station i.e, Tiruppur and Coimbatore, within the radius of 50 Kms. Train No.12674 97% of boarding is near the Starting Station i.e, Coimbatore and Tiruppur, within the radius of 50 Kms. and 95% of the de-boarding is at the Terminating Station i.e, Chennai.
35
TWO TWO TWO TWO FARE SECTORS FARE SECTORS FARE SECTORS FARE SECTORS: :: : For trains running between 375 and 500 kms the passenger patronage is predominantly is for 2 destinations. Hence grouping of passengers can be done in two fare sectors within the distance group.
Train No.16669 - 96% of the boarding is at Starting Station i.e., Chennai and major de-boarding is at two stations Salem (25%) and Erode (67%) whereas in the return direction for Train No.16670 major boarding is at Erode (65%) and Salem (26%) and de-boarding of 97% is at Terminating Station i.e., Chennai.
Train No.12637 98% of the boarding is at Starting Station i.e, Chennai (Tambaram, 5% boarding, a suburban station considered as Chennai for all purposes) and major de-boarding is at two stations Dindigul (17%) and Madurai (72%) whereas in the return direction for Train No.12638 major boarding is at Madurai (72%) and Dindigul (17%) and de-boarding of 98% is at Terminating Station i.e., Chennai (including suburban station of Tambaram 5%).
For trains running between 500 - 950 kms. the patronage is to mainly to stations that can be grouped into 3 or 4 fare sectors within a radius of 100 kms. For such trains the grouping of passengers can be done in 3 or 4 Sectors as deemed fit eg.
THREE THREE THREE THREE FARE SECTORS FARE SECTORS FARE SECTORS FARE SECTORS: :: : Train No.16723 91% of the boarding is at Starting Station i.e, Chennai (Tambaram 9% Chengalpattu 3% boarding, both suburban stations are considered as Chennai for all purposes) and major de- boarding is at three stations Tirunelveli (30%), Nagercoil (19%), Kuzhithurai (13%) and Trivandrum (11%) and the balance distributed among various enroute stations for which the maximum de-boarding percentage is < 4%. 36
FOUR FOUR FOUR FOUR FARE SECTORS FARE SECTORS FARE SECTORS FARE SECTORS: :: : Train No.16041 94% of the boarding is at Starting Station i.e, Chennai and major de-boarding is at four stations Palghat (11%), Trichur (34%), Ernakulam (24%) and Alleppey (10%) balance distributed within a radius of 100Kms. of the major de-boarding points whereas in the return direction for Train No.16042 major boarding is at Alleppey (10%), Ernakulam (15%), Trichur (29%) and Palghat (11%) and the balance at various enroute stations adjacent to the aforementioned major boarding points. Major de-boarding of 93% is at Terminating Station i.e, Chennai.
Train No.16627 54% of the boarding is between Chennai and Katpadi within the radius of 130 Kms., 32% at various enroute stations from Salem to Coimbatore and the balance boarding is between Coimbatore and Cannanore and major de-boarding of 35% between Jolarpettai and Coimbatore, 4% between Coimbatore and Shoranur, 13% between Shoranur and Cannanore and 46% between Cannanore and Mangalore. In the return direction for Train No.16628 57% of boarding is between Mangalore and Cannanore, 19% of boarding is between Cannanore and Coimbatore, 13% of boarding is between Coimbatore and Salem, 8% of boarding is between Salem and Katpadi and major de-boarding of 26% is between is between Cannanore and Coimbatore, 13% between Coimbatore and Salem and 60% between Salem and Chennai. This pattern is because major portion of the travelling is during day time.
ADDITIONAL FARE SECTORS ADDITIONAL FARE SECTORS ADDITIONAL FARE SECTORS ADDITIONAL FARE SECTORS: :: : In some long distance trains the journey involves both day as well as night travel. The patronage of passengers is separately 50 70% for the travel during day and 50 70% for the travel during night. To attract more patronage it is suggested that a special fare (discounted) may be given for the travel during day and a separate fare sector from the point where the night journey commences to the 37
destination of the train and the same has been indicated in the respective trains.
SUMMARY OF ANALYSIS SUMMARY OF ANALYSIS SUMMARY OF ANALYSIS SUMMARY OF ANALYSIS The summary of the analysis of 13 pairs of trains is tabulated below:-
SINGLE FARE SECTOR TRAINS SINGLE FARE SECTOR TRAINS SINGLE FARE SECTOR TRAINS SINGLE FARE SECTOR TRAINS
Sector Stations Sl. No. Train No. Train Name Source Station Destination Station Distance No. of Station Sector From To 1 12657 Bangalore Mail MAS SBC 362 I Sector MAS SBC 2 12658 Chennai Mail SBC MAS 362 I Sector SBC MAS 3 12673 Cheran Express MAS CBE 497 I Sector MAS CBE 4 12674 Cheran Express CBE MAS 497 I Sector CBE MAS
TWO FARE SECTOR TRAINS
Sector Stations Sl. No. Train No. Train Name Source Station Destination Station Distance No. of Station Sectors From To 1 16669 Yercaud Express MAS ED 396 I Sector MAS SA II Sector MAS ED 2 16670 Yercaud Express ED MAS 396 I Sector ED MAS II Sector SA MAS 3 16177 Rockfort Express MS KMU 425 I Sector MS TPJ II Sector MS KMU 4 16178 Rockfort Express KMU MS 425 I Sector KMU MS II Sector TPJ MS 5 12637 Pandian Express MS MDU 497 I Sector MS DG II Sector MS MDU 6 12638 Pandian Express MDU MS 497 I Sector MDU MS II Sector DG MS 7 16222 Kaveri Express MAS MYS 500 I Sector MAS SBC II Sector MAS MYS 8 16222 Kaveri Express MYS MAS 500 I Sector MYS MAS II Sector SBC MAS 9 12671 Nilagiri Express MAS MTP 532 I Sector MAS CBE II Sector MAS MTP 10 12672 Nilagiri Express MTP MAS 532 I Sector MTP MAS II Sector CBE MAS 11 12631 Nellai Express MS TEN 653 I Sector MS VPT II Sector MS TEN 12 12632 Nellai Express TEN MS 653 I Sector TEN MS II Sector TEN VPT 13 12633 MS CAPE 742 I Sector MS TEN
Kanyakumari Express II Sector MS CAPE 14 12634 CAPE MS 742 I Sector CAPE MS
Kanyakumari Express II Sector TEN MS
38
THREE FARE SECTOR TRAINS
Sector Stations Sl. No. Train No. Train Name Source Station Destination Station Distance No. of Station Sectors From To I Sector MS TEN II Sector MS NCJ 1 16723 Ananthapuri Express MS TVC 798 III Sector MS TVC
FOUR FARE SECTOR TRAINS
Sector Stations Sl. No. Train No. Train Name Source Station Destination Station Distance No. of Station Sectors From To I Sector MAS PGT II Sector MAS TCR III Sector MAS ERS 1 16041 Alleppey Express MAS ALLP 746 IV Sector MAS ALLP I Sector ALLP MAS II Sector ERS MAS III Sector TCR MAS 2 16042 Alleppey Express ALLP MAS 746 IV Sector PGT MAS I Sector TVC MS II Sector NCJ MS III Sector TEN MS 3 16724 Ananthapuri Exp. TVC MS 798 IV Sector MDU MS I Sector MAS CBE II Sector MAS SRR III Sector MAS CAN IV Sector MAS MAQ 4 16627 West Coast Exp. MAS MAQ 902 Addl. Sector CBE MAQ I Sector MAQ MAS II Sector CAN MAS III Sector CBE MAS IV Sector SA MAS 5 16628 West Coast Exp. MAQ MAS 902 Addl. Sector CBE MAS I Sector MAS CBE II Sector MAS KTYM III Sector MAS CNGR IV Sector MAS TVC 6 12695 Trivandrum Exp. MAS TVC 922 Addl. Sector CBE TVC I Sector TVC MAS II Sector KYJ MAS III Sector KTYM MAS 7 12696 Trivandrum Exp. TVC MAS 922 IV Sector TCR MAS
39
INFERENCE: INFERENCE: INFERENCE: INFERENCE: The passenger preference is mainly point to point or restricted to 3 or 4 major Originating/destination points. The short distance passengers prefer long distance trains due to their individual convenience vis-a-vis time of departure/arrival. The present system of charging for individual enroute stations with minimal patronage is not advantageous to Railways. The price differential by aggregating stations into different Sectors is very minimal when compared to the present income level of the average passenger. SUGGESTIONS (MAIN): SUGGESTIONS (MAIN): SUGGESTIONS (MAIN): SUGGESTIONS (MAIN): Services extended to passengers preferring to travel short distance in long distance trains should be treated a value added service and should be charged at enhanced rates. An alternate system of train based charging of fares adopting different fare sectors commensurate with the pattern of patronage for the respective trains. For trains with maximum point to point patronage of 95% and above single fare sector is suggested. For trains with maximum boarding and de-boarding at two stations, two fare sectors are suggested. For trains with maximum boarding and de-boarding at three or four sectors respective charging at three or four fare sectors are suggested.
ADVANCE RESERVATION PERIOD AND TATKAL QUOTA: ADVANCE RESERVATION PERIOD AND TATKAL QUOTA: ADVANCE RESERVATION PERIOD AND TATKAL QUOTA: ADVANCE RESERVATION PERIOD AND TATKAL QUOTA: At present the Advance Reservation Period (ARP) for all passengers is 120 days. This should be staggered to two periods i.e., for the first 30 days only end to end reservations should be allowed and after 30 days reservations for enroute stations conforming to the Sector charging system should be introduced. 40
Out of the total accommodation available 50% should be set aside for General quota. In the remaining 50% after setting aside berths for other quotas, the balance should be set aside for Tatkal quota. At present Tatkal tickets are sold only one day in advance of the scheduled departure of the trains, instead tatkal seva option should be opened for public as and when the general quota is filled and waitlist tickets are issued. By adopting this procedure Railways need not wait for the 119 days, thereby blocking the earnings of 10 - 30% of the total accommodation which is earmarked for tatkal. Within the tatkal quota sub-grouping should be introduced in the following lines. o First 50% of the quota should be charged at normal tatkal rates o Next 20% of the tatkal quota should be charged at normal tatkal rates + 30% o Next 20% of the tatkal quota should be charged at normal tatkal rates + 50% o Next 10% of the tatkal quota should be charged at normal tatkal rates + 75% The moment, even the tatkal quota is fully exhausted, the possibility of introducing specials (festival or holiday) should be explored and the pricing for such trains should start with normal tatkal fares treating this as a premium service.
ADDITIONAL GENERAL SUGGESTIONS: ADDITIONAL GENERAL SUGGESTIONS: ADDITIONAL GENERAL SUGGESTIONS: ADDITIONAL GENERAL SUGGESTIONS: The feasibility of reducing halts at stations where the patronage is minimal or at times nil, may be reviewed to decrease the journey time of these trains. The cost of operating the train can also be reduced by minimizing the number of halts as more fuel is used in stopping and starting the trains at each station.
41
CONCLUSION: CONCLUSION: CONCLUSION: CONCLUSION: Railways should adopt charging of fares based on different Sectors, train-wise. The advantages would be as follows: The traffic earnings can be maximized by optimally exploiting train-wise passenger preference/pattern Simplification of methodology of charging fare by removing charges based on various distance slabs. Since the Advance Reservation Period (ARP) is 120 days, by adopting this rationale, we can avoid short distance passengers Sectoring the accommodation of long distance passengers at the beginning of the ARP itself. Passengers will opt more for the direct trains since they may have to pay additional fare for the same destination if they opt for long distance trains.
In this context it would not be out of place to note that various road transport organizations also adopt point to point fare structures between important destinations without any reduction in patronage.
Thus, in keeping pace with the market dynamics and economic environment it is worth examining this in-house exercise of alternate methodology of rationalization of the fare structure of reserved tickets.
Neues verkehrswissenschaftliches Journal - Ausgabe 26: User-based Adaptable High Performance Simulation Modelling and Design for Railway Planning and Operations