Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Kelly Kingsley
TEAC 991 1
Action Research Plan
May 2009/Revised June 30, 2009
Rationale
For the past 21 years, I have tried many different methods and strategies to teach spelling,
from spelling basal programs, worksheets, tests and word activities, and always in the back of
mind has been the thought, “There has got to be a better way to teach spelling.” I know that
spelling is not only important on the Friday spelling test, but that it is important in all areas of the
curriculum, so I want to implement strategies and instruction into the spelling program in my
classroom to help my students become spellers throughout everything they write, not just on a
Spelling has always interested me. I have always wondered why a student who can get
100% on each weekly spelling test couldn’t transfer that learning to their writing. What was
missing in my instruction that wasn’t allowing that connection to be made? Plus, using the basal
spelling program was just downright boring and thus unmotivating to say the least. If I am bored
with the program, then I am sure my students are. Why am I teaching spelling in the first place?
content areas? How can doing workbook pages help children learn to spell words?
Past Efforts
I have experimented with individualized spelling lists, but they still contained a huge
portion of basal lists. Each student was to pick 3-5 words they wanted to learn to spell, but those
words really had no relation to the patterns we were learning, or words the kids needed for
Kelly Kingsley Action Research Plan
independent writing. So how do I identify words that my students should be learning? What
2
words should I teach and how? How will students get contextualized practice with multiple
opportunities? I know I will have above average to below average spellers in my classroom, so
how do I serve each one in the best possible way? How do I incorporate words for all learners to
use and learn to spell? How do I keep my students actively involved in learning to spell without
I have played around with a word wall in my classroom, using it to show content
vocabulary or third grade list words, but I never used the wall as a teaching tool. So how do I
Therefore, my question for fall 2009 will be: Will the integration of spelling in reading
Literature Learning
Research has shown me that children learn to spell in the same manner they learned to
speak. Children need to take risks when learning to spell (Gentry, 1987). They need to
experience invented spelling and not have the pressure of spelling correctly when they are
writing. Children need to experience being wrong when spelling words, so that they are not
afraid of writing, but are learning from it (Gentry, 1987). Students need to do purposeful
writing to experience words and the teacher can guide them with instruction to help them learn
strategies to use when they don’t know how to spell a word (Graham, Harris, & Chorzempa,
2002). Research has shown that there is a close relationship between spelling, reading, and
fragmented subject (Noell, Connell, & Duhon, 2006). The students need to be given instruction
3
on spelling strategies and word study. Combining writing with spelling instruction will give
students tools to use when needing to spell an unknown word (Henry, 1997). Spelling can be
taught as a sensible and interesting task that strengthens the relationships between reading and
writing, and helps build vocabulary knowledge. I would like to call attention to words and word
features as students encounter them in functional context because words become meaningful and
I have also noted from the research that poor readers tend to be poor spellers and those
students will need more opportunities to see and use words to make them their own. Strategies
need to be in place to help strong and struggling spellers, just like what is done for reading
instruction (Graham, Harris, & Chorzempa, 2002). The development of spelling skills isn’t
random, but evolves in stages, described as developmental. Masterson and Crede mention
Henderson’s 5 stages of spelling development: (1) preliterate-scribbles, drawing and some letter,
(2) letter-name stage-children enjoy representing sounds with letters, (3) within-word patterns-
orthographic patterns are learned, (4) syllable juncture-use of doubling principle (5) derivational
constancy-roots and derivations used consistently (Masterson, & Crede, 1999). Knowing the
stages of spelling development will help the teacher to look for strategies for each stage her
There are three main spelling perspectives that appear to parallel particular spelling
practices: (a) traditional, (b) transitional, and (c) student-oriented (Heald-Taylor, 1998). A good
spelling program will incorporate some of each practice. By themselves they are good practice,
Traditional practices are based on traditional attitudes and an implicit learning theory .
4
Instruction, drill, memorization, imitation, rote learning, and an emphasis on correctness are
focused on. Traditional practices are taught formally as a separate subject. Teachers are the
main givers of information, and there is a test at the end of the week.
Transitional practices focus on the integration of numerous spelling strategies and the
significance of reading in learning to spell. Students are given direct instruction in phonetics,
spelling rules, study procedures, and weekly testing takes place. Spelling is mainly learned in
conjunction with various types of word study, like word sorts and spelling games. Teachers
integrate both direct and interactive instruction. Direct teaching is used for introducing words,
patterns, and spelling rules. Interactive strategies are employed when students use word sorts
and spelling games. Students are involved in their own learning. Evaluation is both formal and
informal. Formal evaluation comes from weekly and unit tests. Informal evaluation comes from
monitoring spelling competence in word sorting. Concerns regarding the transitional approach
are many of the activities are conducted separately from contextual reading and are conducted
without regard for students’ developmental stages. Another concern is the lack of specific
instructional strategies to show teachers how they could assist students in improving their
reading provides a context for learning to spell, and spelling is a functional component of
writing. The teacher’s role changes dramatically from predominantly giving information to
facilitating learning based on developmental levels and individual student needs. Students are
expected to engage actively in their own learning as they figure out much of their spelling for
themselves. Strategies are developmental, word study is done through literature, themed units
Kelly Kingsley Action Research Plan
and collaborative groups are employed. The teacher uses metacognitive conferences and mini-
5
lessons for instruction. Spelling is evaluated over time as students integrate numerous spelling
strategies into their repertoire and spelling effort moves toward conventionality. Individual
spelling profiles and conference logs are used to monitor authentic progress.
According to Scott, 2000, spelling integrated in authentic reading and writing allows the child to
begin with the task of producing a text for an authentic purpose. The teacher conferences and
circulates as children are writing, pointing out words spelled correctly, searching for underlying
principles in what isn’t spelled correctly and discusses these with the child. The key is to
capitalize on a teachable moment for spelling. The child should have an opportunity to apply
principle in another text-level writing experience. Students are taught to proof-read and self
correct spelling errors. Peer editing is also used to strengthen skills used in spelling. Poor
spellers need more opportunities to write. They need to find ways to bridge the gap between
explicit word-level spelling work and on-line reading and writing. There must be some text-
level spelling activities in each instructional session. Spelling instruction for a child would be
integrated within a plan that addresses the child’s profile of language abilities.
The Qualitative Inventory of Word Knowledge has been used by others in the field to
learn about students’ capabilities as spellers. Several commercial assessments were also
mentioned, such as the Diagnostic Spelling Test (Kottmeyer, 1970) and The Spellmaster
Assessment and Teaching System (Greenbaum, 1987). These assessments are used to measure
the spelling of phonetically regular words and structural spelling elements, as well as,
nonphonetic or irregular words. Another study used the Spelling subtest from the Wechsler
Kelly Kingsley Action Research Plan
Individual Achievement Test (Wechsler, 1992). I found that most of the studies used a word list
6
and performed a spelling pre-test and post-test format.
Initial Plan
My plan is to create a research supported integrated spelling program that will actively
involve my students in learning to spell words that they are reading and using in their writing.
My goal is to nurture children who will become readers, writers, thinkers, and who are not afraid
to spell.
Methodology
Will the integration of spelling in reading and writing increase the spelling abilities of my
third grade students? My construct is focusing in on spelling growth through the instruction of
Sample
Wake Robin Elementary School is located in Northeastern section of the city of Bellevue,
Nebraska. My third grade classroom usually consists of 20-22 third grade students, with about a
50/50 ratio of boys to girls. I commonly have a range of low to high achieving students in my
classroom each year. Most years I will have a very small sampling of special education students,
I will use a convenience sample using my third grade students. I will group my students
into average, below average, and above average groups. By using my whole class as my sample,
I will be able to stratify the data into gender groups, ability level groups, and by race if I so
desire.
Kelly Kingsley Action Research Plan
Measurements
7
I will administer the Words Their Way Elementary Spelling Inventory (Appendices A-C) in the
fall. The inventory surveys a range of features and I will be able to use the measurement
tool, so it is valid and reliable. The spelling inventory was also used in Developmental-
2004) and Using Children's Spellings to Group for Word Study and Directed Reading in
the Primary Classroom (Bear, Reading Psychology 1989). “Spelling inventories not only
offer information about students’ spelling stages and their knowledge of orthographic
features, but also offer information about their reading. Studies show that scores on these
inventories are consistently related and predict reading achievement at all age levels from
The Qualitative Spelling Inventory measurement will allow me to track growth over
time. The words on the list present a reliable scale of developmental word knowledge. Once the
developmental stage is determined, I will use the student profiles to group for instruction. I plan
to assess the students’ growth several times throughout the school year using the spelling
inventory. My plan is to use the inventory 4 times; the beginning and end of each semester. This
will give me four scores to help verify each child’s growth and developmental stage.
Unfortunately, using the same inventory this many times will familiarize my students with the
word list enough to inflate the results. This maybe something I will need to take a look at and
Students will also be given a weekly spelling dictation tests in both formats (traditional
and integrated in their respected groups). I will use the pre-test/post-test format, the traditional
Kelly Kingsley Action Research Plan
tests will use the spelling textbook words, the integrated format will use words from the Words
8
Their Way book and also irregular words from the Word Wall.
I will also be using the Words Their Way Qualitative Spelling Checklist (Appendix D) to
monitor students’ spelling in their writing. The checklist allows for identification of orthographic
features that my students have mastered, are using, or are still confused about. I’ll ask a
colleague to help with double scoring to increase the reliability of scores and to check that the
By using multiple measurements, I will be insuring that my students are identified to the
best of my ability for instruction and for reporting growth throughout the school year. Since
growth is what I am going to measure, I will need to be able to report it in a sound way.
Students’ independent writing samples will guide my instruction and will inform the
results for my research. Reflecting on my lessons in a journal format, will help to keep track of
strategies that were implemented, and which strategies were successful for each group.
Design
From the research I have read, I have learned that the teacher plays an important role in
increasing students’ interest in words and influencing their attitudes toward spelling (O’Sullivan,
2000). I will need to consider O’Sullivan’s characteristics of effective teachers of spelling: (1)
the teachers enthusiasm and excitement about words is crucial, (2) spelling skills are taught
through a combination of the writing process and explicit teaching approaches, (3) the teacher
helped children develop a variety of spelling strategies, (4) there was a greater focus on syntactic
and semantic features of words, (5) responses and interventions in writing reflected the teacher’s
ability to further support the child’s progress, (6) the analysis of the child’s spelling gave the
Kelly Kingsley Action Research Plan
teacher insight into the spelling process that helped them to identify the child’s strengths and
9
weaknesses the teacher could support and provide help, (7) the teacher collected a wide range of
spelling resources, (8) the teacher involved the children in contributing and discussing resources.
The individual teacher plays a significant role when identifying the needs of individual children
and they need to be able to translate these needs into class, group, and individual approaches.
I plan to implement an ABAB design, or alternating treatments design this fall. For the
first two weeks of school, I will use the Words Their Way Qualitative Spelling Inventories for
baseline measurement. I will then group my students according to the results of the Qualitative
Spelling Inventory. The next four weeks will be spent teaching spelling in a traditional format
using the Harcourt Trophies Third Grade Spelling series. I will pre-test the list words on
Monday and introduce the words to students. The list words will be taught through spelling
workbook pages and lessons from the teacher’s manual. On Friday, the post-test will be
The following four weeks will be spent instructing spelling by integrating the instruction
through reading and writing. I will administer the Words Their Way Qualitative Spelling
Inventory once again to help with modifying my instructional groups. Each group will be
working on word lists that were identified by their spelling inventory results. I will continue with
the pre-test on Monday format, but I will be using small group time to work with students on
specific orthographic patterns that are occurring in their writing, from the spelling inventory, or
that may be used in their reading texts. A post-test will be administered on Friday. Again, both
the pre-and post-test scores will be recorded. I intend to devote more time to students actually
writing in a purposeful manner. This is a great way for students to learn spelling in a very
Kelly Kingsley Action Research Plan
practical and meaningful way. They will be using words that they are familiar with and words
10
they want to include in their writing.
After the integrated intervention sessions, I will go back to the traditional method
for another four weeks, then follow with another four weeks of the integrated intervention.
I will analyze the design results at the end of the semester to check how the
measurement is working and to see if the intervention was successful. I will also look at the
results to see if there is data to support an answer to my question. If there is enough data to show
that the integrated method is a beneficial way of instructing spelling, then I will continue with
that form of instruction for the second semester. If I am not confident with the results, I will
I plan to administer the Qualitative Spelling Inventory again in January to help modify
my groups. The inventory will then be given in late April. I will use the data from all four
Spelling Inventories to show growth to parents and administrators and also quantify the
I intend to teach my students proofreading skills to use when they are writing, and I will
also teach them how to learn words and how to check spelling of words they have attempted.
Students will also be taught a range of strategies in order to internalize them and use them
I will also score my student’s writing two times in each four week period. I will use the
Words Their Way Qualitative Spelling Checklist (Appendix D) to verify what types of
orthographic features the students have mastered and what types of features they are using, but
Kelly Kingsley Action Research Plan
might be confusing. I will use the checklist to monitor the student’s progress through the
11
stages.
Procedure
I will get IRB approval for my research project this summer. I have already spoken to the
head of Elementary Education for Bellevue Public Schools, so I will email her a summary of my
research plan for approval. I will write a letter to parents regarding my plan for the fall semester
regarding spelling instruction and send it home with students the first week of school. The first
two weeks of school will be spent collecting baseline data. I will begin my plan the third week
of school. I will analyze my data at the end of first semester and will make decisions at that time
as to whether to continue with the ABAB format or to go with the integrated format for second
semester.
Timeline
Summer 2009
• Read research incorporating spelling instruction into guided reading groups and in
12
writing mini-lessons
• August 11, 2009 Write letter to parents regarding spelling research plan
• August 12-21, 2009 Collect baseline data by administering the Qualitative Spelling
Inventories
• August 24-September 18, 2009 Teach Spelling in a traditional format using the Harcourt
• Collect data from all students in my classroom which will include spelling pre- and post-
tests, student writing, error analysis results, and samples of student work
• September 21, 2009 Administer the second round of Qualitative Spelling Inventories
• September 22-October 16, 2009 Teach Spelling through the integration of reading and
writing using selected word lists and word wall words (irregular words)
Kelly Kingsley Action Research Plan
• Collect data from all students in my classroom, which will be grouped in three levels of
13
academic ability-above average, average, and below average. Data collected will include:
pretests/posttests, student writing, error analysis results, and samples of student work.
• October 19-November 13, 2009 Teach Spelling in a traditional format using the Harcourt
• Collect data from all students in my classroom which will include spelling pre- and post-
tests, student writing, error analysis results, and samples of student work
• November 16-December 11, 2009 Teach Spelling through the integration of reading and
writing using selected word lists and word wall words (irregular words)
• Collect data from all students in my classroom, which will be grouped in three levels of
academic ability-above average, average, and below average. Data collected will
include: pretests/posttests, student writing, error analysis results, and samples of student
work.
• December 18, 2009 Decide to continue ABAB design second semester or to use
• August 12-December 18, 2009 Keep a personal journal or blog to record teacher
• August 12-December 18, 2009 Continue reading current spelling related research
Kelly Kingsley Action Research Plan
Bibliography
14
Bear, D. R., Invernizzi, M., Templeton, S., & Johnston, F. (2008). Words Their Way;
Word Study for Phonics, Vocabulary, and Spelling Instruction. Upper Saddle
River, New Jersey: Pearson Education, Inc.
Graham, S., Harris, K., & Chorzempa, B. (2002). Contribution of Spelling Instruction to
the Spelling, Writing, and Reading of Poor Spellers. Journal of Educational
Psychology, 94, 669-686.
Appendix A
15
The 26 words are ordered by difficulty to sample features of the letter name-
alphabetic to within words pattern stages. Call out enough words so that you have
at least five or six misspelled words to analyze. If students spell more than 20
words correctly, you may want to use the Elementary Spelling Inventory.
13.coach The coach called the team off the field. coach
16.crawl You will get dirty if you crawl under the bed. crawl
20.spoil The food will spoil if it sits out too long. spoil
16
21.growl The dog will growl if you bother him. growl
26.riding They are riding their bikes to the park today. riding
Words Their Way: word Study for Phonics, Vocabulary, and Spelling Instruction ©2008 by Pearson Education, Inc.
Words Spelled Correctly: ____ / 26 Feature Points: ____ / 56 Total_______/ 82 Spelling Stage
_________________________________
Stages and Emergent Letter Within Word Syllabl
gradations Name - Alphabetic Pattern es &
→ Affixes
Late Early Middle Early Middle Words
Late LateKelly Kingsley Action Research
Featur SpellePlan
e d
Features → Beginni Final Short Digrap Blends Long Other Inflected Points Corre
ng Vowels hs Vowel ctly
↓Words Conson Vowels Endings 17
Conson ants Pattern
ants s
f n a
1. fan
p t e
2. pet
d g i
3. dig
r b o
4. rob
h p o-e
5. hope
w t ai
6. wait
g m u
7. gum
e sl
8. sled
i st
9. stick
sh i-e
10. shine
dr ea
11. dream
bl a-e
12. blade
-ch oa
13. coach
fr igh
14. fright
ch ew -ed
15. chewed
cr aw
16. crawl
Kelly Kingsley Action Research Plan
18
Appendix B
The 25 words are ordered by difficulty to sample features of the letter name-
alphabetic to derivational relations stages. Call out enough words so that you have 19
at least five or six misspelled words to analyze. If students spell more than 20
words correctly, use the Upper Level Spelling Inventory.
17.bottle The bottle broke into pieces on the tile floor. bottle
18.favor He did his brother a favor by taking out the trash. favor
19.ripen The fruit will ripen over the next few days. ripen
20.cellar I went down to the cellar for the can of paint. cellar
Words Their Way: word Study for Phonics, Vocabulary, and Spelling Instruction ©2008 by Pearson Education, Inc
Words Spelled Correctly: ____ / 25 Feature Points: ____ / 62 Total_______/ 87 Spelling Stage
_________________________________
Stages Emergent Within Word Syllables and Derivationa
and Letter Name Pattern Affixes l Relations
Fea
gradation Wor
Late Early Early Middle Early Middle Early tur
s →
Middle Late Late
Kelly
Late
Kingsley Action
Middle
Research
e
ds Plan
Spel
Poi
Conson Sh Digr Ble Long Othe Infle Syll Unac Harder Bas nts led
Features
ants ort aph nds r cted able cente Suffixe es Corr
→ 21
Vo s Vowel d s or ectl
Begin. wel s Vow Endi Junc Final Roo y
↓Words
Final s els ngs ture Syllab ts
s les
1. bed b d e
2. ship p i sh
3. e wh
when
4. l u mp
lump
5. float t fl oa
6. train n tr ai
7. pl a-e
place
8. v dr i-e
drive
9. br igh
bright
10. o sh ppi
shoppin ng
g
11. sp oi
spoil
12. er vin
serving g
13. ch ew ed
chewed
14. ar ies rr
carries
15. ch ar ed
marche
d
16. sh ow er
shower
17. tt le
bottle
Kelly Kingsley Action Research Plan
22
Appendix C
The 31 words are ordered by difficulty to sample features of the within word
pattern to derivational relations to spelling stages. You may want to stop
when students misspell more than eight words and are experiencing
noticeable frustration. If students misspell five of the first eight words, use
the ESI to more accurately identify within word pattern features that need
instruction.
3. trapped He was trapped in the elevator when the electricity went off.
trapped
7. squirt Don’t let the ketchup squirt out of the bottle too fast.
squirt
10.crater The crater of the volcano was filled with bubbling lava.
crater
17.fortunate The driver was fortunate to have snow tires on that winter day.
fortunate
circumference
dominance
27.chlorine My eyes were burning from the chlorine in the swimming pool.
chlorine 24
Words Their Way: word Study for Phonics, Vocabulary, and Spelling Instruction ©2008 by Pearson
Education, Inc.
Words Spelled Correctly: ___ / 31 Feature Points: ___ / 68 Total____/ 99 Spelling Stage ____________________
1. switch sw i tch
2. smudge sm u dge
3. trapped tr pp
5. knotted o kn tt
6. shaving sh e-drop
Kelly Kingsley Action Research Plan
7. squirt ir squ
25
8. pounce ou ce
9.
scratches a tch es
10. crater cr t er
11. sailor ai or
13.
disloyal oy al dis
14. tunnel nn el
15. humor m or
16.
confidenc
e con fid
17. fortu
fortunate ate n
19.
circumfer enc circu
ence e m
20.
civilization liz civil
21.
monarchy arch
22.
dominanc anc
e e min
23.
correspon
d res rr
24.
illiterate ate ll
Kelly Kingsley Action Research Plan
56.
emphasiz 26
e size pha
26.
opposition pos pp
27.
chlorine ine chlor
28.
commotio
n tion mm
29. medi
medicinal al c
30.
irresponsi
ble ible res rr
31.
successio
n sion cc
Totals
/5 /9 /7 /8 /9 /10 /7 /7 /6 /68 / 31
Appendix D
Kelly Kingsley Action Research Plan
27