Professional Documents
Culture Documents
'
93
94
the Hispanic Society of America, now on loan with The American Numismatic Society.
It is quite obvious that any attempt to assign mints to the
dinars lacking mint-names must be based upon a large mass of
material either examined at first hand or eise accurately described or reproduced in the Hterature. A cursory study of the
subject is enough to convince one that many, perhaps the
majority, of the published "mintless" dinars have not been accurately described or reproducedthat is, the minute details
upon which arguments and conclusions must rest have not, in
general, been conscientiously reported, M. Jungfleisch appropriately draws attention to this fact. My good fortune, above
referred to, imposes upon me the prime Obligation of placing before the Student this important body of material. While I doubt
that any definitive conclusions can be reached before a great
many more dinars have been accurately described,3 I have in
preparation for publication a detailed summary of the reliable
material heretofore published, together with specific arguments
for the attribution of over 100 of the 279 varieties of 'Abbsid
"mintless" dinars which I have been able to distinguish. These
attributions (many of them quite tentative) are limited to the
dinars issued after the year 169 A.H.; in other words I have at-.
tacked the problem at the easier and more vulnerable end, for
in the last 30 years of the second, rfnd the first two decades of
the third centuries of the Hijrah, before mint-names begin to
appear regularly on the 'Abbsid dinars, there are many more
3 How greatly simplified the problem would be if provenance and hoards were recorded.
Consider, for example, the Baghdad hoard of 30,000 (?) dinars which came to light on
the banks of the Tigris in 1897, a part of which is apparently still preserved unpublished
in the Istanbul Museum (cf. E.V. Zambaur in his obituary of Halil Edhem, Mitteilungen
derNum. Gesellschaft in Wien, II (XVIII), 7,1940, p. 131). These were mostly 'Abbsid
dinars of later date, but there may have been earlier ones among them. In any case, here
is an example of unpublished material which puts what has so far been described in the
shade. Anotherexample is the great Ermitage collection which has been inventoried only
in the most summary fashion.
95
clues for attribution than there are in the earlier period. My intention in thus working backwards, so to speak, is to provide a
firm basis for further study and for the eventual determination
of criteria for the attribution of the earlier issues.4
It is my hope that the present article may induce readers to
re-examine the pertinent dinars in their possession or under their
care, and to publish, or otherwise make available, their fmdings.
With such additional material I might anticipate making the
study I have referred to a more useful one than it would otherwise be.5 In preparing this publication I have taken into consideration over nine hundred dinars published in the scattered
numismatic literature in addition to those described in the present article. This might appear to be an impressive number; but
the figure is deceptive, for although I have excluded many whose
descriptions are obviously incomplete or faulty, I have also probably included a very considerable number which should for the
same reason, in a lesser degree, have been excluded.6 It can, ,=
therefore, be readily appreciated that the accretion of additional
completely reliable evidence cannot fail to have a favorable effect
on the study and its conclusions.
Herewith the list of dinars in the three collections referred
+ A detailed examination of M. Jungfleisch's arguments, with which I fear I cannot
wholly agree, will appear in its proper place. In brief, he is disposed to see in certain of
the "secret points" indicators of the initial lettersof the names of the mints at which given
dinars were struck. He confesses that "les deductions . . . comportent encore une bonne
part d'hypothese." Particulars aside, I feel that a much larger body of evidence must be
assembled and that the argument must be built, s I say, upon a more secure foundation;
and it is for these reasons that I am approaching the problem in the present fashion.
s I would welcome and gratefully acknowledge descriptions, casts or photographs forwarded to me at the Museum of The American Numismatic Society. By "the pertinent
dinars" I mean all Umayyad dinars of the reformed type and 'Abbsid dinars, including
those bearing mint-names, down through the reign of al-M*mn (a;8 A.H.). Weights
would of course be desirable,and descriptions should include referenceto points, Symbols,
and other peculiarities.
6 Except when a writer has proved himself to be consistently conscientious, it is, for example, difficult or impossible to determine whether all the points and peculiarities have
been described.
96
A, N. S. Museum Notes
to. I have carried the inventory down through the reign of alM'mn, and have included the dinars with mint-names s
they have an important bearing on the attribution of the earlier
or contemporaneous dinars. UM=University Museum, Philadelphia; ANS=American Numismatic Society (MMA=permanent loan from the Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York);
HSAHispariic Society of America, New York. Weights are in
grams, diameters in millimeters. Where there is no description
there is an absence of points or of other special characteristics.
Those coins which are illustrated are indicated by an asterisk.
GEORGE C. MILES
79
79
79
80
m.
4-35
4.21
4.19
4.17
4.26
4.16
4.13
4.19
4.25
3-78
4.21
4.24
4.18
4.17
4.29
80
pierced
4.25
I9
80
80
80
81
4.14
4.14
4.20
4.19
19
19
19
19
81
4.20
19
Date
No date
77
78
78
78
78
78
79
79
79
79
DL
20
Obverse
Reverse
Type of Paris I, no. 26; Berlin I, no. 21 5
Coliectton
UM
UM
UM
20
20
20
19
ANS (Wood)
ANS (Newell)
HSA 537
HSA 539
19-5
19-5
20
19.5
UM
19.5
ANS (Newell)
ANS (MMA-
I9
ANS (MMA-
Durkee)
20
2O
19
20
Durkee)
HSA 536
HSA 538
HSA 544
UM
-' This point is in all probabity a die-cutter's centering point; but s it quite frequently lies somewhat off center with respect to the die itself and might just
possibly have some significance, I have rendered its exact posion with reference to the letters of the word ahaon the first line and those of the word cd-samad
on the second.
N.
Date
*22
23
82
83
Wt.
4.19
4.19
Di.
19
'9
24
84
4.17
19
*25
84
4-25
IQ
26
27
*28
*29
85
IQ
86
86
87
*3o
88
4-23
4.19
4.20
4-23
pierced
4.18
31
88
4-23
2O
*32
89
4.20
2O
33
89
4.27
2O
34
89
4-23
19-5
*35
37
90
90
90
4.26
4.24
4.19
20
*38
91
4-23
19.5
i
SV f
40
*4i
Obverse
Reverse
Collection
: beneath ist letter of ylad.
UM
: beneath ist letter of ylad midway between it UM
and n of al-dlnar.
: beneath ist letter of ylad midway between it UM
and d of al-dlnar.
: beneath ist letter of ylad midway between it HSA 543
and i of al-dlnar.
,
19.5
19
19.5
2O
19.5
19
UM
t- 5
UM
19
ANS (MMA-
;t
>
+.4
9'
pierced
4-22
91
2.12
UM
UM
ANS
UM
J5
i 4)1 v
'
IM V
4| ^
_i>J1
A-S-jJ|
Margin to al-haqq.
*42
91
1.02
14.5
\1 V
pierced
4jJi v
43
91
1.42
44
92
4.10
i9-5
*45
92
4.24
20
*46
92
*47
92
2.29
ringed
1.42
48
93
4.20
49
50
94
94
51
94
4.22
4.18
fitted for ring
4.18
15-5
As no. 41.
As no. 42.
As no. 42.
19.5
20
20
2O.5
ANS (Greenwood)
UM
*.
ANS (Starosselsky)
HSA 13157
m.
*52
Date
94
1.43
Di.
13-5
As no. 42.
53
94
1.07
12
As no. 42.
54
56
95
96
96
57
96
58
96
59
60
61
62
96
97
x/
97
x/
98
*6\j3
*64
99
99
Ne.
4.21
4.19
4.15
Collection
Reverse
UM
Area s no. 4 1 without pellet.
Margin: <>*~ gj\* 1^1 )-** ->.>
ANS (Newell)
Area s no. 41 without pellet.
Margin: (V)ji^-"j jl - MSM 1-i -o^
Despitethedenomination thulth(Y3 ),the weight
is that of % .
Obverse
UM
UM
2O
2O
20
ANS (Nies)
pierced
65
66
I6.5
As no. 41.
1.57
14.5
As no. 42.
->.
As no. 42.
rin.ged
1.44
4-23
4.16
4.18
pierced
4.29
1-45
1.42
4.22
99
IOO
IOO
*67
2. II
2.IO
pierced
H
21
2O.5
20-5
ANS (Newell)
Area s no. 41.
Margin: <j-*~ c i- d*dl l-i* o>>
Despitethe denominationM/M (yz ), the weight
is that of %.
UM
Area s no. 41 without pellet.
Margir s no. 57.
ANS (Newell) .
As no. 58.
UM
HSA 13158
Pt. under beginning of b of duriba.
UM
Pt. under beginning of b of duriba.
UM
Area s no. 41 without pellet.
Margin: (j^uJ^ *-uJ L~ slUJ| I-XA <^j*>
UM
As no. 64.
C(
UM
Pt. under first third of b of tfuriba.
Area s no. 41. Pt. above and after h of al- UM
2O.5
13-5
H
20
15
UM
As no. 42.
As no. 42.
As no. 41.
rahman.
IOO
69
IOO
7O
IOI
71
102
*'
I-I4
twice pierced
ringed & encased
4.16
pierced
A M. 42.
man.
20.^
2O
13
Mint
m.
As no. 42.
*72
IO2
Al-Andalus
4-30
Di.
Obverse
20
As no. 41.
*73
IO2 Al-Andalus
2.12
*74
IO2
Al-Andalus
1.43
75
IO2
Al-Andalus
1.43
15
*76
103
4.21
20
77
78
103
103
4.12
4.29
19.5
No. Date
Al-Andalus
19
UM
Reverse
Collection
Area s no. 41, without pellet beneath. Pel- HSA 13159
let (apparently) above m of bism.
Margin :
Area s no. 41.
Margin:
HSA 13161
beginning of b of duriba.
As no. 76.
HSA 14067
Area s no. 41 without pellet. Pt. between HSA 13211
h and m of al-rahman.
*79
103
W.
i-43
Obverse
Di.
12.5 As no. 42.
80
103
1.42
81
103
1.44
'3
82
104
*83
105
3-'7
clipped
4.20
Mint
No. Date
4.16
As no. 42.
18.5
19.5
20
mu 'minin bi'IHijz
No.
Date
Wt.
Di
86
85
106
107
4.21
4.19
19.5
19-5
UM
: beneath first letter ofylad midway between UM
87
*88
107
108
4.19
4.22
20
20
89
109
3-98
19.5
90
109
4.20
19.5
ANS (Starosselsky)
Central pt. over d of al-^amad. : beneath first UM
letter ofy/ad midway" between it and J of
al-dinar.
Central pt. over space between m and d of al- UM
famad.
As no. 89.
ANS
1 tO
4-3
HO
4.08
24
III
4.21
4.21
19-5
19.5
19.5
19-5
'92
93
94
95
96
97
*g8
99
IOO
Reverse
Collection
Area s no. 42; Pt. above and after h of al~ UM
rahman.
Margin: !Uj siJ>* l- JliJ| IOA o^-
As no. 79.
ANS (MMAMills and Farman)
As no. 79.
ANS (MMAMills and Farman)
Pt. under space between r and of duriba. UM
IOI
IO2
103
104
105
112
"3
114
115
116
117
118
119
119
I2O
I2O
121
106
*io7
121
122
108
109
HO
122
123
124
III
124
3-99
4.21
4.20
4.20
4.20
4-37
20
19.5
20
19.5
3-72
19
19-5
20
2O
20
4.24
4.20
4.60
ringed
4.20
19.5
19.5
2O
20
20
2O
Obverse
Reverse
Collection
i t and d of al-dinar.
w ritten U M
'ashr.
Ten written lashrah. In size, weight, fabric ANS
and style this dinar is atypical. It is possibly
a contemporary forgery, but more probably
the issue of some temporary mint.
Digit written ^n*l
UM
UM
UM
UM
UM
UM
UM
UM
UM
ANS (Newell)
UM
ANS (Newell)
UM
HSA 10625
Central pt. between w Central pt. partly obscured by d of al-$amad. UM
and h, second line of Digit written ^llf
area.
ANS
Digit written s above.
UM
Central pt. over d of al-samad.
As no. 107.
UM
'
ANS (Newell)
116
117
*n8
Date
125
125
125
126
128
129
130
Wt.
4.19
4.20
4.20
4.15
3-89
3.87
4.24
Dl.
Obverse
19.5
19-5 As no. 107.
19-5
As no. 107.
20
19
19.5
18.5
HSA 10626
UM
UM
Pt. under beginning of b of tfuriba.
UM
Two central pts., one over m, one over of al- UM
119
'31
4.14
20
jamad.
Central pt. over d of a/-famad(l).
UM
UM
No.
112
"3
114
115
*I2O
132
pierced
4.20
19.5
Reverse
Collection
UM
ANS (Newell)
As no. 109.
'ABBSID
*I
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
132
133
134
4.25
4.00
4.19
4.20
19-5
19
19
19
'
135
136
'36
'37
3-95
4.22
4.17
4-34
18
18
19
19
*9
138
ringed
4-23
*IO
I7Q
O7
4.21
T
ii
12
lJ
15
16
17
18
19
20
139
I4O
4.18
3-i6
cln*1^*1
4
I42
+.J
4.2O
143
4-20
144
4.12
144
4-22
H5
3-9*
146
pierced
4.19
4.17
146
25
26
27
150
3-99
4.00
4.19
4.19
18.5
l8.5
19.5
l8.5
19
28
152
4.22
I8.5
29
152
4.19
4.01
4.20
4.10
4.00
19.5
3-3
16.5
34
155
35
156
clipped
4.16
pierced
UM
18
18
149
154
23
24
J 53
ANS (Newell)
UM
9
l8.5
IQ7
19
As no, 21.
As no. 21.
As no. 21.
18
19
18.5 Pt. over h of ilafya.
19
UM
3-79
'53
UM
18
19
148
3
31
*32
33
UM
^ ,
T 4:7
152
Durkee;
UM
UM
'
ANS (Newell)
17.5
/ j
18.5
7
*2_L
22
150
"'
18
UM
UM
UM
ANS (MMA-
UM
UM
UM
UM
UM
UM
ANS (Wyman)
UM
Pt. after rasl under space between a and / of UM
al-dinar.
Pt. after rasl under a of al-dinar.
UM
UM
ANS (Wood)
ANS (Newell)
Pt. after rasl under space between dh and a UM
of hadha. Digit written {yZ*
Pt. after rasl under a of hadha. Digit written ANS (Newell)
s above.
ANS (Newell)
Digit written <j^*l
UM
ANS (Newell)
Pt. after rasl under a of al-dinar.
ANS (Wood)
Pt. under / of rasl.
Pt. after rasl under space between hadha anc UM
al-.
UM
Pt. after rasl under dh of hadha.
Pt. after rasl under space between a and / o UM
al-.
No.
*3
37
Wt.
4.20
Date
156
157
3.85
clipped
Di.
19-5
4.20
4.20
3.87
4.05
4.22
*43
160
4.14
44
161
4-15
45
161
4.21
46
162
4.14
47
162
4.22
48
163
4.22
49
163
4>2O
50
164
17
#_ .
3-45
clipped
164.
*"T
4..2I
T"*
IQ
*7
52
*^
06
I65
4.15
19
00
4 ,j.\j
IQ
*7
100
'
j.*o
cJlpIH.il
55
56
166
167
4.19
18.5
20
*57
167
4.12
18.5
*58
167
3^5
18.5
59
168
4-15
20
*6o
168
; *6i
62
168
169
63
4.15
Collection
ANS (Newell)
UM
19
'57
158
158
159
*54
Reverse
Pt. after rasl under / of al-dlnar.
'9
38
*39
40
41
42
157
Obverse
'
UM
ANS (Newell)
UM
UM
UM
ANS (Newell)
UM
ANS (Newell) '
UM
ANS (Newell)
Pt
imHfM- A rf /7*-A/7*
UM
Pt
ANS (Newell)
UM
ANS (MMA
~
f*l. III IlMklftllt llri *-
ANS (Torrey)
ANS (Newell)
Ourkc-)
l-l. -. ,~.M/u...t.r /ufW-W.^. l-t. M,~W-, v,-. U M
ter of rasl.
sl under h of allh.
ANS (Newell)
in margin after ra- 3t. after rasl under a of al-dlnar.
sl under 2nd / of al-
3t.
UM
lh.
UM
j->
^
Pellet between 2nd and 3rd line. Pt. UM
under b of sab1.
UM
Pt. in margin after ra- Pt. after rasl under a of al-dlnar.
~Sttt UTItter flCr / dTT?
Iah.
4.20
2O
4-22
19
4-20
19
169
4.19
l8.5
64
169
4.l8
19.5
65
66
67
169
170
170
4.19
20
4.13
19
9
Pt. in margin after ra- Pt. over r of al-dlnar. Pt. after rasl under a ANS (Newell)
sl under 2nd / of al- of al-dlnar.
lh.
4.12
ANS (Newell)
Pt. over r of li-yuzhi- Pt. under b of tfuriba. Pt. under last tooth of s UM
oftisa1.
rahu.
Pt. in margin after ra- Pt. under b of duriba. Pt. under last tooth of s UM
sl under h of allh. oftisa'.
Pt. over r of li-yuzhirahu.
Pt. in margin after ra- Pt. under b of duriba. Pt. under last tooth of s ANS (Newell)
sl under h of allh. of tisa'.
Pt. over r of li-yuzhirahu.
ANS (Newell)
-
UM
UM
No.
Date
*68
69
170
171
*7o
171
m.
4.22
4.21
19
18.5
3-99
18
'7-5
Di.
Obverse
Reverse
->L-1
172
3-86
72
*73
172
clipped
4.17
4.20
74
4.22
4-15
4.18
18
18
4-15
18
75
'o
76
'73
'73
174
*77
'74
TT
18
79
80
*8i
I75
177
177
3-85
4-23
4.20
18.5
18.5
82
*#3
177
177
4-03
3-65
18
18
4 IQ
*v
18
t 0*>
4-*
7-5
87
I79
4.2O
19
I79
o
180
3-79
4.20
I8.5
19
91
181
182
4.20
4-17
18
18
4-13
Qt
182
187
19.5
18
94
95
183
r\4
4.05
4-17
18
96
97
98
184
184
185
99
185
IOO
101
185
186
*I02
pierced
186
*iO4
3.85
4.20
4.09
4.04
pierced
4.00
4-17
pierced
186
3-59
clipped
4.19
187
4-03
O /*
ANS (Newell)
ANS (Newell)
UM
,+.
UM
3j'3
'">!
UM
19
UM
UM
UM
UM
rvpr nf t^/rmti
UJW
7V
90
UM
UM
18
88
O
89
UM
18.5
4.00
"
18
^75
178
1/
i ?
UM
&*y
18.5
78
84.
T
ANS (Newell)
ANS (Newell)
nrW A o f / / v W A / 7 ^ ? ^
tr*
clipped
71
Pt
Collection
"
- Tl .
k
VI IV 1
iC
ANS (MMADurkee)
UM
TTM
U IVl
"
UM
UM
ANS
TTM
\J IVi
19
18
UM
UM
UM
19
UM
ANS (Newell)
II'5
TM
r iVl
U
>^
7
i9-5
18
Di.
4.22
I8.5
187
188
189
4.10
I8.5
I8.5
I8.5
4.10
4.16
3-63
17-5
in
190
190
190
112
191
4.06
18
"asr
4.20
4.10
19
18
"
114
192
192
18
116
i93
194
4.00
4-15
,8 , -,
1,7
194
3.80
19
106
108
109
*IIO
"5
3-90
4.11
Collection
Reverse
Wt.
Date
187
No.
Obverse
UM
3t.
UM
UM
UM
over n of thamn.
UM
ANS (Newell)
UM
18
'7
4.
UM
UM
UM
UM
"ssr
UM
-S3T
UM
^ 1
4.17
194
*ii8
ANS
W J
IQ
^>\t 1
*ii9
,ao
,5
I9S
4.09
18
3-77^
18.5
1.76
picrccd
10
196
3-70
18
*I23
196
4.10
18
*I24
196
4.24
17. <r
lai
IO
122
^utJwJU
UM
o-V
UM
^Jf/
*^ c^-
UM
^i ^J
UM
v
ANS (Starosselsky)
*U
UM
f^VI
*I2<?
106
<aJUU
18
4..2?
*I26
196
3-72
*I27
IQ7
4.. 2O
17
c
* /O
*I28
108
18
No.
129
Date
198
*i3o
199
jL*
"
. ,. ... P*". M'i'lfr b
^
Mint
UM
03-Vll
Di.
18
4.15
19.5
<<JbJj
UM
Obverse
Reverse
4
JI^Jl
.,
. ,
199
3-30
Collection
ANS (Starosselsky)
ANS (Newell)
IVIarp'in hcfins*
<j~"".j>i 3*
. . . . ^J]
131
^J]
4JJ| ^
17-5 Final letter of bil- .,,, *:1 1 1 Decade clearly* xvritten /****
v^*' * j)
o^ui
hud is free-stancling bar in Held.
UM
UM
^U)
fUyi
^Ul
u-iLl
Wt.
4.07
ANS
No.
132
'33
*i34
Date
199
199
Misr
Misr
4.12
pierced
3-68
Misr
2O I
*i38
Obverse
18
vjlkl
17
Reverse
Collection
&~\>J\
J-l
11
UM
UM
3-85
UM
4-13
18
UM
19.5
3-75
i.7-
3-72
18
3.86
20
Misr
2O 2
c^l
4.07
pierced
201
2O I
Di.
4JJ
200
2OO
136
Wt.
Mmt
JbM
t
_ Marein
bfrins
s no. T"?o.
*-^
^
*'
^a^
UM
UM
(^-*J 1
ANS (Starossel-'
sky)
et
written ^lal
*i39
4.20
202
18
UM
o>l!
^'i -Ji,!-!
140
203
4- 7
18
*i 4 i
203
4-15
20
*I42
203
*H3
203
14^20^
Misr
4.10
17-5
346
17-5
4.2J.
_ji8
*JJ
jun
R/r
UM
4J
l^\ 1) .3
ANS (Newell)
0-
UM
>.
J^*
ANS
, ^bU, <tf
0^iii
Tcj-Jl
____._
T T1V jT
Oxv.1
of al-Sarl.
145
204
146
204
*I47
205
148
205
Misr
4.04
Misr
pierced
4.20
4.11
pierced
346
18
18
19-5
^AU <U
"
UM
tfv-JI
ANS (Newell)
(C
UM
18
ANS
C5*.-^VI
149
2O6
4.24
JbJjJ
18
^j-J| /. 4J| A-,iP
150
207
4-15
18.5
151
207
4.05
18
(t
UM
**U|
UM
jV^rirpfln
Onr'nn T^T T -r
UM
No.
Date
152
208
Mint
m.
Di.
4.14
19
*'53
209
Misr
4.01
17.5
*i54
210
Misr
4.19
17-5
*IS5
156
211
212
4.19
4.01
17
17-5
*i57
213
4.07
18
Obverse
Reverse
4&J
e J| %i 4$\
Collectton
..
Itl
UM
UM
UM
ANS (Newell)
UM
UM
*i58
*i59
160
161
162
214
Misr
4.19
215
Misr
Misr
Misr
Misr
4.11
4.16
4.18
3-87
216
217
218
UM
UM
ANS (Newell)
UM
. N. S. MUSEUM NOTES
UMAYYAD DINARS
P3LTE XVII
A. N. S. MUSEUM NOTES
PLATE XVIII
51
UMAYYAD DINARS: 78-120 'ABBSID DINARS: 1-51
A. N. S. MUSEUM NOTES
'ABBSID DINARS
PLATE XIX
A. N. S. MUSEUM NOTES
PLATE XX
'ABBASID DINARS
A. N. S. MUSEUM NOTES
'ABBASID DINARS
PLATE XXI