Welcome to Scribd. Sign in or start your free trial to enjoy unlimited e-books, audiobooks & documents.Find out more
Download
Standard view
Full view
of .
Look up keyword
Like this
8Activity
P. 1
Electronic Reverse Auction and the Public Sector: Factors of Success; Moshe E. Shalev & Stee Asbjorensen

Electronic Reverse Auction and the Public Sector: Factors of Success; Moshe E. Shalev & Stee Asbjorensen

Ratings:

5.0

(1)
|Views: 2,622|Likes:
Published by almeda777
Electronic reverse auctions (e-RAs) provide purchasers with an opportunity for greater saving, transparency and administrative benefits. This paper reviews the literature, identifying the factors relevant to public sector e-RA success, and then tests these factors through a statistical analysis of a large sample of e-RAs, with a view towards providing guidance to public sector purchasers looking to conduct e-RAs. Our research found no correlation between e-RA success and the number of bidders or auction volume, but correlation between e-RA success and each of competition among suppliers, purchase complexity and purchase specification. The number of bidders was found to be correlated with competition among suppliers, specification and complexity. Auction volume was found to be correlated with none of the factors. We discuss the possible explanations for our results and draw conclusions for public sector procurement managers to consider when deciding whether to conduct an e-RA for a particular purchase.
Electronic reverse auctions (e-RAs) provide purchasers with an opportunity for greater saving, transparency and administrative benefits. This paper reviews the literature, identifying the factors relevant to public sector e-RA success, and then tests these factors through a statistical analysis of a large sample of e-RAs, with a view towards providing guidance to public sector purchasers looking to conduct e-RAs. Our research found no correlation between e-RA success and the number of bidders or auction volume, but correlation between e-RA success and each of competition among suppliers, purchase complexity and purchase specification. The number of bidders was found to be correlated with competition among suppliers, specification and complexity. Auction volume was found to be correlated with none of the factors. We discuss the possible explanations for our results and draw conclusions for public sector procurement managers to consider when deciding whether to conduct an e-RA for a particular purchase.

More info:

Published by: almeda777 on Oct 10, 2010
Copyright:Attribution Non-commercial

Availability:

Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as PDF or read online from Scribd
See more
See less

07/11/2013

pdf

 
 MF\QIDJ FB S\AJON SQFN\QLKLIU* RFJ\KL 43* O^^\L >* 518+5<1 BDJJ 1343
 LJLNUQFION QLRLQ^L D\NUOFI^ DIE UHL S\AJON ^LNUFQ=BDNUFQ^ FB ^\NNL^^
Kf~hl L) ^hdjlr die ^ull D~amfqi~li-
DA^UQDNU
)
 
Ljlnuqfion qlrlq~l d|nuofi~ (lQD~/ sqfroel s|qnhd~lq~ wouh difssfqu|iouy bfq gqldulq ~droig~* uqdi~sdqliny die dekoio~uqduorl alilbou~)Uho~ sdslq qlrolw~ uhl joulqdu|ql* oeliuobyoig uhl bdnufq~ qljlrdiu uf s|ajon~lnufq lQD ~|nnl~~* die uhli ul~u~ uhl~l bdnufq~ uhqf|gh d ~uduo~uondjdidjy~o~ fb d jdqgl ~dksjl fb lQD~* wouh d rolw ufwdqe~ sqfroeoig g|oedinl uf s|ajon ~lnufq s|qnhd~lq~ jff`oig uf nfie|nu lQD~) F|q ql~ldqnh bf|ie ifnfqqljduofi aluwlli lQD ~|nnl~~ die uhl i|kalq fb aoeelq~ fq d|nuofirfj|kl* a|u eoe boie nfqqljduofi aluwlli lQD ~|nnl~~ die (4/ nfksluouofidkfig ~|ssjolq~* (1/ s|qnhd~l nfksjlxouy* die (>/ s|qnhd~l ~slnobonduofi)Uhl i|kalq fb aoeelq~ wd~ bf|ie uf al nfqqljdule wouh nfksluouofi dkfig ~|ssjolq~* ~slnobonduofi die nfksjlxouy) D|nuofi rfj|kl wd~ bf|ie uf alnfqqljdule wouh ifil fb uhl bdnufq~) Wl eo~n|~~ uhl sf~~oajl lxsjdiduofi~ bfqf|q ql~|ju~ die eqdw nfinj|~ofi~ bfq s|ajon ~lnufq sqfn|qlkliu kdidglq~ ufnfi~oelq whli elnoeoig whluhlq uf nfie|nu di lQD bfq d sdquon|jdqs|qnhd~l)
 OIUQFE\NUOFI
Oiuqfe|nle e|qoig uhl 4??3~* ljlnuqfion qlrlq~l d|nuofi~ (lQD~/hdrl gqfwi sfs|jdq oi uhl a|~oil~~ufa|~oil~~ (A1A/ diegfrlqikliu sqfn|qlkliu nfkk|iouol~) Uhl |~l fb lQD~ hd~oinqld~le oi afuh qljduorl die da~fj|ul ulqk~ frlq uokl* diesqdnuouofilq~ lxslnu uho~ uqlie uf nfiuoi|l (Mds* 13310 Aldjj lu dj)*133>0 @d|bkdii " Ndqulq* 13350 ^nhflihlqq " Kdalqu* 1337/)Elrljfsle nf|iuqy gfrlqikliu~* oinj|eoig D|~uqdjod* Ndided*Bqdinl* @fqld* Sfqu|gdj* uhl \ioule @oigefk die uhl \ioule ^udul~*-
Kf~hl L) ^hdjlr* JJK* KAD* die ^ull D~amfqi~li* AD* JJA* dql uhlNfiuqdnu~ Fbbonlq* die di D~~fnodul Sqfn|qlkliu Fbbonlq* ql~slnuorljy*\ioule Iduofi~ ^lnqludqodu Sqfn|qlkliu Eoro~ofi* Ilw _fq`)
Nfsyqoghu ¯ 1343 ay SqDndelkon~ Sql~~
 
 
LJLNUQFION QLRLQ^L D\NUOFI^ DIE UHL S\AJON ^LNUFQ= BDNUFQ^ FB ^\NNL^^ 51?
die kdiy elrljfsoig nf|iuqy gfrlqikliu~ ~|nh d~ Aqd}oj* Nhojl*Nhoid* Nfjfkaod* Ln|defq* L~ufiod* Sdidkd* Sdqdg|dy die Slq|*dkfig fuhlq~* d~ wljj d~ uhf|~die~ fb sqordul ~lnufq fqgdio}duofi~~|nh d~ Glilqdj Ljlnuqon* AKW* Il~ujï die @okalqjyNjdq`l* djqldeykd`l lxuli~orl |~l fb lQD~) Bfq lxdksjl* uhl \ioule@oigefkFbbonl fb Gfrlqikliu Nfkklqnl PFGN[ qlsfqule ~droig~ fb ®<3kojjofi oi OU hdqewdql lQD~ frlq bf|q yldq~* die diuonosduoig ufudj~droig~ fb ®173 kojjofi uhqf|gh djj lQD s|qnhd~l~ ay uhl lie fb bo~ndj yldq 1344&1341 (FGN* 1343/* whojl Glilqdj Ljlnuqon njdokle ufhdrl ~drle %233 kojjofi* fq 8, fb uhloq ~slieoig* uhqf|gh lQD~ oi1334 (^dwhily* 133>/)Oi di lQD* ~|ssjolq~ nfkslul eyidkondjjy fijoil dgdoi~u ldnhfuhlq uf fbblq uhl jfwl~u sqonl* ql~|juoig oi gqldulq ~droig~ uf uhla|ylq) ^oinl uhl liuoql sqfnl~~ hdssli~ fijoil* ou o~ dj~f fbuli bd~ulqdie kfql uqdi~sdqliu uhdi uqdeouofidj sqfn|qlkliu kluhfe~)Hfwlrlq* ifu djj lQD~ dql ~|nnl~~b|j oi dnholroig ~droig~ bfq a|ylq~*die ~|ssjolq~ hdrl dj~f nfksjdoile uhdu uhl lQD~ ogifql sqfe|nuoiifrduofi die t|djouy)Uhl lxo~uoig joulqdu|ql fi lQD~ bfn|~l~ sqokdqojy fi uhl sqordul~lnufq* die jouujl ql~ldqnh hd~ alli nfie|nule fi uhl bdnufq~ uhdujlde uf ~|nnl~~b|j lQD~ oi uhl s|ajon ~lnufq) Uho~ o~ el~soul uhl bdnu uhdu uhl s|ajon ~lnufq d~ d whfjl o~ uhl aoggl~u ~oigjl a|ylq oi diynf|iuqy (Joie~`fg* 1338/* die o~ l~uokdule uf nfi~uou|uldssqfxokduljy 4<, fb wfqjewoel GES fi drlqdgl die daf|u 13, oi~fkl FLNE nf|iuqol~ (Fqgdio~duofi bfq Lnfifkon Nffslqduofi dieElrljfskliu* 1338/) Wdgilq die ^nhwda (1335/ ifule uhdu uhlkdmfqouy fb lxo~uoig ql~ldqnh o~ nfinlsu|dj* sql~nqosuorl dieel~nqosuorl oi idu|ql* die ad~le fi t|djouduorl oiulqrolw~ die nd~l~u|eol~) Uhly dj~f ifule uhdu lrli whli ~|qrly~ wlql nfie|nule* uhl ~dksjl ~o}l~ wlql ~kdjj) Wl hdrl bf|ie uhdu kf~u sdslq~ uhduef bfn|~ fi uhl bdnufq~ uhdu dbblnu lQD~ ~|nnl~~ oi uhl s|ajon ~lnufqqljy sqokdqojy fi ~|qrly~ die nd~l ~u|eol~ uf ~|ssfqu uhloqnfinj|~ofi~)Bfjjfwoig d qlrolw fb uhl joulqdu|ql* wl oeliuobole uhqll aqfdendulgfqol~ fb bdnufq~ uhdu kdy dbblnu uhl ~droig~ dnholrle ay a|ylq~*fq uhl ‚~|nnl~~‛ fb lQD~) Uhl boq~u ndulgfqy fb bdnufq~ qljdul~ ufkdq`lu nfieouofi~= uhl i|kalq fb aoeelq~* uhl ufudj d|nuofi rfj|kldie uhl nfksluouofi dkfig ~|ssjolq~) Uhl ~lnfie ndulgfqy qljdul~ uf uhl s|qnhd~le sqfe|nu fq ~lqronl= ou~ nfksjlxouy* die hfw wljj ou wd~
 
5>3 ^HDJLR " D^AMFQI^LI
~slnobole) Uhl boidj ndulgfqy qljdul~ uf bdnufq~ uhdu ql~|jule bqfknhdigoig ~|ssjolq~* oinj|eoig uhl aqld` oi uq|~u wouh jfig~udieoig ~|ssjolq~ die ~wounhoig nf~u~)Uhl s|qsf~l fb uho~ sdslq o~ uf nfiuqoa|ul d ~uduo~uondjjy~|ssfqulelrdj|duofi fb uhl~l bdnufq~ |~oig d qljduorljy jdqgl ~dksjl fb lQD~ ufelulqkoil whonh dbblnu uhl ~|nnl~~ fb s|ajon ~lnufq lQD~) Wl uhlieqdw nfinj|~ofi~ bfq s|ajon ~lnufq sqfn|qlkliu kdidglq~ uf nfi~oelqwhli elnoeoig whluhlq uf nfie|nu di lQD bfq d sdquon|jdq s|qnhd~l)
FRLQROLW
Ljlnuqfion Qlrlq~l D|nuofi~
Whojl d|nuofi~ sqfroel ~|ssjolq~ uhl fssfqu|iouy uf boie uhl al~usqonl dkfig oiulql~ule a|ylq~* qlrlq~l d|nuofi~ gorl a|ylq~ d nhdinl uf boie uhl jfwl~usqonl ~|ssjolq) Oi lQD~* uhl a|ylq o~ dajl uf gduhlqdjj oiulql~ule ~|ssjolq~ fijoil* oqql~slnuorl fb uhloq glfgqdshonjfnduofi* du d qljduorljy jfw nf~u (Mds* 1331/) E|qoig uhl lQD*~|ssjolq~ ~|akou k|juosjl fbblq~* |~|djjy d~ d ql~sfi~l uf nfksluoig ~|ssjolq~‟ fbblq~* aoeeoig efwi uhl sqonl fb d gffe fq ~lqronl uf uhljfwl~u sqonl uhly dql wojjoig uf fbblq) Ay qlrldjoig uhl nfksluoig aoe~oi qldj uokl uf ldnh sdquonosduoig ~|ssjolq* lQD~ sqfkful‚oibfqkduofi uqdi~sdqliny‛) Uho~* nf|sjle wouh uhl eyidkon aoeeoig sqfnl~~* oksqfrl~ uhl nhdinl~ fb qldnhoig uhl bdoq kdq`lu rdj|l fb  uhl s|qnhd~l (^d~ho " F'Jldqy* 13310 Kdalqu " ^`llj~* 13310^klju}lq " Ndqq* 133>0 Aldjj du dj)* 133>0 ^nhflihlqq " Kdalqu*1337/)
Uhl Derdiudgl~ fb l+QD~
lQD~ dql sqfkfule d~ sqfroeoig s|qnhd~lq~ wouh d i|kalq fb alilbou~) Uhl bfqlkf~u o~ uhdu lQD~ fbuli sqfroel a|ylq~ wouh~ogiobondiu sqonl qle|nuofi~) ^droig~ bqfk lQD~ glilqdjjy drlqdgl<, uf >3, whli nfksdqle wouh uqdeouofidj aoeeoig kluhfe~* wouh4<, aloig kfql uysondj (^d~ho " F'Jldqy* 13310 Mds* 13310 Aldjj ludj)* 133>0 Kdmfq* 1337/* djuhf|gh lxnlsuofidj ~droig~ d~ hogh d~ ?3,hdrl alli dnholrle (Aldjj lu dj)* 133>/) Hfwlrlq* kfql qlnliujy*^oiglq* @fi~udiuoioeo~* Qf|ao`* " Albblqkdii (133?/ t|l~uofile uhl~l s|qsfqulejy hogh ~droig~ qdul~* ~|ggl~uoig uhdu ~droig~ fb dqf|ie 5, dql kfql qldjo~uon)

Activity (8)

You've already reviewed this. Edit your review.
1 hundred reads
1 thousand reads
Nuno Luis liked this
david_wyld liked this
david_wyld liked this
david_wyld liked this
Andora French liked this

You're Reading a Free Preview

Download
scribd
/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->