Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Process of Saving:
■ promotes thinking ahead, prioritizing
■ models behavior for kids
■ emotional payoff (pride, satisfaction)
3
But Saving is Hard
Q: How many
Americans
Challenges lower-income savers
currently hold face:
Savings Bonds?
■ Limited income – a minimum wage
A: 55 Million.
(That’s 1 in 6!) worker makes $15K a year.
■ Consumerism – pressure to buy is
everywhere.
■ Family & friends – are often in need,
creating pressure to share resources.
■ Few opportunities – most people
save with structured help (e.g.,
401(k) plans), but poor people get
little or no such help.
4
With Help, Anyone can Save
Some Examples: Tax Clients want to Save
$500 invested in a US
In one matched saving test: In one study,
Savings Bond 49% of for
at 4%
VITA clients
10 years willagreed:
grow to
■ 2,300 people saved $1.3MM - 2.2% of their
income, an average of $550 “I wish
$743.6that when I had
cash, I was better
■ Almost half lived below poverty level; 4 in 5 disciplined & saved it
lived below 2x the poverty line rather than spent it.”
In test of U.S. Savings Bonds:
■ 1,385 VITA tax clients (6%) saved $250k+ in
bonds for 2,300 people
■ Buyers’ average income: $20K
■ Average amount saved: $192
5
A Quick Quiz…
Low and moderate income tax filers receive how
much money each year in federal tax refunds?
■ $100 million (average of $500 per household)
■ $1 billion (average of $1,000 per household)
■ $100 billion+ (average of $1,680 per household)
6
A Quick Quiz…
Low and moderate income tax filers receive how
much money each year in federal tax refunds?
■ $100 million (average of $500 per household)
■ $1 billion (average of $1,000 per household)
■ $100 billion+ (average of $1,680 per household)7
8
Something to Consider
For many lower-income clients Buying $100 U.S. Saving
Bonds every year for 20
■ tax season is the only chance each year years would leave a tax
when saving seems possible. client with over $3,000 –
■ a tax preparer may be the only person all enough to fill the gaps in a
child’s college scholarship.
year who asks them to think about saving.
9
A Proposition
How about a “Return to Thrift”? Did You Know?
But How?
■ need a secure, trustworthy product
■ available to all, at key moments
■ long-term in nature
■ able to be gifted…
10
Another Quick Quiz
How many Americans own U.S. Savings Bonds?
■ Over 1 million
■ Over 10 million
■ Over 50 million
11
Another Quick Quiz
How many Americans own U.S. Savings Bonds?
■ Over 1 million
■ Over 10 million
■ Over 50 million
55,000,000 Americans own savings bonds – 1 in 6!
12
Quick Quiz
How many Americans own U.S. Savings Bonds?
■ Over 50 million
55,000,000 Americans own savings bonds – 1 in 6!
In the 1960s, tax filers could receive their federal
refund in the form of a savings bond.
■ True
■ False
13
Quick Quiz
How many Americans own U.S. Savings Bonds?
■ Over 50 million
55,000,000 Americans own savings bonds – 1 in 6!
In the 1960s, tax filers could receive their federal
refund in the form of a savings bond.
■ True Yes! Here’s an example…
■ False
1962 Form 1040A
With option to receive refund as U.S. Savings Bond
14
It’s easy to do on Form 8888
Just complete Part II for U.S. .
Savings Bonds
If bonds are for tax filer just
complete Line 4
If bonds are for others,
complete Lines 5 and 6
■ If beneficiary check box
Enter amounts on RHS
15
U.S. Savings Bonds Overview
Series I U.S. Savings Bonds
U.S. Savings Bonds an “IOU” from the US Government:
have been a
popular, respected ■ safe – principal protected by “full faith &
investment option credit of U.S. government”
for over 70 years.
■ accessible – buy for as little as $50
■ smart – solid return (.74%), no fees
■ simple – sold at “face value” ($50 buys
$50 bond), rate adjusts twice a year
■ long-term – must be held for 1 year
before “redemption” (cashing in)
■ portable – may be redeemed at most
banks & credit unions
16
Important Bond Facts
Redemption (“cashing in”)
■ At most banks & credit unions Proceeds from Savings
Bonds are exempt from
■ Requires valid ID federal tax if used for
secondary education
Minimum holding (check IRS Publication
970 for details).
■ Must be held for 1 year
■ If redeemed before 5 years, lose 3 months’
interest
Loss / theft replacement
■ Complete Treasury Form PDF 1048
■ Get signature certification from bank
■ Mail to Treasury
17
Savings Bonds as Gifts
In a 2008 study, 68% of
Tax Clients can buy bonds for: buyers purchased
savings bonds for
■ Themselves others, mostly children
■ And/or up to three other people & grandchildren
18
Example Savings Bond
Issue Date
Purchaser’s Social Security Number
123-45-6789 01 2009
John Q. Saver
123 Main Street
Anywhere, WA 99000-0000
OR Jen Saver
FRB-MPLS
04-15-07
2
19
Bond Features & Benefits
Feature Benefits
Competitive return (.74% Reach saving goal sooner
currently)
No fees No fees to erode savings
Convenient Simple tax site order process saves time
20
Bonds vs. Savings Accounts or CDs
Savings Bonds: CD-like returns, no fees and a $50 minimum
Typical 1 Year
Typical Savings Series I U.S.
Certificate of
Account* Savings Bond
Deposit (CD)*
Rate of Return .17% .53% .74%
Annual Fees $0 $0 $0
Minimum to Open $100 $1,000 $50
Rate Fixed No Yes Adjusts bi-annually
Minimum Holding
None 1 year 1 year
Period
3 months interest
Early Redemption All interest earned
None (redemptions within 5
Penalty / Forfeiture to withdrawal date
years of purchase)
ChexSystems Review Yes Yes No
May Buy as a Gift No No Yes
22
And Another Quiz
Which of the following are true about Series I
U.S. Savings Bonds:
A. They pay a competitive interest rate (.74% currently).
B. They can be purchased for as little as $50.
C. They can only be redeemed where they were purchased.
D. They can be purchased as gifts for anyone else – all you
need is the gift recipient's name.
23
Yet Another Quiz
How long must savings bonds be held before
they may be redeemed?
A. 6 months
B. 12 months
C. 5 years
D. They may be redeemed any time
24
Yet Another Quiz
How long must savings bonds be held before
they may be redeemed?
A. 6 months
B. 12 months
C. 5 years
D. They may be redeemed any time
25
Finding: People Want to Save
LMI tax clients value saving
● 49-63% of buyers saved part of
refund in the past
● 48% of decliners
Saving is a growing concern
26
Finding: People Like Savings Bonds
Pleased with bond purchase
Familiar with bonds
● 65% of tax clients “familiar” (vs.
32% for IRAs)
● 63% of tax clients had bought bond,
received bond as gift or known
someone who has owned
27
Finding: Who Saves
Demographics
● Parents: 70-75% of buyers; grandparents: 4-15%
● Gender: 79% female
● Age: ~ 40 years, same as sample
● Income: average AGI of buyers ~ $20k
● Ethnicity: African American over represented among buyers;
Hispanic slightly under
Other
● Large tax refund ($3.4k for buyers vs. $1.7k)
● First time savers: as high as 50%
28
Finding: Why People Save
Who: for kids & grandkids
● 70%+ of buyers bought for others
● 59% of buyers “I want to put something away for
my kid’s future”
What: for education, retirement
● Children / family (27%), Education (23%),
Retirement (18%)
Time horizon: long-term
● 2/3rds still saved after 3 years (in line with national
average)
29
Finding: How People Decide to Save
When: at “point of sale”
● ~50% report deciding to save at tax site
How: human contact
■ “learned about option to buy bonds today…”
● 79%+ when someone talked to me
● 12% from brochure or poster
● 20% before coming to tax site
30
Presenting Savings
54% of bond purchasers
during the TS ‘07 pilot, said
Consider
Asthey
taxhad
preparer,
no moneyYOU “saved ■ Saving requires many tax clients
play a crucial
or invested” role
prior in a
to buying to take a “leap of faith”
client’s
bonds decision to ● What if they need the money
save for the future -
later? Or their savings disappear?
their own, or that of
their children or ■ Clients generally trust you, their
grandchildren. tax preparer or other VITA staff
■ You are there at the key
moment – when the refund
amount is clear
As the face of any savings offer,
your role is critical.
31
Bond Order Process
How it Works
1. Client chooses to order bond in Part II of
Form 8888
2. Government mails bonds to clients
Your Role(s)
1. Explain opportunity - describe savings
bonds & chance to order at tax site
Tax Preparers Matter 2. Seek decision – ask client to decide if,
In a 2007 study, 41% of how much & for whom to order bonds
tax clients who saved
part of their refund 3. Process order – complete IRS Form
decided to do so only 8888 and enter name of owner and
after meeting with their
tax preparer. co-owner(s) or beneficiary and
amount for bonds
32
Talking with Clients
New Savers?
Bonds are a good fit for… 54% of tax clients who
bought savings bonds
■ Parents / guardians – bonds are in 2007 said they had
no money “saved or
popular gifts for kids
invested” prior to
● 68% of ’08 buyers bought bonds for others buying bonds.
■ First time savers – seeking a safe
way to start saving
● Bonds can be ordered for as little as $50
■ Long-term savers – who want a tool
to build savings over time
■ People on ChexSystemsSM – who do
not qualify for a bank account
33
Conversation Starters
When a client
To raise the topic of saving, try speaks:
open-ended questions: • Listen closely
■ I see you have a savings bond brochure; • Look her in the eyes
have you had a chance to look at it – what • Never interrupt
do you think? • Consider repeating
back her key points
■ We have a new, free service this year to
help you save; have you heard about it –
what questions do you have?
■ Have you ever heard of US savings bonds?
What have you heard? –or- May I tell you
about them?
■ Do you recall how you used last year’s tax
refund? What are your plans this year?
34
Seeking A Decision
Remember:
• Saving is hard & many
To help clients decide about buying
client’s won’t say “yes.” bonds:
• It is normal for about 1
■ Answer any questions; tactfully correct any
in 10 to order bonds.
• Please keep asking
misinformation
clients about bonds – ■ Briefly re-state 2 or 3 relevant bond features
even if many say “no.” ● For example, “as I mentioned, bonds are very
• Always respect clients’ safe, available for just $50, and earn .74% right
choices, as they know now.”
what’s best for them. ■ Then ask directly, “would you like to order a
savings bond today?”
■ If client declines
● Politely ask them why
● Correct any misunderstandings, ask again
35
Possible Client Concerns
Concern: I can’t afford to save During 2007 & 2008
pilots, bond purchases
■ Response used, on average, 6% of
● Even a little is a start; you can begin for $50 their refund to buy
● You just saved $150 in tax preparer fees - you savings bonds
could save some of this amount
● How did you use last year’s refund? Buy a $50
bond & you’ll still have some of your refund next
year
36
Client Concerns (more)
Q: Does one pay
Concern: I’ll save by myself, my own way state or local
Income taxes on
■ Response Savings Bonds?
● It’s great you already have a plan to save! A: No.
● We are offering another saving option that
can save you time & a trip to the bank.
● Bonds are among the safest saving
options with very competitive returns.
● You can buy a bond for your kids, grand-
kids or others - bonds make great gifts.
● For most of us, if we don’t do it now we
may never do it.
● It’s free to split your refund and buy a
bond today.
37
Another One
Which of the following are good ways to begin a
conversation about savings bonds with tax clients?
A. Do you want to buy a savings bond?
B. Have you heard about our new saving option this year? What
questions do you have?
C. Has anyone talked with you today about savings bonds? What
do you think about them?
38
Another One
Which of the following are good ways to begin a
conversation about savings bonds with tax clients?
A. Do you want to buy a savings bond?
B. Have you heard about our new saving option this year? What
questions do you have?
C. Has anyone talked with you today about savings bonds? What
do you think about them?
39
Final Quiz
If a client says “I’m not interested” which of the
following is the best way to respond?
A. Fine. How do you want to receive your refund?
B. Why? Savings bonds are a great way to save and saving is
really important.
C. Okay, that’s fine. Thanks for considering it. It would help me to
understand why you aren’t interested – could you give me
some idea?
40
Final Quiz
If a client says “I’m not interested” which of the
following is the best way to respond?
A. Fine. How do you want to receive your refund?
B. Why? Savings bonds are a great way to save and saving is really
important.
C. Okay, that’s fine. Thanks for considering it. It would help me to
understand why you aren’t interested – could you give me some
idea?
41
YOU can Encourage Savings Habits
42
“Savings is hard. Bonds make it easy”
Multiple dimensions:
● National vs. Local
● Offline vs. Online
National media coverage of the campaign
Potential national launch in D.C.
Boston and Philadelphia are our “launch” or “demo”
cities
● Lots of outreach into the communities (consumers,
gatekeepers, tax preparers)
● Support of elected officials
● Local media coverage; PSAs, etc.
Social media and campaign web site
43
Technical Assistance Delivery
44
Join our Campaign
45
Thank you!
For more information:
■ visit:Doorways to Dreams (D2D) Fund at
www.d2dfund.org
● Preeti Mehta
pmehta@d2dfund.org
(617)-541-9065
46