FileNumber:33800

INTHESUPREMECOURTOFCANADA(ONAPPEALFROMTHEFEDERALCOURTOFAPPEAL)

BETWEEN:

SOCIETYOFCOMPOSERS,AUTHORSANDMUSICPUBLISHERSOFCANADA

Appellant(ApplicantonJudicialReview)-and-

BELLCANADA,MUSICCANADA,APPLECANADAINC.,ROGERSCOMMUNICATIONSINC.,ROGERSWIRELESSPARTNERSHIP,SHAWCABLESYSTEMSG.P.,TELUSCOMMUNICATIONSINC.,ENTERTAINMENTSOFTWAREASSOCIATION,ENTERTAINMENTSOFTWAREASSOCIATIONOFCANADA

and

CMRRAJSODRACINC.

Respondents(RespondentsonJudicialReview)-and-

FEDERATIONOFLAWSOCIETIESOFCANADAandCANADIANLEGALINFORMATIONINSTITUTE/INSTITUTCANADIEND'INFORMATIONJURIDIQUE,CANADIANASSOCIATIONOFUNIVERSITYTEACHERS,THECOMPUTERANDCOMMUNICATIONSINDUSTRYASSOCIATIONandTHESAMUELSON-GLUSHKOCANADIANINTERNETPOLICYANDPUBLICINTERESTCLINIC(CIPPIC)

Interveners

FACTUMOFTHEINTERVENERS,THEFEDERATIONOFLAWSOCIETIESOFCANADAandCANADIANLEGALINFORMATIONINSTITUTE/INSTITUTCANADIEND'INFORMATIONJURIDIQUE

DIMOCKSTRATTONLLP

20QueenStreetWest32

FloorToronto,ONM5H3R3

MACERA

JARZYNALLP

427LaurierAvenueWestSuite1200Ottawa,ONK1R7Y2RonaldE.DimockSangeethaPunniyamoorthyJohnMaceroTel:416-971-7202Fax:416-971-6638Tel:613-238-8173Fax:613-235-2508rdimock@dimock.comspunniyamoorthy@dimock.comjohn.macera@macerajarzyna.comAgentsforFederationofLawSocietiesofCanadaandCanadianLegalInformationInstitute/lnstitutCanadiend'InformationJuridiqueCounselforFederationofLawSocietiesofCanadaandCanadianLegalInformationInstitute/InstitutCanadiend'InformationJuridique

ORIGINALTO:

THEREGISTRAR

COPYTO:

GOWLINGLAFLEURHENDERSONLLP

160ElginStreet,Suite2600Ottawa,ONKIPlC3GillesM.DaigleD.LynneWattMatthewS.EstabrooksTel:613-233-1781Fax:613-563-9869CounselfortheAppellantANDTO:

FASKENMARTINEAULLP

55MetcalfeStreet,Suite1300Ottawa,ONKIP6L5Gerald(Jay)

Kerr-WilsonAnneKoTel:613-236-3882Fax:613-230-6423CounselfortheRespondentsBellCanada,RogersCanada,RogersCommunicationsInc.,RogersWirelessPartnership,ShawCablesystemsG.P.,andTelusCommunicationsInc.ANDTO:

OSLERHOSKIN

HARCOURTLLP

340AlbertStreet,Suite1900Ottawa,ONKIR7Y6GlenA.BloomMarkusKleeTel:613-787-1073Fax:613-235-2867CounselfortheRespondentMusicCanada

OSLERHOSKIN

HARCOURTLLP

340AlbertStreetSuite1900OttawaONKIR7Y6PatriciaJ.WilsonTel:613-787-1009Fax:613-235-2867AgentfortheRespondentMusicCanada

ANDTO:ANDTO:ANDTO:

-2-

GOODMANSLLP333BayStreetSuite3400Toronto,ONM5H2S7MichaelKochTel:416-597-5156Fax:416-979-1234CounselfortheRespondentAppleCanadaInc.CASSELSBROCK

BLACKWELLLLP1200ScotiaPlaza40KingStreetWestToronto,ONM5H3C2CaseyM.ChisickTimothyPinosJasonBeitchmanTel:416-869-5784Fax:416-644-9326CounselfortheRespondentCMRRA-SODRACInc.McCARTHYTETRAULTLLPSuite5300TorontoDominionBankTowerToronto,ONM5KlE6BarryB.SookmanStevenG.MasonDanielGloverTel:416-601-7949Fax:416-868-0673CounselfortheRespondentsEntertainmentSoftwareAssociation!EntertainmentSoftwareAssociationofCanadaNELLIGANO'BRIENPAYNELLP50O'ConnorStreetSuite1500Ottawa,ONKIP6L2Tel:613-231-8210Fax:613-788-3661AgentfortheRespondentAppleCanadaInc.McMILLANLLP50O'ConnorStreetSuite300Ottawa,ONKIP6L2EugeneMeehan,Q.C.Tel:613-232-7171Fax:613-231-3191AgentfortheRespondentCMRRA-SODRACInc.CAVANAGHWILLIAMSCONWAYBAXTERLLP1111PrinceofWalesDriveSuite401Ottawa,ONK2C3T2ColinS.BaxterTel:613-780-2012Fax:613-569-8668AgentfortheRespondentsEntertainmentSoftwareAssociation!EntertainmentSoftwareAssociationofCanada