1994

8 . 3615 156
- - : O.E.,
60,2 <?, 105 64,
. 32.27.323 - 32.24548

1994

To

18 20 1994.

(
).

.
.
, ,
:
. .
, . . . I.
, . . , . . . .
. . . .
, , . .
, . .
. , . .
,
. . , -

 )( )

. . ,
. . . . .
,
. . . . . : Heidegger
. . . . ,
Descartes . Hume
. . .
' ( ,
, , ,
.

.

.

, . ,
,
,
. . , . , .
, .
, 1994

.
7
11

:

15

: ;

25

, ,

29

( )

43

Descartes

Hume

49
59
69

10

)5

.
77



Martin Heidegger

. ;




: ;

83
93
103

115
125

. ;

137

149

:
;

157

10
( '

167

Martin Heiddegger

: ;

131

179

185

189

203


18 1994, 17.00

,
,
,


,

12

)5

.
,


,
: ;

19 1994, 17.00

, .
:
;
,
, .
, ,
,


1,
:

, .

13

,
,
Design
: ;
,
( )

20 1994, 17.00

, .
. ;
,

, .
Hume
,
Descartes
, ,
: ;

14

,
Martin Heidegger
,

Martin
Heidegger

.
(Montaigne)'

'

, , , . < ,
, , , , ,
.
, . ,

.
.

16

, . ( ) -
- , , . , , , , , .
, ,
. , ,
.
, ( ) , . , , ^.
( )
, , , ^.

' , , .

, , .
1. , '
. ,

.
\|)
- , , (, , .) - .
, , , ^.
>

17

(
, , )5.

, .
(, , , .. - : .. ).
, ( ) , . , - - . ,
.
.., , .
(
)
, .
) , ,
( )
, , ,
, (
).
)
. ,
,
''.
) ,
, ( - , )
, .
, , , .".
)
:

18

)5

. , :

a priori

)
,
, '".
.
) ,
: ,
, , . ; , (
), . :
)
(
) , (.. ), , . ( ).
) , ,
( ).
. ( ) () (). ' ,
1 ( , ,
, ) 2 ( ) (.)".

19

,
- -
(1) ( ),
, .
) : ,
(discourse) , ,
.
) -
, . ,
, , .
,
. , ,
, ,
,
, ()
.
: , .
, , , '
.
, .
.
) , : . , ( ) ( , )
( , , ) . , ( ) , .'2.
2. ( ) ( )
( ). ,
, , ., , , -

20

)5

( ) ,
:
(, ) [: ]
...". , ,
. ,
,
.
, ,
, : [ ]
, ,
. ( ) ( ] , ,
()'*.
-

, (, , , , , .) '5 - ,
. : , , , , ., ; :
, ;

(Wittgenstein),
- -
:
) ' , ,
, - ,
-

21

QTitoQix , :
- (
- ^ -)'.
) , - ,
.
.
( .)
- ,
, .- ,
; status , ; , ,
, ,
. ,
' ( ) ,
( ) ,
, . .
.
. , )
, - , )-
: , , , , ,
.".
: ' , , ,
, - * , .
; , * , .

22

)5

'
, , , : . ,
,
, .
, ,
- , ...20.
( , .)
, .
, :
) , , . , . ) () - ,
.-
, -
, ,
.

- , ,
. ,
, (

) , (, .) . -
, ' -
.
-..
, : .

23

.
.. . . ,
, , (, , S)^'.

1. . . , 5 ., '), 1984, . ', . 57

149.
2. J. Derrida, Dissmination, Chicago (C.U.P.), 1982.
Of Grammatology, Baltimore (Johns Hopkins U.P.), 1976. Positions Chicago (C.U.P.),
1971.
: R. Gasche, The Tain of the
Mirror. Derrida and the Philosophy of Reflection, Cambridge, Mass. - London (Harvard U.P.),
1986. - M. Frank, Das individuelle Aligemeine, Frankfurt/M. (Suhrkamp), 1985, no. 48-86. , J. Habermas, Der philosophische Diskurs der Moderne, Frankfurt/M.
(Suhrkamp), 1985, . VII.
3. Positions, .., . 59 ., 69 . - . Tympan
The Double Session ( : . Kamuf (ed.), A Derrida Reader,
New York (Columbia U.P.), 1991, . 148-168 171-199, ).
4. . , , .., . ' , . 53. - . . ,
, (), 1979, . 44 ., 49 . ( . 108-115 . 305 ). - R. Berthes .. Critique et
Vrit, Paris (du Seuil), 1966 Leon. Paris (du Seuil). 1978.
5. J. Derrida, Of Grammatology, .. (. 2), . 160.
6. , 1,1025 b 25 6,145 , 15-16.
7. F. Bacon, De dignitate et augmentis scientiarum, 2, I.
8. J. H. Lambert, Drei Abhandlungen zum Systembegriff (1782, 1787). To : . Seiffert/G. Radnitzky (.), Handlexikon zur Wissenschaltstheorie, Mnchen
(dtv), 1992, . 339.
9. I. , (1790), Hamburg (F. Meiner), 1974, , 36 (, LVIII
. .)
10. .. Seiffert/Radnitzky, .. (. 8), . 344-352 .
11. . Heidegger, Der Ursprung des Kunstwerkes Holzwege, Frenkfurt/M
(Klostermann), 1950. ( . : , , , 1986). - J. Habermas, Tlieorie des kommunikativen Handelns, Frankfurt/M (Suhrkamp), 1981, . 1, . 372 ., 435-452, - M.
Frank, Einfuhrung in die fruhromantische sthetik, Frankfurt/M (Suhrkamp), . 17.
12. . : I.A. Richards, Principles of Literary Criticicm
(1924), London (Routledge and Kegan Paul), 1983, . 34. - . Buhler, Sprachtheorie. Jena
1934, - J. Habermas, .. (. 11).
13. J. Derrida, Positions, .. (. 2), . 59.

24

)5

14. J. Derrida, The Double Session, .. (. 3), a. 187,185.

15. J. Derrida, Positions, .. (. 2), . 114.
16.1. , (1788), Hamburg (F. Meiner) 1974, a. 74 (,
110-111 ..)
17. L. Wittgenstein, (, , . ), (), 1977, . 228, -
. .. (, , (), 1985, . 25-41
( , (), 1986, . 90-98.
18. J. Derrida, The Double Session, .. (. 3), . 190.
19. The Double Session, .. (. 3), . 177 Positions, . 59.
20. F. Nietzsche, Die Geburt der Tragdie G. Colli - M. Montinarl (,), Smtliche
Werke, Berlin (de Gniyter), 1967..,. ,. 14.
21. The Oxford Shakespeare, G. R. Hibbard (.), Hamlet,
Oxford (O.U.P.), 1987:
There are more things in heaven and earth, Horatio, Than are dreamt of In our
philosophy. (1,5, . 174-5) ( in your philosophy).

:
;

1.
, ,
, ya ,
.
,
.
, : '
, '
. ,

.
2. , , , .
-

26

xat

, () , '.
(3) ( ),
, ,
. ( ) 3,
, ,
. , ,
, ,
( ) ( ). .
3. , .

( )
, .
( -),

. , ( 2).

, ^
, ^ ^.
, ,
, design, ready-made . , .
4. . , -

To : ;

27

()

' () ,
() , - ()
- . ( - , () ( ) ()
, , '" ()
- '
" ' , .
, ,
, '2.

1. . W.V.O. Quine: The Roots of Reference, Open Coun. U Salle III., 1973.
2. . T. Sprigge: "Internal and External Properties", (1,.\. 1962, . 197-212.
3. G. Dickie, The Art Circle, N.Y., 1985.
4. A. Danto: The Transfiguration of the Commonplace, Cambridge Mass., 1981.
5. . J.D.Carney: "Style Theory of Art", Pacific Philosophical Quarterly, t.Tl. 1991. .
273-289.
6. . J. Levlnson: "Extending Art Historically", The Journal of Aesthetics and Art
Criticism, . 51, No. 3,1993; . 411 -423.
7. . Ziff, Weltz Kennick W. Elton (ed.).
Aesthetics and Language. . Blackwell, Oxford, 1954.
8. R. Wollheim: "The Institutional Theory of Art", Art and its Objects. Cambridge Univ.
Press, Cambridge, 1980. G. Oppy, "On Defining Art Historically", The British Journal of
Aesthetics, . 32, No. 2, 1992, . 153-161. M. Mandelbaum, "Family Resemblances and

28

Generalisation Concerning the Arts", Aesthetics (eds. G. Dickie and R. Sciafani), St. Manins
Press, New Yoric, 1977.
9. . R. Gaskin, "Can Aesthetic Value be Explained?", Brlttsh Journal of Aesthetics, x.
29. No. 4, 1989, . 329-340.
10. M. Beardsley, "The Instrumentalist Theory of Aesthetic Value", Smoductory Readings in
Aesthetics (ed. J. Hospers), The Free Press, N.Y., 1969.
11. . xoi J. Searle, Speech Acts, Cambridge Press, Cambridge, 1983.
12. . xet F. E.Sparshott, ne Theory of the Arts, Princeton Univ. Press, J., 1982.

, ,
3 ,
,
.
. ,

^

.


. .
' . ,
. , ' , -

30

wxi

. , , ,
- (prudential)- . ,
.
-
,
.
' - , ,
, , ^. , ,
.
.
, ^.
. ,
.
- ,
; .
, , \ *.
. ,

, ,

31

,
, , , . ,
.

^. ,
, ,
,
, . , , ,
.
, calculus, ,
.

.
- -
.
,
, , , .
Wittgenstein,
, Tractatus
'',
:

. .

32

, cni
, . R. Tilghman,

. , , . ,
Wittgenstein

,
.
,
. ,
. ,
. - -, , , , ( ,
...),
' * .
, , , . ,

,
, .
) ,
".

, ,

33

, . , ,
, (.. , Lautramont Chordelos de Laclos, Bataille,
Marinetti,
Leni Riefenstahl)'^. , , , ,
. ,

, .
'
. .

. :

,


. ,
,
, :

( ;
, .

34

)5

'^. Oscar Wilde,

'. '
,
' .


, , . , Tolstoy ( ) ;


,
' ' '^. ,

, . , '
".
,
.

.
. - .
, ,

". ,
, ',

, ,

35

. , , happening
.
, .. . '
, .
Samuel Schefflet
Human Morality^

,
, , . , , ,
. , -.. - ,
.

;,
, ' .

^',

. , ,
,
,

^^.

;
,

36

xav8C; .
, ,
- ( , , , , ,
)
,
^.
,
. ' ,

.
, .
,
.
) .
, .
, '
^^.

, ...
)

, ,

37

(. , , . , ,
() .
,
. Gaugin . .
, ,
. '

( ),
' .
^.
) . '
27.
. , , . , . '
' . ,
. , 3 1808 Goya
Kollwitz. , Nuss-

38

baumle, to - , , , \1) ,
. '


.

.
,
, .. , ' .


. , ' ^'. ,

' ;
: '
. '
, .
, , ,
( ) .

.

, ,

39

) ,
, , , ,
( ) . ,
.


^. ' ,
,
, ' .
,

,
,
. ' ,
.
,
. ,
,

.

1. ..
.. . . . . . .
.
2. - . Frankena, Et/i/'cs (Englewood Cliffs NJ : Prentice-Hall. 1963), 9-10 47-8. -

40

)5

. Howard . Kainz, Ethics In Context (London :

Macmillan, 1988), 116-34.
3.
Anscombe, Murdoch, Maclntyre Bernard Williams . . ,
; 5 (.19SH): 115-29.
4. . Thomas Nagel, The View from Nowhere (New York : Oxford University Press, 1986),
195-200 Charles Larmore, Modernit et Morale (Paris : Presses Universitaires de
France, 1994), .
5.
. Larmore, ., .
6. . . Monroe C. Beardsley, Aesthetics
from classical Greece to the Present : A short History [
( : , 1989)]. .
7. . Tractatus Logico-Philosophicus, . , (1971): 6.421.
8. L. Wittgenstein, Notebooks, second edition, translated by G.E.M. Anscombe (Chicago :
The University of Chicago Press, 1979), 83. . L. Wittgenstein, ( : ,
1993), 166.
9. . B.R. Tilghman, Wittgenstein, Ethics and Aesthetics. The View from Eternity (London:
Macmillan, 1991) .
10. . .
11. ,
. , ; ( : . .
, 1987).
. Marcia M.Eaton, Aesthetics and the good Life (London : Associated University
Presses, 1989), . . Kendall L. Walton, Morals in Fiction
and fictional Morality. Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society suppl. 68 (1994):27-50,
Hume ,
Michael Tanner, ., 51-66.
12. , . ( ,
. 509 (1992):46-52) ( (
)*. , 13 1992), Walton
Tanner, ..
13.
, .., 72 68 . ,
, R. W. Beardsmore, Art and Morality (London : MacMillan, 1971)
Anne Sheppard, Aesthetics: An Introduction to the Philosophy of Art (Oxford : Oxford
University Press, 1987), . . Leslie Birch Ingrid Stadler, "Art for
Art's Sake : A Paradox," Contemporary Art and Its philosophical Problems, Ingrid Stadler,
ed. (Buffalo, NY : Prometheus, 1987), 35-43.
14. The Critic as Artist ( ( : , 1984), 111, 136
112 ].

, ,

41

15. Leo . Tolstoy, What Is An?, translation Alymer Maude, introduction Vincent Tomas
(Indianapolis : Bobbs - Merrill, 1960), 151-2 .
16. . , ,

() . '

. . John Anderson "Art and
Morality" [Australesian Journal of Philosophy 19 (1941):253-66) Joyce . , , Tolstoy
Anderson, , .
17. . Tom L. Beauchamp, Philosophical Ethics: Introduction to moral
Philosophy, second edition (New York : McGraw-Hill, 1991), .
18. ,
,
.
19. Beardsmore, .., 10, Anderson, .., 256, Sheppard, .., 137.
20. New York : Oxford University Press, 1992, 2. To The Rejection of
Consequentlalism : A philosophical Investigation of the Considerations underlying rival moral
Conceptions (Oxford : Clarendon Press, 1982). . David .
Brink, " Reasonable Morality," Ethics 104 (1994):S93-619,
21. ,
, .
22. ., 102. [. ) (pervasive), ,
(moderate),
- . Scheffler ,
ceteris paribus .
23.
,
. . ( : , 1976).
24. . Michael J. Wreen, "Aesthetics," Encyclopedia of Ethics, Uwtence C. Becker
(ed.), vol. 1 (New York : Garland, 1992), 18. . Nelson Goodman, Languages of A n (Indianapolis : Hacken, 1976).
25. -

42

)5

.
.
26. ,
. ,
,
,
. . Bernard Willlains, Moral Luck (Cambridge: Cambridge
University Press, 1981) Thomas Nagel, Mortal Questions (Cambridge; Cambridge University
Press, 1979).
27.
Jauss .. . Robert
C. Holub, Reception Theory. A critical Introduction (London: Methuen, 1984).
28. Love 's Knowledge : Essays in Philosophy and Literature (New York : Oxford University
Press, 1990). Wayne Booth

| (moral criticism). . The
Company we keep: The Ethics of Fiction (Berkeley : University of California Press, 1988)
Nussbaum (. 230-44).
29. , , Walton
("Morals in fiction", ..), .

, ' .
.
30. . Stephen R. Munzer, A
Theory of Property (Cambridge : Cambridge University Press, 1990),
Social Philosophy and Policy ( 2,11 (1994)).

( )
'

.
(
) - - , ,
, , , , :
, a priori
; , , , - .

, -
: -, -, -. ,
, , -

44

;
Hegel, ,
. , ' , , - , ,
, , -
, , :
, , , , -
, , .
, ,
, , . : , ,
, , ( )
. , ,
, - , :

,
, ,
,
. , , ,
, ,
, , . , Hegel,
, ) . , ,
. ^4 , ,
, ^. , , : -

To ( )

45

, ,
. ,
, ,
.
, ,
,
: - ,
,
. , , , , .
, , ' , - , , . ,

. ,

,
, , .
, .

-
, , .
, ,
, , : , , . ,
, , . ( ..
-

46

)5

.)
- , , , , .
Kant, ^. ,
-
, , , .

,
.
: , , ,
^. , ,
' .
ereQov
, ''. , , ,
,
, , ,
.
, , () () . (
, ,
.) , ,
, : ,
, , (
- , , ,
-
), ,
( ,

To ( )

47

, , ).
,
, , .
, -,
, , Derrida, .
.. Magritte - - -,
,
, . ,
Foucault, ,
. () ,

, , ( , ) .



:
,
,
, -,
, Merleau-Ponty Czanne",
.

I. , ,

. Foucault
, . . Nietzsche, la gnalogie, l'histoire. Hommage Jean Hyppole,
Paris, P.U.F., 1971 Dits et crits. II, Paris, Gallimard, 1994.

48

Eoxjta

2. Vorlesungen Uber die sthetik, 1, Werke, 13, Frankfurt am Main, Suhrkamp Verlag, 1970.
3. ...
4. . G. Bataille, Manet, Paris, Skira, 1951 L'rotisme, Paris, les ditions de minuit,
1957.
5. . Kritik der Urteilskraft. Werke, V. Frankfurt am Main, Insel-Verlag, 1960.
6. M. Blanchot, L'espace littraire, Paris, Gallimard, 1955.
7. . .., '' '' Hegel,
, . . , , , 1994.
8. S. Freud, Die Traumdeutung, Gesammelte Schriften, , Leibzig/Wien/ZUrich,
Internationaler Psychoanalytiker Verlag, 1925. . J.-Fr. Lyotard, Drive partir de
Marx et de Freud. Galile, 1994(2).
9. . La vrit en peinture. Paris, Flammarion. 1986.
10. Ceci n'est pas une pipe, Montpellier, Fata Morgana, 1973 . L'usage des
plaisirs- Le souci de sol, Paris, Gallimard, 1984.
11. . Sens et non-sens, Paris, Nagel, 1966(7) L'il et l'esprit, Paris, Gallimard, 1964.

- .
,
, , , , '
-.
, , , .
,
, , ,
, , ' , .

.
1.

50

, . Aldous Huxley : , , , ( ), '.

Huxley
'^ :
,
, ^.
Michael Baxandall
:
, ' : ^.
, ,
, , . ( ), .
Rudolf
Arnhein: ,
: , ( ),
, ' . :
' () ".
2.

- . , . , , , ,
, (
, .
Xans Belting ' : , , , , ^.

51

. , , , , , ,
. ( ' ), ,
, , .
,
- : , -
: )- .
, ,
-,
, , .
,
, ,
, , . : ' , , , ,
,
' , . ,
, . -, , . , ^.
. , ,
: , (
). : . .
, , , ,
.
,
- . ,
, ,
,
, .

52

eeHjta

, , - , , . , , ,
,
, .
() ,
. ,
, , , ,
(, , ), . -
, ,
,
.
,
.
Pierre Francastel , .
. :
. , , .
(l'illusion plastique)
(experience
sesnible) .
,
- , ' . ,
(sens), '.

- ,
,
. Christian Metj '

53

: ,
. , , . (Panofsky),
(Eco) , (statifications)
. ,
. ' '".
, ' ,
Henri Focillon Piero dellla
Francesca. : , Piero dlia Francesca, , , (fond),
(milieu). (decor), ( ) (domaine). (abstrait)
(imaginaire), ' '.
, , - ,
Henri Focillon, , .
,
.

. -

-
, - , , , , .
, , ,

54

,
, . -
,
, , |.
. ^
,
. , ' , - . - , , .
, , :
.

.
' .
,
( ) , .

. , .
- , , .

,
, .
--

55

. , , , .

. Pensee plastique , (Pierre,
Francastel, ). Discorso Visivo '^, l'imagination plastique Claude Levi-Sxrauss, '^.
,
, ()
. , .
,
, , .
, - , -
.

-
,
, , , , , '
.
,
. ( , , ..)
\|. , *
,
.

56

eeHjta

, , ,
. , .
' , ,
( ), .
: .
, . , , ,
.
,
. , ,
. , , , .
( ),
,
, . , ,
,
,
, .
, . , ( ),
, * , .

.

57

, .
, ,
, .

1. Aldous Huxley: L'art de voir, Paris: Payot 1970, . 36.

2. Aldous Huxley: art de voir, Paris: Payot 1970, . 143.
3. Michael Baxandal: Formes de l'intention. Paris: Jacqueline Chambon 1991. . 26.
4. Rudol Arnheim: Arte e percezione visiva. Milano: Feltinelll 1979, . 60.
5. Hans Belting: La fine dlia storia dell' arte la libert delV arte. Torino: Einaudi 1990,
. 19.
6. -: . . ,
1991, . 38-39.
7. .. : , :
, . 27.
8. : (/. 1992, . 7475.
9. Pierre Francastel: La figure et le Hem. Paris: Gallimara 1967, .. 108-109.
10. Christian Metj: , . , 5,
1975.
11. Henri Focillon: Plero dlia Francesca, Paris: Presses Pocicet, 1991, . 112.
12. Mario Salmi: Guida ail'educazlone artlstlca. Firenje: Le Monnier.
13. Claude Levi-Strauss: Regarder, couter, lire. Paris: Pion. 1993, . 19.

Descartes
Descartes, tvow ,
, . ,
Descartes
, ,
. Compendium Musicae, , 1618, Descartes 22 ,
, .
Isaac Beeckman, Descartes
.
Descartes :
"informem, et quasi ursae foetum nuper edituni"^,
. , ,
. , ( Breda
"inter ignorantiam militarem"^), : , *.
, , Beeckman
- -
^.
:
( ) , ,
-

60

eeHjta

, , 19
.
.
Gouhler,
C.M. Descartes
^ Alqui,
' Descartes *.
, Rieman
,
', Schneider C.M. Descartes '". - : - ( ) ".
' '
, '
C.M. , . : Descartes,
.
() ,
.
.
Descartes '
;
, Descartes ,
'2.
'.
' : , , ( Quadrivium) ,
-
, '<. Descartes
, , .
- -

 Descanes

61

-
.

(consonantiae)is.
,
. Zarlino Istitutioni Harmoniche (1558).
Zarliao -', Descartes.
, , '',

Descartes .

: . ' consonantiae ,
.
Descartes . ,
. , C.M.,
,
.
.
' , , : ( ) , '. ", '
. .
,
8 (praenotanda), , - ^.

.
Revault d' Allonnes,
, , .

62

)5

.
, . 2.
,
, , ^^.
Descartes ' .
, (.. les passions de me)
.
' .
Le monde^,
,
^-. .
Mersenne ^, Descartes 1630 . ,
, ,
.
consonantiae ,
, , ... ,
, ,
26. : consonantia
.
,
... consonantia
, 27. , ' ,
' ,
.
, ,
28.
Descartes ' (

 Descartes

63

( , ) .
^', ,
'.
' , .
Descartes 10 C.M.
Mersenne;
.
C.M^' . , , .
Mersenne,
. . Mersenne ,
Descartes. Descartes , , , , .
Descartes
. , , , Mersenne. - - , : ( consonantiae)
"'^.
' . , , '^. , , : , .
' :

64

, axooow , . , ,
, . ,

, , ' 3<.
Pavlov. Gerard Bonnot "Us ont tu
Descartes">^, Einstein, Freud Pavlov Descartes,
, .
, .
, ,
: ,
^. . , Descartes
,
, : 1631, , :
37
... '.

. Descartes , , , .
, ^'.
, 1630 Descartes C.M.
praenotanda , ' Descartes ' . . , ,
.
.

 Descartes

65

Descartes '
. Pirro Descartes '
C-M.-o. , , " , .
,
-".

,
'^.
,
, C.M. ,
, '
(dissonantiae) .
, ' consonantiae.
.
( ) (
),
.
-sequentia (), imitatio (), contrapunctum () , , '^

Descartes ,
Mersenne 1640.
Antoine
Bosset Joan Abert
Ban. Ban Descartes
Descartes :
, , *^.
Monteverdi, , (natural! industria) - - -

66

eecooCa Tjcvti

. Ban
. Mersenne ,
Bosset, ' . Ban , , . ,
.
Mersenne - ' - Descartes. , Ban ^, Bosset
Ban.
, ,
, '? '
"mal instruit" Pirro'. Descartes, C.M.
( , ,
\),
"*'.
Descartes ,
. , . ,
. '
Principes de la Philosophie. , ,
5.

, ,
, Descartes,
18 ., Rameau,
Quantz Carl Philipp Emmanuel Bchai.

 Descartes

67

1. )! Brhier, Copleston, Chatelet, Descartes. Descartes V. Bsch, " a-t-il une esthtique cartsienne?", Travaux du
IXe Congrs international de Philosophie (Congrs Descanes), Tome II, Ile Partie, Paris 1937.
2. Compendium Musicae ( C.M.), Oeuvres de Descartes, . Adam et Tannery
( A.T.), . Paris 1897-1913, . 140.
3... . 141.
4. .. . 140.
5. . H.F. Cohen, Quantifying Music,
Dordrecht 1984, . 192-197. Cohen , , ,
, .
6. Mersenne, 11 1678, .. II, . 388. Descartes , .
7. . Gouhier, Les premires penses de Descartes. Paris 1958, . 91-92.
8. F. Alqui, Science et mtaphysique chez Descartes, Paris 1955, . 5.
9. H. Rieman, Geschichte der Musiktheorie im - Jahrhundert, Berlin 1921, . 420.
Rteman "scharfe Denker" " outstanding musicologist" . ugst ("Descartes's Compendium on Music", Journal of the History of Ideas,
1965, . 119), Rieman
. Scherchen, The Nature of Music.
10. . Schneider, Die franzsische Kompositionslehre in der ersten Hlfte des 17.
Jahrhunderts, Tutzing 1972, . 184.
11. J. Lohmann, "Descartes 'Compendium Musicue' und die Entstehung des neuzeitlichen
Bewusstseins", Archiv fUr Musikwissenschaft 1972, , 81.
12. . . . ,
Descartes et la musique, Paris 1907, . 1.
13. . J. Racek, "Contribution au problme de esthtique musicale chez R. Descartes", La
revue musicale 1930, . 292-3.
14. . H. Schneider, .. . 170.
15. Consonantia = , . .
16. (J. Kepler. S. Stevin),
(V. Galilei, G. Galilei, M. Mersenne) (I. Beeckman, R. Descanes) (. Cohen, ..).
17. C. Laie, Esquisse d'une esthtique musicale scientifique, Paris 1908, . 83.
18. CM. A.T. X, a. 89.
20. ... Walker, "Mersenne's musical competition of 1640 and J A. Ban". Studies in
musical science In the late Renaissance, Leiden 1978. .84.
20. CM. A.T.X. .9.
21. . Revault d' Allonnes, "L' esthtique de Descartes", Revue des sciences humaines,
1951, . 53.
22. G. Rodis-Lewis ,
. .'oeuvre Je Descarfes/, Paris 1971,.33.
23. A Mersenne, 18 1629, A.T. I, . 102.
24. A Huygens, 4 1647, Descartes, Oeuvres philosophiques III, . Alqui,
Paris 1973, a. 725.
25. G. Rodis-Lewis, "Musique et passions au XVIe sicle (Monteverdi et Descartes)",
XVUeSIcle, 1971,. 92.

68

JMieetoCa

26. Mersenne, 3 1630, .. I, . 108.

27. Mersenne, 4 1630, .. I, . 126.
28. Mersenne, 18 1630, .. I, . 132-3.
29. . Cohen, .. . 169.
30. . Encyclopdie de la Pliade, Histoire de la musique II, Paris 1963, a. 8S.
31. .. > consonantiae
* ,
, .
, C.M. .. , . 111.
32. Mersenne, 18 1629, .. I, . 88.
33. Mersenne, 1630, ., I, . 108.
34. Mersenne, 18 1630, .. I, . 133-.
35. G. Bonnot, Ils ont tu Descartes, Paris 1969.
36. A Mersenne, 18 1630, .. I, . 133.
37. A Mersenne, 1631, .. I, . 227.
38. Mersenne. 1640, .. III, . 255.
39. L. Prenant, "Esthtique et sagesse cartsiennes". Revue d'Histoire de la Philosophie et
d'Histoire gnrale de la Civilisation 1942, . 108.
40. Pirro, .. . 120. Racek, .. . 300.
41. Rodis-Lewis, .
Rodis-Lewis, "Musique et passions...", ., . 82.
42. C.M. ,
. Cogltationes Privatae (.. , . 227), C.
Huygens clavecin , Descartes ,
(. Pirro, . . . 12.)
43. CM. .. , . 138-9.
44. Walker, .. . 86.
45. Pirro (.. . 110), .
46. Mersenne, 1640, .. , . 255.
47. Walker. ... 102.
48. Pirro, .. . 108.
49. Walker, Descartes
, Vecchi Cl. Jannequin, < ensemble
Mozart Verdi,
(.. . 105).
50. Prenant, .. . 114.
51. . R. SchBfke, "Quantz als sthetiker", Archiv fUr Musikwissenschaft, 1924, J.
Opper, "The Place of Baroque Music in the Age of Reason", Science and the Arts, New Jersey
1973,

Hume
,
Hume. , Hume: Hume Peter Kivy
Hume
'. ,
Hume
, " . , ,
. Kivy,
, Hume . ,
.
Kivy Hume: Hume
,

^. , -

70

xat

) Kivy, Hume , ,
\| .
, . , Hume, . , ,
, , , .
,


. , Kivy
,
Hume ''.
, Kivy,
.

,
^. ,
Kivy, Hume .
,
Kivy, .
Hume
, . Hume \|),
,
,
. , , .

To Hume

71

Hume, Kivy,
. Hume .
Hume
. .
Hume . ,
, , ,
, , ,
-
, . ,
, , | ,
Kivy, .


,
, .
,

-

.
,
Kivy Hume.

Kivy Hume , '

72

Hume . '
' , Kivy Hume . Hume .
Hume Kivy, : ()
; () Hume ;
()
,
.

' , ,
,
. ,

,
' ,
.
, ' .
.
-
'. ,
, ,
.

.
, , .
, ,

To Hume

73

. ,


.

. , ' . , , . : .
, , , .
- .
.
() , Hume ,
. Hume
, , ,
.

^
.
.
Hume
, . Hume
*^

74

. .

,
. Hume ,
, .
,
,
.
, .
Hume .

, . ,
Hume
Bentham Mill .
, Hume
, ; .
Hume , .
Hume
. ,
, . ,
'
.

To Hume

75

,
' rjni
,
Kant'^. . , ' .

1. . Kivy, "Hume's Neighbour's Wife: An Essay on the Evolution of Hume's Aesthetics",

British Journal of Aesthetics, . 23 (1983), . 195-208.
2. (
) ,
3. ^ Hume . Treatise of
Human Nature, edited by L.A. Selby-Bigje, At the Clarendon Press. (1896) 1928.
Enquiries ncerning Human Understanding and concerning the Principles of Morals, edited by
L.A. Selby-Bigge and revised by P.H, Nidditch, Qarendon Press, 1986. 'Of the Standard
of Taste", Of the Standard of Taste and Other Essays, edited by J.W. Lenz, The Library of Liberal
Arts, The Bobbs-Merrill Company, Inc., 1980, . 3-24 (. . ..
, , , , ,
. , , .. . 102-127). < , * .
4. .., . 200. Kivy D. Hume.
Treatise of Human Nature, . , . , . 1, . 584-585.
5. .., . 201. D. Hume, Treatise of Human Nature, ,
..1,.5,.617.
6. .., . 202. Kivy D. Hume,
Enquiry concerning the Principles of Morals, Enquiries concerning the Human
Understanding and concerning the Principles of Morals, . 173.
7. . . 3.
8. .., . 203-204. . D. Hume, "Of the Standard of Taste", Of the Standard of Taste and
Other Essays, a. 17- . . . . .. , . , , , , . 119.
9. . . . 1,
10. , .. Geach, S. Hampshire A.C. Macintyre.

76

11. , .. Shaftesbury Hutcheson >

, Hobbes Hume. . , R.F. Atkinson, Conduct: an
Introduction to Moral Philosophy, Macmillan, , , 1969, . 58-59.
12.
Hume: Of the Standard of Taste and Passion, Of
Tragedy, Of Simplicity and Refinement in Writing The Sceptic Of the
Standard of Taste and Other Essays, aa. 25,29,43 119 .
13.1. Kant, The Critique of Judgement, . J.C. Meredith, At the
Clarendon Press, (1928), 1978, . 69 80.

,
.
, ,
.

. :
, ,
\| .
, -, , , ,
, :
- -
.
.. '

.
.

78

08(OQla

.. . Duchamp Matisse Picasso; - - .

, ,
, .
) , ,
, , , ,
.
,
, -
- . Duchamp. Duchamp , ,
,
, ' .
- - ,
1960.
) '
: , ( , , . -.
' , , ,
, . ' ,
.
- - .
, .

79

' . ,
.
.
, - ,
- ' , ; ' , , . : .

, , Knt
.
. Kant,
, - | , , ,
, , Duchamp. : ; ( ) , ,
, , .;

Heidegger ( ) Derrida, . Duchamp
,
, , ,
.
Duchamp
'60 .
: Andy Warhol Josef Beuys. Warhol
. Ready Mades

80

Duchamp. , , ready made.

Warhol Duchamp, : Duchamp
(
' ),
Warhol .. Frederick Jameson Warhol
,
Duchamp. ' , , .
, , J. Beuys ' , '
^ .
, .
, - Warhol- , ,
.
, - . , ,
:

' ,
, , , .
.
; ; ' :
. , - .

. ,

81

.
--
. ,
, ,
, .
-, - - . :
, , .
, , Max Weber -
- . Duchamp.
, , . , , , .
.
.
, ( ), (
Duchamp) .
, ' . ,
, ,
. , ,
, , ,
.
- -,
, ,
,
... , (, , ,
).
, , , , .
,

82

Duchamp, ( ) -.
: ; , ( ),
;
, , , .

1960,
Duchamp (Schnabel, Vaulier, Acconci, Manzoni)
( ), , ,
,
, ;
, Stefan Morawsky , :

. . ,
.

1. ,
:. ,
,
.
, '
.

, , . , , ,
. , , ,
,
.
:
. , , , , , .., .
. ,
.
, 2000 ,
:
, -

84

. ...
..., , . ,
, .
. , , ,
, , , , |

'.
:
,
, , , . , ... , (
(), ,
^.

, , ,
( ), ,
. , . ,
, , , . .
- ,
. ' , .., Suger . , ,
, ^. Erwin Panofsky, ' ,
*.

Ol

85

, , . Alberti,
uotno universale,
^. , ,
De re aedificatoria
14525. , ,
,
, .
, Palladio, , , Giangiorgio
Trissino, . , Palladio '
, Daniele Barbare, ^. Barbaro,
, , , (vero contigente) (vero necessario),
. Palladio, ^. Palladio Accademia Olimpica , .
,

. Boulle, ,
. , Locke, Montesquieu Voltaire,

. Boulle , .
19 , ,
, -

86

. ,
, , .
, 19 ,
,

,
'. , ,
, , , ,
'". ,
,
.
,


. , , ,
, , , , , ".
, '^' . ,
,
.

,
, ,
, , .
.
-

Ol

87

. ,
. ,
.
,
, . ,

. ,
, . , ..,
. Godelier, . Lefebvre J.
Baudrillard,
.
.
. , , L. Benevolo, . Tafuri
. Frampton, \)
,
.

, , , .


, , ,
. , F. de Saussure,
status , ,
, -

88

. ,
15 ,
, , ,
'^. , Christopher Alexander 1964
,
,
, "-.
, . Hillier. , , :
: '5. Geoffrey Broadbent,
. Chomsky, (1974) ,
-
'*. , J. Bonta,
Saussure Prieto,
(1973) '7.
. Charles Jencks, ..,
,
, '8.
^ . ,
J. F. Lyotard J. Habermas".

.
1979 London School of Economics, -

89

Popper, Lakatos, Kuhn Feyerabend^o. , , ,

.
.
Husserl , Heidegger ,
Bauen, Wohnen,
Denken 1951,
. Christian Norberg-Schultz.
1963 ,
, 1971
^'. , Genius Loci: , , , Heidegger^z. ,
Norberg-Schultz,
, .
Dasein Heidegger .
Norberg-Schultz ,
O.F. Bollnow, . Merleau-Ponty G. Bachelard,
Herder, Hegel, Marx, Jaspers, Piaget
Popper. Norberg-Schultz ,
,
. ,
' , .
, ,
, ,
-

90

:

^^. ,
. - G. Gadamer
. Ricoeur .
Gadamer ,
, . ,
.
Norberg-Schultz , ,
, , .
,
. , . .
,
, Jacques
Derrida, ,
' , .
, , , , , 40 , , ,
. . , ,
,
^^. ,
, ^ ^ ,

Ol .

91

.

.
, ; ,
, ; .
, , , , . , , . , , .

1. Vitruvius, I, . I, . 1 3.
. . Morgan (Vitruvius, The Ten Books on Architecture, Dover Publications, Inc.. New
Yorlc, 1960).
2. . I, . 1, . 7.
3. . . Panofsky, Suger, Abbot of Saint - Denis, 1081-1151, Princeton, 1979.
4. . Panofsky, Gothic Architecture and Scholasticism, London, 1957.
5. J. Rykwerl G. Leoni: L. . Alberti, Ten Books on Architecture, Tiranti, London. 1955.
6. I died iibri dell' Architetlura di M. Vitruvio, tradutti et commentati da Monsignor
Barbaro, Vinezia, 1556.
7. Quatro Iibri detr ardiitettura, 1570. . ed. Hoepli, Milano, 1951.
8. L'Architecture, essai sur art, 1780. . ed. Perouse de Montclos, Paris, 1968.
9. (Einfhlung)
Th. Lipps (1903, 1906) , , ..,
Henry van de Velde. (reine Sichtbarkeit)
Konrad Fiedler (Schriften Uber Kunst, 1896). , ,
. Wlfflin, . Riegl, Aug. Schmarsow W. Worringen To Abstraktion und Einfhlung
(1908) .
(Gestalttheorie) \) . Wertheimer, W. Khler . Koffka

92

1920 1930, R. Arnheim. >

. . (. ) . TEE,
, 1940).
10. 19 ,
.. Berlage, ,
J. . de Groot. ,
, . . Shoenmaekers
De Stijl, Le Corbusler ,
Modulor. .
11. . : (. . ), 5/1971, . 27-90, (. . . ), 6/1972, . 86-141,
7/1973, . 130-147.
12. . , , .
. . , , , 1980, .
, . 1985.
13. Chr. Alexander. Notes on the Synthesis of Form, Harvard Univ. Press, 1964.
14. Chr. Alexander et al.. A Pattern Language, Oxford Univ. Press, 1977.
15. B. Hillier and A. Leaman, Space Syntax: a Formal Sketch (.), 1974, .
Hillier and }. Hanson, The Social Logic of Space, Cambridge Univ. Press, 1984.
16. G. Broadbent, "The Deep Structures of Architecture", G. Broadbent, R. Bunt, T.
Llorens (eds). Meaning and Behaviour In the Built Environment. Wiley, 1980.
17. J. Bonu, "Notes for a Theory of Meaning in Design", G. Broadbent et al (eds), ..
18. Ch. Jencks, The Language of Post-Modem Architecture, Academy Editions. London,
1977.
19. J.-F. Lyotard, La Condition postmodeme. Les Editions de Minuit, Paris. 1979.
JUrgen Habermas, "Die Moderne - Ein unvollendetes Projekt", Die Zeit, Sept. 19, 1980.
20. Marios Camhis, Planning Theory and Philosophy, Tavistock Publications, London, 1979.
21. Chr. Norberg-Schultz, Intentions in Architecture, Allen and Unwin, London, 1963,
Existence. Space and Architecture, Studio Vista, London, 1971.
22. Ch. Norberg - Schultz, Genius Loci: Toward a Phenomenology of Architecture, Rizzoii,
New York, 1980.
23. Vassiiios Ganiatsas, Permanence and Change: A Philosophical Inqulty Into the problem
of relating new architecture to existing settings (.), 1987.
24. A. M. . . University Studio Press,
, 1985.
25. . , . ,
, 1990.

Martin Heidegger

Heidegger
, ' ' .

(Der Ursprung des Kunstwerkes)'
, ,
1935-1937.
Heidegger^
. '
^
.
, ^.
' , 5, , .
(Ding)
(Zeug). : ; , , , , . ,
, , , .

- -, . ,

. ^ ,
- ^,

' ' . Heidegger
' ,
'" .
", ;
Heidegger : ' ) (), ' ) ,
' ) . , '^ , .
-
(ens creatum)'^-, () (Zeuge),
(Vorhandene).
, , ". dv's.

.
, .
. ' .

, (Seiend).
, , .
. ,
". Heidegger

 Manin Heidegger

95

Van Gogh' .
.
.
,
. , ,
.

, .
''.
, , ,
.
, ,
, ^. Van Gogh . ^'.
, .
-
- . .
,
.
(Insichstehen)^^ , ^^ ' .
Heidegger .
(Streit)^* . . .
Heidegger . ^^
Hlderlin.
(Gevriert)26, , .
^'',
, -

96

, .
Heidegger .
Heidegger

, .
.
Heidegger
,
,
-.
.
.
Heidegger
^ .
, , . . ,
. , , , ^'.
. . , . ,
.
' . ' , ,
, , . .
^. j q
. , , Heidegger
.

 Martin Heidegger

97

^ .
,
,

.
Heidegger
' ,
. , .
, , .
^' ^.
Heidegger (Stoss). '
, ^^ . ,
,
Kant, ^^ .

, ,
' 35
. , ,
.
Heidegger
,
^.
: , ,
.
, , .
.
Heidegger -

98

.
' '^. , ^
, | - \) hic et nunc .
' ,
Heidegger. '
.
,
.

adaequatio^s ,
.
.

, . ^^, .
,
, .
' .

(Gegnerschaft des
Anwesens)40 ' .
,
. , , *^ .
Heidegger
, .
, .
Heidegger
^^.
* .
,
.

 Martin Heidegger

99

to . ^^
-
'',

. . ,
. Heidegger '^ .
'' , '
. . . '
. .
, , , "^,
. .
, , , , . , Heidegger, "
, .
. , , <. , ',
( . ' '. ^^ . Heidegger ,
.
^^
^^ .
. '^

'.
.

100

57 .
^, . '
, , , , ' ,
.
Heidegger
' ,
.
. '
, . Heidegger
.
, Jean Wahl, ^.
,

. , , . , , , -
Heidegger,
- ' .

1. . Holzwege.
2.
:
mid, Erluterungen zu Hlderlins Dichtung, Frankfurt 1963".
Holzw, Holzwege, Frankfurt 1963*.
Hum, Uber den Humanismus, Frankfurt 1947.
SuZ. Sein und Zeit, Tbingen 19631".
TK, Die Technik und die Kehre, Pfullingen 19632.
VA, Vortrge und Aufstze. Pfullingen 19673.
Holzw, ..

 \) Martin Heidegger

101

4. '.,. 7.
5. . .. 210-212. . . V/, 2,22, 36-37.
6. Holzw, . 8.
7. '.,. 9.
8. '.,. 9.
9. .
10. Holzw, . 10.
11. '.,. 12-19.
12. ' ., . 20 . . Ericti Rothacker, Zur Genealogie des menschlichen
Bewusstseins, Bonn 1966, aa. 201-209.
13. Holzw, a. 19.
14. 5uZ, 13,.61.
15. Holzw, a. 11.
16. ' ., a. 22 .
17. '.,. 25
18. '., a. 22 ^.
19. '.,. 18.
20. '., . 25.
21.
'.,.29.
22. . ., . 46.
23. . ., . 33.
24. . ., . 37 .
25. . V. Vycinas. Earth and Gods, The Hague 1961, . 133-173.
26. VA, .2, . 25.
27. Holzw, aa. 31 36.
28. . Wolfgang MUller-Lauter, Mglichkeit und Wirklichkeit bei Martin Heidegger.
Berlin 1960, . 94-98.
29. Holzw, aa. 31 37.
30. ' ., a. 35.
31. ' ., a. 53.
32. Rilke, Heidegger, , ' . .
Otto Fr. Bollnow, Rilke, Stuttgart 1956^, . 115.
33. ,. 45.
34. Holzw, a. 55 .
35. Evfl'avtr., . 57-58.
36. G. W. Fr. Hegel, Vorlesungen Uber Aesthetik, .1, . 403-404 (Smtliche Werke, . 12,
. . Glockner, Stuttgart-Bad Cannstatt 1964').
37. Holzw, a. 59.
38.
'.,.25.
39. ' ., . 49.
40. ' ., . 42.
41. Hld, . 42.
42. . . . , , 1964, , 6076.
43. Holzw, aa. 47-48. . . ., , 98Ia 24-27.
44. Holzw, . 60 .

102

45. '.,. 64.

46. .
47. Holzw, . 60.
48. m/d. . 39.
49. Uo/zw. . 59.
50. SuZ. 58, . 286.
51. Holzw, . 60-61.
52. SuZ. 34, . 160.
53. HId, . 35.
54. Hum, . 45 47.
55. HId, . 40.
56. '.,. 38.
57. '.,. 35.
58. Holzw, . 61, 302-305 343 Aus der Erfahrung des Denkens, Pfullingen 1965^, . 25Hld, . 40.
59. Hld, a. 35.
60.///77, . 521.
61. Hld, . 35 Hum, a. 17.
62. . Jean Wahl, Philosophies of Existence, London 1969, . 7-8.

 M.

To . ;
. : - -
, .
, ,
, , .
'
.

,
, .
: ( ) ( ).
, ; .
; ; .
; ; , , , ; -

104

,
. , ,

- , ,
. ,
.
-
Bach , - . .
, ,
;
: ; '.. ,
-,
; : ''
, ; ;

;
. , - : '' '.
, ' ,
status ;
,
; Vermeer

;
,
;
, ' , ;
;
.

; ,
; , ,
-

To . ;

105

.
(^ ; Vermeer
, ; ,
;
; ' ,
.
. , , Vermeer

. .


.

,
. , , , ,
.
. .
, ' ,


, ,
. , a priori ,
; , , , . , Kurosawa Fellini.
, , , , ,

106

, .
, .. Kandinsky Picasso, .
,
, . !,
! !.
, .
, ,

.
\|)
.
, , ' ' . .
.

. .
.
,
.
.
.
,
, , , ., , ,
.
.

.
* . . -

To . KoVxpxm ;

107

.

.
( ),
, , .
. . ,
.
. '' , , , . ' , ' '. ' ^.
,
. . ,
, , .
.
.
.
-


-
, , . '
' , ' , , .
,

108

xat

.

, ,
.
.
.
. Wittgenstein -^, '.
, ;
', !'; . , '
,
, , .;
,
, , , (' , , ) ' , ' ,
: , , , , . ,
, ; , ,
. - , , . ,
. ,
, ^

, !, ! .,
.
, , ,

To ;

109

, . :
; ; : ; ' ', ,
, ; ' :

;
; ;

.
.
Beethoven
,
. evr
- ,
, .
,

, . ' , .
, ,
. : ,
. , ,
. ,
, '
( ).
' .
Beethoven , '
, ' , ,
. , ,
' ,
, ,
. , -

11

.
,
.
' (
). '
. '
'' .
, .
.
( -.. . ,
. , , ,
.
^.
.
, ,
. .. - la Adorno-

Schnberg ,
, ,
(.. ),
, ,
, . ' ,
, . ' ,
, ( , ). ,
.

To . ;

111

contrapposto .
'' ' ' . ,
'
.
.

va . ,
, '
, ,
.
, ..,
,

. , , ' ' ,
, .
, , ,
, .
, , \). , ,
. , .
(, , II
)
,
, ' , ,
. . , ..,
Michelangelo , , , .
,

112

, , ,
. .
, . to .
. (norms)
.
-
. ,
.

1. . Wittgenstein (
, , 1977), . 261 (209): ... '... ' ;'... ", - '...
' '' . 262
(210): ;
, XI .... ( - , , Blaclcwell, 1967).
2. , , ' .
3. Lectures and Conversations on Aesthetics, Psychology and Religious Belief, compiled
from notes taken by Yorick Smythies, Rush Rhees and James Taylor, Cyril Barrett (ed.).
Blackwell, Oxford 1978, . , , 1977,1. 23, . 142.
4. , . ,
. .
5. . . 1S7,9, i4.

To . ;

113

6.
. " ( ) . '
, , . ,
. ; , .
,
'' .
, ' , "Autonomy and Death of the Arts", Philosophical
Investigations, 13/1 (1990), . 5-8.
7. . L. Wittgenstein . , 1984, . 41, 197,

, 192,212.

! .
. ^, 19
20 (. Loos, De Stijl, Bauhaus, Le
Corbusier ..) 1920 . 1928
CIAM^,
, ,
.
, " (, , )
.
, W. Gropius, Bauhaus, Le Corbusier,
F.L. Wright Mies van der Rohe, , .

, , -

116

eeoigCa

, . F.L. Wright,
( ),
, .
Le Corbusier
, , Mies van der Rohe , , Less is more. W. Gropius, 1945, , Bauhaus
"
.
, ,
, , ,
, , ...,
. '
-, , , , , ..- - , ,
- , , .- . . :

' .

, : Firmitas, utilitas, venustas.
-
- , venustas, , , . -
- ,

 Movtva

117

. . F.L. Wrighf
: Form follows
function. , ,
' : .

. -
Information Theory Informationsacsthetik. , , ,
,
(= ) .
,
. .
' ,
,
.
, . (= )
(= ) , '". ,
, ,
..
, , ,
.. ,
, ,
.
, , -, -

118

- '
, .
,
: )
) , ,
'. '
. , . ' ,
.

:
(= , ),
. ..
.
( ) .
, , .
(= )
.
,
,
, .
( ,
),
( , , ..

119

,
. J. Polaert, 1866-83). :
.
- .
(firmitas).
. venustas
(= )

.
(utilitas).
, .
. Hannes Meyer, W. Gropius Bauhaus, ' : , ' . ' W.
Gropius ' , . Meyer
,
^.
, , , . , . , (), (). -

- , ,
.
. '


,
, .

120

- ,
.

- '^- .
..
,
.
, , 160 bit (binary '-).
, -
. '5 , bit 100 ( ), 25 35 bits .
. . Le Gorbusier , , Modulor'.
,
,
.
, Moduior.
:
;
Moduior Le Gorbusier .
. Le Gorbusier,
- (. Aalto, . Breuer, . Niemeyer, .
Saarinen, L Utzon, F. Candela, L. Nervi ..) (-

121

), .
().
, : , , . '?, , , , .
,

. ' ( '60), , . , '
.
.
,
.
-,
, . , , ,
.
, , .
.

R. Venturi", Complexity and Contradiction in Architecture, '

122

,
. , , , ...

.
20 ,
, , .
, Venustas
, ,
; ,
, .
: . ,

,
-
- .

1. Me
( 1920 ,
. , art nouveau, art
Deco, .. . ; .. , 19-20 :
, /, 1986, . 140 |. . : .. , , , , . : , /, 1983,
.7|.
2. . , 20
, , 1977.
3. (Congrs International d'
Architecture Moderne), 10 , 1928 1956
, , . S.
Giedion, Raum, Zeit, Architektur, Ravensburg, 1964, . 420 |.

123

4. . .. , 19-20 ... . cit., . 193 .

5. . ,
. (....) "
, . . Hoesli : . Hoesli, Architexte, Druck Reprozentrale E.T.H.,
Honggerberg, a.x. . 56 |. : Entwerfen lehren. : Werk,
Bauen + Wohnen, Nr. 3/1983. Hoesli
, : Tatigkeitslisten, Platzbedarfsstudien, Nutzungssystemdiagramm
(NSD), Raumsystemdiagramm (RSD), ein Bauwerk... gestaltet wird.
, .
.
, . Hoesli Grundkurs ...,
. . Kramel. Kramel
(der Bereich der Gestaltung),
: wir versuchen die Form des Baues aus der Logik der Konstruktion herzuleiten. .
H.E. Kramel, Die Lehre als Programm, G.T.A./E.T.H.Z., Zuerich, 1988, . 11.
6. . R. Scruton, The Aesthetics of Architecture, Princeton, N.L, 1979, . 58.
7. ... Form follows function has become spiritually insignificant: a stock phrase... Form is
predicated by function but, so far as poetic imagination can go with it without destruction,
transscends it... Wright : Form and function are one, : ... nor any more scientific than sentient... . F.L. Wright,
The Future of Architecture, Horizon Press Inc., N. York, 1963, . 234.
8. . M. Kiemle, Aesthetische Probleme der Architectur unter dem Aspekt der
Informationsaesthetik, Quickbom, Verlag Schnelle, - 1967, 1960.
9. (Sign, Zeichen) . . . Kiemle, op. cit. . 15: Ohne Kommunikation
gibt es keine menschliche Gesellschaft and ohne Zeichen keine kommunikation... Das
wesentliche des Zeichens besteht darin, dass es... einerseits auf Gegenstaende und Relationen
der realen Objecktwelt, anderseits auf Bedeutungen, d.h. Bewusstseinsfunktionen verweist...
Ch. Morris (Foundation of the Theory of Signs, Internat. Encyclopedia of
Unified Science, Band 1 Nr. 2; Univ. of Chicago Press, Chicago 1938, . 1960, . 6) :
) ( )
) ( )
) ( ).
10. . , Kiemle, op. cit., . 55 .
11. . . Kiemle, op. cit., . 110 .
12. . . , . , , , . II, /, 1993, . 270.
13. , , . . , - , . , 17/1935, . 464 . .

124

(), , 33-36/1937. . ,
, , 1984, . 193 *. ) *
,
<) .
14. bit (= binary digit =
). . . Kiemie, op. cit., . 23 |.
15. , , : 1) Kurashiki (. Kenzo Tanze,
), 2) Tyrone Guthrie,
Minneapolis, Minnesota (. R. Rapson) 3) Buenos Aires
(. S. Elia, P. Ramos Agostini Clorido Testa. , , 160 130 bits . .
. Kiemie, op. cit., . 99 |.
16. Le Corbusier, Le Modulor, 2 , Boulogne - sur - Seine, 1948-SS.
17.
, : Neo-Art-Nouveau, Neo-Gaudi, Neo-De Stljl,
Neo-Expressionismus, - . Decorativismus, Folklore, Plasticity,
Adhocismus, Metaphorismus, Situationismus, New Brutalism, Neo-Manierismus, LateRationalism, Realismus, Relativismus, Kontextualismus, Regionalismus, Empirismus, Show Functionalism. Konzeptualismus, Stnikturalismus, Metabolismus, .. . .. , 19
,... . cit., . 198.
18. . . Hoesli, Architexte, op. cit., . 61: So sieht man kleine selbstdeklarierte Eliten.
Die Architekten wissen voneinander, aber sie sind voneinander getrennt... und bewegen sich
wie Auserwaehlte iii einer selbsgeschaffenen Realitaet, welche vom Rest der Gesellchaft getrennt ist
wie eine Insel in Meer...
19. R. Venturi, Complexity and Contradiction in Architecture, New York, 1966. . .: , . . , ,
1979.
20. , . Ch. Jencks, Modem
Movements in Architecture, (Penguin Books), Harmondsworth, 1973

:
;

,
ne varietur. , ,
, ,
>. , . , . , , , ' , ,
, , , . , ,
, ' , , ' ,

, ' , ' . ,
, , , ^, ,
' ,
, , '
.

126

)cai

, , , ' , ' ,
, ' .
, , ,
,
, , , ^. , ,
, ,
, , , . , , , ,
, ,
. , ' ,
, '
, , , , , .
, , , ,
,
, .

,
. , , , , . , .. , , ' , -

 : <}(;

127

(, ,
*
) '
,
, , ,
' . ,
,
. , '
:
, '

, , , ,
, .
. ' ' : , Wagner Siegfried , ,
Siegfried^.
. , ,
,
,
.
, , ' , Olivier
Messiaen , ,
Wagner, ,

, ,
.
, (, ; ),

' ,
, .

128

xat 9E(QCa

. Beethoven , , ,
; , , , ,
.
: , ' ,
; .
' ,
'
, ,
,
, ' (' , ) ,
.
. ' , ,
\(> minimum optimum,

' . , '
. ,
, , , , , '
' , '

, ,

 : ;

129

, , ' , '
' .

1. Hermann KOLLER, Die Mimesis in der Antike. Nachahmung, Darstellung, Ausdruck.

Bern, Francke, 1954.
2. np. ., , , 655 d 1., ., 5, 1340 a 3 11 39.
3. . . , Alternative Processes in Artistic Creation, Proceedings of
the 8th International Wittgenstein Symposium (Kirchberg am Wechsel, 1982) 1, Wien,
Holder, 1984, . 107-113.
4. . TOY , Les structures de l'imaginaire dans la philosophie de Proclus, Paris,
Les Belles Lettres, 1985, . 45 . . . . GRABAR, Plotin et les origines de 1'
esthtique mdivale, L' art de la fin de I' antiquit et du Moyen ge, ., Paris, Collge de
France, 1968, . 15-29.
5. . . , The Whispers of the Woods. Listening to Nature's Music,
The Reality of Creation. New York, Paragon Press, 1991, . 163-168.
6. , , , , - ' , ,
\|)
.
, ..,
Sinfonia domestica Richard Strauss. '
Bolro Ravel, (
, ,
( ;) ,
.

. ,
.
'.
^.

^.

,
,
. , ,
, , ^. , .
\| , ,

132

)cai

,
, , , , ,
, ,
. , , ,
, , ' '
'.
, ' ,
,
,
, .
,
, ,
.
,

, .
' ,
,

, ,
, '',
, '
,
. .
,
, ' , ,

133

, , ,
, ,
, , . ,
.



'". ,
,
.

,
,
,
, ,
, ,
, , , , , , '
, ".
, , ,
'2, ,

, ,
. ,
, .
, . , , , ( ) . ,
, -

134

)cai

, ,
,
,
. ,
, , ,
, , , . . ,
, )
,
'^. , ,
, , ''.
.

: , ,
,
.
, ,
. , ,

'^.
, , ,
, ,
, , , ,

-

135

, , ", , , ,
,
,
,
, , .


, , , '^,
.

1. , .
2. .
3. .. Forster. E.R. Dods, (:
1978). F. Galton, Inquiries into human Faculty
( 1883). ' , . ,
: , , ...
4. . Koestler, (,AW\\a, 1976). .
5. .
.
6. .
, '
, .
7. .
. , .
8. ,
. .
9. ,
. ,
.
10. ' ,
, .

136

)cai

( , ' , ,
,
, ,
, .
G. Kepes The New Landscape (:
1956). To (Hafnie).
11. ' , DNA 10'".
12. ,
. , .
12. Koestler, ..
13. , ,
:
... ,
,
,
, .
13. Koestler, ..
14. , , , , , , , ' , .
15. , ,
.

:
;
, , : ,
, , .. -
, ,
. : .
: , , ,
, , ..
' , . - .
: , , , ... ,
, .
, , (.. ), . Donoghue
',
^. , : . , -

138

)cai

, ,
. ,
.
( , ..)
' ^,
, ' .
, ,
: , ,
. ,
, ; ,
; ( ,
) ; ; '
. . , ..
, , ( , ), .
, !
.. (
!), .
, (.. , ) ( -: , , , ) : ,
. , ( )
:
.. .
.
. ;
. .
. *,

 - ;

139

': ,
.
. .
, (). '
. '

. /
, , , ,
, , ..
. ,
, , , ,
,
, '
,
.
!

, : .. :
-... ! . ..
,
- .
'',
( : ) .
, ( ) - . , . .
(
) : ( ), ,
. ,
' , , , .
.
,

140

)cai

, , ,
'.
: ,
' . (.. ) -
( ) . : .. ", , , , . ;
,
, '
.
, .
'2, ,
.
, .

'-. : , ,
: ,
. ( ) , . ,
Respublica Litterarutn - '^. , :
'.
, , ..
( ) - , ..:
, , .. , ' -

 - ;

141

, , ". ,
(. . )
'.
; ..
. Munch' .
, , .. (.. , '
), ; . (.. )
Munch .
, - .
: ,
; ^, ; ;
; ' ; - , .. , , , ; , ' ; .
; ;
( );
,
,
^',
' ^^, Hobsbawm.
. ( - ) . ' . , (, , ) . ( -- ) -

142

)cai

( , ),

, . , . . , .

. . ,
( , , , ...) ( )
: ' , , - .
, ; ,
' . , -
.
, , ,
, ,
, ,
, '

- 23_ ,

^-
, ^^. 180 -
OHE 12 .
(.. , , ) , , .
...
...^'.

 - ;

143

, ,

(, , ..)
. ( ) (, , ..), , . , ,
, ( ) '
(.. ) -

: .
, ,

28,
.. ^'.

, Brodsky,
^.

(), ( ),
,
, .
,
,
( DNA
Homo Sapiens ), ; ( ) ; ;
( , ..)
. ,
, , ,
- ^'.
, -

144

3(

- 32. , .
, :
- , , .
,
; ,
, ' , ,
; , ' . , , , . , . ...
33 .
: - : , -, . , ,
^.
- (: -) .

1. Denis Donoghue, The Cherishing Bureaucracy, THE LISTENER. , 2.12.1982,

. 10-13. . 12.
2. John Hemdon, Mediamind: the electrolysis of thought, VORTEX No IV-V, ,
1989, . 5-6 . 40-44, . 40.
3. ..(. I). . 12.
4. , , . 2, - 3, . 5,1990.
5. . .
: ,
, 1.3.94 (. , , . 20,
27.2.1994).
6. . . . , , .
, , 13.5.1979.
7. .. . , , 25.11.90, . 5, 2.12.90, . 6.
, .

 - ;

"'S

8. : ( )
( -- ) ,
-
( ) .
9. , ..., , ', 5, . 7784, . 77.
10. .. (1820.5.1994) .
11. , ,
, 1980-90.
12 . , , , 1986, .
13. , GREEK VOICES IN AUSTRALIA, . Pergamon Press,
1985,
, . , 1985.
14. Nicole Olller, VOIX HELLENIQUES DANS LE MONDE ANGLO-SAXON DES ETATSUNIS D'AMERIQUE, , Doctorat d'Etat, 1994.
15. : (. , , 1976)
( ). ; ,
,
() (14.2.1977).
16. , , 50.
17. ..
, . : For many years I have followed the fertile writings of Rois
Papangelou... More recently I have believed he is really useful to the Greek 'Respublica
Litterarum' and perhaps of great importance. Because of the nature of the modern Greek
'Diaspora', the provinces and the exiles have supplied what the centre could not so easily
produce: Cavafy in Egypt, Kalvos in Exile, Tsaloumas in Australia and Seferis who could not
have existed without Smyrna or without France. So I suppose it is normal for Papangelou to
have lived and worked in England, and yet to have something to contribute to Greek life.(.
, . , 1987, . 9,
. 11).
18. Breyten Breytenbach, : I've a split mind about the notion of exile... It's a very sterile
category to be fitted into (. Hilda Bernstein, THE RIFT,
. Cape, 1994). . .. ( )
Wole Soyinka, . ;
19. Edvard Munch, 1863-1944, ,
.
20. (, , ..) , , .,
. (, , ).

146

)cai

21. Eugen Weber,'Imagined Communities', TLS, no 4569, 1.11.90.(7. 11149.

22. . J. Hobsbawm, NATIONS AND NATIONALISM SINCE 1780: PROGRAMME,
MYTH, REALITY, CUP, 1990.
23. P. , The Poet and his Reader - An irreverent look?. 9 , , 1987, (
) LE POETE & SON LECTEUR, series Louvain
Cashiers No 75, 1988, . 99-105, . .
24...{(}.23),. .
25. ,
...: '
' ' (),
(. , , . , 1983,
. 48, . 19. 1, 161, . 1984, . 281-282). ,
, , .
26.
(.. , ),
, .
(, , ..) . : () 20

- -
: -
-
- . .
. 50 ( , 18 (. John Pilling, AN INTRODUCTION TO 50 MODERN EUROPEAN POETS, Pan
Literature Guides. 1982, pp. 468).
27. Peter Paret,'Heart of Darkness', TLS, No 4650.15.5.1992,0. 13.
28. Cyril Connoly, HORIZON, , 1950.
29. : other than the poet himself and the people that people his poem.
P. 9 , .. (. 23), .
105.
30. Joseph Brodsky, 'The Poet, the Loved- one and the Muse", ,
, . 11.1990. TLS, . 4569, . 26.1990.
31. Ren Wellek & Austin Warren. THEORY OF LITERATURE. Penguin/PeregrineBooks.
London 1976. pp. 374, chapter 5, 'General, Comparative & National Literature', a. 49.
32. ,
, : . , - () ,
, 49. 1992. . 3395-3413.
33. . , 7. :
(

 - ,

147

: '
),
34. .. (. 15).

)
, ,
.


,
1827'.
, , . '


(.
,

, . , oqxi ,
, de
Stal, {IS\4).

150

)cai

- : , ( ) - .
: L.P. Betz, Heine (1895).
-: , , , .
, ,
. ' , ,
^.

, ,
.

, . , . ,
( )
(explication de texte)
.
, ,
18 , .
,,
. ,
,
. ,
,
. ,

 7<)

151

, , .

,
.
,
, . -, . ,
, ,
. ,
, : , . ' , , . ^.
, ,
.
.
, ,
' , ,
. ,

, '
, , ' , . -

152

)cai

.
, , ,
(, ) . , , ,
. , .
,
. , , .
.. , ,

, ".
( ' , .
,
, , , .

, ;
' ,
,
.
-

7<)

153

.
-
. . Ian Mukarovski, | .
.

5.
.
'.


, ,
' . ,
, , , ,
, .
.

, ,
.


' . , ' .



. ' -

154

)cai

, , . . Roman Jakobson,
, , .
,
.
, , .
, . ,
, , .
, , ,
,

''.

, .
Rezeptionaesthetik
,
.

,
.
. -

 7<)

155

, , , 3 ,

.
.


. .
,
,
.
,
, . ,
,
,
.
,

. :
.

1. Weltliteratur
Eckermann, , .
-

156

)cai

to . . Yves Chevrel
, La littrature compare. Paris P.U.F. (Que sais-je?), 1989, . 27.
Armando Gnisci, "Verso un
nuovo concetto di letteratura nazionale-mondiale" Quademi di Gala, 5-6-7 (1992-93) .
135-140.
2. . }. Dumesnil, Voyageurs franais en Italie depuis le XVJe jusqu ' nos Jours. Paris,
1865, : Claude Pichois, L'image de la
Belgique dans les lettres franaises de 1830i 1870. Paris, 1957.
3. . Yves Chevrel, .., . 97-117 Lubomir Dolezel, Occidental Poetics.
Tradition and Progress. 1990, University of Nebraska Press.
4. . , , , 1988, . 33 ..
5. Jochen Schulte-Sasse, Thorie littraire, Paris, P.U.F. 1989, .
289.
6. : A.J. Greimas, Smantique structurale, Paris, P.U.F. 1966
Claude Brmond, Logique du rcit. Paris, Seuil, 1973.
7. Ol H.-R. Jauss, Pour une esthtique de la
recption. Paris Gallimard, 1978 W. Iser, L' acte de lecture. Thorie de !' effet esthtique.
Bruxelles. Mardaga, 1985.
8. . Mario Valds, Why Comparative Literary History? :
Comparative Literary History as Discourse. In Honor of Anna Baiakian. Peter Lang, BernParis, 1992, . 3-20.
.

.

:
;
( )' . .. (
) (
) , ^.
. , . ,
, , ,
, ,
(, ) ^.

. ; ; , , .
; .
.
;
. ,
-

158

)cai

.
, , , ,
^.
5 , ,
.
.

, .
,

,
,
.
; ; :
;
,
.
.
,
. ,
: ,
,

''. ,
:

.
, (Oscar Wilde) -

159

,
(The Picture of Dorian Gray) :
.

. .
, , , .
,
.
,
, ...
, , , , ,
,
.
:
...

[: ]."
,
, . ,
.
, , . '2,
.
(: ) . ,
( )
virtuosit .
,

160

eeoHjta

: ,
,

3. :


'-.
. ,
, .
,
,

, .
, (Plekhanov),
- - 5.
, , . . ,
,


' '.
;

; ,
. .

, .

161

, ..,
' ,
'^.
,

. :
i) .
) , ,

.
iii) , .
(iv) . :
.
.
'
(
)

.
, ,
. ,
. , (
) (
)
.


1994 5 6 -

162

SiJje Marie Kedergaard, 5.

, , . Ame Poulsen

'.
, ,
. '
, , , .
; . , (
) (
) .
, x m ('
)
".
( )
^. , . ,
, , ^. , ,
, , ,
22.
,

. , -

163

;
,
, ' ^.
(
)
.

: ,

, .
,

.
.. , , ,
.. ,
! .
, . ,
, .
. , , , ^-.
,
.
.
, ,
.
, -

164

3(

, .
.
: - - ) ; .
,
;

, . , , . , , ,
, . , ^.
, '


. .

1, . ' , , , ,
(, (J. Hospers), (The Encyclopedia of Philosophy), P.
Edwards (), Macmillan Publishing Co., Inc. and the Free Press, New York-Collier
Macmillan Publishers, London 19722, 1-2, . 36).

165

2. .: olei, , , 6
; ' ti xaind.

( 8, S, 19-21. .: , ,
^; , '
; . : 2\6. 20\b, 204e ..,
452e).
3. . . (Imm. Kant), (Critique of Judgement),
. . (J. C. Meredith), Oxford at the Clarendon Press 1988'', a. 96,
102, 106, 107, 109, III, 112. Oi . : 249,254,257,258,259,261,262, (Kants Gesammelte Schriften), Preussische Akademie der Wissenschaften, 1900-1956.
4. . . (S. Kmer), (Kant), Penguin books 198712, . 193, . :
. , , . ., . 224-225,354.
5.
. : .
6.
& .
. 470e, 489e,
6.12 ... 3.5.19, 8.48.6,
316.
7. . , . , :
. .
. ,
. .
. , ,
*. (. , .
, 1978, . 215).
8. . . (John Wilcox), ( ]
("The Beginnings of 'L'Art pour L'Art'"), The Journal of Aesthetics and Criticism,
11 (1953), . 360-377.

(Irving Singer), [ ] '
', ("The Aesthetics of 'Art for Art's Sake'"). The Journal of Aesthetics and Art Criticism,
12(1954), . 343-359.
9. (Oscar Wilde), H (The Picture of Dorian
Gray), Ta (Complete Works of Oscar Wilde). Collins London
and Glasgow 1988, a. 17.
10. 10D. = 11D.-K.
11. , . .
12. ,
, . ,
. .. , , 1994, . 78-83.
13. .. (R. G. Collingwood) (The
Principles of Art), Oxford University Press, 1958', . 298.

166

3(

14. , ("English Renaissance of Art"),

xat (Essays end Lectures), London 1909, . 128.
15. r . (G. Plekhanov), , (

), 1975, . , . 19-26.
16. . , . , , 435 (1945), . 636.
17. . 398, 568b, 1602c-608b 5-50.
18. . Time, 44 (1994), . 20.
19. . .. , H .., . ., . 118-119.
20. . 1 605c6-605e7.
21. . . 387d-388a.
22. .. , , . ., . 119.
23. , , (
IV3,1448b) ( 5,1).
, ,
. (. .. , ,.., . ., . 119126).

, , . .

-
.
. (. ... , . , . ., . 86).
24. .. (T.S. Eliot),
. . "" , '
(..
, ("Religion and Literature"), (Selected
Essays), London 1932, . 343).
25.
. ,
,
. . ..., . ., . 66-67, 78-91. 116-126,
166-170, 175-176.

! .

1.
, '
, ' : (
) - (
-).
'
. ,
, - -
.
,
( ),
( ),
: ,
( ). ' , ( ).

168

eecagta

-, , .
-, . , . :
, (, , , ,
),
-- , -,
, ' ( )
.
; .

2.

, , .
( ) - ( );
, , (--,
) :
( - ) , - /| .
,
- .
( )
.- , ( ) ( )
. , , (Goethe).
, , , , ' -

169

: , , ( ) . , * (
...)

3.

- , , , .
' - ,
( ): ' - , ' , ' ( ) - .
.., , , Stephen Spender ( ):
,
,
,

.
, '
,
'
- ( '
). ' :
)
, "";
) , ;
' , - .
: (-

170

) - ' ,
.

4. BaoLx

,
( ),
. , ,
:
. (
' - !)
, - .
,
( ' '
- ). , , '
(' ), (' ), -
(, , ,
, , '
).
'
3.
.

171

172

5.

' :
.
, -
- : ' , - . - (' - ).
,
(' - - -).
- ( , , ): ' - , '
. ,
, -
,
-.
( ).
.., ,
.
, '
- .
- ,
- , . (' , , ' ).
' ( )

,
: , -

173

.. , ,
, ... - ...
, '
, - : .. , ( ' ) ' '
' .
' -
,
.
/ , . ( ), ,
optimum: -.. ,

- (' )
-
( )
- , ..
, , ' , . , '
, -.
' ,
- ( ) , .
' 3.

6. - ;
( ) -

174

eecoQto wtS

, * ! - .. : - . - ( ) '
- . .
,
( - ), - ' .
, . ( ) ( , ).
, : '
,
. ' , , -
, - , - .
'
! ,
, ( ) .
, .
, ,
.
, , ' . , ' - ,
. ,
, . - ,
()
() . 2 ! .

175

... ! 2 ( )
,
.
, , . ,
( ).
, - ..
,
, .
.
.
. -
. ,
( + ) .

,
' - .
, - . . Mies Van de Rohe,
() ( )
,
( ).
Louis XVI
'
, ' .
, - !
' .

. -, '
' : , . '

176

; ' . , ; :
- , :
- ' ,
- . .
- , , .
- ,
.
' , ( )
( ) , . ,
- , ()
, ' ' ...
, ' , :
, - ,
: , ' . ( ). , ,
: ,
- .
, - . , ,
. , , . , ( ), - , '
. , ', ' ... . , -

' - . ( )
.
. /
, ' - .

, , ,
, Theoretical
attempts for the aesthetics of engineering structures, (. 18011816, . , , 1991) . . .

Martin Heidegger
:

, ,
;
,
, ( )
, .
. , '
.
, :
(1927) 1935/36
1962 : ^,
,
1950 1954 : ^.
, : (: das Dinghafte)
,

180

.
1927
, ; , '
(: Zeug), ^. '
,
,
,
: , ' , ...
, ,
' a priori ,
. - ,

. , - .
, . ,
,
.
, (..
-

 (<> Martin Heidegger

) , , , .

, ,
,
, .

,
:
( : ) ( : ) ",
. : ,
,
.

, ,
.
,
. ,

. , ,
,
. -

182

, ' -
.

. ,
:
. ;
,

. , ,
, . , ' ,
, , . .. , ,
. ,
,
, '
, ^. , -
.
; !
, ' . , -

 Martin Heidegger

183

, , ,
. :
.

. : .
, .

1. Martin Heidegger: Die Frage nach dem Ding. Zu Kants Lehre von den transzendentalen
Grundstzen, Tbingen 1962.
2. Martin Heidegger: Das Ding, in: M.H., Vortrge und Aufstze, Pfullingen 1954.
3. : Johann Tzavaras, Heideggers Unterscheidung zwischen Zuhandenheit
und Vorhandenheit, Philosophisches Jahrbuch 96 {\9&9), 367-371.
4. : , -- , - 1986, . 40 (= Holzwege 1963, S. 14).
5. .. . 56 (= Holzwege 1963, S. 23).

:
;

, , / (Crafted Object), '
( ( )
'.
Josiah Wedgewood , Richard Slee - Victoria and Albert Museum^- (
/ ) ,
de dicto .
Design ,

.
'70
: ^.
heavenly goods ( -

186

eecoCa

) high design,
: . , , , .
,
, Edinburgh Tapestry
Company, Eduardo Paolozzi, David Hockney Helen
Frankenthailer, (). - - ".

(tableware) designers Addre Powel Nan Swid (1982)
Museum of Art
Museum of Modern Art^.
ready mades
,
'
, ' .
, Duchamp, , , ,
(
Duchamp R. Mutte)
'.

, ' , a priori, , - .

/
,
.
,
, -

 : ;

187

,
, de
dicto .

.
Brancusi ,
Majastra,
.
. ,

. ,
de re ,
.
, , . ' , .

1. Gillian Naylor, The Arts and Crafts Movement. Pottery, London, Trefoil Publications,
1990, no. 149-59.
2. J. Williamson, The Victoria and Albert Museum, London: Victoria and Alben Museum.
1990,00.85-91.
3. Adrian Forty, The Objects of Desire, Design and Society: 1750-1980, London: Thames
and Hudson, 1986, aa. 11-28.
4. Peter Dormer, The Meaning of the Modem Design. Towards the Twenty First Century.
London: Thames and Hudson, 1990, . 116-117,122,128-133.
5. Penny Sparke, An Introduction to Design and Culture in the Twentieth Century, London:
Unwin and Hyman, 1989, aa. 191-196.
6. H.H. Amason, A History of Modem Art, London Thames and Hudson, 1975. . 145146,312-313.
7. X. X0VOQ T. , . : , . 4, 1993, . 136138.
8. , , : , 1992, . 88-119.

. '60 (1)
- '
(2) , (3)
.

,
. ( )
.
E.B.Tylot ':
, , , , ,

.

190

0E(OoCa

Max Weber ^
, ,
,
- , . .
, Hegel, Croce, , . . , , , ^.


.
Raymond Geuss:

, :
.
. ,

.

. (. , , ,
.) .
:
,
. ,
,

.
,
, ,
.

0QOL

191

modernus modo hodiemi,

, . : 1900
' 1960^.

Pop Art 1960.
Ihab Hassan . , ,
Arnold Toynbee (1939) '
, ,
, ^,
.
Joseph Hudnut (1945)
^,

, Pevsner (1966)
[ ]
. Charles Jencks 3.32 .. s 15
1972, Pruitt-Igoe St Louis.

:
,
. Hegel
, Nietzsche
( )

192

Weber, Nietzsche,
(Zweckrationalitaet),

. '
:
Lukcs, Heidegger (
\|) ) ,
1960, Levinas Derrida ,
, .
:
Heidegger,
Adorno, Derrida.

Morawski", -
- .. Adorno
,
-, , '2. , ,
, ... , , , , '^,
. Michel Foucault, Nietzsche,
- , - ,
, -

(, , , , - .) , , , ,
.
1960
Wittgenstein . 1962 Thomas Kuhn -

193

, ,
: ,
, (). , , , .
Feyrabend {1915)
anything goes.
. , Weber . Morawski''
- . ,
, , , ,

. '
Habermas .
, ,
: (..
Rorty' ) , .. (Foucault. Derrida,
Deleuze, Lyotard): Habermas , , Huyssen ,
, , ''. [:
Habermas -, -.]
/ , : () () ,
,
" () -

194

Nietzsche Heidegger ,
, , . . . ' G. Vattimo
".

:
.
Weber :
[] ,
[]
( Habermas^o).
.

, . Duchamp
Dada, , ,
. Adorno
,

^', , , , ^^. , Habermas
- [.] ,
^^.
, Greenberg Fried,
^.
\|)
( ) .

 leoXxsvta

195

,
- ^^ Daniel
Bell. Lyotard
, :
-^. , Jencks,
: ,
, ,
, ".
:
Disneyland,
^. , ,
, ^'. , 1960 |)
, . '^,
.
,
* ,
, - .

, .
Geuss ^',
; ^
(Jameson) (Habennas), , ,

196

0E(OoCa

^^. ,
Jencks, [. ]
,
.

, [ ]
... [],.. ,
''.

:
,
:
.
Clement G r e e n b e r g ' s ,
Fried'
' , ' \ .
Adorno, ,
^', ' ^, , Buerger,
.
,
''. , , , 20 : -
,
.

197

>>.

. Jencks
' [ ], ' .
: () '! ,
- () . ,
-. '
Hutcheon'^ .
, ' , , , , -^.
. ,
John Barth -.
,
. .. Beckett , Adorno ( '''),
, David Lodgers.
Beckett .


, Duchamp :
Pop Art ;

( ),
.

198

)cai

\| Andreas Huyssen
[] ^. , . , ,
:
(1) , 0

. ,

, (
) .
(2)
,
. ( )
, ,
. , 19 , (
) .
,
: ; ; ,
, , ;

1. Raymond WILLIAMS, "Culture and Civilization", Encyclopedia of Philosophy, ed.

P.Edwards, 1967, vol. 11. a. 274.

199

2. WILLIAMS, ..
3. John PASSMORE,"Philosophy", Encyclopedia of Philosophy. 1967, vol. 6, oo. 219-223.
4. Raymond GEUSS, The Idea of a Critical Theory Cambridge: University Press, 1981, o.lO.
5. Margaret ROSE, "Defining the Post-Modem". Charles
JENCKS, The Post-Modem Reader London: Academy Editions, 1992, : PMR, a. 126.
6. ROSE, 0.JI., 0.123.
7. ROSE,0.n.,o.l21-l23.
8. ROSE. ....24.
9. Juergen HABERMAS, .
:
. : , 1993 (1985), . 79.
10. Richard J. BERNSTEIN, The New Constellation. The Ethical-Political Horizons of
Modemity/Postmodemity. Cambridge: Polity Press, 1991, . 36.
11. Stefan MORAWSKI, "On the Subject of and in Post-Modernism". British Journal of
Aesthetics, 32, Jan. 1992, . 53.
12. Vincent DESCOMBES, Le mme et l'autre. Paris: Les Editions de Minuit, 1979, .
126-27.
13. Victor BRGIN, The End of Art Theory. Criticism and Postmodernity. Atlantic
Highlands, NJ: Humanities Press International, 1986, , 32.
14. David HARVEY, "The Condition of Postmodernity". PMR. 1992, .
305.
15. MORAWSKI, .., . 52.
16. Richard RORTY, "Postmodernist Bourgeois Liberalism". Journal of Philosophy. 80 (10),
1983.00.323-328.
17. Andreas HUYSSEN, "Mapping the Postmodern". PMR, 1992, . 61.
1984. .
17. Harold Brown, Rationality. London and New York:
Routledge, 1988.
18. Gianni VATTIMO, La fin de la modmit. Nihilisme et hermneutique dans la culture
post-moderne. Paris: Seuil, 1987 ( . 1985).
19. BERNSTEIN, .., . 11
199, Stimmung- Stimmung , --
[Dasein] - Heidegger
(Martin HEIDEGGER,
Xqvo, 1927. . . , ' , : 1978, 29, ' . Uowiva: 1985) , ,
. ,
. . Richard RORTY, "Deconstruction and Circumvention". Crif/ca//nqu/ry, September 1984, vol.11. No. 1,1-23.
20. Juergen HABERMAS, "Modernity: An Unfinished Project". PMR, 1992 (1981), . 162.
21. Peter BUERGER, "L'anti-avant-gardisme de l'esthtique d'Adomo". Revue d'Esthtique, n.s., 8,1985, a. 88 ..
22. Raymond GEUSS. "Review of Aesthetic Theory". Journal of Philosophy, S3. 1986, a.
736.
23. HABERMAS 1992, "Modernity...", .., . 167.

200

)cai

24. Michael FRIED, "How Modernism Worlcs: A Response to T.J. Clarlc". Critical Inquiry,
September 1982, vol.9, No.l, . 228 (.16). "Art and Objecthood" (1967)
George DICKIE Richard SCLAFANI, Aesthetics: A Critical Anthology.
New York: St. Martin's Press, 1977, a. 435. Clement GREENBERG, "After Abstract
Expressionism" (1962) , . 425-437. ^
GREENBERG "Modernist Painting" (1961) Gregory Battock: The New
Art: A Critical Anthology. New York. 1966, . 100-110.
25. Daniel BELL, The Coming of the Post-Industrial Society". PMR. 1992 (1973), . 251.
Robin MURRAY, "Fordism and Post-Fordism". PMR. 1992 (1989), . 261-Tit.
26. Jean-Francois LYOTARD, . . .
; , 1993 (1979), .26.
27. Charles JENCKS, "The Postmodern Agenda". PMR, 1992, . 11 ..
28. Talcott PARSONS Winston WHITE, " ". H . ; , 1991 (1960), . 187-190.
29. BURGIN, .., . 5.
30. HUYSSEN,.H.,O. 50.
31. GEUSS, 1981, Ue Idea of a Critical Theory, .., . 84.
32. MORAWSKI, ., . 54. HARVEY, .., . 311 ... Fredric JAMESON,
"Postmodernism and Consumer Society". In Postmodernism and its Discontents. London and
New York; Verso, 1988, . 13-29. "Postmodernism and the Cultural Logic of Late Capitalism". New Left Review 146, 1984. Terry EAGLETON, "Capitalism, Modernism, PostModemism", Against the Grain, London: Verso, 1986, . 131-148. HABERMAS, 1992, .
167-68. -, Bell, .
33. Jim COLLINS, "Post-Modernism as Culmination; The Aesthetic Politics of Decentred
Cultures". PMR, 1992, a. 99. 1989.
34. Charles JENCKS, "The Post-Avant-Garde". PMR, 1992, a. 224.
1987.
35. . Clement GREENBERG, 24 .
36. Michael FRIED. "How Modernism Works...", .., . 223.
37. BUERGER, .., . 85.
38. To GEUSS, 1986, "Review of..", .., . 736.
39. BUERGER, .., . 88.
40. Paolo PORTOGHESI, "What is Postmodern?". PMR, 1992 (1981), . 210-214
COLLINS, .., . 96-110.
41. Vernacular, Jencks, vema =
, vemaculus = , , . . Vemaculaire, Petit
Robert.
42. Umberto ECO, 'Postscript to The Name of the Rose". PMR, 1992 (1983), . 73-74.
43. Linda HUTCHEON, "Theorising the Postmodern: Towards a Poetics". PMR, 1992
(1988), . 86.
44 HUTCHEON. ..,. 83.
45. David LODGE. "Mimesis and Diegesis in Modern Fiction". PMR, 1992(1990), . 195.
46. John BARTH, "The Literature of Replenishment: Postmodernist Fiction". PMR, 1992
(1980).. 178.
47. Rainer ROCHLITZ, "Esthtique et rationalit d'Adorno Habermas", Revue
d'Esthtique, n.s., 8, 1985, o. 61.

48. LODGE, .., . 195.

49. HUYSSEN, .., . 59.

201

, ,
. ' , , , , , , .
',

. , ,



Tccrv.

. * .
. , ,

204

)cai

.
'. ,

. '
.
, ,
,
. .
. , , ,
.
.

II
,
, , , . , , ,
. , ,



.
, ,
.
(, . Kant, ..,
,

To

205

^,
. ,
. , ,
3. Kant
, , , , .
Kant .
, )| .
", ,
. -, ' ' '
,
. , . ,
.
', . , ' , .

,
()
, . ,
.
, ,

206

)cai

, ^ ,
.

,

. ,
' , '.
,
, ,
. , , . .
. .
Lukcs, , Kuhn,
, - -

. Lukcs ,
- , , -
Kuhn ()
, ',
.
,
, * ( ,
.

, .

III
19 ,
F. Delbrck: , '".

To

207

,
.
, ,
. , ,
, , ,
.
,

.

.
.
,
". ,
, ,
Lukcs, Adorno
, , .
'^,
, .
, ,
, ,

. ,
. ,
, , , .
Lukcs'^, ,

208

xat

, , , , , . ].
,
. , ,
,
.
Lukcs
. - - .
, Lukcs , , . , . , Lukcs ,
,
Marx, Engels, Lenin Stalin. ,
. ,
, ,
. Lukcs .
, ,
. , , .
Lukcs - '
- ' Adorno,
. Adorno
, - -
< . ,
,
-

To (yyo ,

209

. , - -
,
, Adorno, , .
. , ,
'^.
Adorno
. , , , ',
. , ,
'^, , .
, '
' , ,
,
.
Adorno - . . Adorno

, ' .


".
Adorno
. , ,
,
. BUrger, .., Adorno
1920 1930, ^. BUrger, ' , - -
Adorno. , ,
-

210

)cai

. '
, ,

.
,
.
. . a priori , . Damnjanovic, .., ^',
Piepmeier ^^, . Eco, | , , 23.

IV
,
,
.
^-, , , .
, ,
, .
,
,
. , ,
. , , , . : '
.

To >^(}

211

, .

1. . . , ,
, 1976, . 9.
2. 1. Kant, Kritik der Urteilskraft, Hrsg. von K. Vorlnder, Hamburg (Felix Meiner) 1963,
aa. 155 . |., 157.
3. 1. Kant,
. 163. . . Moutsopoulos, forme et Subjectivit dans I' Esthtique
Kantienne, Aix-En-Provence 1964, a. 182. Kant . . Chronis,
The Evaluation of a Work of Art: Common Sense or Intersubjectivity?, , 14 (1986),
. 102 ..
4. . F. Schelling, Philosophie der Kunst. Schellings, Werke, hrsg. v. M. Schrter, . 3,
Mnchen 1965, . 389.
5. . . Chronis. Beauty as a Cause: Condemnation or Justification of Art?,
40(,9(1981),.82. |.
6. G.W.F. Hegel, sthetik, Hrsg. v. F. Bassenge, . 1, Frankfurt a.M. 1955, . 110.
7. G.W.F. Hegel, Phnomenologie des Geistes, Hrsg. E. Moldenhauer - K.M. Michel,
Frankfurt a.M. (Suhrkamp), . 12, . 18.
8. G. Lukcs, Heidelberger sthetik (1916 - 1918), Werke. . 17, Darmstadt (Luchterhand),
1975, . 9.
9. . Kuhn, Die Ontogenese der Kunst, sthetik, Wege der Forschung, . XXXI, Hrsg.
v. W. Henckmann, Darmstadt 1979, . 117, . 114.
10. F. Delbrck, Das Schne, Berlin 1800, . 29.
11.
.
, , . . . G. von Bayer, The Aesthetic Equation, The Sciences.
1990, . 4 . .
12. . . , , 6, KB ', ,
.. . ., . . . . (1993), .28. .
13. G. Lukcs, sthetik, 1,2. G. Lukcs, Werke, . 12, Neuwied (Luchterhand), . 627.
14. G. Lukcs, sthetik, . ., aa. 219 . . , Probleme des Realismus. I, G.
Lukcs, Werke. . 4, Neuwied (Luchterhand), d. 627.
15. sthetische Theorie, Hrsg. v. G. Adorno - R. Tiedemann, Frankfurt a.M. (Suhrkamp)
1990, 516.
16. .., . 391.
17. . ., . 532.
18. . ., . 521.
19. . ey., . 533.
20. . W. Oelmllller (Hrsg.), Kolloquium Kunst und Philosophie, 1. Paderborn 1981, .
215.
21. M. Damnjanovic, Es gibt Kunstwerke - Wie sind sie mglich?, W. OelmUller (Hrsg.),
Kolloquium Kunst und Philosophie, 3, Padenbom 1983, . 59.

212

22. R. Piepmeier, Das Werk der KUnste, W. OelmUller (Hrsg.), .., a. 71.
23. . Eco, ElnfUhrnng in die Semiotik. Autoris. dt. Ausg. v. J. Trabant, Mnchen 1972, a.
151.
24. . . Baugh, Prolegomena to Any Aesthetics of Rock Music, The Journal
of Aesthetics and Art Criticism, 51,1 (1993), a. 23. . D. Roberts. Art and Enlightenment:
Aesthetic Theory after Adorno, University of Nebraska Press 1991, . 224.