Coss Horizontal Stirling engine was a project just beyond the reach oI my technical skills. Iound this engine on the cover oI the Nov / Dec 2005 edition oI the Home shop machinist.
Coss Horizontal Stirling engine was a project just beyond the reach oI my technical skills. Iound this engine on the cover oI the Nov / Dec 2005 edition oI the Home shop machinist.
Coss Horizontal Stirling engine was a project just beyond the reach oI my technical skills. Iound this engine on the cover oI the Nov / Dec 2005 edition oI the Home shop machinist.
I originally Iound this engine on the cover oI the Nov / Dec 2005 edition oI The Home Shop Machinist. I hadn't really paid too much attention to it as I thought it was beyond my capabilities. I was also deep in other projects at that time. In February 2009 I started looking Ior a project; something just beyond the reach oI my technical skills. Beyond, because it would challenge me and push me to learn and reach beyond my comIort zone. It made sense to build Irom the bottom up. I wanted to build in the same order as assembly - I didn't want any parts on hand that couldn't be attached to another part. The Frame or as Terry calls it, the Tuning Fork was Iirst. BeIore I start cutting, I print the part oII the Cad program and make sure that the size and location suits my mill and material. I also use it to zero the mill on the material. Then let the Iun begin... The Iour extra holes on the leIt side are pin holes to align the Frame and the base. Next came the pillow blocks. The basic dimensions are the same, sort oI, but I did not split them but rather secured the bearings in place by way oI a setscrew down below. Terry advised not to do this as it distorted the bearing enough to induce a bit oI unwanted Iriction. But, once I installed these lovely (and rather expensive skate board bearings), along with the Ilywheel, a quick spin oI the Ilywheel showed that it would spin Ior a very long time indeed. The pillow blocks are also attached Irom below with button head cap screws. Coss Horizontal Stirling http://www.ldrider.ca/cnc/coss-horizontal/coss-horizontal.htm 1 oI 7 7/07/2010 9:45 AM Created by PDF Generator (http://www.alientools.com/), to remove this mark, please buy the software. The Ilywheel isn't quite to the drawing dimensions. The only piece oI aluminum on hand that came close to being the right size was a bit too small. But, it works and probably won't aIIect engine perIormance...I hope. As with all oI the parts, they are only wet sanded to a moderate Iinish. Once everything is built and the engine running, I'll wet sand everything down to about 1000 grit and either leave raw or anodize & dye Ior a bit oI colour. The Cranks bear almost no resemblance to the drawings. The mill Iinish on the sides is rather poor here. The product oI using an end mill that was a little too short and the non-cutting edge spent too much time rubbing the aluminum. Fortunately, it sands out rather easily. They will be secured to the shaIt with No. 4 set screws. Jeez those things are small. These were eventually sent to the recycle bin. See new crank arms below. Next came the base. There is no base in the drawing and is presumably just leIt up to the builder to design. You can see the same alignment holes in the base as in the Irame above. They will also be added to the cylinder which joins the base to the Irame. Coss Horizontal Stirling http://www.ldrider.ca/cnc/coss-horizontal/coss-horizontal.htm 2 oI 7 7/07/2010 9:45 AM Created by PDF Generator (http://www.alientools.com/), to remove this mark, please buy the software. It's starting to look a bit like the picture on the magazine cover. Next comes the body. First one side is milled and drilled. You will notice along the top, three .125" holes Ior index pins. This allows the work piece to be removed Irom the mill, Ilipped over, and precisely repositioned Ior milling and drilling the other side. Because this piece is not symmetrical, the drawing must also be Ilipped beIore creating the cut paths. A piece oI MDF is next clamped to the mill and three matching .125" indexing holes are drilled. Then three .125" x .400" pins inserted. Now the part can be Ilipped over and laid on top oI the MDF with the index pins exactly aligning with the holes in the part. You normally don't want to expose MDF to moisture but the work is all done in an hour or two and that's not enough time to adversely aIIect the MDF. The second side is now milled and the part cut out. Note the nice Iinish on the edge this time Irom using an end mill oI with the right length Ilute. Coss Horizontal Stirling http://www.ldrider.ca/cnc/coss-horizontal/coss-horizontal.htm 3 oI 7 7/07/2010 9:45 AM Created by PDF Generator (http://www.alientools.com/), to remove this mark, please buy the software. Everything is Iitting just Iine so Iar. The drawings call Ior the Power Cylinder Retainer to be at the outside end oI the power cylinder. There is a caution in Terry's article that over tightening the power cylinder retainer bolts can distort the cylinder. Perhaps somewhat misguided, but my sense is that iI the retainer is closer to the Body, and using shorter bolts, there is little or no chance oI distortion. So I recessed the retainer a bit to accommodate a slightly reengineered power cylinder. As it turned out, I leIt the hole the original size which was the same diameter as the cylinder ID whereas it needed to be the same diameter as the cylinder OD in order Ior it to slide over the cylinder. It gave me the opportunity to mount a mostly round part in a Iour jaw lathe chuck, center it using a dial test indicator, and opening the hole to the correct size. I knew theoretically how to do this but had never attempted it beIore. Remember what I said about pushing my limits above ??? You may not be able to tell but the Iit oI the retainer against the Irame at the Four o'clock position leaves just enough room to slide a cigarette paper in there. As they say, sometimes it's better to be lucky than good. I also like the more Iinished, less industrial look oI button head cap screws in many places like on the cylinder retainer. Notice the enlarged hole compared to the picture on the leIt. Coss Horizontal Stirling http://www.ldrider.ca/cnc/coss-horizontal/coss-horizontal.htm 4 oI 7 7/07/2010 9:45 AM Created by PDF Generator (http://www.alientools.com/), to remove this mark, please buy the software. The Power Cylinder was next. A couple years ago, a neighbour was moving out oI his house and practically gave me loads oI machinist tools. In one box was a bunch oI drills. Really big drills. This one, just under 1" Iit the taper on my MyIord Super 7 lathe and saved me a whole lot oI time with a boring bar. I haven't used a boring bar a lot but they don't call it boring Ior nothing. This shows how the cylinder was cut leaving a shoulder on it to Iit inside the retainer. The cylinder still need the diameter reduced to 1.375" to Iit inside the recess oI the body. Lapping will wait until the other cylinder to Iinished. The retainer stands proud oI the body a little too much at this point. What I had in mind was closer to about .050" or so - just enough so I was certain that the cylinder was Iirmly seated against the body. I may reduce the shoulder on the cylinder. But then again, maybe not; it actually doesn't look too bad as it is. With such short screws there is no chance oI distorting the cylinder. The cold end cylinder was the most time consuming. Grooving the exterior with the parting tool took the longest. Lots oI tool chatter which, no matter what I tried, would not go away. I took this procedure extremely slowly so as not to end up with a lump oI scrap aIter so many hours. Hot end, cold end, and retainer completed except Ior holes. Coss Horizontal Stirling http://www.ldrider.ca/cnc/coss-horizontal/coss-horizontal.htm 5 oI 7 7/07/2010 9:45 AM Created by PDF Generator (http://www.alientools.com/), to remove this mark, please buy the software. Displacer piston connecting rod. That end mill is .020" and is just used Ior lettering and similar Iine jobs. The rod may end up being too heavy and have to be re-cut in aluminum. The bearings are router bearings Irom the local Iine woodworking store. The power piston was certainly one oI the Iussier parts to make so Iar. It needs to Iit the cylinder extremely closely yet slide smoothly. The Displacer Piston Barrel This is a very thin piece. The Iirst one I made, I cut oII a little long expecting to Iace it oII to exact length. It was too thin to hold tightly enough in the lathe chuck and when the cutting tool touched it, the end crumpled and ended up looking like a Cabbage Patch Doll. The finished Displacer Piston. Sometimes, I Iind that parts like the end caps can be made more accurately on the mill than the lathe. The thin .150" material is way too thin to grip eIIectively in the lathe chuck. I could have turned them Irom a thick rod but the parting oII process may create its own issues. For me, at least, the mill was just as Iast, more accurate, and required minimal touch up on completion. Coss Horizontal Stirling http://www.ldrider.ca/cnc/coss-horizontal/coss-horizontal.htm 6 oI 7 7/07/2010 9:45 AM Created by PDF Generator (http://www.alientools.com/), to remove this mark, please buy the software. I just couldn't quite get used to the crank arms I made previously. I saw one something like this on another engine and designed and cut these. So much better and in tune with the rest oI the engine I think. Updated: April 11, 2009 Finishing touches to Iollow Coss Horizontal Stirling http://www.ldrider.ca/cnc/coss-horizontal/coss-horizontal.htm 7 oI 7 7/07/2010 9:45 AM Created by PDF Generator (http://www.alientools.com/), to remove this mark, please buy the software.
From Vision to Version - Step by step guide for crafting and aligning your product vision, strategy and roadmap: Strategy Framework for Digital Product Management Rockstars