Miami Debate Institute 08Permits Neg
Permits Neg
Permits Neg ..................................................................................................................................................................................................1Strategy Notes ..............................................................................................................................................................................................7** Topicality ** ...........................................................................................................................................................................................8T – Incentives 1NC (1/2) .............................................................................................................................................................................9T – Incentives 1NC (2/2) ...........................................................................................................................................................................102NC Overview (1/3) ...................................................................................................................................................................................112NC Overview (2/3) ..................................................................................................................................................................................122NC Overview (3/3) ..................................................................................................................................................................................13AT: “We Have Lots of Contextual Evidence” ............................................................................................................................................14AT: “We Have Lots of Contextual Evidence” ............................................................................................................................................15AT: “Cap and Trade Is Predictable” ...........................................................................................................................................................16AT: “Cap and Trade is Core Topic Ed” ......................................................................................................................................................17AT: “We Still Link to Your Offense” .........................................................................................................................................................18Ext: Mandates Are Distinct From Incentives .............................................................................................................................................19Impacts – Ground .......................................................................................................................................................................................20Impacts – Ground .......................................................................................................................................................................................21Ext: Their Authors Wrong/Interp Bad ........................................................................................................................................................22...................................................................................................................................................................................................................23** Generic Solvency ** .............................................................................................................................................................................23Permits fail empirically ..............................................................................................................................................................................24Permits fail – empirically ..........................................................................................................................................................................25Permits Fail ................................................................................................................................................................................................26Permits fail – Other countries ....................................................................................................................................................................27Permits fail – Offsets bad ...........................................................................................................................................................................28Permits fail – Offsets ................................................................................................................................................................................30Permits fail – No Accountability ................................................................................................................................................................31AT SO2 means permits solve .....................................................................................................................................................................32 No Solvency – Carbon Caps fail ................................................................................................................................................................33 No Solvency - Cap and trade doesn’t encourage AE .................................................................................................................................34Upstream Good ..........................................................................................................................................................................................35Upstream good ...........................................................................................................................................................................................36Downstream fails .......................................................................................................................................................................................37AT Banking adv .........................................................................................................................................................................................38AT: Banking Adv .......................................................................................................................................................................................39AT Bali ......................................................................................................................................................................................................40AT Bali .......................................................................................................................................................................................................41
www.miamidebate.blogspot.com
1
Miami Debate Institute 08Permits Neg
Bali Conferences Not Working ..................................................................................................................................................................41Safety Valve block intl markets .................................................................................................................................................................42Permits = market manipulation ..................................................................................................................................................................43Grandfathering bad ....................................................................................................................................................................................44Permits increase emissions ........................................................................................................................................................................45Permits increase emissions ........................................................................................................................................................................46Permits increase emissions ........................................................................................................................................................................47Permit
leakage /c tax solves ..................................................................................................................................................................48Permits
leakage .....................................................................................................................................................................................49Permits = Rent seeking = wars ..................................................................................................................................................................50Permits = cheating and corruption (terrorism IL) ......................................................................................................................................51Permits = cheating .....................................................................................................................................................................................52Permits hurt trade .......................................................................................................................................................................................53Permits = Biz as Usual ...............................................................................................................................................................................54** Politics/Elections Links ** ...................................................................................................................................................................55Cap/Trade helps Mccain ............................................................................................................................................................................56Cap/Trade hurts Mccain .............................................................................................................................................................................57Cap/Trade hurts McCain coal states ..........................................................................................................................................................58Cap/Trade hurts Mccain base .....................................................................................................................................................................59Middle Class Link .....................................................................................................................................................................................60Cap/Trade hurts Obama .............................................................................................................................................................................61Cap/Trade Unpopular .................................................................................................................................................................................62Climate not key to election ........................................................................................................................................................................63Obama will do the plan ..............................................................................................................................................................................64McCain won’t do the plan ..........................................................................................................................................................................65Politics Link cap pop tax unpop .................................................................................................................................................................66C tax popular ..............................................................................................................................................................................................67**** States CP **** ..................................................................................................................................................................................681NC States CP ............................................................................................................................................................................................69States solve generic ..................................................................................................................................................................................70States solve cap and trade ..........................................................................................................................................................................71States Solve Cap and Trade ........................................................................................................................................................................72States Solve Cap and Trade ........................................................................................................................................................................73States Solve GHG Emissions .....................................................................................................................................................................74States Solve Carbon Tax ............................................................................................................................................................................75States
Fed policy ...................................................................................................................................................................................76States solve intl coop .................................................................................................................................................................................77
www.miamidebate.blogspot.com
2
Miami Debate Institute 08Permits Neg
States solve intl ..........................................................................................................................................................................................78States can link to intl markets ....................................................................................................................................................................79States can link to intl markets ....................................................................................................................................................................80States Go Global ........................................................................................................................................................................................81States cap trade now ...................................................................................................................................................................................82State cap/trade now ....................................................................................................................................................................................83States solve warming ...............................................................................................................................................................................84SQ Solves ...................................................................................................................................................................................................85AT no state cooperation .............................................................................................................................................................................86Federalism U ..............................................................................................................................................................................................87Perm links to federalism ............................................................................................................................................................................88Aff – Perm for States CP ...........................................................................................................................................................................89** Carbon Tax CP ** .................................................................................................................................................................................90Carbon Tax CP 1NC ...................................................................................................................................................................................91Carbon Tax CP 1NC ...................................................................................................................................................................................92C tax Generic solvo ....................................................................................................................................................................................93Pricing feasible ...........................................................................................................................................................................................94C tax solve over time .................................................................................................................................................................................95C tax solve emissions best .........................................................................................................................................................................96C tax solves innovation .............................................................................................................................................................................97Carbon tax solves innovation .....................................................................................................................................................................98C tax solve competitiveness .......................................................................................................................................................................99C tax most equitable .................................................................................................................................................................................100C tax upstream solves ..............................................................................................................................................................................101C Tax solvency - faster .............................................................................................................................................................................102AT C tax doesn’t reduce CO2 ..................................................................................................................................................................103US leadership on C tax solves .................................................................................................................................................................104US leadership on C tax solves .................................................................................................................................................................105US leadership on C tax solves .................................................................................................................................................................106C tax solves global ...................................................................................................................................................................................107C tax solves Bali better ............................................................................................................................................................................108Tax more feasible intl ...............................................................................................................................................................................109Price stability solves trade ........................................................................................................................................................................110C tax solves Competitveness ....................................................................................................................................................................111Border adjustments solve .........................................................................................................................................................................112Permits = rollback ....................................................................................................................................................................................113AT Biz con ................................................................................................................................................................................................114AT Biz Con ...............................................................................................................................................................................................115
www.miamidebate.blogspot.com
3
Search History:
Result 00 of 00
00 results for result for
p.
More From This User
Notes
Load more
