Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Case - Toyota Production System
Case - Toyota Production System
Producttun System
Ii
II
U
.i" ..
U
L
f11n .~
Jlf;fI!('O.~.1
,.i ~f"
.I'}u.II.n.
ICFA' ·C_1fir ~~ ~run~_ " .~;i'~W I{lCl'fR.l " ''''",m~¥.! ~ Itt- ,~~ 'JI.' t1i~ hm:u far ~ • llliIoYffQ ~m:h«tlm,j' hI' ~nl.!'iI~[,lrlh·l .,.~ -:d' .i~fJr.'Ic!l'" .~w of (~1Nl.~f'"M.""1 ,drutlur''ij
."j~ ~.~~
"rh.b
.t'ml"C'
"''O.~InrJf/k IJiQfJ#/J!.!.'!'
mo< ,II.,..
j .'~
tJt~·'Tlfitu:
A J_f.JI!, .5,.;w
,,-I~,r ~i~ TIl>;' 1.~f"f"l'.fil·~::''';~~I~rl BI'~""- "~iI!.i""'! ,.II~I St. ..~ II)' 1 Nt'ili11 (!..njH.:r~I!.II~HM;i~ "'~ i'~i .!:i~~~1".:4,~l:I!t ... ~ '~~m l'ji:l'1i~::t·~_~>:.rrmli"'~! 1!~~ i'H.oi·,I!.ir~!l!".::T,;:!('J~.";iii'I\W ,~h~ W!!i!'!-d.,I!I>Ijif.r .o4l~ 'IOU~~~ l~(;r.1!l).l. ,. -.dt{jir~}.I 6i ,~u :.~~~l ~Y. L'.(',('\L;!f:!o .~f.ur"·I~ ~.' ... 1 1\!liI ... @11'~ i'ftnK'II i.i!ut:.,~1,.'S"" W~I, ~tij~:" .. ",... _A..u;-:'!;!IlI~,~~,
".
.'_
~_
._
,.
t~ c(f[JH
irt lir •.
i?"
2:~~Olij.TOyt)i~U f'"lh,uulr C~'I1'CI!':iIII~DU (_~~~~'{I~~'~!lnUiU'!,l!.;:C~d~~n~ nn;u~!.:""iul_n$Ull!. for" d,.;: ~ IClildJCd M01rd~lOO;t. 1 h!.t ,oolUpiln~:'t ~!.."¥!!'Im:cs.<ll1d lopel~ung, I n~!'!lC hOlld!reacll~ rllghs _ • _ 1lr 'SI'b_J:biUdlliI' Md :S'liS ,b:illE~!}n ~I~~:cm;iilil~~y}"n:<cter' ENhib~~ n)'\"\Vii)i11 ~'~flIole"\"oEll,hl' howlll~~. ~ < ...\,"i~~"'" '!I'fa.:; th,,~~be 'Q)m~~~s !ru~~ e<!lI1iIiugs w{:re. mcwt [iJn.an double~l:1iC com,bifu:d 'l71<~reamillgSOllr ., '•.,~_ uromb:n~'rruaj",rsGencnll Mil)lG~('G'.M).IF',tQ'rd.. Dajn1rerCl1~I!'e,r., a,liIdi !-1IordiJI fiO!'" dlCll~1I"ii1lfe5l! l r.~t~ €~t€f~r~ hibli~ U l
(:1"1
f~lli
M[lr
.)-~r
(rU~'!4I~
~T,II" ~.
'1'0
W~.s. t~rml) 'C'mr,i;d~eb~d iJ.S '1J::i.'~ (l!;~11pr:r"'l't1~iOl'l;II'!!' m li:'nmpl~l1I~ Irr~'~lr,~c' ."~j~m'~.~~ha~ i'~~d'un:ry1m <lilt .. ._J 'ill Uill!~!I! ht:1ill Ihe .l1:I.'ln1 s nl Ijl!!!."'nld)U5U,} \'i" ~~. !t!i.'d.1 n,g rm~.jl,~'r ::i~mJl wn I( 'li pro!
sut!'C'J~n.g 1~~1fIlUt :S.h(~\\ jJ !'It''ld~ rrofttOlfhi~ Illm,f'il,a!h~:I.it) ~"\!!f tllile c"Om;pany a ~ (JI! iiii U~,i,! J.1.!P':III~C.~t'~c!,~:ru ~m~ a ~ \~'~lr,l',i=- tJlh~'~I!oI:aOlIII ~~(Ig]lllwhi:~!.i:'mlllild'I!JISiI'~'~~li'id hdp\\d i1 B~1i:au~'~'l i1:!I. ... llIhl~· ca'llh ~.,,,ilinu il '~a:. ilIiillL~1.0' ;'1111"":'>1n ~he dC:""\"'~fnef~l ,or,W'\\ I 'l«"h'!lfI~f)~li$ H~I." hyh:ru.l ClIg1l~ ..p'1!1,'II.... ;;tnd dl.'l d'l1ll"1 brn:m:f.. ~~"\' tii\\' rt'uth· fK~xcll • S~U'N~·, ~~~h:~l J Ini.~,I11~ hel'!~v~,:d H' hL;' n5.'~I~' e;~'
~\)I:-:n
pesiti ~!IDuf<lp~d~J.~a
stro U!1
Ih.u
tll!k'
h'U;'Id',"I-"t
.11 ].,\
~U'.~ ....
'~.t'u~
~IW .. J
IIH;~m\
emeru,
(II),
1-1
~tl:l"iUl:ll'1o[1Hn;:;.
hl..~ ht ..tll.!.:..l..lm~' 1,ln ) "ma .Kul::."· til" cflktc[l<!.:~ in "pt()(.h.lc:hm II Ll) ~ft;lIl \\ :~~.In~1f "~~i~.:o ~';'r;c I,ll! U~~I'Ii],1Ii 1'1 p:~
!Um~"'1 ":iM~·
:!\\
.ud
11'I,WII!
q~i;Jtlh
.t:;'~~"S~'!:
~Ql>1 nlll1h1i
;lIld
\,
b.
e:\iC"n:::l~mo'
/"'r
j,~.~. ~.LL\."j~~. U11~ilt'~. 'b ." .H' I.,,~I~'.\t~tJt!t:d !hl' ~lir-.·r~'~lil\ I'~.III:>_~ I~~~ 1)1.;' ·1'r-.71dU~·~I~.:lS;" o;;U'!1n ~ {ll''':;'l _ .......... h ~\.~ put I'll pl.I\.(' !II .Ih~~ l'J "I ~". J lJi>(h.Ul!~~1.:'1lh~ ~_hu:,"~luu 01 Ih~ ~(1'lnIMI'IJ ~ j;"'!'",,),(j'ulIJLlun dl.d 111,
I)~'
••"!IId.. UTi'll ~O~III~~'~ Onl'ILr..I'~" ~:~UI' (;lil"~"\~~" .,,~ ~'C"~~l~rd ~~~ ,Ih..~r ~ ~~;-UIJI u4!oJhe b:::n-rhmarl I~~ pn)l;~l!t'~\1~\"t'hl\prm:~u th"~!lItomubdc In UlIh,ISIf") _ l-ord 3J1d AM w ill~ IIp:U !I{'<k!1uwi~'iJ~~o,;:l- t,~ Iri1i:!:n~ a·~ ~ ~~I~~W~i'u!.! sup!:rio:l'ilt~ .uld~~h:n bci'!ll.I,w!!':d ii~t.~, Ifcrom ~j~ n~, Onl iiliS 'fO}'oM ,!.<.I'I({iiUI1<l:!:~ l~l'Cf ,anl1l'~iJl'''Plli~ l1udo}! ~~Sra1l1uf.'ithmril'1l!t p.~~~s O to ..no;! c:,;j j t()l~d!;' rlJ}/ aC'£!I;'~:;; ~[~ pI!~n1S. even h'l ~fI~!\ClI:I.:lC ives of iri ""ill compa nics, 1("
I:. ::ll~.!n~ffl:~cl~ I'ru:l~ tm!.:!
Iy
pa~'.
r,,~
'J o~ i!Ii~-a1 ~,"~~,\'liu~ r.lp:!di~ mild had. u~~elll1!,"(in f,prd (~hewmnd la~1 l;'!}1l1pi1:0) I~ the i:'l~~.IY J m £ I.[lb~' m~~! r.kJn:in 20i)3l.~~la~;.·sls dl.':<; la~ l!la, I,L h:ld a 'lief}' goodch<lu(;e '!lIfo'lChevi ng 'i~ l la:r@ei,of t5 IlI;.'Tal1il fm)lir~e~ :sb~,'cb}'20~ .5.. wMd~ wouM~ I'~e~p d'rsrdacc GM as ~nt: bi~ i~ RlfomD'b~k:'i'inm~·~n ~1l:e: ~~,'nri'9 .
HybrHI
~Ht!li'l!m:i
fin-us
¥\JIi!50 :!I,
h:~J.>,.,.:i
CilI~!fle
nKldd
Hyhrid ,ciiiWli~"~
'. hno "",';as' hom j'll ~'9~2: ~n·Ma';'il"dl'I.':II~i,a. Chir '\·~ie~!racl!,I~ilill& 1~lIom '!'I~r,: Nagoya 'f~t;lhrn1.'icallll'~~l Sehorl '. he, JO me . 0)" '~~nlrnn~ rtr.6:Pi V'/of.k~ (TAL W) it'li 932 Md hnentlQV~:d' on .\Q t he nUI~H;l!i{ltii¥f! bUi[n~u ~Il 1943 ;,$, an 'I'~:_'!!~·"[!.l;~j,[ctl-a.nf.l~~.r.In Ihe' l<lite 1'940:s. when h~ \~'l!iS'~r1 cilOdirge • !l)f a mi.l~:!hilm,l.i:lg, s~II~'~ ~hl~ .w~ '~'p:-,r.::~~G!111~i:p'f\cui!Olr!~.Qtl'~ Q~~II;,')o~S,'~;-~,"fJlli",~n~~'lil;;td{r ~•.naus "~~ of ~":ltl j n* .!,P' the "'!l:j~'i nl ~ 'lO IprOOUC'i: hcm~[hjju \\'~fc:ru.':Cd'ed rill 'H~~I)'
i(;. ••
~~~!~~)
C!h~tiI,t '~.
Da_~tfl;g~...
~~ ~~~ I ~
~ ~~ ~h_~~'Orlfiilil:eri~ Ji,in J3~l1' :U1IU1 ~ime as' ~' res1mh~ f"dl~ Sem.ond WiQl'ild"""aJl'" ud d:ie'..:omr;a.Jil) (bd ~. ~".~. t;nollll~ c:qn~::;d ~o'~~, b:uW ~liI~ntOIl'!~ l1JefC:f~ the ~in dmll~~ ~':to pr9dllt."C iIJ!~'.marMmliLm -.mJts l~b~C'. Gj!l'ri:AI~ ·r.lit:l!1~!Ql31<'Ind. D-liher c~~j!m:s... CU:t(!i.;~ also ~lundOO',~ '\\1de variel!" of~~s.. iilnd,'l1:ri$.I~!~'1.'d pmd!ut:t;"m In~Jlilbi~i~.r. In h~ ~pe:Ii~:"oIjO ~n 1hese f~. O~l!f'U)"~ ;nsp-~wtl:l by ~heidc.a:5, (I f IIhtl!Q fDfd~:md EdWBrd
".~ K~
.........'..i' '
~
'C~~::::,6Qt:le~fl ~~ly
'FQiOla,.
Oil ~h~~d~s of Kr!,h IrQ Toyod a, (Ki l chi~(l),. then h~d [If sys~r'liJ.~,.He e:)oi:~nn~,emed. w~th' and dcve'j o~ Ul~llu:l(k~'lo&lesto J:lro)liuC;e I:'l:eeded C0IUp0I:a:r;liFli!$ o'!;~di !i~I"'OlSiS"e:mfullit!s Iliill (! 't~IIlI~~[1 m3Jfllii)e~~o sl!!,p~nli1in;i!Jm $s(::~lIlbl)"". iihis,oo~~tii:c ~b~fldi3~J'il!ll'l ftlll,c J n s.~:;tl!!:m.The impc~'ItIs 10 lh~ d!!:~c'lo'Pme!'!it jflf'JWl" cml)~ wllien o Olllr'!!:!' visii.lOO t hI: US in 1 ~6 u] SU:I.i}. the: n1ill!!U raJ:'hlfl!1~ pr~~~. .. :r~1 fo.wel(l: by Am(;iic;!!ii! Ii:O~'U'i 15.. Y!t1K"fi in An:w."floCo1~he tV~ Mrut!k by 1t1'1I.:'n:Vi!."f!toQ' :r:liiJl~n~ i s"ySlCm filii" ;\if!~~D !;l:Jpern~~. I',Ie 1'I(H,i~!td _'Ii!!;' C!l.!>ll~O~ ~te(;~at Yditat~l~y"ilr1Pted from ~~liIIiI&ikl $hehr.. odJb:;J'y"hidil~he Si:M'r ru .. ~.t' 'S~~: .[mmodim~I.~ 1~1~lpb~ llh,~' ~11d'O;'e"$. nelk~iIIi 1fC'~rl1Ud Ih~1 Ili1:e ~!l,;!!mHl I*In1.1 for'2n ,c:ifl(',j cnl Pl1MUCl100 "~"SI'cIi!'I ,,\(m a1 ~h!! poifl~ t'tf ctlSl.Omer demiil'nd. ",'hi",h ?o!!.'OuldIhen tlctenurru: thi!: Vi'lnO!J~ I~roc~ ~fI 11~1.:' llforl~,-~iflrj. linc. tin ~t T lUVCnh\uy.
~ '9~Os!Oh!'loe~ pamied
Afler he '!:~['lllmc-d In I nyot<l""Cill.~ U~jj~P;"l OhmJi '~tHmiln~ t~fI,~~s l!d1~&t'!> ;f~raClILc:cJLI:~~ ~,t.'·"uwpod In~o Iht' (CL1IWFKilU:' Ji. '1~1'(~(Jl!(:,U0J1phTIO~upl~~, ~kliH!lodlH':i.'d ,nT;m\J A:~mIMIII., ;! W(J I '10'1."11(:'1:'1.1 Y!:I:-; cmHrf'i1 prtidUelit~n t] Lwntl~ i'e;:';, .'1.~~(1 [h\l~~ ht::(""i:I~<nc ~1;1C;' ~1~S>f;;'S.01"11.11.(: TPS. B~ I ~.l-"7~, Ohnc w..!~~ nwd~' 'If Vi ~~~' Irl,;:si·dcmj~ III'! I 9'NiL he ;;t~Ldt'tl' t Ilw rl\'!i.lmli CIlIlbnn f n fl>Iil,'~'r tll ~ ~I~c r ~'~S." h ich ~~1!.!o ~ ! ~~. p:l'Ii!'~!:I!1lt~~
1'f.l1i'~b>~,~~}il: !?r..iUP un U~!)]o-! ~n~=w"~:l!i.n~: .~~~,t.:d Iht~,"~m'~ !,I.'m. hUI 1'O].(I~i111iill !.tJ:fR Ulmu died illl p~n ,II 1o, uw (it:
If,",'m;~~~~d ~~C!,)h:d
wv~h
h~'1I~~:1~ ,.:'1n 11,..~oda I ~ .•d;:~dil J ~n 1."n411~.d inl(ll ,the t e .. t j lc f;:lfJui; busu~ (I r C3q:l!I:n II") ~ kill \ ~.mL."da PO\'l"'" 1(}tII11 rn I Q02 ~nd tou~kJ\.'tIthe P,U'CI1:1Of~m~t""~JOn or royuhll. LhJ:: TOYO(HI tiu,mp. tq:"g ~~le S3.ITH!year fn I ~ 26. S~kj'i:.lhlj 11~"~~Med ~l1alJ[OmtJ.ll(loem ~I'fd~£~oppC"d Qpera1lUll,!J \'\ h ~1f1L ~ !!hr~l.lJd l'!f'll~. TI~II::; ptC'yenH~dlhe 1rl"U!i1i fmcl!L1fe·oriil'fn:pc;1'rr~CI elettr. (Ca1'lilill:!, ~I't'I~;l'lt]O,i' ![I(') :p'fi\objemsa:~d 'rec'[ify~n.S them II ~It the tarJiest tH~r became .'H.~. imp~.H'.~rupan. inc TPS". TIH~.·$amC' ~~at.Sll.~ichi formll'd tf\~ 1
Ie} ~~~7.
\'II
nli!lcihmoy
"uyo~.,
A!JtCl,rn.,~icl.eem
WOllk),,(lr At
or
Sllildc:;hj~$""S:M Kiil;him. ~n ,ei1g~necrFrem TOkYD Uni'Vcrsily.was rtIl)n:: i'nH::ll:sn~ditl ~tQ!I!lrObiih~'~ ,!If1d enwnl!S tJ1;an flm!iJ~·s ~!Ii::ldi~le d~ bLiliil1~s. ln f929. h~ 'rm~red u:. '[he Us. and E~pt; 10 5u.idj"" 1lI:1C'~Y,r~~urifig ~\'i.i:n ~. l~j'Olii~ ~ AFI:~~ rdWTIillig Il'O' J\~l;'JIo1n iiLe ~"1t his 1m.;;: '5'1!iJo)!in_g:, ~T '~flfi ~d ,e""'FDI1fIal~iI~. ""i1!!!~ kN," ~~'5 to IlIiI3PiI,d"ilG!IJ,"t'; laem, ~JiI lit", ,,,,,~.riJy UI'l.'. Riiicfirm WR,~iJllwd his rB~11!eiI' to '~lIIn-.:ilian :,n:!loumbl~e bus11~ :9irJi"JI ii"tl91:], ~kh~
·1i!C:fJQ~ F(!rd'w~
~)~OlJrlliir ctll~1iCIJ!nd ..
o.IffiSSCIlI,bly hnc
m~1i1~r~f~.d.Y~rJi'~~1,
II
p.r9m~ neru
~~;H s,IJdau i
,,~!d
the
fli~,r;~tW
C.Q.!i·t w,!
t no
.,.
._
e:swbllslu!d
nrsl j[i~s.s~n~rt':".'br
to
prot!jl~)!~
\IJ;M
room
(:i[n:n~'lt2'
in E.pg:ll!s!ndito
r,)f<;€
m(ln"~to5cL up <I nl;;'\l\,·;:1!~~oJH, ~e ~;.I~'~I:lt:~~, Kllclurn . ,bi \,~nholl'e The VI"U, £lD~ n~~~) ¥I a~ 11i~1 :h:J 'I ~.~tfta \~h tc:h
~In~
wfli m~:d~ ml)nBlgi.og: diJi~'tcll" (If Uk:' WI~.\, \.vO!~wri uenwitl ~e:i.g;blt brn:s hMo1o.~ l e !£.ht
~l~~~w:Jflg
Ull~~ l"~mi'CT in lap."IIlI J~ikhiUlIr.a.' !l!'loo.lo _111"'&",,' 3g,;;pi:r: .. p..::Ih-~.!i~~ • rr~~';!: .;)1 FflOii I h; ~\\" J~.BII! 031\ !i:rn~~c!' ~ It'II':'~:il;~a:ll ' '-;!li!!!.lr'SCv."1l~e [rohl.\!lld Ih~i[ 'thco' pmdJucU"ll~ of the
strUf!~ ;.W'_·- E~~tl' (;~~i;"ll.: Ford pr,oout"il.ioll th.!: ':I~~1.:::;r~~'51T'idle. pmdl!tC'.~tttQ ~lUI!l.~ In
. h ;timl) 11 C hl~~,j,"'ol
r:-
h:ad
ttl ~
iuen:"I$.~d!
:S~!o.h:m_
~'Qlc
I r n wel1Jt H) OOmpel:e
f'.h~!,~n 2'
Arm","d,
I~
Ilh a
Kiidli'fn f!tlurn ..-U 'Iu ~~i~!1 .Je;,""nn]n~d w.:;Jap:l suriib:n:e W1~wru!l~~I!irt!~i~1imrW:-:rai.jhill~ fDfC~
«~_,.h,dt~iM:!m1!,Wl'thll1l"OY01a..
_---.........._,
~oOOi, F~ ai5;,' t."c.rc;ltiji@a s"~iii"m",,itC.rrc each 1P!(lCi!$S'pi'iiN!tuctTon:J,r Hit: iC).;:a.dnumii .. IO(p.t7'l~ r'"'Sl1i.!I~,rod ihenc;<;T},>ro!i;(;:S:;l in tI'.!J]rodllC~iOJl lin~. ~l1d iU tl\b r~w~t tini:"l"1lli: s;j"5H~rnC'jItMtiflidr~.i, lJ~oigh 1.IU: OllU.omd:lilie, ''oII"~iturrc: '~ SCtup m l!t~ b.te II93!Os. pii:~.~ rc,3lr' p~u~~ion brga:n ,o'mlrry :h'l 19~7.(During' ~ll~ ~~dl W1c:ul,d\Mat.l.he oomp~n',\1'i1s illli\i'ol!~ ilnb~Ud~nG. mili,tal) ~.chhl;~'C$)'- TO~fota nn.'il!d II:DU;g'h ,oom~l'i~ii(l:n. fro." :For@ ,allcl O:M.w:hidl~cere Ih~ top tar
~f<!Cll1l'f1,n
tn J.ilp;!ln :a; 1.h.iill li:IHIl'.. In 195A. :m'-I~rOJIm~(l'r Sl:rH.i!.~ h~ l~d:n:'Jr n;ol1lK, Kiiich~m n:iS u r.l1"l:c:d !p '(~P do~m;l:m.t his <,llt, l>m F'~ i T ...,~.~ ~ [!:..I ii).",. h.., \); a!i: .!loooan 'C'~p~~ fi'QrrI "L .1" ~ f LIIII\ er:;:~~) lrtd ~ v:lll:u~d i),ider: un:.jicnir.~. O \".~ ur.td~ ~'I1'ilsin~ d'n::'~rol'.
fiJI
fflll,"~oo III Kiiehito· .. fOOISh"'p~ .HT'I1 1'!'il\'C'Je!.I ~('I the US 1!.0'Slud) fo.rd·s River Rou,e n nuf~I.IfIa:'~ r;_[:~ru~·nMl~'h hit \,I.",. II'l1Pft'~d b:" ,1'Ie seale ,of Ip!I'lIHI'uc~~onl.~, <"l.ls.o rnliz.cd
UllJ!.~",' :-.h:ffi .,
U\;II 'Si~.
or m1d~·H \\ uh ..
'iot.'"\
~roll r
I~'
l11;m
jr30uring 1I~lfkl~nc,~o_:"
fh .. d~icllEd
u.~!>c-:.'
up
.::J:
~")r'"lKl1
(f'~ ,
~n1."ffi('J~·I1!CH.:'~
~h';lt d'
.tu«: m
'~'I~·.n 'Uhw~
I!~
Oh~1Lil II]dpt;"d I'l,im I n tIrH:S~"Cnlur~ .. h"L~ 1I00\·dt....:l H' ;hc L"S III
I"
Wl.J
1Q.~{,
0:, D1 .1'-
II.
r~I,I;~ th!:o.ilf!Kld~'l
:r:.
I~....I.... h ~ .~t" ~~ fu r I
~rlJlI.l u h u:h
'~:I"1;.;\lliAfl;.:diu
t:0Ir;.
sueeevsful
p:
:o.I":~~~:-
.tt1.....' I
II" (!i:'h~ilu~
I '.' u~.f ..
~."""fI'
h:r}ut;! r.r::.:.:n:!O;'d maJ UI 1.>uo.:;'I 111 the 1"~1i: ~ 'fI=-- '" hen ~h~ 01 i ~is IS made man \ IjlC.OP I~ ~h 11 le .1 i (I~ .Ha ~ C.lrs. fl"O!JUil :li"H11~:h~~.y ,\~LQn .:Ind Lurur-:a:n ~1'~ lnltl!' 'iJfli~~s .;rIm ~~ J ~ rnro f"«esMon ..ud l,tklSlo:1 Lilli: .w:~o mU!.k,:rs Su.~ler:I!'iJ t!J~e:5 t[:IG'Io~;CV"'l the c:ffidcnC1o ;amine;:uDElil~ tU. _. ,.,.",,rf1i!' Tr~$ I~el~d T c:rY·~~fl~ unce h~d:, Til is n<!uJ fil:'H;)' h1..~~!1.h'lellC'd im¢li"{;s~ fliJ Ulf,: l"PS; ~",j~PML rrrll: 5!{';[C-ITI rG.rm!!uy C~ [0 be !L.lI'!o~'nOl:$ the Til'S in i ijl1. Um:il th~l:i..i,!\,v;as, ac:l:lail'il ,af llX"hBll,il!JUb t -" '""G't: ;ullliJl-too """;i~ in T 0:-1»01.1 In 1'~'7S. ~~r(il!!!p C'f '!;Jlgi neers fOON TiOfOla.. Llndar ~h'l: .gn d~c nf Ohne, g,i'we ~.pr~if'lt,J11~n ill To ~IJ OJII ;~ TP$. 1'1111$ f'!.li'ilher il'i!~ lin (w: S}'st~IH and mllnfy ex pnl.$~.~d ',i.'!"1i:I im,erest g (e" m ing mCil.rlIl jJI bu!!l~ II T O}I'U[a bre u~; I:l T!:"S 1'0 me US
'5~m
in 1he
191!tls. when it
sal.
I.I!,p
,j1I
jGiol
Vi;ntu.~
M~.p!uf,jl.Cf'!ilfi''f~~
lnc.._ ~UMMI)
~a I qS). ~hfl:: tCliffi:P:U'l}'·5. niillwtl "''"3:S ch@!I'l!¥O ill' To) ola MO[O'f o~n~d its ~~W1"1pla1it in G~QIFg.eiOWF1'~ K':;lmutl: ..T\~~ Y~M~anr.!r
:h t'9&::!
foyc~a
fa~d'5'
man.!,1.Ca-.e:uu.IllJ,
pl=nl
~nt~
,~rb!l
m d~ 'E"<I.rl~ 10 mfdi-tWOcs
,~
~bsS!ld~liIi$CUI
l1le Mori\LeIiS"o~~ <;, Dll:~~ u:ar.. (Refer ~ibi~ ~ on lu_11 h:bnur ••!,JY~ I. n
,,~~_lf,~I'
~id
~lm~ilut~D'i- lI:e,..i;M Gg}· h!!J~m:r:s. J~,W'OlQly,rL~ O,;ul~d' ,Ja~ <md IRi~s. ~b'1 i~~oC'!d 1uJ _ :or-&f :Z~ ~R"~:,i,~,~~ o,r "fPS, gJi~~ a ... "tfdt,,~ ,~J Cirwn,glNl
nt'
its ~)W~ o~~fo,l1s. ,","'''t;''S$i\~ "'t1plI!lJ!!ipendln~ T3\fLo;:'1 Teyoda (II1liI!~u;ml."\·hofC:UJk O"'l!T:lS, U'IoC!i:nmil~:m~'·S ~rn~d!!fI1 in ~99Z+ Ix'S<'lli~ c::nflli[IIi c~t;$ h~ chmilrl~lir~J;: ~U liI!ml't:cc~f} ~~~:p~lIdiHm:. i9Q~. ;1nC1i T;3i~~r() ~o lu ,re-£~g~-~ddl;ic ~.{i :heilll ~frI ~1;;~'~OflS. I,jli ~~,h il 011\. r:Jrdil:l ~'Ok~idili)1 bel£IlI'lU: I U)'tH ;~I p:r'~'3,dI~nl~ ~nJ ]9'96. lI(;)y:ota! e'>u'!1i>01~(I\'l:~cdh~ ~~ft;dtIC~'l(l'n N{)nh Almcd~R i:rJ .p,rad.t!iI.C.~~~l' o~ll,~siilL((I .IM~Cinch:'lT~Ci;~i-b;;il$~d Toyoti-! MC;lbr M~ll~d'rl,'~uring (Nonh Amcr~C':l.J,
a
In tbc~
rr«f~
~t"",~.
,lIS r(r.rol'a~~lIdal
li~·'pii'~fi1li1fl;l~!!tn·~.
..,
JI~ ••
~.i1! ?9g,l!, Q1kll(1U' • ep,l:aced ChaLnTI}(n S:~to'iehTI'd I'oy,od a al~d Fuj i/O Cho {ChC'!) h~clJ IHe Ihepre.stdem ef !:htCQn:~~~!lY, In fhe 'same y,elll~. TG,'n1!l I~st~d irs S:t~M~son lHHh~hc • N'ew Y.ur,kiHHIi L(iJ!!ld>t!1)1 (".<: s;jirl~k._~,~~h~nce. )' ~I~ee:!Jr!~i2CMXCl.!;,. B T~y?UI !ld b~cum~,o:~~eGft~feh}p ma'!l'Ur.!!lCl'L.l!Im.rs.l1Ifea~ ~11 h .__ '\.._ - 'iIlhl:' ""wid ~d \'>lolllS PQ-!;!i~ ~o bemJlrile she b,ICS~II. laullc:m.o~ll:eoom~!1ji' •
rr.~
"
....-:-!L,
.. ;
'\l,-r.~
~.
"_ ~
"'0·>/
-'i.
'Ij",
nr ~~
-,nl'~ 'iDIJlt!oISlt'i!
part,
dl~ h~duw::,]!~ ~n p
lIW]
T1Iit;; ·~~d·
~n ~~
1I~ TPS invah+ed ,~,f1e~ilik 'ootc:h PU.lCCS!i..wid1 n'lul~'ipnTfKl:ic ~aj'l:IOIll ~-qUir-im::::-:t'a!Rd ll:j'Jn hWf!flitory. It {!~mt-d .III dimtnilir~!iI!1; 'ul'~s~a~e a~J ~,}li.~eiUl~
'a:il:;;o
":oiz:e:n, H
,~UIJpl'rers.
r{)'1:!~,,;\~~~ on
UJ i~tl:re~$e pmdl!1-tl::~ir'li[y
r'mp.~"Iwef!olJ1en~
"r ~~mkcf&and
Ihrnu~h
ill! prm;~olf
(J~, ...
;;:;:>!'ili;ll!OU~
in",~::\I!J'''eml;)flI~ t'i',
1'!l!!ilI!lio!ll<S, '\~"IE:~
iire:\'d{l'~Jm&
l)~,,\.'llit.::
6.04 .ovo.
.lust-in-Tl HIe
j IT was the fO~l.I'ldat.jon of ~~le TPS_lt<;, ..~,,~~~\!a~ 1£ elimin<llC W~S:Qt of a]~ :l-dfl_ds by piOg_u~i!l;g:__Qr ~pIY1T11i~tc~ia!~s of1I"C,~·t du::)'\~~~':JK_~~flL¢'1f__ul!in!l;jplebchinJ ,CI, JrT_ w~s. to
[h c-
ltcct:'l'S.<l,t',:
""F
ume
l,ind I on
~~~{!
n ~"Ce'Ssa'[Y
~
q ua.rH H \.
~~
• [0
,.:;---:''___;-n!~.::.!!ttihof
,,',) ,'
<,
A.dopting J!T ••[lowed T~;~'v!"f10 do ~IW11.: \\·Tth Inventory .1tJfldstores, Ihe!'~b~ ,euHing out the corresponding' iC"SlS, ; \"'~'.l!;e:;p~~idlf i mporlam ItH' TQymJ. as the c.ompan; was based in 11 country wh~·rE: 11a,~ industrial l"lrld "'~'<ls. scarce, Therefore. there was liul.c scope for Toyota [0 ime!1;p-'.11!vc rti cal Iyt ,), . rnak ing' its o.WH c ern pcuerus {~Inl ike c cnrpa ri ies Iik~ G (!,lle:ni I MrH Q rs whj;;;~, wtr~ higJ~J;· vertically iu[~;gratr;';d~.i\;'; a resu It Toyota's ·c()m.piocmeni. l~u"dng·5(Jategj'. \\'.1-5 s 9.l1' eM~ed:~)' •buy' " and 1t '~q:l:S lmport an[ for ~ c Ompan)" to be abl e 1:0 gel irs t~mpon:en on .. he ~S t·itn~ ~"J::.gllvemed T oyota •$> bU~1$tnle_gj' ~.J .
rr
~~_r~'._
.~'"~~v
l~leTO(htct·iQn. . ro~~¢ss·.MtWJlth_g:r ~ ~lyc'idi.n~ elimrqafing_;,.. _ or~ u' i1a:uJlf'.aI, peaks; and .·ulli~$_ iu . ro(fuc.tion~ Olma be Iieye d thii;t.whef! ihe (:!roducliQ!!.:· rQtti~s Was smoQl'i a,n'btIDill:!UOUS. then ·aUpr.o(lOctir(.l<tod:_qu.al:itt'~!E!'s '",:olild iLQiL~~the.·~~E.S~: Ti~)ul-d IIl'en be corrected ..·Hirn:l«)U~) wastspeed without 'cotllinvity' is mcaf1i;:;gl~ss'_ Ifilie ~5j"orl.lchon line was eirhertoo r~:-;~.or tooslow; il "'"ollid cfe:oLte:'irpje:rHOf)"pmbl~rt~!;_ for ..o;allilpli,.:. , h igh-5peed productionat one point ,oj"~h~ ~in~' wcwl.rl rt~ul'l in $~(i6;lJ$_imbalaucesin Jh..: 1()'.steil' h \\:ould sucki n'.suppl ie5- tO~1 lir~L cr~<tHj!ig. ~h~).I1<H':U:Sril .!he··~p!;ece:qlrig -S:tlll-gc."\ Q'I" j1filildutl jon,. <inc! JlT "'as to make
:;'~X;'~'qut
liJ :i\.?Qitll,hi::;
!"or [1'1 tH C
i he
;~r¢~!:,
·{)f the U$ ~LJP~'rrn<lr.kel.s i n hj~ I'Il.lil:*(:IiiL'!i! ~:,:.!tn;<" .i)1' lheg ~_~IIX~I-IiT:II'h:!;;-, 11'; wld·enHw;.a lh~ll1lr'H-L:.~Il(_'(,· ~lf;jd.ding in\ !,.'!HOI';.' on 1:-·, ..·he·1l 1"\\ :1$ ]l~'\~~<:d an.;: not '1o.!l~H\~ !i1;,LI,
_~Ja(i.!d~!'JIIier.
Impl.t"ln~rllal;()11
i Il'sp~r.ed
h}
fllll'~liot1i"ng
ili"~'l:llOr~
rho.: l!(kic:d
I fl"ot;IHOf)
~l:~ l;l·tlild to
(ilL.'
:ell
l10lilH I hal
had .bcen
(I:s",d:
notmore.
'W]
I!:~$_
(J j' t.he uct ;on J i ne Sl aned ·.L~11 he po Int o ~b~'I:~was dcn~l;t·nd ror <I certain 'make er car, ~~s. ~ks.scnTbl:,'bt~g.an IhL.:'faClOi:)', \VhC'~1 as:>cHlbl) ~ asready 10 begrn, (he pans-were dtHvereo H) at [h~ ... tl hj' ljl(' pr'~\'IQ~I~'pmcC'~I:~ j-r'1 tilt: ptoduL,tlon ITnc.VI."bQlr lbe. p1lT1.S hadto be" deIIVC'lt·_,J to tile li$~embly. ,(be S"tJ~1~1icrs ~IJPpl~d !he nl\\ i1~lH~rral~, their' manufacrurc, Ir~short. (h;mriJid pli lled i I()r 111~:1-.:i.GH1of/'<; '~qiTj.;_ 110\\ _ Thj-s b·m;l!~j nn 1h,(;' 'pull" ;S~'!;-irt~f11~r manu nj~'hj"fi ( l1:g .,15 ~lgai o~.i·ilk IMpljl~~rlY" used . push sY*,({';!ll. ~ ''idi~re (;'<l.(_;J, Pi'tlCC'S,:> manufacrused c'omp(Hh~cHS': tc jts: h:ighc:';l Ijdwn[j,ll and then pushedthem dO\\'n \h~~ j I:W, ~)n'O;:ll Cr~;'lllr.lg 'f;Xc!:SS J rwemor; OlHCI id)k~tldi~g ·(}r I 'lhe'ppd~Lit~iprl Ii rte (R.¢fe:r Exhibit \;'1.: .
i"":;;:~:;~i ~ ~ :.~ i
r~tJd
TQ
JHH n ~;;mpl.~.l\hcn
w,~.; .
In an ideal siwatio;ll. i r J IT was, ac]~i~;ve{tIhro~ig,lWU[ lhcorganf:l?ttO,1. then in-..enw,cj:' \\'oul'~ b.. : ~· completely eliminated and the f?LC1'ory would 'ha:ve 110' J~.e¢dforstores' anQ.warehouses. 1·lo'~;:~\·ej·, .ac:hieving.JH in all processes atHom;itl.~i'llly v..:oul.d ~e. v~ry dVm.6"1,111 for ,eom·p,a,nl,e·j like TV)'4ta . .\'I,,'hichreqlJ.irno tho~sar':ds of·compCi:n'e,nt~· to Ifr~nuTac.h;Ir.~ 'One car. The very CQmpl~ji;i~y qJ the -sysrern would make ~1dHflcuh for pn.:~(;;di!)~ pro-C;~$S~S correctly aruicipate the.exact JeHHIf1~~ to o f't he' su bseq uertr processes, It \""~s. to ove rc 0 m ~ th is ·di ffic u lty t hal T oyot<ll d I!""':I'vtx-x! ~he .K (p'; bar:
systerri,
• In 'p,jl:l' based m~i1~Jfae:ttl,r;j(lg. pr",ld.l.l":[.s and ~fOHlpO'IlCnt;::; were p'8~~0,j ~h-ou.gh \11c·5~.":sa~1H 611 demand. In :c(lnn,RtSt,.iF! ;'V;:lsh' b'a:setl nranyfacnkfilifi_: pr"oo'{!C[s· w·el·e WjO'l'I~~!JE'l"Chir~d·~nd t.i1~1: .~~:ISj!Led lhr.ol~:gl~~,b~~f$i'C'r:H f~m nrcge"linsJe ...el~ t{) -subsequent Ic·vds.·
~&m.
:jIj~OO; 10, "ec~iI~lluir e 'quantltig,. The , ar~hon' :~Yfl~n.lnobt; ;~~ l~llCI ~h~ iijn Ilnw !(;ll:l'\1::~"ij ,. ~.c. people ""-'(ll!TkiQt!.on a (;;~~n ptOC~ ef the ~'.iI,;~j(ln ~~~ ~'I!!1\[O Ilhe p~£Wfl;g P1'l)(Iesson [he lin~ 10' YJ.;lhdra."-lhe !'Iecosary un i,s dl~ i\O!Ce:.~,:!.qu;uu.'~" ~~ ~'11iC lTIe~C'5S<l1')'irne. Then 1h~ IprCl;ooi:og ]JFO~" f proou(:l;::1i'I unl",. C;1t'1Ut'D q~mf!:,h~c::> of,u~~~;s ,to R!'IJ;IIOI.clI:'l hl;ll~1l:' JI13~ ~~'ll! \~I ilhdf;Jj\,'" n fmm ~t<l; ifl\fe:n~OC) 10 pro~!Jcel!i~ \'f~nt,dm'I' '" ..:!~i~;s. ~C1ln~dl1'f\OC~:!i!'i M)ln~l:i:n~es ~,he \~~.rn:lno,,,, ~cmle ,mtJeli Ii.In~11$ fmm ~~ p'l'e>C~l;;nJli!preeess, 'i~,",,~'~rl on,
;,i;~ilid! ~
K_fHm ~~·d~
(o~~"f
J;T :~;
j~
" ."1~
~l:.>lboa:IIU·
_;~,
':II
nJ)i]ic
_;gU1i
fa PfO,lZd§ n~cd ifig C L'lr~('j fl\~11~~ w I'Q~~ the' dL.m~il~~lJ;ol!l Jhr;:J:Jn d nfu In \Vhl~l t['1.:ru, weN nt:t:f!!e.-d 2! '4 f;).ir.tl..Bill~~ Ii~~-;i;'!<!!~qjl~' A
pf,oo{!'~~ fil~d wi'~hdre\\ Ihe tlmo'ulu reqljil!ec;I~roh~ II,
-
~"'r~
-.".'?
eadb Ihoklllm,e:li 'ooIitain I::i~ed. ·qUa!li1t1~tyof it A $e1I.oornpri$eiI tlW'OIypes ·of ~afl.btms - thi: W[thdfiliwa~ Kcmlm~ ,and the Ptrod!lll~ion JrZunIIUI1. A Wrlhd!r.~w@J Ktmban d~_1~ .lifickind end qwl!;llit)' of PfQdu.;c ~baf ribl: .$'U~~~t FOClesS shoutd wifhdmw from pi~ing pr~&. The P~poQln'.leri!ng K~~, :s~ifiedl ~he kind and qu~ti'y Qf Ilrnr,..,oo«it ,lba!.Q:le Ipn:.,-ceding lJUlift1 pRiId'!Joc. (Rerer"~' il':ab'e t. ,[ora ,de'mp!ign oflftt ~"Sl('n'll',
!j~s~e~~ I!I!I!Bdt.l, q
~_}....
,-
'I.
'Jmj~
u,~
'The' ~,c:ml-II1UI~~ (l1!r."tm'i:3:I~ ,and me n:um:1i:er (! fI=l~ ~d ('(h1il3lilili;;"""~lIIrd I ·1d .~. ,rn!h:1l!I1~~cd f Iil$~ngOhll1O·:~,Fentml . \N.\hu:h ~jlI ..re lhe ~,,!ml.un W'fItlllfU Oil' [ll.,;enlmllry n;a~cfilJl'd be IFesel'l~ 'LfI! llll: ~:':iiit~1T:! 'to NI~pld d~ pr0(i6'S ~(It:!!;'111eJ-~R~ f... [ hit! i~ ,I) ,\ II ~h~ ~)~C\~5"''S r n 'h~ pn;J(hacriOli lim.- WeI'\" Ih\ll!i cum!cek'd l~ eae h O'II:cr ~hfln.!="h A,./J,h,m
I
] ,':\E~U':: II
~n:S(,'IIU~)'n(]~ OF .. Iq (fI~
/':0'7!1'1~t~ ~,~ ~iI1nl, a ~,U
~.. ~ ~~~' IIt11 r a~ ~~ ~~ nli1li~ dl!t' 1"'I,l~'l::'n~~'llli In, I,;'ru~~(~1:e.t~·.,-e.\2"l n~ .. ; dH'(~'n:nt pr,1L:I:~I":<'l' Ih::,' pi~!dt:n::!~m rll'I~. A::,m~'(j!!' c<t~d5i ~!H ~tlllH:' ~" ~ml I~mtl:.., On,",' ~~c ;.r<i1ll.~.~! Ol~\'1,;'nmL;~' ~jr ~\I'nl'ldnm';LI i'.:J!uha:il· dT.~Ln 1$ t<'llmed "( \~'h~1! gO!f!g I rum (HW Ilr'Ot;;,c:~~ the pr 1:;'~'~lH pr9r;~s~ h.:> ng rh~\ u~I'Wr i ~ L:~111~d • P'roducJ1(m I A'(/f/hw1 ~,tld II); u.... [(~:.·or.J~:r ed prntha'Lwll n~ tfw r:-,n~:,wl~1'\ Il hdni \,~ t~.\, [ile 'Sulb.5eqlH~N. n
r,:,'rnn:
prLn;~~~, 'h..:~c. 1
ri!lm~,.
'lNh~i1 1h¢
'!\~ n
kind:->f.1f
the
·cn'!WJ.I'fH:'r~
hGJ.ldi!lg
d~C'
,oo~ucnu £'If ,j rorn,m,,cr I~t:,ill 10I~W ~dSil"(L[Jl~ ("un'~'~>'~w;c lo."ui~hdn IS reu~o'~'L-d from t1~ c(mtl!linCf, A wort,er :Iak~ Ihls (~I1\cy.auc!!' .'.mllOn :!nd ~o~s ~o thi:' !:WCk poim uf1l:e; p:rccCldlllCpr(')C.CS:S 1.0 ,tel up ~hl::' pru1. I.... then il.'tUICh~s tius, Cun~.C'y~f:I.(:e" K£llti4m I e
to 'Ihe ~! La im"r h(iildi ng, 1.hls .part. ,,"' T~~. t~c' ·~_uC:"i~.!'I /(aJ.' .. rbml" 'ilI~~._ liICd. ,I'll' Ilh!!'. w".Jat.'.ner ILS n:mov.,cd and ,1:u:;n1'l'l5. d,,~op;.'I'cllli!llg '1'IIfCfillOOl'iOQ fm: ·the· p~. 1 ~,e [f,O liD ~~" I ht Sl:oet I~ i~ wi1!litd'l'3Iu.~n id\¢O pmdtrreStfte: I~~~I Ifqllr~ Ish h .<liS arlr as. ~jbille-_ _ \!I, n!l~ ~[rcp(lrducEk!~.~ai~1i~, f Lh~fi ~I ~~b~~ fine are; amrM.~~'~ lin .~.~~~ii~~.~ ~
,m~,
~
-
1
~.
~~Ul
lime
~l~,
or I~
-,
tlil!!
'!i~~~<n'Id
Il'!:IIt£flWlti"(:
Irndio?
j'IJ'St-f':;;'
II
Oll"u;.\; in[[ii~.lIy ~s~dp,]~1;:'!:li (iif' ~per cO~l!1!ili11('d irl nxr..'lilg_uI01r yia~ri ~l:"h1.·r;;.lop~s :0 con'\re'y ~nrQrl'ril¥l~iol'l lH'nWC'l.r1!f. by ti1(' .eHi~~)2000s, A,f.JI~'b,m ii1.1i:d vol ,...~d ~'EW j)I! !"rh~!,t ,c~~~:d e rnVeOl!Oii)' m~!il.~g.~tlltJI~l NlOl1 Ih~~ fim:S'l!J1rgd ~}rod~'.-:ti(li~1 fl ~II~e w~q!lJl;rfcd ~lHN ~tUt;5 1I~ th~·r 1.\1:111] ~i :re i01 alii ~ n m.J·f1l,uJ<1J~~ nl'l rroe.es~es wi] Il!n I:~ ra~!ory, L~r~
f(01-:;i!;"I.r· uwot"'oJ ~~ ~rem.dli;;'~.iof olw.:rv~nim' wO:rkcrs <u)d. HI~i,r work P';~i.!(!.~s~s.:$6tnet'in~t..~ vi (:leo r:ec~rJin's~ we I~ mark afl~ ~7upenilsers jtC'll m.d mJil1:eda deia ~!,I,)d ioS oj' !hi.Jrmp,;;~ryw.Fi~sof ,,,,O'rik,ers. .g~;l,;~O ~J iC\l'cdt Il;ll _qb$t.:f1"'a~i(lil was. tile b~l~'ay [0 ~;P9tl~,roblents; .an~(jLila:l.;C"(Jlfl.s.~~~n ·.:"":·.,:___Gb~e~~,.Th0-n o~,ld .lre~l.t~ prc(ib.~,cfl~Ilh<1.ll.,.wQ_ll,iIld w 'Olhef'W'ib;~e' eS~p'~.;_!mc·~ n~odo~.h~Nlf(Jre" r he .:' ~ "''S!~i~'IIih:~ iim,po:rf~f!ce pefip~e ~~iI'],g ,in '~Gi.I!::!lrw~;m:iitmJwQr :tiI~~ p~3C1:wl,e,lir.': tlle ,aGt~o!rllw~ . , .;; In~llJ~' I~: ,,,~. fHi~'O"'}. I~~ W'Ouk!ur~ rm3l!'1I!FI'Sttl ~ 1[0 lfile fac[(Iri,~ e\'eW}' He\' w:ofUild~Y. "'Go t.Qg~oo e:YiCl}' ,day. And Wfim you go. dlof!"i~.W\~~ ud~.the SQ1n o'f')O'lJlrshoo:; in Yain. You shol!lld oo~b<t~k with a~ leaSl' ClAc:i~ (orK.uJ:,e;r,~' ~ ...
<~~
or
,or
.¥~
r
,.1
Vi.'ihe:nteaclh!!1Iig .~ J~l" ~'I.L:'lili!..~li:urd~h~~'~ f ~l'· Ui:mo "tOU Id ~al,.~·,hr Ilr,,11'l(,'lL" 10 ~he f~~.(iI~. d'.rm."-.a! (;:, rcle on ,~~~~ :1ilfl(U" ~iJtdh~1!'l!:' inlJk',r ~ .. JWI Ih~ ~ [Of a_t:!:iI~pr,C' h.(ll..l'" ~p ~rlI'i!: 0' IOC ~Qll. ,pR!oC~. (the i£~,dOJr ~hc~II:I:Ililillj,;!il11~~IIl1" •. ob!C~ was e~ed ~o :Sll~"fi' "-"',-S. ;p ~""hH;") dlc :~~.o(litil:d be Tmflm.\<·cd -I,k ~.".a.n~~d I'D ~.·~tcllJ,~d :~;..".h,.W" (Wt:f iI.md' I.UW ;J~~1ilJ If ~H· iU~ clld !that. he L!'I~'V (!wI ~11l.:i' rtk"M n,!"Ulld "~llllli.' Mr_ OIl:ll1I'l n;.'OJi!m;d nl;\\ II1ltUglns .iUId. I~
n~·.
~'l!!:
u~dlrn)lu!! In dt.! run ..(ll1~ I 1<I.r ""l,1 hiul.i'- 'Ih ...~ lj,·nmJ.l' r'f1nt true nn~1~;,mdln!:, U tbe p;rcc:~s.~ I'I~ f Mud l1f:'JU~ u' I - hrrllUI.,L rJ~'';;I~kl'll .~III§ 1 ( J)_ 1,)~u~.1 M(lWf" \b:nulm:~lIrm;: '1Ul1il AUlI::.io::a lnc
I
'1 tI~ ·~h·(, l~ II_!<s.' ul..:r~·~uun '~1,1r1tI~n nf i\,u=t'u. t )11[1>1' ~"lll.lhi m"I';" Ih.!·1 rkj':Ulll~ . l~mc.s:...... hc:r. C('~'nlrnlll'~'d h :tU~:~Il\ pfl'hk"l"l~,1 ~\r 1i.'",••lmph.'. tCa ~.;:ll'Ilnt..· !~n.Li.:' ~UH ~ II.
.~I;.
"t,~~.~.'
,1:5"'-• ~ h:...
~r,:L'
n::~~nll
,mti o.ncl! thfl.l ~"'H~ ~~l,;lrrL:,lCl~d. llw p:~qhl~m '~PL:ljJ Hn~ f~·.[!ur.(
K:.ai;~'.n )
JO~ll~
i~h;,~ I'~.Ii 'I",uhl~11 <lnd dc~ ~IHI~.lllwH ~11. hl~~' u nd;.:;r.~~I,t~·~d ~ [.i 1 ch t,~ ~'~Il -;,~~plO:'n'~ Nm n"'I,1~j~J ~ hlH a W·!Jl1'1,: cr was r~~~.!1.s :1)(1(1 ,f!1lmy 'lI~ 3.!>t,;~I~i n"!.'~iH~~~ib'. '~m!ll~i ha\ e t,e- bmv. ,'I. h~ the w("rl;;ef' ~~·il$.ntahm'~ m ~,C' 50 mail! fI1~\~~.lncntl1l. how 11 ClUlJd be reduced, ~lri1l! Ihe .a.:,cuntie: resu II uf c·1 mlA.'ll! ng. such i cxoi!S5ivc mo\'.~m.~I. Sud, ;malys1s requrred deep iu~c:st~:g:.auan lUlU run nnly 11u: prnbleil~l. bul ail :[I~ ~p;dS S!i!lI'!'QYfl:!ilJing f1 "I~e of KM =i'~ \HI!I ~
I~'~H:~~~ t Il'l~ 1 ~Ih~ p[1c~hhm'~alr~iJ1il1 n~ ,dil.~~fWjiI~~'~ l~~I;~I"IIIII!;~ ,[' ~ ~ II~ ~"(lI! ~ ~ ~ ;\"wn,C'~ iCf~·!o'I1~ .. ~k ~,fJ~ ~mlifundmei'lJ lof iltle JI! ~if R~~~tI' im,pl,e~mIIl.'lllla~ion 'WilllwD"I' :~h.~. 1U:1f~'~Ui!I~I-~nai'A . dl~~H@ou'e'!i.c~ ~t iFO;,'o'OL ~~~i :.1!'_'C~~~ie pfIil~~-So...: lIiflpm~l.~'l"tj; d~, no:!' come 'mm 'd1c. prM~:fhcr. Somcllr!'lil"ZS n~ 5'rnmC~t $,-stl£m 'i5' \;Io-r;ong,.fiome:t'mf'Sf~ U1D~n'-f\tSJUll~a;):!i)<St~ is, 'I'l.'1"'OJilg. So k!ifir ii!~·oi''o!"M3!~a\'>'l:i
'C~d~JDlg
Id\l,~ pe~i'loi'C';
rm'!U~
cI
.A:f1~F
mam~~~
.~
anim;pona~ ~liIi~~(o
~u~~~~I~Pr,o: ..
I h~jlmc
w..
:Suppl:ie:r Suppon
Ce:n let
(,ssel. I]
re C.Q~~
pf!llbh"'Il115.~said
.
Ohta,
VP
ohhe
rDj"lOWI
si~~~i
~~!
said :lh1t TIi!IJ~mse.,,,,,~~, '~eu:mned to I~ f&' pes_tiblle 'iimpm ..~~nt!, ,ew:n in ~inal' <t~~enIl ~. :ft.'ldr.. ~Jri~ ~fI_' to see tbeim;pdvC:fM~[S ~mlai1....~ pos.sibl~· C~1iI in tile btit- ~"St~. ~ ~!}"$lS: re'-~ r~l~ tha[K{jj~" was the maj!}1l' (!OntnbuliOfllil Ta!l'.o~:a·$g'lob1'l~~C~ -, . TAII,~ILI~ m PI'U>UE1 'uu·ar r.Sf() R 'I{ArZ:~N .~Di~~<'I.rdc;mv~n!i.:i;)~l"l ti~'ed idl!f;;~-c Think ·Qf hmv, to d(lil. not \~;h)it cam'lm be
~ys.LS
i
ll.)tJrill,·'11 'IIlm"{It~
.~",cuse~:.
:;;[l;l'il,
by
~c:me.
q:l!lest:Il[!Iil:~11g
I])OIill-I~
slii:k ~erre~r,c;ml. o, D
i~ '~~gllrl:IH\,~
C br.1:~l
~~I
~sD[a~~,·
1i"()[~fJIfIll.SO%Of~!l.'e'L ·
• f y!ilU
nul4;J¢a
miSI<lke_
An im"pltlrtll1U e'lemen~, in~(l:i:z.f!.n was pa~,a•.I:'£'*'(! Or ~rm:r pFOO'fi n~. r.~u-)'!'(lh: iO\1lj)1¥ed UtC s,~p Uil :Sih~j~.Win~Gl'[ ~~ '\lin; 'IiQOWliIl~rr;l!T,ol~ III~
c~ep :irrl.. t T (ly'~)!m.preeesses y,..~~~ ·o:rk'l~t'R!ld~d h1 :SII,!cha: ""l!;.¥Il;!l 'tu m~lke jlrtil'!p::i~s~bI'~ so A <l<%cffihie a pmcl1~lCtin ~on:'~y'~y olh{l~ !h~n-lh~·1.':nl:rcc[ 0 ne.re d hni nate th~ ehanee ofcrn:w, At T fl'J'flUl.
lJl"I~lt%nllf.l,ed.
rrGdm:~l;o'~~h:'Ve~11hl'l!J: wO!,~
d~~U1111 tn,
~!ls;ufre
d'lil~ ~hc
L~'~:d
~hrc.b rLlqlJin:dil£;el!lb~y li~a.dafJ! i!!iSOd1l1ed r"'''(luircl~m ,of 100 units; d:urin,~~ 25.)' worl.ing fllfU!lh. dum rour' w~ a~mbl«l (le'li diJ,:¥. nn-: t,!~Iol''') h'l'lt hum!' 'in a:l~ difhl~hQu!l' '~"'Orkinl! d.l.'l\ L~\l.d II~~ w;t" j) I'S,O, applied hl I he iitm of tlni,...'m.::d I ~1Ift! I" eur onE •..:'f~~h~., :liM [n the il'oUo Mh IlIUI!d!Ja'I .. Inhll ~fw f'{!1l:t.nr:,
,~:onf~~rlIo'u:~ ~'!n.(],
'ns~~!~~~1C'. a c,omrKllne!1~ if
~=
ln
mfl_,,1 In:.ll1llf:lc[~ril1g
(Iii" ga1H"aUl"l!1r~.
IUSI
.modw:I
eflen i!!. lu.J:de u) dc\"elnp lilt:Cf,,,,l:jU\ i~y oh\_orl"~I1. er ~nllssit!l~ ~:ru:m:..ihllu~ Itu shern. l-Iu~~·'!.'~""J~Iu.· I~~I1Mcl'i..),r~~e,tH!}h!~·cd ~ ~ ;:.u ;~upnn"m[ m:!!:'~HH1;: A llal~'!l[~~1 id U1.,,1 ~h'~P~3Jl~ uti on Ilim~ ,~'[:r~'~~,li ,of ~I,,~.h~~I~~;,w .~alu rC'i~ ~;~il1l,~ltirCM~" :t!i t11( ~~hll ~ h~ ~h(!~C~)t";J}:t)rn1.~e ICL~ re, ph~y(jd ,!J ""~'!.\ ~n~ If'i~ ~ im Ilu~
=rrs,
rrfip.oll'1a! H re le ! 'r1 Yo), ~~.(,rt" :';'kiCIC,e~ S ~" lhe m.1 i11 co r1s·j tl(>ra1 ~b['18 in TP S "".~r~;: I~I im~.li[l(l'l iQf \M<lJS:tef!l,d m©i¥e:menlts~>t l!>'oiikrgJ!i5 ~, tom;i'dcM~ion ft:u::.wQrkcr:s;· !S:!lifl!l:Y;omd '. !!5Jf-disem'!l of' \.'Kl~~r:s~ c.aJmJbnim.ies2 if:nLnJ.stIru;,them wilh _wellE!!r' ~poMHdUt~ .'
~nd
•
'1m:,
';)!li!iho:ri.& .
Tn !~~i~
ne.:ri!.;bi~,rmy amillltamWmil.
MU
1Q1i1~11c'~~
~'~~i~
.. ' ~1ld, ~
be SfliO!:dbel~d'i'«~~ lpod~;~1 ii~.This na{L&i1'j:(JI'._llIJiicli!, 1""~ilno'!i~Ufdl·'Si'#JlRck·. "'<I!;: ~)I r~f'uE in that .~ mm~oould ,adapt '~Q~fid .-d did ,~~~ ~~ 'di;t:1'IM re:cn~ilnew' w"ft~, w:l::u:mtbe d~pdf~.r !.'lcm:llilfl .rype of product inc.ea~.'d Ptefipk\,v~r:eol~ org;nl ilcdi in Ula~ Oill'ld I~h '[earn was 4'S:S'igned ,11 e-n~il'l pora:iol1of '~<e~K. ~,~el11ooil'$c[llJ1d 'th''l:l'Igt ~ m'!,e!;,~Yill:tiin ~he 111(:411111_ T1!Ili:so1T'se( It~1~ mnllotOIlY m~:s p:rodu~~iGr~ ,
'0
or
The stress W.ID;S an e>mp'C'"",,Ci:':ITl i::llt m1fd work~r.'l w~r~ gi v{'~':! the r<":S'pO:I~r.'ihi lit}' running and ~mfwovJng Ihe~rQwrl w(trijshop.~. Any empk'tyec'at ~ny I:cvel (:of (he. hh':T~rd,yhad a right. I.~ rnake i~:llIil{'()\vil1:l'l~e~ll~S: ]JrQ.c.6ses;.. l'hi,s wa~ eall~d: ·l,oI'is:i'blc !!!"~·!'1!ri,;l· in ::lnda,J ~ w~rkel'5~ook p'cSit,iv,e $~ep~
1
or
'~N
1iJa1e. ~~"iIlm: IliRIel ,~~q,';d~ll:rm 1l~' ~,,",cr(' I~~.nro~:d of dte priQciII~ pa!II1S Ito be 1pi'~~a.r.4 11il,'l:~Il; or~WIli(m ~ll(el;l!IClm. ill ~[~ l!hc ill:ci[tW: ,B1)l"Jmri~ fill dCl!l::~S'l~ ll'li"j;OIiJJ di.5_dli'nl ;;mdl ,~~m~'~ '.t~tedl ilo ilihc·'f~ ,a:n.d •.lhi~ 3U!lIl!'1~~ each $I ttll C0w.:;~iItii:IU·OOl!ldli1;:., '!I;diMii~i'~ ~'i~ ~~ rNn't tI'lc' O'J]!I~Mm d'epa~L This l'Kttp.."'"d imfll"l(!.'in· fl':!imiu. ..... i!iV'lI mlet, ;ind d~ morn'l'~ in Ihe ~ra~.Hlries.
to j~r{)~
O1'Cl;ID!
cf~
JjO'l1
\.~~rnil~hi!'m a"Ii:!"~~~i,liont"'f
-f~yO'I:.:t·~ eornn~~~ul!:nl ;o~\'.<lirds ~rupmu~n~lilL lbis philOS'!!!phJ ~-qI~rirn~~1 ~j.r t1p.~v:.:nj(l!lS: iu ,i! [i~M: n I!!:ne \·.~r <lin i1bllo~:lfIr
dC'i!'«Ei\\'!! C'flndi~ion .~roe;.(·i'!i'~~ ~ in(!',Thi~ d~:!i:":la~oolhe lru::;;l Il1la!:TO)'Qm pWaJe.L"di.n il.he:ca:pa:bll h~ f {I,1f ~~s. ~,vO"r~er.=lIlnJ. ~~.~.!l:. ak;;e: me<lll~,~ l(l, -pr-.omQl!e \!o'llirkelt po(llrtiit[:t~;Ji1 ion 11h'll' ml fo'n~~e:ffJehtrnd .Jid(J.li~j . \V~ ~':!i',t il 'Wi1Ji~ mrli! W~~lJl {}~rntcd 'Ill!: '1I::0'l']\I'cyo ~~!Ii:I"d ~~c;).~ th:e,.t['I~J~~~ ~)" ~m!~dr. W
..
,.<~l' ~, '\..
the p!'odm:!j,ol':!line, Or ttl-und hin:tsc'lf the IGre~8l~@11l h~jpltl'll ng tl cord calJed the'andon' .' ~ ,oofd.",,:J~;h.:b WO,WI l.el !;I~l.orfa:na'l<rml s.~'steml!:fI(jI,'UlultJl!n<l:te: U~e cohll'roolciclc) 'aBGOf:l If!~e¢lriic Ught "", -- .• , .' ·r.. ,." r- 'I !<t." .. ,/~,t::'.L\., . ,j" 'I • - "II l:. 'h"··.. . •.. .~ ·'.:,--oo:a:~a (1I1i!e~Clr I~~I~JlIJnVil[)~ n'L'I:S""'O'~i'l:iI,aJ MrS:,1 '~ue'~Gr~ers~!il'" :~I~p.ervuiOffi"~(1Illhe·:pme~n~ ,Ora I~"ll!tm~.n Jhe lil:le,.il( 'lfieproJ:\liem' '~as no~,~[ilfiied.·'1WiiIJhi~ ~sp~c~fieicl~e.netl:('Onlmi. ~Ehmlbe ~ine 'wo~ld ~I.op. i~1f muY.aJl'[y or ,gto!nu~t:2InJ.· c _'q; -. . 'V "
unable
,)if pr~IJkmin
en.iii're:
Thc.Ji.drJ1«:l s.JS'Iemhel~pb"d1~~atten1 ~n
f(.Umre
t'D
fWl1hu 'ClIH1.~iClilli~ru;. TIlt: ,~bkm Irould O,fl,f.f!1k ~on-:.\·Gb:rl !lnlH .."iI.Ilall.~IS b}. dl~,illgo;'!lU~~it.m
fWlI'
(I'll'
~odit"f
~I!M.
as il: 10000lm;;-d pK""l!:ilTlt!:cl :*i!: ~~~. rr'El~~ ~_IQ~ ,oJ! ~JP'I\e:~e IfnI '0'11' ddfeco !o'"£' plI"od~~"b_ 1 ~~, hc:r~i I o~,'O~O!l. htC"'·(,' ,1it~~1 k-....ds 1.1 qu;:l'l,rl), h .. I:nl ~.~a. illS 'fai'l.ll ~n ~ \:I."IQlike~' ;J'lnh~y OJS ~~nnk...,'TS.
1:dl"-DliiifyiIIJgI:~
or
10 tl'lrsur~
~~C';11
LH'I
that wurl..c~
Olma called
tu ~
rt \,\.1 i
1f~'I;lrU"C[ iul'l!;'
helng
Job.
":~"Jmmun hu ~ 11I11! H·" U, ,,!Ur '~III lie' II ulldr!!.;'d .. nl Ii !l'I~'~ ~~a~h..luI! "n n\ i~1
I '~~"I,I'~O$'"
f~'I:;"~olfie;~.
1'2:ihl~h~~ dli!"~h~'111!!t"tWn nn]Um,~jl"r1i,!',,~\~J,~C~ ~~,!!n::' ~md i~~IIt;'l!JJ<'Ill ~h{' ~~~S Ir(li~'U""~ f1lrn'millf!fI,~n~!I~' ~~1 ~~S w~rrkw~ m~li~jci,1 ilm'~~t~!J:[\$"wmi~IUj i r11 d~v{;'liupil'lg Ihe [ulll p~l'~.~m nl' \~ orli.c$S. 'naljnin~ and ial ind.uCIJ.Q!l ol'.s~JP~!"\I:!~Of~<:Llld m,milll~cr:s ,Qrt~m ~n~~!;!d l:hlt~e n~91l.11~.s-~r11Wr~~ and il W~\~' r~eri,Jli~ NlS nOt <rS$lg!~ed hL~ dC~rl!:ll~H.teclpl~('e ,wt,)rk ~~ntn thl:.~~mupan)' \\';:1~compl~'w~~1 Dr ~mi~r1iC'd 11'1,;)[1he ~~~t.~ film~,lia,r l",j,!h the r~~~,~)lll ~~'~y, 'C'(;~m,lits ~\~ntl po~ti!!d li'r~d~nF~n~m N 1~!ra,i~'1~ oi\'V~:(;'Ne ;llndle,~lr~~the t~~ \;'adolu!!'l i!~It'CI:.~ (If Ilil ,,,:rIPs.~ II] ILh~ l~r,l~ JOG o~.'l (j~'I. ~1,! ~~ ~ O i ~~(:"$i~'I!~ .i I'~ ~•• kl~rUlil!\~ Nj 'e1~'SUf1~ i! h.i:lt ~u ,eru;r.I~Q.YI!::C'~ ~""~I'l.: ~",ll.!I.U..(l~~~c'I~~~ llU 111l1::' Ilnlu~u:li!,cH.J!:!li~~,[l.'lNp!;;,~l,~~i'lUIS J;lm~ ~bl." htH ·:il.l u;ld!ll~iqlJi(:S m ... ~ngi nccri'!~Q.
Siitfay and wQr~c:r lWen«jl1l~ wt:.n:aJ~~iWnii!iSl"~ ,dea:lof hUpon~HC'~ fisToyota .imiJ O!mQ ~~~f:...ed th~t illi SiJfuJy lOOmi!i;,j,QUS wori;, IJdace '",Ldd ~r:(l.Ye the ~I~oli' Il1c''w~ad Ic:ilid ;i1Ji ~w.r l~utli"rit1i". One 'eJ:liiIIplloyec lreal,t~lXil:ed 'lila.~. al :a:i[6i~ n:fll!U" mtmOOF!i !(1f;a 'Ie.~u iw.a.di ,~Ii..md ,anil:dud ror '~oJ;wti~Ka.n 'Qrds ..w~!Rl}m .!!¥,.,!£lI.i~G IIbe~fJell", IIDIIIl:~f'5 ~hm, 'G'« ,c~[I'I:UmI~illlUi,c, w.uc:ed ~i.m.e 31~d' nJ'iiOO!. IliiCII,weVU.,YilIlial Illtey OO:aiBd 'he. ~tJ1;OO t:(il IObr.a •. Ihr poJiQ.U:d, OU:l:~IiI~itf;iIe ~id~ , w~ ,~,,.,;ri",S 1 Ilim~~ dte',dri~l 'wolil'ld h_lIl~ 't!illl ~j)lIil'jj bu~I'dI.~, Ithe ~af~.r .oofl~iH.\~}I'., .Md' 11h~ fo\l{I~ld I!it!i!lt,Ix: pd foil' his, ."",,-rig. OiIi!'lO t:!I!S.OJSa~d ~~iJI, f, Qffth"'~t~le a while prnVided ~~f'(:~5C ~. ~ ~ for 1iJ~ MIT/IOn ,co~kc[ot~s \\i'eU";~iing.. -Mf- Ohl1i!:1 WIllli 1,)I)'ing <IE 'the: .b~ggl!:rpiC~(Ulre. He p~a~ the· ergo-nG'.mic 'Wl:n~ing ~r l~e: '~~m IT!~U'ihcr before :1he SllDfi -term C.(1)!!!1 e m~ (l1f' ic:ngr •- ~d Tesh iar.:i T a.?l,i;,~~~:. pe!ii~i'l; 'OJ( T oYOla
me
ror
ro
61):14170· I
.Aw)}'Sli.5. ~id ~Mt d~ s!'$)(~tie d~t~:'€i~pm1."'II'It ,aoo limpr,m~_fi1r:1l ·,.if '~ihcliPS: ,dVi:~ '0hM!. ·Ohoou.~ ~1' d~blg 'I.'l!fil~ ~~~ u.dl ~'Id 1~1iI!11fi1~ iin I~he·ptmmli~ l1iI:f'his,~~ He "'9t11di ~i:rl!!\f,I'1!1t •. -II ~~. ~ till<'I!l ~:a,~~~ ~hiii ~eiRe.intli::!1 a rUdtinc·~hotP <1001.1 wa:n! e'1if~~ ""''tI\rki~ [hel·~''(Ioi;e fiC~ii1t.~L! ..' in ~11Ifn1:' ~'L; iii! W1e:yeaF~o' see U dODe. -I>ii U'edid nat ~u [litem haw lO do u, -y.(Jlj boo \,~ :hl!< clmi~~ w~tl~ IlIiIm:. saidl'Nhf!Tllan BOOClk. wlilQ lI:ii'l~1i1liled ~ • 11':. Ij .Oh· .· I'I.cn; ~~r". J_ ""lW ,.;,Qg·t·, i$I'~
'0\.-.
~t(lpi!~ !\;3'id ih~;!lJnlll;Q,':!:i, ru!h::It.~-SIfl£:S5. pmbnibJy ~1'Ilmtl'lt:d rr/~I ~Jl~ lI'tl!e~ :th~l~ il~",<It'i.i1ii~l')'IO ~mjptlieme'lIJjl.~,~~~ <itS ~a<. ii;. ~.rlrllli$.-ei~«'I1iw~ly M, po~sHi)re ~~.11oy.m:a".AIO!d he bc.~n rn~:ss. re.]ent]ess, h~~~"o'l!,1lld Yl:l:V'~' liOd t 0 f'~I~'''' ('l:~t1>~ of ~)'Ppo~i~.~tln rtd imp~'~H a Irti!", Ifll~t go .:i.~r~n!; ..... O:~~t~'O' f1 nu~nc~ ~,~ sl tn TQ:~H,~, ~l;'riI~ !.;l,1,;cr in ·JaS::;. ~r']lp!t,~)'~~.~tl~~i."!rl w j,\S~ tl~~'m$~i"ies 'wt~ca~\"'~!!'!icl Oilntl i'l<l!fCsaid. l]1 WiM",",''';'t:: d 0] In' ~ hf: iJr,; dOlie'. \~~hen ~ r~f~(;~ti p.:l rtieu] <l.F~y !I'ltky proM e 1"1'. th~.. :it . . .-
~.s
I.......·
.: ~...... ~
.'.....:.. \'-~~y~~::~d
(!t_!~~)
~~
.__
IrM!t,
-, ~ ./ •
~lh'ihues"cm To,!l'liI. Dr :~heearl)' 20,CWs,J~'G1:a lhad '~~Il;~pahd~1ty IQ IMa!U1I.1lif1l;@111i1fita !C<liI'~, fmfU1 ' dl1l ~al ~:ofiul ~m1w in fi~ dillYS. Thhii G!!;~'~ ailmJWI~' ;ilJ '~mls,idLmlJbIle8d~llagc !ill'll« ,~~l~ Q'ilimy ,11).r m.mtlXll,k ~rlr 10 !!I01Iys 'fti Ihes:;mllC: pn;!C~. w A;~lyru~. ~l the: leli1iliil~ilJ' ~"Iri&llfI by theTPS idlo~ TO~.aJ~o PkIlL"'eUu; ~ 'I1,I!SC oil 1[5 ~es fM ,~31~ 1~!:JI;\ii~y. '~~ I~bt: 19I}1h..;~ For(UQ(: ;anldl:' ~~-dh!) ... C'!I"",o d~W~nl if~C:;SiillirtC_'m;
\"'~milili611~rM1~~ .::n diH:'S<Jffl!!!
m~TP~ 'COlltfe~~d
._
__
.~;E}
'~~ne
~ "1,(I;},'d13,. ~~hift.~
tll'I~md
'of !lit
U1b;r0l1l"
mumlll&:~.u~M,~ .
_
oyo.'Ii'!one of" ;1h.~ ~ ~\'Glrcn:lng,. which ",ade
(ooduc;:ti;."d
~f! c;a:f
C(l!IJ;lf!'1 ..
Si..'1''';
ie.5 in
U~"W
II'I'C \~nrl:d. Ont amlyst
people
fOtT
m.ufllt:li~makilil,~ Soniadm~ A·r'/r:~u l'Ir.l$ IIiJ.ie <lin ~hc' beucir En:t qU:1llly~UJrvC'~
~~lt;:[()pt
~H
\'£'
1'(I~ola 'Cilr'lur~-rllhl: ~Urt ~)(I::<llinnifl, ninl; <Jhl. n.f' I'; 't'hi.:lc' !It'lUl~'''lb <100 "~'()II lit]ree p~,;lIir .31\~"Llrd:s.. l (lru: OII,'I,;lJJYSi s,.m!:. ,(I.~01.i!;1\\sucrcss iloi II~dbj UfhJi.i.ml~i.l.ml~i1);delW~'f~d 2(10.
(OI~ilr~111:~
;"':e pinc~s,··~~·.'hJ~rIii~.I' ~ a'~ld ~d'!'~·1 l:lltJU1'o1111 rC;l';{)'~lrc'n: li.oo lis. re:UJlil ~ed in hi gin: m>lj(~ to: i~mt)=~,:;[he;: w~W~;t:liS'~~ be- ~',!'l~;W' ~il~:.: w~'r\" Vl1hl~II;l 'H tl'll: (,l1~?1'lir1l,n,:: ~11~dil":l~~uyl;;'df;I h;gJh ll!:vd ~nlpt.i,,~'ermun t, G
~ ~l-~IP;:_r)"''I!:-JllI-'-i::'I-U~' 1 -""':j~r~-'-::· -.,_.I:,i\-'c-;·I;-h~~~\.~7·[i cd !O::(' _ .... ~ h~:tl-,.fu~'
.or
rr;:'i,~[iol~ Sll jJ'l!__l~-L.:~:u~m,l.ii.:r~_JI1I~\'~[ceo., L_H.tM___[h~" '~n111,p,m) \V1l_~~~bh~ "1) st .. I'~I ~ .J.!;' -'t1~h.~~.tdu~rl!.:.C" ~ ·0 r nc:dhi u~~' lin;] i~ider.!" h"l~\'l!'r~n~l!ln~~~-;:;I.liSll,;;. r~~:1 n·as, H:'f~ Ph.lh!~~~~'\.·of it .. ~UIl'fI'li~flo ~mcl n~1~miIT~~7~:.;,j I)W ~'~c: rel.uiQll1S n ill! Ih(,nl 'fhb aUnf~cd il tit ..dal'1iI il~lf4ukk.l~ '" !M".rl-..i."t ·el.1m:Ji[illI1S. ~ivi!'~ II .~ C{lm~iH~~C ~d\·,a.fI~;Il,!to· \'4.:<f riv'lb. o ll,n31~:.t:o. CO!1Ir.k'.If.'d fu}'uta's ~h("~ ... "",1111 ,hw¢ u! hs ri~'ah. in ,.,\CSlClll CQ;In(l.I"U~S. ~C\,bu"fur tll~>~r~lu~'r 'J'h1r1, Iw.d hth.ldl! reial!l,iirn> \\ tnc'lf "ufl,o~l=> .mil i.,!,l:IM
~In
:s.ul':Prim,at ,i1Idi~umc,lc.
'>'(Ji~""".$~'r<!;t~$l~i~1i:.~ft1
I~ O!1In.Q'
Es;~t1~.ce o,f
l~\'I11lI Mlllnuf~;C'IiIlllfiftig
iilli'I~
Uu'
.ro~
I} Otm{)~f'I!d SI!lr~~o"··ne E~~~I):C:'e' df 'i,eml rv,jillnUr~!CWrriHJ' 'I!~~ '::l~e r{'oj··~I.:!"'rorJUC!'li(:i!1 Sy3i(~JH,·· i www.s~ratt.gQJ!.im;:.tX.lrn ~.~ JI~nl1"ifer,/ir;koi.'''Toy()1<t'sNl:w .a~r~lll~ng~.~ In;(h.!!~I}' W!~!lJk. J'~,,~'1: L\ 2.(}~H
fro
\VOI'Sill
~fore
implemc!m~'liiio~ mkl.~'!Wj. 1i~u:~. ~~ID S consllJ..li:lly. ~n~l:tgs. ICly~d s.Up bad.;, ~" ~I C nen~w(J~
II (I pl'!;'i:UlfUe1I"Il! l·PS. tl'l~m3.
~!:
they b~'Qam:i:l, ~u~r ...TI,!j,~ dl!:~nOJ~di~d ,oo!npanr~ and dle:yof.i:~n -~bat,l,j,on~d dte' WM ~~s~pt:o@lI!e '[0 ru~ssiiIJ!I} ~nd if Jill w~ .ma~.' ,usm:i:nw s ~~~ ha:tl ~enberorc iUli i~p.klD!!I1la;don;il!lld. sO~i!;i~
lb.'; lib!.!
'("Sse
'!II~~II"me.i'l~ rr, TO.l'ClI~idiid nlfll !"Ii:.a:rrge .i3!n::,' - .had~o be rd !J1bll~C(1 ..,)'1 h~ (".1 ie:ru~.
TSSC"
S pL1jb"C:U \,!:"~!o
10
h~lp
·~.,~00:'f!1~!i
r~~ for
Utal
ill}!m:ir"'l'lllCQ;,
in 'IiTle hUe' 1~ :<Idopring TPSllO .<1n(~ OUily ~;h~ ~n$u[~tarn~· !ll~iI1$e-s in KeDlu¢lr..}<
;~~~~r~Jted
ill
rep!l~
nil!' '~~ffl..".hi~..
~~ ~
.;, ' llUl,~w ,bit 1J"od'd p~~.~llha.t n~ Iproduaion eM. '~Immt&t wCI1.dd TPSitn 1M! :!~~1tlC!r!:ttU!J. -.~, ~ bdi~ bY!1~~l!el~1 'IT!ps·) ~!ii~Uj ~pp!am bo,'Ib .~.uOOOOI MtiI tlI~~niog Ot!ll~~ p~uajBD il'la.n.~Q!nAdusirial endC3!I!W ,.b~e ~ mm'!~'I'Qha1ll,prod~,~~r~'~ltTIor '~!I~:-4~,en~~r'..~, ~~!~~~~~~~tI~Ebe
(I,~~
«.
th~: ~W'frl~6HliTlldpl"IoII'l1eli FI!i~I~~:S;u.011m<l!jclfi cl[~~~~~:!i;Clll~~~!i3i'~y b'1SOO ~!'l,Tok:Yo.. j~pal~1 l''Q;sI: I(~~~e t:OWll[Il"iSi pnM.<lll' :ileJVmce)wht~hwas: pii~rm~d";n 2-tl(D aim e~lIIplo~"d TPS. 1C(Jf~U~~1 ;11 ~.obe,l:p, ~t mrcmnlill~ .c:]Xmrion:s ~d ,ret.'O~~ rmtu. krH:~
~.hr;WS 'GclPl:ml1Iirms.:a1 lmajor '!!.IIS r~: ~:n:pan.~. h,ld 3 TPS (~u:h~ju .. ~ ·Gono!''!"!>. OIl firuo..c,n S~ r~ u~iiI!jpr In the' S.~"'.d lrps to, ~Vu(jL! in\'!m~o~\" ~:I !111i.. Ifi~h"'i~singpl.;uu. Hid1ol)' CI1;I'I~r.<1 Sldbsidli~(ilr indu~f~ k~ll'!lh;'FFLTI'II~hLi!f(;, aml~dl\ 'Ir]l.e.f'mHkiJ!'I"fIL ~'I'~ok"'fn Wi!.:!:!!: st'~\i!ltt)' tRw '~lh>!''''42 y~"<)F'~ by~·dopH~rli'? {herPS. A hh~HJgJ! n.Mr1y !nal~U C;i~~.tJr~'r,!;hI E!,lrn~ ~I;nd l[l~' I.JS ;ldnWli'd !O'1C:lrn~m,;, till!' TP$ in ti'l~"ir of pmd~~~']i:UI] t>!,M~ms. nnn..: oJi'tllll~'m \~~Ii~· :O;~~~~"l;",~f~~j' ~ii ~;UlllIJill'~~it;'·~_, n;:~d~~.~I~n~ rm:,ltki :,\md;:o. ~i'" ih-li! ~id Ih;ll ;I:U\'i: 'fHljo: hl..'('<iu5.(- f ~hl!' ...ilc~aL ~'~H1umiC: u t •.•ifld ,'ullUml (hr'(!,!n;nces.I;II;"p.,u,,~J'l J,;lipaU ;md the
~rthe fPS.
1'hl!1'PS
WfiS.II.I1
'hf!Ponint~.fl of
prl!duc~
~1i\t_'St!:rn U
fl!l.._'Ufl'fl~~n1leCl' In \~C!<tb-ml
~uum!:'i!t5.d'uJ not
e~
H~ f~.~h![O id\t3bhl;,~
~tlO~u ai!!\dIth... '£c~=tlrn~~7J!!mm. Tk~ 'il"~~ .~"!!m i!I!dIt~d ilQ'J; ¥(!i (1!11l1tJU.11HJI and >r~liI!n'n~ fI" pJlIroM1fI'bics rui,Lt "\~iJ'HL-aI,~nil:illltj(IOO~ 5~~!ttw:1!!"!I..~~O\~~"'Cj. in ,t~· i!l'.lI:r'iC~in~b !i:'On~IX'I~UI'e lHil~~·t~, (l r Ihl: c.::lrl'~ 2(1fl(h. ir \\ as. t.":S:!O"C'mi;d for mallu- rOiiC'!u"I1,~ "'fI! pp;:In j~._!J, ~Ci l~~ castS ~d .1. u~iuh~~~U~l.l!lJitd .aJm'\~y~l;~ te'l~ (b<:!t Ilh~ cOiFl!i'eCl h~lt~~C~l~I!;~~~tl'ti('l~l tl~c IPS '~lO!U~(!~~'~ip' of Imarn.ur{!ctllJ1~1!5
~IGhi~~'~~hh.
604-070- i
·:EXHIBIT .I
(,HH(llHltS in milli(lHS
I:--:r='.e-"-:.e-u-.u-:C.---------.---CosrofGood0olJ
or-US dolkil"~ eXtep6 share.·amc}unrs) Min:h Q4i\:I.at·cb ')3 "J'\b Fi;h oil
:('6:3Jlj7,{)
:128.,96S.t)11
107.4431li:
Otois
t:'.~>
.~ -.~ __ w--~~~-----~---~~~~~-----~.~~+_--~~~~. ~r.eciati{lu &. ;'\mortii~ti'Oll 9..177.0 ' 7;243".0' tU;)7S.0 .. r0peraung,f..· :-b"",'1.::_o--:u;:-:le_· .....,1_5.:.....7::-7.:....2·::-.0+ ' O_,_5.:....79 ...:..O....j, __ ..,;;g:,;;;,:2::..::0=-::,7~.O~· .~ ,,-t::'''P?l'41ililg'Margin 9·.4% 8.2CYo , 7.6.% I N.oMpemdng-Jncome:·.c·'~'· 1.269~O~·~~.. 7H8,0 ($7-5..0)., ",\ . No:ri6peratjngE.xpenses .-':196.0 .. ' '.25),0 201.0.
~. c•
SG.i~A E;i-in~t'.
17.845.0.' 6-.446,0 I
J\).644.0· 4.3O"LO .
r:
7)DL6l
3.173.0
3'9'''''-'' ,
====
2:0i~1
=
] n.36
~ 610/11
=J
2,000
=
i ,$ld=::,"S,1
I ,~~5:2
=
i
'Venr
Ne~ l:ml~OJm~
.~
JI-..:.+:..:,;~;~;;,:.;:..;::_UA::';:_~-=-=~--=-'I~~~;j~-=--=-=--:----=----,·---:--:-."Ii'!1-:.i":l:n-!l:(-~~'1--,1.,~,
J-~;;.;,:(,:_c,I-O,:..;~I_1 ~
.100l
~~
.c_7_~::;:-
--
-~=-=--~
~ __;4
~~ __
___J
n ~ •~ _..".
2Wll'
~~,I'~
~52 Ui~.7
--
---~---------~-
__ --
---
• IS7.:t_-
-------~-~--
if! ~mbir::r
foruM.
f'ord
m1KlDH~!i~icrCh,l}lSlcC" ~
0!1l~
'rOJ'o~
.lloih:n 'Krn Cd 10:. 'a I~Cl~~I~.Cir atthe M~IF~chLl!i~r::u._.: l1s~:il~Ult.rCrn!t.fCC.hIJruO:loJitv.!Ilrsl coil1i~d Tihe t'"nll ~ .L~Mi!!.nuflKlll.lI:ing: ~rt;i~':! i!~C' i '''lOs- The'~~l'I.cept 'W~ based an 'lh~ p]~U~PI~y or T ~y(!lJ.;(~ L rmHI,,-~iOIil ~il\'j,~~ '"~ IRar!~I:i1JU~ ... ,k't~~ ,ql,l!;d:i~y pt!d~ ."viil:h a low'f'ii" l&ifOct rnt':.iI'nd ·0111 gre'~i"!!"" :!i~ 1.=D."1I ~i:ll; (OJ;:1~rill~ li(liHI~:" -1y:m, ~:sid~ ~ail\l~!.!jiai:~it!.rinc tiD lk ~k 'l!~em I~~'tml;')n of "!"f'S. iLean rn -nur~ urilllMis ~1(,"t'IIfbeqliLl~~It ~ li."SS- of C\'~I)'~hin~ I~IJ~ ~rdl;C .n,;~n!:ifa'f!lU!tl~'I~~t~~e. ~]~'i.' ~~-t:'S~~II~"ilHifll,'OQ1~IS, Itu: e1lil;gifu;.'C'~i!lllgho:un.3ift~ 1il'tl,1thc h~lrf if haU f t~rne \0 :PJ'O~L~..;e!:luOd~··lh<lt htWil tew~f dji:fcl':t;;. - ~rnl:l:;::co,fd~!lt;;C wi'thCl.i~h:lm(!r d·~ITl~ud. Lea.ll n:~ncfad;tlrin& is m!il~,h iIfi~ 'fleNjh1!ii:'[h~!lI ii'.rspred~'$SOfS.
~~, Wi ~i~M aspem, '!I3!f~l:n. ~ :IilUeel'i:mi1Sl:~!!!lg dl!Cif"s~on~[Elm,g$. It A:-d:W'I~~;ira ~~i_m:um, ~tl_,orm~m~~~nd ~_: r~ '~a;J,;w:all~ ~-~~I)"of~I~~iJh~lrte
t~,~
.-;- ~f.o.llI\,
~:",.:.~. ......'~....-
~.~ou~~~
eo~bineii
.llil~4dU~_,_ ~~ BaU~cvellsof diu::' _~lPlj.on ....:,11 aNS rlli!J!1,Q1iIll~~~ ma,:c.h~ne:sT(<!I·IPFod",(:~ VOlhlliW~Sor P~l!tC~s: 0f
• d
eusiomer W~UH s, h\H th(" (;llWi ~~u~'.~1 ~1::Id\alcIU~'l:='" i~ lI!t.Mth!." ~prQdw'.;: t~wre too 'C"1i;P1.;JilS ive, So m~ ~~ pl'{l<l~'1 ~on n';:lSdc,'\;' Inp",.-J ,,:1L~irl~:a,:!lum ii'~ IOf rll~ h...,~nlic~h~enlUlry as ur~ 1l1~c.r,nalive, "
Cn;fit tfQd ,~t~ 'r,rodm~I' O~ Inal!lfi ~,llQIIiofi. I~ "!"H~ I~ h;~my 's1.'ii'~ed '"aII~,,~ ,~.ple.. hu:r n~i.bli!:: I'aob. h) n~ ~~lIly ~\"hiJ~ Um l(~nf11\tr- ~ 'fl\), - ane ilm!!! 3t :gll~ime:. ~mk .spanS tafS; =Je' ,an example nr «'0'11'11 ml'llnUrJt'UI ri fig. where the: Cillr' I!!. ~JQiU rac:nlred on (lrderilindauP'rdifli!, h~ llh~ eLI!5:{Q'I!~""r·~ ~~e i fii;!l!~io'n~. CllOl'~'t pro>::fm:non h,~ii, I,h" f~ IH~'I%I: ~)Ii. toe in;ji!: ::)ihle ~Clr worv ide ~'""'1l(,'~ 11)w~:ii<.'1l~ ~lh!l1'
j ~n n~'5,
rm.!dW;;1l mll .. ~ho:!p:ri!!l.!l~~T l~£c:!< nmllU\'~ ~~ sl. dll('d 1~'~f""'S'5'IO,t.;Jh [.0 ~Lpn p:nlMliluCts, II~ h} w1S~iUI;.-d er ~1;;'lnililh_"\c1 n;ilrk~·F!Io 'ilrer,JiUn~ "':"'pi;;"lt!O~'~l;. !>~n~k'rm!'f't"l"~ ... m,R;hiu't:"!>c. P,'fOOw::!!!. illf'!1' ~h~tHi~d nUl. In :J ~klutlli~rd.i.J'l.:'d r(~rtrlrn \.:"" hit:h \uhuu,,"!'o_ IkGIU"C Ui~~ rU!~dHl!)~r\ C"p,..b·. 50 1Il~I('h I . , ;md H, i~llt'lli~r.,~m ul' di~:f\!p~"~.lH, m~H~:rl:p(:I'~!~t::rk"r;;"1!,;'p~,~H~il'~~jillddesiJ;;!.I'l~· PI;tlJ~iedfj-!il fo~ ~~~I ~ht.:' .. j'irl 1.I,nn~ i;lj~q;irl;l{,! I.!·h,c!d~~r~'. ,1l~ Ibm'~.l'h Ul~' t:'lili~~.JnWf~~!~ h~\~. ..' ~r.~u~, r)ro,d'.W':.I~•. th~I'I.~' s nH~ari~m I I Lnl h"~I~''''' ·I ~.rl;j In ,~l;!';"' w(llluc1lun ,d~~, h.'ncl ttl 'hod 11K:: uri. mUlKIH~U(IU~~nd tim lI~p~ U Il~ n' ~1.n:;_j
'Ib;rtl('l() 1r!'fiI1 !hro 'J11~\ ~.. l'h!d,,_,,"!IItn '1I,j,~
l)n~"lfl
"'!E''''
11w
,,0011'pflm;I·I,I,,',:
Ulflt,·.
Fn.IIII~h~'M.~
~lMi~~~.(l!:1 ving. u
md
!iU,\-e[
l,.~i~M'il b~hi(! v ed Uhtrll~II'f1IIMafTI~~~.liH,:;~uri fi!:i\jWI)) 1~~'l.;'n,(;l.>d u:r the (b~y .~~ d opem1 i fI~ • n a '~i:gbr!l' dyo!llmicand ,compelit IVC l~n,<il1Qm~:lui o"~I~ich iO\N~: :~K:lliQn IC~' 't:rOOklmake'iilU the di'lI~ncc. 'l!1re ~h ry.,.~ abo on fo.r tl'J.to SiuC(iCSSIJir h:.rn !Q!IIlDI~mJg.. ~~~dI $Olrlll~ ~~' 5;ald. ca~'dl be· Aagi'fe ~ ma_l]Itlirru:!Wri'~s- Alir~ ~lI!'f,~!;niiae s~giI~t to ulinain ~ (Qmp;:'~i'i~ adv.1.fil~ by de>orelopinG agility in piIilnufscturif!1 ~"'"i'S!,i!![;. w:h~ch w()u:~d 1M:¢lp, l~ oo:lW1 paJrJ!jl uJ~.e~ qui:c!i<; I,), ~!i) m~rkc'l: el'bainges. K n"'wd,e!lg¢ 'W1li.S Oli!~i!iO am d
~ompaui!:.!i
or
impolflant
r'eSDWN.)e
iflngIL"m:lfwf~ct'L!rrr!:l~,
is'-!
.,.-
T
"II ...
Ii: i.-i~·f"""
·."'·1. ~
F~):lnij,fr:IV
~ocrects;
This ·ille~ild~~ lmh~ [hal db not meet the" prod uc l>Ton :~peci"fj.ca;titi~tsor q'(J<11 ~U -;s,t,.mdarcls, . :2_ . O~cr P F\ld uctio'l'l; ThI.;; :l~ei.3:rl!l·i;i,i'"(}dud ng in excess 'dfrequ reed 11 utrnri I.j'. It L'nyOh'b' nor o"n[y;wi."i:a_gt::Qf:prt:d.M~3 res.oun;es. but .i!lsp·addeq inY-¢l~tlDr.tcaflyrng ,c9;t~and thecosr
3.. Wait~flg~. 't:!l:ji;;dl::::.[ i~.il~l ut.e~~e'tT~ct~v~ly$.i:i w.&sre asit il'No't\·eg. costs J rk~ \va,ftf·S of ' I wo~ktts, as w~ll aKal~ 1f1"\ed"arlq '6v~):ht!"f.dtnsts )ib~:eJe~G'tH~ity" heating,. ~tt_" T'¢IiIC ,.
4. T(a IlSPO rU n.g: .f\:1Q-vlng C'()illp~nerltri .a:r1Hl:g<lqd.s. bel \\l_eeJl ;pl~"~c1> rl "'01 ves cost.' SQmefj nws i GtlS',~ may... e Ilit;i(le~ fll$- in the b reiCIu ~d·l0.1,J ~ -8, rijr~d~ rpo ve 91;Hpllt) and <1.1 i to _~ther lim~s.".app-arerH ," . OhO?-:,saI!1 that plants ~htlUld be!sId! QfH if:'! '~Hjch
lh'"
(jfrlh:"pO:;,.fng·e;X~
~(!.y¢ril\'f~t\ ..··
..
n.
:6. .In,ap·Rl'Opri~"tC Pr:O:¢!!S$ing.: l'h~~: 'nny ,:~1lIe to ;t.!'I* !i:Mil· f)i'pd ucr. t
I.. iml'em:u.o·'("l.: lW·IQing lhy~:m.QT'}' in ~XC.t~$I~' of \~'~1~1 ls r~l.!-"if'~~ ·0!4ds.Wo the COM· of prod t1clioQ, rt, alse has a b l.d¢en(jA~~t 1n I heseuse t'hi:H.1t ides ptobl~!Tl~ "thw 'V>~QtJ.l d {)l he.rwi SIlo hil\'~e Dee;l1appare FU,
IFt_"'
- _1I3u1:iI"1\;}~S
In the SY.'i;~ie~drrna~ ~l;itdSllJ~~~nbl!o. ,!;~i-ch leads ~u ~lS SU;pt:!~~~li~i(;h results m " SUjJplYlilf~ .malemls. llrt 'SotiJlIi_g romt is ~slo~:r'd:Cli1llalld for ~~ICpcOOu<:~n1U!'!Urad~~ b) . Cg1~!IiI p~~ ~~ne.
pun
Raw
"~~ills,
1
'-
~~l!';3\:l'tlre
i~ ih.:- plJ..h nr.mJlh,.~u~n~ ..~ ~h.",Iill_ lh,.. \~.~ I~ r'lr..bcd ~! m,.~h II..... ":."'~h,"ifn .I!l ~:adl $Ug.: R],~~ · n1,liaut~ .II!: n:flli~~U IHfi. ~I~~· Ul HMlLu1.:k.. '1"'1: rt--' ... t h1 ·c· rl~L1i.ttl· i,'I,;lII't:5 ;J~~. 1l!~.ltIulm1l,e-<t II ._~ JI~ seru ~u I he Z.M,:m hi'~ and ~ ao;;"~·ll1tt iI!.ii; ,If:JJOolLl'C'~ d~ fin ... rlfu';;hLC'1 he I} 1 1he ]lrOO IJ'~ ~ I hen I cad~ Illt markeru It,
'11
1.1&'
The ~Iml !~'1n calc u[~ir,~ ~l'~ nUf1il;t~r Oil!"i{anboo I hal pEa:.~cS" 'rh~ m.g5~ impo;Ml'mI, p.1n foo
.In ~.hL"
...
:::
r,
~,
,"" =
~¥aJi;in,S, I)WY ,~rKlIm.b<l!lI1I Pil:'Nusing ~~IDi: ConLllli rterQlp;lldl) {n,o:t meee tlmn [I'DOh. dai I~ of
n:
. . ...
.'loo.• '
"'::'......."._
rs
~70-1
,.- ......
-_. ....
ThM;,~~gIltl~d oowd m"-,!i. ~~,~~ <In... !oo OJIidlhas ~'p'unm m l'oyllilUl h\1o~or COIIP.'S P'jlIi!'l in CtOOirgd'O~W\l.IK", 1(111'1:~~ ~t S"~ or~~~:b'1 ~. ~h~ IILI'tC S'I.~_
~ ~f:IO.:I n.ristlflC"
Wj~~;mt:.i:W oJ ~I..:.n
,S,lmL
i","~: ~ ,~~
~IM:'~f"n:ac;hes
'Illn;_ !b::e .n tM
'~I!IO""IFdJ~
~L
I~
IS:-S