Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Z - The Black Book of Executive Politics
Z - The Black Book of Executive Politics
of execuTive PoliTics
By
By
Author: Z Editor: Kathy A. Shipp Editorial Director: Patrick DiDomenico Associate Publisher: Adam Goldstein Publisher: Phillip A. Ash
2010, 2002, 1995, 1993, Capitol Information Group, Inc., 7600A Leesburg Pike, West Building, Suite 300, Falls Church, VA 22043-2004; www.BusinessManagementDaily.com. Phone: (800) 543-2055. All rights reserved. No part of this report may be reproduced in any form or by any means without written permission from the publisher. Printed in U.S.A. ISBN: 1-880024-05-5 This publication is designed to provide accurate and authoritative information in regard to the subject matter covered. It is sold with the understanding that the publisher is not engaged in rendering legal, accounting or other professional service. If legal advice or other expert assistance is required, the services of a competent professional person should be sought.From a Declaration of Principles jointly adopted by a committee of the American Bar Association and a committee of publishers and associations.
About Z
ou probably know Z. In fact, youve no doubt read quotes by him in newspapers and seen him interviewed on television shows. You have also probably seen his picture in major business magazines. Z held top executive positions in several of Americas foremost corporations over more than two decades. During those years, Z helped those corporations expand and solidify their leadership in highly competitive fields. In the process, he developed some fascinating and controversial views on what makes people competitive in business. We are pleased to share with you Zs secrets for political survival in the corporate arena. Zs only stipulation was that we preserve his anonymity. What follows is a unique, unvarnished collection of political survival tactics from a top corporate executive.
Contents
1. All About Office Politics
Introduction Is Something Holding You Back? Your Political Road Map Gauge What a Person Can Do for You Your Personal Power Inventory Your Executive Style Political Mistakes
1
1 1 3 5 7 9 11
13
13 15 16
3. Survival Skills
The Power of Acting Out of Character Using the Technique Fighting Manipulation From Others How to Take Intelligent Risks That Lead You Upward The Solitary Risk A Dangerous Game: Bypassing Your Boss How to Distance Yourself From a Boss in Trouble Sexual ComeOns in the Office Handling a Hostile Press Coping With Emergencies Keep Pace With Tech Talk
19
19 19 20 21 22 23 25 26 29 30 32
35
35 36 37 39 43 45
47
47 48
Strategies for Coping With Resistance to Criticism Pros and Cons of Hiring a Friend Why Picking the Right Successor Is Vital
50 51 52
55
55 57 58 58 59 60 61 62 63
7. Moving Up or Moving On
Are You Promotable? Read the Handwriting on the Wall The Good News About Losing Your Job When to Take the Money and Run
65
65 66 68 69
eople who fail come in all shapes and sizes. In my years in business, Ive seen them all. Some rose through the ranks quickly, only to stall and drop for good like punctured balloons. Some were geniuses who perennially were underappreciated and not rewarded enough. But most were simply hard-working people with good ideas and instincts who got permanently stuck in ruts. Ive also seen a handful of people whoregardless of education, intelligence, manners, appearance or other obvious factorsrose steadily through the ranks and then stayed on top through fat and lean times. They were the type who, either consciously or instinctively, knew the art of political survival. These people didnt get ahead as a result of immoral or amoral behavior. Dont think that for a minute. They succeeded by throwing out an overblown, overly polite, crippling world view that keeps most of todays executives tripping over themselves to avoid offending other people.
There are two sides to every question. (The fact is, sometimes youre right and the other side is wrong. The opposite can also be true.) Always insist on getting credit for your ideasand on giving credit to others for their ideas. (Letting other people use your ideas can be more advantageous to you than to them if you cash in on the favor later on. And Ive noticed that many other people have good ideas they dont mind lending.) Work hard and success will invariably follow. (No one will notice hard work unless you make sure they do.) Success results from teamwork and cooperation. (The fact is, success often follows periods of conflict and discord.) The best ideas occur when everyone has a chance to contribute. (This is bunk; some of the greatest ideas in history have come from one visionary thinker.) To get people to work hard, you have to get them to like their jobsor like you. (A quick glance at corporate history disproves this one. Lee Iacocca, for example, was not popular with his subordinates.) It takes time to come back after a failure. (In reality, stunning successes often follow stunning failuresprovided a winning mind-set is at work.) Behave consistently if you want other people to respect you. (People wont know you think a situation is threatening unless you get a little excited from time to time.) People will like you more if you fit in. (In reality, it is differences that win respect and set you apart: Youre smarter, better connected, faster at making decisions and so on.) The best way to deal with people is to treat them as you would like to be treated. (Sure its the Golden Rule, but nine times out of ten people would like to be treated differently from the way you would.)
Do these opinions sound like the mental baggage youve been lugging around? Have they been slowing you down? If so, good. Weve got something to work with.
Black Book of Executive Politics / 3 If I can get you to toss out or just bend one or two of the stale, outmoded, ultimately useless ideas I just mentionedor the ones Im about to attack in the following pagesI guarantee your career will change in ways youll hardly believe. Youve got to have a little faith in meand a lot of faith in yourself. But if youre ready to change your life and your career, read on and lets get started.
4 / Business Management Daily Draw red lines to indicate any personal or strong political alliances you have perceived between people, which may or may not coincide with reporting lines. On or near each line, put one or two facts about the relationship. Examples: John reports to Mary but only on budget; Sue cant make a decision without consulting Elaine. Dont leave this road map lying around; it is a valuable political tool that could be misused in the wrong hands. This road map allows you to quickly visualize many of the relationships and cross-relationships that exist in your workplace, putting you at an instant advantage over people who try to carry this information around in their heads. Others may base their plans for advancement on the companys organizational chart, but you are beginning to get a picture of the power centers at work beneath the surface. You may find, for example, that certain people to whom you report form a power center you had partially overlooked in the past. Perhaps the president and one vice president attended the same college, and maybe a second vice president is a very close friend of the other one. Thats a structure that can have real power. Knowledge of this structure may enable you to exert influence on the company president by lending support to the ideas and projects of one of the vice presidents in question. Give support to the right person, and positive news about you will travel quickly upward to the president. Your map can provide knowledge of where you can exert influence on people, often without talking to them directly. I used this system early in my career to identify an executive who was not closely allied with company leaders and who was therefore likely to leave soon. With this insight, I positioned myself to be the candidate of choice for that job when it became vacant. I made a point of getting involved in the activities supervised by the outgoing executive and added to my skills and experience in areas that would qualify me for his position.
Black Book of Executive Politics / 5 Update your road map every few months without fail. When youre dealing with a large number of individuals, youll be surprised how frequently new situations evolve and power structures change. People leave, and new people come on board. A group of executives falls out of favor with the company president, or their departments lose importance in light of new company agendas.
Do your homework. Learn everything you can about a contacts history, both before and after joining the company. If appropriate, simply ask the person about her past activities and ideas. Be observant too. For example, notice what kind of technology the top executives use. I love the Handspring Visor, a step up from my old Palm Pilot. I carry it around everywhere. A sales-support guy whos way down on the totem pole here is an expert on personal digital assistants (PDAs), and awhile ago he saw me using my Visor. We compared notes like two
6 / Business Management Daily excited techies. Now hes always ready to show off some new feature of his Visor to me when we run into each other in the coffee room or hallway. We have a little bond as a result. If youre trying to learn about someone who is inaccessible because of higher rank, ask everyone you can about her past and her major accomplishments. Try to find out what her management style is and what types of subordinates she prefers to work with. Dont forget to ask, too, about education, interests, personal life and so on. Such traits can form a vital bridge to others in your organization.
Confirm your findings. In a casual way, confirm your findings with other people. One technique: Say to a colleague, Were really lucky to have Chris here, after she spearheaded the development of that successful line at Plum Software. Watch and listen carefully to gauge your contacts reactions.
Hone your observations. Using your personnel road map, begin to develop a picture of the persons responsibilities, reporting lines and activities. As you gather information, enter it into the map. Note projects or programs the person is currently overseeing or has headed in the past.
Go outside the firm. A wise executive doesnt confine himself to his own firm. By going outside your firm, youll learn things that you cant learn from within. For example, if a newcomer brought an extraordinary amount of success to a former employer, odds are that someone outside your firm will provide more detail about it than a coworker can or will. Youll also gain valuable insights on the agenda and approach the newcomer is likely to bring to your company. Such knowledge will give you an advantage over others. If you are told that a newcomer placed great stress on monitoring sales figures at his previous firm, for example, you can start monitoring them, become the in-house expert and win approval and support more quickly than your peers will.
Consider the persons status. Seasoned managers will often provide help to people who are new to a company or industry. If you are fairly
Black Book of Executive Politics / 7 new to your firm, you may find a well-positioned, senior executive who is willing to share ideas and political assistance if you show yourself to be bright and diligent. (Fair or unfair, it is usually more difficult to win that same kind of mentoring support from someone who is at your rank because you are perceived as a potential source of competition.) Dont overlook recently laid-off executives, by the way. Cultivating a relationship with someone who has taken early retirement can pay unexpected dividendsespecially if that person has a wide network of contacts you can tap to land a better job later.
Community. Do you live in the same community as colleagues or someone in upper management? Sharing a commute can strengthen a valuable alliance. So can the advantage of being able to talk about community concerns such as schools, parks and environmental issues. Family. Dont be reluctant to call on your relatives for advice or help. And sharing opinions with colleagues about childrens schooling and other family matters can establish a comfortable common ground. If you or your spouse can offer advice to your colleagues on concerns such as real estate, investments and so on, dont be shy about doing so.
Education and schooling. If you had a first-class education from prestigious schools, let that fact be known in quiet, unpretentious ways. Look for well-placed alumni of your alma mater. Review what you studied to be sure you are not neglecting skills or interests that could help you rise on the job.
8 / Business Management Daily Tip: Scan the parking lot for cars adorned with stickers of your alma mater. If you find one, chat up the cars owner and ask, for example, Did you go to Yale? Even if the person didnt, she may have a kid whos going there. Offer to help her son or daughter network with alumni.
Style. Are you a sophisticate, a jock, a chic dresser, a suburbanite, a tweedy rumpled type or a something else? Look for colleagues who share your style. Youll experience a high level of comfort and rapport with these peopleand youll find a number of allies. Personality. You can build an alliance by seeking out those who are attracted to your personality type or who share it. (You have been doing this already, of course. But have you stopped to think about how and why you do it?) Do you have a great sense of humor? Are you a positive thinker? Are you highly creative and intuitive? Are you a hard-boiled skeptic? These traits have value, and they can work for you. Look for people who sympathize with you and admire your outlook, and build your natural ties to them. Heritage. Although discriminating against people makes you a legal liability, you shouldnt be reluctant to take advantage of your cultural, religious, racial or national-origin background when selecting a firm to work for or when building alliances. Its an equally great mistake, of course, to gravitate only toward people who share your background. If you do, you cut yourself off from many valuable contacts and sources of support. People who take pride in their religion, ethnic background, country of family origin and so on encounter a heightened level of respect from those around them. Such self-respect, in fact, enables people from different backgrounds to connect to each other through similar experiences.
Appearance. An average appearance shouldnt slow you down in business, but if youre better than average looking, you already stand apart from the crowd. Dont rely on good looks exclusively, but count them as an asset that can help you look the part for a leadership role.
Black Book of Executive Politics / 9 Linguistic ability. If you grew up speaking a second language or if you acquired proficiency through study, you have a valuable tool. Use it to build ties to others who speak the same language, and look for opportunities to help your business move into foreign markets or establish ties abroad. Few abilities count for more in todays increasingly international business climate.
Personal interests. Hobbies, sports and other interests can gain you an immediate set of connections. Do you collect paintings or stamps, for example? These may seem like idle pastimes, but if you make these interests known at work, you may find a network of others who share themeven the company president or CEO.
Home. Just like your community, your home can be a great career asset. Use it to host power parties or an open house that showcases your interests and tastes.
In an effort to cultivate corporate style, many young managers try to emulate the attitudes, interests and outlooks of their colleagues. They try to fit in and finally do just thatright into pigeonhole-sized niches they have built for themselves. I remember one young executive who fit in so well that she was nearly indistinguishable from all her colleagues at first. It was only when I worked with her closely on several projects that I learned she had many interest-
10 / Business Management Daily ing individual traits. She had published articles on furniture refinishing and cooking and was a very competitive amateur tennis player. When I asked her why she had never distributed one of her articles or displayed any tournament pictures of herself in her office, she replied that it didnt seem appropriate to do so at work. My view: If your business is inhospitable to your style and thinking, trying to conform will only make you a fish out of water. Frankly, youre in the wrong business.
Standards. If you want to rise to the topmost executive ranks, you have to make a careful assessment of your personal and professional standards. Then you have to make a commitment to stick by them staunchly, no matter how difficult the circumstances. For example, if you are fully committed to the profitability of your department and its time to let some workers go, fire those who are the least capableregardless of your feelings. Central issue: Do you want to make friends or earn respect? The middlemanagement ranks are crowded with people who are popular, well liked by everyoneand stuck. Company CEOs and presidents are often not so well liked. In many cases, it is not because they are callous or unfriendly, but because they adhere to high standards and policies that make them stand apart.
Focus. The ability to concentrate completely on a task and get it done is central to advancement. Focus is also the most important part of what is often called executive presence. To see it in action, observe the person of power in a meeting. While others are veering off toward secondary concerns and dead ends, this person will not be diverted from his or her goals.
Appropriateness. Treat serious issues with a serious attitude. Some executives seem eager to make light of every situation. I have even seen some of them crack jokes just before laying off dozens of staff whose jobs were the sole means of support for their families.
Black Book of Executive Politics / 11 Needless to say, I never again considered those executives for promotions. Although telling a few jokes to blow off steam may break the tension of difficult decisions, it will also make you appear too green for positions of real responsibility.
Sobriety. Nothing will undermine your credibility more quickly than having a few drinks at lunch and returning to the workplace smelling of alcohol. Never do it. Even worse: drinking and acting out of character at a company party or picnic. What you do at home is your affair, but what you do at work is your business. By the same token, inappropriate romantic or sexual liaisons will push you right off the corporate ladder. (See Chapter 3, Sexual Come-Ons in the Office.)
Political Mistakes
Now that youre on your way toward building a bulletproof political network and putting all your assets to work, consider this list of things you should never do: Bad timing. If you havent progressed beyond establishing that you and your contact share an interest in travel, its too soon to ask for help in winning a new sales territory. You have to bide your time. Before asking someone for help, consider whether your relationship is ready to bear the weight of what youre requesting.
Toe stepping. Before you look to a person (or a group) for support, consider the position he occupies. If a new territory or set of responsibilities is up for grabs, asking the head of another department for help in winning that may be a serious mistake if hes considering making a play for it as well.
Exception: If your alliance with such a person is exceptionally strong and well maintained, asking for his support may prompt him to drop out of the competition, sometimes without resentment. Alternately, it may open up discussion of a mutually beneficial approach to the situation.
12 / Business Management Daily Relying on foundationless alliances. Being friendly with another manager is not enough for you to rely on him for strong support in emergency situations. Be sure there are a variety of other supporting factors, including a history of cooperation, to add a foundation to your relationship. The more you ask for, the stronger the relationship must be.
Overusing an alliance. The more valuable an alliance, the less often you should use it for help in big projects. (A strong ally will be silently working for your interests in many small ways without your knowing it every day.) If you walk into a highly placed colleagues office too often to ask for a favor, the quality of your connection will erode quickly.
Think of an alliance as a rechargeable battery. After using it, you have to re-energize it before tapping into it again. After getting a favor, return a favor in a big way or do some high-level stroking to keep the alliance running strong. Letting alliances lapse. If the very person who can help you is someone with whom you used to enjoy close political ties but have been neglecting lately, dont count on picking up your former close relationship where it left off. It is also a serious mistake to suddenly start currying favor by taking that person out to lunch, calling him to chat and so on before making a pitch for support. Best: Maintain close ties to your colleagues, letting none of them lapse. Next best: Come clean. Tell the person that you are aware you havent been in close touch lately but you have good memories of past projects you shared and are calling to ask for support. Strengthen this approach with an immediate offer of support for one of your contacts current concerns.
Posturing. When trying to win support or influence someone, its dangerous to imply that she should support your project because you are strongly connected to someone at the top. First, the implication is a threat. Second, if the top person turns out to be a less-than-staunch supporter in this instance, youre going to lose face with everyone. Third, everyone knows that you are strongly connected to the bigwig anyway and will weigh that information in deciding whether to support you. Blowing your own horn only makes you a blowhard.
These are the basics of political survival. Now lets turn to how you can use them to win the influence game.
ontrary to a popular misperception, clout is not your ability to threaten or coerce people into cooperating with you. Instead, clout is your unspoken influence that leads others to line up behind you and support you without being pressured. Its that kind of strong, silent support base you need to make the ultimate climb into the executive suite. You dont get clout in a day, or even a week. It accrues gradually as people come to see you as a leader when you apply standards, learn to focus and use the other positive political assets Ive already discussed. There are certain times in business when you must cash in on the clout you have built up. Of course, youre not going to call people up and threaten them into supporting you. You are, however, going to tell them you are counting on their support to reach a particular, focused goal. Why do you need to contact people and ask for support? Simply because people are busy and actively pursuing their own needs. You cant expect them to monitor your activities and know when you want their help to reach an immediate goal. It is part of your job to communicate with themto say, Im counting on your help this time, when it will really count. Here, then, are certain times when you may want to cash in your clout by asking for specific support: Youre heading up an especially risky project. Lending your support to a new project that succeeds is a career windfall; to one that bombs, a career nightmare. Its better to be remembered for three remarkable successes than for four remarkable successes and one or two failures, so step into high-risk situations with care and use your clout to build support.
Responsibilities are up for grabs as your firm reorganizes. If your company changes direction and your responsibilities change, you may need 13
14 / Business Management Daily focused help as you carve out a new role for yourself. (Fact: A temporary cutback in responsibilities usually becomes permanent.) Youre taking on significant new responsibilities. If youre supervising a new department or division, for example, you may need to use your clout to get the cooperation required to let you start from a position of strength.
Youre moving to a new location. If you take a job in a branch or regional office, you must leverage your clout to make sure its not a trip to nowhere.
Your momentum has stalled. Youre not at the top, but your upward progress has stopped. Perhaps youre not included in meetings or invited to head new committees. Perhaps your staff is being reduced. Youre getting positive feedback on job reviews, but no promotions. Calling on your support base can break the deadlock. Ive seen stalled executives time and time again regain their career momentum by calling on their clout to win several well-timed gains.
How you frame a request has a real impact on the outcome. Heres a simple example of how the same request can be framed to appeal strongly to different types of people: Suppose you are trying to win support for a community-centered program in which your company would help local elementary schools pay for highspeed Internet access so students could use the Web more efficiently. The idea sounds like only one proposal. But consider how it can be reshaped and positioned in a number of ways to appeal to different executives: 1. When pitching the idea to the head of marketing, position the idea as a marketing tool. Your campaign can reinforce the companys image as a cutting-edge firm that is committed to introducing the latest technology into the community. It can also be used as a vehicle for public relations in the local media, as a form of effective advertising, as a way of gaining exposure for your company through cooperative programs with Internet service providers.
Black Book of Executive Politics / 15 2. When pitching it to the head of human resources, position it as a way to improve employee morale by engendering the feeling that the company practices good citizenship in the community. 3. When pitching it to a cost-conscious company president, position it as a relatively low-cost way to win widespread community exposure and perhaps even as a cost-effective alternative to planned advertising campaigns. An idea is like a work of art in that each observer looks at it a bit differently depending on his vantage point. Your job is to position your idea or proposal in the best light for each person who sees it. This system can double or even triple the frequency with which you gain support for your ideas.
Keep things simple. Distill your ideas into a few sentences. Have supporting data and paperwork available to settle disputes, strengthen your case or distribute laterbut dont present them in negotiations unless theyre needed. Structure your presentation. Reveal your biggest idea immediately, without a preamble. If your first point is well received, make your second and third points. Resist the temptation to keep throwing in lesser and lesser points to fill up the timethey only weaken your stance. If you win agreement, stop talkingeven if you still have points to make. The longer you talk, the greater the chance that someone will disagree. Anticipate objections. Be sure to do your homework on how the people on the other side are likely to react to your proposal. Research how they treated similar proposals in the past, and anticipate objections your opponents are likely to make.
Build in some sacrifices. To protect the meat of your proposalthe things you really dont want to see cut outadd a few chips youre willing to give up. You can then bargain them away and end up with the parts that mean the most to you.
Dont try to score all the points. Your position will be strengthenedand cooperation more likelyif you accede to some ideas from people who are critiquing your presentation. Theyll feel as though they are part of the decision, and theyll be more committed to seeing your idea succeed.
Meet resistance flexibly. When you care a great deal about a project, you may tend to overreact when someone raises questions. Try to foster an atmosphere of cooperationit implies that your project or proposal is already under way. If negotiations stall completely, try to ascertain what is really bothering the other side. Dont become argumentative, but make an effort to read between the lines. As a last resort, consider throwing one of your sacrifice chips away to get things moving.
Dont give away the store. Accept a certain number of modifications to your plans, but dont let them get converted into another persons project that youre now expected to supervise. If you see this happening, offer to withdraw the entire proposal.
Rise above politics. Its funny advice to be giving in this book, but try not to classify past opponents as enemies when youre making a presentation. The more important your proposal, the more vital it is to appear to have the interests of the entire company at heartespecially when top management is in attendance. Dont betray any aggressive feelings toward your opponents or act condescending.
Black Book of Executive Politics / 17 Yes, teams can accomplish remarkable things. But Im also a firm believer that great ideas come from individuals who convince other people through the power of their opinions. Without individual opinions, group progress can become difficult, if not impossible. How many times have you been in a meeting that generated no ideas because everyone was trying to be open to everyone else or proposing lukewarm solutions to avoid offending anyone? One of the most remarkable and effective executives Ive observed at close range owed much of his success to the fact that he didnt follow this practice. For our purposes here, lets call him Mr. O. Having started as head of a branch office, he had been promoted to director of operations for an electronics company in a few short years. When I collaborated with him, he had remained on top for nearly a decade, solidifying his position as he guided his growing company to a position of prominence in its field. Mr. O was not a visionary genius. But what he did havewhenever he had done his homework and knew he was rightwas an opinion. In fact, the ability to press strongly toward the goals he felt were valid was really the only thing that set him apart from his colleagues. He would stride into a meeting armed with some idea or plan he believed was right, and everyone present would be forced either to react positively or to proposeand defendanother approach to the problem. Plans were made and projects completed effectively and simply because Mr. Os opinions acted as a fulcrum for others to use in their thinking and work. I began to notice one curious fact: Ideas from almost everyone on the staff were being implementednot just the ones from this man. Yet he was the reason for the progress. Does an approach like Mr. Os run counter to all the new thinking about teams and cooperation? No. Opinions and agendas are always at work within any group of peoplewhether you call it a team, a task force or a committee. People who have the substance to say, This is what I think; this is what I believe is right, serve as the catalyst for change and action. We need them more than ever. Ive also noticed that such action-oriented individuals often get the credit when a group achieves noteworthy results.
Survival Skills
The Power of Acting Out of Character
onsciously acting out of character is manipulative, but it is one of the most powerful tools at your disposal. In my first job after college, it worked on me. I was called into the office of one of our company vice presidentsa man who was, to put it mildly, aloof. In fact, he had not even nodded to me up until then. When I entered his office, he invited me to sit and was very cordial. He asked questions about my college studies, my interests, my family and whether I had found satisfactory living quarters in the city. Then he outlined some stiff new responsibilities he wanted me to assume and ushered me out of his office. The next day, all I got from him was a hurried nod in the hall. Hungering for some of that same interpersonal contact again, I worked hard to get the job done well. Years later, I realized that he had manipulated me by a change of style. But the ruse was as beneficial for me as it was for the manipulator. I got extra motivation to get the work done, and it contributed to my advancement. This story bears out one of the central ideas of this book: In most cases, bending the rules gets things done and helps everyone out. The rule that was broken in this case was the one that says people will work best for you if you project a consistent personality and outlook.
20 / Business Management Daily Here are some basic character polarities and how to use them: Familiar versus aloof. As shown in the last example, sudden friendliness achieves results. If you are habitually gregarious, by contrast, a dose of aloofness can go a long way toward making people think that you have something on your mind or that they are not performing to your satisfaction.
Polite versus brusque. If youre a cut-the-baloney type, a sudden act of politeness (holding the door for a colleague or helping someone into an overcoat) can temporarily disarm an opponent or predispose an ally toward doing a favor for you. If, however, you are usually a model of civility and decorum, storming out of a meeting once in your career to make an important point is probably a good idea.
Serious versus humorous. Shifting from one pole to the other can produce stirring results. If youre a never-crack-a-smile type, you can sway a meeting once in a while by opening with a cornball joke. However, if you usually have a sunny personality, you can send a shiver down peoples spines by refraining from laughing when everyone else does. Opinionated versus passive. If you always state your views strongly and give detailed instructions, you can motivate a colleague by saying, Youre in charge on this project, and I trust you to do what is necessary. However, if youre more passive in nature, try taking a strong line for an important project.
Black Book of Executive Politics / 21 something I had done and pulled it apart. It was management by terroror at least an attempt at it. But I didnt let myself become a victim. Here are the strategies I used to fight this manipulation: First, my work was always very good. When this executive was in his attack mode, he couldnt really destroy what I had done. I always had a reason for what I had done, approval from the necessary people and a valid goal I was trying to reach. Even when he was looking the other way, I maintained high standards. Second, I kept a steady course. I realized that if I let that executive trick me into spending weeks repairing some project he had just attacked, he would then pounce on some other activity that I had temporarily relegated to a lower priority. I saw that I needed to prioritize my activities according to valid goals and needs, and remain steady. By showing that I was incapable of being manipulated off course, I forced him to deal with me on a more honest plane. Third, I didnt let the manipulations upset meat least not visibly. I saw the manipulation for what it wasa clumsy attempt at intimidation. I adopted a calm, businesslike demeanor when I was under attack or scrutiny. I answered questions, looked the attacker in the eye, remained calm and kept up to speed on all assignments. The boss soon realized that I was not vulnerable to his maneuvers.
What are the worstand bestthings that can happen? If the worst thing that can happen is that youll irritate your staff and the best thing is that youll contribute significantly to the bottom line, the risk is worth taking.
Do you have the total support of the people you need? Look at your political road map (see page 3) and my earlier comments on clout (see page 13). Consider whom you will need to support you. If necessary, reinforce your critical political alliances.
Is it fun? If you can convince yourself, your staff and your superiors that a risky undertaking is challenging and fun, youre far more likely to gain needed support. Frame the undertaking in an appealing way to gain supportlike the way Tom Sawyer induced others to help him whitewash Aunt Pollys fence.
What are the implications for your career? If you undertake a risky assignment and succeed, you become strongly associated with what you have done. Thats a tie that will exert a force on what people ask you to do in the future. Consider career implications before taking action.
Black Book of Executive Politics / 23 Analyze the outcome if you succeed. Are you ready to deal with what youve taken on if you succeed? Its a trap to romanticize the joy of how wonderful it will be to advance rapidly by taking a big chance. It can be grandbut such a step is not without risks.
Prepare. The wise risk-taker knows what shes getting into. Dont just reinforce your key political connections two or three days before you make your move. Telecommuters can fall into this trap if they suddenly start showing up at the office to butter up their contacts just before they submit a controversial proposal. If youre playing with this degree of risk, you had better keep your fences mendedand reinforcedat all times.
24 / Business Management Daily immediately clear to me, and I made a point of subtly promoting it and giving her a chance to show what she could do. (Incidentally, I did not penalize her boss for his resistance to the idea; our opinions on its virtue were simply different.) This was an instance where a subtle end run around a boss netted good results. She succeeded for these reasons:
Her idea was good. Thats the most important factor. Had it been a poor idea, she would not have won. She had shown herself to be an excellent worker. People with poor track records had better not try to circumvent a bosseven the most flawed boss in existence. She had made an honest, concerted effort to convince her boss. She wasnt sneaking around trying to use her good idea to make her boss look bad. She had, in fact, tried to win approval by the book and had been rebuffed and ignored by him. She chose a means that was respectful of company structures. Had she marched into my office to complain about her boss, I would have shown her right out again. She allowed me, through her memo and reports, to recognize the virtue I saw in her idea without making her boss look bad. She had a CEO who was smart and receptive to good thinking. I have always valued profitable ideas over company protocols. Somehow, this woman realized I was that kind of CEOa factor that lessened the degree of risk and increased the chances of a positive response to her idea.
There are other situations, too, when its not out of the question to bypass a boss. If your boss is a bully or completely ineffectual, for example, he will be seen as such by upper management. The spread of 360-degree feedback, in which employees get critiqued not only by their boss but
Black Book of Executive Politics / 25 also by their peers, allows many organizations to identify and eradicate duds pretty quickly. And if its any comfort, bad management radiates up as well as down. If you think that your boss will soon leave or be replaced, that will lessen the overall risk of bypassing him. Doing so may even position you for gain in the restructuring that will follow his departure. But let me close this section on the same note as I began: Bypassing is a great risk. Never attempt it without a prior grasp of the possible and even probable damage that can follow a failed effort. By handling it as I have suggested here, you can make it a calculated risk instead of a slapdash one and increase the chances of success.
In part, establishing this independent profile is a question of style. Dont always be seen with your bossthe me-and-my-shadow syndrome. At staff meetings or company retreats, dont hover around the boss or race to sit close to him. Resist the temptation to cultivate a close tie with your boss exclusively by socializing. Be sure to earn his support through a variety of means.
26 / Business Management Daily Professional autonomy. In your relationship with your boss, be clear that your work activities are your productseven though he may have instructed you to do them. Invest your work with your personal approach and content.
Political independence. Develop a broad range of contacts and a network of support in which your boss is not the only player. Report to him, but interact with dozens of other key people.
If your boss falls into disfavor with top management, key shareholders or the board of directors, you must immediately decide whether that disfavor is justified. If he really has been performing inadequately, continuing to lend unqualified support will only make you more strongly associated with your bosss teamand less likely to survive any coming debacles. If, however, your boss is genuinely capable and upper management is being unfair, you have to weigh a variety of factors and plan appropriate actions accordingly. Consider:
Upper managements style. If your companys leaders motivate workers by instilling fear, its possible that your boss may not be on his way out. Bide your time, and see what happens.
Your bosss clout. If your boss is well respected in your industry, it might be wise to continue your support. He will land on his feet with some other company or emerge victorious from the current power struggle, and your support will have earned you his gratitude. If he leaves, the fact that you continued your support may not work against you with top managementespecially if your boss was in the doghouse because of a difference in style or approach rather than incompetence.
Black Book of Executive Politics / 27 to be vigilant as hell about setting the right example and treating every allegation of harassment seriously. The current efforts to safeguard all employees against the pressure of sexual harassment on the job are laudable and long overdue. However, it is important to remember that sexual attractions are a natural part of interpersonal chemistry, and the workplace is certainly not exempt. Sometimes, Ms. and Mr. Right meet on the job, fall head-over-heels and plan to spend the rest of their lives together. When this happens, all other issues have a way of sorting themselves outwhen and how the pair should tell coworkers and whether one of them should leave the firm to preserve healthy business and domestic relationships. But other sexual interactions pose more difficult questions. The key is to nip unwelcome come-ons in the bud so they dont escalate. Be on the lookout for a coworker who:
Sends you e-mail with off-color jokes or links to sexually suggestive Web sites. Calls you over to gawk at magazine articles, drawings or photographs with a sexual theme. Violates your personal space subtly but repeatedly during face-to-face encounters. Follows you to your car in the parking lot frequently, and pries about your personal life (asks about your dating activity, status of your relationship/marriage and so on). Seems unusually interested in your personal grooming and appearance, and consistently comments on it in excessive detail.
While none of the above necessarily constitutes sexual harassment, the larger issue is knowing how to recognize these red flags and taking steps to deal with them. For example, dont let yourself get suckered into being behind closed doors alone with such a person. While the odds are that nothing terrible will happen, why risk it?
28 / Business Management Daily Another politically smart move is to remain friendly with these folksbut not too friendly. Ignore their risqu e-mails, but reply by discussing a business issue. If they snoop about your personal life, laugh off their interest and change the subject. You might say, Oh, my lifes just fascinating, and then, without skipping a beat, ask in all seriousness, Whats the status of your report? Of course, others may simply find you attractive and want to test the waters. They may not know youre married or otherwise taken, or they may know but want to pursue you anyway. Your job is to draw the line. Accept compliments about your appearance with thanks, and then move on. Fend off advances with a firm but polite reply: My rule at work is to keep things entirely professional. When someone makes a sexual overture toward you, ask yourself the following: Is it a power play? Since biblical times, people have been using sex either promised or providedto advance themselves. Look objectively at the persons position, and decide whether you can make whatever choices you want, free of coercion. Then look at your own emotions: If you feel complimented, empowered or excited by the sexual advance, take care that your own emotions dont lead you into a trap.
Is it just sleazy? Men and women who are bored and looking for sexual liaisons among coworkers often lose sight of their professional or personal priorities. In many cases, theyre emotionally stunted, devious or plain old troublemakers. Avoid these people.
Is it interesting? It would be crazy for me to tell people never to enter into relationships with coworkers. If you have determined (after a reasonable amount of time and some reflection) that the personal and political risks are minimal, you may decide to make an informed decision to explore the attractionbut always do it outside the workplace. Dont blab about your escapades to a friend at work. Trust me, no ones going to keep that kind of secret! Word will spread, and then the real disruption will set in. There are always more risks than you can anticipate when romance and
Black Book of Executive Politics / 29 work are combined. Its like throwing a stone into a pondthe ripples extend outward and may have secondary effects that you simply cannot predict.
What does it say about you? When two coworkers enter into a relationship, it is almost always discovered or sensed by others at work. Pretend that others on the job know of your relationship. What would that be like? What would it say about you? What impact would it have on your career or your partners? If their comments about you would be bad (because your potential partner has had previous relationships with coworkers, one of you is married, and so on), refrain from entering into the relationship. What is the context? If a coworker invites you to dinner or the theater, the flirtation has begun on a fairly sophisticated plane and is mutual. However, a sudden advance at the office partyallowing no time for you to consider the ramificationsshould be rebuffed at all costs. It could easily make you the center of gossip and destroy the credibility it may have taken you years to achieve.
30 / Business Management Daily Another important strategy is to speak in sound bites. Use sentences that are as brief as possible to limit the possibility that your comments will be misinterpreted or taken out of context. This is especially important when youre taping a radio or TV interview because they are likely to summarize your remarks in only two or three seconds of footage. A long, rambling sentence is more likely to be used only in part, increasing the chances that your statements will be used out of context and make you look bad.
The what if question. Example: What if the fire spreads and fatalities resultwill your firm make restitution to the families of victims? Dont ever let yourself get pulled into speculation. Reporters can trap you in a seemingly unimportant speculation and then lead you into more damaging statements.
The yes-or-no question. Example: Did your company take adequate safety precautions? Yes or no? This is an overt ploy to make you look bad, and it will work. To limit the damage, say, We will be issuing a report containing that information shortly. Whatever you do, dont pick some arbitrary date when an answer will be forthcoming.
Black Book of Executive Politics / 31 The No. 1 priority question. Example: What is your companys No. 1 priority in fighting pollution? If you say youre reducing your plants output of airborne pollutants, the press might criticize you for ignoring water-purity restrictions. Say, We are attacking many major concerns, including . . .
The off-the-record question. Always respond to a reporter as though your statements will become a matter of public record. Odds are that they will. If you are asked to comment off the record, refuse. Never say anything unless you are prepared to see it in print or on the air.
The either/or question. Example: Either your company wants to keep the citizens of this town employed or it wants to close down the factory. Which is it? This is an attempt to paint you into a corner. Your best defense is to point out that the either/or case is spurious. Time permitting, explain the issues that confront your company.
The multiple-choice question. Example: Will you replace outmoded equipment to meet new EPA guidelines, repair the old equipment or just shut down temporarily? Simply because the reporter is supplying the options doesnt mean that you cant ignore them and supply some of your own.
The statement question. Example: You obviously dont want to spend money on community development projects. Convert the statement into a question: If youre asking about our current programs, let me explain them for you.
The second-guess question. Example: How do you think your competitors will respond to your new product line? You should respond, Youd better ask them that question.
The policy-statement question. When you go before the press armed with information on a specific issue, some reporter may ask, What is your companys stand on the environment? To avoid a lengthy silence or an ill-conceived reply, tie your answer into the matter you came prepared to discuss and point to it as an example of your companys outlook. Ques
32 / Business Management Daily tions like this present a golden opportunity to display your background research and tell of past activities that show your firm in a positive light.
Black Book of Executive Politics / 33 Track applications in your industry. Stay plugged in to what your competitors are doing on the technology front. Ask friends in those companies what programs theyre using, which vendors and what investments theyre making. You may not get all the answers youre looking for, but snooping cant hurt. And if you uncover useful information, you can pass it along to your bosses and look like a hero. Talk to the IT staff. You win office politics when you build trustand you develop real trust only by sitting down with people and interacting with them on their turf. So dont just exchange occasional e-mails with the info-systems crew down the hall. Get together and learn what excites them. Become familiar with the new technologies theyre beta-testing so that you can, in turn, brag about your cuttingedge knowledge to unenlightened execs.
Maybe youve seen the Saturday Night Live skit, Nick Burns: Your Companys Computer Guy. Nick is an all-too-recognizable help-desk geek who mistreats the hapless end user. He likes to yell Move! when he arrives to fix a technical glitch; then he fiddles with the persons computer and promptly saves the day. Theres a political lesson in this sketch: Be nice to folks who have expertise that you lack. Even if theyre obnoxious, rise above the urge to act the same way. Get on their good side and youll have key allies throughout the organization.
ll of us have gotten into neckandneck races with another executive. It can be as elementary as a oneonone fight for a promotion slot or as complicated as a political struggle to increase staffing during crunch times. In direct competition, youll be comparing yourself to your adversary: your work records, length of employment and so forth. But the sum total of all these variables is the elusive factor known as influence. Roughly defined, influence is the degree of acceptance that upper man agement has accorded you based on your past efforts, personality and political strength. No two employees have the same power to influence. Its one of the most important factors in determining who will succeed. An insecure opponent will usually resort to posturing: alluding to connections, dropping names and bragging about how much she has con tributed to the firm in the past. Or, a close political ally of your opponent may drop by to convey this information to you indirectly. If your adversary throws up this smoke screen, dont be discouraged or intimidated prematurely. Your adversary may or may not be in a position of poweryou wont know until you confirm the following information:
Activity.Is your opponent still on the same committees that she served on three or six months ago?
Staff. How many people does your opponent supervise? Has this number gone up or down over the last year or two? How does turnover in your unit compare to that of your opponent? Why did people leave? 35
Positioning. Where is your company headed? Considering current company policy and plans, compare the role of your department to that of your adversarys. For example, a marketing director may have an advantage over a headof sales in a firm that is moving away from field sales and into direct marketing promotions.
Personality.If you find your opponent unpleasant, odds are that upper management does, too. Unless they need an ogre to do the job, you are probably at an advantage.
act out of proportion. Before doing anything, speak to one or two people to find out what actually occurred. Nothing makes you look more foolish than overreacting to a minor infraction. Dont kill a mosquito with a shotgun. Keepyourcomposure. Dont lose control or become erratic. If youre going to become unpleasant or combative, let it be a conscious decision, used to obtain specific results. In most cases, a calm exterior, coupled with decisive action, lets you come out looking like a pro.
Actquickly. Waiting a few days to get your defenses in place will only magnify the damage.
Respond appropriately. If another executive has told a member of your staff that youre a bad manager, dont go right to his staff and make the same chargesit would only show that you operate on the same low plane as your opponent. Retaliate instead by winning a bigger victory elsewhere. Consider what your political network can do to help you. Youll show your opponent that you can play a more sophisticated game than he
Black Book of Executive Politics / 37 can and that it doesnt pay to tangle with you. But most important, youll send the message subtly. Dealwiththeproblemdirectly.Sometimes it is best to go directly to the offender, state exactly what he has done and demand an explanation. This approach may trigger a feud that will be hard to contain. More often, however, the result is something unexpectedyour opponent comes back at you with a countercharge about some offense you committed in the past and have forgotten. If so, you have been handed a bargaining chip. Agree to undo the damage, and it may be possible to arrange a compromise and win the conflict.
As in all other matters, a wellmaintained political network increases your odds of success: Your opponent knows that what happens to you will affect his political fortunes as well as yours.
Something about him didnt add up from day one. I sometimes wondered why I had seen him in the company of so many people around the organizationpeople with whom he had no reason to be in contact. He often would make statements about how much he hated dishonesty and politicking. If I had trusted my gut feeling, I would have known that he was up to that kind of monkey business.
To my knowledge, my friend was never deceived again. And you wont be either if you apply the following tactics: 1. Acknowledgewhatyouseeandsuspect. If you see a subordinate in the company of dozens of your peers or visiting offices around the company for no apparent reason, ask the people he saw about the purpose of the visits. Then approach the suspected offender with some casual questions about what he was doing, and compare his answers with those of the people he visited. Same goes if you notice that an employee routinely sends email to a wide range of coworkers in other departments. If youre one of the many managers who occasionally monitors your workers email usagewhich I wholeheartedly suggest you do after informing your staff that their email should have a business purpose and that you reserve the right to check up on themsee if youre surprised by any names that keep pop ping up as senders and receivers of his messages. Note, too, that a trickster may take a long time establishing rapport with someone whom he will only later use for political purposes. But you will inevitably see a pattern of deception emerging, provided you pay atten tion to whats happening and ask questions early on. 2. Listenforpatternsandrepetitions. A worker who talks too often about morality or honesty may well be immoral or dishonest. Moral, honest people dont need to tell everyone they have integrity.
Black Book of Executive Politics / 39 3. Comparestatementswithresults. There are always small discrepancies between what a dishonest person does and what he says. A worker may make a show of being a great salesperson, for example, but that greatness is not reflected in the figures he attains. Or he may claim to have great ideas, but you discover that those ideas are never as great or as well developed as he promised. 4. Engageinsomesubtlefactfindingandcrosschecking. Almost always, a deceptive person will inadvertently betray dishonest intentions. He may claim to be nearly done with planning a project, for example, but then prove incapable of showing you what he has accomplished. Or he may claim to have discussed an issue in a meeting, but your probing reveals that he has lied about what was discussed or planned. People unknowingly reveal their secret intentions if you are astute and patient enough to ask the right questions and watch small patterns of behavior over time. In even a short while, a number of small things can add up to a pattern of deception and dishonest plans. There is no reason for you to be taken by surprise.
40 / Business Management Daily against you. In all likelihood, he will make some mistakes and give you the opportunity to accrue some benefits. In the next section, lets look at the most common types of detractors and what you can do about them.
Selfaggrandizers
These opponents routinely exaggerate accomplishments or political clout. At first, you may be taken in by them. They seem to be powerful, influ ential, well positioned. But something does not add up, and that lack of legitimacy in their claims quickly becomes clear. Some years back, I knew a selfaggrandizer in human resources who continually made reference to the many changes she had brought about in the company benefits packagethe benefits she had proposed, the money she had saved, the thanks she had reaped from grateful employ ees. But then I noticed that the company benefits package was nothing special; it was one of those boilerplate affairs so common at many firms. Later, I noticed that the company president was looking at materials from a medical insurance company and asking my opinion rather than that of the human resources head. Of course, I saw quite clearly that the womans claims were bogus. That is the essence of how you spot selfaggrandizers. Something is not believable about their claims; something simply does not add up. When the company president says Good morning to him in the hall, the braggart will come by to tell you he just had a policy meeting with the company president. You wont be taken in if you become sensitive to discrepancies between what a person says and what you see happening. Perennial selfaggrandizers are generally not taken too seriously by anyone unless, for example, the posturer is the presidents nephew or the president himself. You can generally pay little attentionor listen quietlyto the persons trumpedup tales of glory and either forget them or mentally file them away for later assessment.
Insinuators
They engage in intrigues by playing people against each other, juxtaposing halftruths that seem to add up to reality but have no basis in fact. Often, their manipulations seem to serve no political endthey are simply a product of some quirky thirst for turmoil and intrigue. One insinuator I knew told a female executive that the president had just rewritten her quarterly earnings report because it was disorganized. So she spent two days revising the report. When she presented it to the president, she was astonished to hear that the report had been just fine in the first place. When the woman confronted the insinuator, he tried to wriggle his way out of his original claims by insinuating that the woman had misunderstood. Needless to say, the next time he appeared at her office door, she discounted his news. Insinuators often possess magnetic personalities that make their concern seem genuine. Frequently, they offer advice or information in areas where they have no business prying. So beware of sudden friendly advice with notsofriendly overtones, especially from those who have no good reason to offer it. Question their motives. Chances are, they are only try ing to trip you up. To defend yourself from insinuators, make it a practice to confirm their reports directly with those concerned or with others who have pertinent knowledge. The insinuator may say, perhaps, that you are using the wrong vendor and give you the name of someone better. Take that name to other people in the firm and get confirmation that the suggestion is a good one. Or, in the guise of a friend, the insinuator may claim that your boss is displeased with something youve done. Your best defense is to go right to your boss and disclose what that friend just told you. Then confront the perpetrator directly. Even if he tries to shirk blame by saying you misunderstood, you will have sent the signal that hes being scrutinized. A chronic insinuator will eventually play the same card too often and become widely recognized for what he is. One step Id counsel against, however, is going to others in your firm and issuing warnings about the insinuator. It can only reflect badly on you. At
42 / Business Management Daily best, youll come off looking like a tattletale. In the worst of circumstances, it can drag you into a morass of charges and countercharges that can be longrunning and damaging to your reputation.
Sleightofhand artists
A variant of the insinuator, this type tries to throw you off by providing some focused, spurious information to win an immediate, strategic advan tage. Just before a meeting, for example, I once had another executive tell me: That idea of yours will never get approved. I proposed the same thing last year, and it got shot down. Well, I went ahead and proposed it anyway, and it got approved. I could smell that something did not add up in the mans sudden counsel, and I knew that my idea was good. How do you spot these types? The fact is, its hard not to be fooled once or twice by this type of con artistespecially if he is clever and has been a good colleague in the past. Usually, you can spot the spurious advice because it is designed to prevent you from taking some specific action, such as making a presentation or signing a contract. Often, the advice comes at the last minute and is not specific: Something is simply wrong with your idea; it is sure to make you look bad, for no explicable reason; it requires more time for development. You might be fooled once or twicebut make sure the second time is the last.
Advantageseeking strategists
These types implement shortrange schemes designed to make them look good in any situation. For them, even the most minute opportunity to look good at the expense of others must be seizedfrom ordering sand wiches for a meeting (she knows a better deli than you do) to writing a contract (youd better let her lawyers have a look at the document your lawyer prepared). When youre cooperating on a project with this type of person, she says theres no pressure and starts off at a sluggish pace. When you follow her lead and start slowly, she secretly catapults forward, finishes far ahead of you, then turns in her work early to make you look like a snail.
Black Book of Executive Politics / 43 Weve all been victims of petty intrigues like these. But the good news is that such small wins constitute major victories only in the eyes of the strategists themselves. No one else much cares.
Bullies
Theyre simply addicted to the feeling that other people are knuckling under. They may rant, yell or threaten. Just as often, they subtly point out dire consequences if other people do not do as they say. In most cases, they are simply grownup versions of kids who bullied other kids inschool. In many cases, I suspect, they are the very kids who acted that way and who revert to that behavior pattern when they feel unempowered and incapable. Your best defense is, first, to assess their clout objectively and stay focused on doing your job well. If the bully is your boss (which is often the case), it will take a lot of internal fortitude to keep focused on important work. Look at the worst harm the bully can inflict: Will he fire you? In all likeli hood, he will not. Adopt a calm, determined approach to getting your work done well. A bully is never a good manager. He may well be reacting to upper management pressures by bullying people. His power is not real or durable. By remaining emotionally detached from the threats and yelling (it takes concentration and determination on your part), you will even tually outlast a bully. After all, he has already embarked on a process of selfdestruction in which company leaders will be only too happy to assist.
Emergency Phrases
Whether youre meeting with hostile executives or belligerent reporters, their attacks may leave you hard pressed to reassert control of the situa tion. You can regain control in this kind of hostile fire by using the right words in the right way. Here are several potent phrases and advice on how to use them:
I would like to make a statement. This announcement creates a moment of silence and throws aggressors off stride. You then have a few seconds of uninterrupted time to use as you see fit. Supporting tactic: If youve made a strong statement and it seems to have been heard, call an end to the conversation. If you are meeting reporters, simply say, That will be all, and leave. If you are in a meeting, demand an immediate decision on the issue at hand.
strongest statement, repeating it may be your best defenseespecially if it was ignored the first time. You sometimes have to repeat the same state ment three or four times before it sinks in, especially in a situation where tempers are running high.
Whatdoyouneedtogivemethegoaheadonthis? Many times, asking people what they want, and then offering at once to agree to it, is an instant and powerful way to win consensus. If your opponents say your idea is too expensive, offer to do it for less. If it is too risky, ask where the risk lies and find creative ways to minimize it. If it requires too many hours of his staffs time, offer to take over more of the grunt work within your department. This approach involves some fast thinking on your feet, but it can consistently roll roadblocks out of the way.
Iwantashowofhandsindicatingwhosupportsmeinthis.This statement can gain some startling and quick wins in meetings where it seems to be open season on you and your ideas. When you call a vote, a number of fencesitters will simply not go on record as having voted against you.
Imgoingtodothepreliminaryworkupontheprojectandprove to you that Im right. In a meeting where you cannot gain approval, shortcircuit the process by approving the project yourself. Once work is in progress on any project, it often moves ahead without the need for formal consent.
Whatdoyouthinkaboutthis,Paul(orLynn,orwhoever)? Bringing another person into the limelight is a powerful way to break the aggressors
Black Book of Executive Politics / 45 pace, allow yourself time to think and regroup, and move the conversation away from sticking points. It is vital, however, to make a strategic choice of the person to whom you throw the ball. You can ask the highestranking person what he has to say; if he is likely to agree with your position, or even unwilling to take a side, your detrac tors may back down. By asking an opponent who you sense will hesitate to enter into open conflict with you, you may be able to create a useful schism in the forces that oppose you. Or you can pick a neutral person who you suspect may move toward your position, thereby shifting the tide toward supporting you. Accompany any of these phrases with strong, unflappable body language. Maintain eye contact with the aggressors. Remain calm and sit upright. Jot down notes on what the aggressors are sayingwhile they are saying itto show you are in control of the situation and they are not getting to you.
46 / Business Management Daily Find and attack at least one weak point in your opposition. It might be one member of the opposition who can be swayed to your side, a central flaw in your opponents ideas or plans, or a political ally who can be lured back into your camp with the right approach or proposal. Again, let me stress that allout war is rare and should not be undertaken unless absolutely necessary. If you continually ask your political allies for their support in emergency situations, your power and influence will quickly erode. A key rule to observe: Your most influential political allies are the people you should call on the least oftenin those rare situations when you have to fight fire with fire to survive.
here is no doubt that creative employees are worth their weight in gold. As fonts of new and unique ideas, they are often catalysts for a new way of thinking. Unfortunately, their behavior doesnt always conform to normal business standards. Such people are called mavericks. Mavericks pose a serious problem for managers: How can you best tap and encourage their creative powers while ensuring they do not become disruptive? Here are some tactics to help you get the most from mavericks and mini mize the risks:
Keepexpectationsanddemandshigh. Although creative, mavericks often are unable to set priorities. Theyre just as happy writing a funny spoof of an office memo as they are finishing up the report you need by noon tomorrow. Keep close control to be sure their energy is flowing where you need it. Tell a maverick in clear, structured terms what must be done. And if the job has not been done right, explain exactly why.
Turn back work that does not meet standards. Creative people are often best in a projects imaginative stages and less skilled at finishing in an organized way. If results show brilliant ideas but ultimately fall short of what you need, educate the maverick by giving back the work and explaining what you want. Never assign other people to mop up after a creative person. That wastes staff time and engenders resentment.
Be ready to bend company rules. Any true maverick will come up with ideas that require a certain bending of company rules and customs. I once supervised a creative man who consistently ran slightly over
47
48 / Business Management Daily budget and a highly creative woman who needed to spend a fair amount of time outside the office to complete her research. In both cases, I needed to go to bat with upper management and point out the benefits of bend ing the rules. Makesurethemaverickstaysonapositivetack. A potential pitfall of creative, intelligent people is that they sometimes think they are smarter than company leadersincluding you. If this is the kind of maverick you are dealing with, monitor him closely; step in the moment he begins to influence other people to think cynically about the company or about you. The key to managing a maverick is to keep his creative energy focused on positive activities.
Listenfordoubletalk.I always have talked to my people every day, asking about their current activities by using direct, pointed questions.
Black Book of Executive Politics / 49 When you maintain a close, handson relationship with each staffer, you will be more likely to know when you are being fed lies or double talk. When someones style suddenly changes, or he hedges about information you are asking for, chances are pretty good that he is engaging in some behindthescenes activities that may well culminate in an end run. Buildpersonalrapport.I use many of the tools described in Chapter 1 to make sure there is a personal connection with each individual I super vise. It is harder for people to conceal theiremotions if they are about to take action against someone who has established a sympathetic, personal relationship with them. Suddenly, a subordinates body language and style will change noticeably. She may avoid making eye contact with you, may react nervously when you are around or may suddenly grow fidgety when a particular subject is mentioned.
If you see that happening, let the conversation stray to other topics and come back to the one that prompted the nervous response. If it happens again, you have found a probable area in which a doublecross is about to occur. Zero in on it with some pointed questions. At the very least, you have sounded out something that the staffer is hidingduplicitous intentions or not.
Look for irregular behavior. An impending doublecross is often betrayed in this way. I once had a subordinate who regularly provided me with memos about all his activities. Suddenly, his reports contained less data on a particular sales region under my jurisdiction. When I zeroed in on it, I found that a particular test product was selling extremely well. Fortunately, I uncovered the fact that he was withholding information early enough to foil his plot. My subordinate, it turns out, planned to hide this from me and use this information to get a higher position under a rival executive.
To spot an upcoming doublecross, you do not need to become a cloakanddagger spy. You do need, however, to hone your powers of observation and apply them consistently in your relationships.
Dontopenonacriticalnote. Start instead by embarking on a balanced discussion of things that are going well and things that need improve mentwith a stated desire to improve overall quality and have better results next time. Example: If a subordinate developed a new product that was not as successful as you had anticipated, dont ask only what went wrong. Instead, pull every stage of the process apart and engage in a balanced, positive discussion about the process from A to Z.
Ask openended questions. Ask your subordinate to explain his decisions and actions so that you can understand them and help lend sup port in the future. Some good questions to ask: Did he feel the assignment was a success or a failure? What are his impressions of the most critical problems confronting him or his staff at the moment? How would he envi sion making improvements? What will his next activities be?
Black Book of Executive Politics / 51 Challengeyourownassumptions. Perhaps you think that the subordi nate failed to perform a particular assignment according to your instruc tions. Or perhaps you assume that the results were poor. Rather than open with accusations, start instead by discussing the workers impressions of what happened. Again, you need to ask questions. How did she develop a plan for what was to be done? How was that plan structured? What were the actual results, in black and whiteas opposed to your impressions of the results?
Challenge yourself, and invite the person you are criticizing to engage in a process of selfevaluation. By doing so, you elevate the discussion to a higher plane. Invitethestaffertosetapersonalagendaforchange. As the session draws to a close, bring up the issues of improvement, corrections and change. Invite the worker to bring you a plan for making immediate improvements in the problems you discussed.
ing process consistently every time. Even if you have a friend in mind,
52 / Business Management Daily consider several applicants. Post the job internally and describe the job opening on your companys Web site. That way, youll cast a wide net before narrowing down the finalists. Assess the nature of your friendship. Look at areas in which you communicate well, but also consider areas of friction. Its reasonable to expect your professional relationship to mirror these tendencies. Prevent ing problems before you hire someone can avoid both professional and personal friction.
Considerthebenefitsanddetrimentsofhavingafriendonthejob. Knowing that you can count on someone is a tremendous plus. But it can also cause tension with other staff members, who may resent your close personal relationship.
Weigh the political implications. Like it or not, youll be operating as a team, at least in the public view. Consider the ramifications for the political relationships youve already established. Is hiring your friend worth the potential damage? Buildinanescapechute. Establish a mechanism for regularly sharing views about how the liaison is going, and agree that you will terminate the business relationship if it is not working out. If possible, bring your friend in for a trial period and then cement the relationship if it is work ing out well.
Black Book of Executive Politics / 53 Here are some factors that might not have occurred to you:
Therightsuccessorwillhandlemostofyourjobwhileyouarestill onboard.If your candidate is highly capable and eager to advance, you can delegate a lotof your work to him. Then you can begin to devote your time to other important pursuits, such as carefully planning for your next promotion, engaging in some longrange departmental planning or simply managing your other staffers with more care. You can nearly perform two jobs at the same timeand look like a topnotch manager in the process.
Thepresenceofastrongcandidatereflectswellonyou. The current business climate rewards executives who can delegate authority and develop talent. Your ability to select and groom your successor marks you as someone who is worthy of advancement into the upper ranks of the organizationsomeone who is planning for the future instead of just striving to protect the status quo.
Astrongsuccessorcontinuestobuildyourimage. The capable work of a strong successor goes on polishing your image long after you have moved upward in the company or taken a new job elsewhere. If things fall apart after you leave, it implies that you left unsolved problems.
56 / Business Management Daily Bottom line: Determine what position your company is going to need to fill in six months or a yearand then hire yourself for the job before it is actually created. Years ago, I saw a young woman use this strategy to remarkable effect. Hired as a sales rep for a computer and office equipment company, Jane foresaw that more and more business users would be linking their comput ers together into localarea networks. She visited suppliers and learned all she could about LANs. When the market opened up, Jane was already on top of the situation. She was assertive enough to nail down the position of supervising the firms network sales and customer support services, and she increased her salary by 20 percent. Like Jane, youll have to be politically savvy to ensure that youre the person who will take the job youve created. But with thought and planning, the possibilities for advancement are tremendous. Consider exploring these: Newmarketingstrategies.Is there some new marketing approach or tool that is well suited to your products or company goals? If so, become the inhouse expert and sell it to top management.
Newmarkets. Its not always easy to spearhead a companys expansion
into a new market, particularly if youre in lower management. But if you think some new product or a variation of one already in production could open up new profits, educate yourself about the possibilities. Then make a convincing pitch to oversee the expansion. Newgeographicalareas.If you know a lot about an area of the coun tryor even a foreign countrywhere your firm has not yet made inroads, you have a golden opportunity. Even better: If you have an insiders knowledge of a foreign country or fluency in a foreign language, you have a leg up.
Newjointventures.Consider your companys products or services, and the possible benefits of launching a joint venture or cobranding with another business.
Black Book of Executive Politics / 57 Negotiating a raise also involves knowing your market value. Political novices think that by comparing themselves favorably to their peers, they can win the Im worth more than Mark in the next cubicle argument. But thats a deadend strategy. A wiser approach: Assess your worth on the open market by analyzing salary surveys of your industrymany are available onlineand contacting trade groups or professional associations for the latest employment trends and salary data. Also, remember theres more to compensation than money. Benefits play a bigger role than ever. And you may want to discuss how you can make a greater contribution by expanding your responsibilities, working from home, taking a sabbatical or participating in crosstraining. As a CEO, I can tell you its much easier to negotiate a compensation package with a manager who talks in bigpicture terms about how he can make my life easier or address my companys needs than with someone who harps on demanding another $10,000 or $20,000 a year.
58 / Business Management Daily When you have a truly wonderful idea, enhance your proprietary control over it through documentation. Present it in a memo or email, with cop ies to all concerned. If someone has appropriated an idea you havent documented, try first to get back into the process by writing a memo: Here are some further thoughts on the marketing plan I proposed . . . If that fails, you may be justified in speaking to a member of upper management with whom you have firm political ties. But it is often better to reassert your clout by win ning some key project or promotion.
Black Book of Executive Politics / 59 Theideathatseemsmostvaluabletoyouthe very solution to some major business problemmay be of little significance to the person who thought it up. In some cases, he may not even remember it.
60 / Business Management Daily Gettinghamstrung. When some people get a mentor, they worry so much that their actions will reflect badly on their ally that they fail to act at all. As a result, they become ineffectual clones who wait for guidance. Avoid this by finding a mentor who encourages independent efforts and by continuing to act autonomously on most of your projects.
Gettingreinedin.You have an idea that you think is terrific and propose it at a meeting. To your surprise, your mentor is furious because he wasnt consulted or thinks its a bad idea. Recognize that when you agree to a mentoring relationship, you are also agreeing to a certain amount of control.
Blurringroles.Always remember that your mentor is your superior. In almost all cases, it is unwise to take the lead in introducing personal elementsinto your relationship. In matters of joke telling and social inter action, always let your mentor establish initial guidelines. For example, never be the first to suggest that the two of you have lunch. Causingburnout.Dont overtax the relationship by asking for advice too often or stopping by when you have nothing, or only something minor, to discuss. A close relationship can eventually degrade if you become a mental burden to the person who has taken you on. Be willing to distance yourself when necessary.
Format information her way. As a subordinate, one of your major duties is to supply your boss with facts. Try to meet your bosss prefer ences. If she prefers a daily morning chat to a stack of impersonal emails or memos, act accordingly.
Understandhispersonalityandyourown.For the relationship to work effectively, you may have to put a damper on your own style. For
Black Book of Executive Politics / 61 example, if youre fun loving and your boss is always serious, superim posing your lively style on the relationship can be disastrous. Learnwhentomakeproposalsandwhentokeepquiet. Especially in the early stages of a relationship, offer only your best and most fully developed ideas. Spattering your boss with a buckshot hail of suggestions in the hopes that some will hit the mark can brand you as someone who is right only 2 percent of the time.
Anticipatepressures. Pay attention to how and when your boss feels pressure most acutely. Is it when he is facing a meeting with a particular highranking exec? When he prepares quarterly reports? Offer your sup port in these areas first.
Standbyyourboss.Never gossip about his shortcomings; its far too dangerous a game. If your boss is on the outs with upper management, you will have to appraise his situation and act accordingly. In all but the most extreme cases, defending your boss is your own best defense.
Take an objective look at terminology and decide which words are useful. Is the new term really the clearest, simplest way to express a concept? If not, dont use it. Jargonthatexcludespeople. Using a new word or acronym that half the people in the room have never heard may make you feel stylish, but chances are youll be seen only as impolite.
Crazephrases.Will people still be using the expression in six months? Remember when every executive seemed to fret about devising value added services to delight customers? Or how sticking an e or virtual in front of whatever business strategy you were talking about gave it cachet (such as ecommerce or virtual leadership)?
that you use it all the time. People will stop listening.
most appears to be the leader of a group. In fact, the personwho makes short statements and then listens attentively will be perceived as the groups leader. The key is making sure that speakers are giving you most of their eye contact, not ignoring you and focusing on others. Dontstandattheback.You neednt be the person in the lead if the group is walking together. You can be in the front, in the middle or even on the side. The one place you should not be is at the back. People who are facing the backs of all other group members are never perceived as being in charge because they are clearly not communicating with the others.
Adopt receptive, comfortable body language. It is not necessary to walk with an exaggerated, stiff posture to look like a leaderunless that
Black Book of Executive Politics / 63 is your habitual style. Comfort, not a militaristic posture, conveys a sense of authority. Face each person directly as you converseeven if he is sit ting to your side. If you are walking with a group of colleagues, placing a hand on the shoulder of someone of the same sex as you listen implies that you are the person in authority.
Maintainaslightsmile. To look like a leader, you need to look interest ing, interested, intelligent and alive. As you listen to other people, smile slightly and show that you are listening and taking in what is being said.
Includeitemsyouunderstand. If you put up a painting or a framed quote you like and know something about, youll create a positive impres sion when you explain it to those who inquire. If you put up something youre supposed to like but really dont, youll seem pretentious.
Remind people of your successes. If your biggest client sent you a glowing letter of appreciation, frame it and display it prominently in your office. Likewise, if you received a certificate for completing a course offered by an industry association, hang it on the wall. But dont go over board. You want to show competence, not a big ego.
Moving Up or Moving On
hen it comes right down to it, any executive with anything on the ball has two choices: moving up or moving on. The tactics Ive outlined in this book will go a long way toward helping you move up. But sometimes moving up necessitates moving on, so Ive included some tips to help you position yourself for success in your next undertaking whether its a new job or retirement.
Have I established a strong individual presence and profile? Are my spoken and written communication skills as strong as I can make them? Have I kept abreast of new technologies affecting my business and learned how to apply them? Have I consistently supported colleagues, taken an interest in their projects and helped them achieve results? Have I demonstrated a strong ability to confront and solve problems, or have I just skirted them? Have I demonstrated an ability to perform under pressure? 65
Have I consistently completed managements priority assignments before my own? Have I completed projects that demonstrated my specific strengths and abilities? Have I defined my longterm objectives, and do I understand the role my current activities play in attaining them? Have I supported my superiors by cheerfully taking on work in dif ficult periods and offering good advice? Have I achieved a high degree of political clout that reinforces the strengths outlined above and seals the promotion?
Black Book of Executive Politics / 67 downsized, although that word wasnt used at the time. I learned that you need to grab opportunities when they come along and not get com placent just because youre getting a decent paycheck every two weeks. I also learned that those who possess transferable skills and leave no stones unturned in their search for new opportunities can maintain their career momentum. Take these steps to manage the risk of getting downsized out of a job:
Befriend quitters. When people leave your organization, stay in touch. Even if you werent good friends before, make up for lost time now. Invite yourself over to see their new office. Try to finagle a tour of their facility, and meet some executives who might someday want you on board. Try to trade business cards with everyone you meet. Cultivate consultants. Before many CEOs decide to downsize, they throw big bucks at consultants who come in, inspect the place and reas sure them that, yes, its time to downsize. When consultants spend the day observing your operation, make nice. Forge a relationship by asking intelligent questions about what they do and offering ways to help. Find out how they got the assignment with your firm and who their other clients are. Your goal is to make enough of a positive impression so that you can stay in touch. Consultants are great resources to call upon when youre looking for job leads. Track your companys financials. Spot downward trends early. If you see sales slipping or orders drying upand you sense things will only get worsenetwork like mad. Stop skipping those Toastmasters meet ings. Attend conferences hosted by your professional association. Be on the prowl every day. If despite your best efforts youre laid off, dont pout, lash out or crumble into a fetal ball. Think future, future, future. First, secure the best severance package possible so that you can start jobhunting ASAP while getting as much going away money as your employer can possibly spare. That financial cushion will give you the kind of confidence and peace of mind that will impress prospective employers.
68 / Business Management Daily Then, after your last day at work, move on. Dont keep scheduling lunches with old colleagues or finding other reasons to return to the scene of the crime. Hanging around your workplace after youve been downsized is kind of pathetic. Get the hell out of there at your earliest opportunity. Scan the next 10 days of your appointment book and say to yourself, I want to fill every block of my schedule. Finally, dont make any rash moves soon after losing your job. Dont write a scathing letter to your former boss. Dont talk to a reporter about how outrageous your former employer treated you. Dont threaten to file a lawsuit. Keep cool, think ahead and see how you feel in a week. Ive watched too many otherwise decent folks burn bridgespermanentlyby reacting impulsively in the days after a layoff.
Black Book of Executive Politics / 69 Here are some factors to consider as you take that blank piece of paper and begin to draft a description of what your next job ought to be:
In which industry? Should you consider a job in the same industry? In light of the valuable knowledge you gained in your last job, should you make a change? What kind of company would be best for you? How about your strengths, skills and abilities? Were they fully used in your last job? What other circumstances would you like to change? Perhaps in your former job you were uncomfortable with the leaders style of doing busi ness. Perhaps you were in a small, familyrun concern where you stood little chance of making it to a leadership position. You can never change such factors while you are in a job, but you can change them instantly when you switch jobs. Make a longrange career plan and fit your next job into it. Where would you like your career to take you? Do you want to head your own small company? Do you want to become the CEO of a corporation or one of its topranked officers? Is there a particular industry that you love and in which you want to make your mark? Make your next job fit into a plan; dont accept a job offer that you know is not the right one. Id venture to say that accepting the wrong job is far more harmful than losing the wrong job. The former spells lost time and wasted effort. The latter can spell nothing but opportunity and new challenge.
70 / Business Management Daily How much more will my benefits grow if I wait? Ask for help from your accountant or financial planner to determine this. Pay special atten tion to the amount you have vested in your 401(k) and your pension and how your taxes, Social Security (if applicable) and other incomeproviding vehicles will be affected if you bail out early. Also, consider the impact of early retirement on your estate.
The bottom line: Over the next 10 years, exactly how much of a difference in income will you experience if you get out now? Over the next 20 years? Note: If your political alliances are strong, you can have your cake and eat it too by arranging to work on a reduced schedule while increasing pension vesting and Social Security benefits.
Do I want to start a new business? If youre anxious to become a con sultant or start a new business, the chance to do it with a steady income behind you offers a considerable advantage over your competition.
Have I completed my work? If youve reached your career goals and are in danger of becoming a lame duck, sitting pat wont do you or your reputation any good. However, if your longterm aims are about to be realized, staying at the helm and seeing them through may solidify your reputation and pave the way for future challenges.
What will I do? A common mistake is painting a hazy, unfocused pic ture of how good it will be to have lots of leisure time after retiring. Dont forget that spending more time at home (if thats your plan) will be a major adjustment for you and your family. Try to build a welldefined picture of what you would like to do. Then plan on how to do itwhether you will need to move, pursue a second career and so on.
BBEP1011