Declaration of Menahem Golan in Recht v. Metro Goldwyn Mayer determining that Cannon Films never acquired rights to exploit in new media the copyrighted music in the film "The apple", and therefore MGM as successor in interest never acquired rights to release the film in new media, such as DVD or digitized formats.
Declaration of Menahem Golan in Recht v. Metro Goldwyn Mayer determining that Cannon Films never acquired rights to exploit in new media the copyrighted music in the film "The apple", and therefore MGM as successor in interest never acquired rights to release the film in new media, such as DVD or digitized formats.
Declaration of Menahem Golan in Recht v. Metro Goldwyn Mayer determining that Cannon Films never acquired rights to exploit in new media the copyrighted music in the film "The apple", and therefore MGM as successor in interest never acquired rights to release the film in new media, such as DVD or digitized formats.
02-DEC.2008 10:28 #7699 P.col /o0z
DCLARATION OF MENAHEM GOLAN
I Menahem Go!
1, The facts
called as a witness, I c
2. Tam 80 ye
declare as follows:
d within are based on my first hand knowledge, and, if
1d and would testify competently thereto under oath.
old and I reside in Tel Aviy, Israel. My occupation is:
director and producer. { also wrote many screenplays. | produced more than 200
movies all over the wo1
3. Inthe late
Films, Inc. (ak/a "Ci
with Mr. Yoram Globi
Id and directed approximately 50 movies.
0's through the carly 90s, I was one of the principals of Cannon
lon Group"), a California-based production corporation together
4. Cannon's olicy was to negotiate future technologies and future medias
grants from authors, suth as composers and lyricists, and get it in writing, signed by
the author. However, there Were instances where this was not possible or just did not
happen, For example, France and other countries statutorily regulate the ability to
assign future media rights. In those cases, it was Cannon's policy that if the author did
not sign a specific futufe technologies clause including unknown and unforeseen
technologies or medias, Cannon did not acquire such rights. When a motion picture
was distributed in a spqcific media such as video (VHS), Cannon treated the author's
agreement to release tHe motion picture on a specific media, such as video, as simply
an agreement to distribjate the motion picture containing the author's contributions on
that media only, i.e. video alone.
5. "The Ap|
filmed in Berlin and
6. met the
le" was a motion picture produced in 1979 in Germany. It was
publicly exhibited in the Cannes Film Festival in France.
mposer, Coby Recht, in Isracl. He showed me original work
on a musical in Hebrew containing Hebrew lyrics and music for such songs. I wanted
to transform it into a njovie in English.
rent was signed on April 9, 1979 between Recht and "Golan-
"in Israel. It was drafted by my attorney in Tel Aviv. Recht
jh
7. Anagrest
Globus Productions Lt02.DEC.2008 10:23 #7697 P.002 /004
assigned the rights to the already existing Hebrew musical. He agreed to compose
songs for the new movie. His spouse at the time agreed to write the lyrics. I do not
know if she signed the|agreement. They did not assign, sell or transfer rights to the
new compositions and| English lyrics.
8. As¥ discifssed with Recht, the agreement was that the movie be exploited
theatrically, on stage apd on records (vinyl). Video rights were not spelled out in the
agreement, but Recht was either silent about it, or agreed to it orally, which in any
event was limited to vdeo only and not to any form of home viewing.
ey "Byprodycts” of the movie was understood to be related merchandise
items such as posters, memorabilia and souvenir items based on the plot or characters
(which were conceived! by Recht).
10. The i did not address all the bundle of rights a producer usually
takes from the author, {such as rights to distribute, publicly perform or make
derivatives, Those wie to be negotiated in a comprehensive later agreement, which
was never negotiated r signed.
11. There we no “future technologies clause” in the agreement with Recht.
Also, there was no." medias clause". The agreement as written was limited to
production of movies n film, production of plays (stage) and records (vinyl), "to any
extent" (in Hebrew "njida"), That means that the exploitation in the three methods
stipulated was not lim}ted territorially, i.e. in any Country, not limited by time, i.e.
anytime, and not limitpd by scope.
12, Recht ingisted on a contract that reserved copyrights to himself and his
former wife. Recht agreed to split publishing royalties 30%-50% and have it collected
by SACEM, the Frendn equivalent of ASCAP. The agreement therefore incorporated
French law to the extdat it governed SACEM's bylaws and rules.
13. Recht was to be paid for his works in four installments, but he only
received the first two.| We never entered into a follow up agreement with Recht.
sed him that Cannon will protect his copyrights to his music
2 Ay02.DEC.2008 10:23
#7697 P.003 /008
worldwide, so that he fan rely on Cannon to take the steps to protect his copyrights.
15. do not remember if or how rights were transferred from Golan- Globus
Productions, Ltd to i Films. Inc.
16. Cannon
17. Before
arrived in Los Angele
suggested that we hir
local picture and Mr,
pictures. The definiti
Recht Yotvat on Ame}
Recht on the music.
nature of grammar s|
18. Clinton
the Rechts, they didn}
19. Clinton
lyrics. It was the first
certificate, he wrote
may not be accurate,
officials how to comy
-ver accounted to Recht on the proceeds from the movie.
movie was produced in 1979, Recht and his former wife
to continue work on the new compositions and lyries. T
an assistant to save time. An advertisement was placed in a
eorge Clinton showed up with no previous experionce in motion
in of his work was simply to assist. Clinton worked with Iris
eanizing the English of the Iytics. He did not work with Coby
is contributions were not creative or original. It was more in the
Iling, English language tutor, and-a "go-getter".
ed for credits, and because of the friendship developed with
mind to help build up his resume in the industry.
led a certificate with the Copyrights Office for the music and
ime he did this for a cannon movie. What he designated in the
his own without consulting anyone. The information therein
nd was not checked by Cannon. He did not ask me or other
lete the certificate.
20. Inthe abkence of a written agreement signed by the author containing a
signed assignment af future technologies clause drafted in language commonly used in
Hollywood, Cannon
future technologies o
to exploitation of a
exploit in video only
jever acquired rights to exploit the author's music or lyrics in
future medias. I also conclude that the author's oral agreement
vie on video was understood by Cannon as an agreement to
id not in other categories, such as DVD, laser technology,
intemet, ringtones anfl other unknown and unforeseen technologies.
21. Thereby
lirrevocably assign whatever rights and copyrights in the literary
rights to the screenplay of the Apple to Coby Recht, now and forever, past and present,
if,
aA