Professional Documents
Culture Documents
JetBlue Report
JetBlue Report
JetBlue Airways
Team A8: Doug Bennett, Tess Gruenstein, Ramya Raman, Tyler Sachse, Aaron Walsh
On my honor, I have neither given nor received unauthorized aid in completing this academic work.
Contents
Introduction .................................................................................................................................................. 1 JetBlue: The Low Cost, High Expectation Airline ...................................................................................... 1 Industry Overview ......................................................................................................................................... 1 Legacy vs. Discount Airlines ...................................................................................................................... 1 Competitive Set .................................................................................................................................... 2 Bankruptcies and Consolidations .............................................................................................................. 2 Airplanes ................................................................................................................................................... 3 Fuel............................................................................................................................................................ 3 Price-Sensitive Customers......................................................................................................................... 3 JetBlue Analysis ............................................................................................................................................. 4 Cost Structure............................................................................................................................................ 4 Fuel........................................................................................................................................................ 4 Excluding Fuel ....................................................................................................................................... 4 Leverage and Growth................................................................................................................................ 6 Dividends................................................................................................................................................... 7 Valuation ................................................................................................................................................... 7 Marketing and Brand Position .................................................................................................................. 8 Target Market ....................................................................................................................................... 8 Brand Identity ....................................................................................................................................... 8 Marketing Program .............................................................................................................................. 8 Accounting ................................................................................................................................................ 9 Fleet ...................................................................................................................................................... 9 Preferred Stock Authorized in 2009................................................................................................... 10 Recommendations ...................................................................................................................................... 11 Financing ................................................................................................................................................. 11 Line of Credit and Term-Loan Option Facility.................................................................................... 11 Marketing ................................................................................................................................................ 11 Leverage Social Media to Contain Costs ............................................................................................ 11 Continue to Stress Differentiation ..................................................................................................... 11 Leverage Integrated Customer Service System ................................................................................. 12
Target Business Travelers................................................................................................................... 12 Appendix A: Cost Structure ....................................................................................................................... A-1 Appendix B: Profitability Measures and Market Share..............................................................................B-1 Appendix C: Valuation Assumptions and Exhibits ..................................................................................... C-1 Appendix D: Marketing Position and Program ......................................................................................... D-1 Appendix E: Marketing Mix Comparison ................................................................................................... E-1 Appendix F: Accounting Practices of Competitive Set ............................................................................... F-1 Appendix G: JetBlue Airways Corporation Situation Analysis................................................................... G-1 Appendix H: JetBlue SWOT Analysis ......................................................................................................... H-1
Introduction
JetBlue: The Low Cost, High Expectation Airline
Founded by discount airline veteran David Neeleman in 2000, JetBlue Airways (JetBlue) has quickly become one of the largest discount airlines in the United States. Starting primarily by serving the East coast, the airline has since expanded throughout the country and entered the international market. Growth both financial and geographicalhas continued despite a challenging economy in recent years. The reasons for this early success are numerous: JetBlue entered the market with one of the largest levels of liquidity of any start-up airline; it met the needs of customers whose primary concerns are price and route; and it successfully defined its brand and differentiated itself from competitors by offering an above average customer experience and amenities for a discounted price. Looking ahead, JetBlues competitive advantages are increasingly at risk. The company must find a way to deal with a much heavier debt load and industry reorganization while competing with leaner and stronger legacy airlines.
Industry Overview
JetBlue operates under the constraints of the airline industry and its unique dynamics: intense federal regulation, customers driven mainly by price and route with low brand loyalty, heavy capital costs, and monopolistic conditions among its suppliers. These challenges are examined below.
not viable to legacy airlines. The most successful discount airlines were primarily regional until Southwest and JetBlue became national players, now capturing 16 percent of total market share (see Appendix B, Figure 10 for details). Competitive Set For purposes of this analysis, JetBlues competitive set has been defined using a mix of discount airlines and legacy airlines of a similar size to JetBlue. Southwest and AirTran are the dominant discount airlines in the national market1. US Airways and Alaska Airlines both have legacy issues and have similar market cap and network sizes which make them better comparables than the larger legacy carriers.
1 2
AirTran is used for historical comparison only as it is in the process of consolidating with Southwest Airlines. Delta used bankruptcy to reconfigure by retiring the oldest part of its fleet and renegotiating many union contracts and pension obligations. 3 Source: Delta, Northwest See Bankruptcy as Key to Revival (Wall Street Journal), How Delta climbed out of bankruptcy (Bloomberg)
Team A8
Airplanes
Boeing and Airbus, as the worlds two dominant airplane suppliers, have the ability to largely control pricing and force airlines into long-term contracts. The long lead time required to manufacture airplanes means airlines must determine their capital needs far in advance, which requires taking on long-term liabilities.
Fuel
Fuel has been the largest expense on most airlines Income Statements for the last five years (averaging roughly a third of operating expenses among JetBlues competitive set). Given recent volatility in the energy market, fuel costs have had a major impact on airlines financial performance. In 2008, the price of crude oil averaged $99.50 per barrel (peaking at $147.00), a 37.7% increase over the previous year.4 This resulted in fuel expenses as a percentage of passenger sales and operating expenses to rise by 69 and 23 percent respectively. As profits fell across the domestic airline industry, the industrys market value shrunk by 13.7 percent for the year and several regional airlines filed Chapter 11.
Price-Sensitive Customers
A recent study found that there was no correlation between satisfaction and price paid for a flight, which causes passengers to seek out the most inexpensive ticket with a favorable route (a bleak picture for an airline).5 Further, online search engines provide consumers a mechanism for immediate comparison shopping between all airlines (legacy and discount). The result is increased promotions and price wars between carriers except in underserved markets where airlines can still charger relatively higher fares.
4 5
Source: IBIS Domestic Airlines Source: JetBlue, Southwest beat big carriers for service, quality (USA Today)
Team A8
JetBlue Analysis
Cost Structure
Fuel On average, since 2005, jet fuel purchases have comprised 34 percent of JetBlue's operating costs (please see Appendix A, Figure 1 for a graph of JetBlue's historical fuel costs). Fuel expenses for JetBlue were impacted significantly by the spike in energy prices from 2003 to mid-2008; and furthermore, it incurred significant losses on hedges when prices began to drop sharply in Q3 2008. JetBlue hedges6 on a discretionary basis when it is possible to cap the liquidity and profitability risks of sharply rising prices. Currently less than a fifth of its projected quarterly fuel usage is hedged past mid2011 (see Appendix A, Figure 2 for details), exposing the company to a spike in prices. Conversely, such hedges expose JetBlue and other airlines to potential short-term liquidity issues when oil and fuel prices drop sharply. We reasonably assume that no airline has a particular advantage, thus fuel prices impact them all similarly. Excluding Fuel Apart from fuel, changes in airline operating expenses are driven primarily by changes in capacity (measured by "available seat miles" or "ASMs"). Airline management teams and industry observers typically calculate operating costs per available seat mile (CASM)7 in order to the gauge the efficiency with which a given airline serves its customers. JetBlues current cost structure is a source of competitive advantage (see Appendix A, Figure 3), as it allows the company to offer lower fares than many of its competitors. However, JetBlue's cost advantage relative to peers has deteriorated since 2005, especially relative to low-cost peer AirTran,
6
Hedging options include a variety of crude oil call options, heating oil collar contracts, and jet fuel swap agreements. 7 Cost per available seat mile (CASM) calculated by dividing each expense line item by the total number of available seat miles in a given period
Team A8
which recently agreed to be acquired by Southwest. The combined Southwest will likely maintain a close operating cost profile to that of JetBlue, lessening JetBlue's ability to compete on fare price alone. To better analyze the compression of operating cost spread between JetBlue and competitors, the following table describes the four drivers of historic advantage identified by company management. High Aircraft Utilization JetBlue has historically spread fixed costs over a greater number of flights and ASMs thanks to efficient scheduling and operation of aircraft. US Airways and Southwest do not report aircraft utilization; but JetBlue's competitive advantage in this area has shrunk relative to AirTran in the past five years (see Appendix A, Figure 4). Some factors behind declining utilization are out of the company's control (weather, security, congestion, and maintenance delays), but others are controllable. As JetBlue's aircraft are spending less time in the air each day, they also have more empty seats on recent flights (see Appendix A, Figure 5 for more details on JetBlue's shrinking passenger load factor). Finally, the proportion of non-revenue passengers is likely to grow due to recent changes to the TrueBlue loyalty program that make it easier for members to earn, keep, and redeem points for free flights. Low Distribution Costs JetBlue sells only electronic tickets, reducing paper, postage, and back-office processing expenses. In addition, it sells tickets primarily through its website, the lowest-cost distribution channel available. See Appendix A, Figure 6 for JetBlue's sales and marketing expense per ASM relative to its peers over the last few years. The cost spread versus competitors is converging as 1) more airlines move away from paper tickets, and 2) JetBlue's distribution costs rise as it utilizes global distribution systems (GDSs)8 in an effort to pursue more business customers.
JetBlue participates in three major GDSs (Sabre, Travelport and Amadeus) and four major online travel agents (Expedia, Travelocity, Orbitz, and Priceline). The company notes that the higher average fares realized through the GDS channel typically offset the increased distribution costs.
Team A8
Productive Workforce
Flexible and productive work rules, effective use of part-time employees, and the use of technology to automate tasks are cited by management as generators of employee efficiency. JetBlue has generated cost advantages through the use of entirely non-union labor (see Appendix A, Figure 7). However, FAA-licensed employees have secured significant concessions including higher compensation and guaranteed salary/benefits in the event of reduced customer demand, suggesting they are in a strong position to negotiate. Labor costs per ASM have risen 7 percent annually since 2005 and 15 percent in the last 9 months.
JetBlue's fleet consists of two types of planes (Airbus A320 and Embraer 190). This strategy reduces maintenance expenses by simplifying processes, scheduling, and training, and minimizing spare part inventories. However, management has indicated costs will rise as the company's relatively young fleet of planes continues to age (see Appendix A, Figure 8).
Profitability
Despite generating the lowest revenue per ASM among its competitors at 10.83 cents, JetBlue maintains the second highest operating margin (9.7 percent) due to its low-cost operating structure (see Appendix B, Figure 9 for a comparison of profitability measures among competitors). Given the recent deterioration in this cost advantage, JetBlues recent push into the business traveler segment to capture higher revenue customers appears to be a sensible strategy for maintaining profitability.
Team A8
debt as a percentage of sales among its competitive set. For the year ending 12/31/09, its debt-to-sales ratio was slightly over 100 percent while competitors averaged 48 percent. JetBlues primary use of debt has been for the acquisition of aircraft. It increased its fleet size by 65 percent (to 155 planes) between 2005 and 2010. Incrementally, 44 percent (or $22 million) of each plane acquisition is financed by debt. JetBlue expects to grow its fleet another 60 percent (to 248 planes) by 2016. The company will be unable to finance this growth through free cash flow and will need to raise cash through issuance of debt or equity. Using historical averages, they will need to raise $225 million through equity and $2.1 billion through debt. This would raise their overall debt levels to $5.128 billion or 96 percent of projected sales and 68 percent of total value.
Dividends
JetBlue has historically paid no dividends. Given future financing needs we do not expect them to do so in the next five to ten years.
Valuation
Factoring in JetBlues aggressive growth strategy and calculating a weighted average cost of capital of 9.4 percent, a discounted cash flow analysis demonstrates that JetBlues stock price ($6.69 close on 12/09/10) is overvalued by approximately 18 percent. Please see Appendix C for a complete list of assumptions made in our valuation analysis. Successful execution of their strategy over the next six years will increase revenues and earnings before interest and taxes by 45 percent and 115 percent respectively. This results in a current enterprise value of $6.9 billion and equity value of $1.6 billion. During this period, JetBlue will generate $2.4 billion in free cash flow, excluding aircraft capital expenditures which will require the additional $2.3 billion in outside funding we mentioned above.
Team A8
Source: JetBlue 2009 10K SEC Filing Brand Keys Customer Loyalty Engagement Index looks at category drivers that engage customers, engender loyalty and drive real profits.
10
Team A8
Website
Visitors to www.jetblue.com can browse an Experience JetBlue section that features videos of consumers talking about the various benefits of flying JetBlue (e.g., space, entertainment, etc.).
"You Above All" replaced "Happy Jetting" as the company's tagline in Q4 2010 as part of a new advertising campaign. The campaign features humorous ads on YouTube that directly attack the practices of competing airlines (e.g., fees for baggage) and tells viewers "if you wouldnt take it on the ground, dont take it in the air.
Promotions
Recent "All You Can Jet" promotions allowed consumers to buy a monthly pass for unlimited travel to JetBlue destinations in the U.S. and the Caribbean. JetBlue believes half of the buyers had not flown them before.
Brandspace
The flagship terminal at JFK International airport serves as a "brandspace" for JetBlue, much like a brand-specific retail store (e.g., NikeTown).
TrueBlue
This loyalty program was redesigned in 2009 to address customers' desire for the elimination of blackout dates, an extended lifespan for points, and a shift to points for miles flown rather than money spent.
Please see Appendix D for samples of JetBlue's marketing efforts. Please see Appendix E for a marketing mix comparison with JetBlues competitive set.
Accounting
JetBlue uses standard industry practices for accounting and utilizes sound methods (see Appendix F for full comparison with competitive set). JetBlue is publicly traded and has no subsidiary groups. Noteworthy accounting issues are discussed below. Fleet Deciding how to finance a plane is a key concern for an airlines financial statements. Taking on additional debt to purchase planes may not be feasible due to debt covenant constraints but leases have higher average costs due to overhead charged back through the lease from the leasing company. Further, there are tax benefits that a firm must weigh. JetBlue owns 94 planes and leases 61 (57 in Team A8 Integrated Company Analysis: JetBlue 9
operating, 4 in capital). They have used leasing as a way to fuel their rapid growth without increasing the debt load beyond a manageable level. By contrast, US Airways has been forced to lease the majority of its planes due to its high debt to asset level and inability to take on additional debt (see Appendix F for fleet details for both JetBlue and competitors). Further, JetBlue has firm forward commitments for 110 additional airplanes, accounting for $4.4 billion of total capital over the next eight years. This future liability is not represented on the balance sheet. Air Traffic Liability and Loyalty Rewards JetBlue maintains an Air Traffic Liability account on its balance sheet as a reserve for tickets sold but not yet used (essentially an "unearned revenue" account). As of Q3 2010, this account had a balance of $545 million. This account includes liabilities for the True Blue loyalty program totaling $54 million; the company reserves an amount equal to the estimated cost of outstanding rewards points. The company also sells points for utilization via a JetBlue-branded credit card. As the company does not disclose how many points are outstanding it is not possible to analyze whether or enough there is enough reserve to account for this liability. JetBlue noted that recent changes to the loyalty program will increase point redemption, so any underestimation of this liability could result in an overstatement of retained earnings. Preferred Stock Authorized in 2009 In 2009 the company authorized the issuance of 25 million shares of preferred stock at $0.01 par value. None of those shares have yet been issued; we assume they are on reserve should a cash infusion be necessary.
Team A8
10
Recommendations
Financing
Line of Credit and Term-Loan Option Facility We recommend JetBlue finance capital expenditures related to aircraft via one large debt facility with a follow-on equity offering as needed. This would offer JetBlue the lowest possible cost of capital (see Appendix C for calculations related to WACC), eliminate the need raise debt or issue equity annually, and maximize managements flexibility to adapt its growth strategy. Optimally, JetBlue should work with lenders to establish a $2.1 billion, 5-Year Aircraft Acquisition Line of Credit and Term-Loan Option Facility. This would allow JetBlue to acquire aircraft as needed and roll the principal balance into a 30-year term facility at expiration. Interest rates would continue to reset after a specified period and remain fixed during the term portion. Interest rates could be lowered by choosing a term that renews more frequently, but it would be subject to more volatility in interest rate movements. The company could also lock in a forward fixed rate on the term-out portion to minimize future interest rate risk. Overall, this strategy will ensure JetBlue has the capital to realize growth initiatives and allow management to remain focused on creating value for shareholders.
Marketing
Leverage Social Media to Contain Costs JetBlue has built a solid following on Facebook and Twitter, and used YouTube to host videos for its latest campaign. Continuing to rely on these media greatly reduces the costs associated with marketing. Continue to Stress Differentiation JetBlues new You Above All campaign is built upon stressing the idea that the flying experience is significantly better with JetBlue than with other airlines. Continuing this focus is the best way to ensure Team A8 Integrated Company Analysis: JetBlue 11
customer know what JetBlue stands for, especially as the companys ability to continually provide a significantly lower price comes into question. Leverage Integrated Customer Service System JetBlues new customer service system11 provides a great way for the company to profile its customer base, investigate customer actions, and understand key loyalty drivers. Using this tool to build a targeted marketing program that tailors messages to customers will enable JetBlue to increase effectiveness. Target Business Travelers JetBlue is in a unique position to target business travelers during tough economic times. As a discount provider who also focuses on customer service, they can appeal to cost-sensitive business people that need to cut travel costs but dont want to sacrifice comfort, convenience, and modernity. JetBlue should investigate opportunities to increase corporate travel partnerships.
11
SEC Filings: JetBlue implemented a new customer service system, which includes a reservations system, revenue management system, revenue accounting system, and customer loyalty management system.
Team A8
12
Team A8
A-1
Note: Load factor represents the percentage of aircraft seating capacity that is actually utilized (revenue passenger miles divided by available seat miles). Revenue passenger miles represents the number of miles flown by revenue passengers.
Team A8
A-2
Notes Advertising expenses included in calculation as each airline reports sales and marketing expenses in different groupings. Southwest excluded as it does not break out sales and marketing expenses in the income statement.
Team A8
A-3
Team A8
A-4
Excl udes regi ona l opera tions of US Ai rwa ys Expres s a nd Al a s ka Ai r's Hori zon Ai r Incl udes regi ona l opera tions of US Ai rwa ys Expres s a nd Al a s ka Ai r's Hori zon Ai r
Team A8
B-1
12
Team A8
B-2
Other Sales
Since 2005, other sales have increased at a declining rate as a percent of passenger sales. Other revenue has increased from fees JetBlue charges customers for baggage and other services. We expect this trend to flatten and then decline in future years as competition among airlines puts pressure on fees airlines can charge.
Expenses
Fuel and related taxes is the largest single expense for JetBlue; over the last twelve months fuel has averaged 32 percent of passenger sales. We expect annual growth in fuel related costs to revert to its historical average of 3 percent13. Maintenance expenses as a percentage of passenger revenues have increased year-over-year for the past four years, but at a declining rate. We anticipate this trend to continue and eventually flatten out as JetBlues fleet ages. Since 2005, expenses from employee compensation, landing fees, depreciation, aircraft rent, sales and marketing, and other expenses have been relatively consistent as a percentage of sales. We forecast these expenses using a 5-year average as a percentage of passenger sales. We analyzed these expenses
13
Source: IBIS World Gasoline & Petroleum Wholesaling in the US (November 2010)
Team A8
C-1
in respect to passenger revenues rather than total revenues because these expenses are directly related to passenger revenues and not other revenues.
Enterprise Value
Cash flow projections for 2011-2016 were discounted by JetBlues weighted average cost of capital. Terminal value was discounted using JetBlues weighted average cost of capital and perpetual growth rate14. JetBlues weighted average cost of capital is 9.4%, which represents a weighted average of their cost of debt and equity. JetBlues cost of debt is the product of their most recent placement of debt in June 2009 at 6.75 percent and their tax shield15. The components of JetBlues cost of equity are the 10-year Treasury Bond as of 12/07/10 (3.165 percent) 16 as well as the annual return of the S&P 500 from 19502010 (11.94 percent) and raw company beta (1.482) 17. Weights were assigned based on JetBlues current percentages of debt and equity-to-value. JetBlues net debt as of 09/30/10 is the sum of their long and short-term debt, capital leases, and subtracting cash.
14 15
IBIS World Domestic Airlines in the US (September 2010) SEC Filing Google Finance Bloomberg
Team A8
C-2
100%
80% 60% 40% 20% 0%
12/01/05
12/01/06
12/01/07
12/01/08
Jet Blue:
Southwest:
Airtran:
Alaska Airlines:
12/01/09
US Air:
Team A8
C-3
Figure 12. Pro-Forma Income Statement and Discounted Cash Flow Model
Jet Blue Airlines Pro-Forma Income Statement & Discounted Cash Flow Model $'s in millions Sales Passenger Other Total Sales Operating Expenses Aircraft Fuel and Related Taxes Salaries, Wages, & Benefits Landing Fees & Other Rents Depreciation & Amortization Aircraft Rent Sales & Marketing Maintenance Materials & Repairs Other Operating Expenses Total Operating Expenses EBIT Interest Expense Other Income/(Expenses) Pretax Income Income Tax Expense Net Income EBIAT Plus: Depreciation & Amort Less: Non-Aircraft Capital Expenditures Less: Additions to Working Capital Operating Cash Flow Terminal Value Discounted Value Current Enterprise Value Less: Debt, as of 12/31/16 Equity Value Shares Outstanding, as of 12/31/16 Common Share Value Stock Price 12/09/10 % Undervalued/(overvalued) Assumptions: Passenger Sales (Growth %) Other Sales (% Passenger Sales) Aircraft Fuel and Related Taxes (Growth %) Salaries, Wages, & Benefits (% Sales) Landing Fees & Other Rents (% Sales) Depreciation & Amortization (% Sales) Aircraft Rent (% Sales) Sales & Marketing (% Sales) Maintenance Materials & Repairs (Growth %) Other Operating Expenses (% Sales) Other Income (% Sales) Tax rate WC (% Sales) WACC (Rate of return) Perpetual Growth Rate $ $ $ $ 6,754.1 5,127.5 1,626.6 295.6 5.50 6.69 -17.8% $ $ TTM as of, 09/30/10 $ 3,304.0 367.0 3,671.0 1,057.0 864.0 226.0 223.0 124.0 168.0 162.0 507.0 3,331.0 340.0 184.0 10.0 166.0 67.0 99.0 $ $ $ $
2011 3,312.0 364.32 3,676.3 1,088.7 828.6 229.4 227.7 148.6 161.4 183.1 445.0 3,312.5 363.8 220.3 8.3 151.8 91.1 60.7 218.3 227.7 123.1 1.5 321.5 293.7 $ $ $ $
2012 3,528.4 388.12 3,916.5 1,121.4 882.7 244.4 242.6 158.3 171.9 203.2 474.1 3,498.6 417.8 236.8 8.8 189.9 113.9 76.0 250.7 242.6 131.7 40.6 321.0 268.0 $ $ $ $
2013 3,789.4 378.94 4,168.4 1,155.0 948.0 262.5 260.6 170.0 184.7 225.5 509.2 3,715.5 452.9 257.7 9.5 204.6 122.8 81.8 271.7 260.6 140.9 49.0 342.4 261.2 $ $ $ $
2014 4,162.4 374.62 4,537.0 1,189.7 1,041.4 288.3 286.2 186.7 202.8 250.4 559.3 4,004.8 532.2 286.2 10.4 256.5 153.9 102.6 319.3 286.2 150.7 70.0 384.8 268.2 $ $ $ $
2015 4,602.5 368.20 4,970.7 1,225.4 1,151.5 318.8 316.5 206.5 224.3 272.9 618.4 4,334.2 636.5 319.1 11.5 328.9 197.3 131.6 381.9 316.5 161.3 82.6 454.5 289.4 $ $ $ $
2016 4,945.7 395.65 5,341.3 1,262.1 1,237.3 342.6 340.1 221.9 241.0 297.5 664.5 4,606.9 734.4 346.1 12.4 400.6 240.4 160.3 440.6 340.1 172.6 64.4 543.7 8,690.6 5,373.6
$ $
$ $
$ $
$ $
$ $
$ $
0.2% 11.0% 3.0% 25.0% 6.9% 6.9% 4.5% 4.9% 13.0% 13.4% 0.3% 40.0% 18.8% 9.4% 3.0%
6.5% 11.0% 3.0% 25.0% 6.9% 6.9% 4.5% 4.9% 11.0% 13.4% 0.3% 40.0% 18.8%
7.4% 10.0% 3.0% 25.0% 6.9% 6.9% 4.5% 4.9% 11.0% 13.4% 0.3% 40.0% 18.8%
9.8% 9.0% 3.0% 25.0% 6.9% 6.9% 4.5% 4.9% 11.0% 13.4% 0.3% 40.0% 18.8%
10.6% 8.0% 3.0% 25.0% 6.9% 6.9% 4.5% 4.9% 9.0% 13.4% 0.3% 40.0% 18.8%
7.5% 8.0% 3.0% 25.0% 6.9% 6.9% 4.5% 4.9% 9.0% 13.4% 0.3% 40.0% 18.8%
Team A8
C-4
Cost of Equity: Risk-Free Rate Market Risk Premium Raw Company Beta Cost of Equity Calculation of Net Debt, as of 09/30/10: Class G-1, due through 2016 Class G-2, due 2014 and 2016 Class B-1, due 2014 Fixed rate special facility bonds, due through 2036 6.75% convertible debentures due in 2039 5.5% convertible debentures due in 2038 Floating rate equipment notes, due through 2020 Fixed rate equipment notes, due through 2025 Captial Leases Less: Excess Cash Total Debt, as of 09/30/10
Share Outstanding Analysis: Current Stock Price Options Data: Total # In-the-Money Options Weighted Avg. Strike Price Total Dollar Proceeds Total Shares Repurchased New Shares from Options Basic Shares Outstanding Total Share Outstanding Weighted Average Cost of Capital: WACC
9.4%
2008 $ 643.0 60.0 $ 703.0 -18.9% 2008 133 18 9 142 9 $ 71.4 $ 643.0
2009 $ 353.0 108.0 $ 461.0 80.0% 2009 142 11 2 151 9 $ 39.2 $ 353.0
2011 $ 450.7 123.1 $ 573.7 7.0% 2011 155 9 164 9 $ 50.1 $ 450.7
2012 $ 550.8 131.7 $ 682.5 7.0% 2012 164 11 175 11 $ 50.1 $ 550.8
2015 $ 1,101.6 161.3 $ 1,262.9 7.0% 2015 208 22 230 22 $ 50.1 $ 1,101.6
2016 901.3 172.6 $ 1,073.9 $ 7.0% 2016 230 18 248 $ $ 18 50.1 901.3
23.54
22.59
21.30
21.88
19.77
85 9
96 11 23 14
104 8 30 7
107 3 35 5
110 3 41 6
112 2 43 2
116 4 48 5
123 7 52 4
130 7 59 7
142 12 66 7
157 15 73 7
167 10 81 8
Team A8
C-5
Passenger Revenue: Projected Airbus A320 Fleet Available Seats Embraer 190 Fleet Available Seats Total Daily Available Seats Total Annual Avail Seats Avg Daily Rev/Available Seat Annual Rev Increase % Other Revenue: Other Rev Passenger Rev % of Passenfer Rev
2011 3,312.0
Team A8
C-6
Landing Fees Exp as a % of Revenue: 2005 Passenger Rev $ 1,620.0 Landing Fees Exp 112.0 Landing Fees Exp % Sales 6.9% 5-year Average 6.9% Salaries Exp as a % of Revenue: Passenger Rev Salaries Exp Salaries Exp % Sales 5-year Average $ 2005 1,620.0 428.0 26.4% 25.0%
Other Operating Exp as a % of Revenue: 2005 Total Revenue $ 1,701.0 Other Operating Exp 291.0 Other Op Exp % Sales 17.1% 5-year Average 13.4%
Team A8
C-7
Team A8
C-8
Team A8
C-9
Team A8
C-10
C o s t
Experience
Team A8
D-1
$53 $31 $0 JetBlue Southwest AirTran Airways Airlines Airways Alaska Airlines U.S. Airways
$17 $11
Team A8
D-2
Team A8
D-3
Product
JetBlue Airways Model Primarily point-topoint routes Locations 60 destinations in 20 states, Puerto Rico, and eleven countries in the Caribbean and Latin America Focus Cities Boston, Fort Lauderdale, Los Angeles/Long Beach, New York/JFK, Orlando Average Stage Length 1,064 miles Southwest Airlines Model Principally point-topoint routes Locations 69 cities in 35 states Average Stage Length 639 miles AirTran Airways Model Hub and network system; 50% of flights originate or terminate in Atlanta (hub) Locations Serves 63 locations including Puerto Rico, Aruba, Mexico and Bahamas; majority of markets served are in the eastern United States Focus Cities Baltimore, Milwaukee, Orlando Average Stage Length 738 miles US Airways Model Hubs in Charlotte, Philadelphia, and Phoenix and a focus city at Ronald Reagan Washington National Airport Locations Serves more than 200 communities in the U.S., Canada, Mexico, Europe, the Middle East, the Caribbean, Central and South America; member of the Star Alliance network which offers flights to 181 countries Average Stage Length 972 miles Alaska Airlines Model Hubs in Anchorage, Seattle, Portland, and Los Angeles Locations
59 cities in United States, Canada and Mexico
Team A8
E-1
Price
JetBlue Airways 2009 Revenue Per Passenger $102 Yield/Passenger Mile 11.28 cents Ancillary Fees Reservation changes, baggage limitations, TrueBlue frequent flyer point sales, concession Southwest Airlines 2009 Revenue Per Passenger $119 Yield/Passenger Mile 13.29 cents Ancillary Fees Pets, service charge for unaccompanied minor, third or overweight bag fee AirTran Airways 2009 Revenue Per Passenger $97 Yield/Passenger Mile 11.24 cents Ancillary Fees Pets, liquor sales, excess baggage charges, transportation of unaccompanied minors, frequent travel credits, optional fees for advance seat assignments and a fee for call center services, priority seat selection, the extension or transfer of A+ Miles Rewards, purchase of A+ Miles Rewards, checked baggage US Airways 2009 Revenue Per Passenger $118 Yield/Passenger Mile 13.52 cents Ancillary Fees First and second checked bag service fees, processing fees for travel awards, Choice Seats program, and call center/airport ticketing fees Alaska Airlines 2009 Revenue Per Passenger $157 Yield/ Passenger Mile 13.28 cents Ancillary Fees Reservations fees, ticket change fees, and baggage service charges
Note: Yield/Passenger Mile represents the average amount one passenger pays to fly one mile.
Team A8
E-2
Place (Distribution)
JetBlue Airways JetBlue website GDS (Sabre, Travelport and Amadeus) Online travel agent sites (Expedia, Travelocity, Orbitz, and Priceline) Southwest Airlines Southwest website AirTran Airways AirTran web site AirTran Bye-Pass airport self-service kiosks Mobile Web program Travel agency web sites (e.g. Travelocity, Expedia) US Airways US Airways website Online travel agent sites (e.g., Orbitz, Travelocity, Expedia and others) Traditional travel agents (GDS Sabre) Reservations centers and airline ticket offices Alaska Airlines Alaskaair website Traditional and online travel agents (GDS-Sabre, Orbitz) Reservation call centers.
Team A8
E-3
Promotion
JetBlue Airways Message/Tagline You above all 2009 Advertising Costs $53M Target Primarily leisure; increasingly business travelers Media Newspapers, magazines, television, radio, internet, social media, outdoor billboards, targeted public relations, local events and sponsorships, and mobile marketing programs, strong word-of-mouth Highlighted Features Happy Jetting, JetBlue Experience, brand name snacks and drinks Southwest Airlines Message/Tagline Bags fly free 2009 Advertising Costs $204M Target Leisure and business travelers Media Television, internet, social media (Facebook, Twitter) Highlighted Features Southwest Difference, Rapid Rewards frequent flyer program, in-flight Internet connectivity, EarlyBird check-in, Business Select enhancements AirTran Airways Message/Tagline Go. Theres nothing stopping you. 2009 Advertising Costs $31.3M Target Business and leisure travelers Media Newspapers; satellite, Internet, social media (Facebook: AirTranUHome of the really cheap standby flight), and over-the-air radio; broadcast, cable, and satellite television; out-of-home media; direct mail; e-mail; movie theatres; and the Internet, as well as public relations efforts US Airways Message/Tagline Fly with US 2009 Advertising Costs $11M Target Business and leisure travelers Media Internet, social media (Facebook, Twitter) Highlighted Features Dividend Miles frequent flyer program, customer feedback Alaska Airlines Message/Tagline North of Expected 2009 Advertising Costs $16.8M Target Business and leisure travelers Media Television, internet, social media (Facebook, Twitter, YouTube) Highlighted Features Mileage Plan travel awards
Team A8
E-4
JetBlue Airways Highlighted Features Continued Onboard boxed meals, R&R, planes (young fleet), award-winning service, Customer loyalty program, DirecTV programming, XM Satellite Radio, Movies & more, NFL Sunday Ticket, Free wireless, Customer Bill of Rights
Southwest Airlines
AirTran Airways Highlighted Features Destinations, quality, business Class, XM radio, young Boeing aircraft fleet, assigned seating, everyday affordable fares, special sales promotions, frequent flier program A+ Rewards
US Airways
Alaska Airlines
Team A8
E-5
Revenue Recognition
JetBlue Airways Uses Air Traffic Liability account to reserve for unused tickets before tickets are utilized and the revenue is recognized. Alaska Airlines Same as JetBlue. US Airways Same as JetBlue. Southwest Airlines Same as JetBlue.
Airplane Ownership/Leasing
JetBlue Airways Primarily owned 151 planes total; 61 percent owned, 36 percent operating leased, 3 percent capital leased. Alaska Airlines Primarily owned. 137 planes total; 61 percent owned, 39 percent leased (lease structure not disclosed) US Airways Primarily operating leased. 442 planes total; 62 percent operating leased, 29 percent owned, 9 percent capital leased. Southwest Airlines Primarily owned. 537 planes total; 82 percent owned, 16 percent operating leased, 2 percent capital leased.
Team A8
F-1
Equipment Depreciation
JetBlue Airways Planes are depreciated over 25 years with 20 percent residual value. Alaska Airlines Similar. Long range planes depreciated over 20 years, regional planes depreciated over 15 years. US Airways Unspecified. Depreciated over life of asset ranging from five to thirty years. Southwest Airlines Similar. Depreciated over 2325 years with 10-15 percent residual value.
Fuel Hedges
JetBlue Airways Gains/losses incurred due to hedging are recognized in the Fuel Expense account at the time the underlying fuel is consumed. It there is any other value change beyond consumption, it is recognized as an Other Income or Other Expense. Qualifies for Hedge Accounting Rules. Alaska Airlines Different. Marked to market as value changes. Allows unrealized gains/losses to be recognized as the hedge is marked to market. Does not qualify for Hedge Accounting Rules. US Airways Different. Marked to market as value changes. Allows unrealized gains/losses to be recognized as the hedge is marked to market. Does not qualify for Hedge Accounting Rules. Southwest Airlines Same as JetBlue.
Loyalty Rewards
JetBlue Airways Liability reserved as part of Air Traffic Liability account, as incremental cost (no contribution to overhead). JetBlue does not disclose the amount of points outstanding and value cannot be evaluated. Alaska Airlines Same as JetBlue. US Airways Same as JetBlue. Southwest Airlines Same as JetBlue.
Team A8
F-2
Customers Collaborators
Competitors
Team A8
G-1
Context
The industry has traditionally been dominated by the major U.S. airlines such as Delta/Northwest Air Lines, American Airlines, United Airlines, Continental Airlines, Southwest Airlines and US Airways. All airlines are subject to regulation by the DOT, the FAA, the Transportation Security Administration, or TSA, and other governmental agencies. Low-cost airlines largely developed after deregulation of the U.S. airline industry in 1978. Southwest pioneered the low-cost model. The industry is characterized by low profit margins, high fixed costs and significant price competition.
Team A8
G-2
Team A8
H-1
Sources
Brand Keys, Inc. 2010 Brand Keys Customer Loyalty Engagement Index. (http://www.brandkeys.com/awards/) Carr, Sustin. (October 14, 2010). JetBlue Goes Populist for New Ad Campaign. Fast Company (fastcompany.com); Mansueto Ventures LLC. http://www.fastcompany.com/1695138/jetblue-you-above-all Foust, Dean. (May 14, 2009). How Delta climbed out of bankruptcy. Business Week (Bloomberg LP). http://www.businessweek.com/magazine/content/09_21/b4132036798289.htm J.P. Morgan Chase Chase & Co. Airline Industry Overview/Considerations. 2010. JetBlue Airways. SEC Filings. Mintel Oxygen Database. Airlines US May 2010. Molavi, Justin. (October 2010). IBISWorld Industry Report 42272 - Gasoline & Petroleum Wholesaling in the US. Parekh, Rupal. (July 6, 2010). How JetBlue Became One of the Hottest Brands in America Q&A With Airlines Marketing Chief Marty St. George. Advertising Age (adage.com); Crain Communications. http://adage.com/cmostrategy/article?article_id=144799 Quinton, Brian. (October 1, 2010). Brand, Buzz and Bookings Why Fly the Other Guy? Chief Marketer (chiefmarketer.com). http://chiefmarketer.com/disciplines/branding/jetblue-marketing-success-plan1001/index1.html Samadi, Nima. (September 2010). IBISWorld Industry Report 48111b - Domestic Airlines in the US. Sisario, Ben. (October 20, 2010). Catching a Flight, and a Show. The New York Times (nytimes.com). http://www.nytimes.com/2010/10/21/arts/music/21swift.html Stoller, Gary. (September 15, 2010). JetBlue, Southwest beat big carriers for service, quality. USA Today (usatoday.com); Gannett Co., Inc. http://www.usatoday.com/travel/flights/2010-09-151Aairlinecomplaints15_ST_N.htm The Wall Street Journal. (September 2005). Delta, Northwest See Bankruptcy as Key to Revival.