You are on page 1of 1

REPUBLIC vs. COURT OF APPEALS Facts: In "In the Matter of Declaration of Presumptive Death of Absentee Spouse Clemente P.

Jomoc, Apolinaria Malinao Jomoc, petitioner," the Ormoc City, Region al Trial Court, Branch 35, by Order of September 29, 1999, granted the petition on the basis of the Commissioner s Report and accordingly declared the absentee spou se, who had left his petitioner-wife nine years earlier, presumptively dead.Such decision was based on Article 41, par. 2 of the Family Code. The Republic, through the Office of the Solicitor General, appealed the decision by filing a Notice of Appeal. The trial court disapproved the notice of appeal since no record of appeal was filed and served. A motion for reconsideration fil ed was also disapproved thus a Petition for Certiorari was filed before the CA c ontending that declaration of presumptive death under article 41 of the FC is no t a special proceeding thus record on appeal is not required. CA denied the pet ition on the ground that since the petition is a in the nature of a special proc eeding and not an ordinary action. OSG should have filed, in addition to its Not ice of Appeal, a record on appeal Issue: whether or not a petition for declaration of the presumptive death of a p erson is in the nature of a special proceeding. Rulings: No. By the trial court s citation of Article 41 of the Family Code, it is g athered that the petition of Apolinaria Jomoc to have her absent spouse declared presumptively dead had for its purpose her desire to contract a valid subsequen t marriage. Ergo, the petition for that purpose is a "summary proceeding," follo wing above-quoted Art. 41, paragraph 2 of the Family Code. There is no doubt that the petition of Apolinaria Jomoc required, and is, theref ore, a summary proceeding under the Family Code, not a special proceeding under the Revised Rules of Court appeal for which calls for the filing of a Record on Appeal. It being a summary ordinary proceeding, the filing of a Notice of Appeal from the trial court s order sufficed.

You might also like