Professional Documents
Culture Documents
A Tale of Two Technologies: A Tale of Two Technologies: A Tale of Two Technologies: A Tale of Two Technologies: Wimax vs. Lte Wimax vs. Lte
A Tale of Two Technologies: A Tale of Two Technologies: A Tale of Two Technologies: A Tale of Two Technologies: Wimax vs. Lte Wimax vs. Lte
A Tale of Two Technologies: WiMAX vs. LTE Dr. Kun Yang University of Essex, UK y
17th March 2009 @ NII
1
Agenda
Wireless LAN (Local Area Networks) Wireless MAN: WiMAX Mobile Cellular Systems 3GPP LTE (Long Term Evolution) Femto Cell and Mobility Q&A
Some slides here pay courtesy to J. He, & D. Hunter.
2
IEEE 802 11 IEEE 802.11 IEEE 802.15 IEEE 802.16 IEEE 802.21
3
AP
Station (STA)
terminal with access mechanisms to the wireless medium and radio contact to the access point
Access Point
station integrated into the wireless LAN and the distribution system
Portal
bridge to other (wired) networks
Distribution System
STA2 802.11 LAN STA3
interconnection network to form one logical network (EES: Extended Service Set) based 6 on several BSS
STA2
ETSI - HIPERLAN
ETSI standard
European standard, cf. GSM, DECT, ... Enhancement of local Networks and interworking with fixed networks integration of time-sensitive services from the early beginning
HIPERLAN family
one standard cannot satisfy all requirements
range, bandwidth, QoS support commercial constraints
HIPERLAN 1 standardized since 1996 higher layers medium access control layer channel access control layer physical layer HIPERLAN layers network layer data link layer physical layer OSI layers g logical link control layer medium access control layer physical layer IEEE 802.x layers
8
collision avoidance via randomized back-off mechanism minimum distance between consecutive packets ACK packet for acknowledgements (not for broadcasts)
DFWMAC-DCF w/ RTS/CTS (optional)
medium busy
contention
next frame t
10
station ready to send starts sensing the medium (Carrier Sense based on CCA, Clear Channel Assessment) if the medium is free for the duration of an Inter-Frame p (IFS), g( p Space ( ) the station can start sending (IFS depends on service type) if the medium is busy, the station has to wait for a free IFS, then the station must additionally wait a random back-off time (collision avoidance, multiple of slot-time) if another station occupies the medium during the back-off time of the station, the back-off timer stops (fairness)
11
802.11 - DFWMAC
Sending unicast packets
station can send RTS with reservation parameter after waiting for DIFS (reservation determines amount of time the data packet needs the medium) acknowledgement via CTS after SIFS by receiver (if ready to receive) sender can now send data at once, acknowledgement via ACK other stations store medium reservations distributed via RTS and CTS
DIFS sender receiver RTS SIFS CTS SIFS data SIFS ACK
other stations
DIFS
data t
contention
14
Fragmentation
NAV (RTS) NAV (CTS) other stations NAV (frag1) NAV (ACK1) DIFS contention data t
15
DFWMAC-PCF I
t0 t1 medium b di busy PIFS point coordinator wireless stations stations NAV SuperFrame SIFS SIFS U1 NAV SIFS SIFS U2
D1
D2
At the beginning of the contention-free period, the AP transmits a beacon frame (not shown above see later)
This announces the maximum duration of the contention-free period All stations use this duration to set their NAVs
16
DFWMAC-PCF II
t3
t4
contention period
17
Sequence numbers q
important against duplicated frames due to lost ACKs
Addresses
receiver, transmitter (physical), BSS identifier, sender (logical)
Miscellaneous
sending time, checksum, frame control, data
bytes 2 Frame Control 2 6 6 6 2 6 Duration Address Address Address Sequence Address ID 1 2 3 Control 4 version, type, fragmentation, security, ... 0-2312 Data 4 CRC
18
DS: Distribution System AP: Access Point DA: Destination Address SA: Source Address BSSID: Basic Service Set Identifier RA: Receiver Address TA: Transmitter Address
19
Power management
sleep-mode without missing a message periodic sleep, frame buffering, traffic measurements
Association/Reassociation
integration into a LAN roaming, i.e. change networks by changing access points scanning, i.e. active search for a network
10
21
MANET Introduction
Mobile ad hoc networks (MANETs) are basically peer-to-peer multihop mobile wireless networks that
have neither fixed communication infrastructure nor any base stations (BSs). (BSs)
Efficient routing of packets is a primary MANET challenge. M N s MANETs use multihop rather t a s g e op routing to de ve u t op at e than single-hop out g deliver packets to their destination.
22
11
Routing
Conventional networks typically rely on distance-vector or linkstate algorithms, which depend on periodic broadcast advertisements of all routers to keep routing tables up-to-date. In I some cases, MANETs also use th MANET l these algorithms, which ensure l ith hi h that the route to every host is always known. However, this approach presents several problems:
periodically updating the network topology increases bandwidth overhead; repeatedly awakening hosts to receive and send information quickly exhausts batteries; the propagation of routing information, which depends on the information number of existing hosts, causes overloading, thereby reducing scalability; redundant routes accumulate needlessly; communication systems often cannot respond to dynamic changes in the network topology quickly enough.
23
24
12
Bluetooth
Why Bluetooth
1994 Ericsson study on a wireless technology to link mobile phones and accessories Lets replace all those ugly wires with a short range low data rate wireless system. Basically to standardise wireless keyboards and mice
And add a few more on the way
Main references:
IEEE Std 802.15.1, Information Technology Telecommunications and Information Exchange between Systems Local and Metropolitan Area Networks Specific Requirements Part 15.1: Wireless Medium Access Control (MAC) and Physical Layer (PHY) Specifications for Wireless Personal Area Networks (WPANs), 2002.
25
Bluetooth
Bluetooth is a standard for wireless communications. Bluetooth is an infrastructure less short-range wireless system intended to replace the cable between electronic d d l h bl b l user terminals with RF links. The devices can also be used for communications between portable computers, act as bridges between other networks, or serve as nodes of ad hoc networks. This range of applications is known as wireless personal area network (WPAN). Bluetooth devices use the 2.4 GHz band, which is unlicensed in most countries.
26
13
Piconet
The Bluetooth topology is a star network where a master node can have up to seven slave nodes wirelessly connected to it to form a piconet. Piconet i the simplest configuration of a Bluetooth network. Pi t is th i l t fi ti f Bl t th t k Each piconet uses a centrally assigned time-division multiple access (TDMA) schedule and frequency hopping pattern. Transmission power is typically around 20 dBm and the transmission range is on the order of tens of meters.
27
Scatternet
Piconets may be connected together, thus forming a scatternet. A scatternet supports multihop.
i.e., two nodes can communicate with each other even if there is no direct connection between them by using other nodes as relays relays.
Two piconets can communicate by means of a common node belonging to both of them. A node can be a master in one piconet at most and a slave in several others.
28
14
29
30
15
Agenda
Wireless LAN (Local Area Networks) Wireless MAN: WiMAX (IEEE 802.16)
WiMAX PHY/MAC/QoS Features Comparison with IEEE 802.11
Mobile Cellular Systems 3GPP LTE (Long Term Evolution) Femto Cell and Mobility Q&A
31
IEEE 802.16
WiMAX is the commercialization of the IEEE 802.16 standard,
Started at the National Institute of Standards and Technologies (NIST) in 1998 and then transferred to the IEEE to form Working Group 802.16. In June 2004, the working group won approval for the l h k lf h latest 802.16 standard for fixed wireless access, known as IEEE 802.16-2004. In December 2005, an extension that addresses mobility also won approval as IEEE 802.16e-2005.
Specifies the air interface, including the medium access control layer (MAC) and physical layer (PHY), of fixed point-to-multipoint (PMP) and Mesh broadband wireless access systems providing multiple services. services The standard includes a particular physical layer specification broadly applicable to systems operating between 10 and 66 GHz, and below 10GHz.
16
33
Standard History
FirststandardbasedonproprietaryimplementationsofDOCSIS/HFC architectureinwirelessdomain
802.16 (Dec 2001) 802.16c (2002)
OriginalfixedwirelessbroadbandairInterfacefor10 66 GHz:Line of sightonly,Point to Multi Pointapplications GHz: Lineofsight only, PointtoMultiPoint applications 802.16AmendmentWiMAX SystemProfiles10 66GHz, lineofsight Extensionfor211GHz:Targetedfornonlineofsight, PointtoMultiPointapplicationslikelastmile broadbandaccess
AddsWiMAX SystemProfilesandErratafor211GHz
MAC/PHYEnhancementstosupportsubscribers movingatvehicularspeeds
34
17
Other versions
802.16f-2005 Management Information Base (MIB) 802.16g-2007 Management Plane Procedures and Services 802.16k-2007 802 16k 2007 Bridging of 802.16 (an amendment to 802.1D) 802 16 802 1D) 802.16h Improved Coexistence Mechanisms for License-Exempt Operation 802.16i Mobile Management Information Base 802.16j Multihop Relay Specification 802.16Rev2 Consolidate 802.16-2004, 802.16e, 802.16f, 802.16g and possibly 802.16i into a new document. 802.16m Advanced Air Interface. Data rates of 100 Mbit/s for mobile applications and 1 Gbit/s for fixed applications.
Source: wikipedia
35
Services
Deliver both fixed and mobile wireless broadband services Two forms of wireless service:
Desirable Non-line-of-sight (NLOS) service
Small antenna 2 11 GHz Up to 8 km radius (cell phone zone)
Line-of-sight (LOS)
Fixed antenna; strong and stable connection 10 66 GHz Up to 50 km radius
Applications
Broadband B db d on-demand d d
Fast deployment of WLAN hotspots
Residential broadband
Hard competition with DSL, cable and fiber
36
18
Reference Model
37
Protocol Stack
Upper Layers
Service specific convergence sublayer MAC sublayer common part Security sublayer Transmission convergence sublayer Physical medium dependent sublayer
(QPSK | QAM-16 | QAM-64) Physical Layer Data Link Layer
38
19
PHY Considerations
Broadband channels
Wide channels (20, 25, or 28 MHz) ( ) High capacity Downlink AND Uplink
Multiple access
TDM/TDMA High rate burst modems
Adaptive PHY
20
41
TDD Frame
Frameduration:1msPhysicalSlot(PS)=4symbols
42
21
44
22
TDMA portion: transmits data to some half-duplex SSs (the ones scheduled to transmit earlier in the frame than they receive). Need preamble to resync (carrier phase)
45
46
23
Applicability
10-66 GHz Licensed 2-11 GHz Licensed 2-11 GHz Licensed
MAC
Basic Basic, (ARQ), (STC), (AAS) Basic, (ARQ), (STC), (AAS)
Duplexing
TDD, FDD, HFDD TDD, FDD TDD, FDD
WirelessMANOFDM
2-11 GHz License- Basic, (ARQ), TDD exempt (STC), (DFS), (MSH), (AAS) 2-11 GHz Licensed Basic, (ARQ), (STC), (AAS) TDD, FDD
WirelessMANOFDMA
2-11 GHz License- Basic, (ARQ), TDD exempt (STC), (DFS), (MSH), (AAS)
47
MAC Requirements
Provide Network Access Address the Wireless environment
e.g., very efficient use of spectrum
Broadband services
Very high bit rates, downlink and uplink A range of QoS requirements Convergence layers to ATM, IP, Ethernet, ...
24
MAC Layer
Basic Primary Secondary Otherconnects Traffic connection connection connection (Initialaccess connection (RLCandshort,(authentication, (DHCP,TFTP, Broadcast (data) Timecritical Connection SNMP..) Multicast) MACmsg) setup) Fragmentation Packing Grantmanagementsubheader Meshsubheader Management connections subheader subheader
Basic connection: TransmissionConvergencesublayer short, time-urgent msg Primary connection: Long, delay-tolerant msg 1066GHz PHY PHY 211GHz Secondary connection: Delay-tolerant standard-based msg
49
QoS Support
QoS support is critical for the support of commercial applications Defines 4+1 class of services, associated with connections f l f d h ref. next slide Scheduling Services Parameters
Maximum sustained traffic rate Minimum reserved traffic rate Maximum latency Tolerated jitter Traffic priority Request/transmission policy
25
Classes of Service
Unsolicited Grant Services (UGS)
for constant bit-rate (CBR) or CBR-like service flows (SFs), e.g. T1/E1
51
26
Decision based on requested bandwidth and QoS requirements vs the available resources at BS. Grants are realized through the UL-MAP.
53
Unicast Polling
BS allocates space for the SS in the uplink subframe (using ULPoll MAP) Request 2. SS uses the allocated space to send a bw request. Allocate Data 3. BS allocates the requested space for the SS if available (using UL( g MAP 4. SS uses allocated space to send scheduling data.
BS SS
1.
54
27
Agenda
Wireless LAN (Local Area Networks) Wireless MAN: WiMAX (IEEE 802.16)
WiMAX PHY/MAC Features Comparison with IEEE 802.11
Mobile Cellular Systems 3GPP LTE (Long Term Evolution) Femto cell and Mobility Q&A
55
International Licensed
ISM
US Licensed
ISM
GHz
28
Channel Performance
Channel Bandwidth 802.11a 802.16a 20 MHz Maximum Data Rate 54 Mbps Maximum bps/Hz ~2.7 bps/Hz ~5.0 bps/Hz
Scalability: 802.11a 802 11 MAC d i designed to support 10s of users whereas dt t 10 f h 802.16 to support thousands of users
QoS
IEEE 802.11 IEEE 802.16a
Contention-based MAC Grant-request MAC q (CSMA/CA) => poor QoS mechanism is part of the performance under heavy load. standard No guaranteed QoS Designed to support Voice No differentiated service and Video on a per-user basis Supports 5 QoS differentiated service TDD only asymmetric levels 802.11e: QoS is i iti ti 802 11 Q S i prioritization TDD/FDD asymmetric only or symmetric AMC: Adaptive Modulation and Coding
58
29
Range
802.11
Optimized for ~100 meters No near-far compensation
802.16a
Optimized for up to 50 Km Designed to handle many users spread out over kilometers Designed to tolerate greater multi-path delay spread up to 10.0 seconds, optimized for outdoor NLOS performance
Designed to handle indoor multi-path (delay spread of 0.8 seconds), optimized for indoor
Optimization centers around PHY and MAC layer for 100m range Range can be extended by increasing trans. Power - may be non-standard
PHY and MAC designed with multi-mile range d d i d ith lti il in mind
Standard MAC
59
J. Orr of Proxim
60
30
Agenda
Wireless LAN (Local Area Networks) Wireless MAN: WiMAX (IEEE 802.16)
Mobile Cellular Systems
3GPP LTE (Long Term Evolution) Femto cell and Mobility Q&A
61
Motivation
Radio spectrum is very limited,
we have only 10-25MHz dedicated to wireless communication.
Then the cellular idea: division of the whole geographical area to relatively small cells, and each cell may by ma reuse the same frequencies b reducing power of transmission. Each cell has its own antenna (base station), and all base stations are interconnected using microwave or cable communication.
62
31
A bit of history
Once upon a time there was analog cellular communication
didnt support encryption, compression, and ISDN pp yp p compatibility; in addition each country (company) developed its own system, which was incompatible with everyone elses in equipment and operation.
So, in early 80s Europeans realized that pan-European public mobile system should be developed. The new system had to meet certain criteria:
Good subjective speech quality Low terminal and service cost International roaming ISDN compatibility Digital
63
64
32
Frequency Reuse
Adjacent cells are assigned different frequencies to avoid interference or crosstalk Objective is to reuse f b frequency in nearby cells b ll
10 to 50 frequencies assigned to each cell Transmission power controlled to limit power at that frequency escaping to adjacent cells. The issue is to determine how many cells must intervene between two cells using the same frequency.
65
Examples
N=4
N=7
66
33
Frequency reuse
Reuse Distance (D): minimum distance between centres of cells that use the same band of frequencies (co-channels)
67
Increasing Capacity
Adding new channels Frequency borrowing frequencies are taken from adjacent cells by congested cells d ll b d ll Cell splitting cells in areas of high usage can be split into smaller cells Cell sectoring cells are divided into a number of wedge-shaped sectors, each with their own set of channels. Directional Antennas must be used in this case. Microcells a decrease in cell size results in a reduction of the radiated power levels.
68
34
Example: Microcells
Area: 213 km2 , Bandwidth: 336 channels per cluster, cells per cluster: N=7 If cell radius R=1.6 km, then 32 total cells , If cell radius R=0.6 km, then 128 cells
Total channel capacity is 48 x 32 = 1536 Total channel capacity is 48 x128 =6144 channels Number of channels per cell is 336/7=48
Total cells: 32
69
subsystems
RSS (radio subsystem): covers all radio aspects NSS (network and switching subsystem): call forwarding, handover, switching OSS (operation subsystem): management of the network
70
35
GSM: overview
OMC, EIR, AUC HLR NSS with OSS VLR MSC GMSC fixed network
VLR
MSC
71
HLR
36
Agenda
Wireless LAN (Local Area Networks) Wireless MAN: WiMAX (IEEE 802.16) Mobile Cellular Systems
3GPP LTE (Long Term Evolution)
73
CDMA-2000: (2.5G+3G), e.g., China Unicom TD-SCDMA at China; to avoid patent fees
3.5G: UMTS is being upgraded to High Speed Downlink Packet Access (HSDPA): up to 7.2 Mb/s. 3.99G/4G: the 3GPP Long Term Evolution (LTE) project plans to move UMTS to 4G: 100 Mb/s downlink and 50 Mb/s uplink, using OFDM.
74
37
Standard Releases
Version Release 98 Release 99 Release 4 Release 5 Release 6 Release 7 Release 8 Release 9 Release 10 Released at 1998 2000 Q1 2001 Q2 2002 Q1 2004 Q4 2007 Q4 Mar. 2009 Dec. 2009 In progress Description This and earlier releases specify p p y pre-3G GSM networks Specified the first UMTS 3G networks, incorporating a CDMA air interface Added features including an all-IP Core Network Introduced IMS and HSDPA Integrated operation with Wireless LAN networks Performance improvement LTE, All-IP Network (SAE). SAES Enhancements, Wimax and LTE/UMTS Interoperability LTE Advanced
76
From wikipedia
38
LTE-advanced Proposals
Various concepts for Relay Nodes UE Dual TX antenna solutions for SU-MIMO and diversity MIMO Scalable system bandwidth exceeding 20 MHz, Potentially up to MHz 100MHz Local area optimization of air interface Nomadic / Local Area network and mobility solutions Flexible Spectrum Usage Cognitive Radio Automatic and autonomous network configuration and operation g p Enhanced precoding and forward error correction Interference management and suppression Asymmetric bandwidth assignment for FDD Hybrid OFDMA and SC-FDMA in uplink UL/DL inter eNB coordinated MIMO
From wikipedia
77
39
80
40
Comparison
WiMAX
Large Coverage Network Net o k Simplicity
WiFi
Broad Band
Full Mobility
Security
QoS
3G/HSDPA
82
41
Mobility/Range
HighSpeed
Vehicle
limitedmobility HSDPA
IEEE 802.16e
W Walk
Fixed
Indoor PersonalArea
WLAN (IEEE802.11x)
IEEE 802.16d
0.1
10
Agenda
Wireless LAN (Local Area Networks) Wireless MAN: WiMAX (IEEE 802.16) Mobile Cellular Systems 3GPP LTE (Long Term Evolution)
Femto cell and Mobility
Q&A
84
42
Smartphones
Windows Mobile Based: 12% of the market, supports UMTS, WiFi. Symbian Based: 65% of the market, Nokia, Sony Ericsson, support 3G. RIM OS Based: 11% of the market, Blackberry (not currently 3G capable to save battery, with the small exception) Mac OS-like iPhone-OS Based: 7% of the market OS like iPhone OS market. Apple's iPhone (using EDGE)
85
Femto Cell
Also called Access Point Base Station No dual-mode handset needed, existing handset is fine. A femto cell is a small cellular base station, typically for indoors, especially where access would otherwise be limited or unavailable. The femtocell incorporates the functionality of a typical base station but extends it to allow a simpler, self contained deployment Although much attention is focussed on UMTS, the concept is applicable to other network technologies, such as GSM, CDMA2000, TD-SCDMA, WiMAX. Attractions to mobile operators: to improve both coverage and p p g capacity, especially indoors.
There may also be opportunity for new services and reduced cost.
86
43
MacroCellBS
BroadbandRouter
MacroNetwork
Internet
Example Scenario
88
44
Contact, Q&A
Dr Kun Yang School of Comp. Science & Electronic Engineering (CSEE), University of Essex, Wivenhoe Park, Colchester, CO4 3SQ, UK Email: kunyang@essex.ac.uk http://privatewww.essex.ac.uk/~kunyang/
89
45