1

aA
Te
d

aA
1. E - B
a d a d ,
R e e , , d , d r e .
E (B d , 472).
M.: d a a ,
f r e , a , d
a d f c f .
^H c r . E e
E d A [
: b a e r [], b
(f = )] d a . ^O
e \A, E, e r : a ^Ia a
e
Kd , 2006; N, e e , b r
e , d f a a
c c a . Te e c KEIMENA TOY A N . M A P I N H AO TO EPIOIKON E H N I K O N A N E O N

2
c : T a ; d c [sic] !
[^H d c : d c e ] M. \E b a , a c ^Ia , a d d
b a c a
O a d a c c

\E d f e : r b e a
c e b ; ^O ,
, , e a b f ,
b c ;
hA e c : d ; \A, , a a Christine Overall,
g e b c , \ a a c ANYAPIAN .
hA e - c d
Overall.

2. \A
^O e c e
d b c
c f d . \A, , a
e :
^O Ian Walker (148) [ ],
a a r , a c . T a a a
e e e e c a r c .
Ka e David Basinger a q a d a e e a a d a a d a .
\A d e c Overall c , g b e e : c
a . Ka c Overall,
KEIMENA TOY A N . M A P I N H AO TO EPIOIKON E H N I K O N A N E O N

3
a a
e .
^ , , a f f
, c f d
b r . T a :
. , hO e , e , b r
e a e e e . \Ed a d ,
, a e . hA
e r e a
e e b r e e e
K a e .
. E , e Alastair McKinnon, : a c c e r , a e a r c e j . O e e a
a , \ d \
, e b a r a a !
. E , X (George Chryssides),
a e r , c , b
a (agent), : a , , a , b r , r , .
\E , a b e b a d . ^H e b c (;) , b c (b a
a a d
).
O Douglas Odegard, a e
e d a a e . Te
b a . Er b a

KEIMENA TOY A N . M A P I N H AO TO EPIOIKON E H N I K O N A N E O N

4
d e d (.. ),
a e e (.. ). ^O
\ c e c f d , d , d , r
.
A r b , Walker, b r e a
a ( ) (violation miracles)
e , g a .
^H Overall : e , e c
, b a c
, \, , d , c c
. hA c .

3. ^H Overall
. Te r e c d c K
Te e e r a r c
(consistent) b c . E e e d
d r \ c d c
d e f d . O
a d a d
, b r e a d d a , c c , c
. d , b r e a
d .
, , e e
b e , a
e d . ^O Erlandson : Te d e r , a a r
, a c [pattern] , ,
c ( a a ) a c c .
T a c f d
a , c a c -

KEIMENA TOY A N . M A P I N H AO TO EPIOIKON E H N I K O N A N E O N

5
.
. Te b b f f e .
Te e r e : Er
j e e a e ;
^H Overall b r . e
r e a a , a d a e a d a
a (patterns) . Te d d
d c c d . E e e a
e .
ANTEIXEIPHMA A [d \O \E]
r e a e e . ^H a
: e a b r a ,
e r (Erlandson ..).
O, e a : c c d c , c
c (.. d , ..).
[\A a , c r d f
c X \A (119-120):
\E c a
, a , a
a praeter ordinem totius naturae creatae [ a c
]. ^H
b d \ e
, \ d
d . , d e d : M \ , a e d , e d
m c . ^O e d
d a d c
. (...) b b c e -

KEIMENA TOY A N . M A P I N H AO TO EPIOIKON E H N I K O N A N E O N

6
, d e
f f a . ^ b , c
e r c r e , d r , c e . ^ b
, b e e , d
b d e , b a e \ a . \Aa e e a e c d c c .]
^H Overall r : , (. f e a a d ), b r e a c
d d b e (pattern) c . , a a
b q , a c a e , d
c . ^E, , .., Erlandson (
e c ), e a a
r a e e d a
\ d , r
c r e c c d b a a ...
ANTEIXEIPHMA B
E e e Overall
e b a f a , r
e : a c
r e e a a a a e
( , .).
e : , a
, a , c
a (, , ..). ,
a f f e e

KEIMENA TOY A N . M A P I N H AO TO EPIOIKON E H N I K O N A N E O N

7
a : e b f
j b a c
c a c ;
\Ea e , j , a e a c . \E , a a
, ( , ), (b j ) , , . \Aa d a b
c c B , a a a d
( a d ), b
.
A, e c e
O e c f a d , c , Overall a hO , b a r a a a e (, ,
.), d b a r e !

4. \A a Robert A. H. Larmer
^O Xe Robert Larmer e e
e Overall , :
d ) e e e b a , ) \ e (agent), )
c c , ) c . T , , a \ a c , e
, , a , a Larmer, e a c X.
E , e d Overall, r () b e d b e .
^H e e e : c e
e b r a , b
r , hO . T , , \
, d

KEIMENA TOY A N . M A P I N H AO TO EPIOIKON E H N I K O N A N E O N

8
: !
Te e b e e Larmer e e e e e : , ,
e (agent) c , a
a q .

4.1 ^H c d \Ac \E
Bc Larmer r , d b hO e ,
a d a f f
. e , Larmer c a
N , b a
a e K c a , .., e d b ,
g \I c () ex nihilo,
.
^H Larmer i d
e c c d
a a a . Te e r g a
a d f . ^O Larmer
, a e
, i d c .
O e , a
r (defining-postulate) , c
(physicalism) d r
a e e d , r .
\Ad e ,
c c , a c e e [c e e b e
e e ] c , a . b
c e d , c
, a c a e Larmer,
KEIMENA TOY A N . M A P I N H AO TO EPIOIKON E H N I K O N A N E O N

9
a e
a c c a c . Te maximum
e b a a
r e e . ^O Larmer b a c .
Overall Larmer e : a c
d ( c
), a Larmer
a a e
e . \E\ , Overall a
: i c
c c , e , Larmer:
c c c e
(e ). A r Overall a c a q a a d a c .
T, e d c
, Overall y a c y a
c . Er ,
, a c a . b a c
. \E , d
d c ... \A, b a .
^E r c (rational).
hA , a a
Overall, : i c (e
c a : o , , d ,
b , M A, E , IV 23,2 d e c ^Ec
K r ) b e (naive materialism, d
, 5).
4.2 ^H Larmer e e
KEIMENA TOY A N . M A P I N H AO TO EPIOIKON E H N I K O N A N E O N

10

^O Larmer e verall d c
e f , a . b c c
:
E K e
hO d , g . \Ea
e b , b a e
a , r a e
e .. e a e .
\E , Overall,
e e K c , r : i d
c a d b j a
, a c a a e c j c . \E
e r d K e c
c d d a K
e a . \E Overall,
\ c d d c f e K, g c
, e d
d . \Ea e j a q b e
r O e r e .
^O Larmer d e Overall
c b a r c b c c
. \A g e e a r
e j e e . Ka e
Larmer, a a , b r d \ . Er a , b a e .
O, Overall, a , f f d a KEIMENA TOY A N . M A P I N H AO TO EPIOIKON E H N I K O N A N E O N

11
e d a a e r e a
e . \Ea e \
b \ d c ,
. , e a e e e b \ d c c
c e . \E ,
e e b ()
. \E e : r c
r K (. \I 2:1-11); c
;
Te e a d \ e a
O, c a e e
e . ^O Larmer g ,
e , c a c , e e e \
b e a c . ^O
Larmer e d : e .
^H Overall , , , d
e e a q e a r , d
, a . p
e a e c \ c , e d a
e c ;
, a Larmer b a
c c Overall a a
a c , c a d .

5. Te e c ^Ec
c d :
c c e e ,
e d (. c ), b
KEIMENA TOY A N . M A P I N H AO TO EPIOIKON E H N I K O N A N E O N

12
e . ^O , , c
A ... b | , | b d ., ... e c , e d a e e
. Er , +, b e e
.
M , d a r c
e j , ^O , .., e
(e a K), a e , d : c d a (2.1), a r a
( a ). a d e
, a d a (e
vaudeville) . .. \A, 10.452f [. E..: b q
d d b e a
c - c
Xd a a ^A !
b d a . E c c , c , e
e f c e e e d c a (
a d e
) b a e a d d a d a : ...b
, e a , b z a .
\E , , N (658c),
g i c f a d c q
, a . hA e d q a
a a , i , d
, c a q . a a
c : d i q d a f a
, a ; e a , ,
e f a a : E b a a , e
a . q ; [ b r;]...
^H a d c
a c a -

KEIMENA TOY A N . M A P I N H AO TO EPIOIKON E H N I K O N A N E O N

13
b : E e (\I X).
hA c c ^Ec .
\E b c ^Ec ,
g a , \
a \A.
\E , a c c b
, b d . T b
e d e e
f f . ^H r d
a (c ). ^Y a a j , a
b a a (psychical research). b
, a , a q , .., e
, d a . a
b a a , a
a a r a a d a ; \E d c d c
.
A , , , e
. ^O Zf b e \Ae a , e e e N (. , . 55-60) , , \A r , a c b c c . O, a \A r
(j d ) , d
.
a a Overall,
a .
Ta a a c ^Ec b
e c , a b . T b a f :
, c d b e , b r d
a a ,
, , , e N b r , d

KEIMENA TOY A N . M A P I N H AO TO EPIOIKON E H N I K O N A N E O N

14
T, c d .
Kd a a a c
c b , .., d e X c d a e (d a b e b
c c j , ) a f E f b
a a a , a e : e e d
N, e , d , e , \ e . [a d a a (a ) \A \E
.]

B
\A, X: c \O A
\ \E, \A
(\E \A) 1956.
Basinger, David: Miracles as Violations: Some Clarifications, The Southern Journal
of Philosophy 22, 1984, 7.
Burhenn, Herbert: Attributing Miracles to Agents - Reply to George D. Chryssides,
Religious Studies 13 (1977).
Chryssides, George D.: Miracles and Agents, Religious Studies 11, 1975.
Erlandson, Douglas K.: A New Look at Miracles, Religious Studies 13, 1977.
Larmer, Robert A. H.: Water into Wine? An Investigation of the Concept of Miracle, Montreal (McGill-Queens University Press), 1988.
Larmer, Robert A. H.: Against Against Miracles, Sophia 23, 1984.
Larmer, Robert A. H.: Miracles and Conservation Laws: A Reply to Professor MacGill, Sophia 31, nos. 1-2, 1992.
McKinnon, Alaister: Miracle and Paradox, Mostafa Faghfoury (ed.), Ana-lytical
Philosophy of the Religion in Canada, Ottawa, Ontario (University of Ottawa Press), 1982.
Odegard, Douglas: Miracles and Good Evidence, Religious Studies 18, 1982.
Overall, Christine: Miracles as Evidence Against the Existence of God, Michael
Martin & Ricki Monnier (eds.), The Impos-sibility of God, New York (Prometheus Books),
2000, 147-153.
Overall, Christine: Miracles and God. A Reply to Robert A. H. Larmer, Martin &
KEIMENA TOY A N . M A P I N H AO TO EPIOIKON E H N I K O N A N E O N

15
Monnier, 154-166.
Walker, Ian: Miracles and Violations, International Journal for Philosophy of Religion
13, 1982.

KEIMENA TOY A N . M A P I N H AO TO EPIOIKON E H N I K O N A N E O N