JOHN HALDON

. ... -

1992

12

ISBN 960-7089-04-9
, 24-28,
162 31


John Frederick Haldon
....-. 1990
1991.
Birmingham (Centre for Byzan
tine & Modern Creek Studies).
: Recruitment and conscription in the Byzantine
army c. 5 5 0 -950: a study o f the origins o f the 'stratiotika ktemata
( 197 9 ), Byzantine Praetorians: an administrative, institutio
nal and social survey o f the Opsikion and Tagmata c. 58 0 -9 0 0 (
/ 1984), Constantine Porphyrogenitus, Three Treatises
on Imperial Military Expeditions, (, ,
) 1989, Byzantium in the Seventeenth Cen
tury: the Transformation o f a Culture (Cambridge University Press
1990). , I. , Perspectives on
Byzantine History and Culture ( 1986).
Byzantine and Modern Greek Studies
Rodney Hilton,
Past and Present.
,
. ,
, .

,
.

,

fStoi * .

,


. ,
.
.

(.. conventionalism
),
,
, .

.
, ,
,
,
. ,
( )
,
,

.
'
,
.
,
,
1. , ,
. ,
( -
) .
, ,

1. .. G. R. Elton, The Practice o f History, Sydney 1967.

10

- ,
,
.
() ,

2.

Annales . ,

,
,

. , , '
.

.

. , 1950
i9 6 0 ,
'

,

. 1956, 6
, ,
.

-

2.
'jargon' vs. 'the facts? Byzantine History-writing
and Contemporary debates, Byzantine and Modern Creek Studies 9 (1984-85) 95
..

11

-
,
.
Louis Althusser,

.
Althusser
, Etienne Balibar. ,
,
Althusser, ,
, ,
.&.,
:
, (reification)
.
,
3. - ( -)

.
.




.

3.
,
, . G. McLennan, Marxism and the Methodologies o f Histo
ry, 1981 T. Benton, The Rise and Fall of Structuralist Marxism, 1984.

 A'
1.


1950.
. , ,
,

,
,

...

.
,

.

1950,

. 1950
1960
, ,
,
.
. , ,
Annales 1940

14

1950
.
50
, - . ,

, ,

.
;
,


.
,
. ,
,

!

.
(
) , .
, , ,

. , .

,
.

. ,

.
.

15

,
.
, ,
. ,
,

. ,
.

,
, .


. ',
18
4.

, .

4.
, , Hempel
- Popper. , . R. Pop
per, The Logic o f Scientific Discovery, 1974 C. C. Hempel, Aspects o f
Scientific Explanation and Other Essays in the Philosophy o f Science,
1965 ( 1943). . . Mandelbaum, The problem of 'covering laws, P. Gardiner (.), The
Philosophy o f History, 1974, 51-65 ( History and Theory 1
(1961) 229-242), ( .
,
, Bertrand Russell, History o f Western
Philosophy ( , 1961). , ,
, , . Roy
Bhaskar, A Realist Theory o f Science, Brighton 1978 , The Possibility o f
Naturalism: a Philosophical Critique o f the Contemporary Human Sciences, Brighton
1979 R. Harr, Philosophies o f Science: an Introductory Survey, 1972.
(, D. Hillel-Ruben, Marxism and Materialism, Brighton 1979* C. McLen
nan, Marxism and the Methodologies o f History, 1981 (, Marx
ism, Pluralism and Beyond, Cambridge 1989.

16

, ,
,
. ,
.
, ,
17-18
.
,

. ,
(, ),
,
, , ,
. ,
Kuhn


.
,
. Kuhn 5,

, . ,

. ,
,

. , Kuhn
. ,

5.
T. S. Kuhn, The Structure o f Scientific Revolutions, 1970
Kuhn Popper, : I. Lakatos, A.
Musgrave (.), Criticism and the Growth o f Knowledge, Cambridge 1970.
Kuhn, . . 2.

,

.
, Kuhn


.
, , (
-)

Kuhn.
.
, ,
,
,
,
, ,
Kuhn, .
,
, ,
,
, Kuhn.
, ,
(correspondence theory) Kuhn ,

.


( ),

.
. ,

.

()
6.
,
, , , Kuhn
,

.


. , ,


.

6.
. Bhaslcar, HillelRuben xai McLennan 4.
: J. Mepham, D. Hillel Ruben (.), Issues in Marxist Philoso
phy 111: Epistemology, Science, Ideology, Brighton 1979.

2.

, ,

. .

. ,
.


.


( )
7. ,
,
.
, , ,

.
, , .

7.
. McLennan, Marxism and the Methodologies o f Histo
ry, . 66 . 97 . .

20

.
,
,

.

.

.

,
,
. .

,
, ..

,
-
( ).
19
20 . ,

.
.

, ,
. ,

.

21

.


,
-
8. :
,
,
, *
9.

8. , . McLennan, Marxism and the Metho

dologies o f History, 97-111. ,
,
: ,
Ranke,
(
Lvi-Strauss), ,
/ (,
, Hempel Dray),


.
, . . . Lembeck, Die Gultigkeit historischen Wissens: zum Zusammenhang von Ceschichtstheorie une Geschichtstheologie bei Ernst Troeltsch, Saeculum 33 (1982) 103-208 H. Schnadelbach,
Geschichtsphilosophie seit Hegel. Die Problme des Historismus, Freiburg/Munchen
1974. . Saeculum 33 (1982),
0 . Marquard, Universalgeschichte und Multiversalgeschichte, 106-115.
, . . Mandelbaum, The Anatomy o f Historical Knowledge,
1977' P. Gardiner, The Philosophy o f History. , Lembeck , , F. Meinecke, Die
Entstehung des Historismus, 1936 , . Mandelbaum, History, Man
and Reason, 1971, . 429, 113 x. .
9. . Hindess and P. Q.
Hirst, Mode o f Production and Social Formation, 1977 -

22

,
.

.

,
. ,
:
- ,
Annales -
. -
,
. -
.
,

.
. ,
,
,
.
, ,

, -,


10.

. . , J. Hexter
The History Primer, 1972.
10. -

,

,

, - -.

, , ,
, .
, Althusser Balibar, Hindess H irst11,
,

, .
McLennan. Marxism and the Methodologies o f History, 2-14
. ,
, . C. A. Cohen, Karl Marx's Theory o f History: A
Defense, 1979.
11.
: L. Althusser, . Bali
bar, Reading Capital (. ., 1974)' L. Althusser, For Marx (.
. Harmondsworth 1969). . . Geras, Althussers Mar
xism: an account and assessment, New Left Review 71 (1972) 71-86' S. Clarke,
Althusserian Marxism, One-Dimensional Marxism (. S. Clarke ..),
1980, , . P. Thom
pson, The Poverty o f Theory, 1979. -, .
Hindess Hirst (. 9), Pre-Capitalist Modes
o f Production, 1977' P. Hirst, Althussers theory of ideology, Economy
and Society 5 (1976).
,
.
McLennan, Marxism
and the Methodologies o f History. .
: C. McLennan, Philosophy and History: some issues in recent Marxist theory,
Making Histories: Studies in History-Writing and Politics, ( CCCS),
1982,133-152 N. Mouzelis, On the Crisis of Marxist Theory, British
Journal o f Sociology 35 (1984) 112-121.

24

. ,

.
,
(
)
. ,

, ,
, ,

, ,
12.
, , ,
Derek Sayer "
:

.
,
.


. " ,

12. . /
.
. , ,
,

. '
/ .
, . R. Blackburn (.), Ideology in Social Science: readings in critical social
theory, 1972, C. Stedman-Jones, History: The Poverty of Empi
ricism, 95-115.
13. . D. Sayer, Marx's Method, Brighton 1979 D. Sayer, Science as Critique:
Marx vs. Althusser, Issues in Marxist Philosophy III ( . 6).

.
,
.
, , .
8 1890


. /
(
)
/ ,


. ,
,
.
' Annales
1930 1940 ,
,
.


,
.
.

,
.
,

,

.

(
) .
Annales
.
Annales.
'
, .
,
: ,
Marc
Bloch Franois Furet14.
, Annales

, -

14.
Annales, . . .
Born, Neue Wege der Wirtschafts und Sozialgeschichte in Frankreich. Die Historiker-Gruppe der "Annales , Saeculum 15 (1964) 298-309' V. Rittner, Ein Versuch
systematischer Aneignung von Ceschichle: die "Schule der Annales", I. Ceiss,
R. Tamchina, Ansichten einer kiinftigen CeschichIswissenschafl I (1974) 153-172'
G. C. Iggers, New Directions in European Historiography. Middletown. Conn. 1975'
, Die "Annales und ihre Kritiker, Hislorische Zeitschrift 219 (1974)
578-608. , Annales: . Bloch, The Historians
Craft, Manchester 1954 Slavery and Serfdom n the Middle Ages: Selected Essays,
Berkeley 1975' L. Febvre, A Geographical Introduction to History, 1932 P.
Burke (.), A New Kind o f History: from the writings o f Febvre, 1973' E.
Le Roy Ladurie, The Territory o f the Historian, Hassocks 1979' F. Braudel, The
Mediterranean and the Mediterranean World in the Age o f Philip II, 2 , (.
. 1975), . F. Furet, Quantitative History, F.
Gilbert, S. Craubard, Historical Studies Today, 1971, 45-61.
Annales, . . . Hutton, The History
of Mentalities: the New Map of Cultural History, History and Theory 20 (1981)
237-259.

'

27

.
Annales ,
. ' Jacques
Le G off Evelyne Patlagean
15. An
nales . *

,

.
1960 1970 Anna
les .
, .
,
Claude Lvi-Strauss, Ferdinand de Saussure, Roman Jacobson
.


,
,
.

,
. ,
.

,
.

15.
. elSix J. Le Goff, P. Nora (.), Faire de l'histoire, 1974 .
Patlagean, Pauvret conomique et pauvret sociale Byzance, 4e-7e sicles,
1974 trri Structure sociale, famille, chrtient i Byzance, ,
Variorum, 1981.

28

, Saussure16.
,
,



.
Lvi-Strauss - ,

.
, ,
.

,
,
, 17.

-
- -
(de-constructionism).
,
,
,

16. , . J. F. Haldon, On the Structuralist

Approach to the Social History of Byzantium, BS 42 (1981) 203 ..
17. . M. Godelier, Horizon, trajets marxistes en anthropologie, 1973'
M. Auge, Towards a rejection of the meaning-function alternative. Critique of
Anthropology 13/14 (1979) 61-75 ( L'Homme 18 (1978) 139-154)
, The Anthropological Crete: Symbol, Function, History, (Cambridge Studies in
Social Anthropology, 37), Cambridge 1982 M. Glucksman, Structural Analysis in
Contemporary Social Thought: a Comparison o f the Theories o f Claude Lvi-Strauss
and Louis Althusser, 1974 A. Assiter, Althusser and Structuralism,
British Journal o f Sociology 35 (1984) 272-296.

29

.
-
,

.

-
. ' , ;

: Althusser,
,
, Jacques Lacan,
. ,
!
Althusser,
1950 1960,



. Althusser
,
.


.
, Althusser
- .

,
,
. ,
, -

30

. , ,
.
(
) .

,
. , Althusser :

,

,

.




.
.
Althusser, ,
,
,
/,
18.

18.
. Althusser . 11, .
(5
) : Ideology
and Ideological State Apparatuses (notes towards an investigation) , Lenin and Philo
sophy and Other Essays, 1977,121-173. , .
G. McLennan, V. Molina, R. Peters, Althussers theory of ideology. On Ideology
(Centre for Contemporary Cultural Studies, University of Birmingham, Working Pa
pers 1 0 ,2 1977), 1978, 75-105 P. Q. Hirst, Althussers Theory of Ideolo
gy, Economy and Society 5 (1976). Althusser Gramsci,
.
. S. Hall, R. Lumley, G. McLennan, Politics and Ideology: Gramsci, On Ideology,
45 . .

 1 !!

Althusser ,

Lacan.
, ,
Freud. Lacan


.
,
,
. ,
,


. Lacan
' .

19.
-
.
, , , ,
.
,
, ,

19.
. L. Althusser, Freud and Lacan, New Left Review 55 (1969), D. Adlam
et al., Psychology, Ideology and the Human Subject, Ideology and Consciousness 1
(1977) 5-56, S. Hall, Some Problems with the
Ideology/Subject Couplet, Ideology and Consciousness 3 (1978) 113-121. . , R. Wollheim, New York Review o f Books, . 25,. 21-2 ( . 1979).
, . R. Coward, Lacan and Signification: an Introduction,
Edinburgh '76 Magazine 1 (1976) 6-20.

, , .
' ( ,
)
,
,
. . ,

, , .

, , 20. ,

.
- . (discourse)
(discursive practice)

Michel Foucault

21. (discourse) -

20. ., , R. Giraud, Semiology, 1975 R. Barthes, Ele

ments o f Semiology, 1970' P. Macherey, A Theory o f Literary Production,
1978- M. Foucault, What is an author?, D. F. Bouchard (.),
Language. Counter-Memory, Practice: Selected Essays and Interviews,
1977.
21. To Foucault . . Archaeology o f Knowledge, 1972, The Order of
Things: An Archaeology o f the Human Sciences, 1973, The History o f
Sexuality I: An Introduction, 1978, Politics and the study of discourse.
Ideology and Consciousness 3 ( 1978).
, , , . J. Weeks, Foucault for
Historians, History Workshop Journal 14 (1982) 106-119
P. . Hutton, The History o f mentalities ( . 14), 251 .

.
,
,
, ,
. ,
, ,

.
,

,
. ,
.
,

, ,
.
, .


.

.

, .


. -
(inter-discursive practices)
,
22.

. A. Megill, Foucault, Structuralism and the Ends of History, Journal of Modern

History 51 (1979) 451-503.
22.

Kuhn,
. ,
,
Saussure - .
-



, 21.

- (
, , ..) ,
,
.
. ,

,
,

. Hindess P. Q. Hirst, Mode o f Production and Social Formation (..

. 9). . , Macherey, A Theory o f Literary Production (.. . 20), P. Q.
Hirst, The Social Theory of Anthony Ciddens: a New Syncretism? Theory, Culture
and Society 1 (1982) , On Law and Ideology, 1979. / *
,
Macherey Barthes, Pecheux: R. Woods, Dis
course Analysis: The work of Michel Pecheux, Ideology and Consciousness! (1977)
57-59. . , C. Haroche, P. Henry, M. Pecheux, La semantique et la coupure
Saussurienne: langue, langage, discours, Langages 24 (1971), 93-106.
23.
, -
,
.
,

. , ,
.

35

,
. , 24.
-
Jaques Derrida - ,
, Foucault.
, , -

.
,
, ( - ) Cilles Deleuze, Franois Lyotard
Foucault


. '
, ,
,

,
.
.


-

24.
- , . D. Adlam, A. Salfield, A Matter of
Language: Review of R. Coward, J. Ellis, Language and Materialism: Developments in
Semiology and the Theory o f the Subject, 1977, Ideology and Con
sciousness 3 (1978) 95-111. . Bob Scholte, From Discourse to Silen
ce: the Structuralist Impasse, Towards a Marxist Anthropology: Problems and Per
spectives, (. S. Diamond), - 1979, 31-67 D. E. Coodfriend,
Plus a change, plus c'est la mme chose: the Dilemma of the French Structuralist
Marxists, , 91-124.

36

,
25.

. , ,
,


. ,
, , :


. ,
,

. ,
. , ,
,

.

Hayden White ,
,
(,
,
) 16.

25. , .
P. Dews, Power and Subjectivity in Foucault, New Left Review 144 (-
1984) 72-95 , Cary Wickham, Power and Power Analysis: Beyond
Foucault?, Economy and Society 12 (1983) 468-498.
26. Hayden White, Metahistory: The Historical Imagination in Nineteenth-Century Europe, 1973, Tropics o f Discourse, 1978. . ,
L. J. Goldstein, Historical Knowing Austin, / 1976, P. Munz, The
Shapes o f Time: A Mew Look at the Philosophy o f History, Connecticut 1977.

1 0

37

-
.
,
, ,
.
,
, , .
,

,

.
,
,
,
.
-
. -
.
-, ,
-
. '
.
,
27.

27.
- History and Theory 19/
4 (1980 (=Metahistory: six critiques. History and Theory Beiheft 19). .
P. Pomper, Typologies and Cycles in Intellectual History, 30-38 M. Mandelbaum, The Presuppositions of Metahistory, 39-54.

38

, ,
,
Lawrence Stone


. Stone

, ,
.
Stone, -,
28.
, ,
,
.

29.
,

28. . L. Stone, The Revival of Narrative: Reflections on an Old New History,

Past and Present 85 ( 1979) The Past and the Present, Princeton,
N.J. 1982 ( ). , . Hobsbawm, The revival of Narrati
ve: Some Comments, Past and Present 86 ( 1980) 308, Ph.
Abrams, History, Sociology, Past and Present ( 1980) 3-16.
29. . Th. K. Rabb, R. I. Roberg (xS.), The New History: the 1980s and Beyond,
Princeton 1982.
, . ,
, 1960,
Lewis Binford Graham Clark, .

. , ,
,
. .
. Paddaya, Myths about the New Archaeology, Saeculum 34 (1983) 70-104,

. . , D. Bayard,
15 jahre "New Archaeology : eine kritische Cbersicht, Saeculum 29 (1978)
69-106.

39

Anthony Giddens Philip Abrams.

Giddens
. 30.
.
, /
,



.
.


.
(structuration)
(problematic of structuring).

. ,
,
,
.
, -,
.
.

31.

30. A. Giddens, Central Problems in Social Theory, 1979, Ph. Abrams,

Historical Sociology, Shepton Mallet 1982.
31. , . G. Stedman-Jones,

40

,

Giddens, .
(
)
,
. ,
.
Giddens . "
,
()
12.
- -

. - ,
-
.
15-20

XP0v
l.......................
-

- ,
. ,
.

. ,

From Historical Sociology to Theoretical History, British Journal o f Sociology 27

(1976). Giddens, . C. McLennan, Critical or Positive
Theory? a Comment on the Status of Anthony Ciddens' Social Theory, Theory,
Culture and Society 2/2 (1984) 123-129.
32. C. McLennan, Marxism, Pluralism and Beyond, Cambridge 1989, 204 ..

, ,

, - . , .

( ,
)

. ,
(
)


*1.

33.
A. Weir, . Wilson, The British Women's Movement, New Left Review 148
(.-. 1984) 74-103. , . P. Ander
son, A culture in Contraflow, New U ft Review 180 (- 1990)

 '

1. Mai Octdpta :
,
-



.
,
, Theda Skocpol
'. Skocpol
.
(
) ;,\ Skocpol
,
,
. ,
, ,
, .


(
), Skocpol

.

34. . Skocpol, Stales and Social Revolutions, Cambridge 1979.

35. , . C.
McLennan, Marxism, Pluralism, and Beyond, .., 224 ..

44

.
, ,

,
(
) .





.


,
. Michael Mann, The
Sources o f Social Power, W. G. Runciman, A Treatise on
Social Theory ( )18.

(
)

( , - -
). ,
,

36.
Michag) Mann, The Sources o f Social Power, x. 1 :4 History o f Power from the
Beginning to A.D. 1760, Cambridge 1986, W. C. Runciman, A Treatise on Social
Theory, . 1: The Methodology of Social Theory, Cambridge 1989 .
2o . ,
: Joseph
A. Tainler, The Collapse of Complex Societies, Cambridge 1988. ,
: Barrington Moore Jr., Social Origins o f Dictatorship and Democracy.
Harmondsworth 1967/1973.
, . Ralph Miliband, State Power and Class Interests. New Left Review
138 (1983) 57-68.

 TOI'

- .

,
. ,

,
-
. , - ,

, - .
Mann, ,
,

.

- 17.
,
(
),
.
, Runciman
. Mann

, Runciman


. , , 38,

37. . Mann, The Autonomous Power of the State: its origins, mechanisms, and
results. Stales in History, . J. A. Hall, 1986, 109-136.
38. Skocpol, States and Social Revolutions, S.it., J. A. Hall,
.., R. Cohen & E. R. Service (.), Origins o f the State. The Anthropo
logy o f Political Evolution, 1978, H. J. M. Claessen, P. Skalnik (.),

, ,

.
,

39,

: ,
( ) ,
- ; ,

;
, ,
.
.
, ,

The Study o f the State, 1981, H. J. M. Claessen, P. Skalnik, The Early State,
1978 J. H. Kautsky, The Politics o f Aristocratic Empires, Chapel Hill 1982.
39.

F. Engels, The
Origins o f the Family, Private Property and the State, 1877
(. . . Leacock, 1972):


.
Engels
,

. . F. Engels, Anti-Dhring, (. 1877/78,
. . 1939, 197 ..).

 TOT

47

. J.
A. Hall, States in History (1 9 8 6 )40,
,
, - .
, ,
.
,
, ,
,
-
-
.


. , Althusser,
(
) , :
, ,
.
, , 41.

40. J. A. Hall (.), States in History, ' 1986.

41.
. Poulantzas, Political Power and Social Classes (
1968/ 1978).
Engels ( J. Bloch: Marx, Engels,
Selected Works, 1968,682-83) . Engels


: Marx

48

,
. ,
(
) . , (
) -

. , ,

.
, ,
. Anna
les (

), Braudel
,
,
, , ..
,
.

:
,
,

1980.

.
, ... ,

xai
, , xai Si ",
.

 TOT

.
'
,

'
,
. ,
,
, ( )
.
' ,

.
Ernest Gellner, ,
, ,
. ,
42.

42.
Braudel, .
C. McLennan, Marxism and the Methodologies o f History, 1981, 136 ..
, . Christopher Hill
Annales, Braudel and the State, The Collected Essays o f Christopher Hill, 3:
People and Ideas in Seventeenth-Century En^/aW, Brighton 1986,125-142.

, .
John Elster, Making Sense of Marx, Cambridge 1985. Gellner, .
Soviets against Wittfogel: or, the Anthropological Preconditions of Mature Marx
ism, Hall (.), States in History, 78-108 ( Theory and Society
14 [1985]). Gellner, . State
and Society in Soviet Thought, 1988 (
The Asiatic Trauma, 3968). Gellner
,
Ellen Meiksins Wood, Marxism and the
Course of History, New Left Review 147 (1984) 95-107, 99-100.

. ,
,

-
.

2. :
,
,

, :
,


, , ,
41.

.
,
.

.
, ,


.
,
,
Hegel. ,
, .

,
. , -

43.
. Ellen Meilcsin Wood, Marxism and the
Course of History, .., 102.

, Cohen
44.
.
,

. Gregor McLennan,
.

,


411.
, ,
,

.

.

.

-

44. C. A. Cohen, Karl Marx's Theory o f History: a Defense, ' 1978.

, Reconsidering Historical Materialism, J. Chapman, J. R. Pennock (.),
Marx and Legal Theory, 1983 (= Nomos 24), D. Laibman, Modes of
Production and Theories of Transition, Science and Society 48/3 (1984).
45. . C. McLennan, Marxist Theory and
Historical Research: between the hard and the soft options. Science and Society 50/
1 (1986) 125-142. . C. Bertram, International
competition in Historical Materialism, New Left Review 138 (-'
1990) 116-128 J. McMutry, The Structure o f Marxs World View, Prince
ton 1978.

53

.
, .
,

.

.
,

,
, ,
46. ,
. ,


,
47.

McLennan

46. & Roy

Bhaskar, Emergence, Explanation and Emancipation P. F. Secord (.),
Explaining Human Behaviour: Consciousness, Human Action and Social Structure,
Beverley Hills 1982, 275-31 A Realist Theory o f Science, Brighton 1978 Scientific
Realism and Human Emancipation, 1987. . (
Terry Lovell, Pictures o f Reality, 1980, 9-28.

- McLennan, History and
Theory: contemporary debates and directions. Literature and History 10/2 (1984)
139-164. [' : ' :
, , 3 ( 1990) 177-221],
47. History and Theory, .., 156-162.

54

,
, ,

. McLennan,
.

(correspondence theory)
48. , .
McLennan ,
.
.
,
(.. Annales,
, ..)

.

,
.
-
, ,
.
Ellen Meiksins Wood,
()
, :
...
,
.

48. D. Hillel-Ruben, Marxism and Materialism, 1979.

" "

. ,
,
49.

.
:



.
, ,
,
,

.
,

*
(
, ). -ct ,

. , ,


, ,
, ,
. ,
,
,

49. . Meiksins-Wood, Marxism and (he Course of History, 6.rt.

56

.

-
.
(, , )
,
,
.
Cohen

, ,

Elster50.
,


.


( ,

).
,


(, , )
.


. , -

50. J. Elster, Making Sense o f Marx (. . 42).

 1:

. -



.
1890, ,

,
,
. 51.
,
, -
- -
,
/
.

-
.

51.
., , P. Burke, Sociology and History, 1980.
Skocpol, Mann, Runciman
.
Plekhanov
, . C. V. Plekhanov, On the Question of the Individual's Role in
History (1898), Selected Philosophical Works, II, 1976, 283-315. .
, J. Larrain, A Reconstruction o f Historical Materialism, 1986.
Larrain, , McLen
nan, ( )
,
,
, .

58

; "
,
; ,

.

- -

.
.
, .
,

. ,
.



.
, , .
,

.
.

.
-
- (
),
.
, , ,

,
. ,
,
.
a priori
.

. , ,


.
, ,

,
,
,

. Elster
John Roemer,
, - 52.

,

.

52.
. Elster, Making Sense o f Marx (..) J. Roemer, A General Theory o f
Exploitation and Class, Cambridge, Mass. 1982, Alan
Carling, Rational Choice Marxism, New Left Review 160 (1986) 24-62.
, . Ellen Meiksins Wood, Rational Choice Marxism: is
the game worth the candle?. New Left Review 177 (1989) 41-88.
. P. Cammack, Statism, New Internationalism and Marxism, Social
ist Register, 1990, 147-170.

, ,
. ' .

Perry Anderson53.

,
, . ,
.
,

. ,

, .

, , .
,
,
.



,
(
).
.

53. Perry Anderson, In the Tracks o f Historical Materialism, 1983, 24.

61

,
.
, ,
,
. ,

,


,

.
, J. A. Hall


/ , . -


.

54.
J. A. Hall (.), States in History, .., . 5. ,
Hall
. 4 1 )
Marx,
Engels Lenin,
, , '
(
Gellner), 2) (,
, ). , . . J. A. Hall, G. John Ikenberry,
The State (Milton Keynes 1989) 8. (
) ,
, block
( : .

62

; ,
, ,

.

, ,
..,
.



;

(States in
History, 3-4), - , , .
, Hall
,
. ', Skocpol Mann
, ,
McLennan. Marxism, Pluralism and Beyond,
.., 226 ..
/. .
,
.
,
, - ,
, -
,
.
( ) . ,
Plekhanov , Bogdanov
, ,
- ,
,

.

, . (
, )
(
,

)
.


.
-
,

. ,
,
.
,
.
(..,
),
,

.
a priori .
,
.
, ,
:
, (
)
, ,
.

(, ,
, ,
),



.
,
,
, Hall, .


( )
,

( ).
Hall
- .

,
, .


.
,

,
.

.

, ,

65

,
'
, 55.



,
. ,
. 1992
.
, Hall



. ,
.

55.
., , G. Thompson, The Relationship
between the Financial and the Industrial Sectors in the United Kingdom Economy,
Economy and Society 6 /3 (1977) Tom Nairn, The future of Britains Crisis,
New Left Review 113-114 (1979) 43-69, . 55 ..

3.
,
,
- ,
,
,
.
: ;
,

. ,

. ,
, Skalnik
Claessen, Krader , , Mann56:


. Mann57,

,
. ,

. ,
-

56. Mann, The Autonomous Power of the State, . . H. J. M. Claessen, P.

Skalnik, The Early State: Theories and Hypotheses, The Early Stale, . ., 3-29, R.
Cohen, State Origins: a reappraisal. The Early State 31-75, ciSixirepa
.
57. Mann, The Autonomous Power of the State, . ., 112.

 TOT

67

. ,

,
( ,

).
Radcliffe Brown
, ,
.

, , .
. , ,
,
58.
, ,
, ( ) ,

.

,
.
,

58.
A. R. Radcliffe-Brown, African Political Systems, (. M. Fortes, . . Evans
Pritchard), 1940, . IX x. . .
Skocpol, Stales and Social Revolutions ( 34)
: . Skoc
pol, Political Response to Capitalist Crisis: neo-marxist theories of the State and the
case of the New Deal, Theory and Society 10/2 (1980), 200.

.
, Mann, Hall, Skocpol,

. ,
.
,

. ,
.

( 1930-1950)
Giddens. ,

, .
,


, Mann :

.
. ,
,
,
,
59.
,
.
.
.

59.
Mann, The Autonomous Power of the Staten, i. it., 110. . A.
Ciddens, A Contemporary Critique o f Historical Materialism, 1982.

 TOT

,
.

, ,
.
,
( ), ,

.

60.

60.
-
/ 7 : J. F. Haldon, Ideology and Social Change in the seventh century: military discontent as a
barometer, KlioSS (1986) 139-190. ,

- ,
(- )

, , ,
.

,
.
: -
- --.

, ,
,
,
.
. Elster, Mating Sense o f Marx, . ., Roemer, A General Theory o f Exploitation
and Class, . ., Carling, Rational Choice Marxism, . .,
A. Levine, . Sober, . Olin-Wright, Marxism and
Methodological Individualism, New Left Review 162 (1987) 67-84. Ellen Meiksins
Wood, Rational Choice Marxism: is the game worth the candle? (. .) Alex

70

,


.
,

,
19 61.
-
(
),

(
):

... ...
...62.
,
,
,
,
63.

. ,

Callinicos, Making History: Agency, Structure and Change in Social Theory,

1987/1989, Gregor McLenann, Marxism, Pluralism and Beyond, 1989.
61. K. Marx, The Eighteenth Brumaire o f Louis Bonaparte, Marx & Engels, Selec
ted Works, 1968, 96-179, . 169 - , The Civil War in
France, ibid., 271-309, . 285 . .
4 Ralph Miliband, State Power and Class Interests, New Left
Review 138 (1983) 57-60.
62. F. Engels, The Origins o f the Family, Private Property and the State, Marx &
Engels, Selected Works, .., 461-583, 577 ,.
63. i Miliband, State Power and Gass Interests, i.n., 65-7.

 TV KPATVi;

71

Gramsci



.
20 .

-
,
*4.



. , ,
,
,

. ,
; .
,
: ,
,
,
, ,
,
. ,
, .

64.
,
Miliband, New Left Review 58 (1969), 59
(1970), 82 (1973), Ladau, The Specificity of the Political: around
the Poulantzas-Miliband Debate, Economy and Society 5/1 (1975),
, New Left Review, 95 (1976).

72

,
- .
,

, de facto
,


.
-
.
, , ,

,

, ,
.
,

. ( )

,
. ,


,
, .
,
Ralph Milliband.

65.

65.
4 6
.
. -

 TOV '

73

, ,

:
,
,

.
'

.

,
.
, ,
, .

-
, ,
, : ., , Jonathan Fried
man, Tribes, States and Transformations, M. Bloch (.), Marxist Analyses and
Social Anthropology, 1984,161-202' (
-) , Mann, The Sources o f Social Power, .., 82 .., Runciman,
A Treatise on Social Theory, 2, 185 .., R. Cohen, State Origins: a reappraisal,
H. J. M. Claessen, P. Skalnik (.), The Early State, 1978,31-75,
32 .. . . . . Fried, The
Evolution o f Political Society, ' 1967, , The State, the Chicken
and the Egg: or, what came First?, R. Cohen, E. R. Service (.), Origins o f the
State: the anthropology o f political evolution, 1978, 35-47.
E. R. Service, Origins o f the State and Gvilisation, ' 1975,
!
- ,
. "

,
. Miliband, State Power and
Class Interests, .., 66-67.

7'.

, , ,
,
,

. ,
,
,
: ,

,
, ,

.
, ,

, ,

, , .

, () /
(, , .,
- )
.

( )
,

.
.


.

. ,

 TOT

75

-
,
: ,
(Estates)
,
.
()

66.

66.
,
, , ,
.

, ) ,

. ,

.

,
,

. '
(
)
.
. ,
- ,
,
.
,

. , , -
C. . . de Ste Croix,
The Class Struggle in the Ancient Greek World, 1981.

76

.
. , ,
,
.


, ,
.


. ,
,

, - , . ,
Runciman
Max Weber
67, , ,
,
-
. ,

.
Runciman ,
, ,

,
.
-

-
Mann, The Sources o f Social Power, . ., 216 ..
67. Runciman, A Treatise on Social Theory, . ., . 2, 150 ..

 TOT

77

, ,
() ,
,
68.
,
, - , - ,
-
.


.
, ,
,
. ,
,
- ,
Runciman,

, ,
69. ' Runciman
,
.
,

.

68. , 148 ..
69. , 153.

4. : , ,
,



.

.
.


.
,

.
,
:


, ,
. , ,
- .
.

 : , .,

79

, ,
.
,
, ,
. , ,


.
, ,
, ; ,
,

, ,
.

,
. , 3



, ,
,
,
,
, 10.
,
,
, .
.
. , , ,

. ,

70. Karl Marx, Capital, 1970, t . 3, 791.

80

...

,
,
, ,
..,
,
1'.




(). ,

,
12.



, , ,


73.
-

,

71. , 791-2.
72. , . 1, 85 xai . 2. *
-
. . Perry Anderson, The
Lineages o f the Absolutist State, 1974/1979, 401 ,.
73. Engels, J. Bloch, Marx, Engels, Selected Works, 682-83.

 : , .

, .

.

. '
: 1''.

, , ,


, 7\ -

74. Engels, F. Mehring, , 689-93, 690-91.

75. , , ,
1908, Materialism and Empirio-Criticism
(Collected Works, 14, 1962)
(
). ,
,
:
C. V. Plekhanov, Fundamental Problems o f Marxism ( 1908), 1969,
70.
-
Short Course in the Economic Science
(Kralkii kurs ekonomiceskoi nauki, 1897)
. . R. C. Williams, The Other Bolsheviks, Bloomington 1986,38
.. ( Julian Cooper ).
- C. A. Cohen, Karl Marx's Theory o f History: a Defense,
1978.
L. Althusser, . Balibar, Reading Capital, 1971 . ,
Political Power and Social Classes, State, Power, Socialism, / '
1978. ,
, ,
,

82

.
,
.



.


. , Maurice Godelier,
,
,
.

( )
,
.

. ' ,
,
,
.
,
,
. -
,
.
-
. . . Glucksmann, A Ventriloquist Structuralism, New Left Revi
ew 72 (1972) S. Clarke .., One-Dimensional Marxism,
1980.
76.
M. Codelier, Infrastructures, Societies and History, Current Anthropology
19/4 (1978) 763-771,
New Left Review 111 (1978) 84-96.

 : , ,

83

.
, Godelier,

,

.

.
, , , .
.

. ,
(
- ).

.

, ,
. ,
( ) .
,

, , .



. , ,
.

.
,

84

, .


.

,


.


.
.
,
Roy Bashkar
,
.
Mann Runciman, -
, .

,
,

7'.
,

.

,
. ,
-

77.
Bhaskar, Emergence, Explanation and Emancipation Scientific Realism
and Human Emancipation, .. ,
. 1890 Marx, Engels, Selected Works, 682-3.

 : , ,

.
- . ,
,

, .


,
.
,
Mann Runciman ( )

. Runciman, ,
,
,
. ,
, , ,

,
. ,
- Mann Runciman (
)

.

Runciman
. Runci
man,

, .
,
:

86

, ,

. Runciman

, ,
.
Godelier ,
, : ,
,
-
.
Runciman Mann ,
,

,
. ,

.
,


.

,
Mann,
,
,
, .
, ,
, 78. ,

78. Mann, The Sources o f Social Power, 31,

 : . .

87

( )

.

, Mann Runciman,

.
, .
.
(
)
- :
,
.
( Godelier)

.
, Runciman

.

, .
, -

, ,
.

( Cohen, Karl Marx's Theory o f History).
xai
, . . Hobsbawm, Marx
and History, New Left Review 143 (1984) E. Olin Wright, aCidden's
Critique of Marx, New Left Review 138 (1983) 11-35, 24-31,

.

,
.
, ,
, (
) .
- -

. '

,


, -
(. )
,

.
, Milliband, Skocpol, Mann
Runciman

- .
Norman Ge
ras. (

,
,
,

), Geras .
( , , Hall,
). ,
, -
, , (
) .

 : , ,

,
Geras, : [
] ,

. a priori ,
19.
,

.
,
( ),
.



. , ,
,

.

.

.
. '
.
,

.

79.
Hall, States in History, 1 . . . Norman Geras,
Ex-Marxism without substance: being a real reply to Laclau and Mouie, New Left
Review 169 (1988), 40-41. . N. Mouzelis, Marxism Post-Marxism?,
New Left Review 167 (1988) 107-123, . 117
.

. ,
. :


, ,
.


.



,
.

,
,

. ,

.

(
)
. ,
.


.
,
.
.
, ,
,

 : , ,

,

.
, ,
, ,
, ,
. .

5.

" .
Runciman
.
:
, ,
. , ,
, ,
,
80.
-

.
. ,

( )
(
, ). Runci
man, ,

( -
11 )81.
,
Runciman
,

80. Runciman, Treatise on Social Theory, . ., 2, 155-160.

81. , 160 ..

. ,
.

,

, . ,

.
,
.

, , .

Balibar.

, ad hoc
. ,

. , Runci
man
:
,
.
.

.

, ,

.
- ,
(

)

94

-
. ,
,
,


.
Runciman

.
,
,
, . '
. ,

, ,
,
*-. .
,
.
,
( ),
,

, .
111.

82. ,
Runciman , D.
Sayer, The Violence o f Abstraction: the Analytic Foundation o f Historical Materialism,
1987, R. Gottlieb, Feudalism and historical materialism: a critique
and synthesis. Science and Society 48/1 (1984).
83. Runciman, A Treatise on Social Theory, 40 .., 295.

Runciman,

, ,

.
.
,
,
.
(, , ),
. ,
(
,
) (-
, , .). ,
( ,
,
,
).
,
(, ,
),


. , ,
,
.

.

. J. F. Haldon, Ideology and Social Change in the Seventh
Century, . ., - .

, ,
,
. ,
.

.
.


8*.

,
,
.

,
Runciman.
:



,


( )

.

.

,

84.
Mann, The Sources o f Social Power, .., 6, M. Foucault, The History o f
Sexuality, 1979, 81 ..

97

, .


, , 2
.


,
.

6 . Ewota



85.
, ,

. ,

- .

,


, 9
11 .
,

85.
. . Hindess & P. Q. Hirst, Pre-Ca
pitalist Modes o f Production, 1975 xal .
T. Asad . Wolpe, Economy and Society, 5 (1976) 470-506.
, . C J. Wickham, The Uni
queness of the East, Journal o f Peasant Studies 12 (1985) 166-196, Halil Berktay,
The Feudalism Debate: the Turkish end - is 'ta i vs. rent necessarily the product and
sign of a moral difference?. Journal o f Peasant Studies 14 (1987) 291-333. J. F.
Haldon, The Feudalism Debate once more: the case of Byzantium, Journal o f Pea
sant Studies 17 (1989) 5-39 , State Theory, State Autonomy and the
Medieval State, 1992.

 TOT

. ,


18 .


, ,

,

.
,
, , , .
86.
,
- (
Mann Runciman).

-
. , ,
.
: , ,
, ,
,

86.
Haldon, The Feudalism Debate once more, 8..

6 Perry Anderson, Lineages o f the Absolutist State, 1974/1979, .
Chris Wickham, The Uniqueness of the East, Economy and Society 4 /4
(1975) 446-475, Haldon, State Theory..., .., '.

100

. ,

( ),

, .

, , : 1) , ,
(,
, ) . 2)
, - ,

,
. 3)

.
Halil Berktay,
xai
,
,

87.
,

. , ,

,
.

87. Berkley, The Feudalism Debate: the Turkish end, . ., 311.

 TOT

101

,
.

,
. : 1)

,
, ()
(),
,
. 2)


.
, . ,
,
.

,

.




, -
. ,
.

, .

,

.



.
,
- ,

.

,


:
,

, -

104

.
, ,
.
1990

..............................................

7-8

......................................................................

9-11

'
1. ' .......................................................................
2. ..........................

13-18
19-41

'
1. ..........................
2. : ....................
3. ....................................................
4. : , , ..................
5. , . . .
6. .........

43-50
51-65
66-77
78-91
92-97
98-101

.......................................................................103-104

 TOT JOHN HALDON

.




,
. - .
.
1992
....-